Showing posts with label J.P. Stevens. Show all posts
Showing posts with label J.P. Stevens. Show all posts

Friday, July 22, 2011

URGENT APPEAL for Manuel Valle, a Cuban national, due to be executed in Florida on 2 August

Manuel Valle, a Cuban national, is due to be executed in Florida on 2 August. He was convicted of the murder of a police officer in 1978. He was 27 years old when first sent to death row. He is now 61. He is being denied access to a meaningful clemency process.

On 2 April 1978, Officer Louis Peña of the Coral Gables Police Department in Miami, Florida, was shot dead after stopping Manuel Valle and Felix Ruiz in their car. Officer Gary Spell, who arrived at the scene separately, testified that Manuel Valle had shot Officer Peña and then fired two shots at Officer Spell. Manuel Valle was charged with murder and attempted murder. Felix Ruiz was charged as an accessory and sentenced to 10 years in prison.

Manuel Valle was sentenced to death in May 1978. In 1981, the Florida Supreme Court ruled that his lawyer had been prevented from adequately preparing a defense due to the speed with which the case had been brought to trial. At a new trial in 1981, Manuel Valle was again sentenced to death, but this sentence was overturned by the US Supreme Court in 1986. In 1988, a new jury voted by eight to four that Manual Valle be sentenced to death.

On 30 June 2011, Governor Rick Scott signed a death warrant in Manuel Valle's case setting his execution date. The warrant stated that executive clemency was not appropriate. The state has said that a clemency process has been held, but the only information on any such process found by Manuel Valle's current lawyers is a request made in 1992 by the then-Governor Lawton Chiles that a clemency investigation be conducted. Manuel Valle's lawyers have said that they can find no evidence of any clemency proceedings having been conducted, either in the 1990s or under the current governor. They have stated that "without notice, without the opportunity to be heard, without counsel, Mr. Valle's clemency proceedings, if any, did not comport with due process". If any such proceeding has been conducted, the lawyers have asserted, "It was conducted in complete secrecy without counsel"

The US Supreme Court has stated that executive clemency is the "fail-safe" in the criminal justice system, to provide the possibility for remedy or relief not provided by the judiciary. Under article 6.4 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, a treaty ratified by the USA in 1992, "anyone sentenced to death shall have the right to seek pardon or commutation of the sentence". Respect for this right can only be achieved through a meaningful, transparent process, with the participation of the prisoner and his or her counsel. No such process has been conducted here, in violation of the USA's international obligations.

PLEASE WRITE IMMEDIATELY in your own language:

- Acknowledge the seriousness of the crime for which Manuel Valle was sentenced to death and explaining that you are not seeking to downplay the suffering caused;

- Express concern that Manual Valle has not had access to a meaningful and transparent clemency procedure, as required under international law, and urge that this be rectified;

- Point to the cruelty of the death penalty, not least subjecting someone to 33 years on death row, and note that in that time, scores of countries have abolished the death penalty as they have come to recognize its risks, costs, ineffectiveness, and its incompatibility with fundamental human rights principles;

- Urge Governor Scott to prevent this execution and to ensure commutation of Manuel Valle's death sentence.

PLEASE SEND APPEALS AS SOON AS POSSIBLE, AND BEFORE 2 AUGUST 2011 TO:

Office of Governor Rick Scott, State of Florida, The Capitol, 400 S. Monroe St., Tallahassee, FL, 32399-0001, USA

Fax: 1 850 487-0801


Salutation: Dear Governor


URGENT ACTION

FLORIDA EXECUTION SET 33 YEARS AFTER CRIME ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Manuel Valle is a Cuban national. According to his current lawyers, he was not informed after his arrest in 1978 of his right to seek assistance from the Cuban authorities, as required under the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. Cuba ratified this treaty in 1965 and the USA ratified it four years later (see also http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/AMR51/063/2011/en).

Manuel Valle has been facing execution for 33 years, a torment deepened by the fact that during his time on death row more than 60 of his fellow inmates have been taken from their cells and killed by the State of Florida. The US Supreme Court has not ruled on whether prolonged confinement on death row violates the US Constitution, but individual Justices have raised concerns. In 1995, for example, Justice John Paul Stevens wrote that executing a prisoner who had been on death row for 17 years arguably negated any deterrent or retributive justification for the punishment, supposedly the two main purposes of the death penalty. In 2002, in the case of an inmate who had been on death row for more than 25 years, Justice Stephen Breyer stated that if executed, the prisoner would have been "punished both by death and also by more than a generation spent in death row's twilight. It is fairly asked whether such punishment is both unusual and cruel." Three years earlier, he had written that "It is difficult to deny the suffering inherent in a prolonged wait for execution - a matter which courts and individual judges have long recognized", and added that "death row conditions of special isolation may well aggravate that suffering." In 1996, a Florida Supreme Court judge noted that death row prisoners in Florida, as now, "are maintained in a six-by nine-foot cell with a ceiling nine and one-half feet high. These prisoners are taken to the exercise yard for two-hour intervals twice a week. Otherwise, these prisoners are in their cells except for medical reasons, legal or media interviews, or to see visitors¦. These facilities and procedures were not designed and should not be used to maintain prisoners for years and years."

The last execution in Florida was in February 2010. This would be the first execution under Governor Rick Scott, who took office in January 2011. Ordinary judicial appeals in Manuel Valle's case were completed in October 2007, opening the way for his execution to be scheduled. His lawyers are challenging the "arbitrary and standard-less power given to Florida's Governor to sign death warrants". A week before Governor Scott signed Manuel Valle's death warrant in June, he was criticized in the media for not having signed such a warrant during his first six months in office. In those months he had been contacted in writing by the murder victim's daughter in this case asking why Manuel Valle's death warrant had yet not been signed.

The UN Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions has said that "transparency is among the fundamental due process safeguards that prevent the arbitrary deprivation of life", and that "persons sentenced to death, their families, and their lawyers should be provided with timely and reliable information". Lawyers for Manuel Valle are arguing that he has been denied access to records to which he is entitled, including in relation to the state's lethal injection procedures and its acquisition of execution drugs. They are also challenging the legality of the execution procedures. In the past year, following the suspension and then ending of production by the sole US manufacturer of sodium thiopental, the anesthetic component of the three-drug mix used by most of the USA's death penalty jurisdictions, states have scrambled for alternatives (see USA: An embarrassment of hitches, http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/AMR51/058/2011/en). Some have turned to pentobarbital as a substitute, including Florida in June 2011. The Denmark-based manufacturer of pentobarbital has condemned use of its drug in executions, and has also questioned its efficacy for this purpose. On 1 July 2011, it announced that it would now use a "specialty pharmacy" program that would deny distribution of the drug to prisons in US states using lethal injection.

Amnesty International opposes the death penalty unconditionally. There have been 1,263 executions in the USA since judicial killing resumed there in 1977, including 29 this year. Sixty-six men and two women have been executed in Florida since 1977.

Source: AI, July 21, 2011

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Durbin: States should not impose death penalty

SPRINGFIELD, Ill. — States should not impose the death penalty because of the difficulty in administering it fairly, although the federal government should retain that authority in cases involving terrorism or treason that endanger many lives, U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin said.

Durbin told The (Springfield) State Journal-Register that he had always supported the death penalty, but has come to believe that "life in prison is penalty enough." He said that view was influenced partly by those of the late U.S. Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun and retired Justice John Paul Stevens.

"They both at the end of their careers came to the same conclusion: that after a lifetime of supporting the death penalty and trying to make it fair, that we had largely failed as a nation, and I cannot escape their wisdom on this issue," said Durbin, the second-ranking member in the Senate. "I really believe that on reflection, the burden is now on those supporting the death penalty to prove its fairness."

Although his comments come as Gov. Pat Quinn decides whether to sign a bill passed by the Illinois General Assembly that would end the death penalty in Illinois, Durbin said he is not trying to tell Quinn what he should do.

"I will not lobby him, because I think it's a matter of conscience," Durbin said.

Quinn supports the death penalty but has also kept in place the moratorium on capital punishment instituted in 2000 by former Gov. George Ryan, after the death sentences of 13 men were overturned and Ryan concluded the state's death penalty system wasn't working.

In some of those 13 cases, evidence showed the suspects were innocent. In others, the trials were deemed unfair or confessions were found to be coerced by abusive police. Since then, the number of overturned capital cases has risen to 20.

Prosecutors say significant reforms have been put in place since the moratorium was imposed, including more money and training for defense attorneys, videotaped interrogations and easier access to DNA evidence.

Source: Chicago Tribune, January 18, 2011
______________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Saturday, December 4, 2010

Stevens and Death Penalty - Letter to the Editor of The New York Times

To the Editor:

Re "Stevens Settles Legal Mystery in Frank Essay" (Supreme Court Memo, front page, Nov. 28):

When the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of lethal injection in April 2008, Justice John Paul Stevens announced that he had concluded that the death penalty violates the Eighth Amendment. Yet between then and the date Justice Stevens left the court in 2010, nearly 120 people were executed in the United States, virtually all of them with Justice Steven's acquiescence.

It is nice, now that he has retired, that Justice Stevens is amplifying his reasons for finding capital punishment unconstitutional. It would have been nicer if, when he still had the power, he had voted to stop the scores of executions he instead voted to allow.

David R. Dow -- Houston, Nov. 28, 2010

The writer, a death penalty lawyer, is a professor at the University of Houston Law Center.

Source: Letter to the Editor, New York Times, December 3, 2010 - David R. Dow is the University Distinguished Professor at the University of Houston Law Center. In March 2000, Dow founded the Texas Innocence Network, an organization that uses UH law students to investigate claims of actual innocence brought by Texas prisoners. He is also the litigation director at the Texas Defender Service, a nonprofit law firm that provides representation to death row inmates and works for reforms to the criminal justice system, especially on issues involving indigent defendants. Mr. Dow's Website can be found here.

Texas Defender Service: The 6 best arguments against the death penalty in Texas

Execution chamber
Huntsville Unit, Texas
The following guest blog post was written by Andrea Keilen, Executive Director of Texas Defender Service.

This week, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Stevens published an essay detailing the Court's decisions that created a system infected with problems, and one he now believes is unconstitutional. Since 1976, 138 people have been exonerated from death row nationwide.

12 of them were in Texas.

The fact that some mistakes were discovered in time and innocent people were exonerated strongly suggests that there have been other occasions when mistakes were not discovered in time and innocent people were executed.

Beginning Monday, December 6, at a hearing next week in a Harris County District Court, expert witnesses will testify about the numerous flaws that leave Texas' system riddled with errors, inherently unreliable, and unconstitutional as applied.

Attorneys for John Green, who is charged with capital murder, will urge the court to rule the Texas death penalty statute unconstitutional because it creates an unacceptable risk that innocent people have been, and will be, wrongfully convicted and executed.

When innocent people are exonerated, it is often a matter of dumb luck . For example, the real killer confesses or pro bono law firms take an interest in the case. It is rarely because the system catches errors and corrects itself.

Both Ernest Ray Willis and Cameron Todd Willingham were convicted of murder by arson and sentenced to death on the basis of junk fire science. Mr. Willingham is dead and Mr. Willis is alive -- and free -- because a pro bono law firm took Mr. Willis' case.

At the hearing, witnesses will testify about the following factors, which taken together, create an unacceptable risk of wrongful conviction in capital cases:

1st, Texas has no standards to ensure that eyewitness testimony is obtained in ways that protect against the risk of mistaken identification.

Texas does not follow the scientific research or best practices on eyewitness identification recommended by the U.S. Department of Justice, the International Association of Chiefs of Police, or the ABA. Nationwide, more than 75% of individuals exonerated by DNA evidence were convicted because of faulty eyewitness identifications .

2nd, Texas allows the introduction of confessions that have been obtained without safeguards to protect against false confessions. Texas law does not require recording interrogations . 25 % of the exonerations in the U.S. revealed through DNA testing involved a false confession .

3rd, use of informant testimony is largely unregulated in Texas.

Although in 2009 Texas began to require corroborating evidence for jailhouse informant testimony, that standard is loosely defined. Further, Texas has not implemented other important safeguards involving greater transparency and pretrial reliability screenings which more fully protect against false testimony. In one study, nearly 50% of wrongful murder convictions involved perjury by a jailhouse snitch or another witness who stood to gain from false testimony. (Professor Gross study, p. 39)

4th, pervasive flaws have been identified in the analysis of presentation of forensic evidence that result in unreliable results. In a study of DNA exonerations , the prosecution provided invalid forensic testimony in 60% of the cases, that is, testimony that misstated the data or was not supported by the data. (Garrett and Neufeld, p. 41) The National Academy of Sciences recently issued a broad critique of the nation's forensic system. The risk of wrongful conviction due to faulty forensic science at the is, standing alone, constitutionally intolerable.

5th, pretrial discovery procedures are inadequate to safeguard against the prosecution's suppression of evidence favorable to the accused.

A survey of published capital cases in Texas documented state misconduct in 41 capital convictions. (Texas Defender Service, p. 48)

6th, Texas prosecutors in Harris County and elsewhere have a shameful history of excluding African Americans from juries. Although this practice has been illegal for more than a century, recent research shows that discrimination in jury selection increases the risk of wrongful convictions by reducing the thoroughness and accuracy of jury deliberations.

Texas routinely fails to provide competent counsel and adequate defense funding in state habeas corpus proceedings. Extensive research, and a State Bar Task Force have all reached this conclusion. In almost 40% of state habeas cases, the petitions did not include any materials beyond the existing record, a clear indication of a lack of investigation.

The Texas clemency procedure lacks most elements of a sufficient clemency review and fails in its role as the last safeguard against executing the innocent. For example, Claude Jones was executed in 2000 based on false evidence. During the clemency review, then-Governor Bush was not informed that Mr. Jones had requested DNA testing that might have exonerated him. Ten years after Mr. Jones' execution, a DNA test showed that the hair sample at the crime scene was not his.

All 3 branches of Texas government have created entities to review issues in the criminal justice system based on the risk of error:

•In 2005, the Texas legislature created and Governor Rick Perry signed legislation creating the Texas Forensic Science Commission .

•By executive order, Governor Rick Perry created the Criminal Justice Advisory Council .

•In 2008, the highest criminal court in Texas, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, created a Criminal Justice Integrity Unit .

•In 2009, the legislature created and the governor approved the Timothy Cole Advisory Panel on Wrongful Convictions .

But virtually nothing has been done to reduce the most prevalent causes of wrongful convictions Innocent people can and do get sentenced to death in Texas. Action by the courts and legislature to address these serious problems is long overdue.

Source: Dallas Morning News, December 3, 2010

Sunday, November 28, 2010

Former Justice John Paul Stevens Criticizes Death Penalty

WASHINGTON — In 1976, just six months after he joined the Supreme Court, Justice John Paul Stevens voted to reinstate capital punishment after a four-year moratorium. With the right procedures, he wrote, it is possible to ensure “evenhanded, rational and consistent imposition of death sentences under law.”

In 2008, two years before he announced his retirement, Justice Stevens reversed course and in a concurrence said that he now believed the death penalty to be unconstitutional.

But the reason for that change of heart, after more than three decades on the court and some 1,100 executions, has in many ways remained a mystery, and now Justice Stevens has provided an explanation.

In a detailed, candid and critical essay to be published this week in The New York Review of Books, he wrote that personnel changes on the court, coupled with “regrettable judicial activism,” had created a system of capital punishment that is shot through with racism, skewed toward conviction, infected with politics and tinged with hysteria.


Source: The New York Times, November 28, 2010


Stevens' Powerful Anti-Death-Penalty Views

Former Justice John Paul Stevens (left), who retired from the Supreme Court in June after turning 90, has come out swinging in the past few days against the death penalty. In an appearance on 60 Minutes this past Sunday and a New York Review of Books essay that is now online, Justice Stevens makes the case that capital punishment as it is now administered in the U.S. is hopelessly flawed  and unconstitutional.

In so doing, he is pushing the death-penalty debate just where it needs to go. Supporters and opponents generally argue over whether capital punishment is right in the abstract. The discussion often comes off as little more than late-night dorm-room philosophizing: "Killing is killing, even if the state does it," or "Are you saying that if the allies caught Hitler, they shouldn't have executed him?"

Yet as Justice Stevens frames the question, it isn't whether you believe in a death penalty, it's whether you believe in this death penalty, the one the U.S. is currently using. It is a more relevant issue for those who care if the justice system is doing the right thing, and he makes a compelling case that none of us should.

Justice Stevens, who was appointed by a Republican President, Gerald Ford, has not always opposed capital punishment. In 1976, shortly after he joined the court, he provided a key vote in Gregg v. Georgia, one of a group of cases that ended a de facto death-penalty moratorium that had been in place since 1972. He did not join the most liberal Justices at the time, William Brennan and Thurgood Marshall, who insisted that any executions violated the Eighth Amendment ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

In 2008, Justice Stevens famously changed his mind. In a case challenging Kentucky's method of lethal injection, he said in a separate opinion that the court's decision in 1976 that capital punishment is constitutional was based on a belief that it would be applied in a way that would not be discriminatory, arbitrary, excessive or racially discriminatory. After three decades on the court, it had become clear to him that those conditions were not being met.

In his New York Review of Books essay, Justice Stevens gives a fuller explanation of what made him turn away from the death penalty. As he saw it, the 1976 ruling argued for a careful and narrow use of capital punishment, but since then, the Supreme Court has made its use increasingly less careful and less narrow.

One factor that has Justice Stevens and many other people questioning the death penalty is its unreliability. As Justice Stevens points out, more than 130 people have been exonerated and released from death row since 1973, a number of them based on DNA evidence.

Another chief concern is race. In 1987, a challenge was brought to the death penalty that showed it was being used in a highly disparate way: in Georgia, murderers who killed white people were 11 times more likely to get capital punishment than those with black victims. Justice Stevens, who dissented from that ruling, writes in his essay that the far greater punishment the system imposes for the killing of whites "provides a haunting reminder of once prevalent Southern lynchings."

Justice Stevens is also troubled by the way key procedural rules have been rewritten to make it easier to put people to death. One change involves so-called death-qualified juries -- that is, juries that don't include people who oppose the death penalty. In 1968, the Supreme Court ruled that opposition to the death penalty is not a valid reason to exclude someone from a jury. If you allow jurors to be excluded on this basis, you end up with juries that are much more pro-prosecution, and pro-death penalty, than society as a whole. But three years ago, a bitterly divided Supreme Court undid that ruling -- and cleared the way for death-qualified juries.

Another change is in the use of victim-impact statements. In 1987, the Supreme Court ruled that having a jury hear the often emotionally wrenching stories of victims could unfairly inflame jurors and was inconsistent with the "reasoned decisionmaking we require in capital cases." 4 years later, after turnover among the Justices, the court reversed itself - over Justice Stevens' dissent - and ruled that these statements can be used.

Justice Stevens' critique of death-penalty law is exactly right. It is also badly needed, as the current court is becoming ever more enthusiastic about capital punishment and ever more indifferent to important details -- like how certain we are that the person facing execution is even guilty.

Last year, Justice Antonin Scalia wrapped that indifference in constitutional theory, strongly suggesting in a dissent in a Georgia death-penalty case that there is nothing unconstitutional about executing someone who turns out to be actually innocent, so long as they had a proper trial and appeals process.

A great deal of death-penalty arguments, both pro and con, fall on deaf ears. If you oppose the death penalty as morally wrong, you are not likely to be impressed by reasoned (if flawed) arguments -- that it might deter crime, for example, or that it has long had a central place in western civilization. If you believe in capital punishment, you are unlikely to be moved by someone who simply says the state has no right to take a life.

Justice Stevens' arguments are powerful precisely because they come from someone in the middle of the debate -- a man who long believed capital punishment was constitutional provided it was properly applied. His sharp critique should reinforce the resolve of those who do not support the death penalty and raise unsettling questions for those who do.

Source: TIME Magazine; Adam Cohen, a lawyer, is a former TIME writer and a former member of the New York Times editorial board. Case Study, his legal column for TIME.com, appears every Wednesday, December 1, 2010

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Supreme Court Rejects Hundreds of Appeals

On 1st Day of New Term Justices Refuse Cases on Warrantless Wiretaps, Religious Songs in School, and Who Owns "SC"

The 1st Monday in October brought a flurry of decisions by the Supreme Court, most of which were refusals to consider cases.

The High Court announced this morning that it has turned down hundreds of appeals, in matters ranging from warrantless wiretapping and the remains of 9/11 victims in landfills, to death penalty cases, the performance of religious songs in schools, and whether the University of South Carolina or the University of Southern California can claim trademark on the initials "SC."

Today marked the 1st day of the Supereme Court's new term, with Justice Elena Kagan on the bench. Kagan replaced Justice John Paul Stevens, who retired after more than 34 years. For the 1st time 3 women are serving on the 9-justice court.

The Court said today it wants to what the Obama administration thinks before deciding whether to hear an appeal from former detainees at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq over claims of abuse by defense contractors.

The justices on Monday called on acting Solicitor General Neal Katyal to offer his views on whether t2firms, CACI International Inc. and Titan Corp., can be sued over alleged abuses by interrogators they employed at the notorious Baghdad prison.

A divided federal appeals court in Washington dismissed the lawsuits filed by Iraqis who said they or their relatives were subjected to harsh interrogations.

The court imposed no deadline on the administration.

Among the cases rejected today by the justices:

• An appeal by Georgia death row inmate Jamie Ryan Weis, who was convicted of killing a 73-year-old woman. Weis said he went without a lawyer from Georgia's public defender program for 2 years because the state couldn't pay his legal bills. (Weis v. Georgia, 09-10715).

• Another appeal from a Fort Hood Army private, Dwight J. Loving, who was convicted in military court and sentenced to death for killing 2 Texas taxi drivers during separate robberies on Dec. 11, 1988 in Killeen, Texas. His death sentence was upheld by appeals courts and by the Supreme Court in 1996. (Loving v. United States, 09-989)

Source: USA Today, October 5, 2010

Monday, October 4, 2010

John Paul Stevens's One Regret: Upholding The Death Penalty

Over an almost 35 year Supreme Court career, now retired Justice John Paul Stevens said recently that the lone vote he regrets is one that he cast to restore the death penalty in 1976.

Less than a year into his Supreme Court judgeship, Stevens sided with the majority decision in Gregg v. Georgia a case that served to overrule a temporary stay in capital punishment enacted by Furman v. Georgia in 1972.

3 1/2 decades later, Stevens spoke with NPR about that particular vote and the misgivings he had about his opinion in the case.

"I thought at the time ... that if the universe of defendants eligible for the death penalty is sufficiently narrow so that you can be confident that the defendant really merits that severe punishment, that the death penalty was appropriate," he says. But, over the years, "the court constantly expanded the cases eligible for the death penalty, so that the underlying premise for my vote has disappeared, in a sense." According to NPR, Stevens described the bending of the court toward capital punishment as a function of an increasing number of "hard-line conservative justices" who broadened the applicability of the death penalty.

"Not only is it a larger universe, but the procedures have become more prosecution-friendly," Stevens told NPR.

Practices such as allowing prosecutors to screen jurors who could potentially be opposed to giving the death penalty, as well as the approval of emotionally-charged testimony from the families of victims during the sentencing phase of trials have all "load[ed] the dice in favor of the prosecution and against the defendant," Stevens told NPR.

Though Stevens did also vote with the majority in Baze v. Reese, a Kentucky decision that upheld the death penalty by lethal injection in 2008, he called his vote in Gregg "the one vote I would change." According to NPR, Stevens described his vote as "incorrect," and claimed the 1976 court "did not foresee how it would be interpreted."

"I really think that the death penalty today is vastly different from the death penalty that we thought we were authorizing," Stevens said. "And I think if the procedures had been followed that we expected to be in place, I think I probably would've still had the same views."

Source: Huffington Post, October 4, 2010

Busy agenda faces reconfigured US Supreme Court

The US Supreme Court returns to work Monday, completed by 2 judges appointed by President Barack Obama, facing a busy docket crammed with issues such as the death penalty and freedom of expression.

But despite Obama's new appointments -- Sonia Sotomayor who joined the bench at the start of the 2009 session and Elena Kagan who ceremonially took her seat for the 1st time on Friday -- the make-up of the nation's highest court is for many experts one of the most conservative ever.

The court, whose 9 justice are appointed for life, rules on the most pressing moral and social issues facing the United States.

And Kagan's arrival is unlikely to alter the delicate balance of the court, currently divided between four liberal judges, four conservatives and Anthony Kennedy, named by Republican president Ronald Reagan in 1988, who votes with either side.

"3 of the most conservative justices in history are in the Court today," said Susan Bloch, a professor at Georgetown University.

There were already some shock decisions in the last session: the lifting of complex finance laws to allow businesses to make unlimited electoral campaign donations; banning any moves to prohibit guns and overturning some of the legal arsenal used to fight corruption.

And there will be some thorny issues once again before the courts in the coming months.

There will be the case brought by Albert Snyder, incensed that anti-gay groups were allowed to demonstrate at the funeral of his son, Matthew, a lance corporal killed in Iraq in 2006.

Matthew was not gay, but members of the Westboro Baptist Church used the occasion to push their message against homosexuality.

Snyder is now taking his lawsuit claiming emotional distress to the top bench, after an appeals court ruled the group had the right to protest under the First Amendment guaranteeing freedom of expression.

Also in the court's docket is a case brought by California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger calling for violent video games to be banned.

And the death penalty -- a staple issue before the court -- will also be reexamined in the case of convicted murderer Henry Skinner who says DNA tests would prove his innocence.

Last year, in a highly unusual reversal the Supreme Court ordered a new hearing into potentially exonerating evidence for high-profile death row inmate Troy Davis.

A controversial law adopted in Arizona on employing illegal immigrants will also go before the 9 justices, along with questions on whether victims have the right to claim damages and compensation from pharmaceutical companies.

This year's panel will meet for the first time in 35 years without John Paul Stevens who retired earlier this year when he reached the age of 90.

Though he was appointed by Republican president Gerald Ford, Stevens became one of the most charismatic, liberal figures on the bench during his long tenure.

But even if some of Stevens's "views changed with time," this did not counter the fact that "the Court moved to the right," Bloch said.

Now Stephen Breyer, appointed by president Bill Clinton in 1994, is generally viewed as the leader of the liberal wing of the bench.

"I am dissenting more now than I was, say, 5 years ago -- a lot more," he told The New Yorker recently, referring to two Bush-era appointments which turned the court further to the right.

One factor though may stymie progress on a number of cases -- Kagan served as Obama's solicitor general before her appointment and as such prepared the government's position on a number of the cases before the court this session.

She has recused herself from 21 of the 39 cases set to be heard this fall, opening the possibility of a split four-to-four tied decision. In such cases, the previous ruling by the appeals court will stand.

"Unlike most terms, this term may end with more uncertainty about where the Court stands on a number of important questions depending on the impact on Justice Kagan's reclusals," said Steven Shapiro, legal director of the civil rights group, the ACLU, said.

Source: Agence France-Presse, October 4, 2010

Thursday, August 5, 2010

Elena Kagan confirmed to the Supreme Court

Washington (CNN) -- Elena Kagan was confirmed as the 112th justice to the Supreme Court Thursday and could be sworn into her judicial post by week's end.

The vote on the Senate floor was 63-37.

Five Republicans in the Senate had signaled their intention to vote for Kagan, meaning conservatives didn't have the strength in numbers to delay the proceedings with a filibuster.

Only one Democrat announced his opposition: Sen. Ben Nelson of Nebraska.

"I have heard concerns from Nebraskans regarding Ms. Kagan, and her lack of a judicial record makes it difficult for me to discount the concerns raised by Nebraskans, or to reach a level of comfort that these concerns are unfounded," he said in a statement.

Kagan will become only the fourth woman ever to sit on the prestigious bench.

The New York native and former Harvard Law School dean will replace the retiring Justice John Paul Stevens.

She was picked by President Obama on May 10, and the Judiciary Committee sent her nomination to the floor last month.

Source: CNN.com, August 5, 2010

Sunday, June 27, 2010

Stevens leaving legacy of judicial care: "Innocence Matters"

As Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens approaches retirement, observers are beginning to assess the legacy of his almost 35 years on the bench.

One issue with which Justice Stevens may be closely associated is the death penalty. In 1976, he voted with the majority to reinstate the death penalty, ending a four-year period during which capital punishment resided in constitutional limbo.

Justice Stevens’ views of the death penalty and public opinion about it have evolved since 1976. In a 2007 case upholding the constitutionality of lethal injection procedures, Justice Stevens, while feeling compelled as a matter of precedent to vote with the majority, nonetheless expressed grave doubts about the death penalty, calling it “anachronistic.”

But one of Justice Stevens’ last acts involving the death penalty could be the most meaningful.

Last August, the Supreme Court considered the case of Troy Davis (pictured). Davis, who is on death row in Georgia for the 1989 murder of Savannah police Officer Mark MacPhail, was convicted solely on the basis of eyewitness testimony. Most of those witnesses have now recanted their trial testimony, some alleging that police coerced their original statements, and several new witnesses have come forward to implicate another suspect.

In ordering a federal court to hold a hearing on this new evidence, Justice Stevens stated: “The substantial risk of putting an innocent man to death clearly provides an adequate justification for holding an evidentiary hearing.”

He explained that Davis’ innocence claim constituted “exceptional circumstances” requiring the court use its rarely-invoked original habeas corpus jurisdiction.

Justice Stevens’ leadership in this case was a triumph of the common-sense notion that innocence matters; it matters more than procedural technicalities. No matter whether one opposes or supports the death penalty, I would hope we can at least agree that the innocent should not be executed.

The hearing the Supreme Court ordered will take place Wednesday in Savannah. Finally, a court will consider the weight of the new evidence. Prior to the Supreme Court decision, state and federal appeals courts relied on procedural grounds for refusing to hold evidentiary hearings.

I served on the Georgia Supreme Court when the Davis case came up on direct appeal in 1993. We upheld the conviction.

But that was before most of the witnesses had recanted their trial testimony. I was no longer a member of the court when it rejected, by a 4-3 vote, Davis’ extraordinary motion for a new trial in March 2008.

The court did not order an evidentiary hearing. If I had been on that court, the vote might have been 4-3 the other way.

It is by such razor-thin margins that we determine who lives and who dies.

Thanks to Justice Stevens, the hearing other courts failed to hold will finally take place.

Yet the granting of an evidentiary hearing to examine innocence claims is no guarantee those claims will be accepted.

This is not a new trial, where the defendant is presumed innocent. This is only a hearing, where Davis will be required to “clearly establish” his innocence — a very difficult standard to meet.

No matter the outcome of this case, Davis stands for the principle that the factual innocence or guilt of people sentenced to death matters. For those facing the irreversible punishment of death, we should always do our best to get to the truth.

Never should procedural rules trump the consideration of newly discovered exculpatory evidence.

Justice Stevens has clearly endorsed this principle, reminding us that compelling innocence claims should be treated with exceptional care, especially in death penalty cases. And that is an admirable legacy for any judge.

Norman S. Fletcher was a justice on the Georgia Supreme Court from 1989 through 2005, serving as chief justice from 2001 to 2005. He currently serves as a member of the Constitution Project’s Right to Counsel Committee.

Source: Opinion by Norman S. Fletcher, Atlanta Journal-Constitution, June 21, 2010. Judge Fletcher was a justice on the Georgia Supreme Court from 1989 through 2005, serving as chief justice from 2001 to 2005. He now serves on the Constitution Project's Right to Counsel Committee.

Tuesday, June 22, 2010

New Troy Davis hearing this week

Troy Anthony Davis returns this week to Savannah, where he was convicted and sentenced to death almost 2 decades ago for killing an off-duty police officer during a late-night melee in a Burger King parking lot.

For more than a decade, Davis has sought to present his claims of innocence, including the recantations of 7 key prosecution witnesses, in court. On Wednesday, in U.S. District Court in Savannah, thanks to an extraordinary ruling last year by the nation's highest court, he will finally get that chance.

Davis' innocence claims have attracted international attention, including calls from former President Jimmy Carter and Pope Benedict XVI that he be spared from execution. Last August, for the 1st time in nearly half a century, and the 1st time ever in a death-penalty case, the U.S. Supreme Court took a case filed directly to its docket. It accepted Davis' last-ditch plea because Davis had exhausted all his appeals.

The high court ordered a federal judge to convene a hearing and take evidence to determine whether Davis' new claims "clearly establish" his innocence -- a high legal threshold to overcome.

Justice John Paul Stevens noted that no state or federal court had heard the new testimony and assessed its reliability. "The substantial risk of putting an innocent man to death clearly provides an adequate justification for holding an evidentiary hearing," wrote Stevens, who was joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer.

Justice Antonin Scalia, joined by Justice Clarence Thomas, dissented, calling the hearing a "fool's errand" because Davis' innocence claim is "a sure loser."

Davis lost 2 prior challenges to his conviction and death sentence by razor-thin margins. In 2008, the Georgia Supreme Court rejected Davis' bid by a 4-3 vote and, a year later, the federal appeals court in Atlanta denied his appeal by a 2-1 vote.

In recent years, Davis' scheduled execution has been halted 3 times shortly before it was to be carried out -- on one occasion just 2 hours before he was to be put to death by lethal injection.

U.S. District Judge William T. Moore Jr., who will hear the case, is not expected to make an immediate ruling. He has instructed parties that he wants them to file legal briefs after the hearing is over. He also told the lawyers that because he has already read the trial record and the legal pleadings in the case, he expects them to come to his courtroom and "immediately" enter into the presentation of evidence.

"Certainly, Mr. Davis and his attorneys have a very difficult burden ahead of them," said Howard Bashman, a Philadelphia attorney who operates a Web site devoted entirely to appellate litigation. "They have to show far more than there are serious doubts over the validity of the conviction. They have to show that the new evidence clearly establishes Mr. Davis' innocence."

Davis sits on death row for the Aug. 19, 1989, killing of Officer Mark Allen MacPhail. MacPhail was gunned down after he ran to the fast-food restaurant parking lot after hearing pleas from a homeless man who was being pistol-whipped. MacPhail, 27, was shot multiple times before he was able to unholster his weapon.

Source: Atlanta Journal-Constitution, JUne 21, 2010

Thursday, May 6, 2010

Stevens: Risk of wrongful sentences higher

Modern pressures on the judicial system have raised the chance a defendant could be wrongly sentenced to death, Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens (pictured) said Wednesday, explaining his changed view on the constitutionality of capital punishment.

"The risk of an incorrect decision has increased," he told an audience of hundreds of lawyers and judges at a judicial conference here, responding to a question about his 2008 assertion that the death penalty should be abolished. He said that because of advances in DNA testing, which have led to the freeing of some innocent convicts, "we're more aware of the risk than we might have been before."

In a lethal-injection dispute from Kentucky two years ago, Stevens concluded for the first time that "the death penalty represents the pointless and needless extinction of life with only marginal contributions" to society.

Stevens, who will retire this summer after nearly 35 years on the bench, offered both substantive views and lighthearted thoughts (why the bow ties?). He recalled an unpopular decision he wrote while he was a lower court judge that led him to believe he could "kiss goodbye" any chance of ever becoming a Supreme Court justice.

Stevens said capital juries are dominated by people who favor the death penalty, alluding in part to the Supreme Court's 1986 decision that allowed prosecutors to exclude from capital cases jurors who say they would be reluctant to vote for a death sentence. Stevens said the brutality of the murders that often lead to a capital trial can put pressure on prosecutors.

"The dynamics of the litigation," Stevens said, raises the risk of "incorrect decisions" regarding who should be sentenced to die.

Stevens, 90, was elevated from a Chicago-based federal appeals court when President Gerald Ford appointed him in 1975. He recalled that he dissented in 1971 when the appeals court upheld a Wisconsin State Assembly sanction of civil rights leader and anti-war activist Father James Groppi for disorderly conduct on the floor of the Legislature.

"I remember thinking: I have life tenure," Stevens recalled, expressing some relief that he would face no political repercussions for a view unpopular in its day. "I also thought I could kiss goodbye the idea of ever going on the Supreme Court."

That, of course, turned out to be wrong.

Stevens mused that when he went before the Senate Judiciary Committee for his confirmation hearing, no senators asked about Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision that made abortion legal nationwide. It would be a few more years before that ruling generated an anti-abortion movement and the issue became a staple of Supreme Court confirmation hearings.

Stanford University law professor Jeffrey Fisher, a former Stevens law clerk who questioned him Wednesday, asked how he might feel on the first Monday in October, when his colleagues take the bench without him.

"I really don't know," Stevens said softly. He said his worry these days is cases yet to be resolved this term. "We're a little behind in some of our output."

Teresa Wynn Roseborough, another ex-Stevens clerk and senior chief counsel for Metropolitan Life Insurance, asked about his signature neckwear: Why bow ties?

"The truth is I can't tie a 4 in hand," Stevens said of the knot on the more commonly worn tie.

Source: USA Today, May 6, 2010