Showing posts with label Jury. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jury. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Deciding on death penalty in bombing case

On a recent program, CNN’s Piers Morgan asked Arnold Schwarzenegger his opinion on whether accused Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev should receive the death penalty. Although admitting that he was not fully informed about the case, the former Governor of California responded, “If convicted, I think that yeah, he should get the death penalty. Yes."

While Schwarzenegger, like the rest of us, is welcome to have and express an opinion, certainly the decision on such an important, life-and-death matter should not be based on what the majority of the public thinks or wants.

But what about the bombing victims and their families? Should their majority be a major factor on whether the Federal Government should seek the death penalty against Tsarnaev? And should their wishes be communicated to the jury?

Consistent with Justice Department procedure, U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz is in fact consulting with the victims and their families' families before making a recommendation to Attorney General Holder. Reportedly, she has distributed a questionnaire to hundreds of victims that includes the matter of capital punishment.

Hopefully, this part of the decision-making process is more about political correctness than public policy. It is absolutely appropriate for the victims to be kept informed about significant developments in the case. However, the preferences of victims should not guide either prosecutorial strategy or sentencing decisions.


By James Alan Fox, Lipman Family Professor of Criminology, Law and Public Policy, Northeastern University. Source: Corrections.com, Sept. 3, 2013.

Saturday, July 27, 2013

USA: 9th circuit vacates death sentence of Arizona man

Arizona Death Chamber
A federal appeals court on Friday upheld the murder conviction and vacated the death sentence of an Arizona man for a 1995 killing in which he dismembered the victim and buried the body parts.

The 9th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in San Francisco ruled that Michael Joe Murdaugh should get a new sentencing hearing because he was sentenced to death by a judge in November 2001 and not a jury.

A 2002 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Ring v. Arizona held that juries and not judges must decide whether a defendant is eligible for the death penalty.

Calls to Murdaugh's attorneys for comment weren't immediately returned Friday afternoon.

Murdaugh, 59, was convicted of 1st-degree murder in January 2000. He was accused of severely beating David Reynolds and robbing him of $180 and a cellphone on June 26, 1995.

Reynolds showed up at Murdaugh's home after meeting Murdaugh's girlfriend earlier that day and exchanging phone numbers, according to court records.

The girlfriend told Murdaugh that Reynolds had propositioned her and Murdaugh decided to teach Reynolds a lesson, prosecutors said. Murdaugh took Reynolds into a barn at gunpoint, beat him and robbed him, then bound and gagged him and left him inside the trunk of a vehicle overnight.

The next morning, Reynolds was beaten to death with a baseball bat and jackhammer spike, and authorities said Murdaugh took the body to a forest campsite in the Walnut Creek area 40 miles northwest of Prescott.

He severed Reynolds' head and hands, pulled out his teeth and buried the body parts in the forest, court documents show.

Reynolds' 2 gravesites were discovered a week later. Murdaugh was arrested after he went to a Prescott-area hospital for treatment of a cut on his leg unrelated to the murder.

Source: Arizona Daily Sun, July 27, 2013

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Jodi Arias prosecutors still plan to pursue death penalty

Jodi Arias
(Reuters) - A top Arizona prosecutor said on Wednesday that the state still plans to seek the death penalty for convicted murderer Jodi Arias for killing her ex-boyfriend, after a jury deadlocked last month on whether she should be executed.

Arias, a former waitress from California, was found guilty last month of killing Travis Alexander, whose body was found slumped in the shower of his Phoenix-area home in June 2008. He had been stabbed 27 times, had his throat slashed and was shot in the face.

But the same eight-man, four-woman jury that convicted Arias of murder and quickly ruled her eligible for the death penalty subsequently failed to reach a consensus as to whether Arias should be executed, prompting a penalty phase mistrial.

The state of Arizona now has the option of retrying the sentencing phase of the trial, which would require a new jury be empanelled. If there is another deadlock, a judge would sentence Arias to natural life in prison, or life with the possibility of parole after 25 years.

Maricopa County Attorney Bill Montgomery told reporters prosecutors would ask a new sentencing jury to do what the previous one could not - put Arias to death.

After the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict on May 23, Montgomery said that his office would assess its next steps, but was proceeding "with the intent to retry the penalty phase."

Source: Reuters, June 13, 2013

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Florida Senate panel considers death penalty changes

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. -- In what would be a significant change to the state's capital punishment system, a Florida Senate panel discussed a bill Monday to require a jury to unanimously recommend the death penalty.

The Senate's Criminal Justice committee took up the bill (SB 148), but ran out of time to vote. Sen. Thad Altman, a Viera Republican who's co-sponsoring the bill, said the measure would likely return to the committee next week.

Thirty-three states impose the death penalty. Florida and Alabama are the only ones that do not require a unanimous vote of the jury.

The bill also would require jurors in a death-penalty murder case to vote on "aggravating circumstances," factors that increase "the gravity of a crime or the harm to a victim." The jury also must agree unanimously on any evidence that supports a death recommendation.

Altman explained his aim with the bill is to achieve better justice.

"I really believe a unanimous (recommendation) will enable us to have a more effective and accurate system, especially when you have jurors that may be ambivalent on the death penalty," he said. "I think it would enable us to be tougher on crime by requiring a unanimous (recommendation), by making the penalty phase the same as the conviction phase."

Jurors in Florida must be unanimous to convict, but may vote with a simple majority to recommend the death penalty. The trial judge must give "great weight" to the recommendation, and usually follows the jury's suggestion as to death or life imprisonment.

In 1976, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld Florida's system of death penalty sentencing.

"Recommendations are still subject to review by the judge," said Sen. David Simmons, an Altamonte Springs Republican who's skeptical of the measure. "The present system provides the assurance that one juror would not be able to prevent imposition of the death penalty simply because of personal belief."


Source: The Miami Herald, March 11, 2013

Thursday, July 19, 2012

California: Scott Peterson appeal may be helped by ruling

Scott Peterson's prospects for overturning his death sentence may have improved this week.

Peterson, convicted of the Christmas Eve 2002 murders of his wife, Laci, and their 8-month-old fetus, filed his appeal July 5 with the state Supreme Court. One issue his lawyer raised was the trial judge's dismissals of 13 prospective jurors who said in pretrial questionnaires that they opposed the death penalty but might be able to vote for a death verdict in a proper case.

Those dismissals, defense attorney Cliff Gardner argued, violated Peterson's right to an impartial jury, a delicate issue in capital cases. The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that jurors who oppose the death penalty in all cases can be excluded, but those who say they can put their personal views aside may be seated.

The state's high court, which automatically reviews all death sentences in California, shed new light on that issue Monday when it unanimously reversed the death sentence of John Riccardi of Los Angeles.

The 76-year-old Riccardi must be resentenced to life without parole unless prosecutors seek a new penalty trial or appeal successfully to the nation's high court. The ruling will also become a precedent for other California capital cases.


Source: SFGate, July 19, 2012

Related articles:
Jul 06, 2012
Peterson has always maintained his innocence and his appeal to the Supreme Court is no different. Gardner claims that the overwhelming publicity Peterson's trial received, incorrect evidentiary rulings and other mistakes...

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Inmate: Alabama Judge Allowed Drinking During Trial

A new death penalty ruling from the Alabama Supreme Court sides with Mobile County Circuit Judge Charlie Graddick, who's now running for chief justice.

Death row inmate Jeremy Bryan Jones contends in an appeal that Graddick let an alcoholic juror drink during his 2005 trial, which ended in a death sentence. His claim is revealed in an opinion released Friday by the court.

Jones' attorney claims a juror revealed that Graddick allowed him to drink while sequestered for the trial, and that Graddick knew the juror was an alcoholic. The lawyer argues Graddick didn't tell the defense and may now be a witness during appeals.

The Supreme Court says Graddick can remain on the case, however.

Jones was convicted in the slaying of 43-year-old Lisa Marie Nichols in Mobile County.

Source: Associated Press, December 11, 2011

Friday, December 9, 2011

Death row inmate gets new trial because of tweet

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (AP) — The Arkansas Supreme Court on Thursday tossed out a death row inmate's murder conviction and said he deserves a new trial because one juror slept and another tweeted during court proceedings.

Erickson Dimas-Martinez's attorneys had appealed his 2010 murder conviction because a juror sent tweets despite the judge's instruction not to post on the Internet or communicate with anyone about the case. The lawyers also complained that another juror slept.

In one tweet, juror Randy Franco wrote: "Choices to be made. Hearts to be broken...We each define the great line." Less than an hour before the jury announced its verdict, he tweeted: "It's over."

Other tweets by Franco made passing references to the trial, with posts such as, "the coffee sucks here" and "Court. Day 5. Here we go again."

The court said Franco, known as Juror 2 in court documents, violated general instructions to not discuss the case. Before opening arguments, the judge said: "Just remember, never discuss this case over your cell phone. .... and don't Twitter anybody about this case."

Franco didn't immediately return a message left Thursday, but he has defended his tweets in the past.

"None of my texts indicated anything about the trial," he told the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette last year. "I hadn't made up my mind."

That explanation seemed to satisfy a lower court judge, but it didn't sit well with the state's highest court.

"Because of the very nature of Twitter as an ... online social media site, Juror 2's tweets about the trial were very much public discussions. Even if such discussions were one-sided, it is in no way appropriate for a juror to state musings, thoughts, or other information about a case in such a public fashion," Associate Justice Donald Corbin wrote.

The justices also used the case to point out that a wide array of juror misconduct can come into play when jurors have unrestricted access to their cell phones during a trial.

"Most mobile phones now allow instant access to a myriad of information. Not only can jurors access Facebook, Twitter, or other social media sites, but they can also access news sites that might have information about a case," Corbin wrote.

He also asked a panel to consider whether to limit jurors' access to cell phones during trials.

Janice Vaughn, who argued Dimas-Martinez's case in front of the state Supreme Court last month, said the case will likely bring about new rules governing jurors' cell phone usage.

Vaughn said both examples of juror misconduct — the tweeting and the sleeping — were such profound errors that "it had to be overturned."

An assistant attorney general had argued that the tweets were merely about the juror's feelings and not about specifics of the trial.

Courts in Arkansas and around the country are grappling with problems caused by jurors using Twitter, Facebook or other online services during trials. In 2009, a Washington County judge dismissed an attempt to overturn a $12.6 million judgment against a building materials company, despite the firm's complaint that a juror's Twitter posts showed bias.

Dimas-Martinez, now 26, was sent to death row for robbing and shooting a teenager after a party in northwest Arkansas in 2006. Prosecutors said Dimas-Martinez held 17-year-old Derrick Jefferson at gunpoint and demanded his money before he shot him.

Source: AP, December 8, 2011


Death Sentence Overturned On Juror Misconduct

A juror's failure to honestly answer questions during the jury selection process has resulted in a death sentence being reversed and a need for new sentencing trial.

December 08, 2011 /24-7PressRelease/ -- The death-penalty sentence for Gary Sampson, as a result of convictions for multiple murders in 2001, has been reversed and a new sentencing trial has been ordered because a juror lied when answering a jury form.

A Mere Technicality?

The juror, identified only as "C," failed to truthfully answer several questions on a jury questionnaire. During the jury selection process, she failed to disclose that she had been the victim of domestic violence and that her husband had in fact threatened her with a rifle. The juror failed to reveal many circumstances and experiences that would otherwise have disqualified her participation as a juror in the trial.

Judge Mark Wolf was clearly pained by the need to grant a new trial. In his decision, he wrote, "In essence, despite dedicated efforts by the parties and the court to assure that the trial would be fair and the verdict final, it has now been proven that perjury by a juror resulted in a violation of Sampson's constitutional right to have the issue of whether he should live or die decided by twelve women and men who were each capable of deciding that most consequential question impartially."

Some may dismiss this issue as a mere technically. After all, Sampson pled guilty and he clearly murdered three men, so who cares if a juror lied about having been subjected to domestic violence?

When the State initiates the process to execute a person, however, the trial is as much about protecting due process as it is about getting the conviction. Due process should never be dismissed as a mere technicality. It is all that stands between a legal execution and a murder. A judge's duty is to ensure the integrity of the judicial system. When cases involve a potential death sentence, that duty obviously must be heightened.

"Death is Different"

As the Supreme Court has noted, because of the irrevocability of the sentence once it has been carried out, the level of due process a defendant receives needs to be heightened in order to minimize the likelihood of a tragic mistake.

A trial court needs to be scrupulous in maintaining the integrity of the entire process. In this case, Judge Mark Wolf, in a 37-page opinion, painstakingly examined the specific questions put to the offending juror and how true answers could have affected the parties' views of her impartiality.

The judge describes how the juror lied about and concealed information regarding many topics. She did not reveal that her husband had threatened her with a gun. She kept secret the fact that that she feared for her life and obtained a court order for protection from him. She did not disclose that she had witnessed his arrest for violating the order. She failed to reveal that he was a drug user and that his drug use had destroyed her marriage. She did not disclose that her daughter also had a drug problem, had been arrested and had served time in prison.

None of this information came out during jury selection because C was too embarrassed to reveal any of it. This information only became known during three post-trial hearings, at which, Judge Wolf notes, "She often cried when required to think about these matters. She was frequently unable to discuss them candidly or coherently."

She also "repeatedly characterized each of those experiences as 'horrible' and a 'nightmare'."

But Did Her Lies Affect Her Ability To Decide The Issues Impartially?

The U.S. Supreme Court has a rather elaborate set of rules for a court to follow when problems with the veracity of a juror develop. In the case of McDonough Power Equipment, Inc. v. Greenwood, 464 U.S. 548 (1984), the Supreme Court outlined a series of questions a judge should use to examine alleged juror misconduct.

The core issue is whether the juror's lies demonstrate her inability to view the case impartially. The juror's impartiality goes to the fundamental question of the fairness of the trial itself.


Source: DigitalJournal, December 8, 2011

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Florida executions in legal limbo

More than 33 years after he killed a Coral Gables police officer, Manuel Valle's execution has been delayed until at least Thursday to allow time for an appeal. 

It's the latest twist that has seen Valle sentenced and re-sentenced to death three times since he shot Officer Louis Pena during a traffic stop in April 1978. Legal experts say a change in execution drugs that led to one of the latest delays could continue to impede Florida executions, while the state faces a perhaps greater challenge over its method of arriving at death sentences. 

Gov. Rick Scott signed Valle's death warrant, the first since he took office, with the execution initially scheduled for Aug. 2 at Florida State Prison near Starke. A challenge to an execution drug led the date to be pushed to today. Last week, the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta ordered the execution to be postponed at least two more days to consider whether Valle, 61, was improperly denied a clemency hearing. 

For University of Florida legal skills professor George R. “Bob” Dekle, delays to the execution of a convicted killer are nothing new. Dekle prosecuted the case of serial killer Ted Bundy for murdering 12-year-old Kimberly Diane Leach, of Lake City, in 1978. It took about 9½ years between Bundy's death sentence in that case and his execution. 

“It didn't take long at all. He was on the fast track” compared with others on death row, Dekle said. 

The average length of stay on Florida's Death Row for the 69 prisoners executed since 1979 is 12.68 years, according to the state Department of Corrections. Dekle said defense attorneys use “guerrilla warfare” in trying to prolong the lives of clients sentenced to death. Attorneys try to cause enough trouble and cost enough money that prosecutors throw up their hands and agree to a life sentence, Dekle said. 

“It's not the way the system should work,” he said. “Originally, death row was meant to be a temporary holding facility for somebody that should be executed in short order. That's not the way it is now.” 

In Valle's case, he initially went to trial with lighting speed — just 23 days after the crime. The Florida Supreme Court ruled that the quick turnaround denied Valle a fair trial in ordering the case to be heard again. He was sentenced to death again in 1981, but the U.S. Supreme Court vacated the sentence, and Valle was re-sentenced in 1988. 

In recent years, challenges to the lethal injection method have led to delays in executions across the nation. Florida was forced to make changes after the botched execution of Angel Diaz, who appeared to be wincing in pain and required a second dose of lethal drugs, in December 2006. A state commission found that IV lines had been pushed through Diaz's veins. 

The U.S. Supreme Court in 2008 upheld the three-drug cocktail of execution drugs used across the U.S. Florida and other states with lethal injection at the time used a similar three-drug combination of the anesthetic sodium thiopental, followed by a paralyzing agent and finally a drug that stops the heart. But the manufacturer of sodium thiopental stopped U.S. production earlier this year. 

Florida switched to another drug, pentobarbital, in June. The Dutch (sic) manufacturer of the drug later announced that it was untested and unsafe for executions. That led to Valle's challenge over whether enough of the drug was being administered to prevent the pain from the final drug. After a delay to consider the claim, the Florida Supreme Court upheld the method. 

Florida Department of Corrections spokeswoman Gretl Plessinger said the state has confidence in the new drug. She pointed to a consciousness check made after the drug was administered, one of the changes made following Diaz' execution, as ensuring inmates are not awake for the remainder of the execution. 

“We're confident. We're ready to go,” she said. 

Differences in execution methods among states could open up a new round of challenges, said Deborah Denno, a Fordham Law School professor who specializes in death penalty issues. While some states have made a change similar to Florida, she said others have switched to another drug or replaced the 3-drug cocktail with a single drug. 

That could lead the U.S. Supreme Court to again consider whether the variety of methods meets the standards of its previous decision, she said. 

“There was safety in numbers” but having multiple methods “starts to raise questions about what states are doing,” she said. 

Florida also faces challenges to its method of arriving at death sentences. Florida is one of the only states where juries can make death penalty recommendations that are not unanimous. Jurors also are not required to provide reasons for recommending the sentence, a method that a federal judge in Miami ruled in June was unconstitutional. 

Dekle said the state might face other challenges over the non-unanimous death recommendations. The American Bar Association recommended changing the system in a 2006 report on the state's death penalty. 

In Valle's case, a jury voted 8-4 to recommend death. Dekle defends the idea of not requiring unanimity, noting that a jury voted 10-2 for death in Bundy's case that he prosecuted. 

“If he didn't deserve the death penalty, nobody does,” Dekle said. 

Source: Gainesville Sun, September 6, 2011


Step by step, to death -- Florida's executions must follow strict code 

Nothing is certain, to paraphrase, save for death and the Florida Administrative Code. 

On Friday, the federal appeals court in Atlanta delayed Manuel Valle's second date with execution in just more than a month. He was set to be put to death tonight by the state of Florida. That's put off until at least Thursday. 

The legal road, and Valle's life, continue. 

Gov. Rick Scott signed Valle's death warrant, the governor's first, on July 1, only to be interrupted from being carried out in August by Florida court proceedings. When those concluded, in the state's favor, today's date was set. This most recent federal-court delay is far from the second. Valle committed murder more than 33 years ago. 

The convicted cop killer, if he's put to death, will be the 1st condemned prisoner executed by lethal-injection procedures that call for the use of sodium thiopental as the first drug in a three-drug sequence to execute prisoners. 

The Department of Correction's detailed instructions for lethal injections were approved June 8 by former prisons chief Ed Buss. A condemned prisoner is killed by a strict protocol that calls for the administration of three drugs that will, in succession, sedate him, paralyze his muscles (including his lungs) and stop his heart. Witnesses watch from behind a bank of three wide windows, sitting in a small room air conditioned by a loud unit built into the cinderblock walls of the death house at Florida State Prison outside Raiford. 

If Valle reaches the gurney following the legal challenges, each step is meticulously spelled out. 

After medical personnel declare Valle dead, Florida State Prison officials will lead witnesses (separated into two groups consisting of relatives of Coral Gables Police Department officer Luis Pena, murdered by Valle in April 1978, and all other witnesses, including reporters) out of the death house and into two waiting vans. 

Nearby will be a white hearse, curtains across its rear windows. 

Valle's body, if his sentence is carried out, will be taken away by contractor Archer Funeral Home Inc., of Lake Butler. 

The state's 14-page instruction manual for execution details how witnesses are to be escorted from the death house. The reporters will go to one van, family witnesses to another. Reporters, who have surrendered their own pens, keys, phones and all other pocket contents while being issued prison-provided pencils and pads, will literally compare notes after maintaining a respectful silence during their time in the death house. The public-address system that amplifies the condemned man's last words from the execution chamber to the witness room is not state of the art, and capturing that quote, if there is one, is a challenge. 

The short van ride travels through the gates of the prison across the highway to a grassy field, where protesters are roped off in separate designated pro- and anti-death penalty areas. 

By then, the warden will have called in attendants from Archer to remove Valle's body. With a death certificate in hand, the attendants will drive Valle's body to the Alachua County medical examiner's office in Gainesville. Archer's contract with the state stipulates the charge: $130. 

Archer contracts to carry and bury (or cremate) prisoners who die in the custody of the Florida Department of Corrections and are unclaimed. Archer has been paid $1.1 million on the contract over the years, state records indicate, from $93,176 in 2005 to $196,445 in fiscal year 2011. In the 2010 calendar year, there were 275 inmate deaths, plus one execution, throughout Florida's prison system. 

Florida's vast administrative code details how those prisoners, including those executed, are dealt with. The body may be claimed, according to chapter 33-602.112 of the code, first by relatives or friends. It may be claimed by a fraternal organization the inmate belonged to. Finally, the body may be claimed by the Anatomical Board at the University of Florida Health Science Center. 

In Valle's case, his family has told the state it would claim his body. 

If and when he's executed, Valle therefore won't be relegated to the cemetery at Union Correctional Institution. There are 1,946 buried there, the first nearly a century ago in 1913. 

Death is certain for all of us. The date of Manuel Valle's is uncertain now. Whenever it is, whether by the state's or nature's hand, Florida's rules, in all their minute detail, will still be there. 

Source: Paul Flemming is the state editor for the Tallahassee Democrat, September 6, 2011

Friday, August 19, 2011

Virginia executes Jerry Terrell Jackson




Jerry Terrell Jackson
Jerry Terrell Jackson was executed by injection tonight for the rape and murder of an 88-year-old woman he suffocated with a pillow and robbed of $60.

Jackson, 30, was pronounced dead at 9:14 p.m., said officials at the Greensville Correctional Center where Virginia executions are carried out.

Asked if he had any last words, Jackson shook his head indicating no.

It was the 1st execution in Virginia using the sedative pentobarbital as the 1st of 3 drugs administered in lethal injections. Virginia and most states traditionally used another drug that is no longer available.

Larry Traylor, spokesman for the Virginia Department of Corrections, said there were no complications.

Jackson was escorted into the execution chamber by execution team members at 8:53 p.m. He was quickly ushered onto the gurney and strapped in.

At 8:55 p.m., curtains were closed, blocking the view of witnesses while an IV line was inserted in each of his arms.

After the curtains reopened, Jackson declined to make a last statement and the 1st of 3 chemicals started flowing.

His chest moved as he breathed, his right toe appeared to tap and he moved his head a bit, but the movements quickly ceased.

He was pronounced dead by a doctor who was remotely monitoring his heartbeat.

Jackson was sentenced to death for the slaying of Ruth Phillips in August 2001. Jackson broke into her apartment, where she lived alone, assaulted her and fled with her automobile.

Her partially clothed body was discovered by her son, Richard Phillips, who went to check on her when she failed to attend church and did not answer her phone.

"These were senseless crimes committed with no regard for anyone or anything other than Jackson's own gratification," Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli said in a statement tonight. "The just sentence of death has now been carried out. Our thoughts and prayers remain with the family and friends of Ruth Phillips."

Gov. Bob McDonnell turned down Jackson's bid for clemency last week and U.S. Supeme Court rejected his appeal this afternoon.

Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor would have granted his request for a stay of execution, according to a short order from the high court.

Jackson's lawyers filed an appeal and a request for a stay of execution with the justices, in part on the grounds that Jackson’s trial lawyers failed to interview and present testimony from Jackson’s brother and sister about the physical, psychological and sexual abuse Jackson suffered as a child.

The testimony could have persuaded at least one juror to vote for a sentence of life without parole instead of death, they contend.

The Virginia Attorney General’s Office, however, countered that the jury heard a great deal of evidence about the abuse suffered by Jackson and that testimony from his brother and sister would not have broken new ground.

Jackson becomes the 1st condemned inmate to be put to death this year in Virginia and the 109th overall since the state resumed executions in 1982. Only Texas, with 473 executions, has put more people to death since the death penalty was re-legalized in the USA on July 2, 1976. Jackson becomes the 32nd condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 1266th overall since executions resumed on January 17, 1977.

Sources: Richmond Times-Dispatch, Rick Halperin, August 18, 2011


Electric chair or injection? Grim choice on US death row

Behind a blue curtain, the electric chair patiently waits its turn to take a life, but on this night in a chamber of a Virginia prison, murder convict Jerry Jackson dies by the needle.

"15 days prior to execution, the inmate is asked which execution method he chooses," explains David Bass at the Greensville Correctional Center. "He may choose between the electric chair and the lethal injection." For the most part, Bass says, "they prefer the injection."

The man in the dark suit and speaking in a soft southern twang is all too aware that most of America's death row inmates pick the poison over the pulse of electrocution.

Of the various execution methods currently in use in the United States - electricity, firing squad, hanging, lethal injection and lethal gas - injection has become the standard.

As an employee of the Virginia Department of Corrections, Bass is responsible for "guiding" about a dozen people attending Thursday night's execution - volunteers and journalists, including an AFP correspondent - through the facility about 160 miles (260 kilometers) south of Washington.

They are here to witness the death of Jackson, a strapping, 31-year-old African-American man whose crimes a decade ago sent his life on course to the events of this final night.

On an August evening in 2001, Jackson raped Ruth Phillips, an 88-year-old widow in Williamsburg, Virginia, and then suffocated her with a pillow.

Nearly 10 years and several legal challenges later, Jackson's fate came down to an appeal to Governor Bob McDonnell for clemency. Appeal denied.

Hours after the US Supreme Court declined to stop the execution, Jackson walks through a side door and into the death chamber. It is 8:50 pm.

Behind a 2-way mirror, journalists, prison staff and volunteers are wedged in their plastic seats, searching the prisoner's face and body language in search of emotion.

He is wearing jeans, a blue shirt and sandals. His upper lip quivers.

Taylor Roesch, a "citizen witness" in his 20s, squirms in his seat.

"It's something that should be experienced," Roesch, who is studying the death penalty, says about bearing witness to the execution.

"I want to be able to make a case," Roesch says about capital punishment, which remains a deeply divisive issue among Americans.

Jackson lies on a raised gurney fitted with leather straps. Six prison staffers methodically strap him down.

The curtain closes abruptly, and the employees, unseen, insert catheters into each of Jackson's arms.

5 minutes pass, and the audience is silent. A cough escapes from behind the curtain.

After 10 minutes, the fabric is drawn open, and Jackson is still conscious, his arms crossed over his chest.

The catheters, barely visible, will carry the lethal cocktail of three drugs - an anesthetic, then a muscle paralyzer, and finally potassium chloride to stop respiration - to Jackson's body.

Jackson's execution is the 1st in Virginia this year, and the 1st in the state to use the anesthetic pentobarbital, which is normally used to euthanize animals.

Several states switched to the drug this year instead of sodium thiopental for their lethal injections after the sole US supplier ceased production.

Jackson's face is largely hidden by the bulk of his body, but his chest can be seen rising and falling. His toes twitch.

Prison warden George Hinkle looks at Jackson. "Do you have any last words?" Jackson appears to say "no," but no one is really sure.

Hinkle steps away, and the injections begin. A clock above the door marks the time: 9:08 pm.

A minute passes, and Jackson's toes stop twitching. To the witnesses, Jackson looks completely inert.

At 9:14, an official declares, to no one in particular, "the order of the court was carried out."

Jerry Jackson is dead. The curtain is drawn once again, and the witnesses - some of them shaken - stand up. No relatives of the murder victim are in attendance.

Outside the chamber, in a dark parking lot of the prison, a pickup truck waits to take delivery of Jackson's body.

Source: Agence France-Presse, August 18, 2011

Related articles:
Aug 12, 2011
Lawyers for Jerry Terrell Jackson, who is currently facing execution in Virginia on August 18, recently petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to spare Jackson's life, arguing that the jury in his 2003 trial did not receive ...
Aug 14, 2011
McDonnell's action leaves the U.S. Supreme Court as the only hope for Jerry Terrell Jackson, 30, who is scheduled to die by lethal injection at Greensville Correctional Center. "After conferring with the appropriate ...

Friday, August 12, 2011

Virginia Jurors Never Heard Critical Evidence of Childhood Abuse




Jerry Terrell Jackson
Lawyers for Jerry Terrell Jackson, who is currently facing execution in Virginia on August 18, recently petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to spare Jackson's life, arguing that the jury in his 2003 trial did not receive sufficient evidence of the abuse he suffered as a child because his trial lawyers were inadequate.

Jackson's current lawyers told the Court that this evidence could have convinced some jurors not to impose a death sentence: "This Court has repeatedly held that, before a defendant is sentenced to death, a jury must be given the opportunity to consider and confront available mitigation evidence, including evidence of serious childhood abuse, relevant to assessing a defendant’s moral culpability." 

Clinical Psychologist Dr. Matthew Mendel, who appears in a clemency video prepared by Jackson's lawyers, said of Jackson's trauma, "People abused by parents or parental figures are those with the poorest prognosis. Jerry Terrell Jackson was not someone who was engaged in extreme misbehaviors to which the family responded. Child protective services referred to what the parents did to him as 'planned, calculated beatings.'"  

A federal District Court judge previously ruled that Jackson was entitled to a new sentencing hearing, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit recently reversed the ruling, holding that federal review was restricted to what had been presented in Virginia courts. 

Jackson also has a clemency petition pending with Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell, who could commute Jackson's sentence based on the evidence of family abuse that the jury never heard. (Click here to view the video. Caution: portions of the video discuss particularly disturbing examples of abuse.)

Source: Death Penalty Information Center, August 10, 2011


Last chance to stay killer’s execution

Attorneys for death row inmate Jerry Terrell Jackson are scrambling to spare their client’s life as his scheduled execution next week nears.

A stay of execution and an appeal of an appellate court’s decision were filed Friday with the U.S. Supreme Court. A petition of clemency has also been submitted to Gov. Bob McDonnell, asking him to consider commuting Jackson’s death sentence to life. Jackson, 29, is scheduled to be executed on Aug. 18.

All of the legal maneuvers focus on the years of what Jackson’s attorneys call “sadistic abuse” their client endured as a child. They argue that had a jury been aware of the extent of the abuse Jackson suffered they may have issued a life sentence rather than death.

In 2002 a Williamsburg-James City jury convicted Jackson of capital murder, rape, breaking and entering, robbery and petit larceny for the 2001 killing of 88-year-old Ruth Phillips.

Jackson is said to have entered Phillips’ apartment in the Rolling Meadows complex off Longhill Road through an open window. He then raped Phillips before smothering her with a pillow.

He took money from her wallet and fled in her 1987 Dodge sedan. Jackson was connected to the crime by DNA evidence and fingerprints from Phillips’s wallet.

Jackson’s death sentence has been upheld against multiple appeals over the last seven years. Many of the appeals center on childhood abuse, including beatings and sexual assault Jackson says he suffered, and that his trial lawyers failed to present evidence of the extreme abuse. The jury did, however, hear some testimony regarding the abuse.

A federal judge in U.S. District Court ordered a new sentencing hearing for Jackson last year, but the 4th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals blocked that hearing in April.

In the stay of execution and the appeal, Jackson’s attorney argued that while some information regarding the abuse was read to jurors from medical and social service reports, the reports were never put into evidence. Jackson’s mother and step-father testified that abuse occurred, but the attorneys argued that the severity of the abuse was “minimized.”

The District Court ruled that “the reality was a boy living in terror, constantly physically and emotionally abused from a very young age.” The court also found that Jackson’s trial attorneys did not request jury instructions to consider age and background as mitigating factors when considering the death penalty.

The Court of Appeals ruled that because evidence of the abuse was presented at Jackson’s trial, additional testimony from his brother and sister about the abuse wouldn’t have had an impact on the jury’s decision.

The stay of execution is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to postpone Jackson’s execution so the court can review the Court of Appeal’s ruling.

“Because the jury never considered powerful mitigation evidence relevant to Jackson’s moral culpability and because Jackson is facing imminent execution, the court should intervene and grant a review,” the appeal states.

The clemency petition asserts that the omission of testimony from Jackson’s siblings could have changed the jury’s mind and therefore the governor should commute his death sentence to life in prison.

It is unclear when a decision on any of the filings may come. Joshua C. Toll, one of Jackson’s attorneys, said in an e-mail Tuesday the Supreme Court is unlikely to make a decision until the Virginia Attorney General’s Office files a response. He said so far no decision has been made by the governor with regards to clemency.

Source: The Virginia Gazette, August 10, 2011

Friday, August 5, 2011

Using the Death Penalty to Get Re-Elected

Alabama judges seem to impose the ultimate judgment more often in an election year.

While most of the country was riveted by the verdict in the Casey Anthony case -- invoking the O.J. trial and decrying what many regarded as an unjust verdict -- the Equal Justice Initiative (EJI), a nonprofit criminal-defense and civil rights law and advocacy firm, released yet another in a series of reports that clearly demonstrate that the criminal-justice system, especially in the South, is broken and dangerously on the brink of illegitimacy. 

The EJI's latest report (pdf) focuses on a little-known practice, permitted in only three states: judicial override. Florida, Delaware and Alabama allow judges to overturn jury-sentencing verdicts in death penalty cases. 

There are no individuals on death row in Delaware as a result of judicial override, and no judge has imposed a capital punishment override in Florida in the last 12 years. But according to the EJI report, judicial override in Alabama is almost always exercised to impose the death penalty when a jury has recommended life in prison. In fact, although judges have the authority under Alabama law to override a jury's sentence of death and to instead impose a life sentence, 92 percent of judicial overrides are used to order death. 

According to EJI estimates, there are 40 men on death row in Alabama who were placed there after a judge overrode a jury's sentence of life in prison. 

Click here to read the full article

Source: The Root, July 20, 2011

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Texas juror admits mistake at trial and asks Texas Governor to spare Mark Stroman's life on the eve of his execution

Rais Bhuiyan
One of twelve jurors who served in the trial of Mark Stroman in 2002 has made a last-minute appeal to the Governor of Texas to spare his life.

With only 24 hours until Mr Stroman’s scheduled execution, juror Jenifer Sheehan has come forward to reveal how she was badly misled by the District Attorney Greg Davis during the 2002 trial. She has also expressed regret at her decision in the case, insisting that she was not given an opportunity to understand the wishes of the victims.

In a statement, Ms Sheehan said: “When I walked into that courtroom to serve as a juror I believed in the Death Penalty, but as time has passed I have come to deeply regret my decision to sentence Mark to death. Unfortunately, although I had doubts when we were deliberating, I was not able to stand up to the other bullies on the jury.

“I was misled by the prosecution into believing that the murder of Mr. Patel was a capital crime and know now that Mark did not go into the gas station to rob Mr. Patel. I am sure of that and so I should not have taken the decision to give him the death sentence because his crime did not warrant the death penalty.

“I also did not know that surviving victim Rais Bhuiyan did not want Mark to be executed, and the other victims supported his efforts. The prosecution presented the evidence in such a way as to give us just the opposite impression. If I had known that they had such a strong belief in forgiveness there is no way that I would have taken the decision for him to be executed.

“I know that some of the other jurors feel like I do and I urge them to come forward as I am in this appeal for Mark’s life to be spared. I also urge Rick Perry to listen to my voice as a juror as I say that I made the wrong decision and that Mark Stroman should not be executed.”

Mark Stroman was sentenced to death for a series of shootings in the aftermath of September 11, 2001, which left two men dead and one man injured. He is due to be executed in Texas on July 20.

Mark’s surviving victim, Rais Bhuiyan, does not want his attacker to be executed and is actively campaigning for Mark’s sentence to be commuted to life imprisonment. During the 2002 trial, Mr. Bhuiyan was not given the opportunity to tell the court that he was strongly against the death penalty.

Due to his strong religious belief in forgiveness, Mr. Bhuiyan has requested a meaningful period of mediation with Mr. Stroman. He has had no response to his request from the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. He is now suing the Governor of Texas, Rick Perry, for multiple violations of his rights as a victim of violent crime.

Source: Reprieve, July 19, 2011


Related articles:
Jun 03, 2011
Days after the 9/11 terror attacks, 31-year old laborer Mark Stroman went on a shooting spree in the Dallas area. In a drug-fueled mission of revenge, he killed two South Asian immigrants and shot another — Rais Bhuiyan ...

Jul 14, 2011
Mr Bhuiyan was shot by Mark Stroman in the immediate aftermath of 9/11. Fueled by his addiction to methamphetamine, which he used to medicate his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), Mr Stroman was close to the edge ...

Jul 13, 2011
Nearly slain by a racist killer in the wake of the 9/11 terrorist attacks, Rais Bhuiyan is now hoping to prevent the man's execution on Texas' death row. On Wednesday, he even asked for the German government for help. ...

_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Alabama: When Judges Override Juries, Death Is Often the Sentence

Alabama allows judges to reject sentencing decisions from capital juries, which sounds like a sensible idea. You might want a mature and dispassionate jurist standing between a wounded community’s impulse toward vengeance and a defendant at risk of execution.

“If you didn’t have something like that,” said Judge Ferrill D. McRae, who spent 40 years on the bench in Mobile before he retired in 2006, “a jury with no experience in other cases would be making the ultimate decision, based on nothing. The judge has seen many, many cases, not just one."

Judge McRae, chatting on the phone the other day, recalled having breakfast with Justice Thurgood Marshall at an American Bar Association meeting not long after the Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1976.

Justice Marshall was a fierce opponent of the death penalty. But, according to Judge McRae, the justice also saw the wisdom of the override system. “He thought it was better that someone who had seen more than one case was making the decision,” Judge McCrae said.

What Justice Marshall probably did not anticipate, though, was that judges in Alabama would not use their power for mercy — that they would, in fact, be even tougher than juries. Since 1976, according to a new report, Alabama judges have rejected sentencing recommendations from capital juries 107 times. In 98 of those cases, or 92 % of them, judges imposed the death penalty after juries had called for a life sentence.

Indeed, more than 20 % of the people on death row in Alabama are there because of such overrides, according to the report, from the Equal Justice Initiative, a nonprofit law firm that represents poor people and prisoners. The overrides in Alabama contributed to the highest per capita death sentencing rate in the nation, far outstripping Texas.

Judge McRae himself ordered 6 defendants executed notwithstanding jury verdicts calling for life sentences, more than any other judge in Alabama in the modern history of capital punishment. But he never rejected a jury’s recommendation of death.

Judge McRae said he had tried to determine, in the words of an Alabama law, whether the crime in question was “especially heinous, atrocious or cruel.” Having seen a lot of cases helped him made that decision, he said. “Juries don’t know,” he said, “what is ‘especially heinous, atrocious or cruel.'"

Alabama judges have justified their decisions to override in favor of death on other grounds as well. Judge Dale Segrest, who retired from the bench in 2001, said he had rejected 1 jury’s recommendation that a white defendant’s life be spared on the ground of racial equality. “If I had not imposed the death sentence, I would have sentenced 3 black people to death and no white people,” he said at a sentencing hearing in 2000 in Wedowee.

Judge Charles C. Partin, who sat in Bay Minette, said the defendant before him was probably not mentally disabled, a factor that may have figured in the jury’s life verdict. “The sociological literature suggests that Gypsies intentionally test low on standard I.Q. tests,” he wrote in a 1990 sentencing order.

Florida and Delaware also allow overrides, but they are subject to strict standards. No one has been sentenced to death in Florida as a result of a judicial override since 1999, and there is no one on death row in Delaware as a consequence of an override. The most recent override in favor of death in Alabama was in March.

Judges in Delaware are appointed, and they generally use their authority to reject death sentences. Alabama judges are elected, often running on tough-on-crime platforms. Overrides are more common in election years.

“Not surprisingly, given the political pressures they face, judges are far more likely than juries to impose the death penalty,” Justice John Paul Stevens wrote in a 1995 dissent from a decision that upheld Alabama’s capital sentencing system. Much has changed in sentencing law since then, and it is not clear that the system would survive a fresh look from the Supreme Court.

One thing that is clear is that Justice Marshall, whatever he said at breakfast, was appalled by how things turned out in Alabama. “It approaches the most literal sense of the word ‘arbitrary,’ ” he wrote in a 1988 dissent, “to put one to death in the face of a contrary jury determination where it is accepted that the jury had indeed responsibly carried out its task."

Alabama jurors are not notably squeamish about the death penalty, and those opposed to it are automatically excluded from service. Deliberations can be agonizing, former jurors say, adding that they would expect their recommendations to count.

William Davis, who served on a capital jury that unanimously voted for a life sentence, said he did not see the point of the exercise after a judge dismissed the jury’s unanimous recommendation as “not helpful."

“If the judge is going to overrule the jury,” he said in a court hearing in Montgomery last year, “then you don’t need a jury. The jury don’t serve a purpose."

Source: New York Times, June 11, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Sunday, November 1, 2009

America’s Real Death Panels

Jurors in capital cases must pledge support for the death penalty.

Next spring, Texas will decide whether or not to become the first state to admit it executed an innocent man.

Cameron Willingham was put to death in February 2004, 12 years after being convicted of killing his three infant children in a fire at their Corsicana, Texas, home.

In August, the International Association for Fire Safety Science (IAFSS) released a report that concluded none of the evidence from the fire indicated it was set intentionally and that the state fire marshal who testified the fire was arson lacked "any realistic understanding of fires."

The IAFSS was asked to investigate the case by the Texas Forensic Science Commission, which was created in 2005 to re-examine questionable forensic evidence. The TFSC plans to continue its examination of the fire, but admits the report is a "major step" toward exonerating all that is left of Willingham: his name.

As in any jury trial in the United States, Willingham, who maintained his innocence to the end, was convicted by a group of his peers--12 men and women who supposedly represented the community in which he lived. However, the prosecution in his case sought the death penalty, and that automatically changed the pool of people allowed to serve on his jury.

For capital cases in which the jury will debate whether or not to sentence a convicted defendant to death, the Supreme Court mandates that jurors be "death-qualified"--that is, they must pledge during the jury selection process that they morally support capital punishment and that they would have no problem signing a sentence that will result in the death of another human being.

Social science research indicates that this selection process seriously limits juries in capital cases to people who share similar moral viewpoints. During the last four decades, U.S. researchers have found that in capital cases the people most likely to be chosen during the jury selection process are those with "authoritarian" personality types--people who believe that strict enforcement of laws is needed to maintain social stability. Authoritarians follow convention. They think the function of disciplinary action is to control criminals. They predictably tend to convict anyone (both the guilty and the innocent) who is unfortunate enough to be indicted and brought to trial before a jury. In other words, they believe one is guilty until proven innocent, and are thus more likely to accept the prosecution's case rather than the defendant's.

Psychologist and litigation consultant Brooke Butler's research has shown that those on death-qualified juries tend to believe in a fundamentally just world--people get what they deserve and that everything that happens in a person's life is a direct result of things they control. She found that such jurors are more likely to make decisions based on aggravating circumstances (the morbid facts surrounding a victim's death, etc.) rather than mitigating ones. They are more racist, sexist and homophobic than their unselected counterparts, and less likely to accept mental illness or age as a defense. Death-qualified jurors are typically "male, Caucasian, moderately well-educated, politically conservative, Catholic or Protestant, and middle-class," she says.

Victoria Springer, social science researcher and sentencing expert, argues that the people with authoritarian personality types who are typically selected to serve on death-qualified juries will face a serious mental conflict. These pro-crime-control jurors are required to "adopt the attitude that the individual to be tried before them is innocent until proven guilty--which stands in direct opposition to their attitudes, orientation, and personality that has been specifically selected for."

From there, it is easy to understand how for such people the fundamental presumption of innocence conflicts with what the prosecution presents to them as "the facts"--the evidence, regardless of strength. Springer says that if the assumption of innocence clashes with the death-qualified juror's desire to remove a criminal from the streets, then the decision to render a guilty verdict reinforces what these jurors feel is their purpose on the jury in the first place.

Cameron Willingham, wrongfully convicted and executed by a Texas jury selected through the filter of "death qualification," was robbed of the right to have a jury of his peers decide his fate. Instead, he was put to death by those of his neighbors who innately believe that the American judicial system is a bastion of truth.

Source: Diana Novak, In These Times, Oct. 28, 20O9

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Is Texas Changing Its Mind About the Death Penalty?

Texas has executed prisoners with a regularity and in record numbers that has earned the state worldwide attention. But, while Texas still led the U.S. in executions in 2008, juries in the state appear to have began to turn away from the ultimate punishment even for the most heinous crimes.

Ten men and one woman were sentenced to death in Texas in 2008, according to the Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty. It was the lowest annual figure since the 1976 reinstatement of the death penalty. Texas handed out more than 20 death sentences in each of 2003 and 2004. In 2005, the number fell to 14, and it has not risen above that annual figure since. "The need for revenge, for vengeance is being curbed, the appetite is no longer there," contends Robert Hirschorn, a nationally known Texas attorney and jury consultant who has helped pick juries for many prominent clients, including, most recently, millionaire real estate mogul Robert Durst, who was found not guilty of killing and dismembering his neighbor. "The tide has changed," Hirschorn says. "It used to be fashionable to say, 'I support the death penalty.' It used to be unfashionable to say, 'I am against the death penalty.'"

Nationwide, and particularly in Texas, anti-death penalty sentiment has usually been centered on college campuses and within the Catholic Church, Hirschorn says, but is expanding beyond those communities — a trend he sees reflected in his jury questionnaires as well as in nationwide political polls.

The number of people sentenced to death has been falling nationally since a peak of about 300 a year in the 1990s, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, to 115 people in 2007. The reduction comes as more states, such as New York, New Jersey and Illinois have passed death penalty moratoriums; while some, like Maryland, are considering whether to abolish executions altogether.

Texas still accounts for 50% of the executions in the U.S., and with an appeal process of 10 years (the shortest among the states), the numbers are unlikely to decrease significantly. According to Kristin Houle, director of the Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty, the state averaged nearly one lethal injection per week over a five month period in 2008. There have been 423 executions in Texas since the state reininstituted the death penalty in 1982, and 374 condemned men and women are currently residing on Texas' Death Row. (One resident, Michael Blair, walked off death row this year after being exonerated by DNA testing.)

But now the number of new residents appears to be slowing. "[In 2008] officials' zeal for executions was not matched by public desire for new death sentences, as evidenced by the continued steep decline in the number of new inmates arriving on death row," Houle says. Nowhere was that more apparent than in Houston, a city dubbed the "capital of capital punishment" in a study by the NAACP. After years of being a major contributor to Texas death row numbers, thanks in part to high profile "tough-on-crime" prosecutors, Houston juries sent no new prisoners to death row in 2008. The Harris County prosecutor's office (which was roiled by the departure of its elected District Attorney over a sex-and-e-mail scandal) brought only two capital cases this year. One ended in a tough plea bargain and a 60-year sentence; the other, involving the vicious murder of a police officer, shocked the city's legal community when the defendant was convicted but spared the death penalty and given a life sentence.

The changing attitudes reflect broader changes in the cultural, political and social climate, says Hirschorn. But another factor is a key change in state sentencing laws, which now allow Texas juries to levy a life-without-parole sentence, dubbed LWOP. The LWOP sentencing provision, though vociferously opposed by the Texas prosecution bar, was passed by a conservative legislature and signed by a conservative governor in 2005.

"Cop killers, baby killers are poster children for the death penalty," Hirschorn says, "and without the option of LWOP you could guarantee the death penalty." In the Houston cop killing case, the lawyers for defendant Juan Quintero initially attempted an insanity defense, citing a traumatic brain injury. Though the jurors rejected it and found Quintero guilty, Mark Bennett, a Houston defense lawyer argued on his blog "Defendingpeople.com" that the head injury testimony lingered in the minds of some jurors, who may have regarded it as a mitigating factor in deciding on a life sentence rather than execution.

But along with changes in sentencing guidelines, something else has changed in Texas, death-penalty opponents claim. In the past, both Democrats and Republicans for high office have embraced the death penalty as an issue, but in recent elections, Houle notes, the issue has been rarely raised. Improved access to better quality defense counsel and the realization that capital cases usually cost county government upwards of $2 million each, Houle says, have helped reduce the number of death penalty cases. Recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions striking down the death penalty in certain kinds of cases — the rape of a child — and concerns about the legality of executing mentally retarded or mentally ill individuals have also slowed the number of capital cases being brought. With broader legal options, the most execution-prone state of the union may increasingly be opting for some other punishment than a life for a life.

Source: Time.com, December 23, 2008