Showing posts with label Guantanamo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Guantanamo. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Doctors aided US torture at military prisons, report says

Doctors and nurses working under US military orders have been complicit in the abuse of terrorism suspects, a new independent US report says.

The study says medical professionals helped design, enable and participated in "torture and cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment" of detainees.

The report was compiled by an independent panel of military, health, ethics and legal experts.

Both the CIA and the Pentagon have rejected the report's findings.

The two-year study was carried out by the Institute of Medicine and the George Soros-funded Open Society Foundations.

The report says the collusion began at US prisons in Afghanistan, Guantanamo Bay in Cuba and at CIA secret detention sites after the 11 September 2001 attacks in the US.

Co-author Leonard Rubenstein told the BBC's Newsday programme that the report revealed "the legacy of torture and detainee abuse at Guantanamo and elsewhere on the medical community".

"What we found was that the department of defence and the CIA actually changed core ethical standards to facilitate participation by health professionals in the abuse of detainees. And those distortions still exist," he said.


Source: BBC News, November 4, 2013

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Barack Obama pledges new push to close Guantanamo

US President Barack Obama has pledged a new push to close the prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, amid a growing prisoner hunger strike there.

At the White House, Mr Obama said the detention centre was "contrary to who we are" and harmful to US interests.

He cited recent convictions of terror suspects to argue the civilian justice system was adequate for such trials.

Congress has blocked efforts to close the prison, but Mr Obama said he would renew discussions with lawmakers.

Mr Obama told reporters he had asked a team of officials to review operations at Guantanamo Bay and said he was not surprised there were problems there.

"It is inefficient, it hurts us in terms of our international standing, it lessens co-operation with our allies on counter-terrorism efforts, it is a recruitment tool for extremists, it needs to be closed," Mr Obama said.

'No longer necessary'

He described the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay as a "lingering problem" that would worsen if it remained open.

"I think it is critical for us to understand that Guantanamo is not necessary to keep America safe," Mr Obama told reporters.

Mr Obama added that with the war in Iraq ended and detention authority in Afghanistan transferred to Afghan forces, the facility in Cuba should also close.

He also said he would need the help of Congress to devise a long-term legal solution to the prosecution of detainees.

The president's comments come amid a hunger strike that has spread in recent weeks to include more than 100 of the 166 inmates at the facility.

They are protesting against their indefinite detention. Most are being held without charge.

In his remarks, the president seemed to support the US practice of force-feeding some hunger-strikers.

"I don't want these individuals to die," he said. "Obviously the Pentagon is trying to manage the situation as best we can."

The US has had to reinforce medical staff at Guantanamo Bay, with about 40 nurses and other specialists arriving at the weekend, according to a camp spokesman.

Soon after his election, Mr Obama made closing Guantanamo Bay a top priority for his new administration, pledging to close it within a year of his inauguration in January 2009.

But his plan to transfer prisoners to maximum security prisons in the US and try some detainees in the civilian justice system met fierce resistance from lawmakers of both parties.


Source: BBC News, April 30, 2013

Thursday, August 16, 2012

US Army lawyer for 9/11 accused: This is not a trial. It is an attempt to legitimise a death threat

The man accused of masterminding the 9/11 attacks has been detained for nine years. Now his lawyer accuses the authorities of torture and says plans for justice are a sham.

A US Army officer representing one of Guantanamo Bay's most notorious prisoners has spoken out against the secretive nature of the Military Commissions system, insisting it risks becoming little more than a "show game" to execute suspects, denying them and the American people the right to a fair trial.

Captain Jason Wright was appointed by the military to represent Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, who is charged along with 4 others with conspiring and executing the 9/11 attacks. Yet, the officer revealed to The Independent, rafts of vital evidence - including the 3 1/2 years his client spent at secret CIA "black" sites - have been deemed classified.

It was only through a Freedom of Information request that redacted files were released showing that Mohammed had been subjected to waterboarding interrogation 183 times, kept awake for seven days straight and had his family's lives threatened.

Defence lawyers are banned from passing documents in confidence to their clients or even discussing certain issues, funding is severely restricted and requests for additional counsel or experts refused. While the accused face the death penalty if convicted, they are likely to be detained indefinitely even if they are acquitted, a situation Capt Wright likened to torture.

"This is not a trial. It is an attempt to legitimise a death threat," he said. "It can never be fair to bring a man to the brink of death and back 183 times with waterboarding and then do it a final 184th time - but this time it will have full state sanction. The bottom line is, torture denies justice. If you believe fundamentally that America is better than that, then this is a struggle for the soul of America.

"I am concerned there has been this show game to try and find the best system in order to try and execute these men. I am deeply concerned by the prospect that theoretically, if anybody is tried and acquitted, the US government has the authority to continue to detain that person indefinitely."

The officer, who previously spent 15 months as a legal adviser in northern Iraq, continued: "I think a lot of Americans are appalled that Guantanamo Bay is still open. No one denies 9/11 was horrific, but there are many people in the Middle East who have felt aggrieved by the past effects of colonialism and neo-colonialism. There has been a cycle of tragedy and trauma and now we can add torture.

"I think it is time for the hyperbole of the war on terror to end, for all sides to pursue both redemption and rediscovery. It is my hope this case will provide an opportunity for this process. But in order to do so, it must be seen as fair and legitimate, not just to America but to the rest of the world." Despite President Obama's promise to close the notorious detention facility in Cuba, 167 inmates - all Muslims - remain of the original 800 who were brought in after thousands of dollars in bounties were offered to those that turned them in. Of those still incarcerated, about half have been cleared but not released.

Capt Wright said that the reformed Military Commissions Act, brought in after Congress defied the President's attempts to have the trials heard within the American legal system, does not abide by the Geneva Convention, allowing evidence to be gained under duress. He said the situation was "still woefully short of the standards of any normal court in the US".

Along with representatives of the 4 other detainees, he is due to return to court next week to argue that he must be allowed to communicate documents to his client in confidence. 2 years ago, the Joint Task Force Commander at Guantanamo Bay ordered that all papers must be passed through a review team.

"All the defence lawyers have refused to abide by this order. Since December, we have been unable to share any confidential documents with our clients," said the judge advocate. "It violates our duty of client confidentiality and our duty of basic due diligence to represent our clients."

The lawyers are banned from discussing certain subjects - even the term "jihad", which is included in the charge sheet. Court hearings have a 40-second delay, so anything deemed confidential can be silenced before the public gallery hears it.

"It has a chilling effect on our ability to perform a basic aspect of the defence investigation. For instance, anything Mr Mohammed conveys verbally to me, whether it relates to his torture, his treatment or even what may have happened on the eve of his capture in Pakistan, remains classified at the highest level," said Capt Wright. "The US government said that because Mr Mohammed was a high-value detainee, he was exposed to classified CIA information and is therefore a holder of classified information. So effectively: 'Because we tortured you, you can't speak'."

An arraignment hearing in May, normally expected to last no more than an hour, stretched out for 13 hours as each one of the defence lawyers unsuccessfully pleaded for the restrictions to be lifted.

Capt Wright, who insists that he must fulfil his obligation to advocate on behalf of his client, added: "There are severe restrictions on our performing our job competently. It is fundamentally unfair, both for the attorney and the client, to have defence counsel subject to control of the US government."

A Department of Defense spokesman said last night: "Every detainee at Guantanamo has had ample opportunity to get the help of lawyers, and there are plentiful examples of robust and functional attorney-client relationships being formed and of zealous, effective representation being provided."

Pointing out that the accused had a right of appeal to a federal civilian court and ultimately to the Supreme Court, he added: "These reformed military commissions... require all of the protections of fairness and justice that are required by our values. The accused is presumed innocent. The prosecution must prove his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt."

Facing death: The accused

9 years after he was arrested, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was charged with orchestrating the 9/11 terror attacks. Last April, along with 4 others - Walid Muhammad Salih Mubarak Bin Attash, Ramzi Binalshibh, Ali Abdul Aziz Ali, and Mustafa Ahmed Adam al-Hawsawi - he was accused of 8 offences, including murder, hijacking and terrorism.

The 5 are "responsible for the planning and execution of the attacks of 11 Sept 2001, in New York, Washington DC, and Shanksville, Pennsylvania, resulting in the killing of 2,976 people," a Department of Defense statement said, adding: "If convicted, the 5 accused could be sentenced to death." KSM, as he has come to be known, was born in Kuwait in around 1964 but went Pakistan as a teenager before moving to the United States to study mechanical engineering and then on to Afghanistan to fight the Soviet invasion. As well as 9/11, he has been accused of involvement in several terrorist plots, including the Bali nightclub bombings and the Richard Reid shoebomb attempt to blow up an airline. His nephew Ali Abdul Aziz Ali, 34, is a computer technician who was hired in the late 1990s to work for the Modern Electronics Corporation in Dubai. Fluent in English, he described himself as "very open-minded and western-oriented". He is accused of assisting the hijackers with "everyday aspects of life in the West" but insists he was simply helping to boost his income and had no idea who they were.

Ramzi Binalshibh, 40, is a Yemeni who worked as a part-time bank clerk until 1995. He was denied a US visa and travelled to Germany to request political asylum, which was rejected, but he returned to Hamburg with a visa. After the attacks he was accused of being a key facilitator. Walid Muhammad Salih Mubarak Bin Attash, 33, is a Yemeni from a prominent family. He read Islamic Studies in Pakistan before losing his right leg in 1997 fighting in Afghanistan in a battle that killed his brother. The Office of the Director of National Intelligence described him as a "scion of a terrorist family".

Mustafa Ahmed Adam al-Hawsawi, 44, is a Saudi accused of being an organiser and financier of the attacks.

Khalid Sheikh Mohammed: The torture details

Waterboarding involves drowning someone to the brink of death before interrogation.

With its history in the Spanish Inquisition, it involves strapping a detainee by their legs and arms to a board which is tipped head down. A cloth is placed over the mouth and nose while water is poured in at varying heights, giving the sensation of drowning. With a doctor present to prevent death, the detainee is subjected to around minute of pain and panic before being raised up and questioned. While information on his 3 1/2-year detention in CIA custody is classified, certain redacted documents obtained through Freedom of Information requests confirm Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was waterboarded 183 times, kept awake for 7 1/2 days and subjected to authorised enhanced interrogation techniques. Human rights experts insist "enhanced" techniques include sleep deprivation, being subjected to extreme temperatures and having a towel placed around his neck before being thrown against a wall. Mr Mohammed was also subjected to unauthorised treatment like threats to the lives of his family.

Guantanamo Bay: 10 years of detentions for 'unlawful enemy combatants'

January 2002 The Bush administration establishes a detainment and interrogation facility at Guantanamo Naval Base, Cuba, and the first 20 detainees arrive.

March 2003 Khalid Sheikh Mohammed is detained in Pakistan and handed over to the US. He is held by the CIA, accused of being the principal architect behind the 9/11 bombings.

September 2006 The Military Commissions Act of 2006 is passed, which allows certain people to be designated "unlawful enemy combatants", thus making them subject to military commissions. President George W Bush confirms for the 1st time that the CIA has "high-value detainees" in prisons around the world. Fourteen captives, including Mohammed, are transferred to Guantanamo to face military commissions.

January 2009 President Barack Obama signs an order to suspend proceedings at the Guantanamo military commissions for 120 days and announces that the facility will be shut down.

October 2009 A reformed Military Commissions Act is passed. Critics say it still offers sub-standard justice.

January 2011 The Obama administration abandons attempts to close Guantanamo after Congress blocks the President from bringing accused terrorists before US courts.

March 2011 The President approves the resumption of military trials at Guantanamo Bay.

April 2011 Mohammed and 4 others are charged with conspiracy, murder, hijacking and terrorism. A team of 2 military lawyers and 1 civilian lawyer is appointed.

August 2012 Legal representatives of the five suspects set to argue for the right to pass documents in confidence to their clients.

Source: Belfast Telegraph, August 15, 2012

Friday, July 20, 2012

Defense lawyers say Guantanamo court rigged to deliver death sentence

The Pentagon official overseeing the Guantanamo tribunal tried to rig the jury selection process to boost the odds of obtaining a death sentence for a prisoner accused of directing a deadly attack on a U.S. warship, defense lawyers alleged on Thursday.

They asked the judge to drop the charges against Saudi defendant Abd al Rahim al Nashiri, an alleged al Qaeda chieftain who is accused of choosing and supplying the suicide bombers who drove a boat full of explosives into the side of the USS Cole off the coast of Yemen in 2000. The blast killed 17 sailors and wounded dozens more.

The judge, Army Colonel James Pohl, did not rule on the request before a pretrial hearing ended on Thursday at the Guantanamo Bay U.S. Naval Base.

But he suggested that if there has been an attempt to exert improper influence, the remedy would be to follow regular U.S. court-martial procedures for jury selection rather than dismiss the charges.

The defense complaints focused on retired Vice Admiral Bruce MacDonald, the Pentagon appointee overseeing the war crimes tribunals. He decides which cases are referred to trial, whether defendants will face the death penalty, and which military officers will make up the jury pool.

When he referred Nashiri's case for trial on capital charges that include murder, attempted murder and terrorism, he included specific instructions on how the judge was to carry out jury selection, something the defense characterized as unprecedented bureaucratic meddling in matters usually left to the trial judge.

MacDonald limited the number of challenges the lawyers could use to dismiss jury candidates, and capped the number of jurors at 12.

A conviction and death sentence would require unanimous decisions by at least 12 jurors, so U.S. military courts typically empanel 14 or 15 to make sure they do not drop below the quorum if someone gets sick or has to drop out during a long trial, said Lieutenant Commander Stephen Reyes, one of Nashiri's lawyers.

MacDonald's instructions allow for the selection of alternate jurors who would not vote unless the panel was reduced to fewer than 12, thus keeping to an absolute minimum the number of jurors the prosecution would have to win over.

"That is a panel that numerically favors a death sentence," Reyes said.

The chief prosecutor, Brigadier General Mark Martins, disputed there was anything improper or prejudicial and said MacDonald was merely exercising the authority given to him.

KANGAROO COURT, DASTARDLY DEFENDANT

Defense lawyers also asked that the charges be thrown out on grounds that MacDonald was improperly appointed. They said he had so much authority - and no boss - that the appointment should have required Senate approval.

The judge didn't rule on that request either but he did shed a little light on what happened during a closed-hearing on Wednesday. The defense had asked that the prosecution be ordered to turn over secret evidence related to Nashiri's arrest in Dubai in 2002 and his four-year detention in secret CIA prisons before his transfer to Guantanamo in 2006.

Pohl met privately with the lawyers to debate whether that could be discussed in open court without revealing national secrets. He said Thursday that he had postponed arguments on the matter until the next pretrial hearing, which starts on October 23.

The defense has regularly called the Guantanamo tribunals unfair and defense attorney Rick Kammen, who calls them a kangaroo court, wears a golden kangaroo pin on his lapel.

The long delay in bringing Nashiri to trial and the defense criticism of the tribunal have infuriated relatives and sailors who lost loved ones and colleagues in the attack on the Cole.

A small group has made repeated trips to the remote Guantanamo base to attend Nashiri's pretrial hearings. Some spoke to journalists after the hearing.

Saundra Flanagan, whose son Petty Officer 1st Class Kevin Rux was killed aboard the Cole, called the defendant and his alleged al Qaeda conspirators "damn dastardly, cruel and mean."

She said it may take a while longer to see justice done but "we'll be there waiting and watching and listening and praying for the best outcome."

Source: Reuters, July 20, 2012


War court: Accused planner of attack on USS Cole shuns Guantánamo court session

The accused architect of al-Qaida’s USS Cole bombing skipped arguments in his war crimes case Thursday, a day after both the public and the accused were excluded from a hearing that discussed CIA intelligence.

All defense counsel Richard Kammen would say was that Saudi national Abd al Rahim al Nashiri “voluntarily chose not to attend.” So guards did not move him from his cell at the prison several miles away to the court at Camp Justice.

In all his earlier hearings, the man who was once waterboarded by CIA agents showed up and watched the proceedings wearing the white prison camp garb of a cooperative captive. But there was no explanation for his absence this time. Kammen said he was barred from elaborating by the intelligence agencies’ security rules governing the “presumptive classification” of anything an ex-CIA captive says.

Instead, the defendant’s chair sat empty as the judge, Army Col. James Pohl, heard Nashiri’s lawyers argue to get the case dismissed, and if not get the eventual death-penalty trial available for live television broadcasts. Pohl did not rule on any of the motions.

The judge did however start the day by announcing that at the closed hearing a day earlier it was decided to postpone until next time — Oct. 23-25 — arguments on 2 secret defense motions that seek some sort of information about Nashiri’s overseas capture and detention. But the motions are under seal, and the judge said that he had the authority to close Wednesday’s hearing without elaborating on the open-court record.

“No finding justifying closure was required,” he said.

Nashiri spent 4 years in the CIA’s secret overseas prison network before his transfer to military custody in Guantánamo in 2006. According to declassified investigations, U.S. agents interrogated him at gunpoint, with a revving power drill to his head and while hooded — techniques his defense team considers torture.

Attorneys for 14 media organizations objected to closure of discussions of those motions, arguing the public has a keen interest in Guantánamo’s 1st death-penalty tribunal.

With this week’s hearing over, the Guantánamo war crimes court went dark for the month of Ramadan. Muslims were to begin fasting by day Friday in observance of Islam’s holy month, and end days before resumption of hearings in the 9/11 terror case on Aug.22.

Source: Miami Herald, July 20, 2012


Lawyers ask for Guantanamo trial to be televised

Lawyers for the alleged Al-Qaeda mastermind of the deadly 2000 attack on the USS Cole demanded Thursday that his Guantanamo military tribunal be televised.

Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri's trial at the US naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba is the first since the military tribunal system was reformed by President Barack Obama's administration to make it fairer.

But there were howls of protest from defense lawyers and media outlets when Wednesday's pre-trial hearing was held behind closed doors and without the defendant -- who was barred due to the classified nature of proceedings.

Now Nashiri's defense attorney, Richard Kammen, is calling for the trial to be televised.

"We don't request any greater intrusion in the system than already exists. We require additional cable connection," he said. "We want to increase the transparency, so a great amount of the public can see this event of national and worldwide interest."

Al-Qaeda claimed responsibility for the suicide attack off the coast of Yemen, which saw militants riding an explosives-laden skiff blow a 30-by-30-foot (10-by-10-meter) hole in the USS Cole, a US Navy destroyer.

Nashiri, a Saudi citizen, faces the death penalty for allegedly masterminding the bombing in October 2000 that left 17 sailors dead, and for a 2002 attack on the French oil tanker MV Limburg that left one dead.

Guantanamo military trials can be watched by journalists and victims' families who have authorization via a live closed-circuit broadcast at Fort Meade, a military base in the eastern US state of Maryland.

"You have adopted a legal fiction... that Fort Meade is an extension of the courtroom," Kammen told military judge, Colonel James Pohl. "Prosecutors say they want a greater transparency. Let's take them at their word."

But prosecutor Justin Sher argued against the move, saying some "witnesses may be reluctant to testify" if hearings are televised and pointing out that transcripts would be available anyway on the tribunal's website.

Pohl is slated to make his decision before the next pre-trial hearings that run from October 23 to 25.

The judge declined to recuse himself on Monday from presiding over the case after Nashiri's lawyers cited a potential financial conflict of interest due to the nature of his annual renewable contract with military authorities.

After being barred on Wednesday, Nashiri was free to attend Thursday's hearing but chose not to.

Source: Agence France-Presse, July 20, 2012

Saturday, April 28, 2012

Gradual death of a failed experiment

The death penalty experiment that began in the USA in 1976 when the US Supreme Court gave the green light to executions to resume under revised capital laws took another step towards its eventual demise this week when Connecticut became the 17th abolitionist state. The governor signed the bill abolishing the death penalty into law on 25 April.

Connecticut is the 4th US state in 5 years to legislate to abolish capital punishment. In addition, last November the Oregon governor imposed a moratorium on executions and called on the legislature there to reconsider the death penalty, and earlier this week the Secretary of State for California confirmed that repeal of California’s death penalty will be put to the popular vote at the election in November 2012.

California accounts for 1 in 5 of the USA’s death row inmates; if repeal is approved, this would be the biggest chunk of the US death penalty edifice to fall in the past 40 years.

In North Carolina, which accounted for 5 % of the USA’s executions in the decade from 1997, there have been no executions since 2006. While this court-ordered suspension in state killing comes in the context of litigation over lethal injection issues, the abolitionist cause in the state was done no harm when, on 20 April 2012, a state judge handed down a landmark ruling under North Carolina’s Racial Justice Act, overturning a death sentence on the grounds of systemic racial discrimination in jury selection in capital cases. There are 150 more cases pending under the Act.

On the other side of the equation, however, executions continue apace in the USA and serve as a reminder that there is much more to do before the USA joins the majority of the world in abandoning this cruel punishment.

There have been 17 executions so far this year and it is possible that in 2012, the combined judicial death toll since 1976 in just three states – Texas, Oklahoma and Virginia – will reach 700.

And at the national level, while there has not been a federal execution for nearly a decade, the US administration is adding to its regular pursuit of death sentencing in domestic cases in federal court by moving towards its first capital trials by military commissions held at the US Naval Base in Guantánamo Bay, Cuba.

The imposition of the death penalty after such trials will violate international law as the military commissions do not meet international standards of fairness.

Connecticut was one of 15 US states, in addition to the federal government, which resumed judicial killing after 1976 with the execution of a prisoner who had waived his appeals, a so- called “volunteer”. This phenomenon – which accounts for more than 10 % of executions since 1976 – occurred again on 20 April 2012 with the lethal injection of a “volunteer” in Delaware.

In a new report, Amnesty International welcomes abolition in Connecticut (while noting that it is not retroactive and leaves 11 men on death row); looks back on the Delaware execution, setting it alongside the decision by the Oregon governor 5 months earlier to prevent the execution of a prisoner who had waived his appeals and to impose a moratorium in Oregon; reflects on the most recent execution in Ohio, the 1st there in 6 months after a federal judge overseeing litigation on the state’s lethal injection protocol refused to issue a stay despite his clear disquiet with the state’s past conduct during executions; examines the state court decision issued under the Racial Justice Act in North Carolina; and draws attention to the failure of the US federal authorities to work for abolition.

For further information, see USA: Another brick from the wall, 27 April 2012, available at http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/AMR51/028/2012/en

Source: Amnesty International, April 27, 2012

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

The case for letting Khalid Sheikh Mohammed live

What should be done with Khalid Sheikh Mohammed? If the Defense Department is to be believed, the chief planner of the 9/11 attacks on America is guilty of mass murder and crimes against humanity. Even if the evidence elicited by waterboarding him 183 times is void, his declaration in 2002 that “I was responsible for the 9/11 Operation from A to Z” should ensure conviction.

In addition to the 9/11 attacks that killed 2,973, he is credited with commissioning shoe-bomber Richard Reid to down a transatlantic jetliner laden with 300 passengers; planning the 1993 attempt to fell the Twin Towers, the Bali nightclub bombing that killed 200 and a bomb attack in Istanbul in 2003 that killed 60; as well as plots to assassinate Pope John Paul II and Bill Clinton and to demolish the Empire State Building and the Brooklyn Bridge. For those who would argue Mohammed is a war combatant rather than a dangerous psychotic, it should also be noted that he personally sawed off the head of the American reporter Daniel Pearl.

Mohammed and his co-conspirators face the death penalty, but it is by no means certain the prosecution will ask for it.


Source: Reuters blogs, Nicholas Wapshott, April 13, 2012

Related articles:
Apr 07, 2012
Retired Vice Adm. Bruce E. MacDonald, who is in charge of military commissions, signed off on the capital trial against alleged mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, 46, and four accused co-conspirators. The men face ...
Apr 06, 2011
Under military commission rules, Khalid Shaikh Mohammed cannot plead guilty to a crime that carries the death penalty, even though he wants it. And a military jury might be less likely than a civilian one to grant his wish.
Dec 10, 2008
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the alleged mastermind of the attacks, asked a military tribunal at Guantnamo Bay. Two of the five men have not yet been judged competent to represent themselves, and Mr Mohammed and the two ...
Nov 30, 2009
Now the Obama administration plans to seek a death sentence for Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, the self-proclaimed Sept. 11 mastermind. Some legal experts say President Obama was overly confident when he predicted that ...

Saturday, April 7, 2012

Death penalty trial due for 5 accused of planning 9/11

MIAMI — The Pentagon on Wednesday cleared the way for a death penalty trial for five Guantanamo Bay captives charged with engineering the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

Retired Vice Adm. Bruce E. MacDonald, who is in charge of military commissions, signed off on the capital trial against alleged mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, 46, and four accused co-conspirators.

The men face charges of terrorism, hijacking aircraft, conspiracy and murder in violation of the law of war, among other charges, in the system set up by President George W. Bush within months of the attack, and then modified by President Obama in 2009.

If convicted, they could be sentenced to death using a method to be decided by Defense Secretary Leon E. Panetta or his successor.

The charges accuse the five of organizing the attacks — including funding and training the 19 men who hijacked four commercial airliners on 9/11 and crashed them into the World Trade Center, the Pentagon and a field in Shanksville, Pa., killing 2,976 people.

"The Obama administration "is making a terrible mistake by prosecuting the most important terrorism trials of our time in a second-tier system of justice," said Anthony Romero, the group's executive director. He said the war court was "set up to achieve easy convictions and hide the reality of torture, not to provide a fair trial."

"Whatever verdict comes out of the Guantanamo military commissions will be tainted by an unfair process and the politics that wrongly pulled these cases from federal courts, which have safely and successfully handled hundreds of terrorism trials," he said.

All five men were interrogated by the CIA in secret overseas prisons — Mohammed was water-boarded 183 times, according to declassified CIA documents — before their 2006 transfer to Guantanamo. Once in Cuba, he bragged to a panel of U.S. military officers that he was responsible for the Sept. 11 attacks "from A to Z."

The chief prosecutor, Army Brig. Gen. Mark S. Martins, has said that by law no evidence derived through torture can be used at a Guantanamo trial.


Source: PoliceOne.com, April 6, 2012

Thursday, September 29, 2011

Death penalty case set for USS Cole defendant

A senior Pentagon official Wednesday referred the first death penalty case under President Obama for trial by military commission at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri was charged in April by military prosecutors with murder, terrorism and other violations of the laws of war for his role in the October 2000 al-Qaeda attack on the USS Cole in Yemen.

Under military rules, the Pentagon official, known as the Convening Authority, independently examines the charges filed by military prosecutors and decides whether the defendant will be tried on all, some of none of the charges. In Nashiri’s case, the Convening Authority, Ret. Admiral Bruce MacDonald, forwarded the capital charges sworn by prosecutors.

Nashiri, a Saudi citizen of Yemeni descent, is one of 15 high-value detainees held at Guantanamo, and prosecutors allege that he was “in charge of the planning and preparation” of the Cole attack. Two suicide bombers in a small boat pulled alongside the Navy destroyer in the port of Aden and the ensuing blast, which ripped a 30-by-30-foot hole in the ship, killed 17 American sailors.


Source: The Washington Post, Sept. 29, 2011

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Guantanamo detainee lawyers ask that death penalty case be dropped

Lawyers for a terror suspect detained at Guantanamo -- linked by authorities to the bombing of the USS Cole -- say his waterboarding and other mistreatment plus delays in his case should force the government to halt his pending military trial and possible death sentence.

The government says Abd al Rahim Hussayn Muhammad Al-Nashiri was the mastermind behind the 2000 bombing that crippled the U.S. warship and killed 17 sailors.

Al-Nashiri's lawyers have filed a brief with the military commission asking that the proceedings stop.

"By torturing Mr. Al-Nashiri and subjecting him to cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment, the United States has forfeited its right to try him and certainly to kill him," the brief said. "Through the infliction of physical and psychological abuse, the government has essentially already killed the man it seized almost 10 years ago."

Al-Nashiri's legal team is making its request to the so-called Convening Authority of the military court, retired Vice Adm. Bruce MacDonald, who has the power to decide whether cases go to trial at Guantanamo Navy Base in Cuba. The military commission was established by President George W. Bush and overhauled by President Barack Obama.

"The United States has lost its moral authority to seek the death penalty," the defense brief says. "Accordingly, you should not refer charges -- or authorize the death penalty -- against Mr. Al-Nashiri."

His lawyers say Al-Nashiri was waterboarded. Also, while he was naked and hooded, his questioners revved a power drill in his hearing and chambered a round in a handgun, they say.

"The government has admitted to waterboarding Mr. Al-Nashiri and subjecting him to verbal and physical threats to his life and threats to the safety of his family. Both set of acts constitute torture," the brief says.

CNN obtained a copy of the legal document, which was filed at the end of last week and is the latest signal that the Al-Nashiri case is moving forward, with a possible arraignment later this summer.

A military trial of Al-Nashiri is seen as a test of the law and the procedures at Guantanamo before the 9/11 defendants are prosecuted in coming months or years.

Defense lawyers have complained that they have been denied "meaningful discovery" about what information the prosecution has.

"Other than some partial medical records from Guantanamo, Mr. Al-Nashiri and his counsel have been denied discovery from the prosecution," the defense brief says. "The defense is unable to even discern what evidence supports the prosecution's allegations ... accordingly the defense cannot make any principled showing of the weaknesses in the prosecution's case."

The defense also says they are facing other difficulties in preparing for a trial, including political upheaval in Yemen where the USS Cole bombing took place and the CIA's destruction of the videotapes made of Al-Nashiri's interrogation.

"The world wonders whether the Untied States will continue to be an example of how fair trials are conducted or whether it will descend further down the path of expedient and secret justice that Military Commissions have come to represent," the defense brief says.

Government prosecutors have not yet responded to a CNN request for comment.

Source: CNN, July 20, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Amnesty slams US on detentions, executions

The US human rights record has been marred by indefinite detentions at Guantanamo Bay and in Afghanistan and by a flawed capital punishment system, Amnesty International said Friday.

In its annual global human rights report, the London-based organisation said US authorities executed 46 people over the past year, despite doubts in several case about the defendants' guilt and questions in others over legal representation or mental impairment.

At the Guantanamo Bay detention center on a US naval base in Cuba, 174 men were still being held at the end of the year, "including 3 who had been convicted under a military commission system which failed to meet international fair trial standards," the report said.

"Scores of men remained in indefinite military detention in Guantanamo as President (Barack) Obama's one-year deadline for closure of the facility there came and went," it said.

"Military commission proceedings were conducted in a handful of cases, and the only Guantanamo detainee so far transferred to the US mainland for prosecution in a federal court was tried and convicted."

Additionally, the report said "hundreds" were being held at the US airbase in Bagram, Afghanistan, without due process and some were "subjected to torture or other ill-treatment, including prolonged isolation, sleep deprivation and exposure to extreme temperatures."

Amnesty said US authorities also "blocked efforts to secure accountability and remedy for crimes under international law committed against detainees previously subjected to the USA's secret detention and rendition programme."

It said there were questions about "crimes under international law of torture and enforced disappearance," under the CIA program where detainees were transferred from one state to another "by means that bypass judicial and administrative due process."

It also noted that former president George W. Bush acknowledged in his memoirs that "he had personally authorised 'enhanced interrogation techniques' for use by the CIA against detainees held in secret custody."

In other criticisms of the United States, Amnesty said "excessive force" by US law enforcement was a concern, with 45 people killed during the past year after being struck by police Tasers -- 450 deaths since 2001.

"Most of the deceased were unarmed and did not appear to present a serious threat when they were shocked," it said.

Amnesty also expressed concern about an immigration law passed in Arizona which could allow police to demand proof of legal status, fearing it would increase "racial profiling."

It also said "hundreds of women continued to die from preventable pregnancy-related complications" because of a lack of health care coverage.

Source: Agence France-Presse, May 13, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Might a military jury deny 9/11 suspect's death wish?

Under military commission rules, Khalid Shaikh Mohammed cannot plead guilty to a crime that carries the death penalty, even though he wants it. And a military jury might be less likely than a civilian one to grant his wish.

His words leave little doubt about his role. It is his punishment that remains uncertain.

Four years ago, Khalid Shaikh Mohammed not only brazenly portrayed himself as mastermind of the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. The senior Al Qaeda operative also bragged to a U.S. military tribunal that he had directed other major terrorist attacks around the globe.

Mohammed claimed responsibility for the first World Trade Center bombing in 1993, for the "shoe bomber" attempt to blow up a U.S. airliner in 2001, for the deadly bombing of a nightclub in Indonesia, for planned assassination attempts against Pope John Paul II and President Clinton, and for aborted attacks in London, Los Angeles, Chicago and elsewhere.

He even boasted that he had personally decapitated Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl in Karachi, Pakistan. "For those who would like to confirm, there are pictures of me on the Internet holding his head," Mohammed said.

But it's not clear whether his confessions, which mirrored those he made after being waterboarded 183 times by CIA interrogators in 2003, can be used against him in military court. Moreover, now that the Justice Department has transferred his case and that of his four alleged co-conspirators to a military commission at the U.S. naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, winning a death sentence may not come easy.


Source: The Los Angeles Times, April 6, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

US holds on to use of death penalty

GENEVA, Switzerland (AP) — The United States has disavowed torture and pledged to treat terror suspects humanely, but set aside calls to drop the death penalty, as the United Nations carried out its first review of Washington's human rights record.

As part a groundbreaking commitment to improvement under the Obama administration, the US joined the 47-nation Human Rights Council in 2009. And in doing so, submitted to more international scrutiny.

State Department legal adviser Harold Koh outlined nine key improvement areas yesterday, encompassing about 174 of the 228 recommendations the community had urged on Washington in an initial report last November. Nations are held accountable for what they agree to improve.

He said the US would agree to improvements in areas ranging from civil rights to national security to immigration, including intolerance of torture and the humane treatment of suspects at the Guantanamo Bay detention facility in Cuba.

But in some areas the US stance was unchanged, particularly on the death penalty, which had led to a chorus of objections from many European nations.

Critics say the law is inhumane and unfairly applied. But Koh said capital punishment was permitted under international law.

"To those who desire as a matter of policy to end capital punishment in the United States — and I count myself among those — I note the decision made by the government of Illinois on March 9 to abolish that state's death penalty," Koh told the Geneva-based UN Human Rights Council.

Cuba, Iran and Venezuela complained the US was brushing too many recommendations aside, while China and Russia said the US was not going far enough on Guantanamo, and called for it to be shut down as President Barack Obama had promised.

Other nations urged the US to reduce overcrowding in prisons, ratify international treaties on the rights of women and children, and take further steps to prevent racial profiling. Koh said Obama also would push to ratify additional measures under the Geneva Conventions and add protections for anyone it detains in an international armed conflict.

Civil society groups have praised the US for involving itself in the review process, which all UN member states have to undergo every four years. Japan, France and Cameroon had led the writing of the report on the US.

However, Jamil Dakwar, director of the American Civil Liberties Union's human rights programme, said one of the biggest US shortcomings was that it still had not created an independent human rights monitoring commission as has been done in over 100 countries.

"While the Obama administration should be commended for its positive engagement in this process, in order to lead by example, this international engagement must be followed by concrete domestic actions to bring US laws and policies in line with international human rights standards," he said.

Source: AP, March 21, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Friday, November 5, 2010

UN human rights council urges US to end death penalty

American delegate says capital punishment is subject of vigorous debate and applied for in only the most serious crimes

The US today faced an international clamour to abolish the death penalty during a debate at the UN human rights council in Geneva.

The council is gradually reviewing the performance of all 192 UN member states. The US took its moment in the spotlight seriously, sending a high-level delegation of around 30 officials led by Esther Brimmer, the assistant secretary of state for international organisation affairs.

The delegation was given a mostly warm welcome by delegates of the 47-member council, but was forced to listen to repeated calls for the US to put an end to the death penalty.

More than 1,200 men and women have been put to death in the US since executions resumed in 1977 after a decade without them, according to Amnesty International.

Three jurisdictions – Texas, Virginia, and Oklahoma – account for more than half the country's executions. Missouri has approximately 40 people on death row, but has not executed anyone since 2005.

At the end of 2009, 139 countries had abolished the death penalty. The US finds itself grouped with authoritarian countries such as China and Iran in still executing people.

Harold Hongju Koh, the state department's legal adviser, said capital punishment was a subject of vigorous debate and litigation in the US and was applied for in only the most serious crimes.

He pointed out that there were strict procedural safeguards, adding that, in recent years, the supreme court had narrowed the list of offences for which the death penalty could be applied.

But he insisted that capital punishment did not violate international law, telling the council: "International human rights law does not bar it per se."

Koh also strongly defended the use of unmanned drone aircraft to kill "high value tagets" on the Afghanistan-Pakistan border and in Yemen.

"Our targeting practice complies with all human rights law," he said. "Operations are conducted in conformity with rule of law principles. It has been long legitimate to target enemy leaders and force is directed only at lawful targets."

Since the beginning of September, Barack Obama has authorised at least 25 targeted killings.

While the attacks have killed senior al-Qaida and Taliban figures, they have also killed civilians, including a large number of women and children, sparking anger against the US.

The fiercest criticism at the UN council came from countries at odds with the US.

The Cuban ambassador, Rodolfo Reyes Rodriguez, who spoke first, called on the Americans to end their embargo against his country.

Venezuela's envoy, Germán Mundarain Hernández, said the US should "close Guantánamo and secret detention centres around the world, punish those people who torture, disappear and execute detainees arbitrarily and provide compensation to victims".

Iran's delegation urged the US to "halt serious violations of human rights and humanitarian law including covert external operations by the CIA carried out on pretext of combating terrorism".

Koh said the Obama administration had begun by "turning the page" on Bush-era practices and fully ensured the humane treatment of detainees.

"Let there be no doubt, the United States does not torture and it will not torture," he declared.

A state department submission in August, written after extensive public consultation, said the US was "currently at war with al-Qaida and its associated forces" but that it would comply with all applicable domestic and international law in armed conflicts and had ordered foreign detainees be treated humanely.

The report said the US was a democracy guided by "simple but powerful principles", but admits to discrimination against black people and Hispanics and a "broken" immigration system.

Source: The Guardian, November 5, 2010


US: Status Quo Stance at First UN Rights Review

Other Countries Point to Death Penalty, Migrant Policy as Sources of Concern

(New York) - The United States should take concrete steps to address serious failings in its human rights record, Human Rights Watch said today. Many of the issues were raised by UN member countries on November 5, 2010, during the United States' first review of its human rights conditions and policies before the Human Rights Council in Geneva.

"The US wasn't defensive in its responses, but it also refused to budge from the status quo," said Antonio Ginatta, US advocacy director at Human Rights Watch. "US officials were often reduced to restating current practices that grossly violate human rights, like the death penalty, poor prison conditions, and sentencing youth offenders to life without parole."

During what is called the Universal Periodic Review, a vast majority of countries expressed their concern about the death penalty and called for a nationwide moratorium. Similarly, countries pointed out problems with mistreatment of migrants and racial disparities in education, access to health care, and the criminal justice system. Many called on the United States to follow through on its promise to close the prison at Guantanamo Bay.

Almost all participating countries also called on the United States to ratify core human rights treaties, such as the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination against Women, and the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

One senior US official said at the proceedings that the only way to promote American values was to "live them at home." But that doesn't apply to everyone in the United States, Human Rights Watch said. One in ten African American men is incarcerated; about 2,500 youth offenders are serving sentences of life without parole; 40 people have been executed so far this year; 400,000 immigrants are in prison-like detention centers; and 48 people remain imprisoned at Guantanamo facing unfair military commission trials.

Inmates wait in holding pens at
the California Institution for Men in Chino.
The Universal Periodic Review system was established in 2006. The review provides a chance to draw attention to, and make recommendations about, human rights violations in all UN member states. States under review submit written reports concerning the human rights situation in their country and respond to the questions and recommendations put forward by other UN member states. All 192 UN member countries undergo such reviews every four years.

At today's session, more than 55 countries spoke for two minutes each, offering recommendations and asking questions of the delegation. The US took one hour to discuss its record and respond generally to some of the statements. Following its review, the US held a town hall meeting for civil society organizations gathered in both Geneva and Washington, participating through the web. It was a major opportunity for civil society groups to ask questions and further engage with the US government about its rights record. The US is the first country to hold such a session.

The report of the proceedings will be released early next week, and the United States will have until March 2011 to submit its final responses to the recommendations.

"Thankfully the US seems to acknowledge that today's meeting was not the final chapter in the UPR process," Ginatta said. "While today's meeting leaves little room for hope that the government will announce reforms in its final response to the UPR in March, Human Rights Watch and other civil society groups will continue to press the US to fulfill its human rights obligations."

Source: Human Rights Watch, November 5, 2010

Thursday, November 4, 2010

United States for first time submits human rights record to world scrutiny

The United States is submitting its human rights record to the scrutiny of other nations — both allies and adversaries — for the first time, as the Obama administration opens itself up to a committee shunned by his predecessor.

The 3-hour U.N. review Friday will have more than a few uncomfortable moments for the high-level U.S. delegation, which is sure to face questions over the use of torture in the war on terror, not dismantling the prison at Guantanamo Bay, the death penalty, immigration policy, the treatment of racial minorities and questions of religious freedom.

The 30-strong delegation, headed by three top State Department officials and including representatives from many departments, including Justice, Defense and Homeland Security, arrives in Geneva with a 20-page report compiled with the input of civic and social organizations.

For most observers, the high level of U.S. engagement alone is a milestone. The Bush administration shunned the U.N. Human Rights Council, which runs the so-called Universal Public Reviews, because of the participation of repressive states and its constant criticism of Israel.

Some of the most vocal critics of the review process have come from the U.S. Congress, and a landslide by the frequently U.N.-skeptical Republicans in Tuesday's election could leave the country even less receptive.

Human rights organizations say the ultimate test will be in the U.S. response to peer recommendations from any of the United Nations 192 members, including possibly Iran, which will be made next week.

Jamil Dakwar, director of the ACLU human rights program, said it is important that the United States matches its rhetoric with concrete domestic policies and actions.

"We believe that Obama administration should take specific actions through executive order and legislation that assure domestic human rights commitments, including UPR recommendations, are monitored and enforced within the U.S.," Dakwar said.

Some activists say Washington's report glosses over some of the toughest human rights challenges facing the United States, including the treatment of immigrants, the death penalty and officials responsible for the use of torture as a tool in the war against terror.

"We were dissatisfied because we concluded half of the report was basically fluff. It had very little substance," said Ajamu Baraka, director of the US Human Rights Network, a coalition of non-governmental organizations that prepared its own human rights reports in parallel. "It devoted too much space to a rendering of U.S. history as it relates to human rights that we thought was primarily myth."

Beyond front-page issues like torture and immigration, Baraka also wants to see the United States make more progress in what are seen as softer economic, social and cultural human rights, areas that came into sharp focus by the economic collapse that has penalized mostly less powerful members of society.

The 47-member council replaced the discredited Human Rights Commission in 2006, and the Obama administration joined last year — although as a U.N. member would have been required to participate in the peer review in any case. The council has no enforcement powers, but is supposed to act as the world's moral conscience on human rights.

The best tool it has for that is the UPR process, under which it reviews all of the 192 U.N. members' human rights records every four years. It is currently about 2/3 into the first cycle, which will be completed at the end of 2011.

The review will also be a test for the council itself, as governments assess next year whether the young body is living up to its stated purpose to be the world's pre-eminent forum for discussing human rights.

Critics of the council have argued that too often repressive states such as Cuba and Pakistan have used the review process to lavish praise on their allies, a practice the U.S. recently suggested should be banned in future meetings.

The process has its detractors across the Atlantic who don't want to see the United States submit to the scrutiny of countries with lesser human rights records. Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer, for example, called it "internationalism run amok," complaining that the state's controversial immigration law was included in the report. She asked it be removed; it was not.

Indeed, it is highly likely that countries like Iran — whose human rights record is often under fire from Washington — will jockey to be the first to question the United States. But U.S. officials say such scrutiny does not weaken the process.

"We will get some interesting questions. We will get some outrageous questions. The United State is used to public scrutiny," Eileen Chamberlain Donahoe, U.S. Ambassador to the Human Rights Council told a briefing Wednesday.

Donahoe said the United States needs to be willing to hear criticism also from its critics in order to be good role model.

"We genuinely believe that it is through that kind of open process, that the truth about our human rights record will shine through, number one, and the areas where we need to improve will benefit from the real and serious input that we get," she said.

The U.S. report acknowledges areas where problems persist, including discrimination against Hispanics and African Americans, unemployment rates of up to 80 % on some Native American reservations and a "broken" immigration system. But it emphasizes that participating in the review does not place the United States at the same level as countries that systematically abuse human rights.

"There is no comparison between American democracy and repressive regimes," the report says.

Donahoe said she hoped that Tuesday's elections, which gave control of the House to the Republicans, who are generally more wary of the U.N., would have little bearing on the U.S. engagement with the global body over the longer term.

"I feel fairly confident we are starting to change the understanding at home about the value of the opportunity that we have here, that engagement has its benefits," Donahoe said.

On the Net: Universal Period Review: http://www.ohchr.org/EN/HRBodies/UPR

source: Associated Press, November 3, 2010