Showing posts with label Ronnie Lee Gardner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ronnie Lee Gardner. Show all posts

Friday, October 22, 2010

Utah: Prison spent $165,000 on Gardner execution

The chair in which Gardner was
shot by a firing squad
The Department of Corrections spent $165,000 to execute Ronnie Lee Gardner earlier this year.

The bulk of those costs, about $105,000, went toward normal wages for prison staff who were working on execution details, said Steve Gehrke, spokesman for the Department of Corrections. About $35,000 was overtime pay.

Another $25,000 went toward materials used directly in the execution, including the chair in which Gardner was shot by a firing squad and the jumpsuit he wore.

The department declined to provide a more specific breakdown of costs, citing security issues.

"Knowing that we'll likely have to do this again at some point in the future, it would be concerning to lay out all the details that go into carrying out this process," Gehrke said Thursday.

Gardner, 49, was sentenced to die for killing attorney Michael Burdell during an April 2, 1985, escape attempt from a courthouse in Salt Lake City. He had been brought there for a hearing on charges in the 1984 robbery and slaying of Melvyn John Otterstrom at a Salt Lake City bar. After his girlfriend slipped him a gun, Gardner wounded bailiff Nick Kirk and fatally shot Burdell before being captured on the courthouse lawn.

Gardner also was charged with capital murder for killing Otterstrom, a husband and father who was a controller for the Utah Paper Box Co. by day and a part-time bartender in the evening. He pleaded guilty to 2nd-degree murder as part of a plea bargain and received a sentence of 5 years to life in prison.

Source: The Salt Lake Tribune, October 21, 2010

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Hiding From the Death Penalty

Last month, Utah prison officials took a death row prisoner named Ronnie Gardner to a specially designed room, strapped him tightly into a chair, and draped a black hood over his head. By a prearranged signal, a group of five volunteer executioners aimed their Winchester rifles at a target placed over his heart, and opened fire.

Ronnie Gardner's choice to die by firing squad pierced what Albert Camus called the "padded words" with which we have smothered and hidden capital punishment in our society, preventing us from seeing clearly what it "really is" and honestly debating its legitimacy. "The firing squad, please," came as close as humanly possible to showing the nation, and the world, what Camus described as "the machine" of the death penalty, making us "touch the wood and steel" of it.

The truth is that many of the ugly realities of capital punishment are still covered up in our society, described with euphemisms that make the death penalty seem deceptively palatable. We understandably focus on the terrible crimes that capital defendants have committed, but we refuse to examine the origins of their violence. Thus, we are still a nation that largely ignores the plight of desperately poor children, does little to alleviate the suffering of those who are traumatized by neglect and abuse, and turns a blind eye toward underfunded, incompetent, and sometimes callously cruel juvenile institutions that frequently do more harm than good to troubled and vulnerable young people. Instead, we rise up in indignation when one of these profoundly poor, chronically ignored, and badly mistreated children grow up to become, as Ronnie Gardner described himself, a "nasty little bugger," only then paying much attention, with many clamoring for the death penalty to be imposed.


By Craig Haney, a professor of psychology at the University of California, Santa Cruz, a leading expert on capital punishment and the author of Death by Design; The Huffington Post,July 27, 2010

Friday, June 25, 2010

Utah Governor wants streamlined death penalty appeals

After the state executed convicted murderer Ronnie Lee Gardner, Gov. Gary Herbert said he wants to see the appeals process for condemned prisoners streamlined, so executions can be carried out more expeditiously.

"25 years is just too long. There ought to be a process that's more timely," Herbert said Thursday during his monthly news conference on KUED. "It's just too long and it becomes too much of a circus atmosphere. … And it doesn't serve the families very well."

Gardner was executed by firing squad June 18 for the 1985 slaying of attorney Michael Burdell during an attempted courthouse escape. He also wounded bailiff Nick Kirk. Gardner was to stand trial for shooting Melvyn Otterstrom during a bar robbery in 1984.

9 men remain on Utah’s death row; the longest-serving is Ronald Lafferty, who was first condemned in 1985 but was re-sentenced in 1996. Douglas Carter was sentenced to death in 1986 and re-sentenced in 1992. Ralph Menzies was sentenced in 1988.

"I think justice delayed is justice denied," Herbert said.

Herbert said he has discussed ways to streamline the death penalty with Attorney General Mark Shurtleff.

Shurtleff had pushed for an amendment to the Utah Constitution that would let the Legislature limit post-conviction appeals. But the amendment effort was dropped after the Utah Supreme Court agreed to a rule change directing courts to not consider the merits of appeals that were not pursued with "reasonable diligence" during an inmate’s time on death row.

The rule change took effect in January, and the Utah Supreme Court referred to the rule in rejecting 1 of Gardner's final appeals, finding that Gardner could have raised the issues that were grounds for appeal any time in the previous 10 years.

Will the rule shorten the amount of time condemned inmates spend on death row?

"We hope so," said Assistant Attorney General Thomas Brunker, who handles capital appeals.

"One of the problems, of course, is those are state law changes and can’t affect directly the federal court," he said. It will take some time to figure out if the rule change, along with changes to state law in 2008 and 2010, ultimately expedite the appeals. In the meantime, he said, the Attorney General's Office isn't working on any new revisions.

Troy Booher, a Salt Lake City lawyer specializing in post-trial appeals, says the best way to streamline the appeals process is to make sure the accused gets a fair, thorough trial the 1st time, but that would take money.

"I think if we're going to have a death penalty, 25 years is too long between sentence and execution," Booher said. "Our view is the way you streamline the process is to fund the best attorneys to defend people on death row and if it's done right the 1st time, there's a lot less there to challenge."

Utah is 1 of 2 states that does not provide any state funding for its indigent defense fund, not even for capital cases, said Darcy Goddard, legal director for the Utah chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, leaving counties with the expense, which strains their resources and undermines the accused’s defense.

"To the extent that the governor is concerned about expediting the process, which is something I'm not going to opine on one way or another, one way to do it is to make sure the representation they get from the beginning is quality representation and the resources to mount a good, competent defense are provided," she said.

Source: Salt Lake Tribune, June 24, 2010

Thursday, June 24, 2010

The "Prohibitive" Cost of the Death Penalty

Keep reading if Utah’s firing squad execution last week stirred a sense of “he got what he deserved.”

Consider more details and you might be less appreciative for what state-sanctioned vigilante justice gives back to the taxpayer. And it doesn’t matter if the deed is done by a five-man firing squad like the one that killed Utah’s Ronnie Lee Gardner, or lethal injection.

If the nation’s budget crisis is a concern, that is. If news of more cuts to services like highway repairs irks you. If you are troubled by teachers being laid off because states are fiscally strapped, or police officers not being hired, or trash collectors.

The death penalty is a colossal waste of money in the 35 states that have it, including Missouri and Kansas. Adding to the insult, it is ineffective as a crime deterrent.

A state can pay $1 million more to pursue a capital case compared with pursuing any other sentence, according to a 2009 report by the Death Penalty Information Center.

But because only one death sentence is reached for every three sought, the extra expense is even more questionable.

So what does seeking the death penalty accomplish? Why, revenge, of course. The death penalty satisfies the eye-for-an-eye attitude that can’t be soothed by merely seeking the far less costly sentence of life in prison with no parole.

I oppose the death penalty because murder is wrong. It doesn’t matter if it is done by a criminal, or the state. But increasingly even people who don’t philosophically oppose it, like many in law enforcement, are chiming in too. They’re arguing that the money could be better spent elsewhere if the goal is reducing crime.

A poll last year of 500 randomly selected police chiefs found they ranked the death penalty at the bottom of ways to reduce crime. And many pointedly said they could cut crime drastically if money saved by eliminating it were freed up for police use.

Fiscal realities are even undercutting the common argument that life without parole doesn’t preclude the possibility that a lifer will kill a guard or another inmate. Some argue money saved by closing death rows could be applied toward increased guard training and numbers, thereby reducing the likelihood of prison murders.

Kansas City will be host for such discussions at 2 p.m. Saturday at the annual meeting of Missourians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty at the Bruce R. Watkins Cultural Center.

Given all the information on capital punishment’s costs and ineffectiveness as a crime deterrent, revenge is the only reason people remain beholden to the death penalty.

Yet revenge is the least informed, most emotionally reactive rationale of all. And in these times of budget constraints, it’s an even shallower response than ever. -- Mary Sanchez.

Source: KansasCity.com, June 23, 2010

Saturday, June 19, 2010

World opinion condemns the US for a 'savage' execution

Around the world and across the US, the firing squad execution in Utah has been met with a wave of criticism from those entirely opposed to the death penalty and those who say that shooting is not the most humane method of killing a prisoner.

In Salt Lake City, opponents held a multi-faith vigil. "I think we do not prefer to be associated with Iran, China, Saudi Arabia and the other countries who use the death penalty as we have used it," Nancy Appleby, chairwoman of the Utah Episcopal Diocese Peace and Justice Commission.

Rev Tom Goldsmith of the First Unitarian Church agreed: "Murdering the murderer doesn't create justice or settle any score." Bishop John Wester added: "The firing squad is archaic, violent and simply expands on the violence that we already experience from guns as a society."

Civil rights organisations in the US also joined the chorus of opposition. "Gardner's execution was both savage and inhumane and highlights the systemic injustices that plague the entire death penalty system in Utah and the rest of the United States," said John Holdridge, director of the American Civil Liberties Union. "Such arbitrary and discriminatory administration of the death penalty is the very definition of a failed system."

The USA has carried out 28 executions so far this year, and 1,216 since resuming judicial killing in 1977. Utah accounts for six of these executions.

Amnesty International, which has long called for a worldwide repeal of the death penalty, said shooting had also been used in China, Libya, Syria, Yemen and Vietnam this past year.

But that may no longer be the case in Vietnam. The day before Gardner was killed, legislators there voted to end the use of firing squad and make lethal injection the only method for executions. The change is due to take effect next year.

Vietnam has long been criticised for the number of death sentences if imposes. About 100 people are executed each year in Vietnam, many for drug-related crimes.

The decision to switch to lethal injection came after a parliamentary committee said it was necessary to find a more humane method.

Amnesty International said it "opposes the death penalty, in all cases and in all countries, regardless of the method used to kill the prisoner, or the nature of the crime for which he or she was sentenced to death."

Source: The Independent, June 19, 2010

Utah firing squad execution: Twitter posts don't diminish barbarous act

Utah's attorney-general tweeted details of leadup to firing squad execution of double murderer Ronnie Lee Gardner.

Ronnie Lee Gardner was undeniably an awful man, a double murderer. He was executed early Friday morning the old-fashioned way: by firing squad.

Yet the way his death and the legal twists and turns leading up to it were announced on Twitter by Utah Attorney-General Mark Shurtleff was anything but old-fashioned.

His first post: "A solemn day. Barring a stay by Sup Ct, & with my final nod, Utah will use most extreme power & execute a killer. Mourn his victims. Justice"

The second: "I just gave the go ahead to Corrections Director to proceed with Gardner's execution. May God grant him the mercy he denied his victims."

Finally, "We will be streaming my live press conference as soon as I'm told Gardner is dead."

The last post included the URL for the video link.

The BBC has called it Death by Twitter, and cyberspace is humming with debate over the self-serving tone of Shurtleff's posts, as well as his use of social media.

The medium is the message, as Marshall McLuhan said. And, announcing an execution on a medium that seems most commonly used for describing what you ate for breakfast, paradoxically, made the news seem both more shocking and yet almost shockingly mundane.

Yet how the message was delivered should not overshadow the barbarous, repugnant and inhumane act of capital punishment itself.

That it happens in the middle of the night ought to be a sign.

Close to midnight Thursday, 49-year-old Gardner was strapped into a chair surrounded by sandbags. A target was pinned on his chest. He'd come from an "observation room." Nobody wanted him to commit suicide before he was shot.

With Shurtleff's "final nod," 5 shooters hidden by a screen and armed with .30-calibre rifles opened fire.

No one will ever know who killed Gardner. One of the bullets was a blank.

There is no saving grace that Gardner had a choice of being shot or receiving a lethal injection. Capital punishment is cruel and unusual, regardless of how it is administered, regardless of the U.S. Supreme Court that has decided it is not.

It's vengeance so horrifying that even some family and friends of Gardner's victims were among those who petitioned for commutation. It made 4 of 5 anonymous shooters murderers.

There is no excusing what Gardner did; no amount of apologizing or even sincere regret could erase what he did.

In 1984 at age 23, an enraged Gardner killed bartender Melvyn Otterstrom. When Gardner went to court the following year, he tried to escape, and during that attempt, he killed lawyer Michael Burdell.

But like so many criminals, Gardner was a product of his upbringing. At age two, he was found in the street alone, wearing only a diaper. By six, he was addicted to gasoline and glue. By 10, he'd "graduated" to LSD and heroin and helping his stepfather during robberies.

Gardner was sent to a mental hospital at 11, not because he was mentally ill, but because child welfare officials thought it a better place for him than his home. He spent 18 months there.

Later, he was sexually abused in a foster home.

The United States remains among a minority of nations along with Iran, China and Saudi Arabia, that continue to have a death penalty.

Only 18 countries carried out executions in 2009. In the United States, 52 prisoners were put to death. It was the highest total in 3 years because in the 2 previous years the Supreme Court stayed all executions while it considered whether lethal injection was cruel, unusual and, therefore, unconstitutional.

Canada abolished the death penalty in 1976. Contrary to predictions, the murder rate didn't rise.

It has fluctuated over the years, but in the past decade it has stabilized at a rate per-capita less than 1/3 of that of the United States.

Source: The Vancouver Sun, June 19, 2010

Friday, June 18, 2010

Utah executes Ronnie Lee Gardner

Draper, Utah (CNN) -- Convicted killer Ronnie Lee Gardner was executed early Friday by firing squad, the Utah Department of Corrections said.

Gardner, 49, is only the third person in 33 years to die by firing squad in the United States.

He was killed at 12:20 a.m. MST (2:20 a.m. ET), a Corrections Department spokesman said.

A hood was placed over Gardner's head and a paper target pinned to his chest. He was heavily restrained as a five-person firing squad took aim at the target and shot him, witnesses said.

Journalists who witnessed the shooting said it happend quickly. One reporter said she noticed that Gardner moved after he was shot.

"It was over pretty quickly," said Cheryl Worsley, a local radio reporter. "It was cleaner than I expected. It was fast. But he moved. He moved a little bit, and to some degree that bothers me."

Outside the prison in Draper Utah, there was a candlelight vigil attended by members of Gardner's family.

"He did things bad in the past, but now he realizes what he did and he changed the last couple of years," said his granddaughter Darian Gardner, breaking into tears. "I got to know him the last couple of years. It sucks when you have to say goodbye to someone that is like your best friend."

The execution came after Gardner's last-ditch efforts to save himself had failed.

The U.S. Supreme Court rejected a request Thursday to temporarily stay the execution. Utah Gov. Gary Herbert rejected two appeals by Gardner's attorneys to stop the execution, saying he had every chance to present his case.

Gardner, 49, was convicted for the shooting death of attorney Michael Burdell during a botched escape attempt from custody in 1985 at a Salt Lake City, Utah, courthouse.

Among the claims Gardner raised in his appeals is that he has been a death-row inmate for too long.

"He asserts that executing him now, after nearly 25 years on death-row in Utah, so lacks retributive or deterrent value that it violates the Eighth Amendment," Andrew Parnes, Gardner's lawyer, told the high court.

A federal judge late Tuesday declined to block the execution, after Gardner claimed the procedures related to a two-day commutation hearing held by the state Board of Pardons and Parole last week violated his civil rights. The parole board Monday declined to commute Gardner's sentence to life in prison, and the Utah Supreme Court on Tuesday also denied his request for a stay.

Gardner was the third person to die by rifle fire, all in Utah, since the Supreme Court restored the death penalty in 1976. He had a long history of escapes and was slipped a gun before he fatally shot Burdell on April 2, 1985. He was at the courthouse for a pre-trial hearing in the 1984 slaying of Melvyn Otterstrom, who was killed at the Salt Lake City bar where he was working to earn extra money.

Corrections officials announced Gardner had consumed his last meal Tuesday night at 6:30 p.m., and chose to fast prior to the anticipated execution. His dinner included steak, lobster, 7-Up, apple pie and vanilla ice cream.

Source: CNN.com, June 18, 2010


Ronnie Lee Gardner Executed By The Utah Firing Squad

Ronnie Lee Gardner, a death row prisoner was shot dead by Utah firing squad in the early hours of Friday. This is reported to be the first firing execution of Utah in the span of 14 years.

It was Ronnie Lee Gardner himself, who choose the controversial firing squad option over lethal injection method adopted by Utah in the year 2004.

Gardner was shot on his chest by certified police officers, who volunteered for the task. He was declared dead at 12:20 a.m.

Members of Gardner’s family held a vigil outside the prison as he was shot. Some described it as a barbaric act.

Ronnie Lee Gardner was sentenced to death for gunning down an attorney in a failed escape attempt from a courtroom in 1985 during a murder trial.

Ronnie Lee Gardner was the third man to be killed by state marksmen since 1976. The other two were Gary Gilmore, who was shot on January 17, 1977; and John Albert Taylor on January 26, 1996.

Source: UKTodayNews.com, June 18, 2010


Protesters pray, plead for end to capital punishment

Scores of somber death-penalty opponents gathered in a cold wind on the Utah Capitol steps Thursday night to share their distress that their state was executing Ronnie Lee Gardner.

And yet several speakers struck a note of hope:

"This is not the end of the movement," said Ralph Dellapiana, a defense attorney and one of the founders of Utahns for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, a new group that sponsored the protest. "This is the beginning."

Kent Hart, also a defense attorney, introduced himself with a reference to his religion, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

"The Mormon issue is kind of the elephant in the room," said Hart, who has met with eight of the nine men left on Utah's death row. Hart encouraged Latter-day Saints to reconsider the implications of capital punishment. The Salt Lake City-based church officially is neutral.

"I am not delusional. I'm not saying we're going to abolish the death penalty a week from now or next year," Hart said. "But I think we can do it. We'll do it in the name of people like Ronnie Lee Gardner."

The rally was at the Capitol, Dellapiana said, to pressure lawmakers to end capital punishment, as many other states have done. Several members of Gardner's extended family attended the rally, but declined to comment.

Many in the crowd of about 150 protesters were young people carrying handmade signs such as "25 years can change a man! We are not God!" and "Capital punishment is the most premeditated of murders."

Candles were passed around, but few remained lit in the brisk wind.

Perhaps the most-poignant comments came from two people who were with condemned Utah men in the hours before their deaths: a legal studies professor from Utah Valley University and a former Catholic chaplain.

Sandra McGunigall-Smith studied death-row inmates at the prison for several years, and was with Joseph Parsons in the hours before he was executed

If the state wants true and proportional punishment, she said, it should sentence killers to life without parole.

"The life-sentenced prisoners have no way to end their suffering," McGunigall-Smith added. "Prison itself becomes a cemetery, the cell a tomb."

Reyes G. Rodriguez, a Catholic chaplain at the prison for seven years, says he was with John Albert Taylor in the hours before he was shot by firing squad in 1996.

"A soon as they said, 'Fire,' I closed my eyes," Rodriguez said. "That was a very sad, sad event, to see a life just destroyed."

At a protest near the prison, Salt Lake City resident Kristin Powers arrived shortly after 11 p.m. with a handwritten sign reading, "Who would Jesus execute?"

Ron Belnap, a retired priest from All Saints Episcopal Church in Salt Lake City, said he "felt like this was a place for me to be."

"Murder is wrong, he said. "That is true regardless of whether you are a murderer or a government that takes the life of a murderer."

Dozens of Gardner's family members, mingling with the protesters, carried red and white balloons with messages written on them for the condemned killer. They planned to release the balloons at the time of his death.

Not far away were family members of Gardner's victims.

"I had an abusive upbringing. I know people who have done drugs, but we've never killed anyone," said Kearns resident Wayne Hunting while standing with family members of bailiff Nick Kirk, who was wounded in Gardner's 1985 escape attempt. "It's all about taking responsibility for our actions."

Earlier Thursday evening, prayers for Gardner, his victims, their families and his executioners were sent up by about 125 people who gathered at St. Mark's Episcopal Cathedral in downtown Salt Lake City.

"Violence breeds violence," said the Rev. David Henry, interim pastor at First Baptist Church. He urged others to pray that the state soon ends capital punishment.

"It doesn't work," Henry said. "It's ineffective, and it's brutalizing all of us."

Michael Bulson, a deacon at St. Andrew Catholic Parish in Riverton and an attorney, said he learned a lesson from the father of a woman killed in the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing.

"Hate and revenge will not bring about the healing that is needed," Bulson said.

Ogden resident Victoria Sethunya, a native of Lesotho, said she was stunned to learn that Utah still executes killers.

"This is a sacred place," she said. "I grew up thinking only God takes life."

Sandy resident Diana Mafi, a born-again Christian, said she attended the vigil because she cannot share her dismay over capital punishment with family or friends.

"I feel bad about the people who think they can feel better killing another person."

Source: The Salt Lake Tribune, June 18, 2010 - Photo: Brandie Gardner, right, the daughter of Ronnie Lee Gardner, is consoled by her friend Debbie Evans, left, just before the execution of Ronnie Lee Gardner by firing squad on Friday.


9 remain on Utah's death row; the next to be executed is unclear

SALT LAKE CITY — Ronnie Lee Gardner's Friday execution now leaves nine men on Utah's death row.

Four of them could face a firing squad, while the others face lethal injection. But no one can say when those sentences will be carried out.

"I would never hazard a guess," said Tom Brunker, head of the Utah Attorney General's Office capital crimes team.

Gardner's death by firing squad early Friday morning was Utah's first execution in 11 years. There has been seven men executed in the state since 1976.

All nine death row inmates have appeals pending in either state or federal court not necessarily challenging their convictions, but questioning the constitutionality of the death penalty.

Douglas Stewart Carter, who fatally stabbed and shot a Provo woman in 1985, is furthest along in the legal process, but that doesn't mean he would be the next man executed, Brunker said. Carter has appeals pending in both state and federal court.

Capital cases are complicated and filled with volumes of paperwork in the form of court motions, briefs and legal arguments. Von Lester Taylor, for example, filed a 500-page document in his case. Taylor killed two woman during a cabin robbery in 1990.

Source: Deseret News, June 18, 2010


Ronnie Lee Gardner executed by firing squad

Ronnie Lee Gardner, who a quarter century ago put bullets into the heads of 2 good men, died in the earliest minutes of this morning with wounds from 4 .30-caliber rifle rounds in his chest.

He became the 3rd inmate in Utah — and the United States — to be executed by firing squad since a nationwide moratorium on the death penalty was lifted in 1976 and the first since John Albert Taylor's execution in 1996.

Just after midnight, five anonymous executioners raised their rifles and fired from behind curtains and a ported brick wall. One rifle held a blank round, leaving room for doubt in the minds of the marksmen. Gardner was pronounced dead at 12:17 a.m.

He died strapped in a chair, a hood over his head and a white target on his heart.

Gardner's path to execution began in 1985, when he was sentenced to death for shooting and killing attorney Michael Burdell during an attempted escape from a Salt Lake City courthouse in April of that year. An accomplice smuggled a gun to Gardner while he was in the courthouse on charges of killing Melvyn John Otterstrom during a 1984 robbery at Cheers Tavern.

In the escape attempt, Gardner also shot and wounded George "Nick" Kirk, a bailiff, whose family said he died 11 years later as a result of his injuries.

Though Gardner wavered at times in his efforts to fight his execution, he and his attorneys launched numerous appeals in state, federal and appellate courts.

During his final hours of life, both the U.S Supreme Court and Gov. Gary Herbert denied requests to stay Gardner's execution. Herbert twice denied last minute attempts by Gardner's attorney to spare his client's life.

"No court has given us a full and fair adjudication," attorney Andrew Parnes told reporters Thursday evening as he arrived at the prison to inform his client of the decision from the nation's high court. "It's a shame, because if they had, Ronnie Gardner would have a life sentence."

As he had numerous times in a courtroom, Parnes pointed to Gardner's troubled upbringing — a sordid history of physical and sexual abuse, neglect and a drug addiction that started when he was just 5 years old — as the reasons to spare his life.

"We as a society didn't give him the benefit we give a lot of people," Parnes said. "He really is a changed person. … He understands now what created him."

In a parking lot overlooking the prison where Gardner spent more than 1/2 his 49 years, friends and family hugged and wiped tears from their eyes as the execution approached.

"It's hard to say goodbye to somebody you love," said Brandie Gardner, who grew up with her father behind bars.

Gardner's brother, Randy Gardner, said his brother had changed over the last decade and had hoped to help start an organic farm to benefit troubled youths.

Gardner had been on Utah's death row since October 1985. He lived in a 6-by-12 cell in Uinta 1, a maximum-security facility in the prison. He slept on a thin mattress atop a hard bunk. His cell's only other amenities were a stainless steel toilet, a sink, a mirror and a small window that overlooked part of the prison yard.

Wednesday night, for the 1st time in about 25 years, Gardner was permitted to reach through the bars of his cell and touch his family.

"He's never touched no one but his lawyer's hand" since coming to prison, Randy Gardner said.

In the midst of those who loved Gardner, there were some who never knew him at all, but wanted to offer support — even if he had killed someone they had loved.

Donna Taylor, Burdell's niece, and her husband, Lynn, sought out Gardner's family early on, to let them know that there are people who care about them.

"We put it behind us 25 years ago when it happened," she said. "We didn't like that they kept saying he's being killed because he killed Mike. … This is the last thing (Burdell) would have wanted. I just hate that his family has to go through this now."

She said many members of her family have felt angry "like they were shut out" when they constantly tried to point out that Burdell wouldn't have wanted to see Gardner die on his behalf. But she is certain that the two men will meet, and there will be no qualms between them.

"I think Mike will be right there to welcome him home," she said. "You just forgive, you just do, and if you don't forgive, it just hurts you. Michael is at peace. He's fine."

Gardner's family said they would not witness the execution.

"He don't want that to be our last image," Randy Gardner said. "He don't want us to have nightmares and bad dreams."

Gardner fasted from food in the 36 hours leading up to his death, drinking only vitamin water, Sprite, Coke, 7UP and Mountain Dew, prison officials said. Gardner ate his last meal Tuesday evening.

Department of Corrections spokesman Steve Gehrke said Gardner was moved to a smaller observation cell after meeting with family Wednesday night.

In the hours leading up to his execution, prison officials described Gardner's mood as "reflective" and "calm." Gardner slept, read mail and David Baldacci's "Divine Justice," a novel about a former CIA assassin. Gardner intermittently slept and watched "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy.

By 8:45 p.m., Gehrke said Gardner had met with an LDS bishop, a person he had known for several years and whom he trusted. Gardner sat on a bunk in the observation cell and spoke to the bishop through a small port used for handcuffing inmates. Gardner finished meeting with his clergy and attorneys by 9:30 p.m., Gehrke said. As the execution neared, family and friends of the condemned killer held a candlelight vigil outside the prison.

They sang along to Lynyrd Skynyrd's "Free Bird," held each other and wept.

Gardner, meanwhile, slept and waited alone until he was escorted 90 feet down a hallway and around a corner to the prison's execution chamber just before midnight.

At 12 a.m., Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff spoke with prison officials by telephone and told them there was no legal reason not to go through with the execution.

Families of Gardner's victims and others waited at the Utah State Capitol. The nervous sounds of tapping feet or whispered conversations were all that remained as a small crowd waited for the attorney general to re-emerge. "Ronnie Lee Gardner will never kill again. He will never assault anyone again," Shurtleff said to a silenced audience.

Gardner was pronounced dead at 12:20 and 25 seconds.

"Now Ronnie Lee Gardner will be held accountable to a higher power, and I pray he will find more mercy than he showed his victims," Shurtleff said.

Gardner becomes the 1st condemned inmate to be put to death this year in Utah and the 7th overall since the state resumed capital punishment on January 17, 1977, when Gary Gilmore became the 1st condemned individual to be put to death in the US after the Supreme Court re-legalized the death penalty on July 2, 1976.

Gardner becomes the 29th condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 1217th overall since the nation resumed executions in 1977.

Sources: Deseret News & Rick Halperin, June 18, 2010


Firing squad: An eyewitness account of Gardner's execution

Ronnie Lee Gardner's head, covered by a black hood, remained upright. His body sat straight in the chair to which it was strapped.

As my eyes traveled down Gardner's left arm, past his dark blue jumpsuit, I saw his pale white skin appear below his elbow. Half a faded blue tattoo, some kind of diamond shape, stuck out from the restraint around his wrist.

At the bottom of his restraint, I focused on his fist. Gardner died much the way he lived -- with a clenched fist.

Yes, this was my first time witnessing an execution. I have been amazed at how many people asked me that.

Firing 4 bullets into a man's chest is, by definition, violent. If it can also be clinical and sterile, then that also happened in this execution.

8 other journalists and I had our own viewing area with about a 6-foot-wide, bullet-proof window. When the curtain opened, there sat Gardner. We were at about a 45-degree angle to his left.

He looked nothing like the athletic 23 year old with the red hair who murdered Melvyn Otterstrom in a robbery, nor did he flash that grin he had in those infamous photographs of him shackled on the courthouse lawn after killing Michael Burdell and wounding Nick Kirk in 1985.

This time, he looked like Utah's own ghost of Hannibal Lecter. Gardner's skin and his white socks contrasted with the dark blue jump suit he wore and the restraints, chair, wooden backdrop and sandbags, all of which were painted black. Restraints circled his wrists, ankles, shoulders and waist, but the restraint across his forehead best exemplified his confinement to me.

Gardner could not even look around the room and the fluorescent lights in the ceiling tiles illuminated his bald head and pale face.

Over his left breast clung a white square, about 2 inches by 2 inches, with a circle in the middle.

The room had no decor. There was a white tile floor with white cinder block walls. The 2 slits for the shooters sat opposite Gardner and windows for the observers lined the 2 perpendicular sides.

Steven Turley, warden at the Draper prison, picked up a microphone and announced Gardner had 2 minutes to say his final words. When Turley asked Gardner if he had anything to say, Gardner said, "I do not. No." Gardner moved his head ever so slightly trying to shake it.

Gardner's final words were to say he had none.

Turley hung up the microphone. Turley reached up and gently pulled a hood over Gardner's head. Turley picked up the microphone, unplugged its cord from a wall jack, wound the cord in his hand and exited the room.

Over the next 30 seconds, my heart raced. I realized the 5 gunmen would launch their volleys any moment. I placed a Styrofoam plug in my right ear to match the one I had earlier placed in my left. The other reporters and I stood in front of the glass.

I watched Gardner. As the seconds passed, I grew anxious. I pivoted my eyes away from Gardner toward the slits.

In that fraction of a second my eyes were in transit, I heard "boom boom." The sounds were as close together as you could spew them from your mouth.

My eyes darted back to Gardner and to his chest. The target, perfect just a second earlier, had 3 holes. The largest hole was in the top half of the circle and toward Gardner's left side. It may have been where 2 bullets entered Gardner.

Below that hole, still inside the circle, was a smaller hole. Outside the circle, in the bottom right of the target, was a 3rd hole. Each hole had a black outline. Utah Department of Corrections Director Tom Patterson would say later the target was fastened to the jump suit by Velcro and that may account for the black outline.

I watched Gardner's torso. The men who shot John Alberty Taylor in a firing squad in 1996 said they saw Taylor's body slump and I assumed Gardner would, too. But I never saw such a movement.

Instead, a few seconds after the gunshots, I saw Gardner move his left arm. He pushed it forward about 2 inches against the restraints. In that same motion, he closed his hand and made a fist.

Then it happened in reverse. Gardner's hand loosened, his arm bent at the elbow, straightened again and the fist returned. At the time, I interpreted this as Gardner suffering -- clenching his fist in an effort to fight the pain.

As I write this, I don't know whether that's true. It could have just been reflexes or some other process the body begins after a major trauma. Scientists do not know much about what a person shot through the heart feels.

The next movement I saw from Gardner came from beneath his hood. I could see the bottom of his throat and it rippled as though Gardner moved his jaw.

I squinted my eyes, looking for blood. I saw none through the holes in Gardner's chest. None spilled on the floor. The jump suit slightly darkened around his waist and it appeared that's where blood was pooling. But I never saw a drop.

About 2 minutes passed after the gunshots. It was long enough that I wondered (and some of my colleagues later said they wondered, too) whether Gardner would require a 2nd volley of bullets to die.

Through a side door walked a man in a button-down shirt, slacks and blue plastic gloves. He lifted Gardner's hood only enough to check the pulse on the left side of Gardner's neck. The man appeared to do the same on Gardner's right.

Then the man lifted the hood high enough to shine his small flashlight in Gardner's eyes. When he did this I could see Gardner's face. His mouth was agape. His face was even whiter than it was before the hood covered him.

The man withdrew his flashlight and let the hood fall again. He shut off the flashlight and started to walk out of the room. Gardner was dead.

Turley and Lowell Clark, the director of division institutional operations for the Department of Corrections, entered the chamber. Clark grasped the curtain on my side and Turley the curtain on the opposite wall.

As Clark pulled the curtain along its rod, I pushed my head toward the glass to take one final look at the scene. In the final second, my eyes focused on the straightened left arm, seemingly flexing, and that clenched
fist.

Source: Nate Carlisle, Salt Lake Tribune, June 18, 2010


2 loud bangs end 25 years on death row for Gardner

5 shots.

4 bullets.

With 2 loud bangs in quick succession, Ronnie Lee Gardner's quarter century on Utah's death row ended.

At 17 minutes past midnight Friday, Utah Department of Corrections officials confirmed the death of a man whose life was defined by sex abuse, drug addiction, poverty, criminality and murder.

But in the final hours of his life, friends and family members said, Gardner was at peace.

And in his final minutes, witnesses said, the calm, condemned man exchanged private words with Utah's prison chief before being strapped to the execution chair and asked if he had any final words.

"I do not. No," he said.

A hood was pulled over his head. An executioner counted back from five. The shots rang out.

Journey to death row

If the man known as one of Utah's most notorious criminals was a monster, family members said, it was only as a result of his abusive upbringing. And Gardner's appellate attorneys long had argued that if his jurors had known more about his childhood, they would have sentenced him to life in prison, instead of death.

Born in Salt Lake City in 1961, Gardner was 6 when his siblings taught him to huff gas and glue. By age 9, he had landed in state custody for theft. When he was 10, police investigated a report that Gardner had traded a BB gun for marijuana. A stepfather used a teenage Gardner as a lookout while he burglarized homes. A foster father paid Gardner for sex.

In 1980, Gardner was convicted of his first adult crime - a robbery. In 1985, while serving time for a subsequent robbery, he attacked an officer at Salt Lake City's University Hospital, stole his gun, and forced a medical student to help him escape. Two months later, Gardner shot and killed Melvyn Otterstrom, a bartender at Cheers Tavern in Salt Lake City.

Arrested and charged with murder for Otterstrom's death, Gardner escaped from custody when a female accomplice slipped him a gun at a Salt Lake City courthouse. During his escape, Gardner wounded bailiff Nick Kirk and killed attorney Michael Burdell. A jury sentenced him to death.

The intervening 25 years were punctuated by attacks on other Utah State Prison inmates and a standoff in a visiting room during which he broke a glass partition, barricaded the door and had sex with his half-brother's wife as officers looked on helplessly.

At peace with his fate

In a final appeal to the parole board last week though, Gardner described himself as a changed man. His daughter, Brandie Gardner, said she believes that to be true.

"Up until 10 years ago, I would have told you he was a bad person," she said. "But something changed in him."

The convicted killer said he wanted to help sponsor a farm for troubled youth, "so that they don't end up like he did," Brandie Gardner explained.

His appeals exhausted, Gardner spent the final hours of his life in an observation cell about 90 feet from the execution chamber. There, prison officials said, he read a spy novel called "Divine Justice," watched the Lord of the Rings trilogy, consulted with a bishop from The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and visited with his attorneys.

"He was at peace," attorney Tyler Ayres said. "He even laughed a few times during our conversation, and that helped put me at ease."

As Ayres turned to leave, Gardner called out after him, "don't get into any trouble."

"You either," Ayres said, turning back to a man he had come to see as a friend.

Mourning a killer

Under prison policy and state law, Gardner had the right to invite as many as five witnesses to his execution. But in the weeks before he was killed, the 49-year-old prisoner told his loved ones he did not want them to watch him die.

Saying they wanted to respect the condemned man's wishes, while being as close to him as possible in his final hours, more than 20 members of Gardner's family gathered in a parking lot, across the interstate, overlooking the prison where he was to be killed.

"He believes he needs to pay for what he's done," Brandie Gardner said. "He absolutely believes that. But at the same time, people should know that what they're doing is murder."

As the sun set, dozens of death penalty protesters joined family members in a candlelight vigil. One held a sign that read: "Who Would Jesus Execute?" Another implored media onlookers to "tell the world of the barbarity of this act."

Moments after midnight, family members cranked up a car stereo, which played a concert recording of Lynyrd Skynyrd's "Free Bird." They leaned against each other in a tight cluster, sobbing and shouting as they awaited confirmation of Gardner's death.

A sudden, violent death

Gardner was already locked into the chair with 6 thick straps, including one that held his head upright against the chair, when a curtain opened to reveal the death chamber to 9 media witnesses.

"I could see him moving his eyes," television reporter Sandra Yi said.

"He didn't look scared," radio talk show host Doug Fabrizio said.

The prison warden draped the black hood over Gardner's head. A small target was affixed by Velcro over his left breast.

The 5 executioners readied their weapons, only 4 of which were loaded with live ammunition.

At 12:15 a.m., the shots rang out.

"It was so sudden, so quick - boom boom - just like that," television news reporter Marcos Ortiz said.

Several of the witnesses described watching as Gardner's hand and arm continued to move after he was shot.

"He clenched his fist and then let go," Fabrizio said. "And then he clenched it again."

2 minutes after the shots, the medical examiner lifted Gardner's hood to reveal his ashen face, mouth agape.

The killer was dead.

Calls for reform

For the nation, Gardner's death marked what could be the final execution of its kind in the country. Utah is the only state still using a firing squad, and only 4 men on death row could still choose it. The state switched to lethal injection in 2004.

Some hope the attention will highlight problems meting out capital punishment in Utah. Both death penalty opponents and believers decry the nearly 25 years Gardner spent between his conviction for Burdell's murder and the execution.

Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, who has pushed to streamline death row appeals, said the run up to today's execution may have generated legislative momentum to remake state law.

"I'm hearing from a lot of people, 25 years is just too long," Shurtleff said. "It's ridiculous."

Ralph Dellapiana, an attorney affiliated with Utahns for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, said he hopes Gardner's death will spark discussion "that this arbitrary process be changed to something else."

Members of the victims' families argued both for and against Gardner's death. All said they wanted to end a long nightmare.

"This story must be allowed to slip into history," Jason Otterstrom said during the commutation hearing. "Our families need peace."

Barb Webb, daughter of victim Nick Kirk, sobbed when news of the execution came.

"I'm so relieved it's all over," she said, hugging her daughter, Mandi Hull. "I just hope my sister, who just passed away, and my father and all of the other victims are waiting for his sorry ass. I hope they get to go down after him."

Source: The Salt Lake Tribune, June 18, 2010


For a condemned killer's family, one final visit -- Loved ones say he's 'at peace.'

She had one last time to see him. To speak to him. To touch him.

One last time to tell him that she loved him.

But there was one thing she just couldn't bring herself to do.

"I couldn't say goodbye," Brandie Gardner, 33, said of her final visit to her father, Ronnie Lee Gardner.

One by one Wednesday night, 4 family members visited with Gardner, shortly before he was moved to an observation cell near the execution chamber at the Utah State Prison.

Reaching through the bars, the convicted killer took his daughter by the hands. He touched her face. He kissed her head.

"We both cried," Brandie Gardner said. "He told me that he was sorry. And he was at peace."

Gardner also met with his brother, Randy, and son, Daniel, 30.

Then it was Darian Gardner's turn. At 15, the Idaho high school student has never known a time in which her grandfather was not a condemned man. They kept in touch through letters and rare visits.

"For me, this day has always been coming," she said. "I always knew it was going to happen someday."

But that didn't change the way she felt about him. And Wednesday she had one final chance to tell him.

Darian Gardner said she didn't speak to her grandfather about what was to come.

"But I could tell that he wasn't worried about himself," she said. "He was only worried about us. He wanted to make sure we would be OK."

Like her mother, Darian Gardner found it hard to say goodbye.

"So I just told him that I loved him," she said. "And he told me to be strong."

Source: Salt Lake Tribune, June 18, 2010


Rallying Against the Death Penalty

Despite the cold wind, about 200 people sat outside the steps of the Utah State Capitol in protest against the death penalty last night.

49-year-old Ronnie Lee Gardner was pronounced dead at 12:20 a.m. on June 18 after facing a firing squad. Gardner spent nearly 25 years on death row for the 1985 murder of attorney Michael Burdell during an attempt to escape a hearing for the murder of bartender Melvyn Otterstrom in 1984.

Strangers and family members and even former mayor Rocky Andersen alike attended the rally in support of Gardner and to take a stand against the death penalty. Gardner's 1st cousin, who did not offer a name or further comment, said that the family was in mourning.

Rally participants held signs that declared, "Not Fair, Not Just," "Moratorium Now," "The Death Penalty Makes Us All Murderers" and "Pray for the Burdell, Otterstrom and Gardner Families." Although the night was too windy to allow for a candlelight vigil, people in the crowd still raised their candles and held a moment of silence for Gardner.

Ralph Dellapiana, public defense lawyer and director of the Utahns for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, said during the rally that Gardner's life, as well as the lives of others in Utah who have faced the death penalty, was in part on him.

"I felt responsible for his [Gardner's] life, that light which is in each of us," Dellapiana said amidst applause, "and that's when I determined that I'd better try to end the death penalty in Utah."

He added that the community needs to feel that same sense of responsibility in order to make a difference, because "nobody wants to be responsible for anybody else's death."

Criminal defense lawyer and practicing Mormon Kent Hart also spoke to the crowd, acknowledging his faith as to not ignore "the elephant in the room," but also as a way to encourage those of the LDS faith to consider the implications of the death penalty.

Although Hart has not developed a personal relationship with Gardner, he has worked with the other eight out of nine men on Utah's death row and established close friendships with each of them.

According to Hart, Utah still has a long way to go before the death penalty is done away with completely.

"I'm not delusional. I'm not saying we're going to abolish the death penalty next week, or even next year," he said, but added that he believes it can happen.

Former chaplain at the Utah State Prison Brother Rodriguez, who worked at the prison until 1996, recalled the execution of John Albert Taylor. Taylor was executed by firing squad on Jan. 26, 1996, the last execution by firing squad before Gardner's execution.

In 1996 at this hour, I was with Chris Rogers [Taylor's lawyer] and John Taylor in the holding cell," Rodriguez said. "We were all on the floor because there were no chairs."

Taylor was calm, unafraid and accepting of his situation, Rodriguez said. Shortly before midnight, he was told to get ready. The three of them went together "to the same room Ronnie will be going to tonight," he said. Taylor was strapped to the chair, a hood was placed over his head and a marker over his chest. Rodriguez said he sat in one of the two viewing rooms but closed his eyes when the command was given to fire because he did not want to witness the death, re-entering the execution room once Taylor had been pronounced dead.

"There was blood rolling out of his chest," Rodriguez described, bringing tears to the crowd's eyes and reminding them of what was scheduled to happen later that night. Rodriguez commended the crowd for attending, saying that although Gardner will not be able to live out his purpose in life, that purpose will be carried out for him.

Doctor and attorney Clark Newhall said that the death penalty, simply put, "is just stupid."

"We feel like it's wrong for the state, for us, to kill a helpless human in a cage," he said.

Not only is the death penalty unjust, it's wasteful, Newhall added. He said that it's a waste of a human life, what could be done with that life and even of the time and money spent on the executions.

Newhall said that the death penalty reduces the United States to a barbaric, uncivilized nation.

"It takes us out of the realm of civilized cultures and it takes us out of the the realm of reason," he said.

Dellapiana said that though nothing can be done to change Gardner's sentence, it has become clear that he never had a proper hearing.

"His lawyers were legally deficient," he claimed, saying that sufficient evidence was not offered to the jurors. He said that Gardner was abused, given drugs by his brother at age six and suffered brain damage as a result of meningitis.

According to Dellapiana, 4 of the jurors have come forward and said that they would not have voted for death if they had been told of Gardner's past.

"Apparently there's nothing left we can do for Ronnie Lee Gardner," Dellapiana said, "but let's do what we can to make Ronnie Lee Gardner's execution Utah's last."

Source: Salt Lake City Weekly, June 18, 2010

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Governor denies Ronnie Lee Gardner's request to halt execution

The Salt Lake Tribune
Updated: 06/17/2010 04:00:40 PM MDT

Just hours before Ronnie Lee Gardner is scheduled to be put to death, Gov. Gary Herbert has turned down his request to temporarily halt the execution until the killer is awarded another commutation hearing.

Another last-ditch effort to save Gardner failed Thursday, when the 10th U.S. Circuit Court turned down an appeal from the killer. The condemned man's lawyer's immediately appealed that decision to the U.S. Supreme Court, where a second appeal is already pending.

The execution is set for 12:05 a.m. Friday.

"Upon careful review, there is nothing in the materials provided this morning that has not already been considered and decided by the Board of Pardons and Parole or numerous courts," Herbert wrote in a letter to Gardner's attorneys. "Mr. Gardner has had a full and fair opportunity to have his case considered by numerous tribunals."

The Utah Constitution does not grant the governor the authority to issue a pardon or to commute Gardner's sentence.


Source: The Salt Lake Tribune, June 17, 2010

The Spectacle Doesn't Change the Facts

Ronnie Lee Gardner's death by a Utah firing squad is an anomaly. Despite the curiosity generated by the high-profile manner of imposing the punishment, the death penalty is on the wane in America.

A new Rasmussen poll released June 8 shows that public support for the death penalty has declined. Three-quarters of Americans are concerned that some individuals are executed for crimes they did not commit, including 40% who are "very concerned."

So it is no small wonder that the death penalty is increasingly falling into disuse. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty less often, and jurors are returning death sentences less often as well. The active use of the death penalty is confined to a handful of states. Even in Utah, despite this splashy appearance on the executing stage, executions are very rare, with less than a dozen people on death row.

And the legal foundation upon which the system of capital punishment was built is crumbling. The American Law Institute played a pivotal role in the effort to design a capital sentencing scheme that comported with constitutional norms of due process and equal protection through its Model Penal Code. Tellingly, the ALI withdrew the Model Penal Code provision for capital punishment, citing its belief that the intractable problems of arbitrariness, bias and unfairness in the system could not be fixed.

We as a society need to learn to recognize the devastation and lifelong effect of homicides on families of murder victims and our communities. We need to find a response that better serves affected communities.

For our part, we will continue to tell the truth about the way in which capital punishment undermines and degrades our system of justice. We will encourage and support citizens in getting involved in the fight for abolition. We will continue to move forward our programming through Rachel's Fund to build bridges to find common ground to enhance our communal response to homicide.

We have no doubt that given the facts, the public will make the wise choice. It is not now a question of whether, but instead when capital punishment will end.

Source: Diann Rust-Tierney, Executive Director of the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty, June 17, 2010, The Huffington Post

Ronnie Lee Gardner is 1 of 2 death row inmates in 'Super Max'

At the Utah State Prison (left), the highest security unit is called Uinta 1. It's one of eight sections in the Uinta facility that houses several hundred inmates. The building also includes the death row program. "Super Max," or Uinta 1, is reserved for inmates that either need protection or have been determined to be troublemakers.

In prison, one way to control inmates is by allowing them privileges for good behavior. Those in Super Max have lost their privileges. Currently, there are two death row inmates in Super Max — Troy Kell and Gardner. The other eight on death row live in another Uinta unit.

Kell was convicted of murder in Nevada and sentenced to life in prison. He was transferred to Utah's Gunnison facility, however, after problems with other inmates arose while he was in prison in Nevada. While in Gunnison, he stabbed fellow inmate Lonnie Blackmon 67 times, killing him.

In 1998, Department of Corrections officials moved Gardner into Super Max following a string of behavior problems. In 1990, he barricaded the door in the prison visiting area, holding a SWAT team at bay while he had sex with his girlfriend. In 1994, Gardner got drunk from an alcoholic brew he concocted and stabbed inmate Richard "Fatts" Thomas six times.

The cells on Utah's death row are approximately 6 feet by 12 feet. Inmates are housed individually, and each cell contains a stainless steel toilet, sink and mirror, and a hard bunk, thin mattress and small window. If they can afford it, they can even have a television.

Prisoners in Super Max are only allowed out of their cells for one hour a day and cannot have contact with other inmates.

A typical day for a death row inmate includes getting up and eating breakfast at 7 a.m. followed by recreation and shower time. At noon they eat lunch. Then they remain in their cells until 10 p.m., which is designated bed time, though some may be allowed to continue to read in their bunks. Those in the death row program are allowed one hour of civilian visits per week.

While Super Max inmates only get one hour out of their cells, those in the death row program get slightly more.

The recreation yard that death row inmates have access to is 10 feet by 12 feet and is a concrete-floored, concrete-walled area. A covering on the top allows sunlight and open air into the yard.


Source: Deseret News, June 17, 2010

Death penalty foes urge moratorium on Utah executions

Ronnie Lee Gardner's date with the firing squad has spurred a group of people opposed to the death penalty to no longer remain silent.

Utahns for Alternatives to the Death Penalty organized as a judge signed Gardner's death warrant in April. It includes 9 religious denominations, a couple of organizations and more than 160 individuals who've registered at the coalition's website.

The group opposes the death penalty, contending it is expensive, ineffective, arbitrary and discriminatory. Furthermore, it fails to meet the needs of victims' families, risks being imposed on innocent people and conflicts with religious beliefs.

"We oppose capital punishment not just for what it does to those guilty of horrible crimes, but for how it affects society," says Bishop John C. Wester, of the Catholic Diocese of Salt Lake City, a founding member of the group.

Coalition members are calling for a moratorium on further executions in Utah while an independent commission studies capital punishment.

Ralph Dellapiana, a Salt Lake attorney who heads the group, said UTADP intends to incorporate as a nonprofit organization.

"We're in it for the long haul," Dellapiana said. "It's not just the Ronnie Lee Gardner case."

The group drafted a position paper outlining its basic beliefs:

• The death penalty is a failed policy that is extremely expensive and ineffective.

• The death penalty system doesn't help the families of victims.

• Maintaining a death penalty diverts resources that could be spent on truly effective crime prevention and detection activities.

• The death penalty is applied in an arbitrary and discriminatory manner that is socioeconomically, geographically and racially biased.

• Many innocent people have been condemned to die.

• People in the United States and throughout the world increasingly reject the death penalty.

• A death penalty system violates the moral codes of Utah's religious communities.

• Life without the possibility of parole is the current alternative to the death penalty, and it works effectively both to punish offenders and protect society at a fraction of the cost of the death penalty system.

"As Christians we condemn the taking of human life, recalling that Jesus himself was the victim of state-sponsored murder, said Bishop Carolyn Tanner Irish of the Episcopal Diocese of Utah. "His death holds before our eyes the poverty of capital punishment and its capacity to dehumanize those who carry out its sentence. We yearn for the day that justice is neither retributive nor vengeful."

Source: Deseret News, June 16, 2010

Corrections officials deny Ronnie Lee Gardner request to be interviewed by Larry King

Condemned killer Ronnie Lee Gardner now will not do any media interviews prior to his anticipated execution, the Utah Department of Corrections says.

The department previously had said Gardner would not be available for interviews, a decision based, in part, on Gardner's stated desire not to speak to the press, said prison spokesman Steve Gehrke. Other considerations included security and a desire to avoid glorifying Gardner's crimes and further harming his victims.

Gardner earlier Wednesday expressed his desire to appear on CNN's "Larry King Live" to discuss creating an organic farm to help troubled youths. Corrections executive director Tom Patterson agreed to review the request, which included contacting King's producers.

Producers for the show expressed interest for a telephone conversation with Gardner on Wednesday evening. However, upon full review and considering all pending security concerns, the corrections department reaffirmed its decision not to allow any interviews, to ensure the safety and security of the prison facility, Gehrke said.

Prison officials had agreed to allow an interview after Salt Lake attorney Jeff Hunt filed a request on behalf of the Deseret News arguing that prohibiting interviews was a violation of Gardner's First Amendment rights.

Gardner told the Deseret News he wanted to be interviewed by the newspaper, but then told Patterson on Wednesday that he wanted to be on King's TV program.

On Tuesday, Gardner enjoyed his requested last meal. Contrary to some reports, however, his friends and family said he is not fasting for the remaining hours to his scheduled execution at midnight Thursday night/Friday morning.

A friend of Gardner who spoke with the inmate Wednesday told the Deseret News that he just wanted to enjoy his preferred last meal without the stress that will likely accompany Thursday's events leading up to the
execution.

Source: Deseret News, June 16, 2010


Firing squad -- Method has garnered international attention.

If all goes as expected, Ronnie Lee Gardner will take his place in history Friday as the 3rd person in the nation to die by firing squad since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1976.

He could also be the last -- or one of the last -- in the nation to be executed that way in the United States.

Utah is the only state still using shooters, and only the four men on death row who initially selected the firing squad before the state eliminated it in 2004 could still choose bullets over lethal injection.

40 of the 50 men legally executed in Utah since 1852 have been killed by firing squad, according to Weber State University criminologist L. Kay Gillespie. 6 were executed by hanging -- an option along with beheading under Utah's 1st capital-punishment law -- and 4 by lethal injection.

When lawmakers were debating the use of firing squads in 2004, then-Sen. David Thomas, R-South Weber, said the firing squad had been an effective method since statehood and supported keeping it. But he was outvoted, with some legislators citing the publicity that surrounds firing squad executions.

The last Utah inmate to die by firing squad was John Albert Taylor in 1996, who said he selected the method to embarrass the state. His death made international headlines.

Before Taylor, Gary Gilmore ultimately chose to die by bullets rather than lethal injection. Gilmore's crimes and execution spawned the book The Executioner's Song and a television movie of the same name.

The state Attorney General's Office has said it could have argued Gardner, 49, did not have the right to switch back to firing squad but decided not to dispute his choice.

The other death-row inmates who initially picked firing squad are Ron Lafferty, Ralph Leroy Menzies, Troy Michael Kell and Taberon Dave Honie.

Source: Salt Lake Tribune,June 16, 2010


Utah execution reopens death-penalty debate

As the nation again turns an eye toward Utah and its preparations for an execution by firing squad, capital-punishment proponents insist death is the only just penalty for the worst crimes. For opponents, questions persist.

Gary Gilmore earned Utah a special place in history when his 1977 execution by firing squad reopened the door to capital punishment in the United States.

The practice has remained problematic ever since.

Otherwise, Ronnie Lee Gardner — sentenced to die for the 1985 courthouse slaying of attorney Michael Burdell — wouldn't have spent 25 years on Utah's death row.

Most countries and 15 states, as well as the District of Columbia, have found the death penalty untenable and abandoned it.

Now, as the nation again turns an eye toward Utah and its preparations for Gardner's scheduled execution by firing squad early Friday, capital-punishment proponents insist death is the only just penalty for the worst crimes.

For opponents, however, questions persist: Is the death penalty administered arbitrarily? Is justice served when inmates languish for decades? Can states afford to spend the millions of dollars capital cases require? And does the death penalty deter crime and lead to a better society?

Is it fair?

The Supreme Court halted capital punishment in 1972, convinced the penalty had been applied arbitrarily in the case of Henry Furman, who shot a Georgia homeowner during a burglary. The same concern will end the
practice again, opponents maintain.

They say one well-known Utah case — that of Dan and Ron Lafferty — highlights the uneven way the death sentence is applied.

The brothers were convicted of the July 24, 1984, homicides of Brenda Lafferty, their sister-in-law, and her 15-month-old daughter, Erica, in American Fork, 30 miles south of Salt Lake City. Ron Lafferty awaits execution; his brother is serving 2 life terms.

They were tried separately. Unlike Ron, Dan represented himself at trial. Two jurors refused to give Dan the death penalty, although he claimed he slit the victims' throats.

"The law is not very good at specifying who should live and who should die," said Franklin Zimring, a law professor at the University of California, Berkeley.

Zimring was among those who recently persuaded the American Law Institute — an association of about 4,000 lawyers, professors and judges — to abandon its support of the death penalty based on arbitrary application.

The institute was the force that led the Supreme Court in 1976 to reinstate the death penalty in Gregg v. Georgia. The group established a legal framework of aggravating and mitigating factors to standardize the death penalty.

Without the backing of the institute, the death penalty has lost its "intellectual underpinnings," said Roger Clark, a law professor at Rutgers University. "We have to compare crimes and criminals, and we just can't do it very well. The jury makes the call, but the criteria (upon which they make their decision) doesn't make sense."

Should it take so long?

In some cases, such as that of the mother and stepfather charged in the May torture killing of 4-year-old Ethan Stacy in Utah, society demands execution, said Kent Scheidegger, director of Sacramento-based Criminal Justice Legal Fund.

"There are some crimes for which any lesser penalty is not justice," he said.

Although Scheidegger contends there is no way to make capital punishment "completely consistent," he said the system does "by and large only sentence the worst killers to death."

For capital punishment to be effective as a deterrent, he said, states must streamline the appeals process. As an example, Virginia has limited the number of appeals in capital cases to an automatic appeal followed by a second review. An execution date is set immediately if they both are denied, forcing inmates to turn to federal courts, according to the Office of the Virginia Attorney General.

Behind Texas, Virginia has executed more people since capital punishment was reinstated than any other state. Virginia's 5-year average from sentencing to execution compares with a national average of 11 years, according to Northern Illinois University.

But streamlining capital cases could be even more expensive because more attorneys and judges would be needed, Salt Lake City civil-rights attorney Brian Barnard said. The time it takes to execute someone can't be blamed on defense attorneys, he said.

Death-penalty appeals are dealt with painstakingly, he said, and that takes time.

"When society is imposing something that is irreversible, the judicial system says we must be careful because (death penalty) mistakes are irreversible," Barnard said.

And mistakes have been made. The Death Penalty Information Center points to the exoneration of 138 death-row inmates since 1973.

Like most death-penalty proponents, University of Utah law professor Paul Cassell would like the time between conviction and execution to be reduced. Otherwise, he said, the death penalty works well in this country and is structured to be lenient, not barbaric.

"We could make the death penalty apply evenly, but if it's applied evenly, everyone who commits murder gets the death penalty," he said. "The sorting is done by the jury."

Does it improve society?

The last person executed in Utah was Joseph Mitchell Parsons, put to death in October 1999 for the 1987 murder of California resident Richard Ernest.

Then-Iron County Attorney Scott Burns sought the death penalty because, he said, the crime was especially heinous: Parsons robbed Ernest and stabbed him more than a dozen times with a screwdriver.

Ernest had picked up the hitchhiking Parsons in California. The pair were near Parowan in southern Utah when Parsons attacked Ernest and took his car and credit cards.

"My thought was to let a jury decide whether he deserved the death penalty," said Burns, now director of the National District Attorneys Association. "It's a difficult thing. I carry it with me every single day."

Ernest's sister, Jana Salais, witnessed the execution by lethal injection.

"It's justice, but it's not fair," Salais said. Parsons deserved a brutal death, she said. "(But) he just laid there and went to sleep."

Like the rest of the country, the families of Gardner's victims have mixed views on the death penalty.

Kirk's widow and daughters say they can't rest until Gardner has been executed. Donna Nu, Burdell's fiancée, says she would do anything to stop Gardner's execution. Otterstrom's widow, Kathy Potter, and son, Jason Otterstrom, have not weighed in.

"I don't know which path should be followed, but our family needs peace," Otterstrom said last week. "I ask that whatever decision is reached, that it be permanent."

Source: Salt Lake Tribune,June 16, 2010 - Photo: Utah State Correctional Facility


Utah needs a death penalty debate

With the hourglass running down to the execution of Ronnie Lee Gardner, we urge the good people of Utah to examine their majority commitment to capital punishment as a just, moral and practical means of government-sanctioned punishment.

For we are far from alone in asserting that it is none of those things. The evidence supporting our view is not only persuasive but has, over time, become virtually incontestable.

Yet, as a state we continue to embrace an archaic, unfair and notoriously fallible practice in which the most notorious convicted murderers pay their debt to society in a specie that we have determined has no inherent
value.

Capital punishment, compared to lifetime incarceration, is far more expensive. The cost of public defenders trained to handle death penalty cases, years of legal appeals, and the burden on the judicial system far exceeds the tax dollars necessary to house an inmate in a maximum security cell block for life. It is this fact alone that has motivated some of the 15 states that have abolished capital punishment and roughly a dozen others that are considering doing so.

But the economics of the death penalty are secondary to the moral and human cost of retaining a system that has always been unevenly applied. It is beyond argument that racial minorities and the poor are much more likely to face execution than whites from the middle and upper classes. It also is widely acknowledged that executions have no deterrent value.

Since 1994, when the national number of death penalty cases rose to an annual high of 328, that rate has fallen by 63 % to the lowest number since the Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment in 1976. Much of that decline can be attributed to the high-profile impact of cases in which DNA evidence has later exonerated death row inmates, many of whom were sentenced to be executed on the basis of eyewitness testimony.

It is impossible to know how many wrongfully convicted inmates have gone to their deaths, but the Death Penalty Information Center puts at 129 the number of those who have been released from death row since 1977 based on new evidence.

Ronnie Lee Gardner murdered 2 people in 1985. But that fact really is not germane to whether we should retain capital punishment. In deciding that question, we should ask ourselves this question: Do our outrage and natural desire for revenge alone justify retaining a broken and bankrupt system?

Source: Editorial, Salt Lake Tribune, June 16, 2010


Inmate set to die by firing squad asks high court to stay execution

A Utah death row inmate who would become only the 3rd person to die by firing squad in the United States in 33 years appealed to the Supreme Court on Wednesday, seeking a last-minute stay of execution.

Ronnie Lee Gardner's lawyers filed the first of what are expected to be several appeals to the justices. He is scheduled to be put to death early Friday for the shooting death of attorney Michael Burdell during a botched
escape attempt from custody in 1985 at a Salt Lake City, Utah, courthouse.

Among the claims the 49-year-old prisoner raises in his appeals is that he has been a death row inmate too long.

"He asserts that executing him now, after nearly 25 years on death row in Utah, so lacks retributive or deterrent value that it violates the Eighth Amendment," Andrew Parnes, Gardner's lawyer, told the high court. He did not return phone calls from CNN seeking comment.

Gardner's lawyers have launched an aggressive scramble in state and federal courts, as well as the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole, to at least postpone the execution.

A federal judge late Tuesday refused to block it, after Gardner claimed the procedures related to a two-day commutation hearing held by the board last week violated his civil rights. Parnes had argued the clemency hearing was not fair and impartial because representatives from the Utah attorney general's office were both presenting the state's case at the hearing and advising the board. Attorneys representing the state agency said safeguards were in place to prevent a conflict of interest.

The parole board Monday refused to commute Gardner's sentence to life in prison, and the Utah Supreme Court on Tuesday also denied his request for a stay. He claims he is a changed man, and should not be executed for his crimes.

Gardner is set to become the third person to die by rifle fire, all in Utah, since the Supreme Court restored the death penalty in 1976. He had a long history of escapes and was slipped a gun before he fatally shot Burdell on April 2, 1985. He was at the courthouse for a pre-trial hearing in the 1984 slaying of Melvyn Otterstrom, who was killed at the Salt Lake City bar where he was working to earn extra money.

The execution is set for just after midnight (2 a.m. ET) at the Utah State Prison in Draper, about 20 miles south of Salt Lake City.

Corrections officials announced Gardner had consumed his last meal Tuesday night at 6:30 p.m., and has elected to fast prior to the anticipated execution.

During the commutation hearing, parole board members heard testimony regarding Gardner's childhood, which was punctuated by poverty, abuse and neglect. Parnes maintained that jurors in the Burdell trial never heard this evidence -- and presented affidavits from jurors who said it might have persuaded them to decide against the death penalty.

Life in prison without the possibility of parole was not an option for jurors at the time, and Parnes said it was suggested to the jury that Gardner might be released from prison at some point if he were given a life sentence. Gardner pleaded guilty to 2nd-degree murder in Otterstrom's death, and jurors were not told of a judge's recommendation in that case that he not be released from prison, Parnes said.

Utah is the only state that uses the firing squad as a current execution method. Oklahoma allows it only if lethal injection and electrocution are ruled unconstitutional. 40 of Utah's 49 executions in the last 160 years or so have been done this way, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

State lawmakers made lethal injection the default capital punishment in 2004, but at least three inmates who already had chosen the firing squad were grandfathered in under the new law.

5 anonymous marksmen will use matching .30-caliber rifles, standing behind a wall cut with 5 gunports. One of the rifles will be an "ineffective" round, similar to a blank, which delivers the same recoil as a live round. That ensures none of the riflemen will know who delivered the fatal shot.

The marksmen fire from a distance of 25 feet. The inmate is blindfolded, strapped to a chair and a target pinned to his chest.

Lethal injection remains by far the most-used execution method in the United States and is the primary or only option in the 35 states with capital punishment. 9 states still use electrocution, 5 states have the gas chamber, and 2 -- Washington and New Hampshire -- would hang condemned inmates as an alternate method.

The Supreme Court case is Gardner v. Utah (09-11378).

Source: CNN.com, June 16, 2010