Showing posts with label Physical abuse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Physical abuse. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

In Saudi Arabia, Indonesian maids are on death row for sorcery

JAKARTA, Indonesia — After 10 years in a Saudi prison, Ati Abeh Inan finally made it back to Indonesia last month. On death row for “casting a magic spell on her employer and his family,” she was pardoned by King Abdullah.

Needless to say, she was very lucky.

About 40 other Indonesian domestic workers still face potential death sentences in the Saudi kingdom. They’ve been convicted of witchcraft, sorcery or of murdering their employers. Five have exhausted all judicial appeals.

Migrant Care, an Indonesian NGO following their cases, says most of the convicts acted in self-defense against sexual or physical abuse.

For years, rights groups have reported the horror stories of maids in Saudi Arabia.

Nisha Varia, a Human Rights Watch senior researcher who has interviewed domestic workers in Saudi Arabia says she has spoken to women “whose employers beat them, threatened to kill them and dump them in the trash, compared them to animals.” They’ve alleged rape, harassment, mistreatment, torture, and having their bodies burned with irons and boiling water. Some have had nails hammered into their hands.

Behind the closed doors of private homes, the fate of the one to two million domestic workers in Saudi Arabia depends solely on their employers’ will. Migrant Care's director Anis Hidayah explains they are much more at risk than other migrant workers because they’re extremely isolated. “It's very difficult to monitor the situation in the houses of employers,” she says.

In addition to the abuse, human rights groups have described slave-like conditions.

Domestic workers often work from dawn to late at night, sometimes up to 100 hours a week, with no day off. They often lack adequate food, and they sleep in the kitchen or in tiny rooms if they’re lucky. They are not entitled to overtime pay or compensation in the case of work related injury.

And they’re not allowed to resign.

The “kafala” system of sponsorship means a worker’s visa and stay is tied to the one person who gives them a job and a house. This creates an opportunity for exploitation and abuse, experts say.

In 2011, after one of its nationals was executed for killing her allegedly abusive employer, Indonesia decided it had had enough. Its embassy in Riyadh, which had been seeking clemency for the domestic worker, wasn’t even notified until after her decapitation. Jakarta called it “unacceptable,” against “norms and manners” of international relations. The president, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, announced a moratorium on sending domestic workers to Saudi Arabia.

Three years later, the ban might soon be reversed.

At the end of February, the two countries signed a “historic and remarkable” agreement, as Indonesian minister of manpower and transmigration, Muhaimin Iskandar, described it. Indonesian domestic workers in Saudi Arabia will now have access to very basic rights.

They will no longer be deprived of their passports, and will be allowed to communicate with their families, get paid monthly, and have some time off.

Calls for clarifications on how the agreement will be implemented and monitored are yet to be answered.

Until last year, domestic workers were completely excluded from Saudi labor law. In July 2013, the government introduced some new labor regulations for domestic workers, including an outrageous limit of 15 hours of work a day. Yet while maids are considered the most vulnerable group among migrant workers, they are still not granted the same protection as others.

“There needs to be strong regulations that set the standard for what treatment should look like. If you ask average employers in Saudi Arabia, they think it’s acceptable to take the domestic worker’s passport because they’ve paid a lot of money to recruit her,” says Nisha Varia. “There needs to be a change in the norms and regulations to make it clear that it doesn't mean that they then can completely control the domestic worker.”

According to Migrant Rights, 30 to 50 maids report abuse and exploitation every day at the center for housemaid affairs in Riyadh, which deals with runaway maids and those who refuse to work for their sponsors. The center coordinates with the domestic workers' sponsors and embassies to solve the problem, but only accommodates them for a maximum of a week, after which they're deported if no solution is found.

Those who dare submit official complaints for mistreatment face the risk of employers filing counter-claims of witchcraft or adultery, which are severely punished in Saudi Arabia.

According to Indonesian authorities, some 6.5 million Indonesians work overseas, mainly as domestic workers in the Middle East, Hong-Kong, Singapore and Malaysia. Cases of abuse are not limited to Saudi Arabia. In January, the story of Erwiana Sulistyaningsih, a 23 year-old maid who came back to Indonesia on a wheelchair after having been tortured for months by her employers in Hong-Kong, sparked outrage across Indonesia. The president called Erwiana Sulistyaningsih’s father to tell him he was “angry.”

But Indonesian officials are less inclined to condemn the fact that the country’s estimated 2.6 million maids working in Indonesia are also still in legal limbo and facing daily abuse.

“There is nothing protecting domestic workers at the moment. There is no regulation on their working hours, no standard for wages or days-off,” says Albert Bonasahat, from the International Labor Organization office in Jakarta. He says it makes it harder for Indonesian delegations to negotiate better conditions for their workers overseas. “When they ask for a weekly day-off for example, the destination country will reply, well, do you have such regulation in Indonesia?”

Amnesty International recently accused Indonesia of “dragging its feet” on a domestic workers law, stuck in parliament since 2010. The parliament only has a few months to make a change until the bill expires in September this year.

Source: MinnPost, March 17, 2014

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Mississippi death penalty case before US high court

The U.S. Supreme Court will consider Feb. 21 whether to hear an appeal from a woman on Mississippi's death row who is seeking a new trial in the 1999 slaying of her husband based on claims that she was abused.

Court officials say a decision could be announced shortly after the court conference.

Michelle Byrom argues her original lawyer failed to present evidence of physical and sexual abuse at the hands of her husband. Prosecutors say the abuse issue was raised at her trial and denied.

Byrom, now 56, was convicted of capital murder in 2000. In a rare move, she asked the judge, instead of the jury, to decide her sentence. The judge sentenced her to death.

State and federal courts have denied Byrom's appeals for a new trial.

Source: Biloxi Sun Herald, Feb. 3, 2014

Thursday, January 30, 2014

Naeem Williams Trial Could Bring First Death Penalty To Hawaii

Jury selection is underway for the 1st death penalty trial in the state of Hawaii.

Capital punishment was abolished in Hawaii in 1957, but the U.S. attorney's office is seeking the federal death penalty in the trial of Naeem Williams who is accused of beating his 5-year-old daughter to death in 2005.

Williams, an Army specialist who was stationed in Hawaii at the time, had obtained custody of his daughter, Talia, only 7 months before her death. The 2 lived in base housing on Wheeler Army Airfield along with Williams's wife, Delilha Williams, and prosecutors claim the young girl endured months of abuse at the hands of both caregivers.

In July of 2005, Talia died from blunt-force trauma to her head, and an autopsy report showed she suffered from "battered child syndrome."

Court documents reveal that Talia's room had no mattress, no blankets and no furniture, and that "blood spatters could be seen throughout the Williams residence." Talia's room had "blood splatters on the walls ... caused by Naeem Williams 'whipping' Talia with his belt on Talia's back 'bursting open' the scars."

Williams also allegedly duct-taped Talia to a bed post on more than 1 occasion, covering her eyes and mouth with duct tape - "so she couldn't scream" or see - and then whipped the young girl with a belt "for more an hour at a time."

Delilha Williams told FBI agents that she had been "stomping on Talia," before the girl died, telling her that she hated Talia, that she was stupid and that she had ruined Delilha's life.

Delilha pleaded guilty to 1st-degree murder and is currently serving a sentence of 20 years. She is expected to testify against Spc. Williams.

Talia's biological mother, Tarshia Williams, won the right to sue the U.S. Army in 2010 for failing to protect her daughter after obvious signs of abuse. The Army usually handles instances of child abuse through the military police and the Army Family Advocacy Program, but, according to court documents, even an Army major general noted that, in Talia's case, there was "a series of missed opportunities to potentially prevent the death of the child."

Military police and social workers were alerted about possible abuse at the Williams home four times in the 6 months leading up to Talia's death.

Source: Huffington Post, January 30, 2014

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Mississippi death penalty case before U.S. Supreme Court

The U.S. Supreme Court will consider Jan. 10 whether to hear an appeal from a woman on Mississippi's death row who is seeking a new trial in the slaying of her husband based on claims that she was abused.

Court officials say a decision could be announced shortly after the court conference.

Michelle Byrom says she deserves a new trial because her original lawyer failed to present what could have been evidence of physical and sexual abuse by her husband.

Prosecutors argue the abuse issue was raised at her trial and rejected by the sentencing judge.

Byrom was convicted of capital murder in 2000. She was sentenced to death.

Court records show Edward Byrom Sr., an electrician, was shot June 4, 1999, at the couple's home in Iuka.

Source: Associated Press, December 18, 2013

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Terrance Williams loses bid for clemency, faces state's first execution in 13 years

HARRISBURG - Condemned Philadelphia killer Terrance Williams lost in a bid for clemency Monday when the state Board of Pardons did not unanimously recommend his case for consideration by Gov. Corbett.

Nevertheless, advocates for Williams - scheduled for execution Oct. 3 for the 1984 murder of a Mount Airy man, Amos Norwood - noted that three of the five board members voted to spare Williams' life, and some suggested that Corbett might not be barred from commuting his sentence to life in prison without parole even without a unanimous recommendation.

Monday's session was the first clemency hearing in a death-penalty case in 50 years. Pennsylvania voters in 1997 amended the state constitution to require the board's vote for clemency to be unanimous instead of a majority. But advocates suggested after the hearing that because the amendment was spurred by the commutation of a life sentence, the change might not apply to a death-penalty case.

The board granted the Williams case three times its usual 30 minutes to enable defense attorneys and two lawyers for the Philadelphia District Attorney's Office to argue their positions.

The board then deliberated in private for about 35 minutes before returning to the ornate Supreme Court chamber in the Capitol to vote.


Source: Philly.com, Sept. 18, 2012


Push to shut down Pennsylvania's death row focuses on man who killed his sexual abuser

Terrance Williams
Unless the state's Board of Pardons prevents it, Pennsylvania is about to execute Terrance "Terry" Williams, 46, who was sent to death row for the 1984 murder of Amos Norwood, a man who had sexually abused him as a child. Months earlier, Williams had killed another man who had raped him. Gov. Tom Corbett set an execution date of October 3, which would make Williams the 1st person put to death in Pennsylvania in 13 years.

Prosecutors characterized Williams as a serial killer, but the jurors never heard evidence of the years of horrific abuse he suffered from older men. Now, judges, prosecutors, child advocates, the jurors who found him guilty, and the widow of his victim all say his life should be spared. Moreover, over 345,000 people have signed a petition on Change.org calling for clemency for Williams. Such a viral show of support for a death row inmate has not been seen since Troy Davis a year ago this week.

Terry Williams' case has exposed the inherent flaws in the administration of the death penalty, and has acted as a catalyst in the push for a death penalty moratorium in the Keystone state.

If the commonwealth makes good on its plans to kill Terry Williams by lethal injection, he would become the 1st non-volunteer execution since 1978. All 3 of those who were executed since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty waived their remaining appeals.

There is no question that Williams, then barely 18, killed Norwood, 56, with a tire iron, set him on fire and left him in a cemetery. At 17, he had killed Herbert Hamilton, 50, by cutting his throat with a knife, for which Williams received 27 years.

The jury in Williams' capital murder case did not know that Norwood, a church leader, had sexually abused Williams from the age of 13, and had raped him until he bled the previous night. Williams' lawyers failed to properly represent their client by taking the basic steps necessary for capital cases. His new attorneys argue that prosecutors knew about the abuse, but told Williams' co-defendant, Marc Draper, to testify that robbery was the motive for the killing.

In fact, Williams' 1st 18 years were a tragedy filled with traumatic abuse and no one to help him. He was brutally beaten by his mother and alcoholic stepfather with fists, belts, extension cords and switches. At age 6, he was raped by an older boy in the neighborhood, and came home bleeding and crying. In middle school he was repeatedly raped by his middle school teacher. When a robbery landed Terry in juvenile detention, he was gang raped by 2 older boys. Williams' youth was one of exploitation by grown men who used him as a sexual object in exchange for clothes, money, food and other gifts.

Although he suffered Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder as a result of the violence he experienced, Terry received no mental health treatment or counseling. He resorted to alcohol and drugs to self-medicate, and self-mutilation and suicide attempts to deal with his pain. And then he snapped, attacking 2 of his abusers.

5 of the jurors who sentenced Williams to death now say they did not know the victim was having sex with Williams, or that Williams was abused by other men. Had they been aware, they feel it would have influenced their decision. Further, a number of jurors say they want a life sentence for Terry rather than death. The jurors were not instructed that a life sentence means life without parole. Pennsylvania is the only state where such an instruction is not required.

"The reason that I opted for the death sentence was because I was under the impression that if we sentenced Terrance Williams to life in prison then he could get out on parole," said one of the jurors. "If I had known that a life sentence meant life without parole, I personally would have voted for a life sentence, and I think other people probably would have voted for life too."

Mamie Norwood, the widow of Amos Norwood, also wants to see Williams' life spared. She says the execution would go against her Christian beliefs, and she has forgiven him.

Meanwhile, dozens of former judges and prosecutors, child advocates, law professors, mental health professionals and religious leaders, including the Archbishop of Philadelphia, have publicly demanded a commutation of Terry Williams' death sentence. They join a host of human rights organizations and the European Union in calling for clemency.

The Williams case comes at a time when child abuse is front and center in the national consciousness, due in no small part to 2 high-profile sex abuse scandals in the Keystone state. Jerry Sandusky, a former assistant coach at Penn State University, was convicted of sexually abusing young boys. A scathing report from former FBI director Louis Freeh found that university officials failed to intervene and protect children.

And the Archdiocese of Philadelphia has been under fire for providing cover to men of the cloth who abuse children. Recently, Monsignor William J. Lynn - the former secretary clergy for the Archdiocese of Philadelphia - was found guilty of endangering children and protecting predatory priests from the law. He was sentenced to 3 to 6 years.

More importantly, there are serious problems with the implementation of the death penalty, leading citizens in Pennsylvania and around the country to debate whether there should be a moratorium on executions.

While death penalty proponents claim a death sentence is reserved for the worst criminals who commit the most egregious crimes, evidence of an irretrievably broken criminal justice system abounds.

With 216 people condemned to death, Pennsylvania has the 4th largest death row population in America, after California, Florida and Texas. Alabama is in 5th place. According to the Death Penalty Information Center, 61% of death row inmates in the Keystone state are African-American, while only 30% are white and 8% Latino. Blacks are only 11% of Pennsylvania???s population, according to the 2010 census.

And 6 Pennsylvania inmates have been released from death row due to evidence of innocence - 140 across the nation.

A study commissioned by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court found that pay for court-appointed criminal defense lawyers in Philadelphia is grossly inadequate" and "unacceptably increases the risk of ineffective assistance of counsel in individual cases and is primarily responsible for the First Judicial District's growing inability to attract a sufficient number of qualified attorneys willing to accept court appointments in capital cases."

"Court appointed lawyers in Philadelphia rarely visit their clients much, seldom file motions on their behalf, and never use a jury questionnaire," wrote Marc Bookman of the Atlantic Center for Capital Representation. "This is not a technical issue. Death sentence after death sentence has been reversed based on the quality of legal defense in Philadelphia," he added.

In light of these problems and the scheduled execution date, a bipartisan state Senate commission wrote a letter to Gov. Corbett calling for a postponement of all executions until it completes its study on the effectiveness of the death penalty. The commission will release its findings, which will discuss the cost, fairness, proportionality and impact of the death penalty, in December 2013.

Meanwhile, on Monday the lawyers for Terry Williams will attempt to convince the Pennsylvania board of pardons that their client's life should be spared. And on Thursday, a Philadelphia judge will hear testimony as to whether the D.A. withheld evidence of Williams/ sexual abuse from the jury.

Source: The Grio; David A. Love is the Executive Director of Witness to Innocence, a national nonprofit organization that empowers exonerated death row prisoners and their family members to become effective leaders in the movement to abolish the death penalty. Sept. 17, 2012

Related articles:
Sep 15, 2012
Terrance Williams, a 46-year-old African American man, is due to be executed on 3 October in Pennsylvania for a murder committed when he was 18. The victim's widow, five of the trial jurors, and numerous experts on child .
Sep 13, 2012
Terrance Williams, a 46-year-old African American man, is due to be executed on 3 October in Pennsylvania for a murder committed when he was 18. The victim's widow, five of the trial jurors, and numerous experts on child ...

Friday, September 14, 2012

Georgia Court upholds cop killer’s death sentence even though lawyer drank during trial

The federal appeals court has upheld a death sentence against man who killed a sheriff’s deputy, even though the condemned inmate’s lead lawyer drank a quart of vodka every day during trial.

The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta, in a 2-1 decision issued Thursday, said that even though Robert Wayne Holsey’s trial lawyers did not do a competent job, their deficient performance did not prejudice the outcome of the trial. Holsey sits on Georgia’s death row for fatally shooting Baldwin County Deputy Will Robinson while fleeing an armed robbery of a convenience store in December 1995.

Holsey’s appellate lawyers noted that his lead trial lawyer, Andrew Prince, drank a quart of vodka every night of Holsey’s trial because he was about to be sued and prosecuted for stealing client funds. During Holsey’s appeal, Prince testified that he “probably shouldn’t have been allowed to represent anybody” because of his condition.

In its ruling, the 11th Circuit said the key question was not whether Holsey’s lawyers were ineffective. It was whether their deficient performance prejudiced the outcome to the point there was a reasonable probability Holsey would not have been sentenced to death.

Judge Ed Carnes, writing the majority opinion, said the abundant aggravating factors — such as the fact Holsey killed a deputy to avoid arrest and had a prior armed robbery conviction — outweighed any additional mitigation evidence Holsey’s lawyers could have presented to the jury had they been doing their job.

Judge J.L. Edmondson concurred with the decision, but he indicated it was a close question as to whether the poor performance of Holsey’s lawyers prejudiced the outcome of the trial.

In dissent, Judge Rosemary Barkett said the jury never learned that Holsey was subjected to abuse so severe, frequent and notorious that his neighbors called his childhood home “the torture chamber.” Holsey’s mother beat him with an extension cord, shoes and a broom and would hold his head under the bathtub faucet, Barkett wrote, also citing testimony that the house was infested with roaches and reeked of urine and rotting food.

Had the jury heard more about Holsey’s “horrific child abuse,” Barkett wrote, there is a substantial probability he would not have been sentenced to death.

Carnes disagreed. He noted that the jury heard details of Holsey’s abuse during the 1997 trial and said the more exhaustive details of it that emerged on appeal were not enough to strike down the death sentence.

Holsey’s lawyer, Brian Kammer, said the jury did not enough evidence because Holsey’s lead trial attorney “opted to anesthetize himself with vodka rather than prepare adequately to defend against the death penalty. The 11th Circuit majority appears similarly to have anesthetized its sense of justice.”

Lauren Kane, a spokeswoman for state Attorney General Sam Olens, said her office had no comment on the court’s ruling.

Source: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Sept. 14, 2012

Thursday, September 13, 2012

URGENT APPEAL for Terrance Williams due to be executed on 3 October in Pennsylvania

Terrance Williams
Terrance Williams, a 46-year-old African American man, is due to be executed on 3 October in Pennsylvania for a murder committed when he was 18. The victim's widow, five of the trial jurors, and numerous experts on child abuse have called for clemency.The body of 56-year-old Amos Norwood was found in a cemetery in Philadelphia on 15 June 1984. He had been beaten to death. Terrance (Terry) Williams was brought to trial in early 1986, and convicted of first-degree murder. Arguing for the death penalty, the state presented evidence that he had been convicted of armed robbery committed when he was 16 and the murder of a 51-year-old man, Herbert Hamilton, when he was 17. In mitigation, the defense presented three witnesses – the mother, girlfriend, and a cousin of the defendant – who testified as to his good character. Except for a passing reference by the mother that her second husband was "very abusive" to her son, there was no other evidence presented of any abuse suffered by Terry Williams. The defense lawyer urged the jury to consider his client's young age – 18 years and three months – at the time of the crime.

According to Terry Williams' clemency petition, his childhood was marked "by over a decade of sexual abuse" as well as "years of physical and emotional abuse, neglect and abandonment". This "unrelenting abuse and neglect" rendered him "an easy target for sexual predators", two of whom had been Amos Norwood and Herbert Hamilton, according to the petition. In 2007, a US District Court found that the trial lawyer's representation of Terry Williams at the sentencing had been "constitutionally deficient" and "fell far short of prevailing professional norms" because of his failure to conduct a "meaningful investigation" into his client's background. However, under the highly deferential standard for federal judicial review of state cases in US law, the District Court ruled that the lawyer's failings had not altered the trial's outcome. In 2012, the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld the ruling, despite acknowledging that the mitigation evidence
portrayed a "much more complicated and troubled individual than the one depicted during the trial's penalty phase."

Those who have called for clemency include 30 child advocates and experts on child abuse, 18 former prosecutors, eight retired judges, 47 mental health professionals and numerous law professors. Amos Norwood's widow has signed a declaration that she has forgiven Terry Williams for the murder of her husband and that she wishes "to see his life spared". Five of the trial jurors have also said they now oppose his death sentence.

Please write immediately, in English if possible (to Governor until 3 October; to Board until 17 September):
-Explaining that you are not seeking to excuse Amos Norwood's murder or downplay the suffering caused;
-Expressing concern that, during the trial, the jury never heard evidence of Terrance Williams' severely abusive childhood from which he was only just emerging at the time of the crime, when he was 18 years old;
-Welcoming the breadth of opposition to this execution, from former judges, prosecutors, and experts on child abuse, in addition to five of the trial jurors and the widow of Amos Norwood;
-Calling for Terry Williams' death sentence to be commuted.

PLEASE SEND APPEALS BEFORE 3 OCTOBER 2012 TO:
Office of Governor Tom Corbett
Main Capitol Building, Room 225Harrisburg, PA 17120, USA
Fax: 1 717 772 8284
Salutation: Dear Governor

Pennsylvania Board of Pardons
333 Market Street, 15th Floor
Harrisburg, PA 17126, USA
Fax: 1 717 772 3135
Salutation: Dear Board members

Please check with the AIUSA Urgent Action Office if sending appeals after the above date.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
The US Supreme Court has said that "capital punishment must be limited to those offenders who commit a narrow category of the most serious crimes and whose extreme culpability makes them the most deserving of execution". In 2005, in Roper v. Simmons, the Court removed people who were under 18 at the time of the crime from the reach of the death penalty on the grounds of their categorically diminished culpability. The Roper ruling recognized the immaturity, impulsiveness, poor judgment and underdeveloped sense of responsibility often associated with youth. The Court noted that while it was coming up with a categorical rule, the age of 18 as a cut-off for death penalty eligibility was a minimum standard. The Court noted that the "qualities that distinguish juveniles from adults do not disappear when an individual turns 18". Indeed, scientific research shows that development of the brain and psychological and emotional maturation continues at least into a person's early 20s.

Thus if the murder of Amos Norwood had been committed three-and-a-half months earlier, Terry Williams would not now be facing execution as he would have been under 18 at the time of the crime. In addition, if the jury had heard the sort of evidence and expert testimony about the abusive childhood from which he was emerging at the time of the murder of Amos Norwood, it has to be considered possible that at least one of the jurors would have voted for life rather than death (as five of them have now indicated). In 1993, the Supreme Court emphasized that: "youth is more than a chronological fact. It is a time and condition of life when a person may be most susceptible to influence and to psychological damage." According to his clemency petition, Terry Williams' childhood "had a devastating effect on his psychological and emotional development. Terry Williams' first 18 years of life were nothing short of tragic. He was physically abused by his mother and stepfather and was raped and sexually assaulted by adults who should have protected him. He never received any kind of mental health treatment or counseling to help him cope with the trauma". Dr David Lisak, a clinical psychologist and an expert on such abuse and its effects on boys and men, has said that "the violence and abuse that Terry Williams suffered was so severe, and so sustained, that I would not expect any child subjected to such unrelenting trauma to emerge without severe and long lasting psychological damage". Terry Williams has been diagnosed as suffering from, among other things, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and to this day is reported to suffer "secondary symptoms of PTSD, including near constant anxiety, sleep disorders, and nightmares".

According to the clemency petition, the sexual exploitation of Terry Williams by Amos Norwood became increasingly violent over time. The murder for which Terry Williams is now facing execution took place the day after a violent sexual assault by Norwood on the teenager. Terry Williams told Dr Lisak that at the time of the murder, "I was very angry and very scared, and I just snapped. I wanted him to feel the pain that he made me feel. I couldn't think clearly. I felt such anger and betrayal at everyone who used me and betrayed me. I couldn't think of anything else". Terry Williams, who has spent more than half of his life on death row, is reported to be "deeply remorseful" for the murders of Herbert Hamilton and Amos Norwood, and "has demonstrated an ongoing desire to become a better person and to make a positive impact on his daughter and on society from behind the prison walls".

The clemency petition does not seek to excuse the murder of Amos Norwood but asks the clemency authorities to consider the mitigating effect of the childhood abuse Terry Williams suffered, something the jury was never able to do.

Amnesty International opposes the death penalty unconditionally in all cases, regardless of questions of culpability, the details of the crime, or the method used to kill the prisoner. There have been 1,304 executions in the USA since executions resumed there in 1977, including 27 so far in 2012. This would be the first "non-consensual" execution in Pennsylvania for 50 years. The three executions carried out in this state since 1977 were of people who had given up their appeals.

Name: Terrance Williams (m)
Issues: Death penalty, Legal concern
---------------------------------
** POSTAGE RATES **
$0.32 - Postcards
$0.45 - Letters and Cards (up to 1 oz.)
To Canada:
$0.85 - Postcards
$0.85 - Airmail Letters and Cards (up to 1 oz.)
To Mexico:
$0.85 - Postcards
$0.85 - Airmail Letters and Cards (up to 1 oz.)
To all other destination countries:
$1.05 - Postcards
$1.05 - Airmail Letters and Cards (up to 1 oz.)

Amnesty International is a worldwide grassroots movement that promotes and defends human rights.

This Urgent Action may be reposted if kept intact, including contact information and stop action date (if applicable). Thank you for your help with this appeal.

Urgent Action Network
Amnesty International USA
600 Pennsylvania Ave SE 5th fl
Washington DC 20003
Email: uan@aiusa.org
http://www.amnestyusa.org/uan
Phone: 202.509.8193
Fax: 202.675.8566
----------------------------------
END OF URGENT ACTION APPEAL

Related articles:
Sep 07, 2012
Terrance Williams is on death row for fatally beating Amos Norwood with a tire iron in Philadelphia when Williams was 18. Defense lawyers say the 56-year-old Norwood had been sexually abusing Williams for five years after ...
Aug 11, 2012
PHILADELPHIA (AP) — A death-row inmate convicted of killing two people in his teens hopes to avoid becoming the first person executed in Pennsylvania since 1999. Terrance Williams, 46, is on death row for fatally beating ...

Saturday, August 11, 2012

Pennsylvania death-row inmate fights slated October execution

Terrance Williams
PHILADELPHIA (AP) — A death-row inmate convicted of killing two people in his teens hopes to avoid becoming the first person executed in Pennsylvania since 1999.

Terrance Williams, 46, is on death row for fatally beating a man with a tire iron in 1984. Although he has exhausted his appeals, he has asked a Philadelphia judge to halt the scheduled Oct. 3 lethal injection based on new evidence about the victim and the key accuser.

"The killing of Amos Norwood was not a first-degree murder," Shawn Nolan, a federal public defender, wrote in a petition filed on Williams' behalf this year. "Terry Williams and the victim ... were involved in a conflicted sexual relationship in which Norwood paid teenaged Terry for sex. Norwood escalated the violence of their sexual encounters, despite Terry's attempts to stop (it)."

New statements from co-defendant Marc Draper, a policeman's son who testified against Williams in both murder cases, support his claims of a sexual relationship with Norwood. Jurors never heard about the potential motive, or about the deal Draper says he got to testify, Nolan said.

Nor did they hear Williams' claims that he had been physically and sexually assaulted throughout his childhood, and gang-raped at a juvenile facility.

Although the state Supreme Court upheld the death sentence, two judges dissented, finding "a fairly stark picture" of ineffective counsel during the penalty-phase — which consisted of brief, fairly banal comments from Williams' mother, the mother of his infant child and a cousin.

"If I had known those circumstances at that time — what had led him down that path — that definitely would have been a factor and my decision would have been different than the death sentence," juror Thomas Sturgis told defense investigators, according to Williams' petition.

Pennsylvania has executed only three people since the U.S. Supreme Court restored the death penalty in 1976. All of them chose to end their appeals. The last person executed was Gary M. Heidnik, for the murders of two of several women he tortured and held captive in his Philadelphia basement.

Unlike them, Williams has asked a Philadelphia judge for a stay of execution. The Philadelphia District Attorney's Office, which prosecuted him, must respond to his petition by Sept. 21. The office had no comment Friday on the case, spokeswoman Tasha Jamison said.

Williams is also serving a life sentence for third-degree murder for another 1984 slaying which occurred when he was 17. That victim was also an adult male who had sexually abused him, according to his petition. He was also convicted of a 1982 armed robbery.

Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett signed Williams' death warrant on Thursday, as he has 15 others. But those inmates have not yet exhausted their state and federal appeals.

"The governor is sworn to uphold the laws of Pennsylvania, including capital punishment," Corbett spokeswoman Janet Kelley said.

Source: AP, August 10, 2012


Corbett signs death warrant for ex-Phila. man

Thirteen years after Pennsylvania last executed a person, a 46-year-old former Philadelphia man has been ordered put to death by lethal injection Oct. 3.

The death warrant for Terrance Williams - convicted in a 1984 robbery-murder when he was an 18-year-old college freshman - was signed Thursday by Gov. Corbett.

Experts say Williams' execution is likely to happen. He has exhausted three appellate avenues through state and federal courts, and the U.S. Supreme Court rejected his last appeal June 29.

Williams' only legal hope is an emergency petition asking a Philadelphia judge to stay execution based on newly discovered evidence that Williams had been sexually molested throughout his life - including for a dozen years by the man he murdered.

Williams' lawyer, Shawn Nolan, assistant chief of the death-penalty unit at the Federal Defender's Office in Philadelphia, said the victim, Amos Norwood, 56, had a sexual relationship with Williams that began when Williams was 13.

And in January, Nolan said, Williams' admitted accomplice recanted his original testimony that Norwood was killed in a robbery.

In a Jan. 9 sworn statement, Marc Draper said Williams killed Norwood because of the abusive nature of their sexual relationship. Police coerced him into saying robbery was the motive, he said.

None of that information - including background on Williams' physical abuse by his mother and stepfather, and childhood sexual abuse by a neighbor and a teacher - was presented to the Common Pleas Court jury that condemned Williams to death in February 1986.

Click here to read the full article

Source: philly.com, August 10, 2012

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Arizona inmate facing death for 2 murders seeks clemency

Daniel Wayne Cook
Daniel Wayne Cook
An Arizona death row inmate convicted in two gruesome sex-torture murders and scheduled for execution next week has filed a petition for clemency that will be heard by a state board Friday.

Daniel Wayne Cook, 51, wants his death sentence reduced to life in prison and says that he was denied the chance during sentencing to present mitigating circumstances that would warrant leniency.

Cook, in his clemency petition, said he was molested and beaten as a child, factors the trail prosecutor said would have prevented him from seeking the death penalty.

Cook and John Eugene Matzke were convicted in the deaths of 26-year-old Carlos Cruz-Ramos and 16-year-old Kevin Swaney. Prosecutors showed that Cruz-Ramos was tortured and that both victims were raped.

Matzke, who testified against Cook, was released from prison in 2007 after serving a 20-year prison sentence. Cook was sentenced to death.

The clemency petition said Cook, who was 26 at the time of the killings, suffered early in his life at the hands of relatives and others. That abuse "was the same abuse he inflicted upon his victims in his psychotic and delusional state," the petition said.

Evidence regarding abuse in Cook's past and brain damage he suffered because his mother drank alcohol while she was pregnant with him could have saved him from a death sentence, the petition said. But the trial judge refused Cook's request, which would have allowed such evidence into trial, the petition said.


Source: AZCentral, August 1, 2012

Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Abused In Childhood Then Sentenced To Die: 5 Stories

Almost all my [Death Penalty] clients should have been taken out of their homes when they were children. They weren't. Nobody had any interest in them until, as a result of nobody's interest in them, they became menaces, at which point society did become interested, if only to kill them. -- David R. Dow, Texas Public Defender Service attorney

Daniel Cook, abused since infancy and now facing execution on August 8 in Arizona, is just the most current example of someone who endured severe childhood abuse only to later face execution. (Cook has a clemency hearing on Aug. 3; the prosecutor opposes his execution and it can still be stopped.)

There have been plenty of others.

It wasn’t supposed to be this way. In its 1976 Gregg v. Georgia decision, the US Supreme Court allowed executions to resume but required that juries be guided to restrict death sentences to the worst crimes committed by the worst offenders (aka “the worst of the worst”). The Court also endorsed laws “permitting the jury to dispense mercy on the basis of factors too intangible to write into a statute.” Defendants with mitigating circumstances (like youth, diminished mental capacity, or a history of childhood abuse) were supposed to receive lesser sentences.

So why do people with severe child abuse in their backgrounds keep ending up on death row?  Are they really among the worst?


Source: Human Rights Now Blog, Brian Evans, July 31, 2012

Saturday, November 5, 2011

URGENT APPEAL for Paul Rhoades due to be put to death by lethal injection on 18 November in Idaho

The US state of Idaho is scheduled to carry out its first execution since 1994, and only its second in more than half a century. Paul Rhoades is due to be put to death by lethal injection on 18 November. He has been on death row since March 1988. He is now 54.

Paul Rhoades, then 30, was arrested on 25 March 1987 and charged with three separate murders committed over the previous month. The victims were school teacher Susan Michelbacher and convenience store clerks Stacy Baldwin (f) and Nolan Haddon (m). After separate trials for the murders of Stacy Baldwin and Susan Michelbacher, Paul Rhoades was sentenced to death in each case. In the third case, he was sentenced to life imprisonment.

Paul Rhoades is seeking commutation of his death sentence to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. His petition states: "Three people are dead because of me… I cannot erase their loss and the pain they suffered because of my crimes. Nor can I take away the pain endured by each of their family members… Over the past 24 years, I learned that repentance is the only positive way to express my guilt and remorse. For me, repentance means finding ways to make amends for my actions, even if those efforts seem inconsequential in comparison to the crimes I committed… I try to make amends by helping others move from anger toward reconciliation… I hope to show others that a better life, whether inside the prison walls or outside, focuses on service to others."

Numerous former and current inmates, from death row and elsewhere, have submitted letters to the Idaho Commission of Pardons and Parole describing the difference they say Paul Rhoades has made to their lives by persuading them to turn away from violence or helping them in other ways.

Paul Rhoades' childhood was marked by physical, psychological and emotional abuse. His extended family history is replete with serious mental health and developmental difficulties – including substance abuse, depression, and suicides – and criminal conduct. In 2006, a psychologist wrote: "Paul Rhoades grew up in a family context that deprived him of normal development. Paul was exposed repeatedly to violence, drug and alcohol abuse… Paul Rhoades was a damaged human being with little opportunity to be a healthy adult". Paul Rhoades started using drugs at the age of 13 or 14. By the time of the crimes, he had been using highly addictive methamphetamine and other drugs for the previous decade. In the months leading up to the offences, Paul Rhoades' methamphetamine use increased in amount and duration of continual use ("runs") to a point difficult to sustain.

Please write immediately in your own language:
- Express concern that the State of Idaho is due to carry out its first execution in 17 years;
- Explain that you are not seeking to downplay the seriousness of these crimes or the suffering caused;
- Note Paul Rhoades' difficult background, and his positive efforts in prison to try to make amends for his crimes;
- Note the growing concern in the USA about the death penalty, and the isolation of the USA on this issue;
- Call for clemency to be granted to Paul Rhoades.

PLEASE SEND APPEALS BEFORE 18 NOVEMBER 2011 TO:

Commission of Pardons and Parole
3056 Elder Street
Boise, ID 83705
USA
Fax: 1 208 334 3501
Salutation: Dear Commissioners

Governor of Idaho
Governor C.L. 'Butch' Otter
Office of the Governor
State Capitol
PO Box 83720, Boise, ID 83720
USA
Fax: 1 208 334 3454
Salutation: Dear Governor

Please copy appeals to Paul Rhoades's lawyer at Oliver_Loewy@fd.org

Please check with the AIUSA Urgent Action Office if sending appeals after the above date.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
A psychiatrist who has reviewed Paul Rhoades' case has signed a sworn statement based on information unavailable at the time of sentencing, which has been included with Paul Rhoades' clemency petition. She writes that "Paul Rhoades's genetic and social history created a perfect storm of risk factors for drug addiction" and that "Mr Rhoades was a chronic drug user whose use dramatically increased both in quantity and in duration of the runs in the months leading up to and including those during which the murders occurred". Noting that "chronic methamphetamine use is toxic to the brain," she writes that Paul Rhoades's extremely heavy use "strongly suggest[s] that he would have experienced significant deficits in executive [brain] functioning", such as impairments in memory, judgment, complex decision making and impulse control. Recent research, she notes, shows that an inmate with a history of methamphetamine use, as compared to one without, is nine times more likely to have committed homicide.

The judges who imposed the death sentences did not have the full picture about Paul Rhoades's background and severe drug addiction. Nor could they have known what subsequent research has shown about methamphetamine's highly addictive nature, how it changes the brain and that it is highly correlated with homicide.

There are 14 people under sentence of death in Idaho – 13 men and 1 woman. The last execution in Idaho was in 1994, of Keith Wells, who had given up appeals against his death sentence. That was the first execution in Idaho since 1957.

In the past 4 years, 3 states – New Jersey, New Mexico and Illinois – have legislated to abolish the death penalty. Signing these bills into law, the respective state governors pointed to the death penalty's flaws, such as the risk of irrevocable error and unfairness, its discriminatory application, its costs and diversion of resources from crime prevention and victim-assistance, the lack of any proven special deterrent effect, and its potentially brutalizing effect on society. In 2008, the then most senior member of the US Supreme Court, Justice John Paul Stevens, revealed that his 33 years on the Court had persuaded him that the "imposition of the death penalty represents the pointless and needless extinction of life".

While it is true that international human rights law, including article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), recognizes that some countries retain the death penalty, this acknowledgment of present reality should not be invoked "to delay or to prevent the abolition of capital punishment", in the words of article 6.6 of the ICCPR. The USA ratified the ICCPR nearly 20 years ago. The UN Human Rights Committee, the expert body established under the ICCPR to monitor the treaty's implementation, has said that article 6 "refers generally to abolition in terms which strongly suggest that abolition is desirable. The Committee concludes that all measures of abolition should be considered as progress in the enjoyment of the right to life". In the 17 years since Idaho last carried out an execution, some 40 countries have abolished the death penalty, and today 139 countries are abolitionist in law or practice.

Paul Rhoades' lawyers are challenging Idaho's lethal injection procedures in federal court. State lethal injection protocols, and the acquisition of drugs by states for executions, have been the subject of concerns and challenges around the USA in recent months and years (see 'An embarrassment of hitches', July 2011, http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/AMR51/058/2011/en). Amnesty International opposes the death penalty in all cases, regardless of the crime, the offender or the method of execution. There have been 1273 executions in the USA since judicial killing resumed there in 1977, including 39 so far this year.

More information regarding Paul Rhoades can be found at http://www.fdsidaho.org/clemency/rhoades/home.html

Source: Amnesty International, November 4, 2011

Saturday, September 10, 2011

URGENT APPEAL for Steven Woods due to be executed in Texas on 13 September 2011

Steven Woods
Steven Woods is due to be executed in Texas on 13 September 2011. Convicted of a double murder in 2002, he is seeking commutation of his death sentence to life imprisonment. His co-defendant pleaded guilty to killing both victims and received a life sentence.

On 2 May 2001, the body of Ronald Whitehead and the fatally injured Bethena Brosz, who died the following day without regaining consciousness, were found in Denton County, north of Dallas, Texas.

Both had been shot. Two young men in their early 20s, Marcus Rhodes and Steven Woods, were arrested and charged with the crimes.

Although Marcus Rhodes was arrested within three days of the murders, several months before Steven Woods, it was Woods who was brought to trial first, in August 2002. He was convicted and sentenced to death. Three months later, Marcus Rhodes reached a plea agreement with the prosecution in which he pleaded guilty to having personally shot both the victims, was sentenced to life imprisonment and transferred to California where he was facing charges for a murder committed before the Texas killings. He was sentenced to 25 years to life imprisonment for that murder. He is currently serving his life sentences in prison in Texas.

Steven Woods, now 31, is seeking clemency from the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles and Governor in the form of commutation of his death sentence to life imprisonment, arguing that it is "irreconcilable" that he is to be executed for a crime for which his "no less culpable" co-defendant is serving a life sentence.

On appeal, lawyers for Steven Woods have argued that it was fundamentally unfair that the prosecution adopted inconsistent theories of his and Marcus Rhodes' guilt. At Woods' trial, the prosecution argued that while Rhodes had participated in the murders and supplied the car and the guns used in the crime, Woods had planned the crime and committed the shootings. Then in Rhodes' own sentencing under the plea deal in November 2002, Rhodes stipulated that he, Rhodes, had shot both the victims. The Texas appeal courts dismissed Steven Woods' claim of unfairness.

In 2009, a federal court decided that because the US Supreme Court had never ruled on the constitutionality of the state presenting different theories in separate proceedings against co-defendants, it was not contrary to federal law for the state courts to have denied the claim that Woods had been denied due process.

The courts have also rejected the claim that Steven Woods' trial lawyers were constitutionally ineffective for failing to thoroughly investigate mitigating evidence of his history of abuse, neglect and mental health problems to use at the sentencing phase of his trial to try to persuade the jury to vote for a life sentence rather than death.

PLEASE WRITE IMMEDIATELY in your own language:
-Acknowledge the seriousness of the crime for which Steven Woods was sentenced to death;
-Expressing concern at inconsistent prosecution theories against the two defendants in this case and at the unfairness of an outcome where one defendant receives a death sentence and another who plead guilty to personally shooting the two victims receives a life sentence;
-Call for the execution of Steven Woods, prisoner number #999427, to be stopped and clemency granted.

PLEASE SEND APPEALS BEFORE 13 SEPTEMBER 2011 TO:
Clemency Section, Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles
8610 Shoal Creek Blvd.
Austin, TX
78757-6814
USA
Fax 011 1 512 467 0945
Salutation: Dear Board members

Governor Rick Perry, Office of the Governor,
PO Box 12428
Austin, Texas
78711-2428
USA
Fax: 011 1 512 463 1849
Salutation: Dear Governor


ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Steven Woods had just turned 21 years old at the time of the crime for which he is facing execution. At the sentencing phase of his trial in 2002, the defense lawyers presented a single witness, a social worker, who had reviewed certain medical, school and juvenile justice records relating to the defendant's history. She presented some mitigating evidence, including that Steven Woods had been hospitalized as a child for self-mutilation and suicidal behavior, that his father was violent, and that the boy had not received family or institutional support when he began to get into trouble with the law. Since the trial, a psychologist who has evaluated Steven Woods has said that because the social worker had never met Steven Woods or conducted any assessment of him, "she could only provide cursory testimony about what she had read in the records. Moreover, much of her testimony lacked the specificity and important detail about Steven's life needed to help the jury understand the links between his history of child abuse and neglect and his long-standing  psychological problems. This seems to have occurred because trial counsel did not gather the data necessary for constructing an adequate social history."

Further mitigation investigation has been conducted during the appeal process, revealing information with which the jury was not presented. This includes evidence of possible sexual abuse of Steven Woods by his father (who left home when Steven was six), physical and emotional abuse at the hands of his stepfather, evidence of a family history of substance abuse and further evidence of Steven Woods' abuse of drugs from the age of 13, including LSD, cocaine, heroin, methamphetamines, codeine and marijuana. Steven Woods was homeless between the ages of 17 and 19, living in Detroit, Chicago and New York. During this time, he worked as a prostitute to obtain money for drugs. In addition, Steven Woods has been diagnosed with serious depression and other mental health problems and there is evidence of a family history of mental illness.

In 2009, the US District Court found that Steven Woods' trial lawyers should at least have attempted to interview their client's siblings when preparing for the sentencing phase. As a result this federal judge ruled that it had been unreasonable that the state appeal court found it was not deficient that the defense counsel failed to conduct a more thorough investigation into Steven Woods' family background. However, the judge said that he could not find that the outcome of the trial would have been different even if the lawyers had conducted a more thorough investigation. He upheld the death sentence and this was affirmed in 2010 by the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

Amnesty International opposes the death penalty unconditionally, in every case, in every country.

The death penalty's fundamental flaws have led to what once seemed a permanent part of the legal
landscape in many countries being dissolved, with 139 countries today abolitionist in law or
practice. The US administration has dismissed appeals from such countries for the USA to abolish the death penalty as reflecting "continuing policy differences, not a genuine difference about what international human rights law requires." While it is true that international human rights law, including article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), recognizes that some countries retain the death penalty, this acknowledgment of present reality should not be invoked "to delay or to prevent the abolition of capital punishment", in the words of article 6.6 of the ICCPR. The USA ratified the ICCPR nearly 20 years ago. The UN Human Rights Committee, the expert body established under the ICCPR to monitor the treaty's implementation, has said that article 6 "refers generally to abolition in terms which strongly suggest that abolition is desirable. The Committee concludes that all measures of abolition should be considered as progress in the enjoyment of the right to life".

There have been 1,266 executions in the USA since judicial killing resumed there in 1977, 473 of
which have been carried out in Texas. There have been 32 executions in the USA this year, nine of them in Texas. There have been 273 executions in Texas since late 2000 under the governorship of Rick Perry (see http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/AMR51/057/2009/en)

Source: Amnesty International, September 10, 2011

Related article:
Aug 30, 2011
On September 13, 2011, Steven Woods (31) is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection by the state of Texas after being wrongfully convicted and confined 24 hours a day for the past 9 years of his life. ...

Sunday, August 14, 2011

Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell says he won't stop Jackson execution




Jerry Terrell Jackson
Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell said Friday he will not stop Thursday's scheduled execution of a man who was convicted of raping and killing an elderly Williamsburg woman.

McDonnell's action leaves the U.S. Supreme Court as the only hope for Jerry Terrell Jackson, 30, who is scheduled to die by lethal injection at Greensville Correctional Center.

"After conferring with the appropriate parties, as well as thoroughly reviewing the clemency petition and the judicial opinions in this case, I find no compelling reason to set aside the sentence of the jury, imposed and affirmed by the courts," McDonnell said.

Jackson was convicted of the 2001 murder of 88-year-old Ruth Phillips.

His lawyers argue the jury in Jackson's trial was not given a complete picture of the abuse he suffered as a child. The have argued that evidence of abuse could have convinced jurors to spare Jackson's life.

Jackson's attorneys did not immediately offer a comment.

Unless the court blocks the execution, Jackson will be the 1st Virginia inmate to die using a new drug protocol that replaces the sedative sodium thiopental with pentobarbital in the 3-drug cocktail.

A nationwide shortage of sodium thiopental forced many states to substitute pentobarbital, but some have questioned its use. Courts have ruled that the change in drugs is not significant enough to postpone executions.

Jackson's attorneys have argued that his trial attorneys failed to present evidence of his extreme abuse as a child, which could have convinced jurors to spare his life. A federal judge agreed and ordered a new sentencing hearing for Jackson last year, but the 4th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals blocked that hearing on a technicality in April.

Jackson admitted to police that he broke into Ruth Phillips' apartment on Aug. 26, 2001, and that he put a pillow over her face to try to make her pass out once she awoke and caught him rummaging through her purse. He told police he left in Phillips' car and used the $60 to buy marijuana. He said he had not intended to kill Phillips.

At trial, Jackson said he lied to police and that an accomplice smothered Phillips. He denied raping Phillips, but prosecutors presented pubic hairs matching Jackson's DNA that were found around her body. He was convicted and sentenced to death in 2003.

Phillips, a widow for 30 years, worked as a seamstress making slip covers and draperies until her death.

Source: Daily Press, August 13, 2011


Virginia execution: Should severe childhood abuse spare a murderer the death penalty?

On an August night 10 years ago, 20-year-old Jerry Terrell Jackson broke into a James City County apartment.

By the time he fled and hopped into a Dodge sedan that didn't belong to him, $60 cash in hand, 88-year-old Ruth Phillips was lying dead inside, raped and smothered with a pillow. Her body was discovered hours later by her son, who had grown concerned when he couldn't reach her for Sunday supper.

At Jackson's trial in 2002, Williamsburg-James City County prosecutors painted a lurid picture of the crime scene for jurors: Phillips lying twisted and exposed on her bed, nightgown pushed up to her neck, blood vessels burst in her eyes and cheeks.

Closing arguments were capped with Deputy Commonwealth's Attorney Rich Rizk holding a pillow down on a table for several hushed, excruciating minutes, approximating the time it took for Phillips to asphyxiate.

It's an image some jurors still can't get out of their heads.

"The prosecutor, he illustrated exactly what this woman suffered at the hands of this man," jury foreman Lewis Samuels of Williamsburg said recently. "He did this thing with the pillowcase -- I mean, it was almost like slow motion that this woman suffered this horrendous … this death."

It took jurors less than 2 hours to convict Jackson and sentence him to die twice over: For murder while committing robbery, and murder while committing rape.

Jackson, now 31, is scheduled for execution Thursday night.

His team of attorneys scrambled to convince Gov. Bob McDonnell to commute his sentence to life in prison without parole. In a statement Friday, the governor refused, having found "no compelling reason to set aside the sentence." They're also appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court.

They argue that Jackson's original attorneys failed to paint their own grim picture for jurors -- a picture of a childhood saturated with abuse so sadistic and pervasive that, they say, it likely would have moved at least one juror to vote for life in prison. In Virginia, one reluctant juror is all it takes to avoid the death penalty.

In an unusual move, a federal judge ruled in 2010 that Jackson's first attorneys should have put his brother and sister on the stand to provide vivid, firsthand testimony that might have led the jury to spare him. She ordered a new sentencing hearing.

"The picture painted of Jackson by his own counsel," U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema wrote, "all but invited a death verdict."

Her ruling was reversed in April by the U.S. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, setting the stage for the execution. The Fourth Circuit upheld a Virginia Supreme Court ruling that said the siblings' testimony would be merely "cumulative" to other trial testimony, and that the law doesn't impose a "constitutional requirement that counsel uncover every scrap of evidence that could conceivably help their client."

A trial choice

Jackson's lawyer at the time did explore abuse in the trial's penalty phase, when jurors heard aggravating evidence for a stricter sentence, and mitigating evidence for a lesser one.

Norfolk defense attorney Andrew Protogyrou sat social workers, physicians, nurses and a police officer on the stand to read from various documents about bruises and broken bones, hospital visits, allegations of sexual assault, domestic violence, court-ordered family counseling.

Jackson's mother, father and stepfather testified about Jackson's bad behavior and their efforts -- which they acknowledged were sometimes extreme -- to correct it.

"I'm satisfied that every bit of abuse got before the jury," Protogyrou told the Daily Press recently. "We showed that his childhood was replete with abuse at an early age."

It was his strategic decision, he said, not to show jurors the contrast between the troubled Jackson and his brother, who had joined the Navy and had no criminal record.

"I can hear it now," Protogyrou said. "(The brother) made it out, why couldn't he?' So we decided not to give the visual success story. It was a trial choice we had to make."

Brinkema couldn't have disagreed more, blasting Jackson's trial counsel as "constitutionally ineffective." In 2008, she held a 2-day hearing where the siblings testified for the 1st time.

Their "vivid descriptions," she wrote, "would have painted a graphic picture of an unwarranted, continuous, sadistic course of conduct that terrorized and dehumanized Jackson throughout his childhood and left real scars on both of his siblings."

Here are some of those descriptions:

"Told me and my brother to strip our clothes off, and he just started beating me. … and then a lot of crying, really, really hurting, and then he started beating my brother, and just kept beating him and beating him and beating him and beating him…."

"When we came back, my brother was sitting in the middle of the floor with no clothes on, and he had welts and … a 2-by-4 sitting next to him on the floor. He was bleeding from the 2-by-4 marks that was left on his body.…"

"My stepfather telling me and my brother to pull down our pants and stand up and play with ourselves, and I don't even know what happened…."

[Jerry] didn't break down … whenever we'd get beat or something, he wouldn't like give in as easily as I would, and he would actually say, 'You shouldn't be doing this. You're not my dad.' … It was a battle between both of them, and then [Jerry] would eventually just get quiet and give in and just fall to the ground … crying."

Broken bones

At the age of 19 months, Jackson was brought to the hospital with a broken bone that was never explained. It wouldn't be the last. There were beatings, often daily, by their father and stepfather. Sometimes they were forced to strip naked first. Sometimes Jackson and his brother were ordered to masturbate.

The brothers were raped more than once, the siblings testified. In one incident, Jackson witnessed his brother being raped while he hid in the closet, fearing he would be next. When the stepfather tried to molest Jackson's sister, she began sleeping with a knife under her pillow.

A clinical psychologist enlisted by Jackson's appeals team testified that the abuse was among the worst he'd ever encountered. "The contrast between the terror in which [Jackson] was raised and the way in which his upbringing was presented to the jury could not have been more stark," Dr. Matthew Mendel said in an appeals affidavit.

His siblings weren't unscathed. Jackson's brother said he has attempted suicide repeatedly, the first time at age 12. He joined the Navy to escape, but still struggles with depression and a failed marriage. When he sent an email to friends saying he wished he was dead, they contacted Navy authorities, who then intervened.

Jackson's sister lives in Newport News but declined to comment for this story. The family has refused to give current contact information for Jackson's brother. Because they're identified as victims of sexual assault, the Daily Press is not naming them.

Jackson's mother, Amelia Jackson Knight, also declined to comment.

Ignoring the evidence?

The federal appeals court reversed Brinkema's decision -- not over the siblings' testimony, but whether she had the right to hold the evidentiary hearing in the first place. The decision was based on a U.S. Supreme Court ruling regarding federal court review of state judgments, a ruling handed down after Brinkema's hearing.

Under that new ruling, appellate judges found that Brinkema should have considered only the evidence that the Virginia Supreme Court had before it. Given "the breadth and depth of evidence of childhood abuse provided to the jury," the judges said, the state court's decision to deny a new sentencing was not "clearly unreasonable."

Jackson's legal team disputes that finding. "They held that Judge Brinkema wasn't legally permitted to hold that hearing, so they ignored that evidence," said Joshua Toll, with the Washington, D.C., office of King & Spalding.

Jackson's attorneys are petitioning the U.S. Supreme Court to review and clarify that interpretation, which would require a stay of execution. They also argue that Jackson received ineffective counsel, and that jurors weren't told to consider Jackson's age and background as mitigating factors at sentencing. 2 jurors had said they wouldn't consider them unless instructed.

The state attorney general's office won't comment on the case because it's ongoing, referring reporters instead to appeals briefs and decisions.

In those documents, the state has maintained -- successfully, save for Brinkema's ruling -- that the defense strategy was reasonable and even skillful.

"The district court specifically found that Jackson's trial counsel did investigate his childhood abuse," Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli argues. "Its criticism was that counsel were supposed to have gone about it differently."

"It's over"

3 of the original trial jurors located by reporters were briefed on the abuse described in the evidentiary hearing. All stand by their decision.

"[Jackson] is not the only child that's been brought up in a situation where there was abuse in the family," said jury foreman Samuels. "As you grow older, you never get over it, but you accept the fact that I gotta get on with my life."

"A jury has to consider whatever comes before them," said juror Alfonso A. LaFalce. "[But] I have no idea what would have happened or how the jury would have reacted to it.… It's done. I did my duty, and it's over."

A female juror who didn't want her name used recalls hearing some evidence of abuse, but said the verdict would have been the same even had Jackson's siblings taken the stand. Being abused, she said, "doesn't give you the right to rape and suffocate someone the way he did."

Jackson attorney Toll isn't surprised.

"Most jurors want to believe that they reached the right result," Toll said. "I think it's fair to say that the jury heard about the fact that Mr. Jackson was abused, but they did not get a picture of the severity of the abuse, the frequency of the abuse, the depravity and the sadistic nature of the abuse.… They did not get a picture. The picture is what you want, because it's that picture that may sway a juror."

Former prosecutor Rizk, a defense attorney today, stands by the court's judgment: "The ultimate penalty for the ultimate crime."

When told of the siblings' later testimony of extreme abuse, Rizk said he couldn't comment on evidence not presented at trial.

"These capital cases aren't easy on anyone, from judge to attorneys to juries," Rizk said. "No one gets any peace…. Because there are no winners. It's not like the death penalty … brings back Ruth Phillips."

Source: Daily Press, August 13, 2011


Prison interview: Jackson faces death, but hopes to live

Death row inmate Jerry Terrell Jackson hopes that somehow, some way, he won't die as scheduled in 4 days.

But he's also trying to prepare for the worst -- in case the U.S. Supreme Court doesn't intervene to stay his execution. The high court is his last hope after Gov. Bob McDonnell declined late Friday to intervene to commute his sentence.

"I'm not ready, but I'm trying to get myself there," Jackson said in a phone interview from Greensville Correctional Center Thursday afternoon. "I'm talking to my lawyers, I'm talking to whoever I can. My spiritual adviser, Christine, I'm talking to her a lot to feel ready. I have some great friends that are there with me, too, that are there to help me."

His mother, he said, "is trying to keep me strong. My sister and brother are the same."

Unlike at his trial, the 31-year-old Jackson doesn't deny that he raped and killed 88-year-old Ruth Phillips in 2001. On Thursday he sent a message to her family: "I'm sorry that, due to my actions, it hurt Mrs. Phillips, and she lost her life. I apologize to the Phillips family. I'm sorry."

He wouldn't discuss the crime, saying only he didn't intend to harm anyone the night he burglarized her apartment. "I would not have went into that lady's home if I'd known she was home."

"I'm sorry that they suffered the loss of their family member, their mother, their grandmother," said Jackson. "I wish it hadn't happened. I can't take it back."

The day before McDonnell denied his clemency, Jackson said he wished the governor would learn more about him first. "I just wish he would get to know me," Jackson said. "Well, not to get to know me, but I wish he knew who I was before he makes a decision on my life."

Growing up in James City County, Jackson had a close relationship with his grandmother, his brother and sister. Court records show he once walked 10 miles to visit his sick grandmother in a hospital, and at her funeral broke down crying as he tried to lead the congregation in her favorite hymn.

"She was one of the most beautiful people that I've ever known," Jackson said. "She gave everyone a chance."

The abuse he suffered as a boy at the hands of his father and stepfather was brutal, he said -- near-daily beatings, bloodied once by a 2-by-4, a Pepsi bottle thrown at his head to get him to move. He confirmed his siblings' court testimony about his being sexually abused by a family friend.

"My dad, he wasn't the father that you could be proud of," Jackson said. "He was an alcoholic.? He was violent.? He was mean. It wasn't spanking. He would raise his hands high and hit us."

Asked if such abuse caused him to commit the crimes he's set to die for, Jackson said it "played a big part."

"When everybody found out, when the police found out, if somebody would have stepped in at the time, I think my life would've been different," he said. "If my mother would have let me live with my godmother, things would have been different. I wouldn't have been as angry. I wouldn't have thought that there was nobody out there that really cared."

In 2006, Jackson came within days of execution when it was stayed pending an appeal. Last year, a federal judge ruled he should get a new sentencing hearing, but that ruling was reversed by a federal appeals court in April. "It was very debilitating," Jackson said. "It crushed me."

Over the past 10 years in prison, he said, "I've learned that I didn't have to worry about people always trying to hurt me, either physically or mentally or emotionally. I could trust people. And I learned that there are people in the world that really do care."

For now, he said, "I feel like I'm on a path. It finishes itself out. My execution date is real.

"I have faith in my lawyers, but I don't have faith in the system."

Source: Daily Press, August 13, 2011


Son of victim says Jackson's execution is justified

For 9 years, Dick Phillips has been waiting for his mother's killer to die.

Thursday night at the Greensville Correctional Center, his wait may come to an end.

Jerry Terrell Jackson, 31, is scheduled to die by lethal injection for the robbery, rape and murder of 88-year-old Ruth Phillips in 2001.

"I am relieved to see that it's going to come to a conclusion," Dick Phillips said. "I want the sentence to be carried out.? The law is that there's a capital punishment, and the jury felt it was appropriate. I don't disagree."

It was Phillips who found his mother's body hours after she'd been smothered with a pillow. Earlier this year, he voiced frustration at the slow pace of the legal proceedings surrounding Jackson's execution. In fact, he said he wanted the case over -- even if it meant a life sentence without parole rather than death.

"It's time to bring this to a close," Phillips said at the time.

Now that execution is imminent, however, Phillips wants it carried out. He disagreed with a federal judge's ruling in 2010 granting Jackson a new sentencing hearing based on the severe abuse Jackson suffered as a boy.

Phillips said evidence of abuse was introduced at Jackson's trial. "Maybe it wasn't played out as dramatically as it could have been to satisfy the judge," he said. "But nothing was hidden."

Such abuse, Phillips said, should not lessen Jackson's responsibility for what he did.

Phillips also contends that if the federal judge was going to hold a hearing, he and his family should have been included, too. "If she's going to hear sob stories from his brother and sister, then she should know something about (our family) and my mother," he said.

The judge's ruling was overturned earlier this year by the U.S. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Ruth Wilma Evans Phillips was a native of Haverhill, Mass.

The youngest of three daughters, she was born into a family that traces its New England roots to the 1630s. A longtime widow, she lived on her own for many years in New Hampshire before moving to Williamsburg in 1997 to be closer to her family.

Dick Phillips found her an apartment at Rolling Meadows, off Longhill Road near the Williamsburg-James City recreation center. It was within walking distance of her son's home. "We picked it for her because it was secure, it was clean, it was new," he said in 2001.

Dick Phillips and his mother spoke virtually every day, and he visited several times a week. She introduced herself at a local fabric store, and soon was making slipcovers for people all over town. She always kept ice cream and cake on hand, often offering it to her 13-year-old grandson.

A chocolate cake recipe was found on her kitchen counter the day she died.

On Aug. 26, 2001, a Sunday, Phillips went to check on his mother when she didn't answer the phone after several calls to invite her to dinner. He first assumed she had gone to church, but his concern grew as the time passed.

Hours later, he went by his mother's apartment and found her dead.

He said he won't attend Thursday's execution. "I'm not looking for revenge," he said. "I get no satisfaction out of seeing somebody die."

But 10 years after his mother was slain, he said, it's about time the case is finally ending.

Source: Daily Press, August 13, 2011