Showing posts with label Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Church. Show all posts

Friday, April 30, 2010

Utah Catholics lead fight against Gardner's execution

Utah's Roman Catholic leaders are expressing dismay that, for the first time in more than a decade, the state is poised to execute an inmate.

The Salt Lake City diocese is urging parish priests to remind Catholics what the church teaches about the death penalty: that it cannot be justified when there are other ways to keep society safe.

The message to priests was included in the weekly bulletin sent to parishes where 300,000 Utah Catholics worship.

It urges Catholics to learn more about the issue on the Web sites of a new anti-death penalty group in Utah (http://www.utadp.org/) and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' Campaign to end the death penalty (www.usccb.org/deathpenalty).

Dee Rowland, the head of the diocese's Peace and Justice Commission, says there will be a prayer vigil at the Cathedral of the Madeleine in Salt Lake City in the hours before any execution of Ronnie Lee Gardner this spring.

The traditional teaching of the Catholic Church is that states can legitimately use the death penalty if it is the only possible way to defend human life against an unjust aggressor, according to the bishops' Web site.

But for 25 years -- led, in part, by the teachings of Pope John Paul II -- the U.S. bishops have called for an end to executions in this country because killers can be locked up for life in secure prisons.

"We cannot overcome crime by simply executing criminals, nor can we restore the lives of the innocent by ending the lives of those convicted of their murders," reads a 1999 statement by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops that was included in the bulletin to Utah parishes. "The death penalty offers the tragic illusion that we can defend life by taking life."

The bishops' campaign apparently is changing Catholic minds. The percentage of American Catholics who support capital punishment dropped from 70 percent in the late 1990s to 48.5 percent in 2005, according to surveys by Zogby International. Younger Catholics are much more likely to oppose state executions.

Not only does execution shorten the life of a person who may seek forgiveness -- and possibly salvation -- if allowed a natural life span, Rowland says, but it also hurts society.

"Mostly," she says, "it's what it does to us, making us all participants in the death of a person when it is not in self-defense."Other faith communities are likely to join in with protests and vigils before any Utah execution.

Utah Episcopalians always have protested executions, says the Rev. W. Lee Shaw, rector of St. Stephen's Episcopal Church in West Valley City.

He has attended many such protests through the years in Utah and California. He recalls a former Episcopal bishop, George Bates, demonstrating outside the Utah governor's mansion before an execution.

"There have been a variety of venues for this," Shaw says, "but it is always consistent that people of faith have opposed the killing of an individual."

The Utah-based LDS Church takes no position on the issue.

"The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints regards the question of whether and in what circumstances the state should impose capital punishment as a matter to be decided solely by the prescribed processes of civil law," according to a statement on the church's Web site. "We neither promote nor oppose capital punishment."

Source: The Salt Lake Tribune, April 16, 2010

Monday, April 12, 2010

Lech Kaczynski stood alone in opposing plans to hold a “European day against the death penalty"; said "homosexuality would destroy the human race"

Kaczynski’s conservative views and forthright comments made waves in other spheres too, and he occasionally clashed with E.U. partners over what some Poles saw as attempts to foist liberal “European values” on the predominantly Roman Catholic country.

In 2007 Poland angered its European partners when it stood alone in opposing plans to hold a symbolic “European day against the death penalty,” denying the 27-member union the consensus it needed to go ahead with the event.

Warsaw argued that Europe should instead mark a “right to life” day, with abortion and euthanasia on the agenda along with capital punishment.

When Poland had earlier gone through the E.U. accession process it ratified a protocol to the European Charter on Human Rights declaring that “the death penalty shall be abolished,” but Lech Kaczynski (pictured) argued that giving up the death penalty would give the criminal relative advantage over the victim. He predicted that the E.U., in time, would come to realize that capital punishment was justified in the case of murder.

Even before he became president, Kaczynski was upsetting liberal interests.

"Normality Parade"

As mayor of Warsaw in 2005, he refused to issue a permit for a homosexual rights parade, but when a pro-family conservative group applied for a permit for a “normality parade,” he gave the green light.

The stance drew strong protests from the International Lesbian and Gay Association and other advocacy groups, and later brought a rebuke from the European Court of Human Rights, which said the decision to ban the first event discriminated against sexual minorities and violated the right to assembly.

Lech Kaczynski and his twin brother Jarosław Kaczyński are major figures in right wing, homophobic Polish politics. Jaroslaw was until recently the prime minister of Poland. Lech had previously been the Mayor of Warsaw and reached international notoriety because of repeatedly banning gay pride marches from taking place in the city.

Kaczynski was accused of homophobia when in 2007 as President he was challenged over this decision, and said: "If that kind of approach to sexual life were to be promoted on a grand scale, the human race would disappear."

Whilst on a visit to Britain, The President of Poland, Lech Kaczyński has spoken out against "gay culture," warning that it may cause the death of heterosexuality within Europe.

Quizzed on his stance on gay rights by Pink News reporter Kirsty Wark, Mr Kaczyński said: "I haven't changed my position at all." Adding: "There always have been and always will be homosexuals in Poland, they forge careers for themselves, they are active in society."

Controversially, he went on to say: "That's one thing, but as for what's called 'gay culture', it can never be seen as an alternative to heterosexual culture.

"If a 'gay culture' were to be an accepted alternative it could mean that especially here in Europe, our heterosexual culture would disappear."

When he was Mayor of Warsaw, he, refused to issue a permit "for a Gay Pride parade. A short while later he issued a permit for a normality parade," which was denounced by the International Lesbian and Gay Association as a "demonstration whose main objective was an incitement to hate and intolerance toward LGBT people."

Sources: CNSNews.com, PinkNews, November 12, 2010

Saturday, April 10, 2010

One Christian's view on the death penalty

By Reverend Matt Randles
Pastor, Headwaters Covenant Church

In the Easter season, we remember Jesus' crucifixion and death for the sin of the world. Christians declare that Jesus' death brings life, so how can we then demand the death of certain criminals?

The Old Testament says, "You are to take life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth." But developing a biblical understanding of capital punishment isn't as simple as appropriating select verses from the Old Testament. Are we prepared to execute those who curse their parents or worship other gods? These are also capital offenses in the Bible.

In light of the New Testament, we don't follow Old Testament regulations about such things as burnt offerings, building codes, or dietary laws. Jesus addressed "eye for an eye" and said, "Turn the other cheek." He talked about murder but focused on the root issue of anger. And when faced with an actual situation--a woman guilty of adultery--he called for the one without sin to cast the first stone.

A biblical understanding of capital punishment isn't a matter of assembling proof texts; it must be consistent with the gospel: that God redeems the worst people--and even calls them to do great things.

Consider the Apostle Paul. He originally persecuted Christians, overseeing the lynching of a Christian named Stephen. Consider Moses: before leading Israel out of slavery, he murdered an Egyptian. Consider King David: he seduced a woman and engineered her husband's death. Yet, he is called a man after God's own heart!

These stories aren't incidental; they're at the core of the Christian faith. Central to Christianity is the principle that those who have received mercy are to be merciful, renouncing retribution.

Now, this doesn't mean that we abandon the rule of law. But perfect justice will only come from God; ours will always be tainted by mistakes, bias, and injustice. We cannot administer perfect justice; we must therefore not use irreversible methods.

Is fighting the death penalty worthwhile? Aren't there more important priorities-- poverty, homelessness, world hunger? But think about who Jesus stood up for: The guilty, the prostitutes, the sinners. Whom did he criticize? The self-righteous, the judgmental, those interested in maintaining the status quo. So, in speaking up for those that society disdains and against a corrupt system, we are speaking the language of Jesus. Jesus' own death was unjust; Christians, then, of all people, should oppose a system that is impossibly flawed.

Reverend Randles is the pastor of Headwaters Covenant Church in Helena, Mont. This column is a version of the address he delivered in January at the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty national conference in Louisville, Ky.

Source: The Washington Post, April 7, 2010

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Anti-gay pastor screens porn in Ugandan church to garner support for laws dubbed 'odious' by Barack Obama

A PASTOR seeking to bolster Uganda's anti-gay laws screened gay porn in a church in the capital Kampala overnight in a bid to gain support.

The screening in an evangelical church was attended by around 300 supporters after plans for a "million man march" were thwarted by police.

"The major argument homosexuals have is that what people do in the privacy of their bedrooms is nobody's business, but do you know what they do in their bedrooms?" pastor Martin Ssempa asked the crowd.

Pastor Ssempa then displayed a slide show of gay pornographic pictures.

"Is this what Obama wants to bring to Africa?" he asked, referring to fierce US criticism of a Ugandan bill drafted last year that would further criminalize homosexuality.

The bill would even criminalize public discussion of homosexuality and could penalize people who knowingly rent property to homosexuals.

In some instances, homosexuality in Uganda could be punishable by life imprisonment. The penal code identified "carnal knowledge against the order of nature" as an offence.

The bill initially received broad political support in Uganda but attracted fierce criticism from US President Barack Obama, who called it "odious".

"I want us to tell Barack Obama, who has African ancestry, that in Africa sodomy is an abomination," Pastor Ssempa said.

He also accused rights groups such as Amnesty International, which were vocal in condemning the anti-gay campaign, of bringing money to Uganda with the aim of "converting people to lesbianism."

The author of the proposed Ugandan bill, David Bahati, attended the gathering.

While the conservative wing of the Ugandan government continued to push for the bill, some politicians warned that its adoption could cost the country dearly in terms of foreign financial assistance and image.

Source: Heraldsun.com.au, Feb. 18, 2010

Monday, December 21, 2009

Christian leader supports death penalty for gays

A far right Christian group has urged fellow Christians to support Uganda's proposed law that would make homosexuality punishable by death.

Stephen Green, leader of the Christian extremist group 'Christian Voice', remarked:

"The Bible calls for the ultimate penalty for sodomy (Lev 20:13) and for rape (Deut 22:25), and our Lord upheld the death penalty when He called for the accusers of the woman caught in adultery to cast the first stone (John 8:7) – if, that is, they were not implicated in adultery themselves.

"The contrast between our politicians and those of Uganda could not be more stark. A Parliamentarian in Uganda is trying to protect his nation's children. The House of Commons of the United Kingdom is trying to corrupt ours. Which country is the more civilised, I wonder, in the eyes of Almighty God?"

The law would impose the death penalty on those convicted of having gay sex with a minor or disabled person or someone infected with HIV.

Friends and family members of gay Ugandans who do not report them to authorities could also face up to three years in prison.

People who "promote" or assist homosexuality could be jailed for seven years. The bill would also punish Ugandan citizens who have gay sex abroad.

The bill's sponsor, David Bahati MP, has argued that it will curb HIV infections and protect the "traditional family".

It has been subject to worldwide condemnation and since the first reports emerged in mid-October and has received widespread media attention.

Stephen Green added: "What is at stake here is no less than Uganda 's status as a sovereign nation. Will they allow themselves to be bullied by Western secularists, or will they stand by their Christian values and the traditional African way of life?

"I hope and pray it will be the latter, and that the Western homosexuals and abortionists who are trying to corrupt their youth will be sent a firm message to stop their wickedness."

Christian Voice opposes abortion, homosexuality, no-fault divorce and safer sex education. Additionally it supports the death penalty and does not recognise the concept of marital rape.

On September 2nd 2006, Green was arrested while handing out what were considered by the police to be homophobic leaflets at the Cardiff Mardi Gras.

He was arrested for an alleged "homophobic incident", detained for four hours, and charged with public order offences. The Crown Prosecution Service decided to withdraw its prosecution of Green on the grounds of insufficient evidence, though the police stated that this did not "challenge the legality" of his arrest.

Source: PinkNews.co.uk, December 21, 2009

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Execution wrong no matter the method, says Ohio Catholic official

When Ohio inmate Kenneth Biros was executed Dec. 8 with a one-drug lethal injection -- the first person in the U.S. to be executed in this manner -- the Ohio Catholic Conference did not specifically address the execution but instead reiterated the church's opposition to all means of capital punishment.

"The death penalty is wrong no matter what you use" to carry it out, Carolyn Jurkowitz, executive director of the Ohio Catholic Conference, told Catholic News Service Dec. 9.

The U.S. Supreme Court rejected Biros' final appeals the day of his execution. The 51-year-old inmate was executed by one lethal injection, instead of the three-drug cocktail used in all other states, because Ohio adopted this execution method after a failed attempt to execute Romell Broom in mid-September.

Prison authorities spent more than two hours trying to find a usable vein in Broom, 53, convicted of the 1984 abduction, rape and murder of a 14-year-old girl.

Death penalty opponents have argued that while they object to capital punishment taking place at all, at least the single drug is more humane than the three-drug cocktail, which involves a short-acting barbiturate that makes the inmate unconscious, followed by a paralytic and then a chemical to stop the heart.

Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland stopped Broom's botched execution and issued a one-week reprieve that has been extended. A federal judge was to begin hearing arguments Dec. 9 concerning the state's constitutional grounds to carry out a second execution attempt on Broom. His attorneys have called what happened to him "inhuman and barbarous."

Biros was convicted of sexually assaulting and killing Tami Engstrom, 22, in Ohio in 1991.

He was the fourth person to be executed in Ohio this year and the 33rd in the state to die since Ohio resumed capital punishment in 1999. With each execution that takes place in the state, the Ohio Catholic Conference, through one of its bishops, submits a letter to the governor asking for clemency. The Catholic conference is the public policy arm of the state's bishops.

Archbishop Daniel E. Pilarczyk of Cincinnati sent a letter to the Ohio governor Nov. 18 asking him to "stop this lethal form of punishment," referring to the one-drug method.

"Ohio has spent the past several months figuring out how to kill another person more efficiently," he wrote, noting that the state "will lead the country in experimenting with the new one-drug method of lethal injection."

"What a shameful legacy for our state: pursuing the slippery slope of 'humane' death," he added.

Archbishop Pilarczyk noted that the state's bishops have consistently advocated for an end to the death penalty, saying they believe this form of punishment is unnecessary and systemically flawed.

He expressed his condolences and pledged his prayers to the family and friends of Engstrom and victims of "all violent and senseless crimes" as well as prayers for Biros and his family and friends.

News reports of Biros' execution said the inmate received Communion prior to his execution and described himself as being "paroled to my Father in heaven."

"I'm sorry from the bottom of my heart," he said after thanking his family and friends for their support.

Source: TheCatholicSpirit.com, December 9, 2009

Monday, October 19, 2009

Chapter and verse on the death penalty

When Texan jurors turned to the Old Testament to determine if a man on death row should die they crossed an important line.

The Bible, along with other sacred texts, provides solace and inspiration for billions across the planet. But how literally do its readers take passages such as this one?

If he smite him with an instrument of iron, so that he die, he is a murderer:the murderer shall surely be put to death.

Very literally, in some cases. Because this piece of scripture, from the book of Numbers (35:16) in the Old Testament, evidently provides some Christians with what they believe is "literal truth" and a biblical underpinning to their personal support for capital punishment.

When a man called Khristian Oliver stood trial for murder in Texas 10 years ago, several jurors consulted the Bible extensively during their deliberations. Key passages were highlighted and handed around among fellow believers. The "smite him" verse was one of them. One of these jurors later confirmed that reference to scripture played a part in his deliberation. In his view, biblical pronouncements always trumped man-made laws and he fervently believed that "the Bible is the truth from page one to the last page".

This juror, apparently just one of a four-fifths majority of jury members who introduced biblical notions into the jury discussion, also later made it very clear that he was a firm believer in capital punishment, describing life imprisonment as a "burden" on the taxpayer.

Did those religious, believing jury members cross an important line when they began looking up and discussing what they would have seen as "relevant" verses from an ancient text? Was it improper? Was it perhaps a well-intentioned, but deeply worrying deviation from the expected conduct of a jury?

A US appeals court certainly thought so. Last year, the court of appeals for the fifth circuit said that these God-fearing jurors "had crossed an important line" when they searched for guidance in scripture. It was, said this federal court, a more "egregious" example of this than had occurred in other jurisdictions. But federal appeals courts are extremely chary of overturning state courts' decisions. Oliver's appeal was dismissed. Surely the supreme court couldn't let this pass? In fact, because of growing disquiet in the US about a resort to Bibles in jury rooms, earlier this year a group of 46 federal and state prosecutors joined together in a petition to America's senior court urging it to examine the Oliver case to clarify law in this area. The supreme court declined to do so.

Oliver is now scheduled for execution on 5 November. He is left praying for either a rare clemency recommendation from the Texas board of pardons and paroles or, failing that, a stay of execution from the hardline state governor Rick Perry.

Human rights and faith often go hand in hand, a righteous belief in fairness and truth frequently linking arms with a fervent desire to ensure equality before the law and justice for all. Religion is a massively powerful fortifier to those suffering oppression and injustice. Prisoners the world over have held on to or even developed faith to see them through their mightiest challenges. Indeed, many of those within America's massive death row system survive the mental torture of years facing a gruesome death in a lethal injection chamber by turning to God.

But when biblical exegesis replaces the solemn, dispassionate weighing of evidence you know that things have gone badly wrong. It's one thing for a witness to swear on a Bible [1] to tell the truth before a jury in a courtroom. It's quite another for those jury members to take the Bible back with them to the jury room to decide whether a man will live or die.


[1] The author of this blog disagrees with this statement. Swearing on a Bible before giving testimony in a courtroom may well be the first step towards legitimizing the Bible at ALL stages of a trial, including returning a verdict and deciding on a punishment. Let's keep Bibles out of schools and courtrooms!

Source: TheGuardian.co.uk, Oct.

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Innocent man’s execution shows shame of death penalty


The death penalty may have finally crossed a shameful line that, if there is any sense of reason or justice in American society, should bring the practice to a swift and final end. The state of Texas, despite all of the safeguards that proponents of the death penalty claim would prevent this from happening, may have executed an innocent man.

A story in the Sept. 7 issue of The New Yorker details the case of Cameron Todd Willingham who was executed on Feb. 17, 2004, by lethal injection in the Texas death house at the state prison in Huntsville. Texas has made the most prolific use of the death penalty since its re–establishment in 1977.

Willingham was convicted of murdering his three young children after they died in a house fire on Dec. 23, 1991, in Corsicana, Texas. The unemployed auto mechanic had been at home watching the children while his wife was shopping for Christmas presents for their three daughters. He told investigators that his 2–year–old daughter woke him from a nap saying that the house was on fire, but his attempts to rescue the children failed.

Investigators determined that the fire was arson, although there was a history of the children tampering with a space heater used to warm part of the small house where the family lived in a rundown, failed oil town.

However, later reviews of the case by arson and forensics experts determined that investigators used a combination of junk science and folklore to reach their flawed conclusion of arson.

Willingham quickly became the prime suspect, and like most poor defendants, had weak legal representation. As his case worked its way through the process, he steadfastly professed his innocence, to the point of rejecting a plea bargain that would have spared him the death penalty. But based on essentially unchallenged “scientific” evidence, he went to his death.

All of the safeguards failed.

In an interview before his execution, Willingham told The Associated Press he was innocent. “The most distressing thing is the state of Texas will kill an innocent man and doesn’t care they’re making a mistake,” he said.

In a U.S. Supreme Court case decided this summer, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in his opinion that “a criminal defendant proved guilty after a fair trial does not have the same liberty interests as a free man.” Which raises a question: can a trial be fair if an innocent person is convicted?

That there are wrongly convicted inmates on death row is nothing new. Well over 100 people on the nation’s death rows have been shown to be completely innocent of the crimes for which they were convicted through scientific reviews of their cases. How many others, without access to the technology and resources that could prove their innocence have been walked to their death in a prison execution chamber? How many have died unjustly, all in the name of justice?

We are not so naive to believe that everyone on death row is innocent. Prisons across the country are filled with guilty people paying their debt to society. But we shouldn’t strip someone of their dignity when they enter prison, like it’s an old T–shirt. The dignity God gives every person follows them every step of their life. As Catholics, we pray the guilty will repent and be redeemed. And we must demand that the innocent receive justice.

As the church has long taught, the death penalty is not the proper response to crime and violence. Society has both the right and duty to protect its citizens, but modern society has the capacity to do so without resorting to the execution of criminals.

Perhaps the good that might come from the tragic death of three young girls in a house fire and the egregious actions of the state in the execution of their father might open the eyes of our nation to the failed system that has very likely executed an innocent man.

Source: Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, Sept. 23, 2009

Monday, March 30, 2009

Pope might back Jindal on death penalty

New Mexico's Roman Catholic governor last week signed legislation that abolished the death penalty after discussing the issue with a Roman Catholic archbishop.

In Maryland, Gov. Martin O'Malley also a Catholic marched against capital punishment in a failed attempt earlier this month to eliminate executions in his state.

Gov. Bobby Jindal, who converted to Catholicism as a young man, said that despite efforts in other states to abolish capital punishment, he has no qualms about the death penalty, which is law in Louisiana. He wants to extend capital punishment to perpetrators who rape young children.

The issue of religion surfaced recently in an interview with Jindal after some church officials urged several other Catholic governors to support abolition of the death penalty in their states.

Jindal said the Catholic Church deems the death penalty to be permissible.

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops disagrees with Jindal. But Pope Benedict may be in his corner.

"The catechism opposes the death penalty. The catechism is pretty clear," said Kathy Saile, director of domestic social development for the Washington, D.C.,-based bishops conference, referring to the handbook of Catholic principles.

The conference's fact sheet titled "What Every Catholic Should Know About the Death Penalty" states that Catholics should comfort victims' families while acknowledging "the God-given dignity of every human life, even those who do great harm."

15 states prohibit the death penalty.

Saile concedes that the conference has not taken a position on whether Catholic politicians such as Jindal should be denied Communion for supporting capital punishment.

Some Catholic politicians who call themselves abortion-rights advocates have faced that.

Former Gov. Kathleen Blanco, a Catholic, declined to discuss whether she wrestled with the issue of possibly having to sign a death warrant. No one was executed while she was governor.

Pope Benedict's predecessor, Pope John Paul II, was on record as opposing capital punishment.

In 1999, Pope John Paul II made an appeal "for a consensus to end the death penalty, which is both cruel and unnecessary." A year earlier, the pope urged then-Texas Gov. George W. Bush to grant clemency to Karla Faye Tucker, an alleged pickaxe murderer who found religion behind bars. Bush refused the request.

Shortly before becoming Pope Benedict, Cardinal Ratzinger weighed in on one of the most important issues to a Catholic: the receiving of Holy Communion.

Communion can be denied to those considered unworthy.

Ratzinger concluded in a letter that capital punishment and warfare do not carry the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia and that there may be "a legitimate diversity of opinion among Catholics" on the death penalty and war but not on the latter 2 issues.

Saile said she is not aware of the former cardinal speaking about the death penalty since becoming pope.

Across the United States, at least 13 governors are Catholic. Only one of those governors, New Mexico's Bill Richardson, is in a state that does not permit executions.

Colorado's Bill Vitter, a practicing Catholic, said before becoming governor that he would not impose his personal beliefs on public policy.

"No doubt, there will be times when my decisions on some issues may be at odds with the orthodoxy of the Catholic Church," he said in an interview.

Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center in Washington, D.C., said Pope John Paul II forced Catholic officials in the U.S. to take a stance on capital punishment.

There was a time when being a Catholic governor would not raise any questions on the death penalty, Dieter said in an interview. "Today, that is no longer true."

However, Dieter said, church officials, including the current pope, do not seem to be giving the death penalty the same focus it had 10 years ago.

"I believe the opposition is still there, but it is not as pronounced or public as it was," Dieter said. "This probably eases the pressure on Catholic officials who represent a broad diversity of constituents on this issue."

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops keeps a tally of the number of Catholics in each state. Among the top 5 states with the largest percentage of Catholics, only Connecticut allows executions. New Jersey, where 41 % are Catholic, repealed the death penalty 2 years ago. Connecticut has executed 1 person since 1976.

"For the longest time, we were a state that only had the death penalty in name," said Ben Jones, executive director of Connecticut Network to Abolish the Death Penalty.

That changed, Jones said, after Michael Ross admitted raping and killing 8 women. Ross refused to fight his execution, and Connecticut put him to death in 2005.

His death marked the 1st execution in New England in 45 years.

As Ross' execution approached, Catholic church leaders in Connecticut spoke out against the death penalty. They directed an anti-death penalty stance to be explained to parishioners at Mass.

Connecticut Bishop William Lori told National Catholic Reporter in 2005 that the death penalty "offers the tragic illusion that we can defend life by taking life."

Earlier this year, Catholic officials urged Richardson to support legislation repealing the death penalty in New Mexico and hailed him when he signed the bill into law on March 18.

News reports claimed that talks with Archbishop of Santa Fe Michael Sheehan helped sway Richardson, who previously was opposed to abolishing the death penalty.

However, Richardson made clear last week that it was the possibility of executing an innocent person that weighed heaviest on his conscience.

"In a society which values individual life and liberty above all else, where justice and not vengeance is the singular guiding principle of our system of criminal law, the potential for wrongful conviction and, God forbid, execution of an innocent person stands as anathema to our very sensibilities as human beings," he said.

Source: The Advocate, March 30, 2009

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Is Texas Changing Its Mind About the Death Penalty?

Texas has executed prisoners with a regularity and in record numbers that has earned the state worldwide attention. But, while Texas still led the U.S. in executions in 2008, juries in the state appear to have began to turn away from the ultimate punishment even for the most heinous crimes.

Ten men and one woman were sentenced to death in Texas in 2008, according to the Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty. It was the lowest annual figure since the 1976 reinstatement of the death penalty. Texas handed out more than 20 death sentences in each of 2003 and 2004. In 2005, the number fell to 14, and it has not risen above that annual figure since. "The need for revenge, for vengeance is being curbed, the appetite is no longer there," contends Robert Hirschorn, a nationally known Texas attorney and jury consultant who has helped pick juries for many prominent clients, including, most recently, millionaire real estate mogul Robert Durst, who was found not guilty of killing and dismembering his neighbor. "The tide has changed," Hirschorn says. "It used to be fashionable to say, 'I support the death penalty.' It used to be unfashionable to say, 'I am against the death penalty.'"

Nationwide, and particularly in Texas, anti-death penalty sentiment has usually been centered on college campuses and within the Catholic Church, Hirschorn says, but is expanding beyond those communities — a trend he sees reflected in his jury questionnaires as well as in nationwide political polls.

The number of people sentenced to death has been falling nationally since a peak of about 300 a year in the 1990s, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, to 115 people in 2007. The reduction comes as more states, such as New York, New Jersey and Illinois have passed death penalty moratoriums; while some, like Maryland, are considering whether to abolish executions altogether.

Texas still accounts for 50% of the executions in the U.S., and with an appeal process of 10 years (the shortest among the states), the numbers are unlikely to decrease significantly. According to Kristin Houle, director of the Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty, the state averaged nearly one lethal injection per week over a five month period in 2008. There have been 423 executions in Texas since the state reininstituted the death penalty in 1982, and 374 condemned men and women are currently residing on Texas' Death Row. (One resident, Michael Blair, walked off death row this year after being exonerated by DNA testing.)

But now the number of new residents appears to be slowing. "[In 2008] officials' zeal for executions was not matched by public desire for new death sentences, as evidenced by the continued steep decline in the number of new inmates arriving on death row," Houle says. Nowhere was that more apparent than in Houston, a city dubbed the "capital of capital punishment" in a study by the NAACP. After years of being a major contributor to Texas death row numbers, thanks in part to high profile "tough-on-crime" prosecutors, Houston juries sent no new prisoners to death row in 2008. The Harris County prosecutor's office (which was roiled by the departure of its elected District Attorney over a sex-and-e-mail scandal) brought only two capital cases this year. One ended in a tough plea bargain and a 60-year sentence; the other, involving the vicious murder of a police officer, shocked the city's legal community when the defendant was convicted but spared the death penalty and given a life sentence.

The changing attitudes reflect broader changes in the cultural, political and social climate, says Hirschorn. But another factor is a key change in state sentencing laws, which now allow Texas juries to levy a life-without-parole sentence, dubbed LWOP. The LWOP sentencing provision, though vociferously opposed by the Texas prosecution bar, was passed by a conservative legislature and signed by a conservative governor in 2005.

"Cop killers, baby killers are poster children for the death penalty," Hirschorn says, "and without the option of LWOP you could guarantee the death penalty." In the Houston cop killing case, the lawyers for defendant Juan Quintero initially attempted an insanity defense, citing a traumatic brain injury. Though the jurors rejected it and found Quintero guilty, Mark Bennett, a Houston defense lawyer argued on his blog "Defendingpeople.com" that the head injury testimony lingered in the minds of some jurors, who may have regarded it as a mitigating factor in deciding on a life sentence rather than execution.

But along with changes in sentencing guidelines, something else has changed in Texas, death-penalty opponents claim. In the past, both Democrats and Republicans for high office have embraced the death penalty as an issue, but in recent elections, Houle notes, the issue has been rarely raised. Improved access to better quality defense counsel and the realization that capital cases usually cost county government upwards of $2 million each, Houle says, have helped reduce the number of death penalty cases. Recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions striking down the death penalty in certain kinds of cases — the rape of a child — and concerns about the legality of executing mentally retarded or mentally ill individuals have also slowed the number of capital cases being brought. With broader legal options, the most execution-prone state of the union may increasingly be opting for some other punishment than a life for a life.

Source: Time.com, December 23, 2008

Friday, December 12, 2008

The religious roots of southern punitiveness

The Death Penalty Information Center reports that 37 people will be executed in the United States in 2008, down 12 percent from 42 in 2007 and a 30 % drop from 2006.

Are we looking at a gradual erosion of support for the death penalty, or a meaningless statistical blip?

The AP report notes that Texas accounted for 1/2 of the executions in 2007 (18 of 37, or 48% of the national total). Thats a big improvement from 2007 when Texas executed 26 people (62%) out of the 42 inmates executed nationally.

Unlike most reports on this year's numbers, the AP article notes that nearly all of the executions in America this year took place in the South. Only 2 non-Southern states, Oklahoma (2) and Ohio (2) performed executions this year.

Although Oklahoma was still a dumping ground for displaced native Americans at the end of the Civil War, it was largely populated by Southerners and is sometimes considered a southern state for statistical purposes.

But let's not quibble. Of the 1137 executions in the United States since the re-institution of the death penalty in 1976, 935 occurred in southern states. That's 82%. In recent years, the South has accounted for an even higher percentage of the executions in America.

Why are the numbers dropping? Juries in several states (Texas among them) can now hand down a sentence of life without parole. Many jurors will back away from the ultimate penalty if they know a dangerous killer will never be released from custody.

I would like to pose another question: Why are southerners so enamored of the death penalty?

Track lynching statistics by year and by state between 1882 and 1962 (the beginning and end of the Jim Crow period ) and you will think you are looking at contemporary death penalty stats. Lynching was much more prominent in the South than elsewhere in the United States. Moreover, lynching was far more likely to be used against black victims in the South, especially in the first half of the 20th century. For instance, of the 581 people lynched in this period in the state of Mississippi, 539 were black.

In the West, lynching was chiefly used as a form of vigilante frontier justice and most of the victims were white.

A similar trend emerges when we consider incarceration rates. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, in 2005 the South had a regional incarceration rate of 519 prison inmates per 100,000 population (the numbers rise significantly when jail inmates are included). In the same year, the Midwestern states had an incarceration rate of 386, the rate for the Western states was 378 and for the Northeast it was 314.

By international standards, even the Northeastern states are locking people in alarming numbers, but why is the rate of incarceration so much higher in the South?

When we consider that the cluster of states around Texas (with an incarceration rate of 691 per 100,000), the numbers skew in a highly punitive direction: Mississippi (660), Oklahoma (652), and Louisiana (797). In this clump of states, the incarceration rate hovers around 700, almost twice the national average.

Why?

The question becomes more critical when you consider that incarceration rates in Midwestern Red states are virtually the same as in Midwestern Blue states (a tad lower, in fact).

Religion, not conservative politics, is the key factor here.

There is an tragic correlation between high rates of church attendance and high rates of incarceration, but the folks who attend southern evangelical churches are singularly punitive. In particular, a high concentration of Baptists goes hand-in-hand with multiple executions and an incarceration rate up in the nosebleed region. In the cluster of Red states around Texas, Baptists comprise 37% of the population, compared to 21.8% in the Blue Southern states and around 8% nationally. Incarceration rates in the Blue South (states characterized by a low Baptist count and a vast in-migration of northerners) are considerably lower.

How do we account for Southern punitiveness, especially the extreme form on display in and around Texas?

I have spent 8 years of my life studying theology at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Kentucky. 5 of those years (1989-1994) were devoted to an in-depth study of church history with a particular focus on Baptist history in the South. As part of this work I traced the gradual evolution of Baptist attitudes and influence in the southern slave states.

Early on, Baptists were low-status commoners in southern states like Virginia where the Church of England was established. This explains why Baptists like John Leland petitioned Thomas Jefferson for a separation of church and state after the Revolutionary War.

Initially, most Baptists in the South opposed slavery as something antithetical to biblical religion. But as the South expanded westward after the Louisiana Purchase and slavery became the regions peculiar and defining institution, Baptist attitudes began to change. In 1845, when Baptists split North and South over the issue of slavery, the newly formed Southern Baptist Convention rapturously embraced the virtues of a godly slave society.

By the advent of the Civil War, Southern Baptists had moved from condoning slavery to proclaiming its moral superiority to all alternatives. The South was God's Zion largely because it practiced the biblically mandated instituion of slavery.

After the holocaust of civil war, the battered South re-organized around the Southern Baptist Convention. Pastors who disagreed with the Jim Crow regime had to find another line of work. I have read hundreds of books by Southern Baptists from the first half of the 20th century. White supremacy was largely assumed, though the indelicate and worldly subjects of slavery and segregation were rarely addressed. Woe to the pastor who addressed the elephant in the room from a progressive perspective.

As late as 1972, an employee of the Sunday School Board in Nashville was fired for publishing a picture of black and white children playing together. Segregation died hard.

During the Civil Rights Movement of the late 1950s and early 60s, Southern Baptists were disproportionately represented within the KKK and the white citizens councils. Official pronouncements from the Southern Baptist Convention had a moderate and faintly progressive sound, but the reality in the largely rural and small town Southern Baptist churches was quite different.

When Richard Nixon's Southern Strategy sparked a mass shift of southern whites from the Democratic party to the Republicans, Southern Baptists led the way.

The disturbing picture at the head of this post popped up when I Googled images of "Southern Religion."

I am not suggesting that Baptists are inherently punitive. Nor am I arguing that Baptists were the only southerners to embrace slavery and Jim Crow segregation while opposing the civil rights movement. Baptists simply provide the most illuminating case study.

Religion in the slave states reflected the paranoia of the times. Slaves had to be kept into submission, a fact that encouraged runaways. Fear of insurrection was constant, particularly in regions where white freemen were outnumbered by black slaves. During the Jim Crow period, lynching was used to enforce white supremacy. This constant brutality left its mark on the brand of southern evangelical religion that provided a theological justification, and later a twisted spiritual celebration, of slavery.

How do you preach "whosoever will may come," in the heart of the Jim Crow South? Very carefully. It is hard to preach grace to people you regard as subhuman.

A turn-or-burn religion based on the crude juxtaposition of heavenly bliss and hellish torment fit the spiritual needs of the slave states. It was essential that religion be utterly divorced from politics and social p0licy. The profane elephant in the room had to be ignored at all costs.

The hyper-spirituality of southern religion has little to do with evangelical theology. In the North, as in England, evangelicals were frequently at the heart of the progressive movement. But in the slave states, the church was the piper and the wealthy planter class called the tune. These brutal facts of history gave southern evangelicalism a disembodied, anti-incarnational, and schizophrenic character that persists to this day.

Oddly, the punitive cast of southern evangelicalism is more apparent in the courthouse than in the churchhouse. Southern attitudes are changing. The crude racial bigotry of the Jim Crow period is dying fast (the proliferation of noose hangings and hate groups notwithstanding). But the paranoia and punitiveness of the Old South lives on in the juryroom. Fear of the other, a stark line of separation between the saved and the damned, and a deep-seated fear of the angry black man translate into support forthe death penalty and mass incarceration.

I am not advocating that southerners turn their backs on evangelical religion. Quite to the contrary; the South needs a revival of a radically biblical evangelicalism freed from the shackles of cultural captivity.

As a practical matter, support for slavery and segregation meant the abandonment of biblical grace and justice. That's the problem.

Once the disease is diagnosed, the cure is obvious. The South will find its salvation in a back-to-the-Bible revival of religion.

Source: Friends of Justice, December 12, 2008