Showing posts with label James E. Holmes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label James E. Holmes. Show all posts

Thursday, February 20, 2014

Judge orders new sanity evaluation for accused Colorado movie theater shooter

(CNN) -- A judge has ordered that accused Colorado movie theater shooter James Holmes undergo an additional sanity examination, saying there was good cause to believe previous testing was "incomplete and inadequate," according to a ruling issued Wednesday.

Arapahoe County District Judge Carlos Samour Jr. ordered Holmes to undergo an independent exam by the Colorado Mental Health Institute in Pueblo by early March, and the report must be filed by July 14.

Samour further ruled the new examiner may not take into account any mitigating factors that are identified in the state's death penalty statutes.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty against Holmes, who is accused of opening fire in a packed movie theater in Aurora, Colorado, during a July 2012 midnight showing of the latest Batman installment, "The Dark Knight Rises."

Authorities have said Holmes was dressed head to toe in protective gear.

Holmes allegedly threw tear-gas canisters in the theater and then opened fire on the patrons, according to witnesses. Police say he used several weapons, including an AR-15 rifle, before fleeing the theater.

Outside the theater, the shooter was apprehended, identifying himself to police as "The Joker," one of Batman's archenemies.

Holmes faces 166 charges in the rampage that left 12 people dead and dozens more wounded.

Holmes was a neuroscience doctoral student at the University of Colorado's Anschutz Medical Campus until the month before the attack; prosecutors have argued that he began plotting his attack while still enrolled.

The defense, meanwhile, appears to be focused not so much on what Holmes allegedly did that night but his mental state then and earlier.

A psychiatrist who treated him had warned campus police at the University of Colorado how dangerous he was, prompting them to deactivate his college ID to prevent him from passing through any locked doors, according to court documents.

Source: CNN, Feb. 19, 2014

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Judge limits defense's death penalty evidence in theater shooting case

The defense in the Aurora movie theater murder case won't be able to present evidence at trial about the history of the death penalty or about how the gunman's possible execution would impact his family, a judge ruled Thursday.

In 2 orders, Arapahoe County District Court Judge Carlos Samour said neither type of evidence would be relevant to jurors deciding whether to sentence gunman James Holmes to death. Instead, Samour ruled that jurors should be given a "succinct and clear instruction" about the current laws regarding sentences to death or life in prison without parole.

Samour also concluded that, while defendants are allowed to present mitigating evidence during a death-penalty trial, only information about the accused's character and history and about the circumstances of the crime are valid for the jury to consider.

"Because neither the love that family members, friends, and others may feel about the defendant nor the impact his execution may have on them is relevant mitigating evidence, it is inadmissible," Samour wrote in one of the orders.

Prosecutors will seek the death penalty against Holmes if he is convicted of murder in the attack on the Century Aurora 16 movie theater in July 2012. Defense attorneys have admitted that Holmes shot 12 people to death during the attack and wounded many others, but they say he was in the throes of a psychotic episode.

The trial in the case is currently on hold while prosecutors fight for a 2nd court-ordered psychiatric evaluation of Holmes. Prosecutors have accused the doctor who performed the first evaluation of being biased.

Source: The Denver Post, January 24, 2014

Saturday, November 23, 2013

Aurora theater shooting trial postponed indefinitely

James Holmes
James Holmes
The judge in the Colorado theater shootings case on Thursday indefinitely postponed the trial of James Holmes so attorneys can argue whether he should undergo another psychiatric evaluation.

Holmes' trial had been set to begin in February.

Holmes pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to charges of killing 12 people and injuring 70 at an Aurora theater in July 2012. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty, and they want Holmes to undergo further evaluation of his sanity.

District Judge Carlos Samour Jr. scheduled hearings on further testing and other pre-trial issues for Dec. 17 and 18.

The findings of Holmes' 1st mental health evaluation, conducted at a state hospital, have not been publicly disclosed. But the fact that prosecutors want further evaluation suggests that the 1st exam might have found Holmes was insane.

Holmes' attorneys don't dispute that he committed the shootings, but his plea makes psychiatric evaluations - which assess whether Holmes was sane at the time of the shootings - the most important pieces of evidence.

If doctors who evaluated Holmes concluded he was insane, it would be much harder for prosecutors to persuade a jury to convict him of murder and sentence him to death.

If jurors agreed Holmes was insane, he would be committed indefinitely to the state hospital. He could one day be released If doctors there ever concluded Holmes' sanity had been restored, he could one day be released, but that is considered unlikely.

Colorado law defines insanity as the inability to tell right from wrong because of a mental disease or defect. An evaluation by the state mental hospital is mandatory for anyone who pleads insanity. Holmes underwent his last summer.

Source: Associated Press, November 23, 2013

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Colorado: Prosecutors seek further Holmes sanity evaluation

Prosecutors in the Colorado theater shooting case want defendant James Holmes to undergo further evaluation of his sanity, according to court records made public Monday - a development that suggests the first examination might have found he was insane.

The findings of the first evaluation have not been publicly disclosed, but longtime Denver defense attorney Dan Recht said it was highly unlikely prosecutors would ask for further examination if the first found Holmes was sane. Recht is not involved in the case.

Holmes pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to charges of killing 12 people and injuring 70 at a suburban Denver theater in July 2012. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

Colorado law defines insanity as the inability to tell right from wrong because of a mental disease or defect. An evaluation by the state mental hospital is mandatory for anyone who pleads insanity. Holmes underwent his last summer.

If the doctors who conducted the evaluation concluded Holmes was insane, it would be much harder for prosecutors to persuade a jury to convict him of murder and sentence him to death.

If jurors agreed Holmes was insane, he would be committed indefinitely to the state hospital. If doctors there ever concluded Holmes' sanity had been restored, he could one day be released, but that is considered unlikely.

The request by the district attorney's office for a further examination "is a clear indication that the prosecution is unhappy with the state hospital evaluation," Recht said. "It certainly suggests that the opinion of the state hospital psychiatrists is favorable to the Holmes defense of insanity."

Prosecutors would have to show a good reason for the judge to approve their request, Recht said.

Arapahoe County District Judge Carlos A. Samour Jr., who is handling the Holmes case, has not said when he might rule or hold a hearing.

Details of the motion filed Friday seeking a new evaluation were not made public. Only the title - "Motion for Further Examination Pursuant to C.R.S. 16-18-106(1)" - was disclosed.

It refers to the section of the Colorado Revised Statutes governing sanity evaluations.

Prosecutors asked to have the motion kept secret, and Samour agreed. The judge has imposed a gag order on both sides, forbidding them from discussing the case publicly outside the courtroom.

Holmes is charged with multiple counts of murder and attempted murder. His trial is scheduled for next year, with jury selection set to start in February.

Separately, Samour ruled that prosecutors can use evidence that police found in defendant James Holmes' apartment, which authorities said includes homemade bombs and a calendar with the day of the shootings highlighted.

The ruling, also dated Friday, rejected defense arguments that the apartment search was illegal because it began before police had a warrant.

Prosecutors argued the search was permissible because Holmes told them he had explosives at his apartment, and they didn't have time to wait for a warrant because of the potential danger.

They later did get a warrant.

Prosecutors are fighting to use any evidence to undermine Holmes' insanity claim. They could argue that the calendar and the bombs - which law-enforcement officers say were meant to divert first responders from the theater - show the attack was planned and that Holmes understood the shootings were wrong.

Source: Arizona Daily Star, November 19, 2013

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Colorado: Aurora movie theater shooter's 1st statements admissible, judge rules

DENVER -- Police officers who arrested James Holmes moments after the Colorado theater shootings will be allowed to tell jurors that when they asked Holmes if he had an accomplice, he replied, "No, it's just me," the judge ruled Friday.

The officers also say Holmes told them he had four guns and that he had left bombs in his apartment that would go off if wires were tripped.

The judge ruled the arresting officers' testimony about Holmes' statements can be used as prosecution evidence, even though police had not read Holmes his Miranda rights advising him he could remain silent.

The judge said officers were allowed to question Holmes without reading him his rights under a public safety exception to the Miranda rule because they needed to know about any accomplices.

The testimony could help prosecutors in their effort to undermine Holmes' claim that he was insane at the time of the July 2012 shootings, which left 12 dead and 70 injured.

Holmes, now 25, pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to multiple counts of murder and attempted murder. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

Defense lawyers have acknowledged Holmes was the shooter.

Holmes was arrested by some of the first officers to arrive at the theater in the Denver suburb of Aurora. They testified that bleeding victims were still running away screaming as they confronted Holmes, who did not resist.

They said their training taught them that mass killings often have more than one perpetrator, and the fleeing victims made them suspect another shooter might still be inside the theater.

The officers testified they asked Holmes if he had any weapons. Holmes replied "four guns" and added that he had bombs at his apartment, police said. The bombs were defused with no explosions or injuries.

Defense lawyers said the officers' testimony shouldn't be allowed because they had not read Holmes his Miranda rights. The defense also argued Holmes' statements were not voluntary.

Prosecutors argued police did not have to read Holmes his rights because they urgently needed to know if there was another shooter. They also denied Holmes was coerced.

Arapahoe County District Judge Carlos T. Samour Jr. agreed with prosecutors.

Samour has not yet ruled on several other evidence questions. The defense has asked him to bar evidence found in Holmes' apartment and car, statements Holmes made to officers later about the bombs in his apartment, and the contents of Holmes' phone, which included photos of Holmes wearing reddish-orange hair and dark contact lenses and holding guns.

Law enforcement officers have testified at pretrial hearings the photos were taken hours before the attack.

Jury selection for Holmes' trial is expected to begin in February and take several weeks.

Source: AP, November 2, 2013

Monday, October 21, 2013

Defense lawyers, prosecutors in Colorado theater shooting resume battle over evidence of insanity

James Holmes returns to court for another round of skirmishes over what evidence can be used against him when he goes on trial for the Colorado theater shootings.

Pretrial hearings resume Monday.

Defense lawyers and prosecutors are battling over any scrap of evidence that could be used to bolster or weaken Holmes' claim that he was insane at the time of the 2012 Aurora shootings.

Holmes pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to charges of killing 12 people and injuring 70. His lawyers say he was having a psychotic episode.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty, but first they must convince a jury that Holmes was sane.

Trial is scheduled to start in February.

Source: Associated Press, October 21, 2013

Monday, September 30, 2013

Colorado: Lawyers for James Holmes seek to throw out the death penalty

James Holmes
Lawyers for Aurora movie theater shooting defendant James Holmes want the judge in the case to declare Colorado's death-penalty laws unconstitutional.

In multiple motions filed Friday and made public Tuesday, lawyers for Holmes say the state's death-penalty laws are unconstitutionally arbitrary, that the jury-selection process unfairly skews the jury pool, and that the punishment is sought and used so infrequently in Colorado as to make it cruel and unusual.

"Imposition of the death penalty is rare, unusual, freakish, and inconsistently applied throughout the State of Colorado," the defense lawyers write in 1 motion.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty against Holmes, whose lawyers have admitted that he killed 12 people and wounded dozens more in an attack on the Century Aurora 16 movie theater last summer. Holmes has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity.

A number of the motions are based on the findings of a study by 2 University of Denver law professors - a study commissioned by the defense team in another murder case - that found that almost all murder cases in Colorado are eligible for the death penalty.

According to the study, 92 % of the 544 1st-degree murder cases in Colorado between 1999 and 2010 were eligible for the death penalty. But prosecutors pursued the death penalty at trial in only 5 of those cases, according to the study. Based on those findings, Holmes' lawyers argue in the motions that Colorado's laws don't limit the use of the death penalty enough to comply with U.S. Supreme Court rulings. They also argue that, when the death penalty is used, it is applied inconsistently. The only district attorney's office to take death penalty cases to trial in the past decade is the 18th Judicial District attorney's office, the same one prosecuting Holmes.

And the defense attorneys say the process of selecting a jury in a death-penalty case - known as "death qualifying" the jury - results in a jury biased against the defendant. Any juror selected for a death-penalty case has to be willing potentially to impose capital punishment, meaning people opposed to the death penalty are disqualified from service. Citing "social science research," Holmes' attorneys say that selection process results in jurors that "are both partial to the prosecution and prone to convict."

Finally, Holmes' attorneys argue evolving attitudes toward the death penalty should render the punishment inapplicable in the case.

"The death penalty is in steep and consistent decline in Colorado," the attorneys wrote in one motion. "Thus, even if this Court restricts its view to the Colorado Constitution, it should strike the death penalty as inconsistent with the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society."

Prosecutors are due to respond in court filings to the motions later this month, and a gag order in the case prevents them from commenting publicly about the case. In past statements, 18th Judicial District Attorney George Brauchler has said the death penalty is used fairly and cautiously in Colorado.

"Our elected prosecutors prudently exercise discretion as to which few murder cases truly warrant the pursuit of the death penalty," Brauchler wrote earlier this year in an editorial in The Denver Post. "Which killer currently facing death in Colorado deserves a lesser sentence?"

The motions were filed Friday to meet a deadline for raising death penalty-related issues in the case. They are scheduled to be debated in December.

Source: The Burlington Record, September 30, 2013

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Colorado court gets sanity report in Aurora theater shooting

Prosecutors and defense lawyers in the Colorado theater shootings are getting their first look at a long-awaited opinion from a state psychiatrist on whether defendant James Holmes was legally insane when he killed 12 people and injured 70.

The report from the state mental hospital is secret, and prosecutors and defense lawyers cannot speak outside court about it because of a gag order. Its contents may be discussed in open court or written about in a motion.

Filed with the court on Friday, the report won't be the final word on Holmes' mental state - that will be up to the jury in Holmes' trial next year.

But it will be a critical piece of evidence as jurors consider whether Holmes should be found not guilty by reason of insanity and committed indefinitely to the state hospital, or convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison or death by lethal injection.

The report will say whether the psychiatrist who led the evaluation believes Holmes meets Colorado's legal definition of insanity: the inability to tell the difference between right and wrong because of a mental disease or defect.

"It's probably the most important expert witness that we have at this point," said Karen Steinhauser, a former prosecutor who is now in private practice and teaches at the University of Denver. She is not involved in Holmes' case.

Holmes has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity and is charged with more than 160 counts of murder and attempted murder.

Prosecutors say he spent months buying guns and ammunition before he dressed up in a police-style helmet and clothing and began shooting in a suburban Denver theater in July 2012.

Prosecutors say he also rigged his apartment with home-made bombs designed to divert police from the theater. They didn't explode.

Defense lawyers acknowledge Holmes was the gunman, but they say he was mentally ill and "in the throes of a psychotic episode."

Holmes underwent a mandatory sanity evaluation at the Colorado Mental Health Institute in Pueblo this summer after he entered his insanity plea.

Very few people qualify for the legal definition of insanity, even if they have been diagnosed with mental illness, said Steven Pitt, a forensic psychiatrist in Scottsdale, Ariz.

"The diagnosis itself doesn't give someone a get-out-of-jail card," said Pitt, who isn't working on the Aurora case.

The psychiatrist who led the evaluation could be called to testify. That person has not been publicly identified.

Jurors will have other evidence to consider about Holmes' sanity. Either side can ask for an evaluation by another psychiatrist and call others to testify about Holmes' behavior.

"Anyone who was in a position to observe his mental state, to observe how he was acting, whether he seemed to understand what was going on," Steinhauser said.

If the state psychiatrist's report concludes Holmes was insane, prosecutors are more likely to accept a bargain that would put Holmes in prison for life with no possibility of parole in exchange for a guilty plea, said Dan Recht, an attorney and past president of the Colorado Criminal Defense Bar.

Prosecutors might still convince jurors to convict Holmes, "but most juries would be very loath to have someone executed where there's a significant debate about whether the person was even sane at the time," he said.

Holmes' lawyers said in March that Holmes had offered to plead guilty if prosecutors didn't seek the death penalty, but prosecutors rejected the deal.

In other court documents made public Monday, a judge rejected 3 defense motions contesting the death penalty against Holmes because charges were filed by prosecutors and not handed up by a grand jury.

Defense attorneys also renewed their request for a hearing to challenge the admissibility of a 3-D graphic reconstruction of the theater and bullet trajectories. Holmes defense attorneys want the judge to examine the science behind the FBI's use of a survey instrument and remote sensing technology that uses lasers known as LiDAR before they're admitted into court.

Source: Associated Press, Sept. 10, 2013

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Lawyers for James Holmes seek to throw out the death penalty

Lawyers for Aurora movie theater shooting defendant James Holmes want the judge in the case to declare Colorado's death-penalty laws unconstitutional.

In multiple motions filed Friday and made public Tuesday, lawyers for Holmes say the state's death-penalty laws are unconstitutionally arbitrary, that the jury-selection process unfairly skews the jury pool and that the punishment is sought and used so infrequently in Colorado as to make it cruel and unusual.

"Imposition of the death penalty is rare, unusual, freakish, and inconsistently applied throughout the State of Colorado," the defense lawyers write in one motion.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty against Holmes, whose lawyers have admitted that he killed 12 people and wounded dozens more in an attack on the Century Aurora 16 movie theater last summer. Holmes has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity.


Source; The Denver Post, September 3, 2013

Friday, June 28, 2013

Colorado: James Holmes to wear hidden harness anchored to floor

James Holmes
Colorado theater shooting suspect James Holmes will be restrained during his trial by wearing a harness under his clothes that will be anchored to the floor, the judge said Thursday.

Judge Carlos A. Samour Jr. also ruled the jury will not be sequestered during the trial, which is scheduled to start in February and is expected to take 4 months.

Holmes is accused of killing 12 people and injuring 70 others at a movie theater in the Denver suburb of Aurora in July.

He has worn heavy shackles on his wrists and ankles during pretrial hearings. His lawyers wanted him to be unshackled during the trial, saying the restraints would make him look guilty to the jury.

Samour said Holmes has to be restrained because he is charged with violent crimes. He said jurors won't see the harness, and the anchoring cable will blend in with computer cables at the defense table.

The judge ruled earlier that Holmes can wear civilian clothing at his trial.

Holmes pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to multiple charges of murder and attempted murder. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

Defense lawyers wanted the jury sequestered and wanted the jurors barred from having phones, laptop computers or any other electronics devices during the trial.

The judge said sequestration for such a long time would be costly and impractical, and would create an undue burden on jurors. He implied it also could prompt some prospective jurors to try to avoid the case.

However, Samour said he would allow defense lawyers to renew the request later if they think they have grounds to do so.

Denying jurors access to smartphones, computers, television sets and radios - along with email and the Internet - would be drastic and unfair, the judge said.

But he did rule jurors will not be allowed to have the devices in court or during deliberations.

Samour said he might seat as many as 12 alternate jurors - an unusually large number - in the event any of the 12 regular jurors is dismissed for hearing outside information or other reasons.

"The court cannot keep the jurors in a bubble, completely sealed off from the outside world," the judge said.

Samour has said 5,000 potential jurors will get a summons and that he expects 3,200 to 3,500 to respond.

Holmes' lawyers had also asked the judge to scale back the heavy security that has been present during 11 months of pretrial hearings, saying it would be "extraordinary and unnecessary" during the trial and would prejudice the jury against Holmes.

They also objected to deputies standing so close to Holmes in the courtroom that they could hear his conversations with his attorneys.

8 Arapahoe County sheriff's deputies usually stand guard in the courtroom during hearings. Others watch from the rooftops of the 2 courthouse buildings and in the parking lot.

Samour said 4 of the deputies in the courtroom will wear uniforms during the trial, and any others will wear street clothes. He also said they will keep a reasonable distance from the defense table.

The judge overruled the defense objection to having deputies on the rooftops and in the parking lot, saying they're necessary to protect Holmes and the public.

Samour said Sheriff Grayson Robinson had agreed to the hidden harness and tether for Holmes and the plainclothes deputies in the courtroom. Samour added he trusts Robinson's expertise and will heed his advice.

Source: Associated Press, June 28, 2013

Saturday, June 22, 2013

Death is Death: The More Capital Punishment Evolves, the More it Stays the Same

James Holmes
Vengeance and retribution are both human responses to tragedy, especially violence on a large scale. We’re not interested in justice when unspeakable acts take place. We want blood – now. Because our society is one of laws, angry mobs don’t usually hand down guilty verdicts and exact punishment. We have to wait for the guilty to go through the motions – arrest, “fair” trial, and sentencing – to get what we paid for: that sweet execution. Decades may pass from the time a judge hands down a death sentence to the day it’s carried out. The somber, private occasion that is our modern version of capital punishment brooks no cheers, no joyful singing that the guilty is soon to die. It is not the vehicle of satisfaction the public envisions it to be. There’s no catharsis for the victims, and no deterrence for those who might commit similar crimes in the future. In fact, employing it as a mechanism of the justice system has no place in our modern society – not even for the worst of the worst.

“For James Eagan Holmes, justice is death,” said Arapahoe County district attorney George Brauchler, according to ABC News. Holmes is alleged to have killed 12 people and wounded 70 during a midnight showing of The Dark Knight Rises in Aurora, Colorado. Brauchler, and his prosecutorial team, turned down a proposed plea agreement from Holmes, which would have required him to spend the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole. They’re seeking the death penalty, and many victims and the families of survivors applaud that decision. How many times did Brauchler practice that headline worthy snippet in the mirror? Did he imagine it broadcast across the globe by info-hungry media outlets?

Executing Holmes won’t bring back the dead, or provide those left behind with greater comfort. After his legal defense exhaust all of his appeals it may be decades until he sees an execution chamber – if a jury or judge sentences him to death at all. Victims, seeking to move on with their lives and heal, may only have their emotional wounds from that horrible night reopened, all the recovery washed away in a small black box of a room to watch a man die.


Source: Console and Hollawell Blog, Richard Console Jr. Mr. Console is the founding and managing partner of Console and Hollawell, one of the most highly regarded personal injury law firms in New Jersey and Pennsylvania.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Colorado: James Holmes can wear street clothes during movie massacre trial

The judge in James E. Holmes' murder trial in the Aurora movie theater massacre ruled Tuesday that the defendant can wear street clothes to court and that prospective jurors will not be sequestered during what is expected to be a lengthy selection process.

In allowing Holmes to shed his prison clothes, Judge Carlos Samour Jr. quoted from a Colorado appellant ruling: "The presumption of innocence requires the garb of innocence." He also cited a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that determined wearing prison clothes is "inherently prejudicial."

Holmes, 25, is scheduled to stand trial in February 2014 on a total of 166 counts of first degree murder, attempted murder and weapons charges in connection with last summer's Aurora movie theater massacre. 12 people died and 70 were injured on July 20 when a gunman opened fired in a packed movie theater during a midnight showing of "The Dark Knight Rises."

Holmes could face the death penalty if he is convicted.

In his many appearances in court since last summer, Holmes was shackled and wore the baggy maroon shirt and pants of the Arapahoe County Jail. His defense attorneys filed a motion last week asking that he be allowed "civilian clothes."

Although Samour agreed with the defense on clothing issues, he denied a defense request that potential jurors need to be sequestered to avoid exposure to casual conversation about the case in the courthouse.

"Sequestration of prospective jurors in this case would be impractical, especially since jury selection may take weeks and the prospective jurors would presumably be required to stay in their rooms all day," he wrote.

The judge granted a defense motion asking that a separate jury pool be created just for this case and that a list of prospective jurors be given to defense lawyers "as far in advance as possible."

His decisions offer a glimpse at the magnitude of the trial. Previously the defense has said it needed nine months to try the case, while the prosecution predicted a three-month long case. Samour has scheduled a four-month trial, beginning Feb. 3.

The prosecution has indicated there are more than 3,200 people on its potential witness list and more than 40,000 pages of discovery that both sides continue to wade through.

Samour has set aside the month of August to hear pre-trial arguments on scores of motions, including a change of venue, the barring of any potential witnesses -- except Holmes' parents -- from the courtroom, and the exclusion of much of the evidence gathered from Holmes' apartment and car as well as information on his computers, phone and bank records.

Samour has said he will also schedule another month in the fall for all motions related to the death penalty.

The judge, who took over the case in April, has been insistent that the case proceed on schedule.

Last week Samour accepted Holmes' plea of not guilty by reason of insanity, setting in motion mandatory psychiatric testing by doctors at Colorado Mental Health Institute to determine his mental condition. It has been estimated that those findings may not be ready until midsummer. The defense has said Holmes is mentally ill.

If Holmes is found to be insane or suffering from a mental defect, he cannot be put to death.

Source: Los Angeles Times, June 12, 2013

Thursday, May 9, 2013

New insanity plea may slow Colorado shooting case

James Holmes
James Holmes
The trial of the former grad student charged in the deadly Colorado movie theater shootings will likely be delayed weeks or months because he wants to change his plea to not guilty by reason of insanity.

James Holmes' attorneys filed the court papers Tuesday.

The judge handling the case will hear arguments from the defense and prosecutors about the request Monday. If the judge accepts the plea, Holmes would be sent to the state mental hospital where doctors would determine whether he was sane at the time of the shootings. If he's found to be insane, a jury still could find him guilty.

Tom Sullivan, whose son, Alex, was killed in the attack, said prosecutors have warned victims that an insanity plea would delay the case.

"We're just mortified that this is the process that we're going through, and we still have a long way to go," Sullivan said Tuesday. "I know justice will win out in the end."

Holmes, 25, is charged with more than 160 counts of murder and attempted murder in the July 20 attack in Aurora that killed 12 people and left 70 wounded or injured. Prosecutors said Holmes spent months buying guns and thousands of rounds of ammunition, donned police-style body armor and opened fire during a midnight screening of the latest Batman movie.

Prosecutors announced last month they would seek the death penalty at the trial now scheduled to start Feb. 3.

Holmes was widely expected to plead insanity, given the compelling evidence against him. But his lawyers delayed it for weeks, saying state laws on the death penalty and insanity overlap in ways that could severely hamper his ability to mount a defense against capital punishment.

One of their worries: If Holmes doesn't cooperate with the doctors, he could be barred from calling witnesses to testify about his mental condition during sentencing. That would make it nearly impossible for his lawyers to use his mental state as an argument against the death penalty.

"If you don't cooperate during the evaluation phase, you lose the right to call witnesses in your own behalf who could help convince a jury that your life should be spared," said Karen Steinhauser, an adjunct law professor and former prosecutor.

It's not clear how cooperation is defined, she said, and the question hasn't been tested in court since the laws were changed to their present form in the late 1990s.

Colorado law defines insanity as the inability to distinguish right from wrong, caused by a diseased or defective mind. The law specifically excludes depravity, "moral obliquity" and passion caused by anger, hatred or other emotions from being considered insanity.

Holmes' attorneys repeatedly have said in court hearings and documents that Holmes is mentally ill. He was being seen by a psychiatrist before the attack.

Holmes had sent the psychiatrist a notebook that media reports said included crude drawings of violence. Prosecutors might renew their request to see the notebook because state law gives them access to some medical records of defendants who plead not guilty by reason of insanity.

Prosecutors backed off their previous attempt to see the notebook when Holmes' lawyers said it was protected by doctor-patient privilege.

Source: Associated Press, May 9, 2013

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

Colorado: James Holmes to enter insanity plea

DENVER The man accused in the deadly Colorado theater shootings wants to change his plea to not guilty by reason of insanity, his lawyers said Tuesday.

The insanity plea was widely expected given the compelling evidence against Holmes, who is accused of opening fire July 20 in a crowded theater in the Denver suburb of Aurora. Twelve people were killed and 70 injured.

But his lawyers delayed entering an insanity plea for weeks, saying Colorado's insanity and death penalty laws overlapped in a way that could severely — and unconstitutionally — hamper his defense if he did plead insanity.

Holmes, 25, is charged with multiple counts of murder and attempted murder.

A judge in the case previously entered a standard not guilty plea for him. If a judge accepts the new plea, Holmes would be sent to the state mental hospital, where doctors would determine whether he was insane at the time of the shootings.

If the doctors do determine that Holmes was insane, a jury could still find him guilty.

Colorado law defines insanity as the inability to distinguish right from wrong, caused by a diseased or defective mind. The law specifically excludes depravity, "moral obliquity" or passion caused by anger or hatred from being considered insanity.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

Holmes' attorneys have said in court hearings and written in court documents that Holmes is mentally ill. He was being seen by a psychiatrist before the attack at a midnight screening of the latest Batman movie. Prosecutors say Holmes spent months buying guns and thousands of rounds of ammunition, donned police-style body armor and opened fire in the crowded theater.

Last month, prosecutors filed a court document listing aggravating factors they plan to raise in a possible death penalty phase of the trial. The factors included the death of 6-year-old Veronica Moser-Sullivan, the youngest of dead.

Prosecutors also said in the filing that the slayings were "especially heinous, cruel or depraved."

Source: AP, May 7, 2013

Monday, August 6, 2012

Colorado death penalty law unconstitutional, study contends

Colorado prosecutors could seek the death penalty in the vast majority of first-degree murder cases in the state but instead pursue it so infrequently that the state's capital-punishment system is unconstitutionally arbitrary, three law professors argue in a new study.

The conclusion could be earth-shaking for the Colorado criminal-justice system, at a time when prosecutors in Arapahoe County are deciding whether to pursue the death penalty against Aurora shooting suspect James Eagan Holmes. It could have more direct implications in the looming death-penalty sentencing hearing of Edward Montour — whose defense team initiated the study and included it in a motion.

"This is a groundbreaking study," said David Lane, one of Montour's defense attorneys.

Colorado law says a person must be convicted of first-degree murder, the most serious murder charge, and also meet an extra aggravating factor to be eligible for a death sentence. To conduct the study, the professors — in a first-of-its-kind effort in Colorado — assembled a list of all homicide cases between 1999 and 2010, then identified which of those cases were first-degree murder cases.


Source: The Denver Post, August 6, 2012

Monday, July 30, 2012

Colorado shooting: Suspect is charged, no word on death penalty

James Holmes had his 2nd court appearance Monday, as prosecutors formally filed the charges against him.

James Holmes is charged with 24 counts of murder, 2 each for the 12 people killed, and 116 counts of attempted murder, two each for the 58 injured. The 24-year-old is charged with a shooting at an Aurora, Colo. movie theater. Mr. Holmes, accused of opening fire in an Aurora, Colo., movie theater this month, killing 12 people and injuring 58, was charged with 142 counts, including 24 counts of 1st-degree murder, 116 counts of attempted murder, 1 count of possession of an explosive device, and 1 count of a sentence enhancer for a crime of violence.

He was charged twice for each of individuals killed. Colorado has several different classes of murder charges. One set of the charges refers to the fact that Holmes allegedly shot after deliberation. The 2nd set accuses him of killing “under circumstances evidencing an attitude of universal malice manifesting extreme indifference to the value of human life generally."

Holmes also waived his right to a preliminary hearing within 35 days.

The judge, William Sylvester, set a date for a preliminary hearing on Nov. 12. The next court hearing in the case will be Aug. 9, when the court will address a motion filed by several media outlets to unseal records in the case. A court order has kept virtually all case documents sealed, and a gag order has limited what attorneys, police officers, and others can say about the case.

Holmes made his 1st court appearance a week ago; this time, cameras and electronic equipment were barred from the room.

The charges were hardly a surprise, since Holmes’s involvement in the shooting, and the nature of the crimes, seem clear. At this point, most of the speculation centers on whether Colorado prosecutors will seek the death penalty for Holmes, and whether his defense team will be able to mount an insanity defense.

Capital punishment in Colorado exists, though it’s seldom used. In the past 45 years, 1 person has been executed in the state: Gary Lee Davis, in 1997, for rape and murder. (Between 1972 and 1984, the state had no death penalty.) 3 people now sit on death row.

But it also seems likely that prosecutors will seek the death penalty in Holmes’s case.

“If James Holmes isn’t executed,” former Denver prosecutor Craig Silverman told Reuters last week, “Colorado may as well throw away its death penalty law.”

To qualify for the death penalty, Colorado law says, 1 of 17 aggravating factors must be present in addition to 1st-degree murder.

Holmes “satisfies many of them,” says Sam Kamin, a law professor at Denver University. The factors include killing multiple people, killing in an especially heinous or cruel way, lying in wait for the victim, and creating a grave risk of death for 1 or more people in addition to the victim.

“What we don’t know yet, and can’t know, is what the case for mitigation will be,” adds Professor Kamin. The murders and aggravating factors will have to be balanced against that case – most likely centered on Holmes’s mental state, he says.

Conflicting reports have emerged in the past 10 days about Holmes’s mental state, and what information about the attack he may have mailed to a University of Denver psychiatrist.

Court papers last week confirmed that Holmes was seeing a psychiatrist, Lynne Fenton, at the university, but it’s unclear what she was treating him for. News outlets also claimed that Holmes had mailed a package to Dr. Fenton that contained a sort of journal describing plans for the attacks in detail.

However, prosecutors have said that much of the reported information was inaccurate, though they have confirmed that the notebook exists. It’s unclear exactly what the notebook contains, and when the package was received – whether it had been sitting in the mailroom since July 12, as Fox News originally reported, or whether it arrived there the Monday after the shooting.

Holmes’s defense team has filed a motion seeking to determine whether prosecutors or police were responsible for leaking information about the package to media. That had been expected to be discussed at Monday’s court hearing, but was postponed.

Evidence already appears to exist that the shooting was premeditated and that Holmes spent months planning it. In particular, authorities say that Holmes began buying bullets and ballistic gear online 4 months ago, and bought 4 weapons at Colorado stores in May and June.

Such planning may make an insanity defense more difficult to prove. Ultimately, though, the success of such a defense in Colorado would rest on whether Holmes’s lawyers can prove that he was unable to tell right from wrong when he committed the attack.

“We don’t know what was going on inside the mind of what is clearly a disturbed individual,” says Kamin, adding that prosecutors will need to show that Holmes is sane enough to stand trial and was sane enough at the time of the crime to be held accountable for it. They will also need to address any possible mitigating factors in his past.

“The evidence of [Holmes’s] involvement is without question,” Kamin says. “The case is going to ultimately come down to the mental state of this defendant.”

Source: AP, July 30, 2012

Monday, July 23, 2012

Colorado rampage: Legally, focus to be death penalty, expert says

Colorado shooting suspect James E. Holmes is expected to make his first appearance Monday morning in a court case that appears so clear-cut that at least one expert said the legal machinations could come down to one straightforward question:

If he's convicted, does the suspect deserve the death penalty?

"It is all but certain that prosecutors will file first-degree murder charges against Holmes in the Arapahoe County courthouse and that they'll seek the death penalty, criminal law expert Sam Kamin, a law professor at the University of Denver, told the Los Angeles Times.

Kamin predicts that as the case moves forward, points of dispute between the prosecution and the defense will revolve less on the question of what Holmes did or did not do on Friday morning, and more on his state of mind at the time.

"The evidence of his guilt is pretty strong," Kamin said. "The ... case for death is strong. So the question becomes, what is the case for mitigation? Is there a history of mental illness? Is there some instance of abuse in the past? Is there anything in the defendant's past that might make a jury willing to spare him?


Source: Los Angeles Times, July 22, 2012


If guilty, shooter likely to die in jail

The current hard-line district attorney for Arapahoe County is likely to seek capital charges for accused mass murderer James Holmes — but she will be out of office in five months and Colorado has not executed a single prisoner in nearly 35 years, experts note.

“If they do go for death it will cost tens of millions of dollars at a time when Colorado is shutting down elementary schools,” said University of Colorado Institute of Behavioral Science professor Michael L. Radelet, a leading authority on capital punishment. “If the death penalty were a deterrent, this guy would not have done (what he allegedly did) in the top death-penalty jurisdiction in the state.”

Under Colorado state law, a prosecutor must inform the court and the defendant that the state will seek capital punishment within 60 days of arraignment. Under the law, defendants are eligible for the death penalty if found guilty of first-degree murder with at least one aggravating factor, which can include ambushing a victim or using an explosive device.

Click here to read the full article

Source: BostonHerald.com, July 23, 2012


Colorado theater shooting suspect makes first court appearance

(CNN) -- The man accused of opening fire Friday in a packed movie theater in Aurora, Colorado, made his first court appearance Monday, giving the public its first look at the 24-year-old former doctoral candidate since his arrest.

James E. Holmes, his hair dyed various shades of red, looked downward, then straight ahead. He sat without blinking for long periods. At times, his eyes fluttered, then squeezed tight and reopened in a blank stare. Occasionally, his eyebrows arched, giving his face a mournful mien.

But the man who identified himself to police as "The Joker," dressed in a maroon jumpsuit over a white T-shirt, gave little indication that he was paying attention to the courtroom procedure that ensured he will be continue to be held without bond.

He is to be charged next Monday. Those charges are likely to include first-degree murder -- an offense that carries a possible death penalty, if he is convicted -- in the shooting deaths, given allegations over the weekend by police that there is evidence to suggest "calculation and deliberation" in the rampage.

Holmes is being held in connection with the early Friday shootings that left 12 dead and 58 wounded, and the subsequent discovery of his booby-trapped apartment, which authorities believe he rigged before leaving for the Century Aurora 16 multiplex.

Click here to read the full article

Source: CNN, July 23, 2012