Showing posts with label Jewish community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jewish community. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Missouri executes Joseph Paul Franklin

Joseph Paul Franklin
Joseph Paul Franklin
White supremacist serial killer Joseph Paul Franklin was executed Wednesday morning after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected his final requests for a stay, prison officials in Bonne Terre, Missouri, said. CNN affiliate KMOV reported Franklin was executed at 6:17 a.m. CT (7:17 a.m. ET).

The execution, which had been scheduled for shortly after midnight Wednesday, was delayed for hours because of court appeals.

Source: CNN, November 20, 2013





Missouri executes serial killer Joseph Paul Franklin

BONNE TERRE, Mo. — Joseph Paul Franklin, a white supremacist who targeted blacks and Jews in a cross-country killing spree from 1977 to 1980, was put to death Wednesday in Missouri, the state's first execution in nearly three years.

Franklin, 63, was executed at the state prison in Bonne Terre for killing Gerald Gordon in a sniper shooting at a suburban St. Louis synagogue in 1977. Franklin was convicted of seven other murders across the country and claimed responsibility for up to 20 overall, but the Missouri case was the only one that brought a death sentence.

Mike O'Connell, of the Missouri Department of Corrections, said Franklin was pronounced dead at 6:17 a.m.

The execution was the first in Missouri using a single drug, pentobarbital.

Franklin's fate was sealed early Wednesday when the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a federal appeals court ruling that overturned two stays granted Tuesday evening by district court judges in Missouri.

Franklin also admitted to shooting and wounding civil rights leader Vernon Jordan and Hustler magazine publisher Larry Flynt, who has been paralyzed from the waist down since the attack in 1978.

Franklin, a paranoid schizophrenic who grew up in Mobile, Ala., was in his mid-20s in 1977 when he began drifting across America, robbing up to 16 banks to fund his travels.

He bombed a synagogue in Chattanooga, Tenn., in July that year. No one was hurt, but the killings began soon after that, many of them sniper shootings.

Franklin had a particular dislike for interracial couples — several of his victims were black men and the white women with them.

He arrived in suburban St. Louis and picked out Brith Sholom Kneseth Israel synagogue from the Yellow Pages. On Oct. 8, 1977, a bar mitzvah ended and guests were in the parking lot when Franklin opened fire from a grassy area nearby, killing Gordon, 42.

The killings continued for three more years. Franklin was finally caught after killing two young black men who were about to go jogging with two teenage white girls in Salt Lake City in August 1980.

Years later, in federal prison, he admitted to the St. Louis County killing. He was sentenced to death in 1997.

Franklin, in the days leading up to the execution, said in several interviews that he was sorry for his crimes and was no longer a racist.

Source: AP, November 20, 2013

Missouri: Stay of execution lifted for Joseph Paul Franklin

BONNE TERRE, Mo. (AP) — A federal appeals court has upheld the execution in Missouri of white supremacist serial killer Joseph Paul Franklin, restoring the state's plans to kill Franklin just hours after the execution was blocked.

The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled early Wednesday that Missouri could proceed with Franklin's execution, just hours after a lower court blocked the execution and claimed Missouri's disputed lethal injection protocol must be resolved before the execution could go forward.

The latest ruling means that only the U.S. Supreme Court can intervene and stop the execution.

The appeals court's ruling overturns U.S. District Court Judge Nanette Laughrey, who held that the Missouri Department of Corrections "has not provided any information about the certification, inspection history, infraction history, or other aspects of the compounding pharmacy or of the person compounding the drug." She noted that the execution protocol, which has changed repeatedly, "has been a frustratingly moving target."

The state's death warrant for Franklin allows the execution to be carried out anytime Wednesday. After Laughrey ruled in his favor, Franklin's attorney, Jennifer Herndon, said Franklin's mental illness was likely keeping him from comprehending the developments.

Franklin, 63, was convicted of seven other murders, but the Missouri case was the only one resulting in a death sentence. Franklin also has admitted to shooting and wounding civil rights leader Vernon Jordan and Hustler magazine publisher Larry Flynt, who has been paralyzed from the waist down since the attack in 1978.

Source: AP, November 20, 2013


Judge grants stay of execution to racist serial killer

ST. LOUIS (AP) — A federal judge in Missouri has given a stay of execution to white supremacist serial killer Joseph Paul Franklin just hours before his scheduled death.

U.S. District Court Judge Nanette Laughery ruled late Tuesday afternoon that a lawsuit filed by Franklin and 21 other death-row inmates challenging Missouri's execution protocol must first be resolved.

The 63-year-old inmate was scheduled to die at 12:01 a.m. Wednesday for killing 42-year-old Gerald Gordon in a sniper attack outside a suburban St. Louis synagogue in 1977.

It was one of as many as 20 killings committed by Franklin, who targeted blacks and Jews in a cross-country killing spree from 1977 to 1980. 

Source: AP, November 19, 2013

Monday, November 18, 2013

Missouri courts, governor still weighing Franklin execution

The Missouri Supreme Court and Gov. Jay Nixon continued Monday to weigh requests to halt the execution of Joseph Paul Franklin, with time dwindling before the serial killer is scheduled to be put to death.

Franklin, 63, faces execution one minute after midnight on Wednesday. It would be the first in Missouri in nearly three years and the first ever using a single execution drug, the sedative pentobarbital.

Franklin was convicted of killing 42-year-old Gerald Gordon in a sniper attack outside a suburban St. Louis synagogue in 1977. It was one of as many as 20 killings committed by Franklin, a white supremacist who targeted blacks and Jews in a cross-country killing spree from 1977 to 1980. He was convicted of seven other murders — including the Aug. 20, 1980, slayings of David Martin and Ted Fields in Salt Lake City — but the Missouri case was the only one resulting in a death sentence.

Franklin declined multiple Associated Press interview requests but granted a lengthy interview to The Salt Lake Tribune available here.

It wasn’t clear when Nixon would rule on clemency. His spokesman, Scott Holste, said the governor did not yet have anything to announce. Meanwhile, Franklin’s attorney, Jennifer Herndon, said she was still awaiting a ruling from the Missouri Supreme Court.

Last month, Nixon stopped the execution of another convicted killer, Allen Nicklasson, over concerns about Missouri’s plan to use propofol as the lethal drug. The European Union had threatened to limit export if propofol was used in the execution, potentially creating a nationwide shortage of the popular anesthetic.

The Missouri Department of Corrections revised its protocol days later, changing to pentobarbital that will be made through a compounding pharmacy. Because the compounding pharmacy is part of the execution team, few details about it have been made public.

Herndon last week filed a motion for a stay of execution with the Missouri Supreme Court, citing concerns about how the drug is made and what could happen if it doesn’t work properly, potentially leaving the inmate in pain or brain-damaged but not dead.

Amid court cases and the shortage of execution drugs, Missouri has executed just two men in the past eight years — most recently Martin Link in February 2011.

Herndon said Franklin, a paranoid schizophrenic, now regrets his crimes, having had a change of heart after serving time alongside black inmates.

Franklin was in his mid-20s when he began drifting across America 36 years ago, robbing up to 16 banks to fund his travels.

He bombed a synagogue in Chattanooga, Tenn., in July 1977. No one was hurt, but the killings began soon after that, many of them sniper shootings. Franklin has claimed as many as 20 victims.

He had a particular dislike for interracial couples — several of his victims were black men and the white women with them.

He arrived in suburban St. Louis and picked out Brith Sholom Kneseth Israel synagogue from the Yellow Pages. On Oct. 8, 1977, a bar mitzvah ended and guests were on the parking lot when Franklin opened fire from a grassy area nearby, killing Gordon.

Franklin got away and committed a string of other killings in several other states. He was caught after killing Martin and Fields, two young black men who had just finished jogging with two teenage white girls in Salt Lake City’s Liberty Park on Aug. 20, 1980. Years later, in federal prison, he admitted to the St. Louis County killing. He was sentenced to death in 1997.

In addition to the killings, Franklin has admitted shooting and wounding civil rights leader Vernon Jordan and Hustler magazine publisher Larry Flynt.

Flynt, paralyzed from the waist down since the shooting in 1978, has also sued to stop the execution, telling The Associated Press he does not believe it is a deterrent.

Source: Associated Press, November 18, 2013

Friday, October 4, 2013

Faiths plan united effort to repeal death penalty in Ohio

Ohio Death Chamber
The head of a statewide anti-death-penalty group says a “major initiative” is in the works to unite religious organizations in a campaign to abolish executions in Ohio.

Kevin Werner, executive director of Ohioans to Stop Executions, said yesterday that details are being worked out, but he expects events to begin in 2014. “What you’re going to see is a lively and invigorated campaign from the faith communities in Ohio to repeal the death penalty,” he said.

Werner and other members of his group discussed plans with a small number of faith leaders yesterday at the Summit on 16th United Methodist Church in the University District.

The private meeting followed a discussion during which Werner said Ohio’s capital-punishment system is “broken beyond repair” and “broken beyond compare.”

“When we’re looking across the region, Ohio behaves like a Deep South state when it comes to the death penalty. It sticks out like a sore thumb,” Werner said. “We are very outside the norm for traditional Midwest values.”

He said the time is right to gather support from faith communities as more and more issues are being raised about the death penalty in Ohio.

A death-penalty task force formed by the Ohio Supreme Court and the Ohio State Bar Association in 2011 is set to wrap up its review of the state’s system this fall. And Ohio officials are expected to reveal today a new death-penalty protocol, the latest in a string of changes to the procedure since 2006.

Ohio has executed 52 inmates since 1976, ranking it eighth among the states, according to data updated on Wednesday by the Death Penalty Information Center. Texas has had the most executions, with 505, followed by Virginia (110), Oklahoma (106), Florida (79), Missouri (68), Alabama (56) and Georgia (53).


Source: The Colombus Dispatch, October 4, 2013

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Ohio death-row inmate sues over lack of halal meals

A Muslim death row inmate says the Ohio state prison system is denying him meals prepared according to Islamic law while at the same time providing kosher meals to Jewish prisoners.

The state says it has already removed pork from its menus in response to the lawsuit brought by condemned inmate Abdul Awkal, who argues the prison system's failure to provide halal meals is a restraint on his religious freedoms.

Awkal, joined by a second inmate not on death row, says the vegetarian and non-pork options offered by the Department of Rehabilitation and Correction aren't good enough. The inmates say food must be prepared according to halal practice.

"The issue of eating halal meals is especially important to me because I face a death sentence," Awkal said in a filing in federal court this year.

"It is important to me that I follow the requirements of my faith as I approach death."

The state's recent decision to drop pork from all meals accommodates religious preferences without jeopardising security, said Carlo LoParo, spokesman for the state corrections department.

It "eliminates any doubt that Muslims or any inmate who has a specific prohibition against pork products receives pork inadvertently or otherwise".

But the state's announcement doesn't solve the problem that meat isn't slaughtered in the appropriate way for Muslim inmates who adhere to religious tradition, said David Singleton, executive director of the Ohio Justice and Policy Centre, which brought the lawsuit on Awkal's behalf.

He said the lawsuit would continue.

A judge has given lawyers and inmates for the state until next month to finish filing documents bolstering their arguments before an expected January trial.

Awkal, 52, is scheduled to die in June for killing his estranged wife, Latife Awkal, and brother-in-law Mahmoud Abdul-Aziz in 1992, in a room in Cuyahoga County Domestic Relations Court.

Joining Awkal in the lawsuit is Cornelius Causey, 35, serving 15 years to life for murder and aggravated robbery.

Ohio says that providing halal meals could hurt the state financially, given the current budget situation.

Ohio included in its response to the lawsuit a document from a Muslim who does regular spiritual counselling of Muslim inmates.

Although Imam Sunni-Ali Islam said he thought it was problematic that Ohio provided kosher but not halal meals, he said he did not think it rose to the level of religious discrimination.

Ohio spends about US$3.50 to US$7 ($4.65 to $9.30) on kosher meals compared with US$1.70 for regular meals, LoParo said.

Ohio says requiring halal meals could mean new dietary plans for as many as 2000 inmates, while Awkal's lawyers believe the figure is lower because not all Muslims eat halal meals.

Source: Associated Press, 0ctober 5, 2011

Saturday, May 7, 2011

Spain: Jews receive apology over Spanish Inquisition executions

The leader of Majorca has become the 1st government official to apologise for the execution of Jews during the Spanish Inquisition -- centuries after the events.

Francesc Antich, the regional president of the Balearic Islands, issued an official condemnation of the killings in what was heralded by Jewish groups as the first of its kind in Spain.

"We have dared to gather here to recognise the grave injustice committed against those Majorcans who were accused, persecuted, charged and condemned to death for their faith and their beliefs," Mr Antich said at a memorial service held in Palma de Majorca.

At the end of the 15th century King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella set up the Spanish Inquisition to root out remnants of Islam and Judaism after the reconquest of Spain. Over the following two centuries thousands of so-called heretics were burned at the stake.

Following the order to convert or leave the country, the majority of Spain's Jews fled to safer shores while many of those left behind publicly converted to Roman Catholicism yet practised their true faith in secret.

34 Jews were garroted and their bodies thrown on to bonfires in 1691. 3 others, including a rabbi, were burned alive.

Mr Antich said the purpose of the recognition was to "recover part of that memory" of Majorca's dark past and recognise the violence and discrimination that converts faced for centuries.

An estimated 15,000 people living in Majorca are thought to be descendants of the island's Jews, though almost all are Catholic.

The Israel-based group that came up with the proposal for the ceremony lauded the event as "an important gesture of reconciliation".

Source: The Telegraph, May 6, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Saturday, April 23, 2011

Mississippi: Faith leaders call to end death penalty

Leaders of Muslim, Jewish and Christian congregations gathered Thursday at the Capitol to call for an end to the death penalty in Mississippi.

Death penalty supporter Ann Pace of Jackson, meanwhile, held pictures of her daughter, who she said died at the hands of a serial killer.

The main point of contention between the Mississippi Religious Leadership Conference and Pace is whether the death penalty effectively deters crime, but the issue also hinges on inequity in the criminal justice system and religious principles.

“We face the real possibility of three state-sanctioned executions within the next month,” said the Episcopal Rev. Carol Borne Spencer. “The organization thus felt that the time was now for us to ask our state leaders to find new ways to deal with one of the largest societal dilemmas of our time, that is how to deal with heinous criminal actions of murder and violence and still hold people accountable in ways that do not require the killing of a person."

On Wednesday, the Mississippi Supreme Court set execution dates for 2 convicted killers, and Attorney General Jim Hood has requested an execution date for a 3rd.

The religious conference, which grew out of the 1960s civil rights movement, asked Thursday for crime victim support. But members said executions only create new victims — the families of executed criminals. Isolating criminals is better than condemning them to death, members said.

Pace, whose daughter Murray Pace was slain by reputed south Louisiana serial killer Derrick Todd Lee in May 2002, disagrees.

Lee, 43, sits on death row at the Louisiana State Penitentiary in Angola for Pace’s murder. Murray was killed at the age of 22, 1 week after graduating with an MBA from Louisiana State University.

Lee is suspected of killing 7 south Louisiana women between 1998 and 2003, but Pace said he has not yet been put to death because Louisiana state law allows too many appeals.

“Even though the case is a DNA case, his DNA in 7 murders, and it’s been upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court twice, Louisiana still provides for a system called post-conviction relief that can go on for years and years and years, and it made sense before forensic science. It does not make sense now,” said Pace.

She cited a series of studies in the early 2000s finding that each execution prevents between 3 and 18 slayings. The studies have been widely disseminated by pro-death penalty advocates but widely criticized for technical and conceptual errors by those who oppose execution.

“I am here for those three to 18 additional victims,” Pace said. “I think abolishing the death penalty is idealistic, sounds good, feels good to support, but it does not protect life, it does not protect us, and I think our most important moral obligation in our life is to protect ourselves, our children, and our community, and I think that the death penalty does in fact do that."

In addition to the debate over deterrence, the Capitol press conference brought up issues of social equality and faith.

Okolo Rashid of Jackson's International Museum of Muslim Cultures signed the MRLC's call for a moratorium. She said her faith would allow her to support the death penalty if the system did not disproportionately execute black men.

Another MRLC member invoked the symbolism of the Christian day of Good Friday, which marks the day Jesus Christ was crucified.

“We know that Jesus Christ would not want the death penalty for anyone, having suffered himself at the hands of the state,” said the Catholic Bishop Joseph N. Latino of Jackson.

Set to be executed May 10 is Benny Joe Stevens, now 52, who was sentenced to death in 1999 for killing his ex-wife and her husband, his 11-year-old son and his son's 10-year-old friend.

Meanwhile, state officials have set a May 17 execution date for Rodney Gray, now 38, who was sentenced to death in 1996 for the 1994 rape and murder of 79-year-old Grace Blackwell of Louin. Blackwell, who had last been seen withdrawing a large amount of money from her bank, was found shot multiple times in Newton County.

Robert Simon Jr. was sentenced to death for the killings of 3 members of a Quitman County family, but his attorneys say a fall has rendered him incompetent for execution. Hood had earlier asked for an April 20 execution date.

Source: Associated Press, April 23, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Connecticut's Religious Leaders Say End the Death Penalty

Dozens of Religious Leaders Rally in Hartford to Advocate the Abolition of Connecticut's Capital Punishment Law

Calling it the just and moral thing to do, dozens of religious leaders from the state’s Christian and Jewish communities gathered at the Legislative Office Building in Hartford Tuesday to petition the General Assembly to repeal Connecticut’s death penalty law.

“There are times where sometimes we have theological debates about things in which we disagree, however when it comes to the death penalty this is one item that members of major denominations agree, there is consensus that the death penalty should be abolished,” said State Rep. Bruce Morris, D-Norwalk, who also serves as a minister and emceed Tuesday’s proceedings.

The religious leaders presented Morris and State Rep. Gary Holder-Winfield, D-New Haven, with a letter signed by more than 300 clergy supporting passage of House Bill 5036, a bill introduced by Holder-Winfield that would abolish Connecticut’s death penalty. Speakers advocated replacing the state’s capital punishment law with a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of release for the state’s most violent convicted murderers.

“As people of faith, we reaffirm our opposition to the death penalty and belief in the sacredness of human life,” the letter stated. “We urge you, our elected officials, to examine the reality of Connecticut’s death penalty and seek ways to achieve true healing for those who suffer because of violent crime. Please support repeal of the death penalty. It is time for Connecticut to move beyond this broken and harmful system.”

Speakers argued that the death penalty was an “ineffective, unfair and fallible” response to violent crimes.

“The death penalty applies disproportionately to the poor and minorities and puts innocent lives at risk of execution,” Morris said. “Since 1973, 138 individuals sentenced to death were later exonerated of their crimes. When a human life is at stake, there’s simply no room for error.”

James Curry, a Bishop from the Episcopal Church, said that he has spoken to the victims of many families who feel that the death penalty only adds to their pain and suffering, because of lengthy trials and appeals and the notoriety associated with the cases.

“By abolishing the death penalty, we in Connecticut have an opportunity to affirm and respect our dignity as a society,” Curry said. “…Life imprisonment without possibility of release is a punishment that can respect the needs of a victim’s family for closure in the legal process, it can respect their needs for justice, and it can respect the memory of all their loved ones.”

Peter Rosazza, a Bishop from the Connecticut Catholic Conference, said that the Catholic Church opposes the death penalty because it violates the sanctity of life.

“Human life is a gift from god that must be respected from conception to natural death,” Rosazza said. “Our profound respect for human life also explains why we are opposed to any attack against human life, including abortion and euthanasia.”

Rosazza noted that Connecticut was the last state in New England to abolish slavery, adding “we hope it is not the last state to abolish the death penalty.”

Rabbi Donna Berman said that the death penalty went against the Jewish tradition and was not an effective deterrent.

“Even in ancient times there were those who felt that capital punishment was a deterrent to crime, but they represented the minority opinion,” Berman said. “In our own day, studies show that capital punishment is in fact not a deterrent. The truth is we can deter crime and protect society just as effectively, more effectively, with life imprisonment without the possibility of release. In this way we can avoid the very real risk of taking an innocent life.”

The death penalty has always been a hot button issue in Connecticut, but has risen in prominence the past several years due to a brutal 2007 Cheshire home invasion. Jennifer Hawke-Petit and her two daughters, Hayley, 17, and Michaela, 11, were sexually assaulted and murdered in their home after a failed robbery attempt. One man, Steven Hayes, 47, was convicted in 2010 and sentenced to death, while another, Joshua Komisarjevsky, is currently on trial for the crime. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Komisarjevsky.

Both houses of the legislature approved a bill to veto the death penalty in 2009, but then governor vetoed the bill, citing the Cheshire home invasion.

Holder-Winfield said he expected the General Assembly’s Judiciary Committee to vote on the current bill within a week. He said he expected the bill to pass, and Gov. Dannel P. Malloy to sign it into law.

“The work that I’m doing on the death penalty comes out of both my religious faith and my sense for justice,” Holder-Winfield said.

During his campaign, Malloy, a former federal prosecutor, repeatedly stated he was opposed to the death penalty.

In the most recent Quinnipiac University Poll on the subject, released March 10, 67 percent of Connecticut residents said they supported the death penalty, compared to 28 percent who said they opposed it.

The event was originally intended to be held on the steps of the state capitol, but was moved indoors because of the weather.

Source: Montville Patch, April 6, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Condemned Ohio killer of 3 asks panel for mercy

A condemned Ohio inmate with Nazi sympathies who killed 3 men at Cleveland State University is asking the state's new governor for mercy.

Frank Spisak blamed the 1982 murders on his hatred of gays, blacks and Jews and also claimed his crimes were sparked by mental illness related to confusion about his sexual identity.

His attorneys planned to tell the Ohio Parole Board Thursday that Spisak suffers from a severe bipolar mood disorder that was not diagnosed until years after he was convicted.

The lawyers argue the information could have led jurors to consider a different sentence.

Spisak's plea to spare his life will be the 1st death penalty case to come before newly sworn-in Republican Gov. John Kasich

Source: Associated Press, January 13, 2011

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Gay Saudi diplomat says he'll be killed if sent home

A gay Saudi Arabian diplomat is seeking asylum in the US because he says he will be killed if returned to his home country.

The man, who has been named as Ali Ahmad Asseri, says his homosexuality and his friendship with a Jewish woman will lead to his death.

Mr Asseri, who was the first secretary of the Saudi consulate in Los Angeles, said he lost his job when Saudi officials refused to renew his passport after they discovered his sexual orientation and friendship with the woman.

He told NBC News: "My life is in a great danger here and if I go back to Saudi Arabia, they will kill me openly in broad daylight."

According to the station, Mr Asseri criticised his home country for being "backward" on a Saudi website and attacked "militant imams" who have "defaced the tolerance of Islam".

He has also reportedly threatened to publicise embarrassing information about Saudi royal family members living in the US.

Homosexuality is illegal in Saudi Arabia and can be punished with the death penalty.

It is believed that no executions for homosexuality have been carried out in the country since 2002, although there have been reports of prison sentences and flogging for men arrested at gay parties or for "behaving like women".

Source: Pink News, September 14, 2010

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Faiths and the faithful have varied views of death penalty

In the hours before murderer Ronnie Lee Gardner is set to be shot to death by firing squad next week at the Draper prison, prominent religious leaders will gather for a prayer vigil and join others for a protest rally.

They will decry what they see as the state's unnecessary taking of life.

And yet those voices do not reflect the full range of opinion among people of faith.

Indeed, even within those religious traditions that oppose the death penalty -- Jews, Roman Catholics, Orthodox and mainstream Protestants such as the Episcopalians, Presbyterians, American Baptists and United Methodists -- some of the faithful disagree.

Evangelical Christians generally support capital punishment, although some see it as immoral.

Among those traditions that take no stand on the right of states to kill killers, such as the LDS Church and Buddhists, strong positions are found at opposite ends of the question. Most Mormons back the death penalty; most Buddhists reject it.

Here is a sample of the perspectives of Utahns from a variety of faith traditions, starting with those whose religions officially are neutral.

Buddhists

Charles Prebish is the bane of colleagues in Old Main at Utah State University. A 40-year practitioner of Buddhism, he won't kill the box-elder bugs that creep into his office each spring and fall. So it's not hard to understand his position on capital punishment.

"I would have difficulty killing anyone for any reason," says Prebish, director of USU's religious-studies program. "I clearly could not support capital punishment under any circumstances."

Buddha never explicitly addressed capital punishment, Prebish notes. But the first precept, or rule, for personal spiritual development is to abstain from taking life.

It is Prebish's hunch, after four decades as a Buddhist and as one of North American Buddhism's pre-eminent scholars, that most Buddhists reject the death penalty.


Latter-day Saints

Though The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints now has an official position of neutrality -- its statement says "we neither promote nor oppose capital punishment" -- the church has a long history of backing state executions.

Indeed, some early church leaders preached that murder was an unforgivable sin for which Mormons could atone only by accepting a bloody death. That belief in so-called "blood atonement" is thought to be at the root of Utah's use of the firing squad. Though it's no longer an option for those sentenced to death, Gardner was able to choose the firing squad because he was sentenced before the law changed in 2004.

Philip Barlow, who holds the Arrington Chair of Mormon History and Culture at USU, suspects the Utah-based church's relatively recent neutrality is part of its broader attempt to stay out of politics except when certain moral issues are at stake.

Nonetheless, he says, most Mormons likely support the death penalty.

"There is a sense of Old Testament justice," Barlow says, "coupled with a New Testament sense of redeeming by blood and informed by a strong Mormon testimony of free agency."

Barlow, himself a Mormon, does not share that view."I can't imagine Jesus Christ participating in that sort of justice."

Rep. Greg Hughes, R-Draper and a Mormon, agrees with Barlow, although his reasons are more prosaic.

"I don't want to give government the right to execute citizens, period," he says. "Inevitably, you're going to kill innocent people."

Moreover, the ultimate penalty often is applied unfairly, Hughes says. Someone such as Mark Hacking, from an upper-class white family, got life in prison for murdering his pregnant wife in her sleep while William Andrews, a black man, was executed for watching a buddy kill people at Ogden's Hi-Fi shop.

"What is that except a popularity contest?" Hughes asks. "It offends my sense of fairness."

Another Mormon Republican legislator, Sen. Jon Greiner, R-Ogden, comes to the opposite conclusion, not from faith so much as life experience. He is Ogden's police chief and, as a young officer, helped investigate the Hi-Fi murders.

In his experience, the death penalty is a strong deterrent for those who understand there are eternal consequences. Those murderers with any religious background, he says, "do feel that when they move on, there is a significant price they'll pay."


Evangelical Christians

The Rev. Greg Johnson, a Utahn who is on the board of the National Association of Evangelicals, says some crimes are so heinous that the state is justified in putting the perpetrators to death.

And yet, he says, "it ought to make us all sad that this ultimate act of justice has to be performed."

Both Old and New Testament verses can be employed, he says, as justification. "If you take a life, you lose your life," says Johnson, president of Standing Together, a coalition of Utah faith communities.

Moreover, humans have an innate need for justice, Johnson says. "Ronnie Lee Gardner will never be able to kill anyone else."

The Rev. Mike Gray, senior pastor at Southeast Baptist Church, doesn't subscribe to the "eye for an eye" school of biblical interpretation. One can find support for the death penalty in scripture, he says, but not a demand that it be wielded.

"It needs to be used in limited situations," Gray says. "It's not to be a general policy that capital punishment is the answer for every capital crime."

Christians should not approach Gardner's death with a sense of vengeance, he says. "It's not, 'Hey, let's get him.' There's no sanctity of life in that."


Muslims

Shuaib-ud Din, imam of the Utah Islamic Center, says the Quran and Prophet Muhammad's sayings are clear: A society should put killers to death.

In fact, he says, the Quran has a passage very much like that found in Jewish scripture and Christianity's Old Testament concerning an "eye for an eye."

"We don't believe in a God of vengeance," Din says. "We believe in a loving God, and this is for the betterment of society as a whole. It will serve as a deterrent. It will curb crime."

Capital punishment, he adds, never is to be used outside the civil law or by vigilantes. And the imam does have reservations about how well the system works and whether innocent people are sometimes executed.

"That's most disturbing to me," he says. "The judicial system has to be near perfect for capital punishment to take place."


Jews

Rabbi Joshua Aaronson, of Park City's Temple Har Shalom, says Jews never have seen "eye for an eye" as an excuse for retribution, for taking the life even of a killer.

"There is no equality in justice in that way. It never works," Aaronson says. "One life can't be substituted for another life."

Employing all the faith's scriptures -- not just those that Christians share in the Old Testament -- rabbis through the centuries have affirmed that, while Jewish law permits the death penalty, it should rarely, if ever, be used. It is understood as God's prerogative, not man's.

Most movements within modern Judaism oppose capital punishment, although some Orthodox Jews are less emphatic and have called only for a moratorium on its use in the United States.

Aaronson also objects to the way capital punishment is applied in this country, in which most murderers put to death are poor and ethnic minorities. More than 100 people condemned to die have been later found to be innocent, he says. "We diminish ourselves as a state whenever we put to death anyone by any means."


Mainline Protestants

Nancy Appleby, an Episcopalian, says she has no great sympathy for people such as Gardner.

"He's done terrible, terrible things, and it's very hard to love him," says Appleby, chairwoman of the Utah Episcopal Diocese's Peace and Justice Commission. "But if we're called to love everyone, that includes Ronnie Lee Gardner."

Her church has opposed capital punishment for more than 50 years.

Appleby notes that is a particularly difficult issue for Utahns in the wake of last month's murder of 4-year-old Ethan Stacy. His mother and stepfather, Stephanie and Nathan Sloop, are charged with capital crimes in his death.

"That makes everyone think that people who kill ought to be killed," Appleby says, but "when we execute people, we do something bad to ourselves as well. We brutalize ourselves, basically."

In an e-mailed statement, outgoing Bishop Carolyn Tanner Irish, of Utah's Episcopal Diocese, says she longs for the day that justice is "neither retributive nor vengeful."

"As Christians, we condemn the taking of a human life, recalling that Jesus himself was the victim of state-sponsored murder," she writes. "His death holds before our eyes the poverty of capital punishment and its capacity to dehumanize those who carry out its sentence."

The Rev. Steve Klemz says he sees no good from the death penalty, no redemption for society or the victims of crime.

"I can't even begin to understand the pain people feel and the need for some kind of retribution, but it just doesn't happen with the death penalty. If anything, it gets more attention to the person who is being executed," says Klemz, pastor of Zion Evangelical Lutheran Church in Salt Lake City.

His denomination has taken a position that leans against capital punishment, although it hasn't yet condemned the practice as have other mainline Protestant denominations.

As Klemz sees it, scripture's main purpose is to convey what is life-giving and life-diminishing.

"What Jesus said always had to do with life and living life abundantly," Klemz says. "I don't see how the death penalty does anything to promote life."

The Rev. France Davis, pastor of Salt Lake City's Calvary Baptist Church, says he opposes the death penalty not because it is inherently wrong.

It is immoral in practice, he says. Most inmates sentenced to death are poor or racial minorities, he says, and it takes too long for a person to be executed while failing to deliver the intended deterrent effect.

"It's cruel and unusual punishment, it seems to me, to keep someone on death row for years and years and years."

Roman Catholics

The Roman Catholic Church, like most Christian faiths, recognizes a state's right to execute murders. But in the past 25 years, the nation's single largest denomination increasingly has argued that the death penalty is not justified when a society has other means to keep citizens safe.

In a 1999 statement, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops argued that the United States cannot overcome crime by executing criminals, nor can it restore the lives of the innocent.

"The death penalty," the statement says, "offers the tragic illusion that we can defend life by taking life."

Monsignor M. Francis Mannion, pastor of St. Vincent de Paul Catholic Church, says the faith has taught against the death penalty more explicitly since the 1960s and the Second Vatican Council.

"It is part of the church's pro-life stance, which opposes killing anyone."

The church, however, uses much stronger language for abortion, which is considered "intrinsically evil."

The Rev. Erik Richtsteig, pastor of St. James the Just Catholic Church in Ogden, says that while it is clear the church recommends against the death penalty, it is not an infallible teaching that must be believed by all Catholics.

"As a Catholic, you do not have to oppose the death penalty."

Nonetheless, Mannion, a theologian, says: "There isn't as much breathing room as Catholics sometimes think on this matter."

Source: The Salt Lake Tribune, Kristen Moulton (kmoulton@sltrib.com), June 10, 2010

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Florida executes Martin Grossman

STARKE — Florida has executed a 45-year-old man condemned for the murder of a young wildlife officer in Pinellas County 25 years ago.

Martin Edward Grossman (pictured) was pronounced dead by lethal injection at 6:17 p.m.. His attorneys had tried to get the U.S. Supreme Court to issue a last-minute stay, but the high court declined.

Grossman was condemned for shooting and killing wildlife officer Margaret "Peggy" Park, 26, on Dec. 13, 1984. Park's 79-year-old mother went against a doctor's suggestion and traveled from Ohio to attend the execution, as did other family members.

"I would like to extend my heartfelt remorse to the victim's family," Grossman said in his last statement. "I fully regret everything that occurred that night. Everything that was done, whether I remember everything or not, I accept responsibility."

Grossman then said a sacred Jewish prayer and closed his eyes as a three-chemical cocktail began flowing into his body just after 6 p.m.. His chest stopped moving at 6:04 p.m. and a doctor pronounced him dead 13 minutes later.

The execution came after a whirlwind day in which death penalty opponents and religious leaders — Jewish and Catholic — pleaded with Gov. Charlie Crist to halt the execution.

Though the Vatican called for mercy for Grossman, even the pope didn't argue that he was innocent.

Grossman "has repented and is now a changed person, having become a man of faith,'' wrote Archbishop Fernando Filoni on behalf of Pope Benedict XVI. He asked for "whatever steps may be possible to save the life of Mr. Grossman.''

Filoni wrote the letter at the behest of the chief rabbi of Israel, Shear-Yashuv Cohen.

Grossman, meanwhile, declined the traditional last meal. Instead, he had a banana cream and peanut butter cookies, canned fruit punch and a chicken sandwich he bought himself from the inmate canteen, according to the Department of Corrections.

His last visitors were his aunt and two friends.

Grossman becomes the 7th condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 1195th overall since the nation resumed executions on January 17, 1982.

Source: tampabay.com and Rick Halperin, Feb. 16, 2010

Pope calls for mercy for killer Martin Grossman as execution nears

STARKE — The Vatican is calling for mercy for a man scheduled to be executed Tuesday evening for killing a young Florida wildlife officer 25 years ago.

But even the pope doesn't argue that Martin Edward Grossman is innocent.

Grossman, 45, who shot and killed Margaret "Peggy'' Park, 26, on Dec. 13, 1984, "has repented and is now a changed person, having become a man of faith,'' wrote Archbishop Fernando Filoni on behalf of Pope Benedict XVI. He asked for "whatever steps may be possible to save the life of Mr. Grossman.''

Filoni wrote the letter at the behest of the chief rabbi of Israel, Shear-Yashuv Cohen.

Activists against the death penalty took up Grossman's case, including several Jewish organizations that pleaded for clemency, asking Gov. Charlie Crist to commute his sentence to life in prison.

Amnesty International said it had "serious questions about the quality of his legal representation and compelling mental health evidence that was never presented to a jury."

More than 26,000 people signed an online petition asking that Grossman's life be spared. Nobel prize winner and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel also weighed in on his behalf.

Rabbis from groups including the Rabbinical Council of America, the Aleph Institute and the National Council of Young Israel wrote to Crist on Feb. 9 asking him to spare Grossman's life because he "has shown profound remorse and regret" for the officer's murder.

"He acted under the influence of drugs and alcohol. His fatal shooting of Ms. Parks was not an act of premeditation but of panic," the letter said. "He has transformed himself from a deeply troubled teenager into a gentle and simple man, a proud practitioner of his faith and a humble servant of God."

A spokesman for the governor said that by Friday night the office had received more than 9,443 e-mails and more than 7,849 phone calls about the Grossman case.


Source: tampabay.com, Feb. 16, 2010


US Jews rush to stay execution

16/02/2010 04:18

Execution of FL death row inmate "long overdue," says victim’s mother.

NEW YORK – A coalition of Orthodox Jewish groups is appealing for clemency on behalf of a Jewish inmate on Florida’s death row who is scheduled to be executed on Tuesday night.

Martin Grossman (left) was convicted of first-degree murder for killing a Florida wildlife officer in 1984, when the officer found Grossman, then 19, and a 17-year-old friend shooting a stolen handgun inside a nature preserve. But, arguing that Grossman’s crime was not premeditated, and committed while Grossman was mentally impaired and on drugs, the Jewish groups are asking for a 60-day reprieve, in order to prepare another appeal and explore legal options.

“He has conducted himself as a model prisoner since his incarceration some 25 years ago and has shown profound remorse and regret for his actions,” the groups, including the National Council of Young Israel, Agudath Israel of America and the Orthodox Union, said in a statement. Grossman, they argued, should “be permitted to serve his debt to society by serving the rest of his life in prison.”

Chief Ashkenazi Rabbi Yona Metzger, citing “new evidence,” also wrote to Florida Gov. Charlie Crist, according to a letter publicized by Yeshiva World News.

“I am convinced that there is sufficient cause to at least delay this execution until all evidence and legal arguments are presented,” hewrote.

With Grossman sitting on death row for decades, the groups sprung into action on January 12, when Crist signed Grossman’s death warrant.

Click here to read this feature in full.

Source: The Jerusalem Post, Feb. 16, 2010

Monday, February 15, 2010

Execution set for Martin Grossman, convicted killer of Fla. wildlife officer

Martin Grossman (pictured), after 24 years on death row, is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection at 6 p.m. Tuesday at Florida State Prison near Starke.

"It's long overdue," said Margaret Park, the victim's 79-year-old mother who lives in suburban Columbus, Ohio. "He had very good representation all the way through. I think he's been treated very fairly by the state of Florida. I don't take any pleasure in an execution, but it's time."

On the day she was killed, according to court records, Florida wildlife officer Peggy Park came upon two teenagers shooting a stolen handgun. Martin Grossman, who lived in nearby New Port Richey and was on probation from a burglary conviction, begged Park not to turn him in. He had gotten out of prison back in the summer and didn't want to return.

As she walked back to her vehicle to call in the information, Grossman - a foot taller and 100 pounds heavier than the diminutive Park - attacked, hitting her 20 to 30 times with her heavy flashlight as she got in the car. She managed to get off an errant shot and disable the other attacking teen with a kick to the groin before Grossman wrested her gun away and shot her in the head.

Grossman and his accomplice, 17-year-old Thayne Taylor, were arrested two weeks later after they talked about it to a friend who went to police. Taylor subsequently confessed.

Grossman was convicted in October 1985, and the jury recommended the death penalty by a 12-0 vote. Taylor was convicted of third-degree murder and served nearly three years in prison before being released into a supervised program.

Rabbi Menachem Katz, who has counseled Grossman for more than a decade, said the inmate is "holding strong."

"He's praying three times a day," Katz said. "He's continuing on the path of repentance. (He) has a lot of remorse."

Courts have rejected multiple appeals based on claims including ineffective assistance of counsel during the penalty phase, and diminished mental capacity. Katz said Grossman was young, drunk and on drugs when he committed the murder and doesn't believe the facts of the case warrant the death penalty.

Gov. Charlie Crist signed the death warrant Jan. 12. The Florida Supreme Court rejected his latest appeal last week.

If he is put to death Tuesday, Grossman will be the 69th inmate executed by Florida since it resumed the death penalty in 1979. The state has killed 24 by lethal injection and 44 in the old electric chair.

Source: Florida Herald, Feb. 15, 2010

Thursday, February 11, 2010

Death-Row Inmate Martin Grossman Appeals to Florida Governor for Stay of Execution

Declaring that a Jewish inmate who has languished on death row for more than a quarter of a century should not be executed next week, some 200 Jewish and non-Jewish organizations are petitioning Florida Gov. Charlie Crist to intervene and spare his life.

In the petition, the organizations which include Amnesty International, the National Council of Young Israel, Agudath Israel of America, the Orthodox Union, the Rabbinical Alliance of America, Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, and the Aleph Institute, a Chabad-Lubavitch program that serves Jewish prisoners in the United States argue that Martin Grossman (pictured), 45, had no intent to kill and was not able to fully comprehend the nature of his crime when he shot Florida Wildlife Officer Margaret Park on Dec. 13, 1984.

At the time, the organizations state, Grossman was a 19-year-old drug-addicted drop-out with borderline intelligence who panicked when Park came upon him and a friend who were going to fire a found handgun in an isolated nature reserve.

"He may have killed, but he is not a killer," reads a letter submitted by several of the organizations. "He acted under the influence of drugs and alcohol."

"A psychiatrist who evaluated him concluded, from his psychological and medical condition, that he could not have formed the intent to kill," declares a press release from the Aleph Institute. Grossmans accomplice, Thanye Taylor, "served less than 3 years in prison, while Martin was sentenced to death."

Grossman's "childhood history," says a petition signed by almost 12,000 people, "is marked by the fact that as a young child, Martin had [a] feeling of impotence imposed upon his undeveloped psyche, much too young, because he was unable to relieve the suffering of his father, a veteran whom Martin only knew as an ailing and needy invalid."

Among other contentions, Grossmans attorneys and those supporting his plea to the governor argue that allegations of prosecutorial misconduct and an insufficient effort by Grossman's past defense team as well as several mitigating circumstances ignored by the court during sentencing compel Crist to grant a 60-day stay in order for the attorneys to prepare a comprehensive clemency application.

The Florida Supreme Court this week upheld the sentence.

Rabbi Menachem Katz, who has visited Grossman regularly over the past 15 years, says that he is different from the youth who robbed Park's life.

"Martin has shown deep and profound remorse over the years," says Katz, "and is no longer the same wild, reckless person he was 26 years ago."

Source: Associated Press, Feb. 10, 2010

Click here to sign an online petition asking Gov. Crist to grant Martin Grossman a 60 day stay which would enable for a comprehensive clemency application to be presented to the court.