Showing posts with label Arkansas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arkansas. Show all posts

Saturday, December 28, 2013

Arkansas AG seeks executions for 7 felons

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. — Arkansas' attorney general asked Gov. Mike Beebe to set execution dates for seven death row inmates, according to letters obtained Friday by The Associated Press.

Attorney General Dustin McDaniel noted in the letters sent to Beebe late Thursday that six of the seven inmates are challenging the state's new lethal injection law and protocol, which calls for Arkansas to use a drug that has never before been used for lethal injections in the U.S.

However, McDaniel said there aren't any court orders in place preventing executions of those seven prisoners.

The Arkansas Supreme Court said earlier this year that such orders were dissolved when the justices struck down the state's lethal injection law in 2012. The court ruled that, in the old law, state legislators had ceded too much control over execution procedures to the Department of Correction.

So, legislators this year enacted a new law that says the state must use a lethal dose of a barbiturate. However, the new law leaves it up to the Department of Correction to pick the drug.

The AP reported last month that the state plans to use phenobarbital, which is used to treat seizures, in lethal injections from now on.

Source: AP, December 27, 2013

Thursday, December 19, 2013

European boycott of death penalty drugs lowers rate of US executions

New Death Penalty Information Center report claims there were 39 executions this year – the lowest number since 1994.

The European-led boycott of medical drugs used by US corrections departments to execute prisoners is having such an impact that it has driven the number of executions to an almost all-time low, a leading authority on the death penalty has concluded.

The year-end report for 2013 from the Death Penalty Information Center, based in Washington, records that there were 39 executions this year – only the second time since 1994 that the number has fallen below 40. The report says a major factor behind the slump in judicial killings has been the difficulty states that still practice the death penalty are encountering in finding a consistent means of ending life.

California, Arkansas and North Carolina have all had effective moratoriums for the past seven years because they have failed to settle on a workable lethal injection protocol. Several other states are turning to untested drugs or to lethal medicines improvised in single batches by so-called “compounding pharmacies” that are not subject to federal regulations.

“The goal-posts keep shifting under the death penalty states,” said Richard Dieter, director of the Death Penalty Information Center and lead author of the report. “As soon as they move to a new protocol, the boycott spreads.”

The European Commission imposed tough restrictions on the export of anaesthetics to US corrections departments in 2011, and amid the squeeze a succession of states has been running out of their primary lethal drugs supplies. As a result, Florida has turned to midazolam hydrochloride, a drug never before used in executions, provoking an outcry that it might be inflicting cruel and unusual punishment on condemned prisoners.


Source: The Guardian, December 18, 2013

Saturday, November 23, 2013

"It Was Like Being an Alien": Damien Echols of the West Memphis 3 Speaks About Healing After Death Row

Damien Echols
Damien Echols
After 18 years in death row, with much of that time spent in solitary confinement, locked down 23 hours a day at the Varner Unit Supermax, Damien Echols of the West Memphis 3 now walks free - but he is not exonerated.

Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley were convicted for the murders of three young boys in West Memphis, Arkansas, in 1993 in what prosecutors called a satanic ritual killing. Prosecutors asserted that Echols, Baldwin and Misskelley were part of a satanic cult.

The 3 men now walk free in large part because of a new documentary directed by Amy Berg and produced by the couple behind the Lord of the Rings trilogy, Peter Jackson and Fran Walsh. The film, West of Memphis, lays out the key findings of an investigation, more than a year long, funded by Jackson and Walsh after they got involved with Echols' defense team and the fight to free Echols and clear his name based upon new evidence the documentary brings to light.

The film reveals how prosecutors and politicians resisted questioning the validity of the original conviction at all costs, despite new evidence that has emerged over the years contradicting their version of the events, and a fundamentally corrupt criminal justice system bent on shutting the case once and for all. The case of the West Memphis 3 also has been covered in HBO's "Paradise Lost" series and is the subject of a fictional feature film, The Devil's Knot, released in 2013.

Many have hailed the 3 teenagers' conviction as a modern-day witch hunt because prosecutors presented almost no hard evidence tying them to the scene of the crime but painted a horrific picture of a brutal killing based on the young men's dark aesthetic.

Since Echols' release, he has authored a memoir, Life After Death, and now lives with his wife, Lori Davis, whom he married while on death row and who has spent a tireless 16 years working toward his freedom, in the fitting town of Salem, Massachusetts.

Truthout spoke with Damien Echols during an event at the University of North Texas, which screened the new film.

Candice Bernd: How hard was it to adjust to life outside of death row after you were released?

Damien Echols: It was incredibly hard, just because not only had I been in prison for 18 years, I had also been in solitary confinement for the last 10 years. So just dealing with human interaction alone was just something that I was completely unprepared for. To say it's overwhelming doesn't even come close to describing it. But then you also take into account other things, like the fact that I have extreme post-traumatic stress disorder, was completely technologically illiterate, it really was like being an alien in an entirely new world and having to figure out every single thing you do on a daily basis by yourself. It took every ounce of energy I had just to make it through the day for several, several months.

CB: What was it like to learn of the flood of support you received while on death row from rock stars and celebrities? Did you ever imagine that your case would blow up and become something that reached the magnitude it did?

DE: No, but at the same time, when I was in prison, I would call Lori every single morning, and she would tell me what was going on. She would tell me Johnny [Depp] is doing this or Eddie Vedder is doing this or Peter Jackson is doing this. So I knew what was going on, but at the same time, as soon as you hang that phone up, you're going right back to just trying to survive another day in prison. So stuff like that is almost something that's happening in a completely separate world. It almost like something you see on TV. It doesn't have a direct impact on your daily survival when it comes to prison life.

CB: So you're free, but you're not actually exonerated. I wanted to ask about the Alford plea, which is kind of an arcane judicial doctrine. Why was it used in your case?

DE: The Alford plea. I had never even heard of such a thing when we got this. The prosecutor got together with my attorneys, and they came up with this thing called an Alford plea, which basically means that you are accepting the guilty plea that the state offers you - but at the same time you are legally allowed to maintain your innocence - makes no sense whatsoever. In essence, what it comes down to and what it's for is it's a legal way that the state can get you out of their hair, but at the same time they can't be held responsible for what they did to you. It lets them off the hook as far as lawsuits and things like that are concerned. Also, even now the state of Arkansas has never, ever had any exoneration. Nobody on death row has ever been exonerated by Arkansas. So this, us having to take this plea, allows them to maintain that record.

CB: Can you just talk about how Peter Jackson and Fran Walsh came to be involved in your case? What was it like to have their support?

DE: I can't remember how they came to be involved, because they were far more in contact with Lori than they were with me. She would be the one you would have to ask about when and how, but over time I can tell you that they became closer to us than my own flesh-and-blood family is. I absolutely love them dearly. They not only helped us out with the case, but when I got out I also had nothing. I didn't have anything in my pocket. I didn't have a suit of clothes to change into. I had nowhere to go. If it wasn't for them helping me whenever I got out of prison, I mean, really, in essence, I was homeless.

CB: Can you talk about your meditation and your spirituality and how it helped you survive on death row?

DE: It seems like most people out here don't put a great deal of energy into it. It's something that they think pays off once you're dead or in the afterlife or something like that. For me, spirituality, to be of any importance, has to be something you can apply to everyday life, that's practical, that benefits you in some way in your daily existence. And one of the things, for me, by the time I got out, I was sitting anywhere from five to seven hours a day of meditation. Over the years that I was there I received ordination in the Rinzai tradition of Japanese Buddhism, that was the tradition that used to train the Samurai in ancient Japan. I also had to learn a lot of energy work, things like Reiki, Qigong, Tai Chi, just because in prison, especially on death row, they're not going to spend a lot of time and money and energy taking care of someone they plan on killing. It just doesn't make sense. So there were times I had been beaten severely over the years, at one point; I was beaten so bad that I started to piss blood. I had been hit in the face, and it caused a bunch of nerve damage in my teeth, and there are no caps or crowns or root canals or anything like that in there. Your choices are live in pain or let them pull your teeth out. And I didn't want to live without teeth. So I had to find some way to deal with the pain - that's where the energy work came in.

I think a lot of people, whenever they practice spiritual traditions like this, they go through this period of wondering, 'Am I actually doing something or is this just mental masturbation. Am I playing mind games with myself?' And I never had to go through that. Because if I'm in extreme pain and I do something and the pain is gone, then I see that it works. I never have to wonder, 'Am I actually doing something here?' It became something that I was extremely passionate about and still am. That's what I do. I have a place in Salem, Massachusetts, where we live now, and also in Boston, where that's what I love doing, teaching meditation, teaching energy work.

But it made me realize, there are so many things dismissed in the Western world. Just for example, basically a lot of what I do is basically like acupuncture without the needles. And I found out through studying that in the United States we were told that there was no such thing as acupuncture all the way up until the 1970s. It was only when Richard Nixon was president and he went over to China and saw with his own eyes and came back and said 'Yes, I saw it. There is such a thing,' did Western doctors start to admit that it was real. Before then, Americans had been told it was a Chinese fairy tale, an Asian myth, there was no such thing. So it made me just wonder and also be amazed at how many things are possible that get dismissed or discredited due to lack of understanding or information. I've discovered a lot of those things over the years, just through the spiritual practices.

Source: Truth-out.org, November 22, 2013

Thursday, November 14, 2013

USA: Death Penalty Delayed But Not Denied By Drug Problems

California Execution Chamber
California Execution Chamber
Like many states, Missouri is struggling to obtain the drugs it normally uses to carry out the death penalty.

Last month, Democratic Gov. Jay Nixon stayed an execution under pressure from the medical community and the European Union, which threatened to hold up supplies of propofol, the anesthetic the state intended to use.

Missouri's Department of Corrections decided to take matters into its own hands. With another execution scheduled for Nov. 20, the department announced it would be using a different drug and adding a compounding pharmacy to its "execution team."

Other states are pursuing similar courses. Texas and Florida have also recently turned to new suppliers and new protocols. Ohio has an execution scheduled for Thursday, using an untested combination of drugs.

All of it is a response to the most recent form of resistance to capital punishment - legal and logistical challenges to the lethal injection regimens that have been utilized by most states.

It doesn't signal the end of the death penalty, says Franklin Zimring, a law professor at the University of California, Berkeley, but it does reveal a new front in the long-running battle.

"Everybody uses specific issues about lethal injections to have a conversation about how they feel about putting people to death," Zimring says. "In that sense, even though you think you're having a conversation about drugs and means, you're really having a conversation about ends and hostility to state execution."

Reverse Boycotts

Most states have done away with firing squads, gas chambers and the electric chair. 5 years ago, the Supreme Court ruled that the 3-drug protocol that most states used for executions passed constitutional muster.

But legal challenges to lethal injections have continued to proliferate since then, a part of every capital defense attorney's playbook.

Some of the drugs of choice were manufactured in European countries that are officially opposed to the death penalty. State departments of correction kept attempting to find new suppliers of sedatives, and then running into new obstacles.

After sodium pentobarbital became a drug of choice in 2009, for example, there was an uproar in Denmark because the product was made by Lundbeck, a Danish pharmaceutical company. In 2011, the company announced it would no longer ship the drug to American prisons.

There have been other such cases. It's like a reverse boycott, with companies refusing to sell their product to end-users they don't like.

"You don't have a lot of manufacturers of the drugs," says Deborah Denno, an expert on lethal injections at Fordham Law School. "You have a situation where the companies that were supplying the drugs, when they are revealed and realize their drugs are going to be used for executions, they don't want to have anything to do with it."

New Means To Prevent

Now, there are concerns that the new methods states are trying out could cause pain and lingering deaths. There are certain to be more legal challenges and more pressure brought to bear on manufacturers.

All of this is just the latest proxy battle abolitionists are waging against the death penalty itself, says Robert Blecker, author of the new book The Death of Punishment, a defense of capital punishment.

He says it's in keeping with other debates in recent years, such as concerns about racial disparities and claims that the death penalty is simply too expensive to be worth keeping on the books.

"The argument of the moment is the lethal injection argument - we can't do it perfectly and risk a painful death, so we can't do it at all," says Blecker, a professor at New York Law School. "Of course, the irony is that it's the abolitionists who are making it difficult, threatening to boycott European companies that supply the pharmaceuticals that would kill without any doubt."

Any method that states select is going to be subject to litigation, Blecker says, but he argues there's no chance problems with lethal injections will lead to a universal moratorium on executions.

Still, he concedes that the latest debate "could contribute to the weariness of those who support the death penalty in principle, but worry because there are so many obstacles."

Zimring, the Berkeley law professor, agrees. When he published his book The Contradictions of American Capital Punishment nine years ago, he says, prisoners on death row in Texas were 27 times as likely to actually be executed as those in California.

Today, he says, the difference is more like 50 times.

Not Going Away

Last month, Gallup released a poll that showed U.S. support for the death penalty had dropped to 60 %, the lowest registered since 1972.

But that's still a big majority in favor. And, although the number of executions carried out has dropped by more than half since reaching a peak in 1999, there are still dozens of killers put to death each year.

"This is a country that wants the death penalty," Denno says, "but there's enormous stigma."

States are running into almost-unending hurdles when it comes to carrying out executions, says Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center. For some, the cumulative effect has been the creation of de facto moratoriums.

Arkansas hasn't carried out an execution since 2005, largely due to problems with lethal injections.

"Our system is completely broken," Arkansas Attorney General Dustin McDaniel told National Journal. "I can no more flap my arms and fly across the state than I can carry out an execution."

But some states are continuing to execute prisoners, despite the challenges.

"You bring these challenges in Texas against a new drug, and the executions don't get delayed a day," Dieter says.

Source: NPR, November 13, 2013

Monday, October 28, 2013

No Drugs, No Executions: The End of the Death Penalty

Death Penalty Barbie doll
Death Penalty Barbie doll
Florida's new drug of choice replaced pentobarbital, a barbiturate the state used for years as part of its three-drug lethal cocktail until de facto boycotts by foreign drug manufacturers exhausted its supply. Midazolam hydrochloride, marketed as Versed, was chosen not because of its effectiveness but because of its availability, a decision legal experts say calls into question Florida's commitment to the Eighth Amendment's promise of no infliction of cruel or unusual punishment.

Florida is just one of several states scrambling to update or refine its capital-punishment protocol amid a sudden shortfall of its lethal injection drugs, resulting in an unprecedented inconsistency in the way inmates are executed in the United States. Even as a steady majority continues supporting the death penalty, the difficulty in obtaining new lethal drugs, associated legal hurdles, and a gaping void of better execution alternatives has left capital punishment in America with an uncertain future.

Distilling the amount of pain Happ endured is nearly impossible because the second drug in Florida's three-drug cocktail, vecuronium bromide, acts as a paralytic agent. Its purpose is largely cosmetic, effectively masking how much pain the subject may be enduring.

"We don't even know if the new drug (midazolam) is working or not," said Richard Dieter, the executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center. "Everything is a bit of an experiment with a human subject. If this were ordinary medicine, that would not be allowed, but this is the death penalty and that's how it goes."

In a letter to Florida Gov. Rick Scott last month describing the changes to its lethal-injection protocol, Florida Department of Corrections Secretary Mike Crews wrote that "the procedure has been reviewed and is compatible with evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society, the concepts of the dignity of man, and advances in science, research, pharmacology, and technology. He added: "The process will not involve unnecessary lingering or the unnecessary or wanton infliction of pain and suffering. The foremost objective of the lethal injection process is a human and dignified death."


Source: National Journal, Dustin Volz, October 28, 2013

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Missouri Looks at Other States’ Death Penalty Methods

Missouri Death Chamber
ST. LOUIS (AP) - In deciding to not be the first in the nation to use the anesthetic propofol for capital punishment, Gov. Jay Nixon left Missouri with dwindling options as it seeks to execute two convicted murderers in the coming months.

Gov. Jay Nixon halted Allen Nicklasson’s Oct. 23 execution following doctor protests along with threats from the anti-death penalty European Union to limit the drug’s export. Nixon ordered the state corrections department to come up with a different lethal injection protocol and instructed Attorney General Chris Koster to ask the state Supreme Court to set a new execution date for Nicklasson.

Other states, including Ohio and Texas, have turned to private compounding pharmacies to prepare new batches of the sedative pentobarbital after large drug manufacturers balked, a move Missouri could follow. It could also seek to administer a different FDA-approved sedative such as midazolam [used Tuesday night in Florida as part of a three-drug mix for the execution of William Happ, a house painter convicted in a Fort Lauderdale rape and strangulation.]

Another possible scenario for Missouri: months if not years of continued legal challenges. Nicklasson’s lawyer has asked the state Supreme Court to not rule on the request for a date until officials select a new death penalty drug.

“You can’t set an execution date now,” said attorney Jennifer Herndon. “There’s not even a protocol …The state’s request for a new execution date is premature.”

Nicklasson was convicted of the 1994 killing of Excelsior Springs businessman Richard Drummond. A car carrying Nicklasson and two others broke down on Interstate 70 in central Missouri. Drummond, a Vietnam War veteran, stopped to help and was then kidnapped, robbed and shot in the woods off the interstate. Another man in the car, Dennis Skillicorn, was executed in 2009.

Another execution is scheduled for now on Nov. 20. Joseph Franklin was convicted in the 1977 sniper shooting of Gerald Gordon as a crowd dispersed from a bar mitzvah in suburban St. Louis. Two others were wounded. When he confessed 17 years later, Franklin was serving several life sentences in a federal prison for killing two black joggers in Salt Lake City and an interracial couple in Madison, Wis., and bombing a synagogue in Chattanooga, Tenn.

Koster’s written request to the Missouri Supreme Court asks Nicklasson be executed “soon after” Franklin. A Koster spokeswoman said there were no new developments Tuesday, as did a Department of Corrections official.

Unlike propofol and other more widely available drugs previously used in executions, drugs manufactured by compounding pharmacies aren’t regulated by the federal Food and Drug Administration, raising questions among death penalty opponents and public health watchdogs alike. A deadly nationwide meningitis outbreak last year in which 64 people died and 750 others sickened was traced to a tainted steroid custom-made by a Massachusetts compounding pharmacy.

Such businesses also risk public backlash once their identities are revealed. A suburban Houston compounding pharmacy that supplied a special batch of pentobarbital to the Texas prison where an inmate was executed last week asked to have the drug returned after complaining about “a firestorm” of public attention, including hate mail.

“There’s going to be pressure,” said attorney Richard Deiter, executive director of the Washington-based Death Penalty Information Center. “Everybody in the medical business has their ethical codes and the death penalty usually isn’t a part of it.”

In Arkansas, Attorney General Dustin McDaniel recently told a statewide group of local sheriffs that the state’s death penalty system is “completely broken” and called lethal injection a “legal fallacy” given the drug shortage. He suggested the state either overhaul its death penalty laws or abolish it completely.

Missouri altered its execution protocol in April 2012 to include propofol only after it could no longer obtain the other lethal injection drugs it had previously used for a three-drug mix.

The decision to use propofol, the drug best known for contributing to pop star Michael Jackson’s 2009 overdose, quickly prompted a lawsuit filed on behalf of nearly two dozen death row inmates who claimed that using the unproven execution drug could result in pain and suffering for the condemned. 

Source: The Associated Press, October 16, 2013

Tuesday, August 20, 2013

USA: Air conditioning rare on Death Row in Southern states

Louisiana Death Row
Triple-digit heat indexes experienced by three convicted murderers suing officials at Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola are similar to the conditions endured by inmates on Death Row in Texas, Mississippi, Alabama and Florida.

But condemned prisoners in Arkansas have air conditioning, and prison policy calls for summertime cell temperatures ranging from 74 to 78 degrees in that state, according to prison officials.

“We started putting air conditioning in our older units in the late 1970s,” said Shea Wilson, spokeswoman for the Arkansas Department of Corrections. Wilson said all state prisons in Arkansas now have air conditioning for all inmates.

“I’m glad to know that at least one state recognizes the need to treat prisoners like human beings,” said Marjorie Esman, executive director of the ACLU of Louisiana.

The Death Row suit was filed by the New Orleans nonprofit The Promise of Justice Initiative on behalf of three Louisiana inmates.

According to the inmates’ suit, a heat index of 195 degrees was experienced on Death Row at Angola in 2011, and an index of 172 degrees occurred last year.

Angola Warden Burl Cain testified last week that prison officials believe inmates deliberately manipulated Death Row thermometers in ways that falsely enhanced temperature readings in past years.

Cain said he does not believe the super-high heat indexes are accurate.

Temperatures recorded at Angola in July and August 2011 “consistently ranged from 88 … to 100 degrees,” according to a court filing by Mercedes Montagnes, deputy director of the New Orleans nonprofit.

Actual temperatures generally are lower than heat indexes.

This year, court-ordered monitoring by an independent company revealed heat indexes as high as 110 degrees in July and early August, according to filings by inmate attorneys.

Such temperatures and heat indexes could violate the 8th Amendment’s prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment, according to a July 30, 2012, decision by the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. 


Source: The Advocate, August 19, 2013

Monday, August 19, 2013

USA: Death Row Improvises, Lacking Lethal Mix

The decision by the Missouri Supreme Court to allow propofol, the same powerful anesthetic that caused the death of Michael Jackson, to be used in executions — coming at a time when Texas, Ohio, Arkansas and other states are scrambling to come up with a new drug for their own lethal injections — is raising new questions about how the death penalty will be carried out.

“The bottom line is no matter what drugs they come up with, despite every avenue these states have pursued, every drug they have investigated has met a dead end,” said Deborah Denno, a professor at Fordham Law School who studies execution methods and the death penalty. “This affects every single execution in the country. It just stalls everything, stalls the process.”

With manufacturers now refusing to supply corrections departments with the drugs they had been using for executions, some states, like Georgia, have been resorting to obtaining drugs from unregulated compounding pharmacies — specialty drugmakers — which death penalty opponents say lack the proper quality control. Other states, as they run low on their old stock of drugs and are unable to replace them, are turning to new, untried methods like propofol or simply announcing that they are searching for a solution.

In the beginning, it was relatively simple and uniform. Several dozen states adopted the three-drug cocktail for executions first used by Texas three decades ago — a sedative (usually sodium thiopental) was mixed with a paralytic agent (pancuronium bromide) followed by a drug inducing cardiac arrest (potassium chloride). The idea was to provide a quick, painless method to replace the electric chair, gas chamber and firing squad.

But a shortage of pancuronium bromide a few years ago led some states to switch to a single-drug method, often simply administering enough sodium thiopental to cause death.


Source: The New York Times, August 18, 2013

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Arkansas governor to hold off on scheduling executions

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (AP) — Arkansas Gov. Mike Beebe said Tuesday he doesn't have any immediate plans to schedule executions for seven death row inmates, even though the attorney general has asked him to do so.

The governor's decision to hold off on setting execution dates comes as the Department of Correction plans to rewrite its lethal injection protocol and as nine death row inmates challenge the state's new execution law in court, governor's spokesman Matt DeCample said.

"We have to be in a place where we're confident to proceed, and when you now have an active court challenge over the statute and the uncertainty around the protocol, we're not in that position right now," DeCample said.

The Associated Press first reported Monday that the Department of Correction planned to rewrite its lethal injection procedure to include a different drug. That news came after the state last month said it lost its account with a pharmaceutical company that previously supplied it with chemicals.

It's not clear when the revised protocol will be complete, but the expected shift in procedure follows changes in the past year at the state Capitol and the Arkansas Supreme Court.

The high court struck down the state's lethal injection law in June 2012, saying legislators had ceded too much control over execution procedures to correction officials. So this year, lawmakers enacted a new law that said the state must use a lethal dose of a barbiturate in lethal injections. However, the new law leaves it up to the Department of Correction to pick the drug.

The AP first reported in April that Arkansas planned to use an anti-seizure drug called phenobarbital in executions, even though that chemical has never been used in a lethal injection in the United States.

Several death row inmates sued, challenging the state's new lethal injection law, along with the procedure that spelled out plans to use phenobarbital and an anti-anxiety drug called lorazepam.

Source: AP, June 18, 2013

Friday, May 17, 2013

Arkansas loses pharmaceutical company account after revealing plans to use its drug in executions

Weeks after Arkansas acknowledged buying an anti-seizure drug to use in executions, the state correction department said Wednesday it's losing its account with the pharmaceutical company that supplied the chemical.

West-Ward Pharmaceuticals notified the Arkansas Department of Correction on Wednesday that the company was closing its account, prisons spokeswoman Shea Wilson told The Associated Press.

Wilson said she didn't know why the drug company was closing the prison system's account, but West-Ward's London-based parent company, Hikma Pharmaceuticals, said Wednesday that it objects to its products' use in capital punishment.

Hikma also said it has halted direct sales of injectable phenobarbital to U.S. corrections departments after Arkansas' actions last month. However, Hikma spokesman Matthew Cole would not discuss specifics about Arkansas' account.

"More broadly, we're working to try to ensure that there's no unintended use of our product for capital punishment purposes," Cole said.

The AP first reported last month that Arkansas planned to use phenobarbital in executions, even though the barbiturate has never been used in U.S. lethal injections.

Arkansas and many of the more than 30 other death penalty states once used a virtually identical three-drug process: The barbiturate sodium thiopental was administered to put an inmate to sleep, and two other drugs were administered to stop breathing and the heart.

As sodium thiopental supplies dried up, however, Arkansas and several other states initially turned their attention overseas, obtaining the drug from a different British supplier. But, in 2011, they lost their supplies to federal agents amid legal questions about how they got the drug.

So, as drugmakers have continued to object to their products' use in lethal injections, states have been looking for alternatives.

Arkansas this year said it was turning to phenobarbital, the drug it bought from West-Ward Pharmaceuticals.

However, lawyers for 9 death row inmates are challenging the use of the drug, contending that it could be inhumane.

Arkansas hasn't put a prisoner to death since 2005, and for now, the state doesn't have any pending executions.

That's expected to change, though, as Arkansas Attorney General Dustin McDaniel asked Gov. Mike Beebe to schedule execution dates for seven of the state's 37 death row inmates.

Source: Associated Press, May 16, 2013

Wednesday, May 15, 2013

British firm moves to end supply of execution drugs to US

A UK pharmaceutical firm has announced that it is "putting in place concrete steps" to stop the use of its drugs in executions.

Hikma PLC, which is headquartered in London, made the announcement after it emerged that executioners at Arkansas Department of Corrections (DoC) had acquired drugs from the firm's subsidiary, West-Ward, which they intended to use to kill prisoners.

Arkansas had recently announced that it was moving to a new untested execution drug, called phenobarbital, after supplies of previously-used drugs were shut off. Papers filed with courts in the US have pointed out that the untested nature of the new drug in this context may result in prisoners not necessarily being killed but instead left in a “vegetative state” or with “devastating injuries that will cause prolonged suffering.”

In a statement released today, Hikma announced it was taking “concrete steps” to prevent “unintended uses” of its drugs:

“Phenobarbital is the world’s most widely used anti-convulsant. Hikma strongly objects to the use of any of its products in capital punishment. The Company is putting in place concrete steps to restrict the supply of its products for unintended uses. It has ceased the direct sale of injectable phenobarbital to US departments of corrections and will work directly with its distribution partners to add restrictions for unintended use to its distribution contracts.”

Maya Foa, Deputy Director of the Death Penalty team at Reprieve, welcomed the news: "We are very pleased to hear that Hikma are actively working to prevent their drugs being used in executions. Their action, like that of many other companies before them, demonstrates that the pharmaceutical industry is not willing to see its drugs used to kill prisoners. Medicines are made to save and improve lives, not end them in executions. Departments of Correction in the US must take heed of this message.”

Source: Reprieve, May 15, 2013

British firm supplying execution drugs to US

A UK-headquartered company is supplying lethal injection drugs to Arkansas Death Row, it has emerged.

The US state recently announced that it was moving to a new execution drug, called phenobarbital, after supplies of previously-used drugs were shut off by companies which did not want to see their products used to execute.

It has since been revealed that Arkansas Department of Corrections (DoC) obtained the phenobarbital from West-Ward pharmaceuticals, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Hikma plc, which has its headquarters in London.

Recent moves by a number of global pharmaceutical companies – including Lundbeck, Fresenius Kabi, Teva and Hospira – to restrict the supply of a number of barbiturates in order to prevent their use in executions has left prisons in the US struggling to find the means by which to carry out the death penalty.

However, despite being warned by human rights charity Reprieve that their drugs are being used in this way, neither parent company Hikma nor West-Ward have yet followed the example of their competitors in taking concrete steps to restrict supply.

Arkansas is the first – and so far, the only – state to switch to phenobarbital, which has not previously been used in executions. Papers filed with courts in the US have pointed out that the untested nature of the drug in this context may result in prisoners not necessarily being killed but instead left in a “vegetative state” or with “devastating injuries that will cause prolonged suffering.”

Maya Foa, Deputy Head of Reprieve’s Death Penalty Team said: “It’s very disappointing to see a British firm fuelling executions in the USA. Hikma claims to be ‘committed to improving people’s lives’ yet the firm is apparently happy for its drugs to be used in the potentially torturous executions of prisoners in the USA. This callous indifference to the suffering of prisoners and disregard for corporate social responsibility is all the more surprising in light of the ethical steps taken by other manufacturers implicated in the execution drug trade. Hikma knows that it can prevent its drugs from being used to kill, just as other firms have done, yet it is choosing to do nothing. If no action is taken, Hikma may soon become the prime provider of execution drugs across the USA.”

Source: Reprieve, May 15, 2013

Saturday, April 27, 2013

US inmates sue over death penalty

6 death row inmates sued Arkansas state prison officials on Friday, claiming execution procedures adopted by legislators last month will put them at risk for an agonizing death.

The inmates claim the state's planned use of a slow-acting barbiturate violates their right to be killed swiftly. They asked a state judge to prevent the Department of Correction from carrying out any execution.

Lawyers for the inmates said that when their clients were convicted, Arkansas law required that they be given a "lethal quantity of an ultra-short-acting barbiturate in combination with a chemical paralytic agent until the defendant's death."

Procedures adopted last month call for the use of an anti-anxiety drug and phen, a slow-acting barbiturate, in "a completely untried combination and quantity of drugs that will take hours to be injected and to reach their peak effect, that will produce agonizing and degrading effects during the procedure, and that will severely and permanently injure - but may not kill - the Prisoners," the lawyers wrote.

Aaron Sadler, a spokesman for Attorney General Dustin McDaniel, says the AG's office received the lawsuit and was reviewing it.

Attorney Jeff Rosenzweig, who filed the suit, said the new law includes problems similar to the old law, such as allegedly violating separation of powers between the Legislature and the Correction Department.

The Arkansas Supreme Court tossed out the state's previous execution law, saying the Legislature had ceded too much control to Correction Department administrators in carrying out executions. Legislators this year adopted a revised law, directing that inmates be killed with a barbiturate but leaving the specifics to prison officials.

The Associated Press learned last week that the state had obtained doses of lorazepam, an anti-anxiety drug, and phenobarbital, a slow-acting barbiturate used to treat seizures, with which to kill its condemned prisoners. Prison spokeswoman Shea Wilson said phenobarbital was on a list of FDA-approved barbiturates in court papers filed by lawyers for the inmates in a previous case.

In a letter obtained by the AP this month, federal public defender Jenniffer Horan told Democratic Gov. Mike Beebe that phenobarbital takes effect more slowly than other drugs used to execute prisoners and that it carries a "substantial risk of a lingering and inhumane death."

The Death Penalty Information Center said no state has ever used phenobarbital in an execution.

The lawsuit by the inmates - Stacey Johnson, Jack Jones, Jason McGehee, Bruce Ward, Kenneth Williams and Marcel Williams - names Correction Department Director Ray Hobbs.

Arkansas' last execution was in 2005.

Source: SAPA, April 27, 2013

Monday, April 22, 2013

Arkansas turns to different lethal injection drug

After surrendering its supply of a lethal injection drug to federal agents in 2011, Arkansas turned to a somewhat surprising place to look for another drug: a list from lawyers for several death row inmates.

The state Department of Correction told The Associated Press last week that it decided to use phenobarbital after attorneys for several death row inmates mentioned in a lawsuit that it might be an available drug. Phenobarbital, which is used to treat seizures, has never been used in a U.S. execution, and critics contend that a drug that's untested in lethal injections could lead to inhumane deaths for condemned prisoners.

"People should not be using inmates as an experiment," said David Lubarsky, who chairs the anesthesiology department at the University of Miami's medical school. "And that is basically what this is. It's basically experimenting."

As drugmakers object to their products' use in lethal injections, more death penalty states have been looking at different options. But the states have revealed little, if any, information about how they go about picking drugs.

"It's been: Here's what we're going to do and unless you can prove it's excruciatingly painful, the courts, they're not experts either, they're going to allow it go forward," said Richard Dieter, executive director of the Washington-based Death Penalty Information Center.

Just last year, Missouri announced plans to use propofol, the anesthetic blamed for pop star Michael Jackson's death, even though that drug hadn't been used in a lethal injection. In explaining the change, the state merely said the decision was due to a lack of another drug. Department of Corrections spokeswoman Mandi Steele declined to comment further Friday, saying the state's execution protocol is the subject of legal action.

The changes came after states' supplies of sodium thiopental dried up when the makers put it off-limits for use in executions. Oklahoma was the first to try pentobarbital, a sedative commonly used to euthanize animals, leading some other states to follow suit. But now those supplies are running out after manufacturers banned its use by states for executions.

In Arkansas, Department of Correction spokeswoman Shea Wilson said the agency consulted medical sources before picking phenobarbital, but Wilson refused to say what those sources were. She also wouldn't say whether the agency considered using other drugs.

"Our research indicated the drug would take effect within 5 minutes and should result in a painless death," Wilson said in an email to the AP.

But even the paperwork that came with the state's supply of phenobarbital, which is a kind of drug known as a barbiturate, warns that the "toxic dose of barbiturates varies considerably," according to records the AP obtained.

"We have no idea about whether or not the injection of such large doses will produce some acute tolerance effect, in which case you may or may not actually be able to kill someone with it," said Lubarsky, who has testified in death penalty cases.

However, Mike Ritze, a family physician and Republican state lawmaker in Oklahoma, said phenobarbital is humane.

"I don't want to compare humans with veterinarians, but for years, they euthanized animals and you can use anything in the barbiturates and they're all very humane. Basically, the person just closes their eyes," said Ritze, a proponent of the death penalty who said he has used phenobarbital to treat patients with seizures.

Arkansas and many of the nation's more than 30 other death penalty states once used a virtually identical 3-drug process: The barbiturate sodium thiopental was administered to put the inmate to sleep, and 2 other drugs were administered to stop breathing and the heart.

As sodium thiopental supplies dried up, Arkansas and several other states initially turned their attention overseas, obtaining the drug from a British supplier. But in 2011, they lost their supplies to federal agents amid legal questions about how they got the drug.

No one responded to phone messages left Friday at West-Ward Pharmaceuticals, the company from which Arkansas bought its latest batch of drugs.

Lubarsky, the anesthesiology department chair, said that "just because the drug sounds alike - thiopental, pentobarbital, phenobarbital - that doesn't mean they're that close a cousin."

Those 3 drugs vary in the amount of time it takes for them to start kicking in. Sodium thiopental is like a light switch: It starts working quickly, and it wears off quickly. Phenobarbital, the drug Arkansas plans to use, takes a bit longer to kick in, and it takes longer for the drug to wear off.

Some say that means executions using phenobarbital could take more time.

Federal public defender Jenniffer Horan wrote to Arkansas Democratic Gov. Mike Beebe this week, calling on the governor to review the state's planned use of phenobarbital, saying it carries a "substantial risk of a lingering and inhumane death." A spokesman for Beebe said the governor's office is reviewing the letter in conjunction with the attorney general's office.

Arkansas hasn't executed an inmate since 2005 and it doesn't have any executions scheduled, though 37 inmates are on death row. Should executions be set, the state plans to inject inmates with the anti-anxiety drug lorazepam before giving them a large dose of phenobarbital.

"The lorazepam is a pre-execution sedative, but it also is intended to offset the side effects of the barbiturate should any develop," Wilson said in an email.

However, Jon Groner, a surgery professor at the Ohio State University College of Medicine, says that might not work because lorazepam can make some people excitable, instead of relaxed. Groner has worked with lawyers who represent death row inmates and has written about how lethal injections create an ethical conflict he calls the Hippocratic paradox.

Medical professionals are arguably the most knowledgeable when it comes to the drugs used in lethal injections, but they're supposed to heal people, not harm them.

"These states are not experts in pharmacology," Dieter said. "They're just trying to carry out their law."

Source: Associated Press, April 22, 2013

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Lawyers say Arkansas to use untried execution drug

Arkansas plans to begin putting prisoners to death with a drug that apparently has never been used in a U.S. execution, and lawyers for condemned inmates warn that it could take longer for someone to die than with other lethal injection drugs.

The state doesn't have any scheduled executions, but Arkansas Department of Correction spokeswoman Shea Wilson told The Associated Press on Tuesday that it plans to use phenobarbital, along with lorazepam, to kill condemned prisoners.

Both phenobarbital and lorazepam are used to relieve anxiety. Phenobarbital, which is a barbiturate or a kind of depressant drug, is also used to control seizures.

In a letter obtained by the AP, federal public defender Jenniffer Horan told Democratic Gov. Mike Beebe that phenobarbital takes effect more slowly than other drugs used to execute prisoners and that it carries a "substantial risk of a lingering and inhumane death."

"No state has ever used Phenobarbital in a lethal injection procedure, and for good reason," wrote Horan, whose office represents a number of Arkansas death row inmates. "Throughout the history of lethal injection, states have preferred ultra-short-acting barbiturates that cause rapid unconsciousness and death. Phenobarbital, however, has a long onset of action."

The Death Penalty Information Center's executive director, Richard Dieter, also said phenobarbital has never been used in U.S. executions.

Arkansas' last execution was in 2005. The state is seeking to resume executions after legislators this year rewrote an execution law that the state Supreme Court struck down in 2012.

Source: Associated Press, April 16, 2013

Tuesday, March 26, 2013

Arkansas judge rules state's lethal injection records are exempt from Freedom of Information Act

Death-row inmates cannot use Arkansas' open records law to obtain information about the origin, history of quality of the drugs the state will use to execute them, a state judge ruled Monday.

Pulaski County Circuit Judge Collins Kilgore ruled after a hearing Monday that communication between the Department of Correction and a drug company was not subject to disclosure under the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act - even for the inmates who may one day receive a fatal dose.

6 condemned killers sought the information despite a section of the FOI law that limits the release of certain information about execution procedures - including how the drugs are obtained. The Legislature last month changed execution procedures after the state Supreme Court ruled in 2012 that previous lawmakers had given the Correction Department too much control over the process.

Kilgore said that, following a review of emails and other communication between the Department of Correction and a drug company, he had to reject the inmates' request. A Department of Correction official testified Monday the documents reflected an attempt to open an account with a drug manufacturer to procure new lethal injection drugs.

An attorney for the 6 inmates, Jeff Rosenzweig of Little Rock, had said they should have a right to the information because of problems with drugs obtained in the past. He noted in a court filing that his clients discovered in 2011 that the state was seeking to execute them using "unregulated, non-FDA-approved chemicals that it obtained from a business operating out of the back of an overseas driving school."

After Kilgore's decision Monday, Rozenzweig said the inmates would appeal.

In 2011, Arkansas turned its supply of sodium thiopental over to federal officials amid questions about how it was obtained. The sedative is used in some lethal injections, but has been hard to come by since its sole U.S. manufacturer stopped making it, so Arkansas and at least a half-dozen other death-penalty states turned to overseas suppliers.

The state Legislature last month enacted a new lethal injection law that spells out in greater detail the procedures that must be followed - Arkansas must use a lethal dose of a barbiturate, but leaves it up to the Department of Correction to determine which drug.

Arkansas' most recent execution occurred in 2005; the state currently does not have any scheduled for the 37 men on death row. Attorney General Dustin McDaniel this month asked the Arkansas Supreme Court to lift stays of executions for 6 death-row inmates who have exhausted their appeals.

Source: Associated Press, March 26, 2013

Saturday, March 23, 2013

California: Death row inmates challenge use of death penalty drug

Daniel Wayne Cook sexually assaulted, tortured and killed 2 men, a jury agreed. He's dead now, executed last August in an Arizona prison. But Cook's name lives on, as part of a lawsuit challenging the Food and Drug Administration's allowing importation of a drug used in executions by injection.

Death row inmates in California and several other states are now carrying on the challenge first filed under Cook's name, though of course none will be present Monday when a top appellate court debates the case that's 1 of many attacking lethal injection.

"They're trying to conduct this war on as many fronts as possible," said Kent Scheidegger, legal director for the Sacramento-based Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a nonprofit public interest law group. "I think this one is important for the way the inmates went after the death penalty by suing the FDA."

Scheidegger, a death penalty supporter, filed a friend-of-the-court brief that prompted additional questions from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. A 3-member appellate panel of the court will hear oral arguments Monday in the lethal injection drug case.

The inmates argue that the FDA acted improperly in 2010 when it allowed some state prison systems to import foreign-made sodium thiopental for use in executing prisoners. Though states have since been substituting other drugs for the fast-acting sedative, the legal challenge continues with the potential to reach even beyond the death penalty realm.

"This case is not about halting executions, but about ensuring that illegal drugs are not used in carrying out otherwise legal executions," attorney Eric A. Shumsky, who represents the death row inmates, said Friday.

In turn, the appeal being heard Monday is only part of a much broader set of challenges to how executions occur in the 35 states that, along with the federal government, currently use lethal injection. Some of these larger issues have reached the Supreme Court, and others may get there eventually.

In a 2008 Kentucky case involving convicted cop killers Ralph Baze and Thomas Clyde Bowling Jr., the Supreme Court upheld the state's use of a 3-drug lethal injection combination that included sodium thiopental. Baze and Bowling, sentenced to death for murdering 2 Powell County deputy sheriffs, had unsuccessfully argued that the 3-drug injection amounted to cruel and unusual punishment because of the risk for errors.

As states shift to other drugs, said Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, a nonprofit death penalty information and research group, they now face "quite a few challenges" questioning other elements, like where the drugs come from.

"Every aspect of California's lethal injection protocol is being litigated," said Terry Thornton, spokeswoman for the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.

In the 3-drug protocol long employed by many states, sodium thiopental induces general anesthesia. Another drug paralyzes the condemned inmate, and the third stops the heart.

A domestic manufacturer stopped producing sodium thiopental in 2009, prompting states, including Idaho, Kentucky, Missouri and Texas, to switch to a different drug protocol. California, Tennessee and Arizona decided, at least initially, to import the sedative.

Arizona has since switched to using 1 drug, and California Gov. Jerry Brown last year ordered state prison officials to consider making the same move. Thornton said Friday that review is still underway.

Last year, a Washington-based federal judge ruled that the FDA should not have permitted importation of a drug not approved for domestic use. In response, California officials denounced the ruling as "contrary to law" and federal officials contended they were acting with appropriate administrative leeway.

"FDA exercises enforcement discretion in the context of drug importation in a range of circumstances, a practice that has repeatedly been brought to Congress's attention," Justice Department attorneys said in a legal brief.

Like many of the death penalty cases, the case being heard Monday brings together different worlds in sometimes jarring juxtaposition.

Robert G. Fairbank is one of 20 death row inmates currently named in the lawsuit. He pleaded guilty to killing San Francisco State University graduate student Wendy Cheek in December 1985. Cheek had been beaten, stabbed and set on fire. Her body was buried in a shallow grave in the foothills of San Mateo County, south of San Francisco.

Fairbank later tried unsuccessfully to withdraw his guilty plea, saying he issued it when he was still hung over from drinking jailhouse brew. Shumsky, the appellate attorney, is a partner with the prominent firm Sidley Austin, which is handling the case pro bono. The case particulars, moreover, do not deal at all with what Fairbank and the other inmates did or didn't do.

Instead, lawyers are arguing over technicalities, like what Congress meant by the word "shall" in the statute defining the FDA's authority. It sounds dry, but it's crucial. Beyond its application to the lethal injection question, the eventual appellate ruling could shape future administrative challenges in other agencies, as well.

"The case also is important because of what it means for federal agencies that disregard federal law," Shumsky said. "Congress said clearly that drugs like these should be excluded from the country, but FDA claims to have unfettered discretion to let them in."

Source: Sacramento Bee, March 22, 2013


Arkansas AG asks judge to dismiss prisoners' FOIA lawsuit about lethal injection drug records

The attorney general's office on Friday asked a judge to dismiss a lawsuit from 6 death row inmates who want the court to order the Arkansas Department of Correction to turn over documents about lethal injection drugs.

Assistant Attorney General David Curran argued that the documents the inmates are seeking are exempt from the Freedom of Information Act.

Plus, Curran said, the inmates will almost certainly file another lawsuit, regardless of whether they get the documents they want.

Arkansas hasn't executed a death row inmate since 2005 in part because of legal challenges.

The state Supreme Court last year deemed Arkansas' 2009 lethal injection law unconstitutional, saying the Legislature had given the Department of Correction "unfettered discretion" to figure out the protocol and procedures for executions, including the chemicals to be used.

The Legislature this year enacted a new lethal injection law that spells out in greater detail the procedures that must be followed. The new law says the state must use a lethal dose of a barbiturate, but leaves it up to the Department of Correction to determine which drug. Correction officials say they haven't figured out which drug to use yet.

Arkansas doesn't have any pending executions, but Attorney General Dustin McDaniel's office recently took a step toward changing that. His office asked the Supreme Court to lift stays of execution for 6 of the state's 37 death row inmates: Don Davis, Stacey Johnson, Jack Jones, Jason McGehee, Bruce Ward and Marcel Williams.

Of those inmates, only Davis is not involved in the FOIA case. Kenneth Williams, another death row inmate, is the sixth person involved in that case.

In the FOIA case, the inmates' attorney, Jeff Rosenzweig, has argued that the prisoners have long been concerned about the correction department's "ability and willingness to carry out a humane and constitutional execution." The inmates are seeking documents containing information about the origin, history and quality of lethal injection drugs.

"Those concerns were heightened when, in 2011, the prisoners discovered that the ADC intended to execute them using unregulated, non-FDA-approved chemicals that it obtained from a business operating out of the back of an overseas driving school," Rosenzweig wrote in a court filing.

That year, Arkansas turned its supply of sodium thiopental over to federal officials amid questions about how it obtained it. Sodium thiopental, a sedative used in some lethal injections, has been hard to come by since its sole U.S. manufacturer stopped making it, so Arkansas and at least a half dozen other death-penalty states turned to overseas suppliers.

Rosenzweig said a fellow attorney, Josh Lee, asked correction spokeswoman Shea Wilson for records related to lethal injection drugs earlier this month. But according to Rosenzweig's lawsuit, Wilson said the department didn't have any new information to release under the state's new lethal injection law.

Curran, who represents the correction department and Wilson, said Wilson should be dismissed from the lawsuit. He says she's not a custodian of records that would fall within the scope of the inmates' FOIA request.

A judge is expected to hold a hearing in the case on Monday.

Source: Associated Press, March 22, 2013

Friday, February 22, 2013

Arkansas Governor Signs New Lethal Injection Law

February 20, 2013: Arkansas Gov. Mike Beebe's office said today that he signed legislation (SB 237) that rewrites the state's lethal injection law, despite his misgivings about the death penalty.

The new law spells out in greater detail the procedures the state must follow in carrying out executions. It says the state must use a lethal dose of a barbiturate but leaves it up to the Department of Correction to determine which one.

The legislation came up after the Arkansas Supreme Court struck down the state's 2009 lethal injection law last year.

The new law means Arkansas could potentially resume capital punishment, but court challenges may further delay the state from executing a prisoner for the 1st time since 2005.

Source: Associated Press, Feb. 20, 2013


Legal challenges likely to delay Ark. executions

Arkansas got a new lethal injection law this week, but court challenges will likely block the state from resuming executions anytime soon.

The attorney general's office expects some of Arkansas' 37 death row inmates to challenge the new law that revises another law the state Supreme Court struck down last year.

No new legal challenges had surfaced by Friday - 2 days after Gov. Mike Beebe signed the new execution legislation. No new execution dates have been set either, meaning the state doesn't have any pending executions.

The new law spells out in greater detail the procedures the state must follow in carrying out executions. It says the state must use a lethal dose of a barbiturate, but leaves it up to Department of Correction to determine which one.

Source: Associated Press, February 22, 2013

Sunday, September 16, 2012

West Memphis 3: Life after death



Just a little over a year ago, Echols was facing execution on Arkansas' death row:

"You sleep on concrete. You walk on concrete. You sit on concrete. It wears the joints of your body out. You're living with death hanging over your head at any moment, and all these things combined wear you down," he said.

He wears glasses in order to see beyond four or five inches from his face, due, he says, to being enclosed in a very small space for so many years.

"Your eyes are just like any other part of your body. If it doesn't get use, it starts to wither away. And that's what happened to my eyes."

And then in August of 2011, after spending nearly two decades in Arkansas prisons, Damien Echols and two other men were suddenly released as part of a highly-unusual plea deal (which we'll explain later).

Source: CBSNews, Sept. 16, 2012

Saturday, July 14, 2012

Ex-death row inmate avoids death penalty in Arkansas

A former Arkansas death row inmate whose conviction was overturned because 1 juror slept and another tweeted during court proceedings avoided the death penalty Friday by pleading guilty to capital murder.

Erickson Dimas-Martinez, 27, was sentenced to spend the rest of his life in prison without parole as part of a plea deal with prosecutors.

He admitted to robbing and killing 17-year-old Derrick Jefferson and apologized for what he had done, his attorney and a prosecutor said. He also received another life sentence for an aggravated robbery charge during his court appearance in Bentonville.

Dimas-Martinez was previously convicted and sentenced to death for killing Jefferson in northwest Arkansas in 2006, but the state Supreme Court overturned his 2010 conviction last year. The high court ruled that a juror who tweeted during court proceedings violated general instructions not to discuss the case.

"Most mobile phones now allow instant access to a myriad of information," Justice Donald Corbin wrote for the court last year. "Not only can jurors access Facebook, Twitter or other social media sites, but they can also access news sites that might have information about a case."

Dimas-Martinez's case raised questions about social media and jury trials, and the state Supreme Court asked a panel to consider whether to limit jurors' access to cellphones during trials. No decision has been made so far, but the issue almost certainly would have come up if Dimas-Martinez had gone to trial next month as scheduled.

Prosecutor Van Stone said he was pleased with the plea deal, which spared Jefferson's family from having to endure another trial and round of appeals.

"He'll die in prison and that's not insignificant," Stone said Friday.

One of Dimas-Martinez's lawyers, Tony Pirani, said Dimas-Martinez told the court that he would take his actions back if he could.

"Erickson for quite some time now has wanted nothing more to let the family know how sorry he is," Pirani said.

Jefferson's family wasn't able to make it to court Friday, but the prosecutor said this was the outcome they wanted.

Dimas-Martinez's guilty plea comes a day after he spoke and prayed with his family in El Salvador, Pirani said.

"It's one thing to get that as a sentence, but to sign up for it is not an easy thing to do," Pirani said.

Source: Associated Press, July 14, 2012