Showing posts with label Electrocution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Electrocution. Show all posts

Friday, March 14, 2014

Tennessee can electrocute inmates, AG says

Tennessee can electrocute inmates if the drugs needed to perform lethal injection are unavailable, state lawyers say in an opinion released Thursday.

A bill pending in the state legislature that allows the state to use the electric chair for all executions is constitutional, Attorney General Robert Cooper's office says. Tennessee currently lets inmates sentenced to death choose electrocution or lethal injection, but Senate Bill 2580 would mandate the electric chair if lethal injection is found unconstitutional or if the drugs cannot be obtained.

The attorney general's office says courts have ruled previously that electrocution violates neither the Tennessee nor United States constitutions.

"Electrocution has never been found to be cruel and unusual punishment by any American court," state lawyers quote an appeals court as writing in 1997. They go on to note that the method probably would be challenged in court, nonetheless.

Tennessee has begun to reconsider the electric chair as court challenges and pressure groups have made it harder for states to obtain lethal injection drugs. Some states are believed to have turned to compounding pharmacies to make the drugs for them, a practice that has raised new questions about their effectiveness.

In Tennessee, executions have been on hold since 2009, in part because one drug was unavailable but also because of other legal challenges. After a substitute drug was found, the state announced plans late last year move ahead with 11 executions.

Source: Tennessean, March 13, 2014

Friday, February 21, 2014

Virginia lethal injection drug same as one in Ohio suit

The Virginia Department of Corrections said Thursday that it has approved the sedative midazolam as an alternative first drug in the state's three-drug execution protocol. Midazolam was one of two drugs used in last month's execution of an Ohio inmate who made snorting and gasping sounds and took an unusually long 26 minutes to die. His family is suing Ohio.

Illinois-based Hospira Inc., which manufactures midazolam, opposes its use for capital punishment but has been unable to stop state prison systems from obtaining it from suppliers.

The development comes as many death penalty states are grappling with a shortage of drugs that can be used in executions. Many of the drugs are manufactured in European countries that have prohibited their export for use in capital punishment.

Virginia lawmakers are considering legislation that would allow the state to use the electric chair in executions if lethal injection drugs are not available when an inmate's execution date arrives. Under current law, death row inmates can choose either the electric chair or lethal injection. If they decline to choose, they get the injection.

Source: AP, Feb. 21, 2014

Friday, February 7, 2014

Controversial Death Penalty Bill Killed in Virginia Senate

RICHMOND, Va (WVIR) - Lawmakers in the state legislature have killed a controversial death penalty bill - at least until next year.

Due to a nationwide shortage of lethal injection drugs, the bill filed in the state Senate proposed using electrocution as Virginia’s secondary means of execution. The bill was met with fierce opposition by some who view electrocution as archaic, but sponsor Bill Carrico says it's about justice.

“What about the victims and their families? What about the cruel and unusual punishment that took place there? Does anybody even think about that?” said 40th District Senator Bill Carrico (R).

“It's quite inhumane, and Virginia would be the only state where a death row prisoner could be forced to be electrocuted,” said 31st District Senator Barbara Favola (D).

The Senate voted 21 to 19, mostly along party lines to send the bill back to committee, effectively killing it for the year.

Source: WVIR, Feb. 7, 2014

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Food for thought...


"Electrocution leaves minor burns, just barely noticeable."

- Debra Gardner, chief deputy director of Virginia's Department of Corrections, on why Virginia could establish the electric chair as the state’s default method of execution when drugs used for lethal injection are not available.

Virginia lawmakers expected to set electric chair as backup when lethal injection unavailable

Virginia lawmakers are expected to vote this week to establish the electric chair as the state’s default method of execution when drugs used for lethal injection are not available.

The measure, prompted by a long-standing shortage of the drugs, would make Virginia the only state where a death-row prisoner could be forced in some circumstances to be electrocuted.

The bill has passed the House of Delegates and is expected to emerge from the Virginia Senate this week. A spokesman said Gov. Terry McAuliffe (D) has not taken a position on signing or vetoing the legislation.

The embrace of an execution method largely shunned over the past two decades comes as the death penalty, while still legal in many states and supported by a large if declining majority of Americans, is becoming increasingly difficult to implement.

Across the country, states are struggling to procure the drugs necessary to perform lethal injections. Manufacturers in Europe have refused to sell drugs for use in capital punishment, as has at least one major U.S. manufacturer. The three-drug cocktail used commonly since the Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1976 is now out of reach.


Source: The Washington Post, Feb. 5, 2014

Tuesday, January 28, 2014

US considers reviving old-fashioned executions

Utah's contraption for executions by firing squad
Most states abandoned those execution methods a generation ago

St Louis: With lethal-injection drugs in short supply and new questions looming about their effectiveness, lawmakers in some death penalty states are considering bringing back relics of a more gruesome past: firing squads, electrocutions and gas chambers.

Most states abandoned those execution methods more than a generation ago in a bid to make capital punishment more palatable to the public and to a judicial system worried about inflicting cruel and unusual punishments that violate the Constitution.

But to some elected officials, the drug shortages and recent legal challenges are beginning to make lethal injection seem too vulnerable to complications.

“This isn’t an attempt to time-warp back into the 1850s or the wild, wild West or anything like that,” said Missouri state Rep Rick Brattin, who this month proposed making firing squads an option for executions. “It’s just that I foresee a problem, and I’m trying to come up with a solution that will be the most humane yet most economical for our state.”

Brattin, a Republican, said questions about the injection drugs are sure to end up in court, delaying executions and forcing states to examine alternatives. It’s not fair, he said, for relatives of murder victims to wait years, even decades, to see justice served while lawmakers and judges debate execution methods.

Like Brattin, a Wyoming lawmaker this month offered a bill allowing the firing squad. Missouri’s attorney general and a state lawmaker have raised the notion of rebuilding the state’s gas chamber. And a Virginia lawmaker wants to make electrocution an option if lethal-injection drugs aren’t available.

If adopted, those measures could return states to the more harrowing imagery of previous decades, when inmates were hanged, electrocuted or shot to death by marksmen.

States began moving to lethal injection in the 1980s in the belief that powerful sedatives and heart-stopping drugs would replace the violent spectacles with a more clinical affair while limiting, if not eliminating, an inmate’s pain.

The total number of US executions has declined in recent years — from a peak of 98 in 1999 to 39 last year. Some states have turned away from the death penalty entirely. Many have cases tied up in court. And those that carry on with executions find them increasingly difficult to conduct because of the scarcity of drugs and doubts about how well they work.

In recent years, European drug makers have stopped selling the lethal chemicals to prisons because they do not want their products used to kill.

At least two recent executions are also raising concerns about the drugs’ effectiveness. Last week, Ohio inmate Dennis McGuire took 26 minutes to die by injection, gasping repeatedly as he lay on a gurney with his mouth opening and closing. And on Jan. 9, Oklahoma inmate Michael Lee Wilson’s final words were, “I feel my whole body burning.”

Missouri threw out its three-drug lethal injection procedure after it could no longer obtain the drugs. State officials altered the method in 2012 to use propofol, which was found in the system of pop star Michael Jackson after he died of an overdose in 2009.

Oregon Gas Chamber
The anti-death penalty European Union threatened to impose export limits on propofol if it were used in an execution, jeopardizing the supply of a common anesthetic needed by hospitals across the nation. In October, Gov Jay Nixon stayed the execution of serial killer Joseph Paul Franklin and ordered the Missouri Department of Corrections to find a new drug.

Days later, the state announced it had switched to a form of pentobarbital made by a compounding pharmacy. Like other states, Missouri has refused to divulge where the drug comes from or who makes it.

Missouri has carried out two executions using pentobarbital - Franklin in November and Allen Nicklasson in December. Neither inmate showed outward signs of suffering, but the secrecy of the process resulted in a lawsuit and a legislative inquiry.

Michael Campbell, assistant professor of criminal justice at the University of Missouri-St Louis, said some lawmakers simply don’t believe convicted murderers deserve any mercy.

“Many of these politicians are trying to tap into a more populist theme that those who do terrible things deserve to have terrible things happen to them,” Campbell said.

Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Centre in Washington, D.C., cautioned that there could be a backlash.

“These ideas would jeopardize the death penalty because, I think, the public reaction would be revulsion, at least from many quarters,” Dieter said.

Some states already provide alternatives to lethal injection. Condemned prisoners may choose the electric chair in eight states: Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Kentucky, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia. An inmate named Robert Gleason Jr was the most recent to die by electrocution, in Virginia in January 2013.

Arizona, Missouri and Wyoming allow for gas-chamber executions. Missouri no longer has a gas chamber, but Attorney General Chris Koster, a Democrat, and Missouri state Sen. Kurt Schaefer, a Republican, last year suggested possibility rebuilding one. So far, there is no bill to do so.

Delaware, New Hampshire and Washington state still allow inmates to choose hanging. The last hanging in the US was Billy Bailey in Delaware in 1996. Two prisoners in Washington state have chosen to be hanged since the 1990s — Westley Allan Dodd in 1993 and Charles Rodman Campbell in 1994.

Firing squads typically consisting of five sharpshooters with rifles, one of which is loaded with a blank so the shooters do not know for sure who fired the fatal bullet. They have been used mostly for military executions.

Since the end of the Civil War, there have been three civilian firing squad executions in the US, all in Utah. Gary Gilmore uttered his famous final words, “Let’s do it” on Jan. 18, 1977, before his execution, which ended what amounted to a 17-year national moratorium on the death penalty. Convicted killers John Albert Taylor in 1996 and Ronnie Lee Gardner in 2010 were also put to death by firing squad.

Utah is phasing out its use, but the firing squad remains an option there for inmates sentenced prior to May 3, 2004.

Oklahoma maintains the firing squad as an option, but only if lethal injection and electrocution are deemed unconstitutional.

In Wyoming, Republican state Sen. Bruce Burns said death by firing squad would be far less expensive than building a gas chamber. Wyoming has only one inmate on death row, 68-year-old convicted killer Dale Wayne Eaton. The state has not executed anyone in 22 years.

Jackson Miller, a Republican in the Virginia House of Delegates, is sponsoring a bill that would allow for electrocution if lethal injection drugs are not available.

Source: The Associated Press, January 28, 2014

Monday, January 27, 2014

Americans Favor The Death Penalty, But Few Want The Executed To Suffer

Most Americans favor the death penalty as a punishment for people convicted of murder, according to a new HuffPost/YouGov poll. But the poll also finds that few people want to inflict unnecessary pain on those who are executed.

According to the poll, 62 percent of Americans favor the death penalty for people who are convicted of murder, while only 26 % are opposed. That support crossed party lines -- 87 % of Republicans, 58 % of independents and 51 % of Democrats said that they were in favor of execution as a punishment for murder.

The survey found that lethal injection is the most favored method of execution among Americans by far, and the only one approved of by at least half of Americans. 54 % of respondents said that they approved of lethal injection as a method of execution, including 44 % of Democrats, 50 % of independents and 79 % of Republicans.

But a significant number of those polled said that just because a prisoner should be put to death doesn't mean he or she needs to suffer.

43 % of respondents said that execution methods should be as quick and painless as possible, while just 11 % wanted them to be as slow and painful as possible, and 8 % weren't sure. Another 38 % weren't asked the question because they said they were opposed to the death penalty, or they weren't sure if they were in favor of it or not.

The poll was conducted after the execution of Dennis McGuire, an Ohio inmate who reportedly gasped for air and took 26 minutes to die after being injected with an untested cocktail of lethal injection drugs last week.

States that allow the death penalty have struggled in recent years to find drug combinations that guarantee a quick and painless death, after European manufacturers cut off supplies to drugs previously used for execution by lethal injection.

If Americans were to come to view lethal injection as too slow and painful, the poll shows little support for other methods that might take its place. No other method of execution, including hanging, gas chambers, the electric chair, firing squads and beheading, received the support of more than 35 percent of Americans in the poll.

Much of that support was clustered among Republicans, of whom 54 % said they would approve of the electric chair and 51 % said they would approve of gas chambers as a method of execution. Among Democrats and independents, no alternative method of execution received more than 34 % approval.

The poll also found that for most Americans, life in prison without a chance of parole actually sounds like a worse form of punishment than execution. Asked which of the 2 they personally thought would be worse, only 30 % of respondents said execution, while 52 % said that life in prison with no possibility of parole would be the worse form of punishment.

The HuffPost/YouGov poll was conducted Jan. 18-19 among 1,000 U.S. adults using a sample selected from YouGov's opt-in online panel to match the demographics and other characteristics of the adult U.S. population. Factors considered include age, race, gender, education, employment, income, marital status, number of children, voter registration, time and location of Internet access, interest in politics, religion and church attendance.

Source: Huffington Post, January 26, 2014

Death Penalty News: "Should execution methods be as quick and painless as possible?" 8 % of respondents... weren't sure. My God, what kind of world are we living in?

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

What Happens to the Death Penalty When Lethal Injection Isn’t Quick and Painless?

San Quentin's brand new death chamber
For decades supporters of the death penalty in America have embraced lethal injection not just as an evolutionary plateau in the method of capital punishment but as a convenient solution to a problem that is both legal and moral. By purporting to ease the suffering of the condemned as he is killed, the procedure is supposed to neutralize concerns that any particular execution is “cruel” under the Eighth Amendment. And by purporting to put the prisoner to deep sleep first before the poison was administered, the practice is supposed to assuage whatever guilt exists in the minds of the executioner, or the administrator, over the intentional taking of life. We hide behind science, in other words, and then pat ourselves on the back for our ingenuity.

But these two pillars of support for lethal injection have always been based on a form of deceit. Making executions tidier does not make the dead any less dead or those who authorize the poison any less culpable for taking life. It is the act of capital punishment itself, not just the manner in which it is carried out, that carries the moral force. And no human development, no magic pill, no sterile syringe, can change that. This profound question is pertinent again, as a practical matter as well as a legal and political one, because recent developments in the practice of lethal injections have raised new doubts about the pain associated with their use. And if lethal injection protocols cause profound suffering the landscape of capital punishment as we know it may change.


Source: The Daily Beast, January 21, 2014

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Virginia: Electric chair bill advances in the House

January 17, 2014: The House's Militia, Police and Public Safety Committee passed House Bill 1052 that would allow forced electrocutions when lethal drugs aren't available.

The bill passed on a 12-6 vote. The vote was largely along party lines, with Republicans voting in favor.

The legislation could head to the House floor as soon as next week.

Republicans control the House, and the bill has a good chance of passing there.

The Senate is divided between Republicans and Democrats.

This bill, sponsored by Del. Jackson Miller, R-Manassas, would authorize electrocution if the head of the Virginia Department of Corrections certifies that lethal injection drugs aren't available.

Those drugs are becoming scarce because companies that produce them don't want them used in executions. Virginia already has electrocution in its protocols, but lets the inmate choose between lethal injection and electrocution. The new law would give the Department of Correction the power to overrule the inmates’ choice.

Richard Dieter, head of the Death Penalty Information Center, said the change would "certainly precipitate vigorous court challenges." "This is not a minor step," he said. "This would be like adopting the electric chair as the main method of execution, which no other state has."

Dieter said there are related proposals in other states, though, borne of frustration over the lack of available drugs.

There's a proposal in Wyoming to use firing squads, one in Arkansas for the electric chair and one in California to use the gas chamber. None are close to becoming law, Dieter said.

Source: Daily Press, January 17, 2014

Friday, January 17, 2014

Choice of method in death penalty could be overruled in new Virginia bill

Death row inmates in Virginia who wish to die by lethal injection still could face execution by electrocution under a bill that advanced Thursday in the House of Delegates.

By a 4-1 voice vote, a House subcommittee on Militia, Police and Public Safety backed a measure that would override a condemned prisoner’s choice of execution in the case of a shortage of lethal injection drugs.

“It’s really a just a process issue. This doesn’t expand the death penalty in any way, shape or form,” Del. Jackson Miller, R-Manassas, sponsor of HB 1052, said in an interview Thursday.

Under current state law, a condemned prisoner may choose whether to die by lethal injection or the electric chair. If the inmate doesn’t select either option at least 15 days before the scheduled execution, the method is lethal injection by default.

Since the introduction of lethal injection in Virginia in the mid-1990s, most convicts on death row opted to die that way or were put to death that way by default. Only seven of the 86 people executed in Virginia since 1995 chose electrocution, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

Miller said he wants to avoid a stay of execution when a prisoner has exhausted all appeals but the chemicals to administer lethal injection are not available on the day of the execution.

“It’s just getting more and more difficult for the Department of Corrections to find the chemicals necessary for the cocktail that they use for the lethal injection,” Miller said.

Source: roanoke.com, January 17, 2014

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Tinkering with Ohio's machinery of death: Jack Shuler

On January 16, the state of Ohio will become the first state to use a combination of the sedative midazolam and painkiller hydromorphone when it executes condemned killer Dennis McGuire. Some experts claim the deadly combo could result in seizures, vomiting, spasms, and suffocation. These changes represent the most recent technological advances in the long history of the death penalty. But how far have we really come?

How the drugs are manufactured and what drugs are used does not alter the fact that, as a state, we are using our innovation, our intelligence, our energy, and, quite frankly, our resources to kill a human being.

In the early 19th century, governments throughout Europe and across the United States began adjusting execution protocols to placate critics of the death penalty. To keep people from becoming desensitized to violence, hangings were moved behind prison walls and away from crowds. Ohio followed suit in 1885, and moved hangings behind the walls of the state penitentiary.

In the second half of the 19th century, enlightened hangmen worked on engineering a swifter death. In 1866, an Irish doctor named Samuel Haughton noted that death from hanging comes in three possible ways: from apoplexy, asphyxia or a fractured “vertebral column.” He suggested that a longer, more precise drop would dislocate the hanged person’s neck, a possibly more humane treatment.

Haughton wrote, “It seems to me unworthy to the present state of science to continue a mode of execution which … is extremely clumsy and also painful to the criminal.” His solution took into account the condemned person’s height and weight when determining how far he should drop from the gallows. Haughton claimed this would ensure a hangman’s fracture and thus a swift death.

Perhaps influenced by Haughton’s essay, English hangman William Marwood devised a measuring table in the 1870s that accounted for the height and weight of the condemned when determining the length of rope for an execution. The “Table of Drops” eventually made its way to the United States.

And yet, no matter how precise the drop became, no matter how much the process was perfected, hangmen could never account for the many ways the human body reacts to violence, to trauma, to pain. Necks stretched. Faces contorted. Bowels evacuated. Ropes snapped and the half-dead had to be re-hanged. Drops were too long and people were decapitated.

In 1885, New York Governor David B. Hill remarked that hanging executions were a carryover from the “dark ages” and wondered if modern science could offer a “less barbarous manner” for killing condemned criminals.

Hanging had become fully shameful to the citizen spectator. For many, execution by hanging brought to mind ghastly public spectacles or lynching. It was seen as an archaic punishment, out of step with modern sensibilities. People couldn’t escape the fact that a real, live person was at the end of that rope.

It didn’t take long for the electric chair and the gas chamber to supplant the noose in the United States. In 1889, William Kemmler became the first person to be put to death by electrocution in Auburn, N.Y. Ohio introduced the electric chair eight years later. And in 1924, Gee Jon became the first American to be executed by lethal gas in Carson City, Nev. Not only were these new technologies modern marvels, but gas and electricity were widely believed to kill more quickly, more humanely.

However, both led to horrific deaths — through burning and asphyxiation — that must have traumatized the viewers and tortured the condemned. There was a real, live person sitting on that electric chair; a real, live person inside that gas chamber.

Today, the private, bureaucratic and antiseptic process of lethal injection is a far cry from the ugly spectacle of a public hanging. It is the end result of an apparently progressive history. But is it any better?

We can continue to tinker with the machinery of death, to borrow Justice Harry A. Blackmun’s phrase. We can fool ourselves that we are humanizing this process, that we are executing the worst of the worse. But as with all other manners of executing, the problem with lethal injection is that a real, live person is strapped to that gurney. How far have we really come?


- Op-Ed by Jack Shuler, January 7, 2014 This article was originally published on Cleveland.com. Mr. Shuler is an author, John and Christine Warner Professor and assistant professor of English at Denison University. His forthcoming book is titled “The Noose: A History,” a study of the history of hanging from the Iron Age to today. Also by Jack Shuler on this website: The Other Iranian Execution Stories, October 29, 2013, and The questions Ohio should be asking about the death penalty, November 8, 2013.

Friday, November 15, 2013

Ohio: Death-row organ donations pose practical, ethical hurdles

Ohio's governor has postponed the execution of a child-killer so he can study his offer to donate organs — a proposal that experts say would be a logistical nightmare and an ethical minefield.

"The only options for executing someone to obtain vital organs is to either shoot them in the head or chop their head off and have a team of doctors ready to step in immediately," said Arthur Caplan, a professor of medical ethics at NYU Langone Medical Center.

Theoretically, he said, the method of execution could be the removal of the organs under anesthesia.

"The problem is no doctor is going to do it," he said. "It violates all medical ethics and now you're making the doctor the executioner."

Those are some of the practicalities that Ohio Gov. John Kasich will have to consider as he explores the possibility of allowing death-row inmate Ronald Phillips, 40, to give his organs to ailing relatives or members of the public.

Phillips, who was convicted of raping and beating to death his girlfriend's 3-year-old in 1993, was one day away from a lethal injection when Kasich stayed his execution so he could weigh his donation request.

"I realize this is a bit of uncharted territory for Ohio, but if another life can be saved by his willingness to donate his organs and tissues then we should allow for that to happen," the first-term Republican said in a statement.

Some ethicists say the life-for-a-life equation isn't that simple.

The United Network for Organ Sharing, the non-profit organization that coordinates transplants across the country, called the scenario "ethically troubling."

"Allowing condemned prisoners to donate organs could provide an inappropriate incentive to execute prisoners and could lead to significant human rights violations," Alexandra Glazier, head of UNOS' ethics committee, said in a statement.

She said allowing prisoners facing death to donate organs could also muddy the ideal of "coercion-free consent."

"Taking organs from a condemned prisoner is not generally seen as an ethically appropriate way for the U.S. to expand the availability of organs for transplantation."

But Sally Satel, a psychiatrist who is a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, said a donation policy would be "humane" — both for people actively waiting for organs and for killers who are trying to make amends.

"Every organ helps," she said.

Satel scoffed at the notion that the possibility of a post-execution donation would encourage juries and judges to impose capital punishment.

"It's an absurd and morbid fantasy," she said. "This is just the kind of outlandish scare tactic people use when they have no rational arguments against the issue."

There are more than 77,000 people actively waiting for organs, and the demand far outstrips the supply, according to UNOS.

With the number of executions in the U.S. hovering between 40 and 50, organs from death row are not going to solve the chronic shortage, Caplan said.

To donate a organ, a person usually has to die from a head injury that destroys the brain but leaves the rest of the body functioning. Life support is used to keep blood flowing to the organs until they are removed.

He said electrocution or lethal injection would injure the organs. Plus, the organs would have to be removed within five minutes to remain viable, which is not enough time to complete the formalities legally required in an execution.

The prison population would likely yield low-quality organs because of diet, lack of exercise and the high-rate of drug-related diseases such as HIV and hepatitis, Caplan said.

Dr. Jay Pal, a heart and transplant surgeon at the University of Washington Medical Center, said that even though up to seven people could benefit from the organs of a executed prisoner, he would not be comfortable with the process.

"It's very different to remove organs from someone who died in a car accident than it is to remove something from someone who is still alive," he said.

"I understand that person may not be alive for much longer for whatever crimes, but me personally, I think it would be very difficult knowing that's the act that killed somebody."

Phillips isn't the first death-row inmate to make the request. Christian Longo, facing execution for the murder of his wife and three children, asked to do the same two years ago and was turned down by authorities in Oregon.

Defense lawyer Tim Sweeney said his client has been praying and reflecting a lot in recent weeks as his final appeals — including a challenge to Ohio's plan to use an untested drug cocktail for the lethal injection — have been rejected.

He said that when he told Phillips about the seven-month reprieve, his reaction was: "God is good."

"Our client was very grateful the governor is going to give him time to explore this," Sweeney said.

"He'll have 230 more days of life and that's a very special thing. Hopefully he'll have the opportunity to do some good with that time if he's allowed to donate his organs."

Source: NBC News, November 14, 2013

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Nebraska researches "Death Penalty" drug

Nebraska will be looking at a number of options to maintain the death penalty.

Nebraska has been blocked from carrying out executions, because it cannot get adequate supplies of sodium thiopental, the drug the state would use as an anesthetic. No longer produced domestically, the drug has become increasingly difficult to obtain from European manufacturers who have been blocked from selling it for use in executions.

Missouri has announced it will change its death penalty protocol after it became difficult to receive propofol, an anesthetic used in its 3-drug protocol. The state now will use the sedative pentobarbital and is considering a switch to a 1-drug protocol.

Attorney General Jon Bruning says Nebraska will be review the move by other states toward a 1-drug protocol to carry out lethal injection, rather than the 3-drug method now on the books.

"Certainly, that's under discussion. The governor and I have had conversations and will continue to have conversations. That's one of the options," Bruning says. "We both believe that the men on death row deserve the penalties that have been meted out by the courts and judges."

Some states, such as Texas and Ohio, have begun using compounding pharmacies to prepare the needed drugs, which would avoid difficulties in buying from manufacturers under pressure by death penalty opponents to not sell drugs for use in executions.

Oklahoma was the 1st state to use a 1-drug protocol, using pentobarbital for an execution.

Bruning says his office has been reviewing the changes made by other states.

"We have had reviews of what a number of states are doing. There's of course the 3-drug protocol we use. There's a 1-drug protocol. There are various options and I think if you were to see any sort of change in the protocol it would give Corrections a number of different options. We don't (want to) hamstring ourselves with 1 option," Bruning says.

Nebraska has some sodium thiopental on hand, but it expires in December. It has become increasingly difficult to get for use in executions.

The legislature could change the state execution protocol or changes could be made to the regulations used by the state Department of Correctional Services.

The state switched to lethal injection after a 2009 Nebraska Supreme Court ruling declared the electric chair to be cruel and unusual punishment. Nebraska last carried out an execution in 1997. 11 prisoners now reside on death row.

Source: Nebraska Radio Network, October 28, 2013

Saturday, June 22, 2013

Death is Death: The More Capital Punishment Evolves, the More it Stays the Same

James Holmes
Vengeance and retribution are both human responses to tragedy, especially violence on a large scale. We’re not interested in justice when unspeakable acts take place. We want blood – now. Because our society is one of laws, angry mobs don’t usually hand down guilty verdicts and exact punishment. We have to wait for the guilty to go through the motions – arrest, “fair” trial, and sentencing – to get what we paid for: that sweet execution. Decades may pass from the time a judge hands down a death sentence to the day it’s carried out. The somber, private occasion that is our modern version of capital punishment brooks no cheers, no joyful singing that the guilty is soon to die. It is not the vehicle of satisfaction the public envisions it to be. There’s no catharsis for the victims, and no deterrence for those who might commit similar crimes in the future. In fact, employing it as a mechanism of the justice system has no place in our modern society – not even for the worst of the worst.

“For James Eagan Holmes, justice is death,” said Arapahoe County district attorney George Brauchler, according to ABC News. Holmes is alleged to have killed 12 people and wounded 70 during a midnight showing of The Dark Knight Rises in Aurora, Colorado. Brauchler, and his prosecutorial team, turned down a proposed plea agreement from Holmes, which would have required him to spend the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole. They’re seeking the death penalty, and many victims and the families of survivors applaud that decision. How many times did Brauchler practice that headline worthy snippet in the mirror? Did he imagine it broadcast across the globe by info-hungry media outlets?

Executing Holmes won’t bring back the dead, or provide those left behind with greater comfort. After his legal defense exhaust all of his appeals it may be decades until he sees an execution chamber – if a jury or judge sentences him to death at all. Victims, seeking to move on with their lives and heal, may only have their emotional wounds from that horrible night reopened, all the recovery washed away in a small black box of a room to watch a man die.


Source: Console and Hollawell Blog, Richard Console Jr. Mr. Console is the founding and managing partner of Console and Hollawell, one of the most highly regarded personal injury law firms in New Jersey and Pennsylvania.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Ex-Virginia executioner becomes opponent of death penalty

Jerry Givens
Jerry Givens executed 62 people.

His routine and conviction never wavered. He’d shave the person’s head, lay his hand on the bald pate and ask for God’s forgiveness for the condemned. Then, he would strap the person into Virginia’s electric chair.

Givens was the state’s chief executioner for 17 years — at a time when the commonwealth put more people to death than any state besides Texas.

“If you knew going out there that raping and killing someone had the consequence of the death penalty, then why are you going to do it?” Givens asked. “I considered it suicide.”

As Virginia executed its 110th person in the modern era last month, Givens prayed for the man, but also for an end to the death penalty. Since leaving his job in 1999, Givens has become one of the state’s most visible — and unlikely — opponents of capital punishment.

Givens’s improbable journey to the death chamber and back did not come easily or quickly for the 60-year-old from Richmond. A searing murder spurred his interest in the work, but it was the innocent life he nearly took that led him to question the system. And he was changed for good when he found himself behind bars.

His evolution underscores that of Virginia itself and the nation. Although polls show that the majority of state residents still support the death penalty, Virginia has experienced a sea change on capital punishment in recent years that is part of a national trend.

Givens grew up in the Creighton Court housing complex in Richmond, where he also graduated from high school in the early 1970s. By 1974, he had gotten a job at a Philip Morris plant and then lost it after fighting with a co-worker.

He recalled someone telling him that he should apply for a job at the state penitentiary before he got sent there. Givens did just that.

After two years as a prison guard, he said, a supervisor approached him about working on death row. He would not be paid extra, but he accepted the job.


Source: The Washington Post, Articles, Justin Jouvenal, February 10, 2013





"Executioners sentenced to remorse"

Ordinarily they don't talk. The executioners have no name, no face, and are not supposed to have qualms. "When I executed prisoners, even my wife knew nothing," remembers Jerry Givens, 60 years old, former executioner in the state of Virginia, and one of the first to have broken this silence. "I didn't want it to affect my wife, I didn't want her to have to live through everything I felt," he explains, sitting in a restaurant in his city of Richmond, in front of a fish he sometimes stops eating when his story becomes too macabre. "But since this death we give is legal, approved by the voters, why hide?" he wonders, between 2 bites.

"When people do things they're ashamed of, they tend to do it in secret," replies attorney Steve Northrup, director of the group Virginians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, an abolitionist movement which Jerry Givens has joined. "The jurisdictions which practice executions take a lot of trouble to keep secret the identities of all the persons involved."

More than 3000 prisoners are awaiting their last hour on the famous "death rows". These last few years, however, the number of executions is down (43 executions in 2012, compared with about 60 a year, or more, at the beginning of the 2000s). More than 60% of the Americans still say they favor the "supreme punishment", but this support is tending to decline. The statements by executioners is contributing to this slow evolution. Between 1982 and 1999, Jerry Givens killed 62 prisoners, 37 by electrocution and 25 by lethal injection of barbiturates. "I never liked that," he says. "For me, every time an execution was announced, it meant that I had to prepare myself mentally to kill. Ordinarily, as a prison guard, my job was more to preserve lives. During executions, I was in an opposite role, I became the one who had to take a life."

For the executioner, the putting to death of a prisoner breaks down into a series of well coded steps, says Jerry. "At the moment, I thought especially about doing my job right so as to avoid mistakes that would make the prisoner suffer. After his last meal the prisoner had the right to a shower. Then, if he was sentenced to be electrocuted, I had to shave his head and his right leg, where the electrodes would be placed, to avoid the hairs catching fire. Then he had the right to a final telephone call. Then the death sentence was read to him once again. While I was cutting their hair, I asked them if I could pray for them. Some said yes, others replied that they didn't care." At the time, Jerry Givens was convinced that the death penalty was right. As a teenager, he had seen a girl killed right before his eyes at a party. Murderers guilty of such acts just deserve death," he thought.

"Most of the prisoners talked to me," continues Jerry. They asked me if it was going to hurt. I told them I didn't know, having never been in their position. Or they asked me what would come after life. There again, I had to say I didn't know. Some made jokes. They asked me for a few minutes more, so as to be nice and clean when they went to heaven, or asked me to give them a nice haircut. Others were serious. One had ordered a McDonald's sandwich but couldn't manage to swallow it. He asked me to put it in the fridge for the next day. He hadn't realized this was his last day. Others fought right to the last minute with their lawyers to try to get a stay."

The executioner is not the only one involved, of course, a whole team of "technicians" helps him at the moment of the execution, each with a precise task, but finally, it was Jerry who had to push the button. At times he told about it like a workman presenting his work: "I did so many executions that at the end all I had to do was look at the size of the prisoner to know how many volts would be needed to kill him. If the guy wasn't very heavy, a 35-second discharge would be enough, if he was bigger, 45 or 60 seconds needed to be planned."

The worst, for Jerry Givens, was the executions by lethal injection, which have become more common in the United States. "When you pick up the syringe, you feel much closer to the prisoner than when you just push a button. You see the chemical solution flow, like you were seeing death advance down the tube." His other worry today is that innocent men were among the 62 men he killed: "I truly hope there were no innocents among them," he says. "If I ever learned thata I had executed innocent men, I don't know what that would do to me."

In 1999, Jerry Givens' career as an executioner came to an abrupt end: he himself was arrested and sentence to 4 1/2 years in prison for receiving money from drug trafficking. On the other side of the bars, where he feels he was wrongly sent, he turned to God and reconsidered his point of view on the death penalty. "Who am I to give death?" he wonders today. "It's up to God to decide who must die, not me. By applying the death penalty, we are worth no more than those who crucified Jesus, and innocent man."

Today working as a construction site truck driver, Jerry goes all over the United States for his work, but also to talk about his conversion and his new abolitionist faith. "Many people still defend the death penalty, but when I ask in public: 'Who would like to do this job of executioner?' no one raises his hand." Militating also helps him overcome this past as a killer, he explains. "If I kept all that inside, I would risk blowing up." Many of his former colleagues suffer from post-traumatic stress, reports Jerry, who claims that he is OK himself: "I think that God made me do that so that I could speak out now."

Ron McAndrew is another of those rare "State killers" who talk today about their profession. The experience seems to have been much more traumatic for him. "To this very day, I am in therapy, I have nightmares. The prisoners I executed come back to visit me in my dreams," confesses this sturdy 74-year-old man, who has however had all sorts of adventures: intelligence agent in the air force, stationed in France at the Evreux base from 1956 to 1961, perfume seller in Europe, Japan and Vietnam, then prison guard in Florida where he climbed through the ranks to become warden of the prison which included supervising executions. In 1996 and 1997, Ron McAndrew executed 3 men in the electric chair. At the third execution, that of Pedro Medina, a Cuban refugee, the body caught fire. "When we sent the electricity, we heard a sharp pop, and his head began to smoke," says Ron. "We had set this man's head on fire! The whole room filled with smoke. It was the worst experience I ever went through." After this tragedy he was sent to Texas, where he attended 5 more executions, by lethal injection, to train in the technique. "I didn't find it cleaner or easier," he sighs. "In both cases, I was facing a man first living, then dead."

For Ron McAndrew also, the death penalty was long obvious: "I grew up in the country, in North Carolina, at the end of a dirt road, in a really conservative family where the Holy Scriptures were taken literally: an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth," he explains. "For me, the death penalty was as natural as looking to the left and right before crossing the street." Even before his 1st execution, his conscience began to bother him. "It was in 1997," he remembers precisely. "The mother and sisters of the 1st prisoner I was supposed to execute, Leo Jones, came to see me at the prison. 'Warden,' the mother, an old black woman who could barely speak asked me, 'Will you let me hug my baby one last time before you kill him????' I could feel all this mother's pain and I could no longer turn my head away. At the last minute, her son got a reprieve - he was executed later, when I had left the job. But immediately afterward I received orders to execute another prisoner."

At the time his sleep was disturbed. "I took sleeping pills and I drank. A bottle of wine every evening, glassfuls of cognac. I had nightmares, I was cracking up, my wife was really worried about me. I was sicker and sicker." Ron McAndrew finally asked for a transfer and began psychotherapy.

"My therapist told me that talking about it would help me remain healthy," he explains. "As long as I have that in my mind, I need to talk about it, she told me."

These former executioners who have become opponents of the death penalty are a little club, very informal, with about 10 members, says Ron. "We call each other when our morale is low. Recently a colleague asked me how I hang on. My recipe? A really supportive wife, a good therapist, and a little medication." At least 2 former executioners have committed suicide in recent years in the United States. Dozens of others live hidden, still convinced of their "mission", or keeping their traumas to themselves, in silence.

Source: LIBERATION, June 12, 2013

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Spain's ex-US death row inmate speaks out

Florida Electric Chair
Former death row inmate Joaquin Martinez, who was acquitted of a double homicide in the US state of Florida after five years behind bars, will be campaigning for the abolition of capital punishment in an international congress to be held in Madrid this week.

Twelve years after leaving death row in Florida, Joaquin Martinez still cannot abide traditional lightbulbs.

"At the time we still had the electric chair and just like in the movies, the bulbs flickered and went out when they executed someone," said Martinez, who is visiting Madrid to join the fifth World Congress against the Death Penalty.

"I don’t have any normal light bulbs at home, just halogens," he said.

His hair impeccably brushed back, the well-dressed 41-year-old Spaniard was arrested in 1996 in Florida on suspicion of double murder before being found not guilty by the US justice system and freed in 2001.

"I still dream sometimes that I am a prisoner. I wake up with a shudder," he said in a presentation event ahead of the June 12-15 congress, organised by the French lobby group Ensemble Contre La Peine de Mort (Together Against the Death Penalty).

Organizers say they expect 1,500 people from 90 countries, including high-profile politicians such as French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius, to gather for the congress.

The debate will be punctuated by testimony from people who were once condemned to death or the relatives of those now living on death row.

Another Spaniard, 40-year-old Pablo Ibar, has now spent 19 years under lock and key in the same Florida death row that Joaquin Martinez left behind.

Arrested in 1994 for triple murder, Ibar was condemned to death in 2000. Ever since, his relatives have proclaimed his innocence.


Source: The Local, Agence France-Presse, June 11, 2013

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

Papua New Guinea revives death penalty, repeals sorcery law

SYDNEY: Papua New Guinea pressed ahead Tuesday with a controversial revival of the death penalty, passing laws allowing execution by a range of methods, while repealing its contested sorcery act.

The impoverished Pacific nation’s parliament voted to extend the long-dormant death penalty to cover rape, robbery and murder with new legislation permitting hanging, electrocution and firing squad executions.

Lethal injection and medical asphyxiation — which it did not define — will also be permitted methods under the law, which will provide the death sentence for crimes including aggravated rape or gang rape of a child under the age of 10.

“Which method to be used will be determined by the head of state on advice from the National Executive Council,” a spokesman for Prime Minister Peter O’Neill said in a statement.

“These are very tough penalties, but they reflect the seriousness of the nature of the crimes and the demand by the community for parliament to act.”

Death sentences are currently in place for treason, piracy and wilful murder but Papua New Guinea has not carried out an execution since independence in 1954.

The nation’s parliament also repealed its 1971 Sorcery Act, which criminalises the practice of sorcery and recognises the accusation of sorcery as a defence in murder cases.

Any black magic killing will now be treated as murder punishable by death, following a spate of horrific public executions of women accused of witchcraft.

One was beheaded and another was burned alive while, in separate unrelated attacks, two foreigners were gang-raped, drawing international condemnation.

Though it criminalises the practice of sorcery — in which there is a widespread belief in PNG, where many people do not accept natural causes as an explanation for misfortune and death — the 1971 act had been criticised.

The United Nations and human rights groups said it led to an increase in false accusations by people against their enemies and gave the notion of sorcery a legitimacy it would not otherwise have had.

The PNG government received more than 100 petitions from human rights and other groups across the globe calling for urgent action on the spike in violence.

Under the new laws kidnapping and theft of 5-9.99 million kina (US$2.25-4.5 million) will have a 50-year jail term without parole, while kidnap for ransom or theft in excess of 10 million kina will carry a life sentence.

Source: AFP, May 28, 2013

Sunday, February 24, 2013

The big switch; 1 drug is dismantling the lethal injection protocol, shot by shot

The switch from sodium thiopenthal to pentobarbital in lethal injections is having larger consequences than state correction officials ever anticipated.

It is hard to imagine that Oklahoma Chief Medical Examiner Jay Chapman could have foreseen the storm now raging around the 3-drug lethal injection protocol he engineered in 1977. But recent moves by Oklahoma and most other death penalty states to change the 1st of the 3 drugs is giving death penalty opponents new leverage in attacking lethal injection - as is currently the case in Maryland - perhaps inching the death penalty closer to its demise.

Chapman and other medical professionals welcomed a revision of the protocol because of growing doubt surrounding the efficacy and availability of sodium thiopenthal, which is no longer manufactured in the U.S. What they didn't expect is that a slower acting and, many argue, less effective drug called pentobarbital would replace sodium thiopenthal, leaving the door open for lawyers to argue that death by lethal injection is "cruel and unusual punishment," banned by the U.S. Constitution.

Executioners are essentially "chemically burying someone alive and then injecting them with an extremely caustic chemical," says Dr. David Lubarsky, a professor of anesthesiology at the University of Miami whose 2005 study on lethal injection played a major role in the U.S. Supreme Court's 2008 decision allowing inmates to challenge the states over their protocols.

The 3-drug protocol, a series of three successive injections, has been the preferred execution method in the U.S. for years. It is responsible for about 1,100 deaths in 35 states since 1982. The 1st drug - then sodium thiopenthal, now pentobarbital - is designed to anesthetize inmates, so that they are unaware and pain-free. The 2nd is a muscle relaxant designed to paralyze. And the 3rd, potassium chloride, stops the heart, explains Dr. David Waisel, a professor of anaesthesiology at Harvard Medical School who recently testified in a 5-year-old class-action suit challenging Pennsylvania's lethal injection protocol.

But executioners are not trained medical professionals. And since the switch to pentobarbital, their lack of experience and medical know-how has had serious consequences. Executioners have not been waiting long enough for the 1st shot to take full effect before administering the next 2, says Lubarsky.

The problem is that pentobarbital is not an anesthetic - a drug that induces loss of consciousness - and has never been tested as such, according to Waisel. It is a sedative that doctors typically administer in small doses to calm patients during a procedure, while maintaining their awareness. In larger doses it can induce a coma, which can be useful in patients who are experiencing seizures because the drug allows the brain to rest before it starts functioning once more.

After the switch from sodium thiopenthal to pentobarbital it didn't take long for executioners to realize that pentobarbital takes much longer to take effect than its predecessor: 10 to 20 minutes, instead of 3 to 4 minutes, according to Miami's Lubarsky. So while the executioner might think the inmate is comatose, "the prisoner might just be sleepy," and capable of feeling the intense pain of the subsequent, heart-stopping injections, says Lubarsky.

Some doctors disagree with Lubarsky's assessment, however. During a court hearing in Alabama in March of 2012, Dr. Mark Dershwitz, anesthesiologist at the University of Massachusetts, noted that the dose of pentobarbital used in the state's protocol is "far in excess" of that used to induce and maintain a coma following a brain injury. So there is little risk that the inmate could feel pain during the subsequent injections.

But debating what a prisoner did or did not feel shortly before dying is no easy task. The only way to test lethal dosages is to test these sorts of drugs on animals, which is far from ideal given how different other species' body chemistry can be from ours. And animals aren't exactly known for giving us clear feedback about how much pain they are in. So when American veterinarians use pentobarbital to euthanize your pooch, they are required to first make sure the dog is either unconscious or deeply sedated before injecting a lethal dose into their body cavity. In fact, in the state of California, injecting a conscious animal with pentobarbital is a crime.

The 3-drug protocol was first employed in Texas in 1982, 5 years after it was initially developed. It was quickly adopted by other states because officials wanted to make executions easier for witnesses to watch - prisoners sometimes caught fire during electrocutions - and more humane.

"Everything went along fine for the first thousand executions in the U.S. They were all with the same 3 drugs and it had a long history," says Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, a Washington-based non-profit organization.

However, physicians in many death-penalty states, including Oklahoma's Chapman, eventually began pushing for a revision of the protocol. In part, they were worried about looming shortages of sodium thiopenthal. Hospira Inc., the drug's manufacturer, had planned to move manufacturing to Italy, but ended up stopping production altogether in 2011 because of the Italian government's opposition to capital punishment.

But there were also growing doubts about sodium thiopenthal's efficacy in knocking out inmates before executioners administered the other two, more painful drugs. A study by Lubarsky and his colleagues, for example, found that the concentration of sodium thiopenthal that the executioners were injecting in the inmates was actually lower than the concentration used in most surgical procedures. And in 43 % of the cases analyzed, the concentration used would have left the inmates aware of what was taking place. But because the 2nd drug is a paralyzing agent, the inmates were unable to communicate their pain once the final drug was administered.

Switching to pentobarbital was supposed to solve these problems. "The assumption was, we'll just substitute this drug in the same amount and it won't constitute a substantive change. But it is," because pentobarbital is a slower-acting drug, says Lubarsky.

Death penalty opponents are now taking advantage of pentobarbital's slowness to grind executions to a halt. To avoid these legal challenges, some states have decided to do away with the last 2 drugs, adopting a protocol consisting of a very large dose of pentobarbital instead. "The states said, look, we are not going to be administering any painful drugs, we are just going to be administering the [drug that's supposed to act as an] anesthetic," says Dieter, of the Death Penalty Information Center. "And in sufficient dosage to eventually cause death."

In the single injection procedure, pentobarbital puts the brain's electrical activity to sleep so the cells don't fire, Lubarsky explains. "You need your brain to fire to keep breathing." According to Lubarsky, when you inject an inmate with a very large dose of pentobarbital, the respiratory center of the brain stops responding, the diaphragm stops contracting and the inmate dies of asphyxiation.

Compared to the error-prone 3-drug injection, "It is probably a more humane way to end someone's life, if done correctly," he says.

But even this simpler protocol is not always carried out correctly. South Dakota recently executed inmate Eric Robert using a compounded version of pentobarbital, which is not FDA approved, because Akorn Inc., its most recent manufacturer, has been limiting prisons' access to the drug. Akorn Inc. decided to exert some control over how its drug would be used because of consumer backlash.

Compounded drugs are designed for patients who are allergic to certain ingredients in commercial medications. Small pharmacies acquire the necessary raw materials and make drugs to the recipient's requirements. "In this case, there is almost no regulation, no oversight, and minimal testing," says Harvard's Waisel, adding that this increases the risk that the drug's quality will be subpar.

And so, a fungus-contaminated drug made its way into a South Dakotan executioner's hands on Oct. 15, 2012. Robert reportedly opened his eyes during the execution, which, according to human rights group Reprieve, could be a sign that the contaminated drug did not properly anesthetize him.

Because getting commercial versions of pentobarbital is now almost as difficult to obtain as its predecessor, sodium thiopenthal, Pennsylvania is also planning to use compounded drugs during its executions. The state is getting them from the same pharmacy responsible for the recent meningitis outbreak that killed 33 Americans.

"We were confident in the efficiency and accuracy of the drugs and had them verified by a third party," says Susan Bensinger, deputy press secretary at the Pennsylvania State Department of Corrections. Declining to disclose the identity of the 3rd party, Bensinger says that the department views the use of compounded drugs as safe, adding "other states have used them as well."

But that is only one of the death penalty issues the state is now facing. During a recent federal lawsuit hearing challenging capital punishment in Pennsylvania, Harvard's Waisel noted that those who prepare the lethal injection drugs in Pennsylvania do not follow standard drug label guidelines that regulate the color of the drug's label and bottle cap to avoid mix-ups. Because the labels are the wrong color, there is a "high risk" that executioners may administer the drugs in the wrong order, he says. These recent blunders, combined with pentobarbital/s weaknesses, are now making some states consider alternatives, like propofol, a fast-acting hypnotic agent. But obtaining new execution drugs may be extremely difficult because drug companies want to be associated with saving lives, not taking them, says Maya Foa, head of Reprieve's Stop Lethal Injection Project.

Dieter, of the Death Penalty Information Center, agrees, and points out that there were just 43 executions in the U.S. last year - far too few to generate a high-volume profit for manufacturers. Pharmaceutical companies care about their image, which they carefully craft to give people confidence that their drugs will help them live longer, he says. Finding out that your prescription is also being filled by executioners is "like finding a rodent hair in a McDonald's hamburger - it just scares people," Dieter said.

So while lethal injection opponents probably don't envisage doing away with the death penalty through market shares and profit loss, it is possible they will one day hail "image" and "branding" as one of the tools that helped burst the execution bubble. And as public scrutiny intensifies, the drug switch's role in dismantling the death penalty will become more and more apparent, because, as Dieter sums it up, "the death penalty is really just 1 problem after another."

Source: Science Line, February 23, 2013

Sunday, February 17, 2013

Ohio debates ways to carry out executions

A low-key announcement that the state's prisons agency wants a law to protect pharmacies that might mix execution drugs underscores a high-profile problem: The state has enough of its current lethal drug to execute four inmates but has nine executions scheduled after that, including 1 announced Friday.

The request by the Department of Rehabilitation and Correction immediately raised the question of whether the state would have to move to another method of execution, such as the electric chair or hanging.

But the agency's chief attorney said such discussion is premature.

"That's 2 or 3 good long steps down the road before we come to that," DRC general counsel Gregory Trout said after Thursday's announcement. "I would suggest that pursuing alternate means of acquiring appropriate drugs to humanely cause an execution would be the 1st step."

Trout said legislation may be needed to protect compounding pharmacies, which custom-mix medications in doses that generally aren't commercially available, and without such a law the state might not be able to obtain execution drugs. He didn't say when the agency might request such legislation, and the prisons department isn't commenting.

The state's supply of pentobarbital, a powerful sedative, expires at the end of September.

Compounding pharmacies have been in the news recently following an outbreak of meningitis linked to the Framingham, Mass.-based New England Compounding Center, which has since closed. The outbreak has killed 45 people and sickened more than 600 nationwide, including 20 in Ohio.

Compounding pharmacies traditionally fill special orders placed by doctors for individual patients, turning out small numbers of customized formulas each week. They typically are overseen by state pharmacy boards.

Ohio law doesn't allow compounding pharmacies to mix drugs if they're commercially available.

In 2011, Denmark-based Lundbeck Inc., the only U.S.-licensed maker of pentobarbital, sold the product to another firm. Lundbeck said a distribution system meant to keep the drug out of the hands of prisons would remain in place after Lake Forest, Ill.-based Akorn Inc. acquired the drug.

Ohio law also requires compounding pharmacies to mix drugs in small supplies and says a "prescription shall be compounded and dispensed only pursuant to a specific order for an individual patient issued by a prescriber."

Ohio's prisons agency wouldn't be limited to compounding pharmacies in the state. But its request for a change to state law seemed to indicate it hoped to acquire the drug within the state.

Trout quietly laid out the agency's requests Thursday to members of a state Supreme Court task force considering changes to the death penalty law but not whether the state should have capital punishment.

Afterward, state Sen. Bill Seitz asked Trout about other options.

"Is there some Supreme Court case that says we can't if we choose go back to firing squad and hanging?" said Seitz, a Cincinnati Republican and criminal justice expert. "There's no shortage of rope."

Nothing would stop the state in such circumstances, and the firing squad has never been found unconstitutional, Trout said. But, he added, there are "certain public policy considerations."

Those likely refer to the prison system's willingness to consider a non-drug method, since one of the reasons the state abandoned the electric chair was out of consideration for the stress it would put on prison employees carrying out executions.

Seitz said Friday the prison agency's proposals would get a fair hearing in the Legislature, which is not inclined to abolish the death penalty.

Ohio is scheduled to use pentobarbital next month to execute Frederick Treesh, who was convicted of shooting an adult bookstore guard in 1994. Treesh, of Waterloo, Ind., had said he didn't intend to shoot anyone during the holdup.

The last execution using pentobarbital would be that of Harry Mitts, scheduled to die in September after being convicted of shooting two people, including a Garfield Heights police sergeant, in suburban Cleveland in 1994.

On Friday, the Supreme Court set a 2015 execution date for Robert Van Hook, who was convicted of killing a man he had met in a gay bar in 1985. Van Hook had argued the lawyers who represented him during the sentencing phase of his trial in the Cincinnati killing failed to do an effective job. It's unknown how he might be put to death.

Source: The Courier, Feb. 17, 2013