Showing posts with label Mexico. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mexico. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 28, 2014

La Comisión Interamericana de Derechos Humanos condena ejecución de Edgar Tamayo Arias en Estados Unidos

Edgar Tamayo
27 de enero de 2014 - Washington, D.C. — La Comisión Interamericana de Derechos Humanos (CIDH) condena la ejecución judicial de Edgar Tamayo Arias, la cual tuvo lugar el 22 de enero de 2014 en Texas, Estados Unidos, en violación de sus derechos fundamentales.

En enero de 2012 fue presentada, en nombre del señor Tamayo, una petición alegando violaciones a la Declaración Americana así como una solicitud de medidas cautelares. La CIDH, mediante el otorgamiento de medidas cautelares, solicitó a Estados Unidos de ejecutar la pena capital hasta tanto la Comisión tuviera la oportunidad de decidir sobre los reclamos de la peticionaria. El 17 de julio de 2012 la CIDH decidió que el caso era admisible.

Luego de analizar el fondo del caso, el 15 de enero de 2014 la Comisión Interamericana adoptó el Informe No. 1/14 en el cual concluyó, entre otros, que el no respeto por parte del Estado de la obligación de informar al señor Tamayo de su derecho a la notificación y asistencia consulares prevista en el artículo 36.1 de la Convención de Viena sobre Relaciones Consulares lo privó de un proceso penal que satisfaga los estándares mínimos de debido proceso y juicio justo requeridos bajo la Declaración Americana. En consecuencia, la Comisión recomendó a Estados Unidos revisar el juicio y la condena del señor Tamayo de acuerdo con las garantías reconocidas en la Declaración Americana. A pesar de las conclusiones y recomendaciones emitidas por la Comisión, el gobierno de Texas procedió a ejecutar al señor Tamayo como previsto.

La Comisión Interamericana deplora la falta de cumplimiento de Estados Unidos y del estado de Texas con las recomendaciones emitidas por la CIDH en un informe de fondo. El hecho que Estados Unidos no haya preservado la vida del señor Tamayo estando pendiente una solicitud de la CIDH de revisión de su juicio y condena, contraviene sus obligaciones internacionales derivadas de la Carta de la Organización de Estados Americanos y de la Declaración Americana en vigor desde que Estados Unidos se incorporó a las OEA en 1951. La falta de cumplimiento con las recomendaciones de la Comisión resultó en un grave e irreparable daño al derecho más fundamental del señor Tamayo, el derecho a la vida.

La Comisión Interamericana ha abordado durante décadas la cuestión de la pena de muerte como un desafío crucial en materia de derechos humanos. A pesar de que la mayoría de los Estados miembros de la Organización de Estados Americanos ha abolido la pena capital, una minoría considerable la mantiene. Al respecto, la Comisión destaca que Estados Unidos es actualmente el único país del hemisferio occidental en aplicar ejecuciones a la pena de muerte.

La Comisión reitera la recomendación formulada en su informe “La pena de muerte en el Sistema Interamericano de Derechos Humanos: de restricciones a abolición” publicado en 2012, de que los Estados apliquen una moratoria a las ejecuciones como paso hacia la gradual supresión de este tipo de pena.

La CIDH es un órgano principal y autónomo de la Organización de los Estados Americanos (OEA), cuyo mandato surge de la Carta de la OEA y de la Convención Americana sobre Derechos Humanos. La Comisión está integrada por siete miembros independientes que se desempeñan en forma personal, que no representan a ningún país en particular y que son elegidos por la Asamblea General de la OEA.

Fuente: CIDH, 27 de enero de 2014


English Translation: IACHR Condemns Execution of Edgar Tamayo Arias in the United States

January 27, 2014 - Washington, D.C. — The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) condemns the judicial execution of Edgar Tamayo Arias, which took place on January 22, 2014, in Texas, United States, in violation of his fundamental rights.

In January 2012 a petition alleging the violation of the American Declaration and a request for precautionary measures were filed on Mr. Tamayo’s behalf. The IACHR granted precautionary measures asking the United States to refrain from carrying out the death penalty until the Commission had the opportunity to issue a decision on the petitioner's claims. On July 17, 2012, the IACHR decided the case was admissible.

After analyzing the merits of the case, on January 15, 2014, the Inter-American Commission adopted Report No. 1/14 in which it concluded, among other findings, that the State’s failure to respect its obligation under Article 36.1 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations to inform Mr. Tamayo of his right to consular notification and assistance deprived him of a criminal process that satisfied the minimum standards of due process and a fair trial required under the American Declaration. Accordingly, the Commission recommended that the United States review Mr. Tamayo’s trial and sentence in accordance with the guarantees recognized in the American Declaration. Despite the Commission’s conclusions and recommendations, the government of Texas proceeded to execute Mr. Tamayo as scheduled.

The Inter-American Commission deplores the failure on the part of the United States and the state of Texas to comply with the recommendations issued by the IACHR in a merits report. The failure of the United States to preserve Mr. Tamayo's life pending a recommendation by the IACHR to review his trial and sentence contravenes its international legal obligations derived from the Charter of the Organization of American States and the American Declaration which are in force since the United States joined the OAS in 1951. This failure to comply with the Commission’s recommendations resulted in serious and irreparable harm to Mr. Tamayo’s most fundamental right, the right to life.

The Inter-American Commission has dealt with the death penalty as a crucial human rights challenge for decades. While a majority of the member States of the Organization of American States has abolished capital punishment, a substantial minority retains it. In this regard, the Commission notes that the United States is currently the only country in the Western hemisphere to carry out executions.

The Commission reiterates the recommendation made in its report “The Death Penalty in the Inter-American Human Rights System: From Restrictions to Abolition” published in 2012, that States impose a moratorium on executions as a step toward the gradual disappearance of this penalty.

A principal, autonomous body of the Organization of American States (OAS), the IACHR derives its mandate from the OAS Charter and the American Convention on Human Rights. The Inter-American Commission has a mandate to promote respect for human rights in the region and acts as a consultative body to the OAS in this matter. The Commission is composed of seven independent members who are elected in a personal capacity by the OAS General Assembly and who do not represent their countries of origin or residence. (Source: IACHR)

Monday, January 27, 2014

Support for death penalty climbs in Mexico amid murders

The Texas execution of Edgar Tamayo for the murder of a U.S. police officer was heavily criticized by Mexican officials, who say their country rightly banned capital punishment years ago.

But if the Mexican people had their way, the death penalty would be an option for justice for murderers such as Tamayo, say surveys and criminal experts here.

Surveys by polling firms and media outlets in Mexico over the past seven years show that support for the death penalty has been increasing to a point where a majority would like to see it reinstated. Recent polls found between 70% and 80% would like to see the death penalty imposed for crimes such as murder and kidnapping, a rate that is above the majority support for the death penalty in the United States.

The rising support for the death penalty in Mexico comes amid the gruesome kidnappings and mass murders committed by criminals and drug cartels in recent years.

Tamayo's execution made front-page news in Mexico and protests were held in his hometown in Morelos state, just south of Mexico City. The Foreign Ministry said Tamayo was not informed properly of his consular rights and academics and human rights groups questioned why the United States uses a punishment other countries abandoned years ago.

"It's an embarrassment that the United States, which considers itself a modern country, continues applying the death penalty," said Juan Federico Arriola, law professor at the Iberoamerican University in Mexico City.

Tamayo, 46, was executed by lethal injection Wednesday in the 1994 shooting death of Houston police officer Gary Gaddis.

Gaddis, 24, had been on the Houston police force for 2 years and was driving Tamayo, who was in the country illegally, and another man from a robbery scene when Tamayo shot him 3 times in the head and neck with a pistol he had hidden in his pants. The car crashed and Tamayo fled but was captured a few blocks away, still in handcuffs.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry said the punishment was proper for such a "despicable" crime, adding that the law is the law.

Some Mexicans say their government seems to have a double standard when it comes to heinous crime: Mexican officials defend citizens convicted of murders abroad, but don't do enough to provide justice or attend to victims of crime back home.

"People are complaining because he's Mexican. There's no other reason," waiter Marco Antonio Rodriguez said of Tamayo.

"People might support (the death penalty) in the case of horrible crimes like rape and kidnap," he said of Mexicans.

Mexico did away the death penalty in 2005 and hasn't executed anyone in more than 50 years. Polls taken a decade ago showed the country split on the issue, with 38% of respondents in a 2004 survey by polling firm Parametria supporting capital punishment, while 42% were opposed.

Support shifted after the country began cracking down on crime and drug cartels in late 2006 and the incidence of murder and kidnapping increased. The National Survey on the Perceptions of Citizen Security released in November 2012 showed 74% of Mexicans backing the death penalty.

Despite the polls, political analysts express some skepticism that the issue would move the masses.

"If it were (popular) someone would be trying to take advantage of it politically," says Aldo Munoz Armenta, political science professor at the Autonomous University of Mexico State.

One party has done so, however, and successfully.

The Green Party campaigned in 2009 on a platform of bringing back the death penalty for kidnappers. It even hired soap opera stars to spread the message in radio and TV commercials. In that year's midterm elections, the party won more than 7% of the vote - a record showing for the party, which is an ally of the governing Institutional Revolutionary Party.

Munoz says the campaign worked due to widespread fear over kidnapping, especially after the 2008 abduction and murder of Fernando Marti, 14, son of the founder of a sporting goods retail empire. His kidnap and the response from authorities prompted a rare protest march from Mexico's middle and upper classes over insecurity.

Opponents of the death penalty, such as Munoz, point to practical problems in bringing it back, including the country's criminal justice system. The system is being overhauled to introduce more transparency, but has a reputation for routinely putting the wrong people in prison - often on flimsy evidence.

Mexico is also a heavily Catholic state, and the church has expressed its opposition to capital punishment.

"Do people actually think the justice system works? ... The police will pick up anybody," says Father Robert Coogan, an American Catholic priest working as chaplain in the city of Saltillo -- 190 miles south of the U.S. border at Laredo, Texas. At Coogan's morning Mass at a Saltillo prison on Thursday, prayers were offered for Tamayo from prisoners who were concerned about the execution.

Coogan also questioned if Mexicans would want to bring back the death penalty given the shortcomings of the system.

"I don't really think Mexicans would accept the death penalty, because they would be putting themselves at risk."

Source: USA Today, January 25, 2014

How 2014 is turning into a deadly year for prisoners across the globe

Edgar Arias Tamayo took 17 minutes to die.

The 46-year-old Mexican national was taken into the Texas execution chamber, strapped down and given a lethal injection which would eventually kill him.

He didn't have any final words to say, instead choosing to remain silent.

Tamayo, who was convicted of the 1994 shooting and killing police officer Guy Gaddis, 24, as he was being arrested for robbery was in the US illegally.

His execution went ahead despite objections from the US and Mexican governments arguing it violated international law, ignoring a 2004 court order from the International Court of Justice.

The ICJ argued that Edgar Tamayo, along with other Mexican nationals, was not informed of his right to seek consular advice without delay following his arrest.

This move denied him assistance that anti-death penalty advocates say could have provided crucial evidence in the case.

In 2008 a psychologist put Edgar Tamayo's intellectual functioning in the "mild mental retardation" range, which would render his execution unconstitutional under US law.

He was put to death regardless while his victim's mother and four other relatives looked on, the BBC reported.

Tamayo is just one of dozens of prisoners and people who have been put to their deaths across the globe so far this year.

In the past 2 weeks alone, inmates have been killed in countries such as Iran, Iraq, and the USA, which are among the top 5 states in the world carrying out the death penalty, according to Amnesty International.

Just this week Iraq was under the human rights spotlight after reports emerged of 12 secret executions carried out by authorities, bringing the number of prisoners put to death since Sunday 19th January to 38.

Amnesty claim many of those executed were convicted after grossly unfair trials, in which 'confessions' were extracted under torture and then used as evidence in court.

Most of those executed were convicted on charges of terrorism under the 2005 Anti-Terrorism Law.

Neighbour Iran carried out a total of 40 executions since the beginning of 2014, with at least 33 carried out in the past week alone.

Amnesty said it represented an alarming spike considering Iran was trying hard to change its image in the international community.

In the week since 9 January this year, more officially acknowledged executions were carried out here than during the whole month of January 2013.

At least 1 of these executions have been carried out in public this year, which normally sees the inmate lifted by a noose around the neck in front of a crowd and hanged.

Closer to home, Vietnam is set to add to those numbers after it sentenced 30 men and women to death on Tuesday for drug smuggling in the biggest drugs trial to take place in the country.

Vietnam executed its 1st prisoner to death last August following a 2-year hiatus in carrying out capital punishment due to difficulties obtaining chemicals for lethal injections.

The convicted drug smugglers join more than 700 others now estimated to be on death row in the south-eastern Asian nation.

Amnesty International spokeswoman Sarah Saleh said the number of executions which had taken place so far this year was certainly alarming.

"Amnesty opposes the death penalty in all cases, without exception," Ms Saleh said.

"It is a violation of every human being's right to life and is a cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment."

She added authorities must urgently take steps to abolish the death penalty, which has been shown again and again not to have any special deterrent effect on crime.

"Rather than continuing to hand down death sentences, these countries should be moving towards abolition, in line with the global trend," she said.

Source: news.com, January 27, 2014

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Texas: AG Candidates Weigh In on Execution of Mexican National

Wednesday night's execution in Texas of a Mexican national convicted of killing a Houston police officer has given the candidates vying to be the state's next attorney general an opportunity to weigh in on the death penalty - revealing only slight differences in how they might have handled the case.

Texas officials went ahead with Edgar Tamayo's execution despite pressure from both the Mexican and U.S. governments to delay it. U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry warned that the execution "could impact the way American citizens are treated in other countries."

Among the Republicans vying to replace Attorney General Greg Abbott, who is running for governor, all of them said they would have proceeded with the execution.

Enrique Marquez, state Rep. Dan Branch's campaign manager, said in an email that Branch "has never wavered in his belief that the death penalty is a just punishment for the most heinous crimes." Marquez said that because "there seems to be no question about Edgar Tamayo's guilt or of the due process," Branch would also have allowed the execution of Tamayo to go forward.

State Sen. Ken Paxton, R-McKinney, said in an email that Tamayo was "punished in accordance with state law, which provides for the death penalty." He said there was no need for a delay.

And Railroad Commissioner Barry Smitherman, who has long favored capital punishment on the stump, said Texas officials acted properly.

In 2002, during an interview with the Harris County district attorney's office, where he was hired as a prosecutor, Smitherman apparently led his interviewer to believe otherwise. "Smitherman is opposed to the death penalty for religious reasons," notes from his personnel file state. "He said that being pro-life doesn't 'square with' the death penalty."

Smitherman's campaign said his views had been mischaracterized in the notes.

"Barry supports, and has always supported, the death penalty for the most heinous and violent criminals," Jared Craighead, Smitherman's campaign manager, said in an email. "...It is clear that there was a misunderstanding in a short interview with one person that occurred over a decade ago regarding Barry's views on the death penalty."

Only Sam Houston, a Houston attorney and the lone Democrat in the race, said he would have asked for a delay in the execution. But his personal views on the death penalty don't appear to be much different from his Republican counterparts.

Houston said that in the Tamayo case, he is concerned that violating international treaties could put Americans in danger abroad and "have further far-reaching ramifications." He added that he had "no sympathy" for the offender.

Houston said he believed that the process by which criminals are convicted and given the ultimate punishment should be carefully scrutinized to make sure no innocent person is put to death. But if the appropriate legal process is followed, he said, "I am not personally opposed to the death penalty."

Source: The Texas Tribune, January 24, 2014

Support for death penalty climbs in Mexico amid murders

The Texas execution of Edgar Tamayo for the murder of a U.S. police officer was heavily criticized by Mexican officials, who say their country rightly banned capital punishment years ago.

But if the Mexican people had their way, the death penalty would be an option for justice for murderers such as Tamayo, say surveys and criminal experts here.

Surveys by polling firms and media outlets in Mexico over the past seven years show that support for the death penalty has been increasing to a point where a majority would like to see it reinstated. Recent polls found between 70% and 80% would like to see the death penalty imposed for crimes such as murder and kidnapping, a rate that is above the majority support for the death penalty in the United States.

The rising support for the death penalty in Mexico comes amid the gruesome kidnappings and mass murders committed by criminals and drug cartels in recent years.

Tamayo's execution made front-page news in Mexico and protests were held in his hometown in Morelos state, just south of Mexico City. The Foreign Ministry said Tamayo was not informed properly of his consular rights and academics and human rights groups questioned why the United States uses a punishment other countries abandoned years ago.

"It's an embarrassment that the United States, which considers itself a modern country, continues applying the death penalty," said Juan Federico Arriola, law professor at the Iberoamerican University in Mexico City.

Tamayo, 46, was executed by lethal injection Wednesday in the 1994 shooting death of Houston police officer Gary Gaddis.

Gaddis, 24, had been on the Houston police force for 2 years and was driving Tamayo, who was in the country illegally, and another man from a robbery scene when Tamayo shot him 3 times in the head and neck with a pistol he had hidden in his pants. The car crashed and Tamayo fled but was captured a few blocks away, still in handcuffs.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry said the punishment was proper for such a "despicable" crime, adding that the law is the law.

Some Mexicans say their government seems to have a double standard when it comes to heinous crime: Mexican officials defend citizens convicted of murders abroad, but don't do enough to provide justice or attend to victims of crime back home.

"People are complaining because he's Mexican. There's no other reason," waiter Marco Antonio Rodriguez said of Tamayo.

"People might support (the death penalty) in the case of horrible crimes like rape and kidnap," he said of Mexicans.

Mexico did away the death penalty in 2005 and hasn't executed anyone in more than 50 years. Polls taken a decade ago showed the country split on the issue, with 38% of respondents in a 2004 survey by polling firm Parametria supporting capital punishment, while 42% were opposed.

Support shifted after the country began cracking down on crime and drug cartels in late 2006 and the incidence of murder and kidnapping increased. The National Survey on the Perceptions of Citizen Security released in November 2012 showed 74% of Mexicans backing the death penalty.

Despite the polls, political analysts express some skepticism that the issue would move the masses.

"If it were (popular) someone would be trying to take advantage of it politically," says Aldo Munoz Armenta, political science professor at the Autonomous University of Mexico State.

One party has done so, however, and successfully.

The Green Party campaigned in 2009 on a platform of bringing back the death penalty for kidnappers. It even hired soap opera stars to spread the message in radio and TV commercials. In that year's midterm elections, the party won more than 7% of the vote - a record showing for the party, which is an ally of the governing Institutional Revolutionary Party.

Munoz says the campaign worked due to widespread fear over kidnapping, especially after the 2008 abduction and murder of Fernando Marti, 14, son of the founder of a sporting goods retail empire. His kidnap and the response from authorities prompted a rare protest march from Mexico's middle and upper classes over insecurity.

Opponents of the death penalty, such as Munoz, point to practical problems in bringing it back, including the country's criminal justice system. The system is being overhauled to introduce more transparency, but has a reputation for routinely putting the wrong people in prison - often on flimsy evidence.

Mexico is also a heavily Catholic state, and the church has expressed its opposition to capital punishment.

"Do people actually think the justice system works? ... The police will pick up anybody," says Father Robert Coogan, an American Catholic priest working as chaplain in the city of Saltillo -- 190 miles south of the U.S. border at Laredo, Texas. At Coogan's morning Mass at a Saltillo prison on Thursday, prayers were offered for Tamayo from prisoners who were concerned about the execution.

Coogan also questioned if Mexicans would want to bring back the death penalty given the shortcomings of the system.

"I don't really think Mexicans would accept the death penalty, because they would be putting themselves at risk."

Source: USA Today, January 24, 2014

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Texas executes Edgar Tamayo

Edgar Tamayo
HUNTSVILLE, Texas (AP) — Edgar Tamayo, a Mexican national, was executed Wednesday in Huntsville, Texas, for the slaying 20 years ago of a Texas police officer, Guy Gaddis, 24. 

The US Supreme Court had temporarily put on hold the execution of Edgar Tamayo, as justices considered appeals to keep him from the Texas death chamber.

Tamayo's appeals were eventually denied by the high court. Justices Ginsburg, Breyer and Sotomayor would've granted Edgar Tamayo a stay.

Tamayo was put to death at 9:32 p.m., three hours after his scheduled execution. Tamayo's execution was the 1st of 2014, and the 1st of 4 convicted Harris County killers scheduled to be put to death in the next 4 months.

Texas officials have opposed appeals to stop the scheduled lethal injection, despite pleas and diplomatic pressure from the Mexican government and the U.S. State Department.

Tamayo's attorneys and the Mexican government contended Tamayo's case was tainted because he wasn't advised under an international agreement that he could get legal help from his home nation after his arrest.

Legal assistance guaranteed under that treaty could have uncovered evidence to contest the capital murder charge or provide evidence to keep Tamayo off death row, Mexican officials have said.

Records show the consulate became involved or aware of the case just as his trial was to begin.

Secretary of State John Kerry previously asked Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott to delay Tamayo's punishment, saying it "could impact the way American citizens are treated in other countries." The State Department repeated that stance Wednesday.

But Abbott's office and the Harris County district attorney opposed postponing what would be the first execution this year in the nation's most active capital punishment state, where 16 people were put to death in 2013.

Tamayo's lawyers went to the Supreme Court after the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said an appeal this week renewing an earlier contention that Tamayo was mentally impaired and ineligible for execution was filed too late.

The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles on Tuesday rejected Tamayo's request for clemency.

"It doesn't matter where you're from," Perry spokeswoman Lucy Nashed said. "If you commit a despicable crime like this in Texas, you are subject to our state laws, including a fair trial by jury and the ultimate penalty."

Gaddis, who had been on the force for two years, was driving Tamayo and another man from a robbery scene when evidence showed the officer was shot three times in the head and neck with a pistol Tamayo had concealed in his pants. The car crashed, and Tamayo fled on foot but was captured a few blocks away, still in handcuffs, carrying the robbery victim's watch and wearing the victim's necklace.

At least two other inmates in circumstances similar to Tamayo's were executed in Texas in recent years.

The Mexican government said in a statement this week it "strongly opposed" the execution and said failure to review Tamayo's case and reconsider his sentence would be "a clear violation by the United States of its international obligations."

Tamayo was in the U.S. illegally and had a criminal record in California, where he had served time for robbery and was paroled, according to prison records.

"Not one person is claiming the suspect didn't kill Guy Gaddis," Ray Hunt, president of the Houston Police Officers' Union, said. "He had the same rights as you and I would have.

"This has been looked at, heard, examined and it's time for the verdict of the jury to be carried out."

Tamayo was among more than four dozen Mexican nationals awaiting execution in the U.S. when the International Court of Justice in The Hague, Netherlands, ruled in 2004 they hadn't been advised properly of their consular rights. The Supreme Court subsequently said hearings urged by the international court in those inmates' cases could be mandated only if Congress implemented legislation to do so.

"Unfortunately, this legislation has not been adopted," the Mexican foreign ministry acknowledged.

2 other Mexican nationals with Vienna Convention violations have been executed in Texas. Jose Medellin, condemned for the 1993 rape-murder of 2 Houston teenagers was executed in 2008; Humberto Garcia, convicted of killing a San Antonio teen, in 2011.

Tamayo becomes the 1st condemned inmate to be put to death in Texas this year and the 509th overall since the state resumed executions on December 7, 1982. Tamayo becomes the 270th condemned inmate to be put to death in Texas since Rick Perry became governor in 2001.

Tamayo becomes the 4th condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 1363rd overall since the nation resumed executions on Janaury 17, 1977. 

Source: The Associated Press, Rick Halperin, January 22, 2014

As execution nears, Mexican national Edgar Tamayo denied clemency

The Walls Unit, Huntsville, where executions
are carried out in Texas
With his scheduled execution just hours away, the state Board of Pardons and Paroles has denied a clemency request from a Mexican national convicted of gunning down a Houston police officer in 1994.

Parole officials said Wednesday the seven-member board refused a request for clemency or a reprieve request by a 6-0 vote. Board member Roman Chavez, a former Hoston policeman, did not vote.

The decision came after attorneys for Edgar Arias Tamayo on Tuesday asked U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel of Austin to delay the execution scheduled Wednesday evening, alleging the clemency process is legally flawed. No decision has been announced.

In announcing its vote, the parole board noted that federal appellate courts have upheld its authority to deny clemency.

Tamayo, 46, was convicted of capital murder in the shooting death of Houston officer Guy Gaddis, 24. Authorities at the time said Gaddis had arrested Tamayo and another suspected for a robbery at a bar, and the officer was shot three times in his car as he was transporting Tamayo to jail.

In recent months, the case has drawn international attention, as the Mexican government has protested the execution claiming that evidence in the case was tainted because Tamayo was never advised under an international treaty that he could get legal help from his home nation following his arrest.


Source: American-Statesman, January 22, 2014

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Texas Court of Appeal rejects Tamayo appeals, denies stay

The Walls Unit's Death House
Huntsville, Texas
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals on Tuesday rejected attempts by Edgar Tamayo's lawyers to save him from the state's death chamber on Wednesday for the 1994 murder of Houston policeman Guy Gaddis.

Tamayo's lawyers argued that the state's star witness against their client had lied under oath during the killer's trial, telling jurors he had not received a promise of lenient sentencing in return for his testimony. The state's highest criminal appeals court also denied the convicted killer's request for a stay.

In a separate action Tuesday morning, lawyers for the Mexican national argued in an Austin federal court that the state pardons board should be barred from ruling on Tamayo's petition for clemency unless the panel ensures it would receive a transparent, unbiased consideration.

The lawyers argued that the board violated its own rules by accepting information concerning the case from prosecutors and law enforcement agencies without giving them a chance to participate in the discussion. They also called for board member Romulo Chavez, a former Houston policeman, to recuse himself from the case.

A ruling on that issue was pending.

Tamayo's case has drawn international attention for its apparent violation of United National Vienna Treaty on Consular Relations. That document, to which the United States is a party, requires authorities to inform arrested foreign nationals of their right to contact their nation's consulate.

Seven years ago, a United Nations international court included Tamayo's among similar cases, calling for court hearings to determine whether the violations adversely affected their defenses.

Gaddis was killed in January 1994, as he attempted to transport Tamayo and another man to jail. Tamayo, handcuffed and seated in the squad car's back seat, retrieved a pistol from his clothing and shot Gaddis in the head.

Source: Houston Chronicle, January 21, 2014

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Mexican on US death row spotlights foreigners' plight

The looming execution of a Mexican highlights the fate of foreigners on death row in the United States who were not informed of their rights and risk being put to death in violation of international law, experts say.

Edgar Tamayo Arias, who was convicted in the 1994 fatal shooting of a police officer, is set to die by lethal injection in Texas on Wednesday.

With the clock ticking, rights activists and even the top US diplomat have tried to intervene, saying the 46-year-old was deprived of his consular rights, which may have spared him his death sentence.

The 1963 Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, ratified by 176 countries including the United States, sets out how authorities must act when foreign nationals are arrested or detained.

This involves notifying the individuals in question of their rights to have their consulate informed. They subsequently also have the right to consultations with consular representatives.

However, of the 143 men of 37 nationalities currently awaiting execution in the US, just six have been notified of their consular rights, according to the latest report published by the Death Penalty Information Center (DPIC), a non-profit organization based in Washington.

Most of the foreign death-row inmates are from Central America, it said, while eight are from Europe and include one citizen each from Germany, Spain and France.

And of the 28 foreigners put to death since 1976, when capital punishment was reinstated in the United States, the Vienna Convention was only applied in a single case, according to the DPIC report.

"There's very strong evidence that in many of those cases prompt consular assistance could have made the difference between life and death," said the report's author Mark Warren, of Human Rights Research.

"Remember the death penalty is never mandatory in the US, juries always have the option to convict a person to a lesser punishment than death," he told AFP.

In 2004, the International Court of Justice ruled that Washington had not honored its international obligations for 51 Mexicans sentenced to death.

The Hague-base court had ordered the suspension of the execution of two of them to determine if the non-respect of their consular rights had hurt their defense.

But Texas authorities went ahead anyway, putting the duo to death in 2008 and 2011 after the Supreme Court rejected their appeals.

Tamayo's execution next week is the third to be set while some 40 others await their final hour.

In the US federal system, where states have authority over criminal jurisdiction, "interference by the federal government in states' activities puts the governments on the defensive," DPIC director Richard Dieter told AFP.

"Texas is always the flashpoint for all these controversial cases," he added.

Responsible for more than a third of executions in the US, Texas is likely to go ahead with Tamayo's despite its "promise to comply to the due process guaranteed by the constitution," said Maurie Levin, a lawyer representing the Mexican.

Tamayo is set to die Wednesday at 2300 GMT in the death chamber of the prison in the city of Huntsville.

Claiming that "clemency is almost never granted" in Texas, Levin has appealed to federal authorities for a last-minute reprieve.

'Crisis grows with every execution'

US Secretary of State John Kerry recently also weighed in on Tamayo's case, urging Texas Governor Rick Perry to delay the execution until a judicial review is completed.

"How can we go around the world and ask other countries to give our folks consular access if they are imprisoned (and) if we don't do the same thing here?" deputy State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf asked last month.

Mark Warren, legal advisor to defense teams representing foreigners in the United States, said the matter has been a "major irritant on foreign relations."

One example, he said, was the 1999 execution of two German brothers in Arizona.

"The crisis grows with every execution," the Canadian researcher added.

"Foreign nationals are uniquely disadvantaged when they're arrested in an unfamiliar legal system far from home," he said.

"They don't know the legal process, they may not speak the language, they don't know what their rights are -- the only assistance they can rely on is their consulate, but many times they don't even know they can get that assistance."

Source: Agence France-Presse, January 19, 2014

Friday, December 13, 2013

Texas Plan to Execute Mexican May Harm U.S. Ties Abroad, Kerry Says

Texas Governor Rick Perry: "[Texas] is not directly
bound by the World Court’s decision."
The Mexican, Edgar Arias Tamayo, 46, was convicted of shooting and killing a Houston police officer who was taking him to jail after a robbery in 1994. Mr. Tamayo, who was in the nation illegally, was not notified of his right to contact the Mexican Consulate, in violation of an international treaty known as the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. That violation, an international tribunal’s order for his case to be reviewed and a judge’s recent decision to set Mr. Tamayo’s execution for Jan. 22, are now at the center of a controversy that has attracted the attention of the State Department and the Mexican government.

Despite Mr. Kerry’s involvement, there has been no sign that Texas officials plan to delay the execution. On Wednesday, Mr. Tamayo’s lawyers asked Gov. Rick Perry to grant him a 30-day reprieve and petitioned the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles to commute his death sentence to life in prison. They are using Mr. Kerry’s letter, sent to Texas officials in September, to highlight the international issues at stake.

In 2004, the top judicial body of the United Nations, the International Court of Justice, ordered the United States to review the convictions of Mr. Tamayo and 50 other Mexican nationals whose Vienna Convention rights, it said, were violated and who were sentenced to death in the United States. The international court, also known as the World Court, found that United States courts had to determine in each case whether the violation of consular rights harmed the defendant. In the nine years since the World Court’s decision, no United States court has reviewed the Vienna Convention issues in Mr. Tamayo’s case, said Maurie Levin, one of his lawyers.

In a letter sent to Mr. Perry and the Texas attorney general, Mr. Kerry took the unusual step of weighing in on a state death-penalty case, arguing that Mr. Tamayo’s execution would affect the ability of the United States to comply with the international court’s order in what is known as the Avena case. The World Court’s judgment is binding on the United States, Mr. Kerry wrote, and complying with it ensures that the federal government can rely on Vienna Convention protections when aiding Americans detained abroad.

“I have no reason to doubt the facts of Mr. Tamayo’s conviction, and as a former prosecutor, I have no sympathy for anyone who would murder a police officer,” Mr. Kerry wrote, describing his concern as a “process issue” that could impact the way Americans are treated overseas. “Our consular visits help ensure U.S. citizens detained overseas have access to food and appropriate medical care, if needed, as well as access to legal representation.”

Mr. Kerry also shared with Mr. Perry and the Texas attorney general, Greg Abbott, a letter sent to him earlier this year by Mexico’s ambassador to the United States, Eduardo Medina Mora, who wrote that “this issue has become and could continue to be a significant irritant in the relations between our two countries.”

Texas officials, including Mr. Perry, have argued that the state is not directly bound by the World Court’s decision and that it is a matter best handled by federal officials and Congress, where legislation ordering the states to comply with the tribunal’s judgment is pending. “It doesn’t matter where you’re from — if you commit a despicable crime like this in Texas, you are subject to our state laws, including a fair trial by jury and the ultimate penalty,” Lucy Nashed, a spokeswoman for Mr. Perry, said when asked to respond to Mr. Kerry’s letter.

In 2008, Texas executed another Mexican national, José E. Medellín, who was part of the Avena case and was convicted in the rape and murder of two teenage girls in Houston. Before Mr. Medellín’s execution, President Bush ordered Texas and other states to review the convictions of Mr. Medellín and the other Mexican nationals whose consular rights were violated. But the Supreme Court ruled in 2008 that the president had no authority to order state courts to abide by the World Court’s decision, agreeing with the arguments made by Texas’s then-solicitor general, Ted Cruz, now one of its senators in Washington.

Mr. Medellín was executed four months after the Supreme Court’s ruling in Hunstville, Tex., site of the state’s death chamber, the busiest in the country. In his 2010 book, “Fed Up! Our Fight to Save America from Washington,” Mr. Perry wrote that three justices did not agree with the state’s position, “perhaps believing instead that international law should trump the laws of Texas.”

Source: The New York Times, December 11, 2013

Thursday, September 19, 2013

TEXAS/MEXICO: Convicted cop killer gets execution date set after lengthy delays

An execution date in Texas is drawing the attention of the US Secretary of State. Back in 1994, Edgar Tamayo was convicted in the shooting death of a Houston police officer during an arrest. Now, if a Harris County District Court judge's ruling sticks, Tamayo will finally be executed, 20 years after his crime. But Tuesday's decision is making waves.

Judge Michael McSpadden ordered Mexican national Edgar Tamayo to be sentenced to death January 22, 2014. Unless he is granted a stay, he will be executed for killing that Houston police officer.

After 19 years of appeals and other delays, Tamayo is 1 step closer to facing execution. Tamayo was convicted of the capital murder of Houston police Officer Guy Gaddis. Gaddis died after Tamayo shot and killed him back in 1994.

Judge McSpadden says decisions like this are never easy.

"This is the worst part of my job, even though my responsibility is to see the jury's verdict is fulfilled," he said.

Assistant District Attorney Roe Wilson says the state and federal courts have given Tamayo every right a US citizen would receive, and it's about time this case proceed forward.

"We are now in a position where it's time to set an execution date," she said. "It's long past time to set an execution date and so we are going to proceed with that."

Lawyers for Tamayo argue he was not given his rights under the Vienna Convention at the time of his arrest, that treaty stating everyone has a right to contact their consulate after a run-in with the law in a foreign country.

Although officials from Mexico were in court on Tuesday representing Tamayo's interest, they did not address the court directly. Judge McSpadden stated that he had at least hoped that the slain officer's family would have received an apology from the Mexican government.

He said, "I just suggested today it might be nice on their part to apology once. Saying, 'I know one of our nationals came over here. I'm going to make sure this person has all his rights guaranteed to him but at the same time we would like to issue an apology.'"

The court did receive letters from both Secretary of State John Kerry and the Mexican ambassador to the US, both urging the court not the set an execution date, stating that setting the date would be detrimental to the United States/Mexico relationship.

Judge McSpadden proceeded forward saying he feels it's his responsibly to carry out the wishes of the jury who sentenced Tamayo to death.

Source: KTRK News, September 18, 2013

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Texas groups among those alleging racially discriminatory remarks made by federal judge

A coalition of civil rights organizations filed a judicial misconduct complaint Tuesday against a conservative federal judge for comments she allegedly made during a speech that are seen as discriminatory.

Judge Edith Jones of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals based in New Orleans addressed the University of Pennsylvania law school on Feb. 20. Her comments were not recorded, but five students and one attorney who were in attendance signed affidavits on what was said.

Those were used to generate a 12-page complaint filed in New Orleans stating that Jones "has engaged in conduct that is prejudicial to the effective and expeditious administration of the business of the courts, undermines public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary, and creates a strong appearance of impropriety."

Jones is accused of saying that certain "racial groups like African-Americans and Hispanics are predisposed to crime," and are "prone to commit acts of violence" and be involved in more violent and "heinous" crimes than people of other ethnicities.

The judge also allegedly said Mexicans would prefer to be on death row in the United States than serving prison terms in their native country, and that it's an insult for the U.S. to look to the laws of other countries such as Mexico.

The complaint also states that Jones said defendants' claims of racism, innocence, arbitrariness, and violations of international law and treaties are just "red herrings" used by opponents of the death penalty, and that claims of "mental retardation" by capital defendants disgust her. The fact that those defendants were convicted of a capital crime is sufficient to prove they are not "mentally retarded," the complaint alleges Jones to have said.

And it alleges she said a death sentence provides a service to capital-case defendants because they are likely to make peace with God only just before their execution.

A message seeking comment left at Jones' law office in Houston was not immediately returned Tuesday. Appointed by President Ronald Reagan, Jones has served on the court since 1985 and was its chief justice for 7 years, until October 2012.

"Students were appalled by her speech," said Katie Naranjo, a spokeswoman for the coalition, which includes the Mexican Capital Legal Assistance Program, the League of United Latin American Citizens and the Texas Civil Rights Project.

Also included in the complaint are the Austin chapter of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and the National Bar Association's Houston affiliate.

Naranjo said the coalition is demanding an investigation. She said it took months for those who heard Jones' comments to contact lawyers and verify that they could warrant a formal complaint. It also took time to compile the affidavits, she said.

The coalition said Jones' comments resembled those made during the trial of Duane Buck, a black Texan sentenced to death in 1997 for the murder of his former girlfriend and another man.

At Buck's trial, a state psychologist listed race as one of several factors in describing the danger he would continue to pose. Though the psychologist was called to the stand by defense lawyers, a prosecutor emphasized the testimony in her closing argument.

Later, John Cornyn, then Texas attorney general, identified the case as among six in which race had played an inappropriate role in imposing death sentences. The other inmates all received new sentencing hearings, and they've all been resentenced to death. Buck hasn't received a new hearing.

"Judge Jones's comments are frighteningly similar to those that violated Duane Buck's constitutional rights.

Source: Associated Press, June 5, 2013

Saturday, April 6, 2013

Mexican Senate wants report on Mexicans on death row in U.S.

Mexico City, Apr 4 (EFE).- The Senate has asked the Foreign Relations Secretariat for a report on the number of Mexicans on death row in the United States and efforts being made to provide them with legal assistance.

Human rights activists have expressed concern about a possible "wave of executions" of Mexicans in the United States, Sen. David Monreal, who sponsored the measure, said, without explaining the source of the information.

The goal is to learn about the situation of Mexicans on death row in the United States and provide them with more legal assistance so their human rights will not be violated, the senator said.

Mexico just marked nine years since the International Court of Justice, or ICJ, issued a ruling ordering the United States to review the cases of scores of Mexicans sentenced to death in that country.


Source: La Prensa, April 4, 2013

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Oklahoma executes George Ochoa

McALESTER, Oklahoma — An Oklahoma death row inmate was executed Tuesday for the 1993 shooting deaths of an Oklahoma City couple.

George Ochoa
George Ochoa, 38, was given an injection of lethal drugs at the Oklahoma State Penitentiary at McAlester. He was pronounced dead at 6:07 p.m. CST.

"I'm innocent," Ochoa said before the flow of lethal drug began.

The punishment came less than a month after the state Pardon and Parole Board rejected Ochoa's request that it recommend Gov. Mary Fallin reduce his death sentence to life in prison.

Ochoa is one of two men convicted of first-degree murder in the shooting deaths of Francisco Morales, 38, and Maria Yanez, 35. Investigators say Morales was shot 12 times and Yanez 11 times in their bedroom on July 12, 1993. The couple's three children were inside the house at the time of the shootings.

Ochoa claimed he had been shocked and suffered injuries during his incarceration, but prosecutors said his claims of hallucinations and harm were likely an attempt to feign mental incompetence. Courts prohibit the execution of people who do not understand why they are being punished.

Officials said earlier psychological evaluations showed no evidence of delusions or hallucinations, and that claims about such didn't start until he was charged.

Ochoa lost a late attempt at having his execution postponed when the U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday denied his request for a stay. A federal appeals court on Monday rejected arguments that Ochoa was mentally unfit to be executed and a challenge to the state's procedure for determining sanity.

Prosecutors said there was little evidence to suggest a motive for the killing, but no doubt that Ochoa and his co-defendant, Osbaldo Torres, 37, were responsible. Ochoa and Torres were stopped by police near the crime scene and were described by police as "sweating and nervous," court records show.

Torres, a Mexican citizen, was also convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death in the shootings, but his sentence was reduced by then-Gov. Brad Henry in 2004. Henry imposed a sentence of life without parole after Mexican government officials raised concerns that Torres was not given a chance to speak with the Mexican consulate after being accused, as required by international conventions.

Source: Daily Reporter, December 4, 2012

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Mexican brothers face death sentence in Malaysia

Three Mexican brothers have been sentenced to death after being found guilty of drug trafficking in Malaysia.

The Gonzalez Villarreals, Luis Alfonso, 44, Simon, 37 and Jose Regino, 33 were convicted of drug trafficking and sentenced to hang by the Kuala Lumpur High Court along with a Malaysian and a Singaporean.

The suspects were arrested at a factory in southern Malaysia in 2008, with police seizing almost 30 kilograms of methamphetamine and chemicals used to produce the drug.

Prosecutors say they hope the sentence will serve as a warning to foreigners.

The five men's lawyers say they will appeal the verdict, which can take years to go through the Court of Appeal and if necessary the Federal Court.

Drug trafficking carries a mandatory death penalty in Malaysia.

Executions are not publicly announced and activists say few people are thought to have been hanged in recent years.

Source: Radio Australia News, May 17, 2012

Saturday, April 7, 2012

Mexico: Government Urged to Do More for Mexicans on U.S. Death Row

Mexico’s independent National Human Rights Commission called on the government to intensify its efforts to prevent Mexicans from being executed in other countries, noting that 58 of the nation’s citizens are currently on death row in the United States.

The death penalty, which Mexico formally outlawed in 2005, is “the most severe penalty imposed on people, the application of which is irreversible, and it is a measure that does not guarantee that justice is served,” the commission said in a document titled “Protecting the Right to Life.”

It said therefore that it takes steps to monitor and verify that Mexicans sentenced to capital punishment abroad receive consular assistance and legal representation.

The organization said it also seeks “in appropriate cases” to have the death penalty commuted to lengthy prison sentences.

According to official figures, 745 Mexicans had their death sentence commuted between 2000 and 2011. The rights commission said its records indicate a total of 58 Mexicans on death row at U.S. prisons through 2011.

The majority of those defendants were named in a lawsuit the Mexican government brought against the United States in 2003 before the International Court of Justice in The Hague, citing violations of procedural guarantees contained in the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations.

In its 2004 ruling in what is known as the Avena case, the ICJ instructed the United States to “review and reconsider” the convictions and death sentences handed down to 51 Mexicans who were denied their right to consular notification and assistance at the time of their arrest.

However, in June 2008, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the ICJ’s ruling was not enforceable as domestic law because Congress had not passed implementing legislation.

Several months later, one of the Mexican citizens included in the Avena case, Jose Ernesto Medellin Rojas, convicted of partipating in the 1993 gang rape and murder of two teenage girls in Houston, Texas, was executed in that state.

Another Mexican citizen, Humberto Leal Garcia, convicted of the 1994 rape and murder in San Antonio of a 16-year-old Texas girl, was executed last year after the Supreme Court denied his attorneys’ request for a stay of execution based on authorities’ alleged failure to provide him with consular assistance at the time of his arrest.

Another pending case, the commission said, is that of brothers Jose Regino, Luis and Simon Gonzalez Villarreal, who could be sentenced to death by hanging if convicted of drug trafficking in Malaysia.

In light of this situation, the commission “considers it necessary to intensify actions aimed at preventing the death penalty in cases of Mexicans held in foreign prisons and to safeguard their rights to life, dignity and physical integrity.”

Source: Latin American Herald Tribune, April 7, 2012

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Mexican national’s execution in U.S. prompts diplomatic disappointment

The top United Nations human rights official said Friday that the execution of a Mexican national in Texas was a breach of international law, while diplomats, including Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, expressed disappointment in the outcome of the case.

Humberto Leal Garcia Jr., who had been convicted of raping and killing a 16-year-old San Antonio girl in 1994, was executed by lethal injection on Thursday night, shortly after the Supreme Court denied the Obama administration’s request for a delay.

The administration had filed an amicus brief in the case because of concerns that Texas authorities, in failing to notify Leal of his right to access Mexican consular officials, had violated the United Nations’ Vienna Convention.

In 2004, the International Court of Justice at The Hague ruled that Leal and other Mexican nationals facing execution had been denied their rights under the treaty.

The “execution will undermine the role of the International Court of Justice, and its ramifications are likely to spread far beyond Texas,” Navi Pillay, the U.N. high commissioner for human rights, said Friday.

U.S. officials had expressed concern about the impact of the case, suggesting that Leal’s execution could make other nations less likely to respect the terms of the Vienna Convention should American citizens abroad be in need of consular assistance.

Shortly after the execution, Mexico issued a statement of condemnation and said it had submitted an official protest to the State Department. A group of former U.S. ambassadors who had pressed for a stay also expressed disappointment.

“Texas justice is Texas justice,” said State Department spokesman Victoria Nuland. But, she added, “This is simply about ensuring an American — a non-American facing judicial proceedings in the United States — has the same rights that we expect an American facing judicial proceedings overseas would have."

In seeking the stay, the Obama administration had sought more time so that Congress could take up pending legislation to bring the United States into compliance with the Vienna Convention.

The Supreme Court, however, ruled 5 to 4 that that was not enough to rule in the government’s favor, saying in an unsigned majority opinion that the court was tasked with ruling on current law, “not what it might eventually be."

The immediate impact of the execution is unclear, and some experts have argued there is unlikely to be any.

They note that 3 years ago, Texas executed another Mexican national, even though he had similarly not been informed of his rights under the Vienna Convention. Then, too, there were warnings about the impact on U.S. foreign-policy interests.

“Congress,” the high court’s majority wrote Thursday, “evidently did not find these consequences sufficiently grave to prompt its enactment of implementing legislation, and we will follow the law as written by Congress."

Source: Washington Post, July 9, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Saturday, July 9, 2011

U.S. broke international law by executing Mexican national, says U.N.

(CNN) -- The United States breached international law by executing a Mexican national without having granted him consular access, the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights said Friday.

Navi Pillay, in a statement, said she deeply regrets the execution of Humberto Leal Garcia, after a 5-4 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court denied him a stay of execution Thursday night.

"The execution of Mr. Leal Garcia places the U.S. in breach of international law," said Pillay, who is on an official mission in Mexico. "What the state of Texas has done in this case is imputable in law to the U.S. and engages the United States' international responsibility."

Pillay said Leal was not granted consular access, which -- as a foreign national -- was his right under Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations.

The denial of access raises concerns about whether Leal got a fair trial, Pillay said.

Leal, who was convicted for the 1994 rape and murder of a 16-year-old girl, was executed Thursday evening by lethal injection in Texas.

Federal officials, including the Obama administration, had tried to persuade Texas Gov. Rick Perry to delay the execution. "The secretary herself is quite disappointed in the outcome in this case," said State Department spokeswoman Victoria Neuland about Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

"The U.S. government sought a stay of Leal's execution in order to give the Congress time to act on the Consular Notification Compliance Act, which would have provided Leal the judicial review required by international law."

Neuland said the case underscores the importance of the act's passage. "If we don't protect the rights of non-Americans in the United States, we seriously risk reciprocal lack of access to our own citizens overseas," she said.

"I am sorry for everything I have done," Leal said at the Huntsville facility before he was executed. "I have hurt a lot of people. Let this be final and be done. I take the full blame for this."

Leal then shouted "Viva Mexico," followed by "I'm ready warden, let's get the show on the road."

Mexico condemned the execution, saying it violated an International Court of Justice ruling ordering the United States to review capital convictions of Mexican nationals.

The U.S. Supreme Court earlier denied a stay of execution by 5-4, despite pleas from the Obama administration and the Mexican government to delay the execution.

In an unsigned opinion by the majority, the court refused to delay the execution until Congress could pass pending legislation giving federal courts the authority to hear similar claims from foreign inmates.

"We decline to follow the United States' suggestion of granting a stay to allow Leal to bring a claim based on hypothetical legislation when it cannot even bring itself to say that his attempt to overturn his conviction has any prospect of success," said the majority.

In their dissent, the four justices, led by Stephen Breyer, urged that Leal's execution be delayed. "It is difficult to see how the state's interest in the immediate execution of an individual convicted of capital murder 16 years ago can outweigh the considerations that support additional delay, perhaps only until the end of the summer," said Breyer, who was supported by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan.

Sandra Babcock, lead appellate attorney, said, "It is shameful that Mr. Leal will pay the price for our inaction. The need for congressional action to restore our reputation and protect our citizens is more urgent than ever."

"This case was not just about one Mexican national on death row in Texas," Babcock said in a statement. "The execution of Mr. Leal violates the United States' treaty commitments, threatens the nation's foreign policy interests, and undermines the safety of all Americans abroad."

The state's Board of Pardons and Parole ruled that Leal did not deserve to have his death sentence commuted to life in prison without parole.

The victim's mother, Rachel Terry, had called for the execution to go ahead as planned.

"A technicality doesn't give anyone a right to come to this country and rape, torture and murder anyone, in this case my daughter," she told CNN affiliate KSAT in San Antonio. "It's been difficult for myself and her family members," she added. "She certainly was taken away from us at a very young age. We just want closure."

Leal's lawyers argued the consulate access violation was more than a technicality. Babcock told CNN that Mexican officials would have ensured Leal would have had the most competent trial defense possible had they been able to speak with him immediately after he was arrested.

"I think in most of these cases it was not a deliberate thing," Babcock said. "Local police lack training" on the Vienna Convention, she added, referring to the international agreement that mandates consular access.

Leal's backers say he had learning disabilities and brain damage and had been sexually abused by his parish priest. They say those factors should have been considered at his sentencing.

The Mexican government had filed a supporting appeal with the high court in Washington, asking the justices to block Leal's execution.

And on Friday, the Obama administration asked Texas to delay the execution.

"This case implicates United States foreign policy interests of the highest order," including protecting U.S. citizens abroad and promoting good relations with other countries, Solicitor General Donald Verrilli Jr. said.

Congress has also weighed in. Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vermont, chairman of the Judiciary Committee, introduced a bill in June to grant federal courts the power to review such appeals.

"This case is not an isolated instance; the issue of consular notification remains a serious diplomatic and legal concern," Leahy said Thursday.

In Texas, Perry's office countered that a federal appeals court had already given Leal the judicial scrutiny the Obama administration and the United Nations were seeking.

"If you commit the most heinous of crimes in Texas, you can expect to face the ultimate penalty under our laws," Katherine Cesinger, spokeswoman for the governor, told CNN. "Congress has had the opportunity to consider and pass legislation for the federal courts' review of such cases since 2008, and has not done so each time a bill was filed."

Ted Cruz, the state's former solicitor general who argued the 2008 Supreme Court case for Texas, said Leal waited too long to raise these issues.

"The question is not should a foreign national have the right to contact their consulate," Cruz told CNN. "The question is, years later, after they have been tried, after they have been convicted, after it has been clear like Humberto Leal that they are a vicious child rapist and murderer, should you come in and set aside that conviction. You can't come back years later and try and set aside your trial with some additional claim you wish you had raised."

Cruz is running for the U.S. Senate as a Republican candidate.

Source: CNN, July 8, 2011

Related articles:

Jul 08, 2011
The Government of Mexico strongly condemns today's execution of Mexican national Humberto Leal García, in Huntsville, Texas, in clear violation of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) Avena ruling of 2004 (Mexico vs. ...
Jul 08, 2011
By a 5-4 vote along ideological lines, the Supreme Court has just refused to stay the execution of convicted killer Humberto Leal Garcia, a Mexican convicted of the rape and murder of a 16-year-old girl in 1994. ...
Jul 07, 2011
Humberto Leal, 38, is awaiting a ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court on whether to block his lethal injection in Huntsville. He was sentenced to die for the 1994 rape and murder of 16-year-old Adria Sauceda of San Antonio....
Jun 11, 2011
Humberto Leal Garcia Jr., 38, was convicted of raping a 16-year-old girl and then bludgeoning her to death with a 35-pound piece of asphalt in 1994. He is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection on July 7. ...
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.