Showing posts with label Videotaped execution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Videotaped execution. Show all posts

Friday, February 28, 2014

Power Punishment & Execution in Iran: An analysis of Foucault’s Discipline and Punishment applied to modern Iran

Karaj, Iran. - Feb 25, 2014. The condemned man breaks free of his
restraints and attempts to escape. The man is finally beaten into
submission by a gang of guards, and hanged.
Iran leads the world in per capita executions, and is one of the few countries which continues to publicly hang condemned individuals, creating a spectacle of terror in the street.

These executions carry political significance beyond the administration of supposed justice. They are in essence an abstraction of the political and judicial climate in Iran, in which a population is controlled through sheer violence and terror.

Michel Foucault’s analysis of 18th century punishment from his work Discipline and Punishment, and the ritual of the public execution in particular, evoke eerie parallels with modern day Iran.

“It is a ceremonial by which a momentarily injured sovereignty is reconstituted. It restores that sovereignty by manifesting it at its most spectacular. The public execution, however hasty and everyday, belongs to a whole series of great rituals in which power is eclipsed and restored… Its aim is not so much to re-establish a balance as to bring into play, as its extreme point, the dissymmetry between the subject who has dared to violate the law and the all-powerful sovereign who displays his strength.” (Michel Foucault)

Foucault also analyzes the role that the crowd plays in the execution, which provides an interesting explanation for why many Iranians choose to attend such a horrific spectacle.

“If the crowd gathered round the scaffold, it was not simply to witness the sufferings of the condemned man or to excite the anger of the executioner: it was also to hear an individual who had nothing more to lose curse the judges, the laws, the government and religion.” (Michel Foucault)

In the video (see below) the tension from the crowd can be heard throughout the man’s pleading, and it finally erupts in restrained jubilation when he briefly escapes. For many Iranians who do attend such an event, it is to glimpse the momentary defiance of the condemned man, and use the opportunity to express their own frustration with the regime.


Source: Hamid Yazdan Panah, "Attorney by day, Revolutionary at night", February 27, 2014

Video of the execution (Warning: Graphic and Disturbing Content):




Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Video Reignites Death Penalty Debate in China

Screenshot from the video
An online video purporting to show a public execution in the Chinese countryside has reignited debate about the death penalty in a country consistently singled out by human rights groups for executing vastly more people than any other.

The video, posted to the Sina Web portal Monday evening, is shot from a ridge overlooking a field and shows a group of onlookers watching as a line of police cars drives into a field, sirens blazing. The camera zooms in to show blurry images of what appear to be police removing a figure from a van wearing a white placard around the neck. Onlookers can be heard talking casually as the figure is led into a field, made to kneel and is shot in the head.

China Real Time was unable to verify the authenticity of the video (warning: graphic content). A short line of accompanying text said the footage was originally posted online prior to November 2012 but gave no other information. Onlookers, described in the video’s title as local villagers, speak a dialect found in the region of southwestern China’s Guizhou province.

The video had been viewed more than 2 million times and attracted thousands of comments by Tuesday evening.

Many of the reactions to Monday’s video reflected recent controversies, including one in April in which a local court overturned the death penalty for a man coerced into confessing to the murder of a woman in the eastern city of Hangzhou.

“The most important reason to get rid of the death penalty is that you can’t undo the damage done to those who are wrongly convicted,” wrote one commenter on the Sina video site.

Most of the criticism, however, focused not on the morality of the purported execution, but instead on the manner in which it was carried out – and on the reactions of the onlookers, many of whom can be heard talking casually and laughing before and after the shooting.


Source: Josh Chin, China Real Time Report, WSJ, August 13, 2013

Sunday, March 10, 2013

No more beheading? Saudi Arabia considers death row gunfire executions

AL ARABIYA - Saudi Arabia is looking into the possibility of implementing executions by shooting and not decapitation, Saudi daily “Al-Yawm” reported on Sunday.

The daily quoted sources as saying the suggestion was being studied by a commission formed from members of the ministries of interior and health, the prosecution office, general security office and the general directorate of prisons.

It added that the interior ministry authorized governors to implement executions by shooting until the “appropriate means” to carry out the punishment is finalized.

An announcement issued by the bureau of investigation and the prosecution said the means to implement the execution is up for the governor to decide when the means is not specified in the capital punishment verdict and that implementing execution by shooting is acceptable as long as it is not considered a legal violation.

If shooting is approved as a method to implement capital punishment, it would not be a first. A woman in the Saudi city of Ha’il was executed by being shot several years ago after she was found guilty of murdering her husband.

Source: al arabyia, March 10, 2013


Firing squads could replace executioners

Decision left to governors’ discretion as study is being carried out, report says

Manama: Saudi Arabia could soon replace beheading with a sword by a firing squad when carrying out the death penalty in public.

“A specialised committee made up of representatives from the ministries of interior, justice and health as well as the commissions of investigation and prosecution, the public security and the prison general directorate are looking into a study that replaces beheading by a firing squad,” sources told local Arabic daily Al Youm.

However, the country’s area governors have already been given the right to resort to the firing squad, the sources said.

“They can use their own discretion for the execution if the court does not specify how the capital punishment verdict is to be carried out,” the unidentified sources said. “Using the firing squad is not against Islam.”

According to the sources, the limited number of executioners by the sword was a major reason for the decision.

“They are not readily available everywhere and on some occasions, executions were marred by confusion as the executioner was late in showing up at the designated public place, causing confusion and sparking speculation and rumours,” the sources said.

Cases where a firing squad was used to carry out a capital execution included a woman who was found guilty of murdering her husband and hiding his body.

The woman was executed at the women’s prison in the northern city of Hael.

Her daughter, an accomplice in the murder, was sentenced to 15 years in jail.

Offences that could result in the death penalty in Saudi Arabia include murder, rape, armed robbery, repeated drug use, apostasy, false prophecy, witchcraft and sorcery.

According to reports, 15 people have been executed in Saudi Arabia this year.

Source: Gulf News, March 10, 2013


Public Execution in Saudi Arabia (Warning: Graphic Content)




Related videos (Warning: Graphic Content)
Apr 21, 2012
Riyadh: Saudi Arabia beheaded and crucified a Sudanese man in Riyadh on Friday after he was convicted of raping, robbing and killing a woman, the interior ministry announced. ... Source: GulfNews, AFP, April 20, 2012 ...

Sunday, July 1, 2012

Execution caught on video in Saudi

A Saudi newspaper has carried a film showing the beheading of a man convicted of raping a teenaged boy before murdering him in the heart of the desert.

The rare and shocking 51-second film showed the executioner bringing down his sword on the defendant’s head, which was severed in just a split of second.

The executioner, a tall man wearing traditional Saudi dishdasha (gown) and ghutra (head cover), then wiped blood off his sword with a piece of cloth after the beheading before waling away from the rapist’s headless body.

Sharq newspaper, which published the film, did not say how it was shot as filming of executions in the conservative Gulf kingdom is banned.

Newspapers said the unnamed defendant had been convicted of abducting the Saudi boy to a desolate desert area and raping him. He then forced him to lie on the sand and crushed him with his four-wheel car.

Warning: Graphic Content



Source: Emirates24/7, June 3, 2012

Related videos:
Apr 21, 2012
Riyadh: Saudi Arabia beheaded and crucified a Sudanese man in Riyadh on Friday after he was convicted of raping, robbing and killing a woman, the interior ministry announced. ... Source: GulfNews, AFP, April 20, 2012 ...

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Saudis behead, crucify Sudanese man for robbery, rape and murder

Riyadh: Saudi Arabia beheaded and crucified a Sudanese man in Riyadh on Friday after he was convicted of raping, robbing and killing a woman, the interior ministry announced.

Abdulrahman Zine Elabidine "broke into a house strangling its owner to death while she was asleep."

He also raped her and stole 165,000 riyals ($44,000/33,000 euros) as well as gold jewellery, said the statement carried by state news agency SPA.

Arson

He then set the house on fire.

His beheading took to 20 the total number of executions in the conservative kingdom so far this year, according to an AFP tally based on official reports.

Under the AFP count, at least 76 people were beheaded in 2011, while rights group Amnesty International put the number of executions last year at 79.

The death penalty in Saudi Arabia applies strict Sharia (Islamic) law for a wide range of offences including rape, apostasy, armed robbery, homosexuality and drug trafficking, as well as murder.

Source: GulfNews, AFP, April 20, 2012


VIDEOS OF THE EXECUTION AND CRUCIFIXION:
Public beheading and "crucifixion" on scaffolding of a Sudanese convict in Saudi Arabia in the capital Riyadh, April 20th, 2012. Riyadh has one of the lowest crime rates in the world and the horrific nature of the man's crimes caused outrage in the kingdom. His execution was watched by thousands of citizens.


Video 1: Arrival of the convicted man to the execution arena in a police convoy




Video 2: The beheading (Warning: Graphic Content)




Video 3: The "crucifixion" (Warning: Graphic Content)


Thursday, August 18, 2011

Virginia to carry out experimental execution with new drug today, Florida set to follow suit

Today Virginia is set to execute for the first time using an untested new lethal injection drug, in a move which could soon be followed by Florida unless the state’s Supreme Court overturns the ruling of a lower court.

Jerry Jackson is expected to be executed in Greensville, VA this evening using pentobarbital, which recently replaced the more widely used anaesthetic sodium thiopental. The new drug is untested for the purposes of anaesthesia in humans, and until recently was best known for its use in putting down animals.

Meanwhile, a decision is expected imminently from the Florida Supreme Court on the state’s plan to use the same drug to execute Manuel Valle – a Cuban with close ties to Spain – despite serious concerns that doing so could result in extreme pain and suffering for the prisoner. Oral arguments on the lethal injection issue had been scheduled to be heard next week, but were yesterday cancelled by the Supreme Court.

The state of Georgia’s first execution using pentobarbital was ‘clearly botched’ according to Harvard anaesthesiologist Dr David Waisel, who highlighted reports that the eyes of the prisoner, Roy Willard Blankenship, remained open throughout the process. The execution went so badly that a Georgia judge took the unprecedented step of ordering a subsequent lethal injection to be videotaped to provide evidence on whether it constituted ‘cruel and unusual punishment’.

Despite this, a number of other states are planning to push ahead with their own ‘experimental’ execution programmes, using the same drug. The Florida circuit court, in a move that is being appealed by Mr Valle’s lawyers, even rejected eyewitness evidence of the Georgia execution submitted by those who had been present, hearing only the version of events provided by State’s witnesses and Georgia corrections officials. The circuit court also excused Florida Department of Corrections officials from having to attend, although they had been called by Mr Valle’s lawyers.

Earlier this week, Montana became the latest state to announce that it was making the switch to pentobarbital.

Reprieve investigator Katherine Bekesi said:

“We are starting to see an epidemic of states carrying out experimental executions using untested drugs. Florida in particular already has a grim history of botched executions – it is crucial that they think again before subjecting Manuel Valle to what could be an excruciatingly painful death.”

Source: Reprieve, August 18, 2011

Related article:

May 10, 2011
Virginia to switch execution drugs amid shortage. Virginia will join other states that are switching the sedative used in lethal injections because of a nationwide shortage of the drug, officials said Monday ...

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Experimental execution drug set to be used for first time in three US states

Three more death penalty states are preparing to adopt a new lethal injection drug this summer, despite evidence that it has caused botched executions and intense suffering to prisoners across the USA.

Delaware plans to use the untested barbiturate pentobarbital – in place of the anaesthetic sodium thiopental, which has been hit by domestic shortages – for the first time this Friday [July 29] in the execution of Robert Jackson. Virginia will use the same drug in the execution of Jerry Jackson on August 18.

Florida had planned to execute Manuel Valle, a Cuban with close ties to Spain, using pentobarbital on August 2, but the State Supreme Court issued a stay until September due to concerns over whether use of the drug could lead to unnecessary pain and suffering.

The concerns stem from reports of a number of botched executions using pentobarbital, notably that of Roy Willard Blankenship in Georgia earlier this year, who suffered a "thrashing, jerking death," during which his eyes never closed. Harvard anaesthesiologist Dr David Waisel testified in a sworn affidavit that Mr Blankenship must have "suffered greatly" during the process.

As a result, a recent execution in Georgia using pentobarbital has been videotaped on the orders of a judge, to assess whether it violates the Constitutional ban on "cruel and unusual punishment". This lends the process to an even greater appearance of human experimentation.

Reprieve investigator Kat Bekesi said: "It seems incredible that the 'thrashing' deaths of prisoners and the opinion of medical experts are not enough to persuade states that they should not be trying out experimental drugs in their execution chambers. The stay of execution in Florida is a small step in the right direction, but in the longer term, state authorities will need to think hard about whether they want yet another badly botched execution on their conscience."

1. For more information please contact Donald Campbell or Katherine O'Shea at Reprieve's Press Office: donald.campbell@reprieve.org.uk / +44 (0) 20 7427 1082 / (0) 7791 755 415 / katherine.oshea@reprieve.org.uk / +44 (0) 20 7427 1099 / (0) 7931 592 674.
2. Reprieve-assisted prisoner Manuel Valle is a Cuban national with Spanish links, who has now been on death row for 33 years. He has been denied proper clemency proceedings, and (similarly to the recent case of Humberto Leal in Texas) did not receive the consular assistance to which he was entitled. His execution has been stayed until September 1st to allow a full hearing on the matter to take place. Reprieve is assisting Mr Valle as part of our EC project.
3. An eyewitness from the Associated Press has described the "thrashing, jerking death of Roy Willard Blankenship" during which "his eyes never closed". The full text of Dr David Waisel's affidavit on Roy Blankenship's inadequate anaesthesia can be found on Reprieve's website.

Source: Reprieve, July 28, 2011

Sunday, July 24, 2011

Video of a Lethal Injection Reopens Questions on the Privacy of Executions

As Andrew Grant DeYoung died by lethal injection in a prison in Jackson, Ga., on Thursday night, a video camera watched silently.

For decades in the United States, what goes on inside the execution chamber has been largely shrouded from public view, glimpsed only through the accounts of journalists and other witnesses.

But the video recording of Mr. DeYoung’s death, the first since 1992, has once again raised the possibility that executions might be made available for all to see. In the process, it has reignited a widespread debate about how bright a light to shine on one of the most secretive corners of the criminal justice system.

Legal experts say the decision by Judge Bensonetta Tipton Lane of Fulton County Superior Court to allow the taping in Mr. DeYoung’s case opens the way for defense lawyers across the country to push for the video documentation of other executions. And it is inevitable, many experts believe, that some of those recordings will make their way onto television or even YouTube, with or without the blessings of a court.

Brian Kammer, a defense lawyer who argued for allowing Mr. DeYoung’s execution to be recorded, said that documenting the death was essential because of the controversy over the drugs used in lethal injections.

“We’ve had three botched lethal injections in Georgia prior to Mr. DeYoung, and we thought it was time to get some hard evidence,” Mr. Kammer said.

After Mr. DeYoung’s execution, the video was sealed and sent to a judge’s chambers for safekeeping, and Mr. Kammer, for one, said he hoped it stayed hidden. “It’s a horrible thing that Andrew DeYoung had to go through, and it’s not for the public to see that,” he said.

But Douglas Berman, a professor of law at Ohio State University who commented on the issue on his blog, Sentencing and Law Policy, said, “I think it would be foolish for anybody who is authorizing or supervising the videotaping of executions to assume that it will always remain sealed and unseen.” Mr. Berman added, “Somewhere, somehow, at some point, this will become publicly accessible.”


Source: The New York Times, July 23, 2011

Related articles:

Jul 22, 2011
Andrew DeYoung was put to death by lethal injection Thursday night at the state prison in Jackson after courts turned down his appeals. The 37-year-old was pronounced dead at 8:04 p.m. ...
Jul 21, 2011
DeYoung had been due to die by injection at 7 p.m. Wednesday at the Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Prison in Jackson. But amid last-minute court activity at the state and federal level, Department of Corrections ...
Jul 21, 2011
If the lethal injection of Andrew Grant DeYoung is carried out as scheduled at 7 p.m. Thursday, it would be the nation's first known video recording of an execution in nearly two decades. Superior Court Judge Bensonetta ...
Jul 21, 2011
The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals is reviewing a ruling issued earlier Wednesday by U.S. District Judge Steve Jones, who concluded that DeYoung failed to show the state's use of pentobarbital as part of a lethal ...

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Georgia executes Andrew DeYoung with video cameras rolling

Andrew DeYoung
JACKSON, Ga. — A Georgia man convicted of killing his parents and sister has been executed after the courts allowed what was likely the nation's first video-recorded execution in almost two decades.

Andrew DeYoung was put to death by lethal injection Thursday night at the state prison in Jackson after courts turned down his appeals. The 37-year-old was pronounced dead at 8:04 p.m.

The execution was set for Wednesday but was pushed back a day as the state tried to block the video recording. It was requested by another death row inmate seeking evidence of problems with Georgia's reconfigured lethal injection procedure.

A video camera and a camera operator were in place for the lethal injection.

No other death penalty states allow filming of executions, and tonight’s recording will be the first in almost two decades.

Judge Lane has ordered that the tape be immediately handed over to court after the execution. It will then be reviewed by a defense expert who will also oversee DeYoung’s autopsy.

Source: AP, July 21, 2011


Georgia killer Andrew DeYoung's execution filmed

A judge in the US state of Georgia has allowed the execution of a convicted murderer to be filmed at the request of another death row inmate.

Andrew DeYoung, convicted of murdering his parents and sister, was executed by lethal injection on Thursday night.

Lawyers for the second condemned man said filming DeYoung's execution would show a chemical used in the lethal cocktail causes unnecessary suffering.

They say the drug does not adequately sedate the inmate and can cause pain.

The chemical in question, pentobarbital, is commonly used to put down animals.

No final prayer

Several US states have switched to using pentobarbital because of a nationwide shortage of the more traditionally used lethal drug, sodium thiopental.

DeYoung, 37, was convicted of stabbing his parents and 14-year-old sister to death in 1993 over an inheritance.

His last meal request was for pizza, grape juice, vanilla ice cream and all-fruit strawberry preserves.

When asked to make a final statement, DeYoung said he was "sorry to everyone I hurt". He declined the offer of a final prayer.

When the three-drug injection began, DeYoung blinked and swallowed for about two minutes, then his eyes closed and he became still, according to the Associated Press news agency.

He was pronounced dead at 20:04 EST on Thursday (00:04 GMT on Friday).

On Monday, a Fulton County Georgia judge ruled that death row inmate Gregory Walker's lawyers may have a videotape of DeYoung's execution.

Prosecutors had objected to the proposed recording.

Walker has filed a lawsuit challenging his own death sentence on the grounds that the state's lethal injection drugs illegally cause pain and suffering.

He was sentenced to death in 2005 for the murder of a 23-year-old hotel maid who had stolen drugs and cash from him as he slept in a hotel room.

The BBC's Peter Bowes in Los Angeles says the only other instance of a similar recording of an execution was in California in 1992 as part of a challenge against the use of the gas chamber.

California later abolished that method of execution.

Source: BBC News, July 22, 2011


US murderer executed on camera

Lawyers for death row inmate Gregory Walker argued that recording DeYoung's execution would provide critical evidence in his appeal about the effects of pentobarbital, which is the sedative now being used as the first step in Georgia's injection procedure.

Walker's lawyers want to show that pentobarbital does not adequately sedate the inmate and could cause pain and suffering.

In court filings, state prosecutors argued that having a videographer in the execution chamber would jeopardise security. They also said creating a video came with the risk of it being distributed.

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Bensonetta Tipton Lane allowed the recording to take place, and that decision was allowed to stand by the Georgia Supreme Court. The video will be kept under seal by the court.

Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal said it was up to the courts to decide the matter, though he told reporters following a news conference Thursday he had "grave reservations" about videotaping executions.

Defence lawyers countered that the state corrections department has long allowed cameras to film parts of the prison, although they acknowledged the state has never before allowed an execution to be recorded.

"It is simply disingenuous to assert that video recording of Mr. DeYoung's execution constitutes a fundamental threat to the security of the institution," attorneys wrote in the filing.

The use of pentobarbital became an issue in Georgia after Roy Blankenship's June 23 execution.

Blankenship was the first Georgia prisoner put to death using the sedative pentobarbital as the lead-off drug in the state's lethal three-drug combination.

An Associated Press reporter witnessed Blankenship jerking his head several times during the procedure, looking at the injection sites in his arms and muttering after the pentobarbital was injected into his veins.

Death penalty critics said Blankenship's unusual movements were proof that Georgia shouldn't have used pentobarbital to sedate him before injecting pancuronium bromide to paralyze him and then potassium chloride to stop his heart.

In seeking a stay, DeYoung's attorneys argued that using pentobarbital could cause DeYoung to suffer. But those arguments were rejected by the courts.

Source: The Telegraph, July 22, 2011

Related articles:

14 hours ago
DeYoung had been due to die by injection at 7 p.m. Wednesday at the Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Prison in Jackson. But amid last-minute court activity at the state and federal level, Department of Corrections ...
Jul 21, 2011
The Georgia Supreme Court's 4-3 decision rejected an appeal by Andrew Grant DeYoung, who claimed the state's plan to use a new lethal injection drug would cause him needless pain and suffering. In a separate opinion, ...
Jul 20, 2011
Superior Court Judge Bensonetta Tipton Lane, in an order signed Monday, said the taping shall occur so long as condemned killer Andrew Grant DeYoung does not object to it. She also ordered the videotape, once compiled, ...
3 hours ago
If the lethal injection of Andrew Grant DeYoung is carried out as scheduled at 7 p.m. Thursday, it would be the nation's first known video recording of an execution in nearly two decades. Superior Court Judge Bensonetta ...

Georgia judge clears way for video of execution

Andrew DeYoung
JACKSON, Ga. (AP) — A Georgia judge has cleared the way to record video of a planned execution after rejecting the state attorney general's effort to stop it.

If the lethal injection of Andrew Grant DeYoung is carried out as scheduled at 7 p.m. Thursday, it would be the nation's first known video recording of an execution in nearly two decades.

Superior Court Judge Bensonetta Tipton Lane said in the ruling Thursday that state attorneys had failed to prove the video would interfere with DeYoung's execution.

Attorney General spokeswoman Lauren Kane said the office could not appeal the judge's order.

The Georgia Supreme Court also denied a second petition by DeYoung to halt his execution. The U.S. Supreme Court denied a stay on Wednesday night, though his attorneys have asked it to reconsider.

Source: The Associated Press, July 21, 2011

DeYoung's Execution Delayed by Day

Andrew Grant DeYoung in 1995
Northeast Cobb killer Andrew Grant DeYoung received an extra 24 hours of life when the state postponed his execution Wednesday.

DeYoung had been due to die by injection at 7 p.m. Wednesday at the Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Prison in Jackson. But amid last-minute court activity at the state and federal level, Department of Corrections officials announced around 10 p.m. that the execution was delayed until 7 p.m. Thursday, the Marietta Daily Journal, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution and WABE-FM reported.

Each of those media outlets had a reporter in Jackson to witness the execution.

Attorney General Sam Olens did not disclose why the execution was postponed.

But Olens did say the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision not to stop the execution didn’t come until two hours after the scheduled lethal injection, the MDJ reported.

The Georgia Supreme Court voted 4-3 not to stay the execution, the AJC reported, and the state justices also decided to uphold a Fulton County judge’s order that DeYoung’s death be videotaped.

The videotaping order came at the request of another death-row prisoner. At issue is whether Georgia’s new mix of drugs in its lethal injection allows a person to suffer pain before dying.

It’s not clear whether the videotaping order contributed to the delay, but it’s something new for the state prison. The Associated Press reported that DeYoung’s execution would be the first videotaped in the United States since a California execution in 1992. That tape was destroyed.

DeYoung had a final meal of pizza, breadsticks, all-fruit strawberry preserves, Concord grape juice and vanilla ice cream Wednesday afternoon. That last meal will not be repeated today, the MDJ reported.

DeYoung is being executed for the 1993 murders of his parents and younger sister at their Northeast Cobb home when he was a 19-year-old college student.

Source: NortheastCobbPatch, July 21, 2011

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Georgia court allows taping of execution, denies stay

Andrew Grant DeYoung
JACKSON, Ga. (AP) - Georgia's top court on Wednesday narrowly rejected a death row inmate's last-ditch appeal to block his execution and cleared the way for what could be the nation's first videotaped execution in almost two decades.

The Georgia Supreme Court's 4-3 decision rejected an appeal by Andrew Grant DeYoung, who claimed the state's plan to use a new lethal injection drug would cause him needless pain and suffering. In a separate opinion, the court unanimously upheld a county judge's ruling that the 7 p.m. execution could be videotaped and kept under seal.

DeYoung was sentenced to die for the 1993 slayings of his parents and teenage sister in suburban Atlanta, barring intervention by federal appeals courts.

The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals is reviewing a ruling issued earlier Wednesday by U.S. District Judge Steve Jones, who concluded that DeYoung failed to show the state's use of pentobarbital as part of a lethal three-drug combination violated the constitutional ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

The request to videotape the execution was filed by Brian Kammer, an attorney for death row inmate Gregory Walker. He said he wanted to preserve "the best evidence possible" for his challenge to the state's method of lethal injection.

Prosecutors asked the court to reverse the ruling, worrying that it could set a troubling precedent. But justices said they dismissed the challenge because the state failed to follow proper appeal procedure.

Kammer said lawyers believe the only other time an execution was videotaped was in California in 1992, when lawyers were challenging the use of gas as a method of execution. That is also the understanding of Richard Dieter, executive director of the Washington-based Death Penalty Information Center, which opposes capital punishment.

Dieter said the tape of the California execution was later destroyed and he was aware of no other court-ordered videotaped execution. Dieter said Timothy McVeigh's 2001 execution at a federal prison in Indiana was broadcast on closed-circuit TV to a gathering of survivors and victims' family members in Oklahoma City, but there was no indication it was taped.

In seeking a stay, DeYoung's attorneys argued using pentobarbital would cause DeYoung to suffer based partly on accounts of Roy Blankenship's June 23 execution. An Associated Press reporter witnessed Blankenship jerking his head several times during the procedure, looking at the injection sites in his arms and muttering after the pentobarbital was injected into his veins.

It was the first time the drug was used in Georgia. Amid a national shortage of sodium thiopental, states have been turning to pentobarbital to carry out executions. The drug has now been used this year to put at least 18 inmates to death in eight states.

Death penalty critics have said Blankenship's unusual movements were proof that Georgia shouldn't have used pentobarbital to sedate him before injecting pancuronium bromide to paralyze him and then potassium chloride to stop his heart. State prosecutors have raised questions about the timeline cited in the AP's account and argued Blankenship's movements occurred before the sedative took hold.

The state attorney general's office has said adequate safeguards are in place to prevent needless suffering, including a consciousness check before the second and third drugs are administered. The consciousness check was used for the first time in Blankenship's execution.

In addition, prosecutors argued the courts have held that a certain amount of pain is acceptable during an execution.

DeYoung was convicted of stabbing to death his mother, father and 14-year-old sister, Sarah. Prosecutors said DeYoung, then a student at Kennesaw State University, killed his family as part of a plot to gain control of his parents' money so he could start a business.

Authorities said DeYoung cut the telephone wires of his family's home in the middle of the night. He then stabbed his mother repeatedly while she was sleeping upstairs, then also stabbed to death his father and sister, prosecutors said. A brother sleeping downstairs escaped after hearing the commotion and ran to a neighbor's house for help.

Source: AP, July 20, 2011

Georgia: Planned execution puts drugs under new scrutiny

Georgia is scheduled tonight [July 20, 2011] to execute a second death row inmate since resuming lethal injections last month, but questions linger about whether the state’s new three-drug cocktail inflicts pain as it works.

Since Georgia’s electric chair was declared unconstitutional a decade ago, death penalty opponents have repeatedly attacked lethal injection, contending it is cruel and unusual punishment. The state’s recent switch to the sedative pentobarbital -- the first of three drugs used in the process -- prompted new attacks.

Witnesses to the June 23 execution of Roy Willard Blankenship, put to death for a 1978 rape and murder of a Savannah woman, gave mixed accounts of what happened. An Associated Press reporter wrote that Blankenship’s eyes remained open after the pentobarbital was injected and that the inmate jerked his head from side to side, grimaced and appeared to cry out. The publisher of the Claxton Enterprise has reported he saw Blankenship show discomfort and mouth “ow,” but that Blankenship did not appear to be suffering or in agony.


Source: acj.com, July 20, 2011


Judge orders videotaping of scheduled execution

Andrew Grant DeYoung
at his 1995 trial
A Fulton County judge has ordered that an execution scheduled for Wednesday be videotaped after hearing claims from attorneys that the state’s new lethal injection procedure may cause needless pain and suffering.

Superior Court Judge Bensonetta Tipton Lane, in an order signed Monday, said the taping shall occur so long as condemned killer Andrew Grant DeYoung does not object to it. She also ordered the videotape, once compiled, be submitted immediately to the court under seal.

DeYoung is scheduled to be executed at 7 p.m. Wednesday for the 1993 murders of his parents and his sister. Cobb County prosecutors said DeYoung stabbed them to death because he expected to get an inheritance the couple put towards a business opportunity.

DeYoung's lawyers were in federal court most of Tuesday trying to persuaded a judge to stop the execution until there was more information about how well pentobarbital anesthetizes an inmate before the next two drugs are administered -- the paralytic pancuronium and the potassium chloride that stopped his heart. U.S. District Judge Steve Jones did not immediately render a decision based on Tuesday's hearing.

The argument concerns efforts by Georgia -- and other states -- to find an alternative to sodium thiopental when the drug manufacturer stopped making it. Georgia and other states replaced thiopental with pentobarbital, commonly used to euthanize dogs and cats.

Death penalty opponents and the maker of the maker of pentobarbital say the anesthetic is unsafe for executions.

Lane's order, however, did not involve DeYoung's appeal. Instead it concerned another Death Row inmate, Gregory Walker.

“This court is not making a finding that any executions have been ‘botched,’ but is finding that there are many facts relevant to the constitutionality of the state’s execution process that it has refrained from disclosing to those who seek to challenge it,” Lane wrote.

The merits of the execution, Lane added, were not before her, only the question as to whether Walker can gather evidence for his claim.

Lane said that the type of evidence being sought “is of a type that is likely to be relevant to a determination regarding whether the method of execution … violates federal and state constitutional restrictions against inflicting cruel and unusual punishment.”

DeYoung's lawyers argued Tuesday that it does.

Dr. David Waisel, an expert called by DeYoung's lawyers, said in court Tuesday descriptions of the execution of the man most recently put to death in Georgia suggest it was unconstitutionally painful because pentobarbital is inadequate and unsafe.

Some witnesses to Roy Blankenship's execution for the murder of an elderly Savannah woman 33 years ago said the 55-year-old jerked his head several times early in the procedure but his movement and breathing slowed within minutes. Prison officials say Blankenship’s movements occurred before the sedative took hold.

But Waisel said in court witnesses also had observed similar reactions when Eddie Duvall Powell was executed in Alabama on June 16 and when Johnnie Baston was put to death in Ohio on March 10. He said the movement in the Georgia and Alabama executions came because they felt pain when the other drugs were administered. Ohio uses on pentobarbital in its executions.

“Pentobarbital has not been scientifically tested as a free-standing anesthesia on humans; the test Georgia conducted on the first inmate executed using pentobarbital, Roy Blankenship, resulted in his needless suffering,” a court filing said.

Source: acj.com, July 19, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.