Showing posts with label Virginia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Virginia. Show all posts

Monday, March 17, 2014

USA - Torture on Death Row: Court Rules Against Automatic Use of Solitary Confinement for the Condemned

The Supreme Court has ruled that the death penalty itself does not constitute "cruel and unusual punishment." Yet the treatment of the condemned is nonetheless subject to Eighth Amendment protections, as well as Fourteenth Amendment guarantees of due process.

In the past few years, this ironic legal reality has been the subject of a renewed national debate centering on execution methods. The European drug companies that U.S. states have historically relied on to provide the materials for lethal injections have refused to replenish supplies. As a result, states have developed new drug protocols, often implementing them without testing or research. Last month, Dennis McGuire struggled and gasped for well over ten minutes before he finally died.

But at a recent Senate Judiciary Subcommittee hearing, exoneree Damon Thibodeaux called attention to a different, rarely-discussed aspect of death row that he believes also constitutes "torture, pure and simple" -- the conditions of confinement that people endure prior to execution:

"I spent my years at Angola, while my lawyers fought to prove my innocence, in a cell that measured about 8 feet by 10 feet. It had three solid walls all painted white, a cell door, a sink, a toilet, a desk and seat attached to a wall, and an iron bunk with a thin mattress. These 4 walls are your life. Being in that environment for 23 hours a day will slowly kill you. Mentally, you have to find some way to live as if you were not there. If you cannot do that, you will die a slow mental death and may actually wish for your physical death, so that you do not have to continue that existence. More than anything, solitary confinement is an existence without hope."

Thibodeaux was exonerated after spending fifteen years on death row at Angola State Penitentiary in Louisiana. While his story may be unusual, his experience of extreme isolation is standard for people facing execution.

A recent ruling, however, suggests that the federal courts may soon mandate higher due process protections for individuals sentenced to death. Last November, U.S. District Court Judge Leonie Brinkema found in Prieto v. Clark that the state of Virginia had violated the Constitution by automatically placing individuals on death row in indefinite isolation. In January, she rejected a request from state attorneys to delay the implementation of her ruling.

In her determination, Judge Brinkema describes what people on death row in Virginia must bear from the time of their sentencing to the time of their execution:

"Plaintiff's conditions of confinement on death row are undeniably extreme and atypical of conditions in the general population units at [the prison]. He must remain alone in his cell for nearly 23 hours per day... The lights never go out in his cell, although they are scaled back during the overnight hours... Plaintiff is allowed just 5 hours of outdoor recreation per week...and that time is spent in another cell at best slightly larger than his living quarters... He otherwise has no ability to catch a glimpse of the sky because the window in his cell is a window in name only... Nor can he pass the time in the company of other inmates; plaintiff is deprived of most forms of human contact... His only real break from the monotony owes to a television and compact disc player in his cell and limited interactions with prison officials..."

As the judge outlines, those on death row are automatically and permanently placed in solitary confinement - forced to withstand particularly severe conditions purely as a consequence of their sentence. This placement is functionally indefinite since it can take years, or even decades, before individuals exhaust their appeals and finally face execution. (According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, those executed in 2010 had spent an average of 14.8 years on death row). By contrast, all others incarcerated in Virginia are assigned an initial security classification based on 8 factors, including several unrelated to their sentences: their history of institutional violence, escape history, current age, etc.

The Court's finding in Prieto v. Clark is that the automatic placement of death row prisoners in solitary confinement violates their Fourteenth Amendment rights, since they endure "uniquely severe" conditions without any kind of procedural protections or stopgap measures.

Judge Brinkeama concludes that the Virginia prison authorities have 2 options: either providing an individualized classification procedure for each person sentenced to execution, or altering conditions on death row "such that confinement there would no longer impose an atypical and significant hardship."

The court's ruling comes several months after the publication of an American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) report that examined the conditions of confinement endured by those on death row. As the ACLU notes, this extreme isolation constitutes a "punishment on top of punishment":

--Cell size: Most common cell size is 8x10 feet (27% of prisoners), just a bit bigger than the size on an average bathroom.

--Basic comfort: Beds provide in death row cells are made out of: Steel 60%; Concrete 13%; Steel with mattress 9%; Concrete with pad 6%; Metal 6%.

--"Enforced idleness": States that allow death inmates to exercise for 1 hour or less: 81%.

--Social isolation: States with mandated no-contact visits for death row inmates: 67%.

--Religious services: States that fail to offer religious services to death row prisoners: 62%.

At the Senate hearing on solitary confinement last month, Thibodeaux told the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee that he had contemplated ending the appeals process - despite his innocence - in order to escape his extreme isolation:

"Fairly early during my confinement at Angola, I very seriously considered giving up my legal rights and letting the State execute me. I was at the point where I did not want to live like an animal in a cage for years on end, only to lose my case and then have the State kill me anyway. I thought it would be better to end my life as soon as I could and avoid the agony of life in solitary. Fortunately, my lawyer and friend, Denise LeBoeuf, convinced me that I would be exonerated and released someday, and she gave me hope to keep fighting and living."

According to the NAACP's most recent quarterly report on the death penalty, published last week, since the death penalty was reinstated 140 individuals - about 10% of those placed on death row - were executed after giving up their appeals. (See the Death Penalty Information Center for a complete list of these individuals and more comprehensive information about "volunteers.")

Judge Brinkema's ruling is significant since it accords at least minimal due process protections to those placed in solitary confinement, even the so-called "worst of the worst." But calls to change the blanket use of isolation on death row have also emerged from outside the courts and the Senate subcommittee hearing. Last month, Texas's largest correctional officers' union called for low-risk individuals on death row to be housed with others, and recommended that state prison officials introduce privileges to those on death row, including work assignments and streaming television.

Source: Solitary Watch, March 16, 2014

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Pharma firms must put in place execution drug controls as US states push ahead with new ‘cocktail’

Two pharmaceutical companies, one of which describes itself as “one of the biggest…in the UK,” are facing urgent calls to put in place new controls on drugs which could be used in executions.

Akorn, headquartered in Illinois, produces midazolam, a sedative which is currently being used by Florida and Ohio to carry out lethal injections.

Teva, a global company which “suppl[ies] more packs of medicines to the NHS than anyone else,” produces two paralytic agents – rocuronium bromide and vecuronium bromide – which are used by Virginia and Florida respectively as part of their three-drug execution ‘cocktails.’

Although it is not certain that any US state has yet procured the relevant drugs from either of the companies, both have so far failed to put in place distribution controls which would prevent this from happening. This failure stands in contrast to the other US manufacturers of the drugs in question, which have taken simple and effective steps to prevent their medicines being used to fuel executions.

Florida is today [Wednesday] due to carry out its fifth execution using midazolam as part of a three-drug cocktail that was first used on William Happ in October last year; Happ reportedly took twice as long to die as is normal.

Problems with the previously-untested lethal injection drug have been widespread – when Ohio first used midazolam as part of a two-drug combination in January, eyewitnesses reported that the prisoner took nearly half an hour to die.

Just last week, Virginia joined Florida and Ohio, announcing that it too would make midazolam one of the drugs available for use in executions.

Legal charity Reprieve has raised with both Akorn and Teva the need for them to move urgently to put in place effective controls in order to ensure they do not become involved in the death penalty process, but has yet to receive a satisfactory response.

Teva has previously acted to put in place controls on an anaesthetic, propofol, after it emerged that executioners were planning to use it to kill, but has yet to take the same positive action on the two paralysing agents.

Maya Foa, Director of Reprieve’s Death Penalty team said: “Executioners are increasingly turning to these new drugs in order to kill. If Akorn and Teva fail to take swift, decisive action, they face the very real threat of becoming the go-to suppliers of execution drugs across the USA. If Teva and Akorn wish to preserve their reputation as responsible pharmaceutical companies, they must ensure their drugs can only be used to save lives, not end them in executions.”

Source: Reprieve, Feb. 26, 2014

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

U.S. Supreme Court won't block Justin Wolfe's capital murder retrial

WASHINGTON (AP) - The Supreme Court will not block Virginia from retrying an accused drug dealer, whose earlier capital murder conviction was set aside because of misconduct by prosecutors.

The justices on Monday rejected an appeal by Justin Wolfe, who said the prosecutors' misdeeds were so serious that they precluded a fair second trial.

A federal judge agreed with Wolfe and had ordered his immediate release, but the federal appeals court in Richmond, Va., said the new trial could be held fairly.

Wolfe was sent to death row in 2002 for a drug-related murder, but his original conviction and sentence were overturned.

Source: AP, Feb. 24, 2014

Sunday, February 23, 2014

The last breaths of America's machinery of death

When the history of the long, slow decline of capital punishment in America is written, a footnote must be reserved for the Apothecary Shoppe of Tulsa, Oklahoma. Do not be deceived by the name. Quaint and cosy it may sound, but until this month the company was the unofficial supplier of the drug used in executions by neighbouring Missouri.

The arrangement resembled something out of The French Connection rather than preparation for the ultimate punishment that the state can mete out to one of its citizens. An official from Missouri's Department of Corrections (by such euphemisms are prison services known in the US) would secretly travel to Tulsa. There he would pay $11,000 in cash for a specially commissioned version of pentobarbital, a powerful barbiturate. The official would then carry the stuff by hand back across the state line to Missouri, to be injected into the condemned man.

Three times this happened last year – and the same thing was to have happened for this Wednesday's scheduled execution of Michael Taylor, convicted of raping and murdering a schoolgirl in 1989 while under the influence of crack cocaine. But on 10 February, the Missouri legislature held a hearing on the state's execution protocol, and the department's shifty little drug-running operation with Tulsa became public.

Taylor's lawyers, who since 2006 has been fighting the death sentence on the grounds that lethal injection violated the US constitution's ban on "cruel and unusual punishment", brought a new action against the Apothecary Shoppe, claiming it was not certified to do business in Missouri. The company thereupon announced it would not supply the drug for the execution after all.


Source: The Independent, Feb. 23, 2014

Friday, February 21, 2014

Virginia lethal injection drug same as one in Ohio suit

The Virginia Department of Corrections said Thursday that it has approved the sedative midazolam as an alternative first drug in the state's three-drug execution protocol. Midazolam was one of two drugs used in last month's execution of an Ohio inmate who made snorting and gasping sounds and took an unusually long 26 minutes to die. His family is suing Ohio.

Illinois-based Hospira Inc., which manufactures midazolam, opposes its use for capital punishment but has been unable to stop state prison systems from obtaining it from suppliers.

The development comes as many death penalty states are grappling with a shortage of drugs that can be used in executions. Many of the drugs are manufactured in European countries that have prohibited their export for use in capital punishment.

Virginia lawmakers are considering legislation that would allow the state to use the electric chair in executions if lethal injection drugs are not available when an inmate's execution date arrives. Under current law, death row inmates can choose either the electric chair or lethal injection. If they decline to choose, they get the injection.

Source: AP, Feb. 21, 2014

Friday, February 7, 2014

Controversial Death Penalty Bill Killed in Virginia Senate

RICHMOND, Va (WVIR) - Lawmakers in the state legislature have killed a controversial death penalty bill - at least until next year.

Due to a nationwide shortage of lethal injection drugs, the bill filed in the state Senate proposed using electrocution as Virginia’s secondary means of execution. The bill was met with fierce opposition by some who view electrocution as archaic, but sponsor Bill Carrico says it's about justice.

“What about the victims and their families? What about the cruel and unusual punishment that took place there? Does anybody even think about that?” said 40th District Senator Bill Carrico (R).

“It's quite inhumane, and Virginia would be the only state where a death row prisoner could be forced to be electrocuted,” said 31st District Senator Barbara Favola (D).

The Senate voted 21 to 19, mostly along party lines to send the bill back to committee, effectively killing it for the year.

Source: WVIR, Feb. 7, 2014

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Food for thought...


"Electrocution leaves minor burns, just barely noticeable."

- Debra Gardner, chief deputy director of Virginia's Department of Corrections, on why Virginia could establish the electric chair as the state’s default method of execution when drugs used for lethal injection are not available.

Virginia lawmakers expected to set electric chair as backup when lethal injection unavailable

Virginia lawmakers are expected to vote this week to establish the electric chair as the state’s default method of execution when drugs used for lethal injection are not available.

The measure, prompted by a long-standing shortage of the drugs, would make Virginia the only state where a death-row prisoner could be forced in some circumstances to be electrocuted.

The bill has passed the House of Delegates and is expected to emerge from the Virginia Senate this week. A spokesman said Gov. Terry McAuliffe (D) has not taken a position on signing or vetoing the legislation.

The embrace of an execution method largely shunned over the past two decades comes as the death penalty, while still legal in many states and supported by a large if declining majority of Americans, is becoming increasingly difficult to implement.

Across the country, states are struggling to procure the drugs necessary to perform lethal injections. Manufacturers in Europe have refused to sell drugs for use in capital punishment, as has at least one major U.S. manufacturer. The three-drug cocktail used commonly since the Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1976 is now out of reach.


Source: The Washington Post, Feb. 5, 2014

Tuesday, January 28, 2014

US considers reviving old-fashioned executions

Utah's contraption for executions by firing squad
Most states abandoned those execution methods a generation ago

St Louis: With lethal-injection drugs in short supply and new questions looming about their effectiveness, lawmakers in some death penalty states are considering bringing back relics of a more gruesome past: firing squads, electrocutions and gas chambers.

Most states abandoned those execution methods more than a generation ago in a bid to make capital punishment more palatable to the public and to a judicial system worried about inflicting cruel and unusual punishments that violate the Constitution.

But to some elected officials, the drug shortages and recent legal challenges are beginning to make lethal injection seem too vulnerable to complications.

“This isn’t an attempt to time-warp back into the 1850s or the wild, wild West or anything like that,” said Missouri state Rep Rick Brattin, who this month proposed making firing squads an option for executions. “It’s just that I foresee a problem, and I’m trying to come up with a solution that will be the most humane yet most economical for our state.”

Brattin, a Republican, said questions about the injection drugs are sure to end up in court, delaying executions and forcing states to examine alternatives. It’s not fair, he said, for relatives of murder victims to wait years, even decades, to see justice served while lawmakers and judges debate execution methods.

Like Brattin, a Wyoming lawmaker this month offered a bill allowing the firing squad. Missouri’s attorney general and a state lawmaker have raised the notion of rebuilding the state’s gas chamber. And a Virginia lawmaker wants to make electrocution an option if lethal-injection drugs aren’t available.

If adopted, those measures could return states to the more harrowing imagery of previous decades, when inmates were hanged, electrocuted or shot to death by marksmen.

States began moving to lethal injection in the 1980s in the belief that powerful sedatives and heart-stopping drugs would replace the violent spectacles with a more clinical affair while limiting, if not eliminating, an inmate’s pain.

The total number of US executions has declined in recent years — from a peak of 98 in 1999 to 39 last year. Some states have turned away from the death penalty entirely. Many have cases tied up in court. And those that carry on with executions find them increasingly difficult to conduct because of the scarcity of drugs and doubts about how well they work.

In recent years, European drug makers have stopped selling the lethal chemicals to prisons because they do not want their products used to kill.

At least two recent executions are also raising concerns about the drugs’ effectiveness. Last week, Ohio inmate Dennis McGuire took 26 minutes to die by injection, gasping repeatedly as he lay on a gurney with his mouth opening and closing. And on Jan. 9, Oklahoma inmate Michael Lee Wilson’s final words were, “I feel my whole body burning.”

Missouri threw out its three-drug lethal injection procedure after it could no longer obtain the drugs. State officials altered the method in 2012 to use propofol, which was found in the system of pop star Michael Jackson after he died of an overdose in 2009.

Oregon Gas Chamber
The anti-death penalty European Union threatened to impose export limits on propofol if it were used in an execution, jeopardizing the supply of a common anesthetic needed by hospitals across the nation. In October, Gov Jay Nixon stayed the execution of serial killer Joseph Paul Franklin and ordered the Missouri Department of Corrections to find a new drug.

Days later, the state announced it had switched to a form of pentobarbital made by a compounding pharmacy. Like other states, Missouri has refused to divulge where the drug comes from or who makes it.

Missouri has carried out two executions using pentobarbital - Franklin in November and Allen Nicklasson in December. Neither inmate showed outward signs of suffering, but the secrecy of the process resulted in a lawsuit and a legislative inquiry.

Michael Campbell, assistant professor of criminal justice at the University of Missouri-St Louis, said some lawmakers simply don’t believe convicted murderers deserve any mercy.

“Many of these politicians are trying to tap into a more populist theme that those who do terrible things deserve to have terrible things happen to them,” Campbell said.

Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Centre in Washington, D.C., cautioned that there could be a backlash.

“These ideas would jeopardize the death penalty because, I think, the public reaction would be revulsion, at least from many quarters,” Dieter said.

Some states already provide alternatives to lethal injection. Condemned prisoners may choose the electric chair in eight states: Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Kentucky, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia. An inmate named Robert Gleason Jr was the most recent to die by electrocution, in Virginia in January 2013.

Arizona, Missouri and Wyoming allow for gas-chamber executions. Missouri no longer has a gas chamber, but Attorney General Chris Koster, a Democrat, and Missouri state Sen. Kurt Schaefer, a Republican, last year suggested possibility rebuilding one. So far, there is no bill to do so.

Delaware, New Hampshire and Washington state still allow inmates to choose hanging. The last hanging in the US was Billy Bailey in Delaware in 1996. Two prisoners in Washington state have chosen to be hanged since the 1990s — Westley Allan Dodd in 1993 and Charles Rodman Campbell in 1994.

Firing squads typically consisting of five sharpshooters with rifles, one of which is loaded with a blank so the shooters do not know for sure who fired the fatal bullet. They have been used mostly for military executions.

Since the end of the Civil War, there have been three civilian firing squad executions in the US, all in Utah. Gary Gilmore uttered his famous final words, “Let’s do it” on Jan. 18, 1977, before his execution, which ended what amounted to a 17-year national moratorium on the death penalty. Convicted killers John Albert Taylor in 1996 and Ronnie Lee Gardner in 2010 were also put to death by firing squad.

Utah is phasing out its use, but the firing squad remains an option there for inmates sentenced prior to May 3, 2004.

Oklahoma maintains the firing squad as an option, but only if lethal injection and electrocution are deemed unconstitutional.

In Wyoming, Republican state Sen. Bruce Burns said death by firing squad would be far less expensive than building a gas chamber. Wyoming has only one inmate on death row, 68-year-old convicted killer Dale Wayne Eaton. The state has not executed anyone in 22 years.

Jackson Miller, a Republican in the Virginia House of Delegates, is sponsoring a bill that would allow for electrocution if lethal injection drugs are not available.

Source: The Associated Press, January 28, 2014

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Virginia: Electric chair bill advances in the House

January 17, 2014: The House's Militia, Police and Public Safety Committee passed House Bill 1052 that would allow forced electrocutions when lethal drugs aren't available.

The bill passed on a 12-6 vote. The vote was largely along party lines, with Republicans voting in favor.

The legislation could head to the House floor as soon as next week.

Republicans control the House, and the bill has a good chance of passing there.

The Senate is divided between Republicans and Democrats.

This bill, sponsored by Del. Jackson Miller, R-Manassas, would authorize electrocution if the head of the Virginia Department of Corrections certifies that lethal injection drugs aren't available.

Those drugs are becoming scarce because companies that produce them don't want them used in executions. Virginia already has electrocution in its protocols, but lets the inmate choose between lethal injection and electrocution. The new law would give the Department of Correction the power to overrule the inmates’ choice.

Richard Dieter, head of the Death Penalty Information Center, said the change would "certainly precipitate vigorous court challenges." "This is not a minor step," he said. "This would be like adopting the electric chair as the main method of execution, which no other state has."

Dieter said there are related proposals in other states, though, borne of frustration over the lack of available drugs.

There's a proposal in Wyoming to use firing squads, one in Arkansas for the electric chair and one in California to use the gas chamber. None are close to becoming law, Dieter said.

Source: Daily Press, January 17, 2014

Friday, January 17, 2014

Choice of method in death penalty could be overruled in new Virginia bill

Death row inmates in Virginia who wish to die by lethal injection still could face execution by electrocution under a bill that advanced Thursday in the House of Delegates.

By a 4-1 voice vote, a House subcommittee on Militia, Police and Public Safety backed a measure that would override a condemned prisoner’s choice of execution in the case of a shortage of lethal injection drugs.

“It’s really a just a process issue. This doesn’t expand the death penalty in any way, shape or form,” Del. Jackson Miller, R-Manassas, sponsor of HB 1052, said in an interview Thursday.

Under current state law, a condemned prisoner may choose whether to die by lethal injection or the electric chair. If the inmate doesn’t select either option at least 15 days before the scheduled execution, the method is lethal injection by default.

Since the introduction of lethal injection in Virginia in the mid-1990s, most convicts on death row opted to die that way or were put to death that way by default. Only seven of the 86 people executed in Virginia since 1995 chose electrocution, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

Miller said he wants to avoid a stay of execution when a prisoner has exhausted all appeals but the chemicals to administer lethal injection are not available on the day of the execution.

“It’s just getting more and more difficult for the Department of Corrections to find the chemicals necessary for the cocktail that they use for the lethal injection,” Miller said.

Source: roanoke.com, January 17, 2014

Saturday, November 16, 2013

Death Row is Not a "Constitution-Free Zone"

Alfredo Prieto sits alone 23 hours a day in a locked, seventy-square-feet box. The lights never go out.

According to trial records, Prieto grew up in tough circumstances in war-torn El Salvador, escaped with his family to California. He became involved in gangs and violent crime, culminating ultimately in his conviction for rape, larceny and double murder in Virginia. But during his eight-year incarceration, Prieto has been by all accounts a model prisoner. He is one of eight men who await execution on Virginia's death row.

Virginia locks its death-row prisoners in solitary confinement and throws away the key, no questions asked, until they are released due to successful appeal or executed. And Virginia is not alone. For many, a death sentence means a double punishment. As we documented extensively in our report A Death Before Dying, people on death row can spend decades locked alone in a tiny, cement room before they are ever strapped to an execution gurney, dying a slow and painful psychological death in solitary confinement before the state executes them.

No other class of prisoners is automatically locked alone with no end in sight.

But this week, a Virginia federal court looked past the murder convictions and death sentence Prieto is still challenging (in the lengthy capital appellate process), and held that the U.S. Constitution still affords him rights. In a case brought by Prieto, District Court Judge Leona Brinkema has ruled that Virginia's automatic placement of death-row prisoners in solitary confinement – without any process in which the prisoner could challenge the placement, and certainly without respect to their dangerousness, misconduct, or any other individualized reason – violates the right to due process guaranteed by the Constitution.

This is the first time any court in this country has made such a ruling.


Source: ACLU Capital Punishment Project, November 15, 2013

Friday, October 4, 2013

USA: The Cost of Death Sentences: $25 Billion, Much of it Paid by Virginians, Study Says

Study estimates cost of each execution at more than $20 million

Prince William and Fairfax counties are among the 62 jurisdictions that have prosecuted the most criminals executed in the United States since the reinstatement of capital punishment, according to a study released Tuesday, and Virginia taxpayers have paid a substantial portion of the $25 billion spent on death sentences.

The report from the Death Penalty Information Center found that the 2 counties were among the 2% of counties in the United States that were responsible for a majority of the 1,320 executions from 1976 to 2012.

The U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1976.

Prince William had nine death-row inmates who were executed and Fairfax County had 5.

The report showed that geography, rather than the nature of a crime, was the biggest factor in who was executed and who was not.

"There's an arbitrariness to the death penalty," Richard Dieter, the Death Penalty Information Center's executive director, told The Washington Post. "Most of the counties in Virginia have never had an execution in this modern era."

Among those executed in Prince William County: John Allen Muhammad, part of the sniper team that shot 10 people in the Washington area in 2002. He was executed in 2009.

The study cited the cost of each death sentence at $3 million and the cost of each execution at more than $20 million.

With more than 8,300 death sentences in the United State since 1976, the total cost of the cases was about $25 billion, the study found, adding that the costs are not limited to the counties involved but hit state and federal budgets.

Source: Ashburn Patch, October 3, 2013

Friday, September 6, 2013

USA: Recommendations offered for Virginia death penalty process

A review of Virginia’s death penalty aimed at improving fairness and accuracy calls for safeguards in the use of suspect lineups and more access by defense lawyers to information to help them prepare cases.

The recommendations are among more than a dozen in the two-year effort sponsored by the American Bar Association’s Death Penalty Assessment Project that since 2003 has studied and reported on the death penalty in 10 other states.

“If you’re going to have a death penalty, I think everyone would agree we have to get it right,” Mark L. Earley, a former Virginia attorney general and member of the Virginia Death Penalty Assessment Team, said Thursday.

“This wasn’t a project about whether Virginia should have the death penalty or should not have the death penalty. It wasn’t a project about whether we should have a moratorium on the death penalty,” Earley said.

“It was really a project that (considers) this: If a state is going to have the death penalty, how can we be sure it has integrity and that it is accurate and fair in all respects,” he added.

A top-priority change urged by the study is to require law enforcement agencies to adopt the Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services’ model eyewitness identification policy for suspect photo and live lineups.

Misidentification played a role in the wrongful convictions of 18 Virginians later proved innocent in non-death penalty cases.

According to the Virginia Department of Corrections, Virginia has executed 110 killers — 31 by electrocution and 79 by injection — since the U.S. Supreme Court allowed capital punishment to resume in 1976.

The toll is second nationally only to Texas, which has executed 503. But in Virginia three out of four persons sentenced to death since 1976 have been executed — a higher rate than even in Texas, which has carried out roughly half its death sentences.


Source: Richmond Times-Dispatch, Sept. 6, 2013

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

Texas executes Kimberly McCarthy

Kimberly McCarthy
Kimberly McCarthy, 52, was put to death by lethal injection at 6:37 p.m. Wednesday, making her one of a small number of women to have been executed.

In her final statement, McCarthy did not mention her status as the 500th inmate to be executed or acknowledge Booth or her family.

"This is not a loss. This is a win. You know where I'm going. I'm going home to be with Jesus. Keep the faith. I love you all," she said, while looking toward her witnesses - her attorney, her spiritual adviser and her ex-husband, New Black Panther Party founder Aaron Michaels.

As the drug started to take effect, McCarthy said, "God is great," before closing her eyes. She took hard, raspy, loud breaths for several seconds before becoming quiet. Then, her chest moved up and down for another minute before she stopped breathing.

Friends and family of Booth told reporters after the execution that they were not conscious that Texas had carried out its 500th execution since 1982. They said their only focus was on Booth's brutal murder.

Donna Aldred, Booth's daughter, reading a statement to reporters, said that her mother "was an incredible person who was taken before her time." 

McCarthy, a former cocaine addict, was convicted of killing her 71-year-old neighbor during a 1997 robbery. She was found guilty of using a butcher knife and a candelabra to beat and stab retired college professor Dorothy Booth. Using the same knife, she severed Booth's finger to steal her wedding ring.

McCarthy was granted a retrial by an appeals court in 2002 on the ground that police had obtained her confession illegally, but she was sentenced to death row again.

Members of Booth's family said they didn’t care about Texas' macabre tally, only about justice for their loved one.

"The only significance for us is that Kimberly McCarthy, because of her crack cocaine addiction or her sociopathic personality, deprived us of Dorothy Booth," Randy Browning, Booth's godson, told The Dallas Morning News. "Whether it's the 500th or the 5,000th, it doesn't matter."

Browning had said he planned to attend the execution Wednesday evening.

A death row inmate is executed every three weeks in Texas, a rate that far exceeds that of any other state. Texas is the leader in executions in the U.S. by about 400, with Virginia a distant second. Since the Supreme Court ruled on death penalty laws in 1976, Texas has accounted for 40 percent of the more than 1,300 executions nationwide.

Despite a cultural shift away from the death penalty in many parts of the country, 32 states still allow it.

The rate of executions has declined in recent years in Texas, as well. More than three dozen people were executed in 2000, but this year, McCarthy was the eight person subjected to capital punishment.

But many Texans support the death penalty, according to a 2012 poll by the Texas Tribune and the University of Texas. Only 21 percent said they were opposed.

Gov. Rick Perry is among the majority.

"I think our process works just fine," Perry said in 2012 during his unsuccessful presidential bid. "You may not agree with them, but we believe in our form of justice."

McCarthy was the first woman put to death in the U.S. in more than three years and the 13th since the Supreme Court's ruling. The last woman executed in the U.S. was Teresa Wilson Lewis in Virginia on Sept. 23, 2010.

In the past year, McCarthy’s execution has been pushed back twice, most recently in early April. Her attorney, Maurie Levin, continued to fight for McCarthy, but her latest appeal to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals was rejected Tuesday.

Levin said black jurors were improperly blocked from McCarthy's trial, a claim the convicted woman made in her appeals.

"The shameful errors that plagued Ms. McCarthy’s case — race bias, ineffective counsel and courts unwilling to exercise meaningful oversight of the system — reflect problems that are central to the administration of the death penalty as a whole," Levin said.

McCarthy's trial was decided by an all-white jury despite Levin's claim that four non-white jurors qualified. McCarthy is black, and Levin said the Dallas County jury selection process has a "troubling and long-standing history of racial discrimination in jury selection."

The only way McCarthy could have avoided the death penalty was if the court had said it wanted more time to review the appeal, said John Hurt, a prison agency spokesman for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice's Huntsville unit.

Levin told NBC News on Wednesday morning there was "no chance" of that happening because the court had already struck down her appeal.

"For this to be the emblem of Texas' 500th execution is something all Texans should be ashamed of," she said.

There are currently 283 men and women on death row in Texas.

McCarthy was the 8th Texas prisoner executed this year. She was among 10 women on death row in Texas, but the only one with an execution date. 7 male Texas prisoners have executions scheduled in the coming months. 

McCarthy becomes the 500th condemned inmate to be put to death in Texas since the state resumed capital punishment on December 7, 1982. McCarthy becomes the 261st condemned inmate to be put to death in Texas since Rick Perry became governor in 2001.

McCarthy becomes the 18th condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 1338th overall since the nation resumed executions on January 17, 1977. 

Source: NBC News, Associated Press, Rick Halperin, June 26, 2013

Sunday, June 23, 2013

Texas' grim death penalty milestone

Holding cells at Huntsville Prison where death-row
inmates spend their last hours. The execution
chamber is located at the far end of the corridor.
Owing to its size and inclinations, Texas registers prodigious statistics, but none so bleak as what comes from the state's pre-Civil War red-brick prison in Huntsville that houses the nation's busiest execution chamber.

There, on Wednesday, Texas' 500th execution since national reinstatement is set to be carried out. The life scheduled for termination belongs to Kimberly McCarthy, whose grisly murder of elderly neighbor Dorothy Booth of Lancaster brings the state to this grim milestone.

It's one that no other state may ever touch. Virginia, 2nd in terms of executions, is barely a 5th of the way there, and the pace of capital punishment has slowed nationwide, even in Texas.

Part of that has to do with a collective shudder at the realities of a fallible criminal-justice system. Part of it has to do with a growing list of states - now at 18 - that have abolished the death penalty. Part of it has to do with a willingness to pause and take an unflinching look at the system and why it singles out some killers to die and others to live.

In Ohio, the 8th-ranking capital-punishment state, a special commission appointed by the state Supreme Court is now doing that self-examination. It was galvanized by a report that showed the likelihood of being executed depended on where a killer committed his crime and who he killed. Defendants paid a disproportionately higher price in Cincinnati, for example, as opposed to Cleveland and other major cities. Killers of whites were far likelier to face execution than killers of blacks.

Unevenness in capital punishment is also a blemish on the Texas record. Again, geography and race count - among the reasons that this newspaper opposes capital punishment.

Of Texas' 254 counties, only 22 have sent killers to death row in the previous 5 years, and only 11 have done so in the previous 2, according to an analysis from the Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty. A death case is too time-consuming and expensive for many counties to take on.

Studies indicate that the race of the victim and murderer likely produce different outcomes in Texas, from decisions made by jurors to convict and by prosecutors to bring charges. Of the 46 death verdicts in the past 5 years, 21 defendants were black.

It's time, in Texas, for our own unflinching self-exam on the system of sending people to the death chamber.

That's especially important for Dallas County, which is suddenly notable as Texas' leading county for new death sentences, with 8 in the previous 5 years.

The McCarthy case, the potential 500th execution, dredges up this county's sketchy history of racially discriminatory jury selection. New briefs in the case cite findings by this newspaper that, as recently as 2005 - 3 years after the McCarthy trial - Dallas County prosecutors excluded eligible blacks from juries at more than twice the rate they rejected eligible whites.

McCarthy is not a sympathetic character, and her culpability in a brutal murder is not at issue. Still, in the grim business of seeking an eye for an eye, Texas must insist on a fair, dispassionate, even-handed, colorblind justice system. It's not the one we have today.

LEADING DEATH-PENALTY STATES

Executions since national resumption in 1976:

Texas: 499

Virginia: 110

Oklahoma: 104

Florida :77

Missouri: 68

Alabama :55

Georgia: 53

Ohio :51

North Carolina: 43

South Carolina: 43

Source: Editorial, Dallas Morning News, June 21, 2013


It's time to halt executions in Texas

The figure 500 is sobering, particularly when it is applied to people and their deaths.

On Wednesday evening, barring intervention by a court or the governor, Texas will carry out its 500th death sentence since capital punishment was reinstated in 1974.

Between 1924 (when the state took charge of executions from its counties) and 1964, the start of a decade-long moratorium, the Lone Star State performed 361 killings by electrocution.

Texas has the bragging rights for its frequency of ultimate punishment, leading the nation even though other states have more inmates on death row.

These large numbers represent people, individuals with names who, although convicted of horrible crimes and deserving punishment, should not have their deaths determined by flawed human beings acting in the name of the state.

Kimberly McCarthy, if her sentence is carried out shortly after 6 p.m. Wednesday, will have the distinction of being that 500th person (and only the 4th woman) to be executed in Texas since the death penalty was reinstated.

It is time - in fact, long past - for Texas to get out of the killing business.

A character in an 1889 short story, The Bet by Anton Chekhov, makes a compelling argument during a dinner party debate on capital punishment. He boldly states, "The State is not God. It has no right to take away that which it cannot give back, if it should so desire."

Precisely.

On moral grounds alone, Texas should abolish capital punishment as six other states have done in the last 6 years. Maryland become the most recent in May.

Just as the Supreme Court declared in 1972, the death penalty is cruel and unusual punishment, and its application continues to be arbitrary and capricious.

Whether a killer receives a death sentence can vary according to many factors, including the county where the crime occurs. The costs of prosecuting such cases and providing court-appointed lawyers are too high for some counties to absorb. Poor rural counties are less likely than large urban ones to seek the death penalty.

Death row tends to be occupied by the poor, as rich people seldom are sent there. And minorities are over-represented. Of the 283 people on Texas's death row, 39.2 % are black, 29.7 % are Hispanic and 29.7 % are white, state figures show.

Although no one is certain that an innocent person has ever been executed, Texas has an embarrassing record of wrongful conviction, as evidenced by the number of recent prisoner exonerations.

Progress has been made on limiting executions in certain cases, and in reducing the overall number of capital cases and death sentences. For example, recent Supreme Court rulings prohibit the execution of the mentally ill and people who were under age 18 when the crime was committed. After 2005, when Texas began allowing prison sentences of life without parole in capital cases, jurors have been more inclined to hand down that sentence instead of death.

Although a Gallup poll shows 63 % of Americans still favor capital punishment, the number of executions has dropped by more than 1/2 in the past 15 years, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

Texas executed 15 people last year, compared to 40 in 2000. McCarthy, convicted of robbing and murdering a 70-year-old Dallas woman, would become the 8th person to die by lethal injection this year. 7 other executions are scheduled through November.

Proponents of the death penalty argue that it is the appropriate punishment for people who take a life, often in the most heinous way.

The victims, they say, deserve justice, and killing their killers is the best way to mete it out.

Abolishing capital punishment would neither demean the memory of victims nor deny any of them justice. Instead, it would make our society as a whole more just, more morally consistent and certainly more humane.

Texas retired "Old Sparky," its electric chair, in 1977.

It is time to permanently close our infamous death chamber.

Source: Editorial, Fort Worth Star-Telegram, June 21, 2013

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Ex-Virginia executioner becomes opponent of death penalty

Jerry Givens
Jerry Givens executed 62 people.

His routine and conviction never wavered. He’d shave the person’s head, lay his hand on the bald pate and ask for God’s forgiveness for the condemned. Then, he would strap the person into Virginia’s electric chair.

Givens was the state’s chief executioner for 17 years — at a time when the commonwealth put more people to death than any state besides Texas.

“If you knew going out there that raping and killing someone had the consequence of the death penalty, then why are you going to do it?” Givens asked. “I considered it suicide.”

As Virginia executed its 110th person in the modern era last month, Givens prayed for the man, but also for an end to the death penalty. Since leaving his job in 1999, Givens has become one of the state’s most visible — and unlikely — opponents of capital punishment.

Givens’s improbable journey to the death chamber and back did not come easily or quickly for the 60-year-old from Richmond. A searing murder spurred his interest in the work, but it was the innocent life he nearly took that led him to question the system. And he was changed for good when he found himself behind bars.

His evolution underscores that of Virginia itself and the nation. Although polls show that the majority of state residents still support the death penalty, Virginia has experienced a sea change on capital punishment in recent years that is part of a national trend.

Givens grew up in the Creighton Court housing complex in Richmond, where he also graduated from high school in the early 1970s. By 1974, he had gotten a job at a Philip Morris plant and then lost it after fighting with a co-worker.

He recalled someone telling him that he should apply for a job at the state penitentiary before he got sent there. Givens did just that.

After two years as a prison guard, he said, a supervisor approached him about working on death row. He would not be paid extra, but he accepted the job.


Source: The Washington Post, Articles, Justin Jouvenal, February 10, 2013





"Executioners sentenced to remorse"

Ordinarily they don't talk. The executioners have no name, no face, and are not supposed to have qualms. "When I executed prisoners, even my wife knew nothing," remembers Jerry Givens, 60 years old, former executioner in the state of Virginia, and one of the first to have broken this silence. "I didn't want it to affect my wife, I didn't want her to have to live through everything I felt," he explains, sitting in a restaurant in his city of Richmond, in front of a fish he sometimes stops eating when his story becomes too macabre. "But since this death we give is legal, approved by the voters, why hide?" he wonders, between 2 bites.

"When people do things they're ashamed of, they tend to do it in secret," replies attorney Steve Northrup, director of the group Virginians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, an abolitionist movement which Jerry Givens has joined. "The jurisdictions which practice executions take a lot of trouble to keep secret the identities of all the persons involved."

More than 3000 prisoners are awaiting their last hour on the famous "death rows". These last few years, however, the number of executions is down (43 executions in 2012, compared with about 60 a year, or more, at the beginning of the 2000s). More than 60% of the Americans still say they favor the "supreme punishment", but this support is tending to decline. The statements by executioners is contributing to this slow evolution. Between 1982 and 1999, Jerry Givens killed 62 prisoners, 37 by electrocution and 25 by lethal injection of barbiturates. "I never liked that," he says. "For me, every time an execution was announced, it meant that I had to prepare myself mentally to kill. Ordinarily, as a prison guard, my job was more to preserve lives. During executions, I was in an opposite role, I became the one who had to take a life."

For the executioner, the putting to death of a prisoner breaks down into a series of well coded steps, says Jerry. "At the moment, I thought especially about doing my job right so as to avoid mistakes that would make the prisoner suffer. After his last meal the prisoner had the right to a shower. Then, if he was sentenced to be electrocuted, I had to shave his head and his right leg, where the electrodes would be placed, to avoid the hairs catching fire. Then he had the right to a final telephone call. Then the death sentence was read to him once again. While I was cutting their hair, I asked them if I could pray for them. Some said yes, others replied that they didn't care." At the time, Jerry Givens was convinced that the death penalty was right. As a teenager, he had seen a girl killed right before his eyes at a party. Murderers guilty of such acts just deserve death," he thought.

"Most of the prisoners talked to me," continues Jerry. They asked me if it was going to hurt. I told them I didn't know, having never been in their position. Or they asked me what would come after life. There again, I had to say I didn't know. Some made jokes. They asked me for a few minutes more, so as to be nice and clean when they went to heaven, or asked me to give them a nice haircut. Others were serious. One had ordered a McDonald's sandwich but couldn't manage to swallow it. He asked me to put it in the fridge for the next day. He hadn't realized this was his last day. Others fought right to the last minute with their lawyers to try to get a stay."

The executioner is not the only one involved, of course, a whole team of "technicians" helps him at the moment of the execution, each with a precise task, but finally, it was Jerry who had to push the button. At times he told about it like a workman presenting his work: "I did so many executions that at the end all I had to do was look at the size of the prisoner to know how many volts would be needed to kill him. If the guy wasn't very heavy, a 35-second discharge would be enough, if he was bigger, 45 or 60 seconds needed to be planned."

The worst, for Jerry Givens, was the executions by lethal injection, which have become more common in the United States. "When you pick up the syringe, you feel much closer to the prisoner than when you just push a button. You see the chemical solution flow, like you were seeing death advance down the tube." His other worry today is that innocent men were among the 62 men he killed: "I truly hope there were no innocents among them," he says. "If I ever learned thata I had executed innocent men, I don't know what that would do to me."

In 1999, Jerry Givens' career as an executioner came to an abrupt end: he himself was arrested and sentence to 4 1/2 years in prison for receiving money from drug trafficking. On the other side of the bars, where he feels he was wrongly sent, he turned to God and reconsidered his point of view on the death penalty. "Who am I to give death?" he wonders today. "It's up to God to decide who must die, not me. By applying the death penalty, we are worth no more than those who crucified Jesus, and innocent man."

Today working as a construction site truck driver, Jerry goes all over the United States for his work, but also to talk about his conversion and his new abolitionist faith. "Many people still defend the death penalty, but when I ask in public: 'Who would like to do this job of executioner?' no one raises his hand." Militating also helps him overcome this past as a killer, he explains. "If I kept all that inside, I would risk blowing up." Many of his former colleagues suffer from post-traumatic stress, reports Jerry, who claims that he is OK himself: "I think that God made me do that so that I could speak out now."

Ron McAndrew is another of those rare "State killers" who talk today about their profession. The experience seems to have been much more traumatic for him. "To this very day, I am in therapy, I have nightmares. The prisoners I executed come back to visit me in my dreams," confesses this sturdy 74-year-old man, who has however had all sorts of adventures: intelligence agent in the air force, stationed in France at the Evreux base from 1956 to 1961, perfume seller in Europe, Japan and Vietnam, then prison guard in Florida where he climbed through the ranks to become warden of the prison which included supervising executions. In 1996 and 1997, Ron McAndrew executed 3 men in the electric chair. At the third execution, that of Pedro Medina, a Cuban refugee, the body caught fire. "When we sent the electricity, we heard a sharp pop, and his head began to smoke," says Ron. "We had set this man's head on fire! The whole room filled with smoke. It was the worst experience I ever went through." After this tragedy he was sent to Texas, where he attended 5 more executions, by lethal injection, to train in the technique. "I didn't find it cleaner or easier," he sighs. "In both cases, I was facing a man first living, then dead."

For Ron McAndrew also, the death penalty was long obvious: "I grew up in the country, in North Carolina, at the end of a dirt road, in a really conservative family where the Holy Scriptures were taken literally: an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth," he explains. "For me, the death penalty was as natural as looking to the left and right before crossing the street." Even before his 1st execution, his conscience began to bother him. "It was in 1997," he remembers precisely. "The mother and sisters of the 1st prisoner I was supposed to execute, Leo Jones, came to see me at the prison. 'Warden,' the mother, an old black woman who could barely speak asked me, 'Will you let me hug my baby one last time before you kill him????' I could feel all this mother's pain and I could no longer turn my head away. At the last minute, her son got a reprieve - he was executed later, when I had left the job. But immediately afterward I received orders to execute another prisoner."

At the time his sleep was disturbed. "I took sleeping pills and I drank. A bottle of wine every evening, glassfuls of cognac. I had nightmares, I was cracking up, my wife was really worried about me. I was sicker and sicker." Ron McAndrew finally asked for a transfer and began psychotherapy.

"My therapist told me that talking about it would help me remain healthy," he explains. "As long as I have that in my mind, I need to talk about it, she told me."

These former executioners who have become opponents of the death penalty are a little club, very informal, with about 10 members, says Ron. "We call each other when our morale is low. Recently a colleague asked me how I hang on. My recipe? A really supportive wife, a good therapist, and a little medication." At least 2 former executioners have committed suicide in recent years in the United States. Dozens of others live hidden, still convinced of their "mission", or keeping their traumas to themselves, in silence.

Source: LIBERATION, June 12, 2013

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Support for death penalty stable in US as Texas approaches 500th execution

Texas is moving closer to an unflattering jubilee: the 500th execution since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976 – barring any last-minute stays or reprieves. This Wednesday, June 12, Texas will execute its 499th person, and execution no. 500 is scheduled for June 26. Texas uses the death penalty more than any other state, and the competition does not even come close.

No. 2 on the execution list is Virginia, which has killed 110 people – and only five since 2010. Texas has executed more people than the next six states (Virginia, Oklahoma, Florida, Missouri, Alabama and Georgia) combined. It wasn’t always so. Texas executed fewer than 10 people a year until 1992, when executions spiked under then-Governor Ann Richards. They peaked under George W. Bush, who sent 37 people to the death chamber in 1997 and 40 in 2000.

The Texans put to death are disproportionately African-American.

Americans’ support for the death penalty as punishment for murder has levelled off in recent years after several years in which support appeared to be falling. Sixty-three percent now favour the death penalty as the punishment for murder, similar to 61% in 2011 and 64% in 2010, according to polls conducted by Gallup.

Since the Boston bombings, the numbers have nudged up a bit. The majority or at least plurality of most demographic and political groups is in broad agreement about supporting the death penalty as punishment for murder.

One exception to that is adults who describe their political views as “liberal.” Just under half of liberals, 47%, favour the death penalty, while 50% oppose it. However, most conservatives and moderates support it, as do majorities of all party groups, including 51% of Democrats. Additionally, non-whites are closely divided on  the issue, with 49% in favour and 45% opposed. That contrasts with whites, among whom 68% are in favour.


Source: Euronews, June 11, 2013

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Somali pirates will face death penalty in federal trial in Virginia

For two days, the four Americans held aboard their yacht by Somali pirates had been shadowed in the Indian Ocean by a U.S. aircraft carrier, two guided-missile destroyers and a cruiser. The U.S. military and FBI agents wanted to negotiate; the pirates wanted to reach land.

When one of the destroyers neared the 58-foot sailing boat, gunfire erupted. By the time Navy SEALs reached the Quest, the four Americans had been fatally shot — the first time U.S. citizens were killed in a wave of piracy that has rippled out from the coast of Somalia in recent years.

On Tuesday, a federal court in Virginia will begin jury selection in the capital trial of three Somali pirates charged in the February 2011 deaths of Scott and Jean Adam of Marina del Rey, Calif., and Bob Riggle and Phyllis Macay of Seattle.

Eleven of the pirates who attacked the Quest pleaded guilty in federal court in 2011 and were given life sentences. The onshore negotiator was also captured and given multiple life sentences in federal court in Virginia.

Federal prosecutors allege that the defendants going on trial this week — Ahmed Muse Salad, Abukar Osman Beyle and Shani Nurani Shiekh Abrar — were the ones who shot and killed the four Americans aboard the U.S.-flagged Quest.


Source: The Washington Post, June 4, 2013

Thursday, May 23, 2013

Federal appeals court allows capital murder retrial of Justin Wolfe; lower court had ordered him freed

McLEAN, Va. — A federal appeals court ruled Wednesday that Virginia should be allowed to pursue a capital murder case against an alleged drug kingpin from northern Virginia, overruling a lower court that had sought to put an end to the 12-year legal saga by ordering his unconditional release.

In a 2-1 ruling, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond overturned a federal judge in Norfolk who had ordered a halt to the prosecution of Justin Wolfe, who faces death penalty charges in Prince William County for the 2001 slaying of a large-scale marijuana supplier, Daniel Petrole.

The district court judge, Raymond Jackson, said misconduct by prosecutors in Prince William County made it impossible for Wolfe to get a fair trial.

But a majority on the appellate court disagreed. Judges Robert Bruce King and Allyson Kay Duncan ruled that a new trial can be done fairly. They wrote that Jackson “fashioned an overbroad remedy and thereby abused (his) discretion by precluding the Commonwealth from retrying Wolfe.”

A dissenting judge, Stephanie Thacker, said the misconduct was so bad that freeing Wolfe was the only proper outcome. She reeled off a long list of examples of misconduct, including failures by Prince William County Commonwealth’s Attorney Paul Ebert to disclose evidence that would have undermined the credibility of the state’s star witness.

Wolfe’s case has now been in front of the appeals court three separate times. He was sentenced to death after his 2002 conviction in Manassas, and spent a nearly a decade on death row. In 2011, Jackson overturned Wolfe’s conviction and the appeals court upheld his action.

Source: AP, May 22, 2013