Showing posts with label G.W. Bush. Show all posts
Showing posts with label G.W. Bush. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Support for death penalty stable in US as Texas approaches 500th execution

Texas is moving closer to an unflattering jubilee: the 500th execution since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976 – barring any last-minute stays or reprieves. This Wednesday, June 12, Texas will execute its 499th person, and execution no. 500 is scheduled for June 26. Texas uses the death penalty more than any other state, and the competition does not even come close.

No. 2 on the execution list is Virginia, which has killed 110 people – and only five since 2010. Texas has executed more people than the next six states (Virginia, Oklahoma, Florida, Missouri, Alabama and Georgia) combined. It wasn’t always so. Texas executed fewer than 10 people a year until 1992, when executions spiked under then-Governor Ann Richards. They peaked under George W. Bush, who sent 37 people to the death chamber in 1997 and 40 in 2000.

The Texans put to death are disproportionately African-American.

Americans’ support for the death penalty as punishment for murder has levelled off in recent years after several years in which support appeared to be falling. Sixty-three percent now favour the death penalty as the punishment for murder, similar to 61% in 2011 and 64% in 2010, according to polls conducted by Gallup.

Since the Boston bombings, the numbers have nudged up a bit. The majority or at least plurality of most demographic and political groups is in broad agreement about supporting the death penalty as punishment for murder.

One exception to that is adults who describe their political views as “liberal.” Just under half of liberals, 47%, favour the death penalty, while 50% oppose it. However, most conservatives and moderates support it, as do majorities of all party groups, including 51% of Democrats. Additionally, non-whites are closely divided on  the issue, with 49% in favour and 45% opposed. That contrasts with whites, among whom 68% are in favour.


Source: Euronews, June 11, 2013

Thursday, May 30, 2013

Remembering Executed Veterans

Memorial Day is over, with its picnics, parades, and poignant remembrances of the veterans who gave their lives in America's wars. But there is one group of vets few want to remember: the ones who went to war, came back tragically changed, committed a crime and were executed.

Vets like Wayne Felde, who arrived in Vietnam on his 19th birthday by choice, not by the draft; who saw heavy action and was wounded; who came back to the U.S. hounded by his memories of death and crippled by what those memories did to him. Drunk, unable to hold down a job or a marriage, in trouble with the law, he was probably trying to kill himself when his gun went off while he was in the back of a police car. The bullet ricocheted and killed an officer. He was sent to death row, and in March of 1988, executed by the state of Louisiana.

Or a veteran like Louis Jones, executed in all our names by the federal government on March 18, 2003. Jones served with great distinction in Grenada and the 1st Gulf War, where he was exposed to chemical neurotoxins. The effects of the nerve gas and the combat-induced PTSD -- often called "Gulf War Syndrome" -- turned a model soldier into a sick man, one whose remorse for the killing he committed was deep, who confessed to his crime immediately. 2 days after President Bush denied clemency for Sgt. Jones, the invasion of Iraq began.

There are other stories. Perhaps one Memorial Day soon, we'll have an exemption for veterans who commit capital crimes in part because of what happened to them in our wars. As Felde said to his jury:

I am not a criminal but a troubled and wrecked man. Like many other vets I know what [war] did to me.... Critical wounds do not always pierce the skin, but enter the hearts and minds and dreams of those that are only begging for help so badly needed.

Better still, perhaps the United States will abolish the death penalty for all.

Source: Denny LeBoeuf, Capital Punishment Project, ACLU.org, May 30, 2013

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Cuba: Executions & Accomplices in April

This April marks a decade since one of the most depressing moments of recent Cuban history: Black Spring. It was a time when Fidel Castro, excited about what he recognized as a revolutionary wave in Latin America and the arrival of the 1st Venezuelan subsidies, decided to eradicate all signs of discontent and opposition that had accumulated along the path of defeat-after-defeat-until-the-final-victory he had outlined.

His pretext, as had been usual since 1959, was to stop the imperialist threat.

Although the Black Spring is remembered especially for the imprisonment of 75 opposition activists without due process, I'm focusing my attention on another event: the executions of 3 black youths for the failed hijacking of the Havana Bay ferry.

A group of 11 young people participated in this criminal act on April 2, 2003 with the aim of reaching the coast of Florida. This involved the kidnapping of 30 passengers, including two foreign women who became key parts of the negotiations between the hijackers and the police.

The boat finally ran out of gas, prompting the hijackers to accept a settlement that can only be explained by their naivete: to be towed to the Mariel port where they would be refueled so they could resume their journey to the north.

The result was the capture of all the hijackers, which occurred successfully without any physical injuries to any of the dozens of hostages. On April 8th, a summary trial concluded in which the detainees had no right to lawyers of their choice.

3 of the young men (Lorenzo Capello, 31; Barbaro Sevilla, 22; and Jorge Martinez, 40) were sentenced to death, while others were punished with sentences ranging from life imprisonment to 2 years in prison.

According to the Washington-based Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (of the Organization of the American States), the Cuban state proceeded to "try and find them guilty without due process." Moreover, the body determined, "The offenses committed against the alleged victims (under the law applied) does not provide for the death penalty, but a prison sentence."

In the galactic time span of 3 days, the sentences were reviewed by the Supreme Court and the Council of State, whose members unanimously pronounced the 3 youths be shot to death.

The men were killed on April 11, without notifying their families (who during all that time were confident of a reversal of the death order), nor were they allowed to bid farewell to the men. This means that in 9 days (between April 2 and 11) the decision was handed down, appeals were made on the lives of 3 people, and their executions were carried out.

In a 4-hour tirade about the shootings, Fidel Castro said the Council of State based its decision on "the potential dangers posed not only to the lives of many innocent people but also for the security of the country, subjected to a plan of alarming provocations hatched by the most extremist sectors of the US government and its allies of the terrorist Miami mafia with the sole purpose of creating conditions and pretexts for attacking our country."

According to Fidel Castro, this means the shooting of the 3 young Cubans, who didn't kill anyone, was to deal with the threat posed by the George W. Bush administration. 


Source: Haroldo Dilla Alfonso, Havana Times, April 9, 2013

Saturday, September 10, 2011

Rick Perry’s Lethal Overconfidence

Huntsville Unit, Huntsville, Texas
Jaws dropped when the governor of Texas, running for president, said on national television he was “100 percent sure” everyone who had been executed on his watch was guilty. The governor was George W. Bush, appearing on NBC's Meet the Press, during his first presidential run. Six months before Bush's election, Texas executed Gary Graham, who continued to protest his innocence even as the lethal injection was killing him and whose objections were almost certainly true. Then, just before Bush moved to the White House, Texas executed Claude Jones. Last year, new DNA testing on a hair found at the crime scene cast doubt on Jones's guilt.

Asked at Wednesday night's presidential debate if he ever worried that Texas had executed an innocent person on his watch, Perry answered, “I've never struggled with that at all.”

Certainty is cheap if one achieves it by ignoring the actual facts, and indeed, Governor Perry's answer to the death-penalty question asked of him Wednesday night reflected a staggering inattentiveness to the facts. As the founder of the Texas Innocence Project, I've had a couple of dozen clients executed during Perry's tenure as Governor. There are some I think could well have been innocent-- Frances Newton, for example, who supposedly killed her husband and two children without getting even a spot of blood or speck of gunpowder in herself; or Charles Nealy, who did not remotely match the description of the person who killed the convenience store clerk . But, there was no DNA in either case, and so I am left being unsure.


Source: The Daily Beast, David R. Dow, September 9, 2011

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

U.S.: The Quiet Revolution In The Death Penalty Debate




Terre Haute, Indiana
Federal Penitentiary
There are 58 people on federal death row in Terre Haute, Ind. But for now none appears likely to face the ultimate punishment, at least not on President Obama's watch.

The Justice Department is reviewing its lethal injection protocols because of a shortage of a key drug. While that study is underway, authorities have backed away from setting execution dates.

Over the last few years, a quiet revolution has overtaken the death penalty debate. Like many trends, this one started in the states and moved to the federal level, says death penalty expert David Bruck.

"I think it's fair to say that the federal government seeks the death penalty less often now than it did 5 or 10 years ago, but that's simply part of a national trend," says Bruck, a law professor at Washington and Lee University.

Just consider, Bruck says, a state quite close to the seat of national government.

"Virginia — which is the state that's executed the second largest number of people since the death penalty came back in the 1970s — has only added 1 new defendant to death row in the last 3 1/2 years," he says.

And among those already sentenced to death, a lot fewer are actually being executed. One reason for that is a shortage of sodium thiopental, a main drug that states and the federal system use in executions.

The federal prison system told a judge last month they're still working through changes to the execution protocol because of that drug shortage and the changes aren't final. That court filing was first reported by Politico.

Until those changes are finalized, death row inmates like James Roane, convicted of taking part in gang murders in Richmond, Va. in the 1990s, won't get a new execution date.

Roane's lawyer, Paul Enzinna, is suing the prison system along with several other attorneys representing inmates on federal death row.

"The issue at the heart of our lawsuit is that the...question of the risk that the inmates being executed will suffer unnecessary pain," Enzinna says. "And that that is a violation of the Eighth Amendment," which prohibits cruel and unusual punishment.

That lawsuit is on hold while the court waits to hear about changes the federal prisons may make to the lethal injection protocol.

The last federal execution happened in President George W. Bush's first term, in 2003. Louis Jones Jr. was a military veteran convicted and sentenced to death for raping and killing a woman soldier.

But not everything related to the federal death penalty is stuck in neutral gear. Last month, after more than 2 years of study, the Justice Department quietly adjusted the directions it gives federal prosecutors who want to seek the death penalty.

The changes didn't get much attention, but they represent a turnaround in two main areas, Bruck says.

"This administration is much more willing to listen to what the local prosecutors who actually have to prosecute the cases in court are saying about when the death penalty should be sought," he says.

So federal officials in Washington are consulting more with prosecutors across the country. That follows a controversy from the Bush presidency when Attorney General John Ashcroft sometimes overruled the decisions of U.S. attorneys who chose not to seek the death penalty.

Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, says the change makes sense.

"The federal government should be very cautious about you know, intruding on areas that have traditionally been under state control and where it's the conscience of the community that determines this," Dieter says.

The Obama Justice Department made another significant change recently, Bruck adds.

"This administration is much less likely to seek the death penalty or to authorize or require a prosecutor to seek the death penalty in cases involving the murders of drug dealers," he says.

Experts say most juries don't like to sentence people to death for killing drug dealers. Removing those cases means the Justice Department seeks capital punishment less often.

It also saves money, notes Dieter. When public defenders mount a death penalty defense in the federal courts, it costs more than $400,000 just for the trial, and that doesn't include the costs of prosecuting the case or handling appeals that can stretch on for years.

Source: AP, August 15, 2011

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Guantanamo detainee lawyers ask that death penalty case be dropped

Lawyers for a terror suspect detained at Guantanamo -- linked by authorities to the bombing of the USS Cole -- say his waterboarding and other mistreatment plus delays in his case should force the government to halt his pending military trial and possible death sentence.

The government says Abd al Rahim Hussayn Muhammad Al-Nashiri was the mastermind behind the 2000 bombing that crippled the U.S. warship and killed 17 sailors.

Al-Nashiri's lawyers have filed a brief with the military commission asking that the proceedings stop.

"By torturing Mr. Al-Nashiri and subjecting him to cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment, the United States has forfeited its right to try him and certainly to kill him," the brief said. "Through the infliction of physical and psychological abuse, the government has essentially already killed the man it seized almost 10 years ago."

Al-Nashiri's legal team is making its request to the so-called Convening Authority of the military court, retired Vice Adm. Bruce MacDonald, who has the power to decide whether cases go to trial at Guantanamo Navy Base in Cuba. The military commission was established by President George W. Bush and overhauled by President Barack Obama.

"The United States has lost its moral authority to seek the death penalty," the defense brief says. "Accordingly, you should not refer charges -- or authorize the death penalty -- against Mr. Al-Nashiri."

His lawyers say Al-Nashiri was waterboarded. Also, while he was naked and hooded, his questioners revved a power drill in his hearing and chambered a round in a handgun, they say.

"The government has admitted to waterboarding Mr. Al-Nashiri and subjecting him to verbal and physical threats to his life and threats to the safety of his family. Both set of acts constitute torture," the brief says.

CNN obtained a copy of the legal document, which was filed at the end of last week and is the latest signal that the Al-Nashiri case is moving forward, with a possible arraignment later this summer.

A military trial of Al-Nashiri is seen as a test of the law and the procedures at Guantanamo before the 9/11 defendants are prosecuted in coming months or years.

Defense lawyers have complained that they have been denied "meaningful discovery" about what information the prosecution has.

"Other than some partial medical records from Guantanamo, Mr. Al-Nashiri and his counsel have been denied discovery from the prosecution," the defense brief says. "The defense is unable to even discern what evidence supports the prosecution's allegations ... accordingly the defense cannot make any principled showing of the weaknesses in the prosecution's case."

The defense also says they are facing other difficulties in preparing for a trial, including political upheaval in Yemen where the USS Cole bombing took place and the CIA's destruction of the videotapes made of Al-Nashiri's interrogation.

"The world wonders whether the Untied States will continue to be an example of how fair trials are conducted or whether it will descend further down the path of expedient and secret justice that Military Commissions have come to represent," the defense brief says.

Government prosecutors have not yet responded to a CNN request for comment.

Source: CNN, July 20, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Saturday, June 25, 2011

Texas Gov. Rick Perry's role in possible wrongful execution may hurt campaign chances

Texas Gov. Rick Perry presided
over 231 executions -- more than
any governor in U.S. history
AUSTIN, Texas — Gov. Rick Perry of Texas has presided over 231 executions, more than any governor in the death penalty's modern history. If he runs for president, one of those executions may become a campaign issue — a case involving questions of whether he allowed an innocent man to be put to death, then tried to scuttle a state commission's investigation into the matter.

The execution of Cameron Todd Willingham drew little attention when it took place in February 2004. But in the subsequent seven years, the way Perry handled the execution and an ongoing investigation into the case has become controversial. A presidential bid would likely increase the scrutiny, particularly as the Republican governor becomes better known.

Whether the scrutiny would influence the outcome of the presidential campaign is another question.

When Bill Clinton ran for president in 1992, he rushed back to Arkansas from New Hampshire as the Gennifer Flowers scandal broke to preside over the execution of Ricky Ray Rector, who was so brain damaged from a gunshot wound to the head that he saved the dessert from his last meal in hopes of eating it later.

There was only a smattering of protest, and the execution of Rector did not slow Clinton's campaign.

And though reporters pored over George W. Bush's support for the death penalty while he was Texas governor and examined several controversial executions, what became an issue were allegations that Bush had ridiculed convicted murderer Karla Faye Tucker for claiming she had had a Christian conversion.

"There's something there, but to my mind it's not going to be Willingham or the death penalty alone," said James Henson, who teaches government at the University of Texas and is the director of the Texas Politics Project. "But with something else, it may get voters to take a longer and more critical look at Perry."


Source: Chicago Tribune, June 25, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Texas: Federal judge won’t stop Mexican’s execution

A federal judge has refused to stop the upcoming execution of a Mexican national convicted of the 1994 rape-slaying of a 16-year-old San Antonio girl.

Humberto Leal, 38, a native of Monterrey, Mexico, faces lethal injection July 7 in Huntsville.

Leal’s attorneys argued his punishment should be blocked because he wasn’t told he could contact the Mexican consulate for legal help after his arrest for the murder of Adria Sauceda. They also said a bill introduced last week in Congress would allow federal courts to review cases of condemned foreign nationals.

U.S. District Judge Orlando Garcia ruled Wednesday the consulate claim was “utterly lacking in arguable merit."

He also said the measure introduced June 11 by Vermont Sen. Patrick Leahy was “a mere proposal” and that similar attempts have failed twice in recent years.

“It is not an enactment of new law,” Garcia said.

Leal’s attorneys presented several dozen former diplomats, State

Department officials and retired military officers backing their appeal and the likelihood that Leahy’s measure would pass Congress.

Garcia dismissed them as “little more than highly speculative predictions from a variety of political science professors and a handful of hopeful executive branch and congressional officers."

Sandra Babcock, an attorney for Leal and a Northwestern University law school professor, said Garcia’s decision would be appealed.

“With consular access, Mr. Leal would have had highly qualified and experienced lawyers and expert assistance that would have transformed the quality of his defense,” she said. “The legislation before Congress is narrowly tailored to provide review for precisely this kind of case where lack of consular assistance may have made the difference between life and death.

“Mr. Leal is constitutionally entitled to receive a stay of execution while Congress is considering taking the necessary measures to remedy this serious violation."

Leal had contended in earlier appeals he should have been allowed to pursue an appeal after President George W. Bush in 2005 agreed with an international court ruling that Leal and 50 other Mexican-born inmates should be entitled to new hearings in U.S. courts to determine if their consular rights were violated at the time of their arrests.

The U.S. Supreme Court subsequently overruled Bush and the impact of the International Court of Justice decision. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals cited the Supreme Court’s ruling in denying Leal in 2009.

Police summoned to a dirt road on San Antonio’s south side in May 1994 found a gruesome scene. Sauceda’s nude body had been bludgeoned with a chunk of asphalt. Evidence showed she had been raped, bitten and strangled. A large stick that had a screw protruding from it was left in her body.

Among other evidence, the bite mark was matched to Leal. Her bloody blouse was found at Leal’s home. She and Leal had been attending a party not far from where she was found.

His lawyers say the bite mark match is junk science. They say the dirty blouse was found outside and his mother had planned to wash it and include it in items she donated to Mexico.

Source: Associated Press, June 24, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Amnesty slams US on detentions, executions

The US human rights record has been marred by indefinite detentions at Guantanamo Bay and in Afghanistan and by a flawed capital punishment system, Amnesty International said Friday.

In its annual global human rights report, the London-based organisation said US authorities executed 46 people over the past year, despite doubts in several case about the defendants' guilt and questions in others over legal representation or mental impairment.

At the Guantanamo Bay detention center on a US naval base in Cuba, 174 men were still being held at the end of the year, "including 3 who had been convicted under a military commission system which failed to meet international fair trial standards," the report said.

"Scores of men remained in indefinite military detention in Guantanamo as President (Barack) Obama's one-year deadline for closure of the facility there came and went," it said.

"Military commission proceedings were conducted in a handful of cases, and the only Guantanamo detainee so far transferred to the US mainland for prosecution in a federal court was tried and convicted."

Additionally, the report said "hundreds" were being held at the US airbase in Bagram, Afghanistan, without due process and some were "subjected to torture or other ill-treatment, including prolonged isolation, sleep deprivation and exposure to extreme temperatures."

Amnesty said US authorities also "blocked efforts to secure accountability and remedy for crimes under international law committed against detainees previously subjected to the USA's secret detention and rendition programme."

It said there were questions about "crimes under international law of torture and enforced disappearance," under the CIA program where detainees were transferred from one state to another "by means that bypass judicial and administrative due process."

It also noted that former president George W. Bush acknowledged in his memoirs that "he had personally authorised 'enhanced interrogation techniques' for use by the CIA against detainees held in secret custody."

In other criticisms of the United States, Amnesty said "excessive force" by US law enforcement was a concern, with 45 people killed during the past year after being struck by police Tasers -- 450 deaths since 2001.

"Most of the deceased were unarmed and did not appear to present a serious threat when they were shocked," it said.

Amnesty also expressed concern about an immigration law passed in Arizona which could allow police to demand proof of legal status, fearing it would increase "racial profiling."

It also said "hundreds of women continued to die from preventable pregnancy-related complications" because of a lack of health care coverage.

Source: Agence France-Presse, May 13, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Monday, December 13, 2010

10 Infamous Cases of Wrongful Execution

There’s no doubt about it – the U.S. criminal justice system is not perfect. And those imperfections become apparent when someone is the innocent victim of the death penalty. Wrongful executions have been happening for hundreds of years, but until the advent of DNA evidence and improved forensics technology, these individuals have remained guilty as charged.


Today, DNA evidence has exonerated and released 15 death row inmates since 1992, but only eight inmates have been acknowledged of their possible innocence after execution by the Death Penalty Information Center.


Here are 10 infamous cases of wrongful execution that deserve a second look:

1. Claude Jones: Claude Jones was executed in 2000 for the murder of liquor store owner Allen Hilzendager, in San Jacinto County in 1989. On Nov. 14, 1989, Jones and another man were seen pulling into a liquor store in Point Blank, Texas. One stayed in the car while the other went inside and shot the owner. Witnesses who were standing across the road couldn’t see the killer, but Jones and two other men, Kerry Dixon and Timothy Jordan, were all linked to the murder. Although Jones said he never entered the store, Dixon and Jordan testified that Jones was in fact the shooter and they were both spared the death penalty. The deciding factor and only admissible evidence in Jones’ conviction came down to a strand of hair that was found at the scene of the crime. A forensic expert testified that the hair appeared to have come from Jones, and he was sentenced to death. Forensic technology was underdeveloped during the 1990 trial and it wasn’t able to match Jones’ DNA with the hair sample. Therefore, before his 2000 execution, Jones’ attorneys filed petitions for a stay of execution with a district court and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals and requested that the hair be submitted for DNA testing that was now possible, but all courts and former Texas Governor George W. Bush denied Jones and he was executed. In an attempt to prove that Texas executed an innocent man, the Innocence Project and the Texas Observer filed a lawsuit in 2007 to obtain the strand of hair and submitted it for DNA testing, which was determined to be the hair of the victim.

2. Jesse Tafero: Jesse Tafero was executed by electric chair in 1990 for murdering two Florida police officers, Phillip Black and Donald Irwin. The murders occurred on Feb. 20, 1976, when Black and Irwin approached a parked car at a rest stop and found Tafero, his partner Sonia "Sunny" Jacobs, her two children and Walter Rhodes asleep inside. They were ordered to get out of the car when the officers saw a gun lying on the floor inside the car and, according to Rhodes, Tafero proceeded to shoot both officers and took off in their police car. They disposed of the police car and stole a man’s car, but were arrested after being caught in a roadblock. The gun was found in Tafero’s waistband, although it was legally registered to Jacobs. Tafero had been convicted of robbery and had served seven years of a 25-year sentence before being convicted for murder. Tafero and Jacobs claimed that Rhodes was the lone shooter, but Rhodes testified against them in exchange for a lighter sentence. Rhodes later admitted that he was responsible for the killings, but Tafero was still sentenced to death.

3. Cameron Todd Willingham: Cameron Todd Willingham was executed in 2004 for murdering his three young daughters by intentionally setting fire to the family home in Corsicana, Texas. The arson-murder case fueled much controversy about Willingham’s guilt, which was determined by the case’s primary evidence – the arson investigators’ findings. They determined that the fire was deliberately set with the help of a liquid accelerant due to specific burn patterns, laboratory tests and points of origin. Willingham maintained his innocence and appealed his conviction for years, but was executed at the Texas State Penitentiary in Huntsville on Feb. 16, 2004. In 2009, the Texas Forensic Science Commission panel reevaluated the case and determined that state and local arson investigators used "flawed science" when they labeled the fire as arson. Although advances in fire science and arson investigations have improved since 1991, the year of the fire, experts now believe the Corsicana Fire Department was negligent in their findings. The science commission is still investigating the arson ruling, and if the judge clears Willingham, it would be the first time an official has formally declared a wrongful execution in Texas.

4. Larry Griffin: Larry Griffin was executed in 1995 for a drive-by shooting that killed 19-year-old drug dealer Quintin Moss in St. Louis. Griffin immediately became a suspect because his older brother Dennis Griffin, another well-known drug dealer, was murdered just six months earlier. Moss was believed to have killed Dennis Griffin. Although there were a number of possible suspects in the murder of Moss, a witness account by a white man named Robert Fitzgerald, who claimed to have seen the shooting, knew the license plate number of the vehicle and could identify the gunman was all it took to have Griffin arrested. Fitzgerald was a convicted felon who had a long history of run-ins with the law, which raised concerns about the legitimacy of his story. During the 1993 hearing, Fitzgerald admitted to being unsure if Griffin was the man in the car after all. There were two key witnesses who wavered and a third person whose testimony could have helped Griffin, but was never contacted by either the defense or prosecution. Griffin continued to proclaim his innocence until his execution. The NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund investigated the case after Griffin’s execution and wanted to uncover more witness accounts that could support their claim that Missouri executed an innocent man.

5. Ruben Cantu: Ruben Cantu was executed in 1993 for the murder-robbery of a San Antonio man at the age of 17. Cantu had no previous convictions, but was pinpointed as a violent murderer who shot one victim nine times, as well as shot the only eyewitness nine times with a rifle, but he lived to testify. Juan Moreno offered his testimony to police and identified Cantu as the shooter, but later recanted, admitting that he said Cantu out of influence and fear of authorities. Although the case had a compelling witness testimony, there was no physical evidence that linked Cantu to the crime. In addition, his co-defendant David Garza, who allegedly committed the murder-robbery with Cantu, remained silent and signed a sworn affidavit allowing his accomplice to be falsely accused. Cantu maintained his innocence until his execution and claimed that he had been framed in this capital murder case.

6. David Spence: David Spence was executed in 1997 for murdering three teenagers in 1982 in Waco. Spence was convicted of raping, torturing and murdering two 17-year-old girls and murdering an 18-year-old boy. As the original allegations go, Spence was hired by convenience store owner Muneer Deeb to kill one girl and he ended up killing these three teens by mistake. Deeb was charged and sentenced to death, but later received a re-trial and was acquitted. Authoritative sources even had serious doubt about Spence’s guilt. Although there was no clear physical evidence to link Spence to the crime, prosecutors used bite marks that were found on one of the girl’s body and matched it to Spence’s teeth. Even jailhouse witnesses were bribed into snitching on Spence. Despite weak evidential support and jail mate testimonies, Spence was executed.

7. Carlos De Luna: Carlos De Luna was executed in 1989 for the 1983 stabbing of Wanda Lopez, a Texas convenience store clerk. There were two eyewitnesses who played a key role in the conviction of De Luna. Before the murder-robbery, George Aguirre was filling up at the gas station where the crime occurred, when he saw a man standing outside the store slide a knife with the blade exposed into his pocket and enter. The man asked Aguirre for a ride to a nightclub, but he refused and went inside the store to warn Lopez about the suspicious man. Aguirre left and Lopez called the police to describe the man. As she was on the phone with a dispatcher, the man came back into the store and robbed her. The second witness, Kevan Baker, pulled into the station and heard bangs on the station’s window and saw a man struggling with a woman. As Baker approached the gas station, the murderer threatened him and took off. When police searched the area, they found De Luna not far from the station. He was shirtless and shoeless in a puddle of water and screamed, "Don’t shoot! You got me!" Both Aguirre and Baker confirmed De Luna was the man at the station. Little to no physical evidence was collected at the crime scene, including blood samples and fingerprints that could have helped De Luna. De Luna maintained his innocence and repeated that Carlos Hernandez was the actual killer. Despite Hernandez’s trouble with the law and repeated confessions to the murder, De Luna was executed.

8. Joseph O’Dell: Joseph O’Dell was executed in 1997 for raping and murdering Helen Schartner. O’Dell was convicted on the basis of blood evidence and a jailhouse snitch. O’Dell represented himself and continued to proclaim his innocence in various unsuccessful appeals to the Virginia Supreme Court, Federal District Court and the Supreme Court. O’Dell requested that the state submit other pieces of evidence for DNA testing, but he was refused. Despite much effort and several appeals, the 4th Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals upheld his conviction and reinstated his death sentence. After his execution, Lori Urs, an anti-death penalty advocate and former wife to O’Dell, sought to further investigate the case and exonerate O’Dell based on mistaken blood matches, court opinions and refusal of DNA testing. However, the last of the DNA evidence from O’Dell’s case was burned in March 2000 and the appeals were laid to rest.

9. Leo Jones: Leo Jones was executed in 1998 for murdering a police officer in Florida. Although Jones confessed 12 hours after the murder, he said that he was forced to say he did it during hours of intimidating police interrogation, where they threatened his life and made him play Russian roulette. One witness believed that the police department was out to get Jones because he had assaulted an officer once. The same two arresting officers were released from the department shortly after for using violence in other cases. Despite repeated appeals, other potential suspects and witness testimonies in support of Jones’ exoneration, the sentencing stood as is. Jones was also denied another method of execution and was killed by the electric chair.

10. Timothy Evans: Timothy Evans was sentenced to death by hanging for the murder of his daughter in 1949 at their home in Notting Hill, London. Evans maintained his innocence and repeatedly accused his neighbor, John Christie, of murdering his wife and daughter. The police investigation and physical evidence used to convict Evans was weak. After Evans’ trial and execution, Christie was found to be a serial killer who was responsible for murdering several women at his residence. There were massive campaigns to overturn Evans’ conviction and an official inquiry was conducted 16 years later. It was confirmed that Evans’ daughter had been killed by Christie, and Evans was granted a posthumous pardon. This case of injustice had a strong influence in the UK’s decision to abolish capital punishment.

Source: Criminal Justice Degrees Guide, December 13, 2010

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

10 years after his execution, Claude Jones' ashes are laid to rest amid new questions about his guilt

For 10 years, Travis Jones faithfully carried the ashes of his brother, who he believed had been wrongfully executed in Texas, in a box with him most everywhere he went.

That box, which became Jones' constant companion, was finally lowered into a grave at White Oak Cemetery in Porter on Tuesday. It marked the 10th anniversary of his brother Claude Jones' execution. That was just as Claude wanted, a last wish that some family members initially viewed as "crazy" but now see as prophetic.

Until his last breath, Claude, a 60-year-old career criminal, denied being the one who entered a San Jacinto County liquor store in 1989 to fatally shoot and rob the owner, Allen Hilzendager.

Before the execution, Jones told his younger brother, Travis, that he did not want to be buried in a cemetery in Huntsville with other killers and rapists. He asked his brother to sprinkle a small portion of his ashes in three spots: the Gulf waters in Kemah, his mother's grave in Houston and his ex-wife's grave in Humble, but then preserve the rest for 10 years.

"My brother promised 'all would come out good' after that. Good things would happen," said Travis, saying his brother refused to explain further and just repeated that things would turn out "good." "He'd gotten kind of religious. I don't know if he'd had some kind of vision or dream or what."

But a few weeks before the 10th anniversary of the execution, new DNA testing has raised questions as to whether Claude was innocent. Mitochondrial DNA tests determined a strand of hair — which had been the only physical evidence linking Claude to the crime scene - actually belonged to the murder victim instead.

An expert who had examined the same hair fragment under a microscope 10 years earlier had testified during Claude's murder trial that the strand "matched" the defendant.

Without the hair evidence, Barry Scheck, co-director of the Innocence Project, believes Claude's case might have been overturned for insufficient evidence.


Source: Houston Chronicle, December 7, 2010

Saturday, December 4, 2010

Texas Defender Service: The 6 best arguments against the death penalty in Texas

Execution chamber
Huntsville Unit, Texas
The following guest blog post was written by Andrea Keilen, Executive Director of Texas Defender Service.

This week, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Stevens published an essay detailing the Court's decisions that created a system infected with problems, and one he now believes is unconstitutional. Since 1976, 138 people have been exonerated from death row nationwide.

12 of them were in Texas.

The fact that some mistakes were discovered in time and innocent people were exonerated strongly suggests that there have been other occasions when mistakes were not discovered in time and innocent people were executed.

Beginning Monday, December 6, at a hearing next week in a Harris County District Court, expert witnesses will testify about the numerous flaws that leave Texas' system riddled with errors, inherently unreliable, and unconstitutional as applied.

Attorneys for John Green, who is charged with capital murder, will urge the court to rule the Texas death penalty statute unconstitutional because it creates an unacceptable risk that innocent people have been, and will be, wrongfully convicted and executed.

When innocent people are exonerated, it is often a matter of dumb luck . For example, the real killer confesses or pro bono law firms take an interest in the case. It is rarely because the system catches errors and corrects itself.

Both Ernest Ray Willis and Cameron Todd Willingham were convicted of murder by arson and sentenced to death on the basis of junk fire science. Mr. Willingham is dead and Mr. Willis is alive -- and free -- because a pro bono law firm took Mr. Willis' case.

At the hearing, witnesses will testify about the following factors, which taken together, create an unacceptable risk of wrongful conviction in capital cases:

1st, Texas has no standards to ensure that eyewitness testimony is obtained in ways that protect against the risk of mistaken identification.

Texas does not follow the scientific research or best practices on eyewitness identification recommended by the U.S. Department of Justice, the International Association of Chiefs of Police, or the ABA. Nationwide, more than 75% of individuals exonerated by DNA evidence were convicted because of faulty eyewitness identifications .

2nd, Texas allows the introduction of confessions that have been obtained without safeguards to protect against false confessions. Texas law does not require recording interrogations . 25 % of the exonerations in the U.S. revealed through DNA testing involved a false confession .

3rd, use of informant testimony is largely unregulated in Texas.

Although in 2009 Texas began to require corroborating evidence for jailhouse informant testimony, that standard is loosely defined. Further, Texas has not implemented other important safeguards involving greater transparency and pretrial reliability screenings which more fully protect against false testimony. In one study, nearly 50% of wrongful murder convictions involved perjury by a jailhouse snitch or another witness who stood to gain from false testimony. (Professor Gross study, p. 39)

4th, pervasive flaws have been identified in the analysis of presentation of forensic evidence that result in unreliable results. In a study of DNA exonerations , the prosecution provided invalid forensic testimony in 60% of the cases, that is, testimony that misstated the data or was not supported by the data. (Garrett and Neufeld, p. 41) The National Academy of Sciences recently issued a broad critique of the nation's forensic system. The risk of wrongful conviction due to faulty forensic science at the is, standing alone, constitutionally intolerable.

5th, pretrial discovery procedures are inadequate to safeguard against the prosecution's suppression of evidence favorable to the accused.

A survey of published capital cases in Texas documented state misconduct in 41 capital convictions. (Texas Defender Service, p. 48)

6th, Texas prosecutors in Harris County and elsewhere have a shameful history of excluding African Americans from juries. Although this practice has been illegal for more than a century, recent research shows that discrimination in jury selection increases the risk of wrongful convictions by reducing the thoroughness and accuracy of jury deliberations.

Texas routinely fails to provide competent counsel and adequate defense funding in state habeas corpus proceedings. Extensive research, and a State Bar Task Force have all reached this conclusion. In almost 40% of state habeas cases, the petitions did not include any materials beyond the existing record, a clear indication of a lack of investigation.

The Texas clemency procedure lacks most elements of a sufficient clemency review and fails in its role as the last safeguard against executing the innocent. For example, Claude Jones was executed in 2000 based on false evidence. During the clemency review, then-Governor Bush was not informed that Mr. Jones had requested DNA testing that might have exonerated him. Ten years after Mr. Jones' execution, a DNA test showed that the hair sample at the crime scene was not his.

All 3 branches of Texas government have created entities to review issues in the criminal justice system based on the risk of error:

•In 2005, the Texas legislature created and Governor Rick Perry signed legislation creating the Texas Forensic Science Commission .

•By executive order, Governor Rick Perry created the Criminal Justice Advisory Council .

•In 2008, the highest criminal court in Texas, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, created a Criminal Justice Integrity Unit .

•In 2009, the legislature created and the governor approved the Timothy Cole Advisory Panel on Wrongful Convictions .

But virtually nothing has been done to reduce the most prevalent causes of wrongful convictions Innocent people can and do get sentenced to death in Texas. Action by the courts and legislature to address these serious problems is long overdue.

Source: Dallas Morning News, December 3, 2010

Monday, November 29, 2010

Tariq Aziz sentenced on crimes against Iraqi Kurds

Tariq Aziz
BAGHDAD (AP) — An Iraqi court on Monday convicted Tariq Aziz, Saddam Hussein's longtime foreign minister, of terrorizing Shiite Kurds during the Iran-Iraq war, sentencing him to 10 years in prison.

The jail term piles a new penalty on the 74-year-old Aziz, who already faces an execution sentence from another case.

Aziz was spared the death penalty in the Saddam-era crimes against humanity because he had a lesser involvement in the atrocities than some of his co-defendants, said Mohammed Abdul-Sahib, a spokesman for the Iraqi High Tribunal. The case involves crimes targeting Iraq's small sect of Shiite Kurds, known as Faili.

At least three former Saddam loyalists were sentenced to death in the same case, although two of the dictator's half brothers were found not guilty in the campaign against the Faili Kurds.

Saddam was a Sunni Muslim. In all, 15 defendants were charged in the case.

The small Faili minority comes mainly from an area in northeastern Iraq that straddles the Iraq-Iran border. Saddam killed, detained and deported tens of thousands of Faili Kurds early in his 1980-1988 war with Iran, denouncing them as alien Persians and spies for the Iranians.

Aziz was the highest-profile defendant to come before judges on Monday. He already faces execution in an earlier case linking him to Saddam's persecution of Shiite political parties.

His Italy-based lawyer, Giovanni di Stefano, called his return to court an example of "how seriously flawed is the Iraqi criminal justice system." He said all of the allegations against Aziz should have been rolled into one trial.

Di Stefano also said he plans to sue the U.S. government for reneging on what he called an agreement approved by former U.S. President George W. Bush to release Aziz after being questioned about the Saddam regime as a condition of his 2003 surrender to American forces in Iraq.

Aziz is still waiting to hear whether President Jalal Talabani, himself a Kurd, will grant him a presidential pardon or if he will be executed on order from the High Tribunal's appeals court — a decision that could come at any time. Talabani has said he will not sign off on Aziz's death warrant, given his old age and the fact that he was the only Christian in Saddam's inner circle.

But there are ways in Iraq's constitution to bypass the president in capital cases — such as an act of parliament or the approval of one of Talabani's two deputies. It's also not clear if Talabani has the constitutional authority to grant Aziz a pardon.

Source: AP, November 29, 2010

Thursday, November 11, 2010

DNA Tests Undermine Evidence in Texas Execution

New results show Claude Jones was put to death on flawed evidence.

Claude Jones (left) always claimed that he wasn’t the man who walked into an East Texas liquor store in 1989 and shot the owner. He professed his innocence right up until the moment he was strapped to a gurney in the Texas execution chamber and put to death on Dec. 7, 2000. His murder conviction was based on a single piece of forensic evidence recovered from the crime scene—a strand of hair—that prosecutors claimed belonged to Jones.

But DNA tests completed this week at the request of the Observer and the New York-based Innocence Project show the hair didn’t belong to Jones after all. The day before his death in December 2000, Jones asked for a stay of execution so the strand of hair could be submitted for DNA testing. He was denied by then-Gov. George W. Bush.

A decade later, the results of DNA testing not only undermine the evidence that convicted Jones, but raise the possibility that Texas executed an innocent man. The DNA tests—conducted by Mitotyping Technologies, a private lab in State College, Pa., and first reported by the Observer on Thursday—show the hair belonged to the victim of the shooting, Allen Hilzendager, the 44-year-old owner of the liquor store.

Because the DNA testing doesn’t implicate another shooter, the results don’t prove Jones’ innocence. But the hair was the only piece of evidence that placed Jones at the crime scene. So while the results don’t exonerate him, they raise serious doubts about his guilt. As with the now-infamous Cameron Todd Willingham arson case, the key forensic evidence in a Texas death penalty case has now been debunked.

“The DNA results prove that testimony about the hair sample on which this entire case rests was just wrong,” said Barry Scheck, co-founder of the Innocence Project, in a statement. “Unreliable forensic science and a completely inadequate post-conviction review process cost Claude Jones his life.”

Jones was 60 years old when he was executed on December 7, 2000—the last man put to death by then-Gov. Bush.


Source: texasobserver.org, Dave Mann, November 11, 2010

Friday, November 5, 2010

UN human rights council urges US to end death penalty

American delegate says capital punishment is subject of vigorous debate and applied for in only the most serious crimes

The US today faced an international clamour to abolish the death penalty during a debate at the UN human rights council in Geneva.

The council is gradually reviewing the performance of all 192 UN member states. The US took its moment in the spotlight seriously, sending a high-level delegation of around 30 officials led by Esther Brimmer, the assistant secretary of state for international organisation affairs.

The delegation was given a mostly warm welcome by delegates of the 47-member council, but was forced to listen to repeated calls for the US to put an end to the death penalty.

More than 1,200 men and women have been put to death in the US since executions resumed in 1977 after a decade without them, according to Amnesty International.

Three jurisdictions – Texas, Virginia, and Oklahoma – account for more than half the country's executions. Missouri has approximately 40 people on death row, but has not executed anyone since 2005.

At the end of 2009, 139 countries had abolished the death penalty. The US finds itself grouped with authoritarian countries such as China and Iran in still executing people.

Harold Hongju Koh, the state department's legal adviser, said capital punishment was a subject of vigorous debate and litigation in the US and was applied for in only the most serious crimes.

He pointed out that there were strict procedural safeguards, adding that, in recent years, the supreme court had narrowed the list of offences for which the death penalty could be applied.

But he insisted that capital punishment did not violate international law, telling the council: "International human rights law does not bar it per se."

Koh also strongly defended the use of unmanned drone aircraft to kill "high value tagets" on the Afghanistan-Pakistan border and in Yemen.

"Our targeting practice complies with all human rights law," he said. "Operations are conducted in conformity with rule of law principles. It has been long legitimate to target enemy leaders and force is directed only at lawful targets."

Since the beginning of September, Barack Obama has authorised at least 25 targeted killings.

While the attacks have killed senior al-Qaida and Taliban figures, they have also killed civilians, including a large number of women and children, sparking anger against the US.

The fiercest criticism at the UN council came from countries at odds with the US.

The Cuban ambassador, Rodolfo Reyes Rodriguez, who spoke first, called on the Americans to end their embargo against his country.

Venezuela's envoy, Germán Mundarain Hernández, said the US should "close Guantánamo and secret detention centres around the world, punish those people who torture, disappear and execute detainees arbitrarily and provide compensation to victims".

Iran's delegation urged the US to "halt serious violations of human rights and humanitarian law including covert external operations by the CIA carried out on pretext of combating terrorism".

Koh said the Obama administration had begun by "turning the page" on Bush-era practices and fully ensured the humane treatment of detainees.

"Let there be no doubt, the United States does not torture and it will not torture," he declared.

A state department submission in August, written after extensive public consultation, said the US was "currently at war with al-Qaida and its associated forces" but that it would comply with all applicable domestic and international law in armed conflicts and had ordered foreign detainees be treated humanely.

The report said the US was a democracy guided by "simple but powerful principles", but admits to discrimination against black people and Hispanics and a "broken" immigration system.

Source: The Guardian, November 5, 2010


US: Status Quo Stance at First UN Rights Review

Other Countries Point to Death Penalty, Migrant Policy as Sources of Concern

(New York) - The United States should take concrete steps to address serious failings in its human rights record, Human Rights Watch said today. Many of the issues were raised by UN member countries on November 5, 2010, during the United States' first review of its human rights conditions and policies before the Human Rights Council in Geneva.

"The US wasn't defensive in its responses, but it also refused to budge from the status quo," said Antonio Ginatta, US advocacy director at Human Rights Watch. "US officials were often reduced to restating current practices that grossly violate human rights, like the death penalty, poor prison conditions, and sentencing youth offenders to life without parole."

During what is called the Universal Periodic Review, a vast majority of countries expressed their concern about the death penalty and called for a nationwide moratorium. Similarly, countries pointed out problems with mistreatment of migrants and racial disparities in education, access to health care, and the criminal justice system. Many called on the United States to follow through on its promise to close the prison at Guantanamo Bay.

Almost all participating countries also called on the United States to ratify core human rights treaties, such as the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination against Women, and the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

One senior US official said at the proceedings that the only way to promote American values was to "live them at home." But that doesn't apply to everyone in the United States, Human Rights Watch said. One in ten African American men is incarcerated; about 2,500 youth offenders are serving sentences of life without parole; 40 people have been executed so far this year; 400,000 immigrants are in prison-like detention centers; and 48 people remain imprisoned at Guantanamo facing unfair military commission trials.

Inmates wait in holding pens at
the California Institution for Men in Chino.
The Universal Periodic Review system was established in 2006. The review provides a chance to draw attention to, and make recommendations about, human rights violations in all UN member states. States under review submit written reports concerning the human rights situation in their country and respond to the questions and recommendations put forward by other UN member states. All 192 UN member countries undergo such reviews every four years.

At today's session, more than 55 countries spoke for two minutes each, offering recommendations and asking questions of the delegation. The US took one hour to discuss its record and respond generally to some of the statements. Following its review, the US held a town hall meeting for civil society organizations gathered in both Geneva and Washington, participating through the web. It was a major opportunity for civil society groups to ask questions and further engage with the US government about its rights record. The US is the first country to hold such a session.

The report of the proceedings will be released early next week, and the United States will have until March 2011 to submit its final responses to the recommendations.

"Thankfully the US seems to acknowledge that today's meeting was not the final chapter in the UPR process," Ginatta said. "While today's meeting leaves little room for hope that the government will announce reforms in its final response to the UPR in March, Human Rights Watch and other civil society groups will continue to press the US to fulfill its human rights obligations."

Source: Human Rights Watch, November 5, 2010

Thursday, November 4, 2010

United States for first time submits human rights record to world scrutiny

The United States is submitting its human rights record to the scrutiny of other nations — both allies and adversaries — for the first time, as the Obama administration opens itself up to a committee shunned by his predecessor.

The 3-hour U.N. review Friday will have more than a few uncomfortable moments for the high-level U.S. delegation, which is sure to face questions over the use of torture in the war on terror, not dismantling the prison at Guantanamo Bay, the death penalty, immigration policy, the treatment of racial minorities and questions of religious freedom.

The 30-strong delegation, headed by three top State Department officials and including representatives from many departments, including Justice, Defense and Homeland Security, arrives in Geneva with a 20-page report compiled with the input of civic and social organizations.

For most observers, the high level of U.S. engagement alone is a milestone. The Bush administration shunned the U.N. Human Rights Council, which runs the so-called Universal Public Reviews, because of the participation of repressive states and its constant criticism of Israel.

Some of the most vocal critics of the review process have come from the U.S. Congress, and a landslide by the frequently U.N.-skeptical Republicans in Tuesday's election could leave the country even less receptive.

Human rights organizations say the ultimate test will be in the U.S. response to peer recommendations from any of the United Nations 192 members, including possibly Iran, which will be made next week.

Jamil Dakwar, director of the ACLU human rights program, said it is important that the United States matches its rhetoric with concrete domestic policies and actions.

"We believe that Obama administration should take specific actions through executive order and legislation that assure domestic human rights commitments, including UPR recommendations, are monitored and enforced within the U.S.," Dakwar said.

Some activists say Washington's report glosses over some of the toughest human rights challenges facing the United States, including the treatment of immigrants, the death penalty and officials responsible for the use of torture as a tool in the war against terror.

"We were dissatisfied because we concluded half of the report was basically fluff. It had very little substance," said Ajamu Baraka, director of the US Human Rights Network, a coalition of non-governmental organizations that prepared its own human rights reports in parallel. "It devoted too much space to a rendering of U.S. history as it relates to human rights that we thought was primarily myth."

Beyond front-page issues like torture and immigration, Baraka also wants to see the United States make more progress in what are seen as softer economic, social and cultural human rights, areas that came into sharp focus by the economic collapse that has penalized mostly less powerful members of society.

The 47-member council replaced the discredited Human Rights Commission in 2006, and the Obama administration joined last year — although as a U.N. member would have been required to participate in the peer review in any case. The council has no enforcement powers, but is supposed to act as the world's moral conscience on human rights.

The best tool it has for that is the UPR process, under which it reviews all of the 192 U.N. members' human rights records every four years. It is currently about 2/3 into the first cycle, which will be completed at the end of 2011.

The review will also be a test for the council itself, as governments assess next year whether the young body is living up to its stated purpose to be the world's pre-eminent forum for discussing human rights.

Critics of the council have argued that too often repressive states such as Cuba and Pakistan have used the review process to lavish praise on their allies, a practice the U.S. recently suggested should be banned in future meetings.

The process has its detractors across the Atlantic who don't want to see the United States submit to the scrutiny of countries with lesser human rights records. Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer, for example, called it "internationalism run amok," complaining that the state's controversial immigration law was included in the report. She asked it be removed; it was not.

Indeed, it is highly likely that countries like Iran — whose human rights record is often under fire from Washington — will jockey to be the first to question the United States. But U.S. officials say such scrutiny does not weaken the process.

"We will get some interesting questions. We will get some outrageous questions. The United State is used to public scrutiny," Eileen Chamberlain Donahoe, U.S. Ambassador to the Human Rights Council told a briefing Wednesday.

Donahoe said the United States needs to be willing to hear criticism also from its critics in order to be good role model.

"We genuinely believe that it is through that kind of open process, that the truth about our human rights record will shine through, number one, and the areas where we need to improve will benefit from the real and serious input that we get," she said.

The U.S. report acknowledges areas where problems persist, including discrimination against Hispanics and African Americans, unemployment rates of up to 80 % on some Native American reservations and a "broken" immigration system. But it emphasizes that participating in the review does not place the United States at the same level as countries that systematically abuse human rights.

"There is no comparison between American democracy and repressive regimes," the report says.

Donahoe said she hoped that Tuesday's elections, which gave control of the House to the Republicans, who are generally more wary of the U.N., would have little bearing on the U.S. engagement with the global body over the longer term.

"I feel fairly confident we are starting to change the understanding at home about the value of the opportunity that we have here, that engagement has its benefits," Donahoe said.

On the Net: Universal Period Review: http://www.ohchr.org/EN/HRBodies/UPR

source: Associated Press, November 3, 2010

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

Jailed Tareq Aziz handed over to Iraqis

AMMAN — Iraq's jailed ex-deputy prime minister Tareq Aziz (left) has been handed over by the US military to the Iraqi authorities, his lawyer said on Wednesday, warning that his client's life is "in danger now."

"The American side handed over Aziz and other detainees to the Iraqi side on Tuesday night," Amman-based lawyer Badie Aref told AFP.

"Aziz called me and said he was being held in the Kazemieh prison in Baghdad."

Aref urged intervention by international organisations.

"He should have been released. What the Americans did violates the Red Cross code because they handed him over to his enemies. His life is in danger now."

Aref said Aziz told him that US President Barack Obama "is no different to (former US president George) Bush, and that he will take part in killing us, indirectly."

Aziz, 73, who turned himself in to US forces in April 2003, is one of Saddam Hussein's few surviving cohorts after the late dictator's henchman Ali Hassan al-Majid -- better known as "Chemical Ali" -- was hanged in Iraq in January for a poison gas attack against Kurds in 1988.

Appointed deputy premier in 1991 under Saddam -- having previously been foreign minister -- he was jailed for 15 years for murder in 2009, and was given a seven-year term in August last year for his role in expelling Kurds from Iraq's north.

The family of Aziz, who had reportedly already had two heart attacks since turning himself in to US forces just days after Saddam's ouster in April 2003, has repeatedly called for his release on health grounds.

The former Iraqi official hails from a Chaldean Catholic family.

Source: Agence France-Presse, July 14, 2010


Iraq: US hands over Tariq Aziz, other detainees

BAGHDAD — Iraq's deputy justice minister says U.S. authorities have handed over 55 members of Saddam Hussein's former regime, including the longtime international face of the regime, Tariq Aziz.

Wednesday's announcement comes a day before U.S. authorities are to depart Camp Cropper, the last American-run detention facility in Iraq.

Iraq's deputy justice minister Busho Ibrahim tells The Associated Press the handover has taken place over the last three days.

U.S. authorities confirmed Wednesday that they had handed over some detainees but would not give any identities.

Source: Associated Press, July 14, 2010