Showing posts with label Arson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arson. Show all posts

Friday, March 7, 2014

Japan: Top court upholds death penalty for man over Osaka fatal arson

The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld lower court rulings that sentenced a man to death for killing 16 people by setting fire to a video-viewing parlor in Osaka in 2008 in a failed suicide attempt.

The highest court's 5-justice first petty bench led by Justice Tomoyuki Yokota turned down an appeal filed by Kazuhiro Ogawa, 52, against decisions by the Osaka district court in 2009 and high court in 2011.

Ogawa had pleaded not guilty, and denied setting fire to the parlor.

Justice Yokota said the accused "committed an extremely selfish crime" and the death penalty is unavoidable as Ogawa "has not sincerely reflected on" his conduct. The arson "caused major shock and anxiety to society," Yokota added.

According to the lower court rulings, Ogawa set fire to a room at a video-viewing parlor in Osaka's Naniwa Ward at around 3 a.m. on Oct. 1, 2008, in a bid to commit suicide.

The fire destroyed the store completely, killed 16 customers and injured 4 others.

Source: Mainichi News, March 7, 2014

Friday, February 28, 2014

Evidence of Concealed Jailhouse Deal Raises Questions About Todd Willingham's Execution

The Willingham's house after
the blaze that killed 3 children
In the 10 years since Texas executed Cameron Todd Willingham after convicting him on charges of setting his house on fire and murdering his three young daughters, family members and death penalty opponents have argued that he was innocent. Now newly discovered evidence suggests that the prosecutor in the case may have concealed a deal with a jailhouse informant whose testimony was a key part of the execution decision.

The battle to clear Mr. Willingham’s name has symbolic value because it may offer evidence that an innocent man was executed, something opponents of the death penalty believe happens more than occasionally. By contrast, Justice Antonin Scalia wrote seven years ago that he was unaware of “a single case — not one — in which it is clear that a person was executed for a crime he did not commit.”

Mr. Willingham was convicted on charges of setting the 1991 fire in Corsicana, Tex., that killed his three children, and was sentenced to death the next year. The conviction rested on two pillars of evidence: analysis by arson investigators, and the testimony of a jailhouse informant, Johnny Webb, who said that Mr. Willingham had confessed the crime to him.

The arson investigation has since been discredited; serious questions were raised about the quality of the scientific analysis and testimony, which did not measure up to the standard of science even at the time. But the prosecutor who led the case shortly before Mr. Willingham’s execution argued that even though the arson analysis had been questioned, the testimony of Mr. Webb should be enough to deny any attempt for clemency.

In recent weeks, as part of an effort to obtain a posthumous exoneration from the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles and Gov. Rick Perry, lawyers working on Mr. Willingham’s behalf say they have found evidence that Mr. Webb gave his testimony in return for a reduced prison sentence.


Source: The New York Times, February 27, 2014

Suggested reading:
- Trial By Fire, The New Yorker, David Grann, Sept. 2009
The fire moved quickly through the house, a one-story wood-frame structure in a working-class neighborhood of Corsicana, in northeast Texas...

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Chinese Man Given Death Penalty for Fire

A Chinese court has sentenced a 25-year-old man to death for setting fire to a building that killed eight people as part of a revenge attack, state media reported.

Lin Binwei confessed to setting the fire Feb. 23 in revenge against a man he thought was having an affair with his girlfriend, the official Xinhua News Agency reported Saturday. A man on duty Sunday at Intermediate People's Court in Taizhou City confirmed a verdict had been handed down, but said he had no details.

All death sentences are automatically reviewed by the Supreme People's Court.

Xinhua said Lin's arson attack targeted the rival man's warehouse, where he stored products for his online shoe business, and that the fire spread to homes upstairs, killing eight and injuring one. The brief report had no further details, including whether the business owner was hurt or killed.

Private gun ownership is largely prohibited in China so knives, homemade bombs and arson are frequently used to settle scores.

On Friday, a man unhappy with life set fire to a commuter bus to vent his anger, killing 47 people and injuring 34, according to authorities in southeast Xiamen city.

In a microblogging account reported to be the suspect's, the writer chronicled his frustrated efforts to get a local police station to correct his age so he could be eligible for social security payments.

Source: AP, June 9, 2013

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Texas man gets new trial amid arson finding doubts

DALLAS (AP) — A Texas man convicted of setting a fire that killed his two stepsons was granted a new trial Wednesday by the state's highest criminal court, which sided with experts who question the fire investigation used to convict him.

Ed Graf's case is one of several flagged by a new state panel re-examining arson investigations. The Texas state fire marshal is working with criminal justice advocates who say many arson convictions have been won with the help of faulty scientific conclusions.

Graf was given life in prison for the 1986 fire in a backyard shed that killed 9-year-old Joby and 8-year-old Jason. Four reviews of the original fire forensics in Graf's case, including one commissioned by prosecutors, found investigators may have drawn the wrong conclusions from photos of charring and burn patterns and that the fire could have been an accident.

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals ordered Graf's conviction set aside Wednesday.

The original investigation determined charring was deepest near the shed entrance and on the doors. Investigators then pointed to "alligator" charring and other patterns to suggest a quick fire started by an accelerant like lighter fluid.

Experts now say those patterns could have been caused by a condition known as "flashover," when a fire escalates to a point where the whole room is in flames.



Source: Houston Chronicle, March 27, 2013

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Texas executes Carl Henry Blue

Carl Henry Blue
(Reuters) - The state of Texas executed a man on Thursday for killing his former girlfriend in 1994 by dousing her with gasoline and setting her on fire.

Carl Henry Blue, 48, was put to death by lethal injection at 6:56pm on Thursday night at The Walls Unit, in Huntsville, Texas.

Blue was convicted of killing ex-girlfriend Carmen Richards-Sanders, 38, in her apartment in Bryan, Texas, on the morning of August 19, 1994, as she was getting ready to leave for work.

His execution was the first carried out in Texas this year and the second in the United States.

According to court records in the Texas case, Blue threw open the door to Richards-Sanders' apartment, tossed gasoline on her and another man who was in the home at the time and set the two of them ablaze with a lighter.

"I told you I was gonna get you," Blue said to Richards-Sanders, according to a court summary of the case.

The male victim survived his injuries, but Richards-Sanders died 19 days later due to organ failure caused by burns over 40 percent of her body.

After turning himself in to police, Blue claimed the incident was a prank and said he did not intend to kill his ex-girlfriend, according to the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.

But prosecutors said Blue had exhibited violent behavior towards other women, including a sexual assault of one former girlfriend and a beating of another when she was eight months pregnant.

Five years after Blue's conviction, his death sentence was among about a half-dozen in Texas overturned by a federal judge who ruled it was improper for a former state prison psychologist to testify the black man's race could indicate a propensity for violence.

Blue again was sentenced to die at a second punishment trial in 2001.

At least 11 other prisoners are scheduled for lethal injection in the coming months in Texas, which executed 15 inmates last year.

In Georgia, attorneys for death row inmate Andrew Allen Cook, 38, sought to block his execution by arguing the state's method of lethal injection violated state and federal law.

Cook was convicted of fatally shooting two Mercer University college students in 1995.

Source: Reuters, Feb. 21, 2013

Monday, October 29, 2012

Texas Gov. Rick Perry's death penalty debacle

Perry's popularity dipped at home after he dropped out of the [presidential] race, but something else lurking in his past could cause worse than a downturn in his poll numbers. Perry, it turns out, not only stood by while his state's executioners took the life of a man widely believed by forensics scientists to have been innocent, he later acted to prevent evidence of that innocence from seeing the light of day. He oversees a state whose procedures for reviewing inmate appeals are a national disgrace and that may, if the case of Cameron Todd Willingham is ever given a fair hearing, prove to be the home of the first execution of a factually and legally innocent person since the advent of the modern judicial system.

Willingham was convicted in 1992 of setting an arson fire that killed his three young daughters based on the testimony of witnesses, including a jailhouse informant who claimed Willingham confessed to setting the fire, and a pair of veteran fire investigators. As the New Yorker chronicled in an extensive 2009 article about the Willingham case, when a pen pal of the inmate's named Elizabeth Gilbert began investigating in 1999, she discovered numerous holes in witnesses' statements; a few months after a visit from Gilbert, the jailhouse informant who was the prosection's key witness sent a Motion to Recant Testimony to the prosecuting attorney asserting that Willingham was innocent. But it was the later discovery that the work of fire investigators had been based on outdated and unscientific methods that should have saved Willingham from the death chamber. Anywhere but Texas, it probably would have.


Source: Dan Turner, Opinion, Los Angeles Times, October 28, 2012

Saturday, October 6, 2012

Texas forensic panel to hear report on wrongful convictions in arson cases

Texas criminal watchdogs are expected to tell the state's top forensic panel today that Texas may have falsely convicted about a half dozen people of felony arson based on outdated science.

"We're looking at four or five cases," said Jeff Blackburn, chief counsel for the Innocence Project of Texas. "Those are going to be looked at hard."

Blackburn is scheduled to appear before the Texas Forensic Science Commission in Austin to report on a records examination of hundreds of arson convictions. The effort is aimed at finding examples of junk science similar to that used to convict Cameron Todd Willingham of killing his three daughters, which resulted in a controversial review by the commission. Willingham was executed in 2004.

Blackburn says one or more of the new cases may involve inmates from North Texas.

At the request of the state's top forensic panel, the Texas Innocence Project reviewed 1,025 arson-related crimes in Texas from recent years, and concluded that most don't involve questionable evidence. A small number, maybe a half dozen, may have used scientific processes now deemed to be faulty, Blackburn said.

Blackburn's work, commission members have said, is expected to send a clear message to fire investigators on the proper protocols for handling arson-related cases.

For many months, commissioners have been calling for additional reviews of arson cases like Willingham's after methods used to analyze evidence were called into question.


Source: Star-Telegram, October 4, 2012

Thursday, June 7, 2012

USA: After 26 years in prison, Ionia man is cleared in fire that killed his family

An Ionia man who spent 26 years behind bars for murdering his wife and daughters in a house fire walked out of prison a free man Wednesday after prosecutors agreed he was convicted with faulty evidence and outdated science.

His first stop: a cemetery near Ionia to visit the graves of his wife and daughters. It was the first time he'd been there.

"It was a very emotional scene," said David Moran, a law professor and co-founder of the Innocence Clinic at the University of Michigan Law School, which fought for the release of 54-year-old David Lee Gavitt. Moran said 15-20 of Gavitt's family members also arrived to welcome him home.

Gavitt's conviction is among several nationwide that innocence projects have challenged with modern fire science.

Last week, James Kluppelberg was freed after Cook County prosecutors dropped their case against him. He had spent nearly 22 years in prison for setting a fire in Chicago that killed a mother and her five children.


Source: Detroit Free Press, June 7, 2012

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Cameron Todd Willingham Exoneration Was Written But Never Filed By Texas Judge

Todd Willingham
and daughter
A Texas judge who reviewed the controversial 2004 execution of Cameron Todd Willingham planned to posthumously exonerate the father who was put to death for killing his three daughters in a house fire.

Scientific experts who debunked the arson evidence used against Willingham at his 1992 trial and a jailhouse witness who recanted his shaky testimony convinced District Court Judge Charlie Baird in 2010 that "Texas wrongfully convicted" him. But Baird's order clearing Willingham's name never became official, because a higher court halted the posthumous inquiry while it considered whether the judge had authority to examine the capital case.

While waiting for permission to finish the case from the Third Court of Appeals, Baird put together the document that "orders the exoneration of Cameron Todd Willingham for murdering his three daughters," because of "overwhelming, credible and reliable evidence" presented during a one-day hearing in Austin in October 2010.

"You can't do anything for Willingham except clear his name," Baird told The Huffington Post.


Source: Huffington Post, May 19, 2012

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Saudis behead, crucify Sudanese man for robbery, rape and murder

Riyadh: Saudi Arabia beheaded and crucified a Sudanese man in Riyadh on Friday after he was convicted of raping, robbing and killing a woman, the interior ministry announced.

Abdulrahman Zine Elabidine "broke into a house strangling its owner to death while she was asleep."

He also raped her and stole 165,000 riyals ($44,000/33,000 euros) as well as gold jewellery, said the statement carried by state news agency SPA.

Arson

He then set the house on fire.

His beheading took to 20 the total number of executions in the conservative kingdom so far this year, according to an AFP tally based on official reports.

Under the AFP count, at least 76 people were beheaded in 2011, while rights group Amnesty International put the number of executions last year at 79.

The death penalty in Saudi Arabia applies strict Sharia (Islamic) law for a wide range of offences including rape, apostasy, armed robbery, homosexuality and drug trafficking, as well as murder.

Source: GulfNews, AFP, April 20, 2012


VIDEOS OF THE EXECUTION AND CRUCIFIXION:
Public beheading and "crucifixion" on scaffolding of a Sudanese convict in Saudi Arabia in the capital Riyadh, April 20th, 2012. Riyadh has one of the lowest crime rates in the world and the horrific nature of the man's crimes caused outrage in the kingdom. His execution was watched by thousands of citizens.


Video 1: Arrival of the convicted man to the execution arena in a police convoy




Video 2: The beheading (Warning: Graphic Content)




Video 3: The "crucifixion" (Warning: Graphic Content)


Thursday, March 29, 2012

China: Three executed over fatal fire

March 29, 2012: Three people responsible for a fire, in which 11 people were killed and two others badly injured in China's Jilin province last year, were executed, court officials said. 

Wang Jiansong, Qu Long and Wang Lu were convicted of setting fire to a bar. The fire spread to the upper floors of a budget hotel May 1, 2011, Xinhua quoted officials with the Intermediate People's Court as saying in Tonghua city.

Eleven people, including hotel tenants and firefighters who responded to the accident, were killed when the fire spread.

The three were found to have set fire to seek revenge on the bar's owner with whom they had disputes, said officials.

Their death sentences were approved by the Jilin provincial Higher People's Court.

Source: IANS, March 29, 2012

Saturday, January 28, 2012

Connecticut: Komisarjevsky denies blame as death sentence passed

A man convicted of murdering a woman and her 2 daughters in a 2007 home invasion has tried to deflect blame, as a judge sentenced him to die.

Joshua Komisarjevsky, 31, was ordered to face lethal injection after emotional statements from family members of the victims.

The crime shocked America and helped defeat a bill to abolish the death penalty in the state of Connecticut.

Komisarjevsky's accomplice, Steven Hayes, was sentenced to death in 2010.

The 2 were on parole for burglary when they broke into a home in Cheshire, Connecticut.

'Personal holocaust'

While Dr William Petit was tied up, his wife Jennifer Hawke-Petit was forced to withdraw money from her bank.

She was then raped by Hayes and strangled to death.

Hawke-Petit's 11-year-old daughter, Michaela, was sexually assaulted by Komisarjevsky.

Both girls were tied to their beds and left to die as the house was doused in petrol and set on fire.

The only survivor, Dr Petit, was beaten with a baseball bat and tied up but escaped.

He testified during Friday's sentencing hearing that the crime had been a "personal holocaust".

"I lost my family and my home,'' he said. "They were three special people. Your children are your jewels.''

Defence lawyers had argued that Komisarjevsky, convicted of sexual assault and murder in October, should be spared execution in light of the abuse he suffered as a boy.

But Judge Jon Blue disagreed and told the convicted man he had brought the harshest sentence on himself.

In court on Friday, Komisarjevsky acknowledged he had hurt many people, but insisted that he never raped the girl and had not intended to kill.

"They were never supposed to lose their lives," said Komisarjevsky, who will become the 11th man on Connecticut's death row.

"I know my responsibilities, but what I cannot do is carry the responsibilities of the actions of another,'' Komisarjevsky said. "I did not want those innocent women to die.''

During the trial, Komisarjevsky and Hayes blamed each other for escalating the crime.

Being condemned to death was a "surreal experience", Komisarjevsky added.

Talking about the penalty, he said: "I wonder when the killing will end."

They are not likely to be put to death soon, as both cases will be automatically appealed, a process that could last decades.

Source: BBC News, January 28, 2012

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Condemned Ohio man claims innocence in arson death

COLUMBUS, Ohio — A death row inmate convicted of starting a fire that killed his 3-year-old son says new arson science backs up his claim of innocence.

Michael Webb is trying to stop his execution, scheduled for next month. He's seeking mercy from the Ohio governor, saying a leading arson expert can prove the 1990 fire could have been set anywhere in the house, and not just near a closet or bathroom.

Webb's attorneys made their plea Tuesday morning to the Ohio Parole Board, which will make its recommendation to Gov. John Kasich, who has the final say, next week.

At the heart of the state's evidence against Webb was testimony from the Goshen Township Fire Chief Virgil Murphy that evidence from the fire on Nov. 21, 1990, showed it could only have been set near a bathroom or closet, based on where the majority of the fire damage was. Webb told investigators he was standing outside the bathroom.

Webb's attorneys submitted an analysis by Austin, Texas-based arson expert Gerald Hurst that said the fire chief relied on methods that 20 years of arson science have deemed unreliable.

Hurst said it's impossible to say in a fire where gasoline is spread through a house where the blaze began.

"Thus, we now know, to a scientific certainty, that it is impossible to determine in this case where the gasoline vapors ignited," Webb's attorneys said in their filings to the parole board.

The state says that all Hurst's analysis proves is the fire could have been set anywhere in the house, not that it eliminates the site near the bathroom as the origin.

Webb's attorneys concede this point, saying the report does not exonerate their client.

Webb's attorneys say police failed to follow up properly on reports that a boyfriend of one of the daughters might be responsible, and that he later boasted about responsibility for the fire and had a jacket that smelled of gasoline.

Prosecutors say the police investigation disproved the claim of a boast, and couldn't verify a witness' claim that the boyfriend's jacket smelled of gasoline. Webb's attorneys point out police never located the jacket.

Hurst's conclusions about the unreliability of previous arson investigations are backed up by a major shift in fire analysis that began in the early 1990s.


Source: DeseretNews, January 24, 2012

Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Texas: State Fire Marshal Resigns as Arson Inquiry Begins

Willingham's house
after the blaze
The Texas state fire marshal who defended the agency’s work in the Cameron Todd Willingham arson investigation quietly and hurriedly resigned in December after seven years on the job.

Paul Maldonado’s one-sentence, hand-written letter of resignation, dated Dec. 12, comes just as the fire marshal’s office, in conjunction with the Innocence Project of Texas, embarks on an unprecedented review of arson cases in the wake of the Texas Forensic Science Commission’s protracted examination of the Willingham case.

Asked why Maldonado resigned, spokesman Jerry Hagins said the agency does not discuss personnel issues. “The personnel change won't affect the work of the State Fire Marshal's office,” Hagins wrote in an email.

In October, after discussions with the Texas Forensic Science Commission and the Innocence Project, Maldonado had agreed to cooperate with a review of old arson cases to determine whether faulty science might have led to wrongful convictions.

The agreement came after more than two years of heated controversy at the science commission over the Willingham case. Willingham was executed in 2004. He was convicted of arson in the 1991 fire that killed his three daughters. Several scientists who reviewed the evidence shortly before and after Willingham’s execution had concluded the deadly blaze was not intentionally set. And the New York-based Innocence Project asked the Forensic Science Commission to review the scientific methods used by the State Fire Marshal’s Office that led to Willingham’s conviction.


Source: Texas Tribune, January 9, 2012

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Film questions Texas death penalty arson case

(CNN) -- Throughout "Incendiary," a new award-winning documentary, filmmakers pose a tough question with potentially huge consequences: Was a man wrongfully executed because of outdated arson investigation methods?

The movie surrounds the 2004 Texas execution of Cameron Todd Willingham after his murder conviction in the house fire deaths of his three young children.

Directed by Joe Bailey Jr. and Steve Mims, it goes behind closed doors to visually document how Gov. Rick Perry and the Texas Forensic Science Commission handled the case.

It also examines a broader question: How accurate are criminal arson investigations? The filmmakers say it's a question crucial to the convictions of hundreds if not thousands of prison inmates nationwide. 

Bailey, a 29-year-old law school graduate and first-time filmmaker, told CNN the documentary was inspired by a New Yorker article by David Grann and just took off from there. It starkly illustrates how officials review death penalty cases, Bailey said, and American society's complicated relationship with science.

CNN: In general, do most people know much about how arson investigations are conducted?

BAILEY: I have to assume that most people don't have any idea about arson investigations. I know I sure didn't.

If you have an expert testifying to something, a jury gives a lot of weight to that testimony. That's something you learn in law school.

When techniques improve and when standards change, it really gives you pause and you think, wow how many cases have we conducted with a lesser standard or with a standard that was false?

It's an important principle that we have in our justice system and as a society as a whole that when we make mistakes we correct them, and we use them as instruction for the future.

CNN: Do we know how many convicted people would be affected by changes to arson investigation laws?

BAILEY: In Texas it's estimated at something like -- I don't remember the exact number — it's like 750 cases or so -- and they're not all death row cases, and I don't think there are very many that are death row cases. One good thing to come out of all this is the Texas Forensics Science Commission was able to enter into an agreement with the Texas fire marshal's office so it can pair up with the Innocence Project of Texas to go through all of those cases that they think might have a problem and really scrutinize them.

Click here to read the full article

Source: CNN, December 8, 2011

Monday, November 14, 2011

Texas Forensic Science Commission Closes Case of Possible Innocence

The Texas Forensic Science Commission recently closed its inquiry into the case of Cameron Todd Willingham (pictured with daughter), who was executed in Texas in 2004.

The Commission was told by the Texas Attorney General that it did not have jurisdiction to rule on the Willingham case. Hence, in its final report on October 28 on the matter, it declined to issue any finding regarding allegations of negligence or misconduct by the City of Corsicana or the Texas State Fire Marshal in the Willingham matter. 

The Commission, however, acknowledged that outdated science regarding arsons played a role in Willingham’s 1991 murder conviction. 

Willingham was convicted of setting the fire that killed his 3 daughters. Since then, modern fire experts have determined that none of the more than 20 arson indicators identified by the standards of arson science in 1991 are reliable evidence of intentional fire. 

Experts say that the cause of fire should have been "undetermined." 

Stephen Saloom, policy director for the Innocence Project in New York, said, "The world should now know that the evidence relied upon to convict and execute Cameron Todd Willingham for the fire that killed his daughters was based on scientifically invalid and unreliable evidence.” 

The Commission’s final report also included a commitment from the state fire marshal’s office to review old arson rulings to determine whether convictions were based on the now-debunked science."

Source: Death Penalty Information Center, November 13, 2011

Friday, November 4, 2011

Texas Execution of a Man Believed to Be Innocent Continues to Draw Attention

The Texas Forensic Science Commission on Friday found that unreliable fire science methods, which led to the wrongful conviction of Cameron Todd Willingham, are still in use.

Mr. Willingham was convicted of setting the fire that killed his three young daughters in 1991. Shortly before he was executed in 2004, an internationally known arson scientist reviewed the evidence in his case and concluded it was flawed. Governor Rick Perry declined to stay the execution.

The Commission's examination of the forensic evidence that led to Mr. Willingham's conviction was restricted this summer when Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott issued an opinion barring the Commission from considering evidence gathered or tested before 2005.

Despite the limitations on its jurisdiction, the Commission acknowledged in its October 28, 2011, amended report that unreliable fire science played a role in Mr. Willingham's conviction. It identified faulty assumptions and methods in the Willingham case that continue to be used today, and issued 17 recommendations for improving arson investigations in Texas.

The Commission also recommended that Texas arson investigators adopt national standards and establish a timeline for all to receive advanced training. Its recommendations also include new certification criteria for expert witnesses, and additional rules and regulations aimed at preventing the use of outdated science and improving the quality of testimony and analysis.

The Commission's findings, and the limitations placed on its investigation, raise troubling questions about the reliability of the death penalty.

Source: Equal Justice Initiative, November 3, 2011

Saturday, October 29, 2011

Willingham inquiry ends, but effects linger

The Willingham house
after the blaze
A state investigation into the science used to convict and execute Cameron Todd Willingham came to a quiet close Friday, but its results might echo across the justice system and the nation's death penalty debate for years to come.

Making final changes to its report on the Willingham case, the Texas Forensic Science Commission signed off on a document acknowledging that unreliable fire science played a role in the Corsicana man's conviction for the murder-by-arson deaths of his three young daughters in 1991. He was executed in 2004.

Following commonly held beliefs now known to be wrong, arson investigators testified that the Willingham house fire was intentionally set using a liquid accelerant, the commission concluded.

Modern fire experts working for the commission and for the New York-based Innocence Project, which is representing Willingham posthumously, have determined that none of the more than 20 "arson indicators" identified by fire investigators in 1991 are reliable evidence of accelerant use. The cause of the fire should have been "undetermined," the experts said.

Though the commission's inquiry was never intended to weigh Willingham's guilt or innocence, the findings have added fuel to the debate over capital punishment.

"The world should now know that the evidence relied upon to convict and execute Cameron Todd Willingham for the fire that killed his daughters was based on scientifically invalid and unreliable evidence," said Stephen Saloom , policy director for the Innocence Project. "By any fair estimate, that indicates he was innocent, that he did not set that fire."


Source: statesman.com, October 28, 2011

Thursday, September 29, 2011

The Controversial Willingham Case: What Rick Perry Knew and When

On the day in 2004 that her first cousin Cameron Todd Willingham was scheduled to be executed in Texas, Patricia Cox had good reason to believe he was innocent.

Willingham was convicted of murder for killing his three daughters in a late-1991 house fire following a prosecution that was based almost entirely on a forensic fire analysis performed by an assistant fire chief and a state deputy fire marshal in the days after the blaze. Two weeks before Willingham’s execution date, though, Cox managed to get famed arson analyst Gerald Hurst to take a fresh look at the case.

Working pro bono, Hurst reviewed the evidence and drafted a study that devastated the original findings. While Hurst’s conclusions relied on his own skills, arson forensics had become far more advanced and standardized in the previous 13 years. “A contemporary fire origin and cause analyst might well wonder how anyone could make so many critical errors in interpreting the evidence,” Hurst’s report began.

Hurst found that there was, in fact, no arson at all. Hurst and Willingham’s attorney rushed the report to the office of Governor Rick Perry on Feb. 13, just four days before the scheduled execution, Cox says.

Little is known about why the Hurst report did not compel Perry to use his authority to delay Willingham’s execution for further review. The governor’s office has resisted legal efforts to pry loose Perry’s most sensitive deliberative documents on the Willingham execution. “The governor’s office has been a giant black hole of information,” says Walter Reaves, Willingham’s post-conviction attorney.


Source: Time Swampland, Sept. 27, 2011


Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Incendiary: The Willingham Case




Depending on your point of view – and, perhaps, your political persuasion – the name Cameron Todd Willingham incites different reactions. Texas Gov. Perry calls him a monster. His own defense attorney calls him a psychopath. Others call him – or rather, call his conviction in 1992 and his subsequent execution in 2004 – a jaw-dropping miscarriage of justice.

In 1991, a few days shy of Christmas, Willingham’s house in Corsicana, Texas, burned down with his 3 toddler daughters still inside. Willingham escaped with minor burns. He attempted to re-enter the house and was eventually restrained by police officers to prevent further injury to himself or to others. 2 weeks later, Willingham was arrested and charged with murder. He was offered a plea bargain – confess to setting the fire and he’d get life, said the state prosecutors – but Willingham declined. He was found guilty and executed by the state of Texas in 2004. He never – publicly, at least – stopped insisting he was innocent.

As its title suggests, the locally produced Incendiary: The Willingham Case is concerned with the case, not the person of Willingham, who seems pretty universally accepted to have been physically abusive to his wife and, as one attorney puts it, an “SOB”. Both sides of the death-penalty debate have enlisted the example of Willingham to their cause, painting him alternately a martyr or a poster “monster” for the state getting it right. But Incendiary smartly sidesteps that firestorm to focus on the science used to convict Willingham. Junk science, it turns out.

The case against Willingham was premised on the idea that the fire was arson; that’s what the fire marshals on the scene determined, using the standards widely practiced at the time, bolstered by a common attitude that fire investigation is an art, not a science. But when Willingham’s advocates later brought in fire experts to re-examine the investigation – including the raggedy-bearded Gerald Hurst (who invented the Mylar balloon, incidentally) and John Lentini – they determined that evidence of arson was inconclusive. Ergo: no proof of arson, no proof of murder.

Incendiary, which won the Louis Black Award at the 2011 South by Southwest Film Festival, gets technical fast. Luckily, fire is an incredibly cinematic thing, and Lentini and Hurst, both of whom are interviewed extensively here, are articulate, animated speakers. As the fire experts dismantle the prosecution’s case, co-directors Steve Mims (a longtime fixture in the Austin filmmaking and teaching community) and Joe Bailey Jr. (a law school graduate and former student of Mims’) artfully illustrate the technical aspects of the case, taking concepts like “crazed glass” and making them concrete and easy to understand.

The film also follows the efforts of the Texas Forensic Science Commission to re-evaluate the case – efforts that were undermined from within when Perry abruptly removed three members of the committee and installed a combative new chairman for whom “transparency” appeared to be a very dirty word indeed. Scientific inquiry bumps up against political maneuvering – wanna guess which side comes out on top?

Aggravated by his opponents' political rhetoric and special flair for twisting words (undermining accredited fire investigators' authority by referring to them repeatedly as "supposed" experts or "so-called" experts, for instance), Hurst worries to the camera about what he calls the current "anti-intellectual" climate in our country. Well, you know what they say: Everything's bigger in Texas, including the irrational hostility toward science, toward learning, toward temperance, as Mims and Bailey's well-made, deeply disheartening film demonstrates.

Source: Austin Chronicle, Kimberley Jones, Sept. 26, 2011