Showing posts with label Midazolam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Midazolam. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Pharma firms must put in place execution drug controls as US states push ahead with new ‘cocktail’

Two pharmaceutical companies, one of which describes itself as “one of the biggest…in the UK,” are facing urgent calls to put in place new controls on drugs which could be used in executions.

Akorn, headquartered in Illinois, produces midazolam, a sedative which is currently being used by Florida and Ohio to carry out lethal injections.

Teva, a global company which “suppl[ies] more packs of medicines to the NHS than anyone else,” produces two paralytic agents – rocuronium bromide and vecuronium bromide – which are used by Virginia and Florida respectively as part of their three-drug execution ‘cocktails.’

Although it is not certain that any US state has yet procured the relevant drugs from either of the companies, both have so far failed to put in place distribution controls which would prevent this from happening. This failure stands in contrast to the other US manufacturers of the drugs in question, which have taken simple and effective steps to prevent their medicines being used to fuel executions.

Florida is today [Wednesday] due to carry out its fifth execution using midazolam as part of a three-drug cocktail that was first used on William Happ in October last year; Happ reportedly took twice as long to die as is normal.

Problems with the previously-untested lethal injection drug have been widespread – when Ohio first used midazolam as part of a two-drug combination in January, eyewitnesses reported that the prisoner took nearly half an hour to die.

Just last week, Virginia joined Florida and Ohio, announcing that it too would make midazolam one of the drugs available for use in executions.

Legal charity Reprieve has raised with both Akorn and Teva the need for them to move urgently to put in place effective controls in order to ensure they do not become involved in the death penalty process, but has yet to receive a satisfactory response.

Teva has previously acted to put in place controls on an anaesthetic, propofol, after it emerged that executioners were planning to use it to kill, but has yet to take the same positive action on the two paralysing agents.

Maya Foa, Director of Reprieve’s Death Penalty team said: “Executioners are increasingly turning to these new drugs in order to kill. If Akorn and Teva fail to take swift, decisive action, they face the very real threat of becoming the go-to suppliers of execution drugs across the USA. If Teva and Akorn wish to preserve their reputation as responsible pharmaceutical companies, they must ensure their drugs can only be used to save lives, not end them in executions.”

Source: Reprieve, Feb. 26, 2014

Friday, February 21, 2014

Virginia lethal injection drug same as one in Ohio suit

The Virginia Department of Corrections said Thursday that it has approved the sedative midazolam as an alternative first drug in the state's three-drug execution protocol. Midazolam was one of two drugs used in last month's execution of an Ohio inmate who made snorting and gasping sounds and took an unusually long 26 minutes to die. His family is suing Ohio.

Illinois-based Hospira Inc., which manufactures midazolam, opposes its use for capital punishment but has been unable to stop state prison systems from obtaining it from suppliers.

The development comes as many death penalty states are grappling with a shortage of drugs that can be used in executions. Many of the drugs are manufactured in European countries that have prohibited their export for use in capital punishment.

Virginia lawmakers are considering legislation that would allow the state to use the electric chair in executions if lethal injection drugs are not available when an inmate's execution date arrives. Under current law, death row inmates can choose either the electric chair or lethal injection. If they decline to choose, they get the injection.

Source: AP, Feb. 21, 2014

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Can Europe End the Death Penalty in America?

On January 19, Dennis McGuire died gasping and choking during a lethal injection administered by the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction. “Over those 11 minutes or more he was fighting for breath, and I could see both of his fists were clenched the entire time,” wrote Father Lawrence Hummer, the Catholic priest who gave McGuire his last rites and witnessed the execution. “There is no question in my mind that Dennis McGuire suffered greatly over many minutes.”

Ohio corrections officials had used an experimental two-drug cocktail of midazolam, a sedative and anesthetic, and hydromorphone, a painkiller and morphine derivative, to execute McGuire. Three weeks later, on February 7, Ohio Governor John Kasich delayed the state's next scheduled execution, of the convicted murderer Gregory Lott, until November while the state reviews McGuire’s execution and determines what to do next.

Why did Ohio, which has used lethal injection since it resumed executions in 1999, suddenly try an unproven chemical mixture on McGuire? The answer lies in a growing shortage of standard lethal-injection drugs brought about primarily by a 2011 export ban by the European Union, the effects of which are starting to be felt in death-row chambers across America.

“The EU embargo has slowed down, but not stopped executions,” Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center in Washington, D.C, told me. “It has made the states seem somewhat desperate and not in control, putting the death penalty in a negative light, with an uncertain future.”


Source: The Atlantic, Feb. 19, 2014

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Louisiana: Killer set for Wednesday execution wins 90-day delay, trial regarding drugs

Death-row inmate Christopher Sepulvado was granted a 90-day stay of execution today, just 2 days before he was set to be killed with a new, controversial combination of lethal-injection drugs.

The state and Sepulvado's attorney's agreed to a 90-day temporary restraining order after a closed-door meeting with U.S. District Court Judge James Brady, said Pam Laborde, spokeswoman for the state Department of Safety and Corrections. The meeting was held in Brady's chambers to discuss recent changes in Louisiana's lethal injection protocol.

A trial on the constitutionality of the state's execution method is scheduled to begin April 7.

"The stay will allow additional time for review and responses to outstanding issues related to the execution," Laborde said in her written statement.

Last week the state announced it would be using a mix of the sedative midazolam and the painkiller hydromorphone. The deadly concoction was used earlier this month in Ohio, where it reportedly caused convicted rapist and killer Dennis McGuire to gasp and snort for 15 minutes before dying.

Sepulvado was sentenced to death in 1993 for killing his stepson. He beat the 6-year-old child with a screwdriver and held him in scalding water.

This is the latest in a string of delays won by Sepulvado. He and fellow death-row inmate Jessie Hoffman have a joint federal lawsuit pending that says they deserve to know precisely how the state will execute them. Their lawyers are trying to show that the state's methods could cause unnecessary pain and suffering, violating their constitutional rights.

Sepulvado's lawyers have repeatedly complained that the state has withheld information about its lethal-injection process, including the source of the drugs and whether they're expired.

On Friday, following pleadings by Sepulvado's lawyers, Brady ordered the state to "identify, by type, manufacturer, lot number, quantity, expiration date, and source, the drug or drugs to be used by the DOC in the lethal injections given to death row inmates."

In response, the Department of Corrections released a document stating that Louisiana had hydromorphone and midazolam "in compliance with the recently revised protocol."

However, the state's execution protocol calls for a concentrated mixture of of midazolam, a sedative, 5 times stronger than what the state's records show it has in stock, according to a state document recently filed in court.

Ohio's protocol, which death-penalty opponents say resulted in a botched execution, also called for the stronger dose of midazolam.

The state provided to Sepulvado's attorneys only some of the information ordered by the judge. It did not identify what company or pharmacist supplied the drug. In a court filing last week, a lawyer for the state argued that it's imperative to protect the identities of companies that provide drugs to the DOC.

"In truth, other than exposing those people to the potential abuses and harassment of anti-death penalty advocates, there is no good reason for exposing the identities of these people," wrote state attorney Jeffrey Cody.

Sepulvado's case underscores "troubling new developments" concerning Louisiana's planned method of execution, according to Sophie Cull, the former director of the Louisiana Coalition for Alternatives to the Death Penalty.

"Recent issues in Oklahoma, Ohio and Missouri have highlighted the national crisis surrounding lethal injection, marked by botched executions, extreme secrecy and the replacement of FDA-approved drugs with drugs of unknown sourcing and testing in new experimental combinations," she said.

The stay of execution follows a court filing last week by Gary Clements, a lawyer for Sepulvado. Clements said that Louisiana's "11th-hour" switch of execution drugs was both secretive and appeared to violate its own regulations.

"Consistent with its belief that it need not provide any information about the execution, the state has 'disclosed' its protocol in name only: petitioner has no way of knowing what drugs will actually be used in the execution," Clements wrote.

This is the 3rd time in several years that the state has changed its lethal-injection method, as states all over the country have faced nationwide shortages of execution drugs.

In February 2013, the state announced a change from a 3-drug mixture of lethal injection drugs to the single drug, pentobarbital. But that drug only has a shelf life of 3 years, and the state disposed of its supply after it expired in September.

The state couldn't find another source of pentobarbital, Laborde said.

Documents obtained by The Lens in response to a public-records request for documents regarding acquisition of pentobarbital show that in September the state received a confidentiality agreement from an Oklahoma compounding pharmacy called The Apothecary Shoppe, which is not licensed in the state of Louisiana. Several states around the country have been turning to compounding pharmacies, which aren't regulated by the FDA, to obtain lethal injection drugs.

Source: The Lens, Feb. 4, 2014

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

I witnessed Ohio's execution of Dennis McGuire. What I saw was inhumane

Dennis McGuire
I first began to visit [Ohio death-row inmate] Mcguire in November. He told me about the evil act he had committed, the murder in 1989 of a young woman Joy Stewart who was pregnant and whose unborn child also died. He confessed his sin to me, and expressed sorrow for what he had done. I said he should pray for forgiveness from the woman he had killed, and from that unborn child, and over the course of the final eight weeks, I know that he did.

After that, I had to deal with him as I do anyone else who repents: as a forgiven sinner. It can be very difficult for people not in the religion to accept that with regard to a murderer, but the faith is clear: once forgiven, you are forgiven, no matter how heinous the sin.

On the day of his execution, last Thursday, I gave him his last sacraments at Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, which lodges the "death house". Shortly before the execution was due to start, his son, daughter and daughter-in-law, who were with him at the time, asked me to come with them as witness. McGuire also said he wanted me there as his spiritual adviser.

I felt nauseous before I entered the room, as I had never seen an execution before. As the execution got underway, the nausea passed and was replaced by an intense feeling that I wanted to get out of that room, away from the horrendous act that was playing out before me.

I've seen people die many times before: in nursing homes, families I've known, my own mother. In most settings I've found death to be a very peaceful experience. But this was something else. By my count it took 26 minutes for McGuire to be pronounced dead.

He made his final statement. He said thank you to Joy Stewart's family who had offered him some words of comfort in a letter they had written to him, and he told his children that he loved them and would see them in heaven. They began to put lines into him. That was unsettling, as from what I could observe they seemed to find it hard to get insert the IV and there seemed to be blood coming from his right arm.

At 10.27am, the syringe containing the untested concoction of midazolam and hydromorphone was injected into him. At 10.30am, three minutes into the execution, he lifted his head off the gurney, and said to the family who he could see through the window: "I love you, I love you." Then he lay back down.

At about 10.31am, his stomach swelled up in an unusual way, as though he had a hernia or something like that. Between 10.33am and 10.44am – I could see a clock on the wall of the death house – he struggled and gasped audibly for air.

I was aghast. Over those 11 minutes or more he was fighting for breath, and I could see both of his fists were clenched the entire time. His gasps could be heard through the glass wall that separated us.


Source: The Guardian, January 22, 2014

What Happens to the Death Penalty When Lethal Injection Isn’t Quick and Painless?

San Quentin's brand new death chamber
For decades supporters of the death penalty in America have embraced lethal injection not just as an evolutionary plateau in the method of capital punishment but as a convenient solution to a problem that is both legal and moral. By purporting to ease the suffering of the condemned as he is killed, the procedure is supposed to neutralize concerns that any particular execution is “cruel” under the Eighth Amendment. And by purporting to put the prisoner to deep sleep first before the poison was administered, the practice is supposed to assuage whatever guilt exists in the minds of the executioner, or the administrator, over the intentional taking of life. We hide behind science, in other words, and then pat ourselves on the back for our ingenuity.

But these two pillars of support for lethal injection have always been based on a form of deceit. Making executions tidier does not make the dead any less dead or those who authorize the poison any less culpable for taking life. It is the act of capital punishment itself, not just the manner in which it is carried out, that carries the moral force. And no human development, no magic pill, no sterile syringe, can change that. This profound question is pertinent again, as a practical matter as well as a legal and political one, because recent developments in the practice of lethal injections have raised new doubts about the pain associated with their use. And if lethal injection protocols cause profound suffering the landscape of capital punishment as we know it may change.


Source: The Daily Beast, January 21, 2014

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Unclear future for death penalty in Ohio

USA: An Execution Frenzy
Ohio's latest experience with putting an inmate to death raises new question about the ability of states to carry out executions in constitutional fashion.

It took Dennis McGuire 26 minutes to die on Thursday after the chemicals — intravenous doses of the sedative midazolam and the painkiller hydromorphone — began flowing into his body. Initial reports said McGuire took more than 15 minutes to die. His death marked the longest execution of the 53 carried out in Ohio since capital punishment resumed 15 years ago.

McGuire, who was sentenced to die for raping and stabbing a pregnant newlywed to death in 1989, appeared unconscious but gasped repeatedly as he lay on a gurney, with his stomach rising and falling and his mouth opening and shutting.

Deborah Denno, a professor of law at Fordham University, said that a lethal injection is supposed to last about three or four minutes.

"It's hard to know exactly what went wrong," Denno told Al Jazeera. "These drugs had never been used on a human being before, and experts had predicted that these very kinds of reactions could occur."

Whether McGuire, 53, felt any pain was unclear. His death — unconsciousness, followed by apparent obstructed breathing — followed the prediction of one state expert.

The question may center on states' tolerance for a constitutional method that is difficult to observe, said Doug Berman, an Ohio State University law professor and death penalty expert.

"How much will Ohio care, how much will the rest of the country care, that it seems that what we now have discovered is Ohio is using a method that gets the job done, but looks ugly," Berman said. "We don't know if it actually was ugly. We just know that it looked ugly."


'Nobody deserves that'

Members of McGuire's family, who plan to file a lawsuit against the state, said the execution amounted to torture.

"Nobody deserves to go through that," said McGuire's son, also named Dennis.

States are in a bind for two main reasons: European companies have cut off supplies of certain execution drugs because of opposition to the death penalty. And states can't simply switch to other chemicals without triggering legal challenges from defense attorneys.

In light of what happened in Ohio, "states will now have more of a burden to show that they are using a well-thought-out best practice," said Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center.


Source: Al Jazeera, January 19, 2014

After a Prolonged Execution in Ohio, Questions Over ‘Cruel and Unusual’

Dennis McGuire
As the lethal drugs flowed into his veins in the Ohio death chamber, Dennis B. McGuire at first “went unconscious” and his body was still, his daughter, Amber McGuire, said Friday.

But a few minutes later, she said, she was horrified to see her father struggling, his stomach heaving, a fist clenching.

“He started making all these horrible, horrible noises, and at that point, that’s when I covered my eyes and my ears,” said Ms. McGuire, who watched the execution on Thursday at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, near Lucasville. “He was suffering.”

Mr. McGuire’s execution, conducted with a new and untested combination of drugs, took about 25 minutes from the time the drugs were started to the time death was declared. The process, several witnesses said, was accompanied by movement and gasping, snorting and choking sounds.

It has not been established whether Mr. McGuire was conscious of pain or whether the drugs that were used were responsible for his prolonged death. But at a time when the drugs once routinely used in executions are in short supply and states are scrambling to find new formulas, the execution is stirring intense debate about the obligations of the state toward those it kills.


Source: NYT, January 18, 2014

Related Video:  Son of executed Ohio man breaks silence (edition.cnn.com)

The son of Dennis McGuire describes what it was like to witness his father's execution by a new mix of lethal drugs.

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Ohio executes Dennis McGuire

Dennis McGuire
A man convicted of murder in the US state of Ohio has been executed using a new, never-before-tried lethal injection combination.

Dennis McGuire, 53, was killed on Thursday with a two-drug cocktail, after the maker of the previous execution drug refused to allow its use in capital punishment.

His lawyers argued the new method would cause him to experience extreme terror.

McGuire was sentenced to death for the 1989 rape and murder of Joy Stewart.

Stewart was pregnant.

In recent years, US states have had increasing difficulty obtaining drugs for use in lethal injections, as their manufacturers have grown unwilling to provide them for that use.

Ohio officials elected to use intravenous doses of the sedative midazolam and painkiller hydromorphone for McGuire's execution.

Lawyers for McGuire had said the drugs placed him at risk of air hunger, a phenomenon which causes terror as the patient struggles to catch his breath.

During the more than 15-minute procedure, McGuire gasped several times and his mouth repeatedly opened and closed, according to an Associated Press news agency reporter who witnessed the execution.

'I'm going to heaven, I'll see you there when you come,' he said in the small, windowless room in the Lucasville correctional facility. He was pronounced dead at 10:53 a.m., after one of the longest executions since Ohio resumed capital punishment in 1999.

McGuire thanked his 22-year-old victim's family for a letter he received from them, referring to 'kind words' that meant a lot. Joy Stewart's sister Carol Avery wrote in the note that she had forgiven him but also insisted 'it is time - past time - for him to pay for what he did to my sister.'

The 53-year-old opened and shut his hands as if waving to his adult son, daughter and daughter-in-law sitting a few feet away and a full minute later he stood up and told them, 'I love you, I love you.'

McGuire's last meal yesterday consisted of roast beef, a cream cheese bagel, fried chicken, potatoes two ways, butter pecan ice cream and Coca-Cola. He skipped a shower and breakfast this morning and had a final visit with his children before the scheduled execution.

On Wednesday, he arrived calmly at the death house and spent the night writing letters, phoning his mother and sister and visiting with his son and daughter.

An Ohio federal judge had rejected a last-minute appeal to delay the execution after McGuire's legal team argued a jury never heard details of his reportedly troubled childhood.

McGuire's lawyers alleged he was abused, leading to impaired brain function that made him prone to impulsive actions.

Ohio Governor John Kasich also rejected McGuire's efforts to become an organ donor, a legal manoeuvre that previously allowed another death row inmate an eight-month reprieve.

Source: BBC News, Daily Mail, January 16, 2014


Ohio killer’s execution takes almost 25 minutes

LUCASVILLE, Ohio — A condemned man appeared to gasp several times and took an unusually long time to die — more than 20 minutes — in an execution carried out Thursday with a combination of drugs never before tried in the U.S.

Dennis McGuire’s attorney Allen Bohnert called the convicted killer’s death “a failed, agonizing experiment” and added: “The people of the state of Ohio should be appalled at what was done here today in their names.”

McGuire’s lawyers had attempted last week to block his execution, arguing that the untried method could lead to a medical phenomenon known as “air hunger” and cause him to suffer “agony and terror” while struggling to catch his breath.

McGuire, 53, made loud snorting noises during one of the longest executions since Ohio resumed capital punishment in 1999. Nearly 25 minutes passed between the time the lethal drugs began flowing and McGuire was pronounced dead at 10:53 a.m.

Executions under the old method were typically much shorter and did not cause the kind of sounds McGuire made.

Prison officials gave intravenous doses of two drugs, the sedative midazolam and the painkiller hydromorphone, to put McGuire to death for the 1989 rape and fatal stabbing of a pregnant newlywed, Joy Stewart.

The method was adopted after supplies of a previously used drug dried up because the manufacturer declared it off limits for capital punishment.

The execution is certain to launch a new round of federal lawsuits over Ohio’s injection procedure. The state has five more executions scheduled this year, with the next one to come on Feb. 19.

What was particularly unusual Thursday was the five minutes or so that McGuire lay motionless on the gurney after the drugs began flowing, followed by a sudden snort and then more than 10 minutes of irregular breathing and gasping. Normally, movement comes at the beginning and is followed by inactivity.

In pressing for the execution to go ahead, Assistant Ohio Attorney General Thomas Madden had argued that while the U.S. Constitution bans cruel and unusual punishment, “you’re not entitled to a pain-free execution.”

U.S. District Judge Gregory Frost sided with the state. But at the request of McGuire’s lawyers, he ordered officials to photograph and preserve the drug vials, packaging and syringes.

A few minutes before McGuire was put to death, Ohio prison director Gary Mohr said he believed the state’s planning would produce “a humane, dignified execution” consistent with the law.

Click here to read the full article

Source: The Washington Post, January 16, 2014

Prisons Have Begun Treating The Death Penalty Like a Science Experiment

Unintended consequences of a boycott

Pentobarbital and sodium thiopental are anaesthetics, used around the world by doctors and vets on all kinds of patients in a variety of cases. They are also used to render prisoners unconscious in the ten U.S. states that use lethal injection to execute their condemned.

That is, as long as they can obtain the drug. Since pharmaceutical company Hospira stopped manufacturing sodium thiopental in early 2011, there hasn’t been a domestic producer of either drug within the U.S. American prisons rely on either one of the drugs as the first of the three used in the standard cocktail given to those due to be executed—the others being pancuronium bromide, which paralyses all of the muscles in the body, and potassium chloride, which stops the heart.

A couple of years later, and prisons have started to use up the stockpiles, bought from before production ceased. The result is the rise of new, untested drugs in execution cocktails. Here’s the Guardian from yesterday:

On Thursday, the state of Ohio is scheduled to inject Dennis McGuire, 53, with two drugs: first, the sedative midazolam; then, the painkiller hydromorphone. When it is over, McGuire, who was convicted of the 1989 rape and murder of Joy Stewart, will be dead—which is Ohio’s goal. But the procedure is untried and untested; the drugs that the state will employ have never been used in a death chamber. And experts have warned in legal proceedings that if the process goes wrong, McGuire will not just peacefully drift away, but will be awake, struggling and failing to pull enough air into his lungs, until the drug overdose that will kill him takes hold.

"McGuire will experience the agony and terror of air hunger as he struggles to breathe for five minutes after defendants intravenously inject him with the execution drugs," his lawyers have said in court documents.

But on Monday a federal judge in Columbus, Ohio, ruled that McGuire's execution could go ahead. Judge Gregory Frost found that there was insufficient evidence to show a substantial risk of severe pain for the condemned man and said that “Ohio is free to innovate and to evolve its procedures for administering capital punishment.”

An Ohio state prosecutor, addressing the court, said: "You're not entitled to a pain-free execution.”

That last point is contentious—much of the motivation for making sure that executions are calm and painless is to avoid accusations that they might constitute a “cruel and unusual punishment,” as prohibited by the Eighth Amendment. Lethal injection is used specifically because it is seen as less painful than historical forms of execution, such as beheading, electrocution, or firing squad.

Yet the pretense of kindness relies on there being no struggle from the condemned prisoner. While there is no sure way of knowing the pain that someone experiences when getting the sodium thiopental/pancurium bromide/potassium chloride cocktail, there are several cases of prisoners appearing to be in severe pain. A typical lethal injection death should be completed within seven minutes. Often that time is exceeded, sometimes by one or two hours, and throughout the execution the prisoner can be twitching, shaking, blinking, or appearing to try to speak.


Source: New Republic, January 15, 2014

US prisons stockpiling medicines for executions while hospitals face shortages

Prisons in the US are sitting on large stockpiles of life-saving medicines, which they plan to use in executions, while hospitals face shortages of the same drugs.

Death rows in Florida and Ohio have both bought up supplies of midazolam – a sedative used in surgery and to treat seizures – in order to carry out executions by lethal injection. Ohio has also bought quantities of hydromorphone, an opiate pain-killer, which it is planning to use today along with midazolam in its new lethal injection protocol.

The American Society of Health-System Pharmacists has warned that the US is facing current shortages of both midazolam and hydromorphone – leading to concerns that patients may be denied potentially life-saving drugs while prisons stockpile them in order to kill.

Executioners in Florida and Ohio not only already hold stashes of the drugs, but are expected to seek further supplies as they reach their expiry dates, potentially worsening the existing shortage.

Joel Zivot, Medical Director of the Cardiothoracic Intensive Care Unit at Emory University Hospital, says the USA is facing a “public health emergency” because of the shortages. He says he is “shocked and appalled” that vital drugs which are in short supply for life-saving medical use are being hoarded by prisons for use in executions.

In addition, Ohio has also been warned by a leading expert that the execution it plans to carry out today using midazolam and hydromorphone – which will be the first of its kind – may cause the prisoner to experience “the terror of air hunger during the first five minutes of the execution.” The warning was made this week by Harvard anaesthesiologist Dr David Waisel.

Commenting, Maya Foa, Director of legal charity Reprieve’s death penalty team said: “It is a scandal that executioners are hoarding medicines in order to kill, while those who want to use them to save lives face shortages. Regardless of anyone’s views on the death penalty, surely we can all agree that saving lives should take priority over executing prisoners. This is yet another sign of how blinkered, cruel and unthinking US executioners have become in their desperate drive to keep on killing.”

Source: Reprieve, January 16, 2014

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Tinkering with Ohio's machinery of death: Jack Shuler

On January 16, the state of Ohio will become the first state to use a combination of the sedative midazolam and painkiller hydromorphone when it executes condemned killer Dennis McGuire. Some experts claim the deadly combo could result in seizures, vomiting, spasms, and suffocation. These changes represent the most recent technological advances in the long history of the death penalty. But how far have we really come?

How the drugs are manufactured and what drugs are used does not alter the fact that, as a state, we are using our innovation, our intelligence, our energy, and, quite frankly, our resources to kill a human being.

In the early 19th century, governments throughout Europe and across the United States began adjusting execution protocols to placate critics of the death penalty. To keep people from becoming desensitized to violence, hangings were moved behind prison walls and away from crowds. Ohio followed suit in 1885, and moved hangings behind the walls of the state penitentiary.

In the second half of the 19th century, enlightened hangmen worked on engineering a swifter death. In 1866, an Irish doctor named Samuel Haughton noted that death from hanging comes in three possible ways: from apoplexy, asphyxia or a fractured “vertebral column.” He suggested that a longer, more precise drop would dislocate the hanged person’s neck, a possibly more humane treatment.

Haughton wrote, “It seems to me unworthy to the present state of science to continue a mode of execution which … is extremely clumsy and also painful to the criminal.” His solution took into account the condemned person’s height and weight when determining how far he should drop from the gallows. Haughton claimed this would ensure a hangman’s fracture and thus a swift death.

Perhaps influenced by Haughton’s essay, English hangman William Marwood devised a measuring table in the 1870s that accounted for the height and weight of the condemned when determining the length of rope for an execution. The “Table of Drops” eventually made its way to the United States.

And yet, no matter how precise the drop became, no matter how much the process was perfected, hangmen could never account for the many ways the human body reacts to violence, to trauma, to pain. Necks stretched. Faces contorted. Bowels evacuated. Ropes snapped and the half-dead had to be re-hanged. Drops were too long and people were decapitated.

In 1885, New York Governor David B. Hill remarked that hanging executions were a carryover from the “dark ages” and wondered if modern science could offer a “less barbarous manner” for killing condemned criminals.

Hanging had become fully shameful to the citizen spectator. For many, execution by hanging brought to mind ghastly public spectacles or lynching. It was seen as an archaic punishment, out of step with modern sensibilities. People couldn’t escape the fact that a real, live person was at the end of that rope.

It didn’t take long for the electric chair and the gas chamber to supplant the noose in the United States. In 1889, William Kemmler became the first person to be put to death by electrocution in Auburn, N.Y. Ohio introduced the electric chair eight years later. And in 1924, Gee Jon became the first American to be executed by lethal gas in Carson City, Nev. Not only were these new technologies modern marvels, but gas and electricity were widely believed to kill more quickly, more humanely.

However, both led to horrific deaths — through burning and asphyxiation — that must have traumatized the viewers and tortured the condemned. There was a real, live person sitting on that electric chair; a real, live person inside that gas chamber.

Today, the private, bureaucratic and antiseptic process of lethal injection is a far cry from the ugly spectacle of a public hanging. It is the end result of an apparently progressive history. But is it any better?

We can continue to tinker with the machinery of death, to borrow Justice Harry A. Blackmun’s phrase. We can fool ourselves that we are humanizing this process, that we are executing the worst of the worse. But as with all other manners of executing, the problem with lethal injection is that a real, live person is strapped to that gurney. How far have we really come?


- Op-Ed by Jack Shuler, January 7, 2014 This article was originally published on Cleveland.com. Mr. Shuler is an author, John and Christine Warner Professor and assistant professor of English at Denison University. His forthcoming book is titled “The Noose: A History,” a study of the history of hanging from the Iron Age to today. Also by Jack Shuler on this website: The Other Iranian Execution Stories, October 29, 2013, and The questions Ohio should be asking about the death penalty, November 8, 2013.

Friday, January 3, 2014

Florida Supreme Court rules execution drug is effective sedative

The Florida Supreme Court unanimously upheld the state's new lethal injection procedure, clearing the way for the execution of a death row inmate who argued it was ineffective and caused needless suffering.

Askari Abdullah Muhammad, formerly known as Thomas Knight, was due to be executed Dec. 3, but the state Supreme Court ordered a stay last month to hear arguments about the effectiveness of the drug, midazolam hydrochloride, which is used as an anesthetic prior to administering 2 other drugs that cause paralysis and then death.

A Circuit Court judge ruled earlier this month that midazolam is an FDA-approved drug routinely used as a pre-anesthetic sedative and said "the evidence was undisputed" that the correct dosage of the drug would render an inmate unconscious.

The Supreme Court agreed on Thursday that the drug was effective and lifted the stay on Muhammad's execution.

"Muhammad failed to establish that the current 3-drug lethal injection protocol using midazolam hydrochloride as the 1st drug in the procedure presents a serious risk of needless suffering or sufficient imminent danger in violation of the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment," the court wrote.

The state has used the drug only twice and, in its first use, some movement of the prisoner caused opponents of capital punishment to claim he was suffering.

Muhammad was convicted of the fatal stabbing of a death row prison guard, Richard Burke.

He was also sentenced to die in 1974 for the abduction, robbery and murder of a Miami couple, Sydney and Lillian Gans.

Aside from his challenge to the 1st execution drug, Muhammad also argued that his 3 decades on death row violated the U.S. Constitution's ban on "cruel and unusual punishments" and affected his mental health.

The justices held that both the state and Muhammad's defense team were at least partly responsible for his time under death sentence, and that lengthy periods he spent in solitary confinement "does not provide a sufficient distinguishing basis for this court to depart from its established precedent on this issue."

Several other Florida inmates have also argued in court that the U.S. Constitution's ban on "cruel and unusual punishments" should bar use of midazolam as the 1st part of the 3-drug death protocol adopted by Florida's Department of Corrections.

In the 2 previous executions involving midazolam last month, the Department of Corrections said it was a humane replacement for pentobarbital, the sedative used previously.

Source: Reuters, January 2, 2014

Saturday, December 21, 2013

Florida Supreme Court approves state's new lethal injection procedure

Florida Death Chamber
Florida Death Chamber
The Florida Supreme Court approved the state's new lethal injection procedure Thursday, signaling that the stayed execution of an inmate on death row who challenged the procedure can take place.

The inmate, Askari Abdullah Muhammad, formerly known as Thomas Knight, filed an appeal to his execution on Dec. 3, on a claim that the drug to be used, midazolam hydrochloride, may not prevent pain.

The Supreme Court denied the claim, supporting the district court's ruling in late November.

The district court in Bradford County ruled that there was no evidence that the drug causes or is “very likely to cause serious illness and needless suffering,” and gives rise to “sufficiently imminent dangers.”

That opinion was based on testimony from an anesthesiologist, pharmacy professor and state inspector who witnessed an execution in which the drug was used — on William Happ on Oct. 15.

The Happ execution raised concerns after journalists' testimonies said that Happ moved several minutes after the administration of the drug.

Dr. Mark Heath, the anesthesiologist at Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center who testified in the district court, said that although he didn't have enough information on the movements made by Happ to conclude on the reason, he speculated that Happ might not have been fully anesthetized.

However, he concluded that the drug, in the dosage used by the Department of Corrections — which is 500 milligrams — would induce unconsciousness, respiratory failure and death.

Lee Evans, a pharmacy professor at Auburn University, also testifying on behalf of the state, said the drug in half the dosage amount used by the state would render a person unconscious within one and a half to two minutes.

Evans also said Happ's movement could have been a compensation for the respiratory failure induced by the drug.

The Supreme Court concluded that a drug that makes inmates unconscious works effectively.

Deborah Denno, a law professor at Fordham University in New York, who has studied lethal injection procedures in the U.S., disagreed with the ruling. She pointed out that in the case of Heath's testimony, “As an anesthesiologist in a hospital setting, that's an entirely different kettle of fish than what happens in a prison setting.”

She also said that the court struck down Muhammad's requests for information, for example, on members of the execution team and their qualifications.

“The process remains absolutely shut and sealed and secretive,” she said.

Dr. Joel Zivot, an assistant professor of anesthesiology at Emory University, questions the soundness of any scientific conclusion of the true effect of the drug used in an execution.

“You cannot guarantee that there is not awareness,” Zivot said. “These drugs aren't intended to be used to kill people,”

The Florida Department of Corrections had no comment on the ruling and has previously said that it started using midazolam hydrochloride because of a shortage of the drug it had previously used, pentobarbital sodium.

Zivot pointed out that there is also a shortage of midazolam hydrochloride in the clinic. According to the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists website, the drug is in short supply.

This shortage is another reason the Florida Supreme Court's decision is worrying, Zivot said.

“Instead of being given to patients, (the drug) is used to kill people. That doesn't seem ethical to me,” Zivot said.

Muhammad, 62, was convicted of killing corrections officer Richard Burke in 1980 in Miami-Dade County.

The DOC could not say when the execution of Muhammad would take place.

Source: The Gainsville Sun, December 20, 2013

Thursday, December 19, 2013

European boycott of death penalty drugs lowers rate of US executions

New Death Penalty Information Center report claims there were 39 executions this year – the lowest number since 1994.

The European-led boycott of medical drugs used by US corrections departments to execute prisoners is having such an impact that it has driven the number of executions to an almost all-time low, a leading authority on the death penalty has concluded.

The year-end report for 2013 from the Death Penalty Information Center, based in Washington, records that there were 39 executions this year – only the second time since 1994 that the number has fallen below 40. The report says a major factor behind the slump in judicial killings has been the difficulty states that still practice the death penalty are encountering in finding a consistent means of ending life.

California, Arkansas and North Carolina have all had effective moratoriums for the past seven years because they have failed to settle on a workable lethal injection protocol. Several other states are turning to untested drugs or to lethal medicines improvised in single batches by so-called “compounding pharmacies” that are not subject to federal regulations.

“The goal-posts keep shifting under the death penalty states,” said Richard Dieter, director of the Death Penalty Information Center and lead author of the report. “As soon as they move to a new protocol, the boycott spreads.”

The European Commission imposed tough restrictions on the export of anaesthetics to US corrections departments in 2011, and amid the squeeze a succession of states has been running out of their primary lethal drugs supplies. As a result, Florida has turned to midazolam hydrochloride, a drug never before used in executions, provoking an outcry that it might be inflicting cruel and unusual punishment on condemned prisoners.


Source: The Guardian, December 18, 2013

Monday, November 18, 2013

Florida: Supreme Court delays execution amid questions about new drug

In a 5-2 decision, the Florida Supreme Court on Monday ordered that Thomas Knight's scheduled execution be delayed so he can argue that a new drug used to sedate a prisoner at the start of the lethal injection process could subject him to "serious harm." Knight, also known as Askari Abdullah Muhammad, had been scheduled to die at Florida State Prison on Dec. 3.

Florida is the only state in the U.S. that uses midazolam hydrochloride as an anesthetic in the first stage of a three-drug lethal injection mixture. The new drug replaced pentobarbital after the state Department of Corrections exhausted its supply.

The state's high court stayed Knight's execution until at least Dec. 27 and sent his case back the state's Eighth Judicial Circuit, which includes Bradford County, where he is imprisoned. A circuit court judge must hold a hearing on the inmate's claims and issue a ruling no later than 2 p.m. Nov. 26, two days before Thanksgiving, after which time both sides can file additional arguments.

Knight has been on death row since 1975 for the murders of a Miami couple. While in prison he stabbed a correctional officer, Richard Burke, to death. It is that killing for which he is condemned to die.

In its order, the court said: "The Court has determined that Muhammad’s claim as to the use of midazolam hydrochloride as an anesthetic in the amount prescribed by Florida’s protocol warrants an evidentiary hearing. We conclude based on the allegations in Muhammad’s 3.851 motion that he has raised a factual dispute, not conclusively refuted, as to whether the use of midazolam hydrochloride in Florida’s lethal injection protocol will subject him to a 'substantial risk of serious harm.'

"We further direct the DOC (Department of Corrections) to produce correspondence and documents it has received from the manufacturer of midazolam hydrochloride concerning the drug’s use in executions or otherwise, including those addressing any safety and efficacy issues," the court ordered.

Justices Barbara Pariente, Fred Lewis, Peggy Quince, Jorge Labarga and James Perry were in the majority. Chief Justice Ricky Polston and Justice Charles Canady dissented.

Source: Tampa Bay Times, November 18, 2013

Missouri courts, governor still weighing Franklin execution

The Missouri Supreme Court and Gov. Jay Nixon continued Monday to weigh requests to halt the execution of Joseph Paul Franklin, with time dwindling before the serial killer is scheduled to be put to death.

Franklin, 63, faces execution one minute after midnight on Wednesday. It would be the first in Missouri in nearly three years and the first ever using a single execution drug, the sedative pentobarbital.

Franklin was convicted of killing 42-year-old Gerald Gordon in a sniper attack outside a suburban St. Louis synagogue in 1977. It was one of as many as 20 killings committed by Franklin, a white supremacist who targeted blacks and Jews in a cross-country killing spree from 1977 to 1980. He was convicted of seven other murders — including the Aug. 20, 1980, slayings of David Martin and Ted Fields in Salt Lake City — but the Missouri case was the only one resulting in a death sentence.

Franklin declined multiple Associated Press interview requests but granted a lengthy interview to The Salt Lake Tribune available here.

It wasn’t clear when Nixon would rule on clemency. His spokesman, Scott Holste, said the governor did not yet have anything to announce. Meanwhile, Franklin’s attorney, Jennifer Herndon, said she was still awaiting a ruling from the Missouri Supreme Court.

Last month, Nixon stopped the execution of another convicted killer, Allen Nicklasson, over concerns about Missouri’s plan to use propofol as the lethal drug. The European Union had threatened to limit export if propofol was used in the execution, potentially creating a nationwide shortage of the popular anesthetic.

The Missouri Department of Corrections revised its protocol days later, changing to pentobarbital that will be made through a compounding pharmacy. Because the compounding pharmacy is part of the execution team, few details about it have been made public.

Herndon last week filed a motion for a stay of execution with the Missouri Supreme Court, citing concerns about how the drug is made and what could happen if it doesn’t work properly, potentially leaving the inmate in pain or brain-damaged but not dead.

Amid court cases and the shortage of execution drugs, Missouri has executed just two men in the past eight years — most recently Martin Link in February 2011.

Herndon said Franklin, a paranoid schizophrenic, now regrets his crimes, having had a change of heart after serving time alongside black inmates.

Franklin was in his mid-20s when he began drifting across America 36 years ago, robbing up to 16 banks to fund his travels.

He bombed a synagogue in Chattanooga, Tenn., in July 1977. No one was hurt, but the killings began soon after that, many of them sniper shootings. Franklin has claimed as many as 20 victims.

He had a particular dislike for interracial couples — several of his victims were black men and the white women with them.

He arrived in suburban St. Louis and picked out Brith Sholom Kneseth Israel synagogue from the Yellow Pages. On Oct. 8, 1977, a bar mitzvah ended and guests were on the parking lot when Franklin opened fire from a grassy area nearby, killing Gordon.

Franklin got away and committed a string of other killings in several other states. He was caught after killing Martin and Fields, two young black men who had just finished jogging with two teenage white girls in Salt Lake City’s Liberty Park on Aug. 20, 1980. Years later, in federal prison, he admitted to the St. Louis County killing. He was sentenced to death in 1997.

In addition to the killings, Franklin has admitted shooting and wounding civil rights leader Vernon Jordan and Hustler magazine publisher Larry Flynt.

Flynt, paralyzed from the waist down since the shooting in 1978, has also sued to stop the execution, telling The Associated Press he does not believe it is a deterrent.

Source: Associated Press, November 18, 2013

Secretive scramble for lethal injection drugs prompts concern

Missouri intends to carry out an execution Wednesday with drugs supplied by a pharmacy the state will not name, highlighting the growing lengths prisons are going to in order to buy lethal ingredients.

Campaigners have said that new lethal injection methods — being used after pharmaceutical firms refused to sell execution states their products — are unethical, unconstitutional and could amount to torture.

Moreover, as more drug-makers refuse to be part of the execution game, state officials are hiding the trail of their drug purchases — in some cases refusing to divulge the suppliers’ names or making purchases through petty cash and via seemingly defunct hospitals in order to disguise the paper trail.

“If you mask executions in a shroud of secrecy, vital oversight is lost,” Maya Foa, death penalty director for Reprieve, told Al Jazeera. “There is a risk that bad drugs could be used — and journalists, lawyers and the public would have no means of knowing what exactly is being injected into the prisoner.”

The scramble for drugs comes amid a backdrop of a drop in overall support for executions. According to a Gallup poll published last month, the number of Americans in favor of the death penalty is at its lowest point in over 40 years, with a 60 percent approval rating. It is down from a high of 80 percent in 1994.

In all, some 32 states currently have death penalty policies. Last week alone saw Florida and Texas proceed with the execution of convicted murderers. Ohio was scheduled to put a convicted child killer, Ronald Phillips, to death last Thursday, but a last-minute decision to stay the execution was made so that medical experts can assess whether or not his non-vital organs or tissues can be donated to his mother or possibly others.

But finding the means to carry out the ultimate sentence has become harder for execution states.


Source: Al Jazeera, November 18, 2013

Thursday, November 14, 2013

USA: The Lethal Injection Debacle

Our European allies are imposing economic sanctions. Multinational pharmaceutical companies are threatening our supply of vital drugs. At the same time, medical practitioners have been drawn into an area that is foreign to them.

How did the U.S. get itself into this position? Blame the death penalty.

In an attempt to carry out long-scheduled executions, states have been embarrassing themselves in a frenetic scramble to secure execution drugs from wherever they can find them.

Increasingly, they are resorting to secrecy and backup execution protocols necessitated by drug shortages instead of treating those condemned to death with the dignity appropriate to any human life.

A short list of recent developments illustrates the debacle that encompasses today's practice of lethal injection:

--In an attempt to obtain execution drugs, many states turned to a tiny overseas distributor called "Dream Pharma," located in the back of a driving school in London. The drugs were seized by the U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency, and the United Kingdom quickly took measures to prevent further exports.

-Ohio has changed its execution protocol 5 times in recent years. Its latest proposal is to use a 2nd-tier backup procedure, involving a combination of drugs never before applied in an execution.

--Florida also instituted an un-tried combination of drugs, different from Ohio's. Florida begins with the injection of midazolam, identified as a sedative rather than an anesthetic. The next drug paralyzes the inmate so no pain can be observed; it then injects an extremely painful liquid salt, potassium chloride. If the midazolam does not anesthetize the inmate effectively, the execution will be excruciating - though no one but the inmate will notice.

--A few months ago, Texas announced its lethal injection drugs were reaching their expiration date. Shortly before its next scheduled execution, the state suddenly found a new source for the drug it had been using (pentobarbital): a compounding pharmacy in Houston, unregulated by the Food and Drug Administration. Once the source became public, the pharmacy demanded the return of the drugs, but Texas declined. Last year, contaminated drugs from a compounding pharmacy killed 60 people.

--Missouri also announced it would introduce a new drug into the lethal injection process - propofol. When the German manufacturer responsible for almost all of the propofol used in the U.S. heard of this plan, it protested, indicating the entire supply of propofol for vital surgeries in the U.S. could be jeopardized. Missouri returned the drug and is now resorting to a compounding pharmacy, declaring them part of the state's "execution team."

Using drugs to kill people is not new.

As hangings began to appear distasteful, New York considered using lethal injections as far back as 1890. It chose a newer technology instead - the electric chair - to carry out executions.

Starting in 1976, when the Supreme Court allowed capital punishment to resume after a 4-year pause to allow states to draft more precise death penalty laws, states began investigating alternative approaches to carrying out the death penalty.

In Oklahoma a coroner suggested a 3-drug execution process, without stipulating who would oversee the procedure. Compared to the electric chair or the gas chamber, it seemed a more palatable means of taking human life.

Texas, in 1982, became the 1st state to carry out a lethal injection, using a 3-drug procedure.

Eventually, every death-penalty state and the federal government adopted lethal injection, and the U.S. Supreme Court gave its approval in 2008. Over 1,000 lethal-injection executions were carried out around the country before the present crisis emerged.

Although many lethal injections did not go as planned, the most embarrassing incident occurred in Ohio in 2009.

Romell Broom was strapped to the gurney and prodded with IV needles for nearly 2 hours before the governor called a halt to the failed proceedings. Ohio recognized that changes had to be made, and it became the 1st state in the country to use a single-drug (sodium thiopental) in executions.

The sole supplier of sodium thiopental to the U.S. was an Illinois-based company named Hospira, Inc.

In 2010 Hospira announced it objected to the use of its drug in executions and eventually ceased production altogether, citing objections to the death penalty by Italian workers who manufactured the drug.

Since all states were using thiopental, they were forced to change their execution process.

After sources from overseas were cut off by a federal court ruling that imported drugs must be controlled by the Food and Drug Administration, most states turned to a drug called pentobarbital, which was widely used for anesthetic purposes in the U.S.

Although the supply at first seemed sufficient, the main manufacturer of pentobarbital - Lundbeck, Inc. of Denmark - issued a strong statement condemning the use of this drug in executions and promising to restrict its sale to prisons.

With no new supply, the existing quantities of pentobarbital began to expire. Many states searched for either alternative sources or alternative drugs to carry out executions.

Compounding pharmacies, which can prepare a single dose of a drug in response to a prescription, and which are not as well known as the large pharmaceutical companies, became a natural choice for execution drugs.

South Dakota was the first to use this source in 2012. Other more prolific execution states such as Texas, Ohio, Georgia, and Missouri also announced they would use compounding pharmacies.

However, these pharmacies are part of the medical profession, and states' efforts to involve the medical community have often been met with resistance.

States adopted various strategies in response. Missouri's included a pharmacy in its "execution team." Ohio added "Medical Team" to its execution protocol. But the growing difficulties in obtaining drugs from compounding pharmacies may spell future trouble in persisting with this medical model of taking lives.

The use of new drugs and new, unregulated sources is under attack in the courts, with the international community and the medical profession watching closely. Every change to a state execution procedure is challenged in court by those about to be executed. On the international front, the European Commission has imposed export controls on various drugs used in executions. Within the medical community, organizations such as the American Society of Anesthesiologists have issued statements warning of drugs being removed from the market because of their use in executions.

Congress is already considering FDA control over compounding pharmacies, following the string of deaths that occurred in 2012 from contaminated drugs produced by these pharmacies.

But with the death penalty already declining in public support and use, the lethal injection crisis may be one more indicator that capital punishment no longer comports with our evolving standards of decency.

Source: Richard Dieter is Executive Director of the Death Penalty Information Center, thecrimereport.org, November 12, 2013

Thursday, November 7, 2013

US judges dismiss Florida death penalty challenge

JACKSONVILLE — Two federal judges threw out Wednesday challenges from seven Florida death row inmates arguing that the state's use of its lethal injection drug constitutes cruel and unusual punishment, but said the decision was based on legal technicalities.

U.S. District Court Judges Marcia Morales Howard and Timothy J. Corrigan said Wednesday that the lawsuits are not trivial, as a state assistant attorney general asserted, and gave the inmates and their lawyers 60 days to file new complaints. The state Attorney General's Office will then have 30 days to respond.

The lawsuit stems from the state's recent change of its execution protocol to include the sedative midazolam hydrochloride, instead of the previously used pentobarbital.

"Midazolam is not intended for use as an anesthetic," the lawsuit said, adding that it is typically used to sedate patients before anesthesia is administered. "Its use in this context is wholly untested."

The seven inmates are challenging the new procedure in U.S. District Courts in Jacksonville, Ocala, Tampa and Orlando. The inmates had earlier sued to stop the previous lethal injection drug mix and filed amended complaints to reflect the new procedures. They now will have to file more amended complaints.

The ruling will not affect the scheduled execution of Darious Kimbrough next week because he is not one of the inmates appealing the new protocol, said attorney Maria DeLiberato, one of the attorneys representing the seven inmates. Kimbrough broke into the Orlando apartment of 28-year-old Denise Collins as she slept in October 1991. He sexually assaulted Collins and then beat her to death.

The judges questioned the evidence from the inmates' attorneys and state lawyers. Neither side submitted medical expert statements.

"If it's so great, why weren't they using it before?" Corrigan asked Assistant Attorney General Scott Brown Thursday, referring to midazolam. Brown responded that enough is administered to render the inmate unconscious.

Corrigan said he was not questioning whether the use of the new drug is proper, but he wanted more evidence from medical experts.

Source: AP, November 7, 2013