Showing posts with label Idaho. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Idaho. Show all posts

Thursday, January 30, 2014

Washington state to increase access to executions

Washington state will allow witnesses to executions to see the entire process, including the insertion of intravenous catheters during a lethal injection, state officials told The Associated Press.

The new witness protocol, currently a draft that is in its final stages of approval, includes the use of television monitors to show the inmate entering the death chamber and being strapped down, as well as the insertion of the IVs, which had both previously been shielded from public view. The new technology has already been installed, and officials say the protocol will be finalized within the next week.

Through public disclosure requests, the AP had sought information about any potential changes to execution protocols. State corrections officials spoke with the AP about the new procedures this week. The change is in response to a 2012 federal appeals court ruling that said all parts of an execution must be fully open to public witnesses. That ruling was sparked by a case brought by the AP and other news organizations who challenged Idaho's policy to shield the insertion of IV catheters from public view, in spite of a 2002 ruling from the same court that said every aspect of an execution should be open to witnesses.

"We have been working on this for many, many months," Dan Pacholke, assistant secretary of the prisons division at the state Department of Corrections, said Wednesday.

Pacholke said they have been researching the technology needed to make the change and followed the process currently used by Arizona, which provides an overhead view via TV monitor of the IV insertion during an execution.

"It really does provide greater viewing capacity to the witnesses," he said. "It's going to take an overhead view to provide the view that the court wants."

Under the draft proposal, which is currently under final review within the Department of Corrections, witnesses will watch the inmate enter via monitors from behind a closed curtain to the death chamber, according to Corrections Secretary Bernie Warner. The curtain will be lifted after the inmate is strapped down, and the inmate will be given an opportunity to make a final statement. The curtain will close again, and the insertion of the IVs will be done via TV monitor. The curtain will rise again after the needle has been inserted.

Warner said that while some minor changes could still be made to the draft proposal, the main changes concerning full viewing access for witnesses will not.

The San Francisco-based 9th Circuit Court of Appeals originally ruled in 2002 on witness viewing during an execution, and that ruling applied to the 9 Western states in the court's jurisdiction. But until the 2012 ruling, 4 states initially kept part of subsequent executions away from public view: Arizona, Idaho, Washington and Montana.

The states had argued the policy was necessary to protect the anonymity of the execution team. Open government and journalism groups countered that witnessing all aspects of an execution is the only way to determine if it is being properly carried out. The media also argued there was a First Amendment right to view the entire process.

Arizona and Idaho changed their procedures as a result of the 2012 ruling that same year. Arizona now uses video monitors to show the IV insertion, but Idaho witnesses see the inmate strapped to the table and the insertion of the IVs through a window. According to an execution protocol approved last year in Montana, IVs are still inserted out of view of the witnesses.

Katie Ross, an attorney who has handled death-penalty cases and is director of the Washington Death Penalty Assistance Center, said that the move by the department is important for transparency of the entire process.

"Everything the state is doing when they're in the process of killing a human being should be scrutinized," she said. "When mistakes are happening, the media, as well as the witnesses present, should be able to see that and accurately report it."

9 men await execution at the Washington State Penitentiary in Walla Walla. No executions have occurred since the 2012 ruling, and none are currently scheduled. But the state Supreme Court just last week rejected a petition for release from death row inmate Jonathan Lee Gentry, sentenced for the murder of a 12-year-old girl in 1988. Gentry could be the 1st execution in the state since September 2010, when Cal Coburn Brown died by lethal injection for the 1991 murder of a Seattle-area woman.

"This is the most extreme criminal justice sanction handed out by the courts, and this seriousness is not lost on those of us involved," Pacholke said. "Our objective is to carry out the sanction administered by the court and do so consistent with the most recent court rulings."

Source: Associated Press, January 30, 2014

Thursday, July 12, 2012

ACLU Attorney: Idaho Becoming a 'Heavy User' of Executions

Idaho Execution Chamber
Currently, there are 3,170 American men and women on death row. Since 1976, 1,300 people have been executed but 140 people have been released from death row, having been exonerated due to DNA or confessional evidence.

“There are dozens more who are presumably innocent, but the type of evidence is not decisive,” said Tanya Greene, ACLU advocacy and policy counsel. “I would say that the number is much higher, and that should definitely be a concern.”

Greene also pointed to the skyrocketing costs of prosecution, incarceration and constitutionally required appeals involved with capital punishment, and how they compare to life in prison without parole.

“Despite what intuitively seems to flow, it is less expensive to permanently incarcerate someone than it is to charge, try, convict, sentence and execute to death,” said Greene. “

According to Greene, the costs of capital proceedings through execution are two to three times more than permanent imprisonment, and states with limited funding need to decide where their budget is most effectively utilized.

“You make a decision—are we going to pay for schools, keep the public library open, are we going to provide social services or are we going to try and kill people,” said Greene. “It is a failed government program. If any other government program operated at this type of loss in terms of money, it would never happen.”

Greene also pointed to Idaho's recent executions, two in the past eight months.

“Given these recent two executions in the state, Idaho in fact seeks to join the heavy-use states, the states that are executing,” she said.

Greene questioned the audience, asking for their ideas on how to get local attention and how to encourage Idahoans to question capital punishment.


Source: Boise Weekly, July 11, 2012

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Idaho executes Richard Leavitt

Richard Leavitt
BOISE, Idaho (AP) — Idaho prison officials on Tuesday executed a convicted killer for brutally stabbing a woman nearly three decades ago, marking the first time witnesses were allowed to watch the whole process of lethal injection in the state after a challenge by media organizations.

Richard Leavitt, 53, was pronounced dead at 10:25 a.m. at the Idaho Maximum Security Institution.

Tuesday's lethal injection was unprecedented in the state due to the expanded access granted to media and other state witnesses in the wake of a federal lawsuit.

The Associated Press and 16 other news groups sued last month, arguing that Idaho Department of Correction policy barring witnesses from viewing a lethal injection last November in its entirety violated the First Amendment and the public's right to know.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed, ordering Idaho prison officials to open the curtain immediately after Leavitt entered the execution chamber, enabling witnesses to oversee as executioners insert IV catheters into Leavitt's body.

The insertion of IV catheters, used to deliver lethal doses of sedatives and other chemicals, has come under fire in recent years. Death row inmates in Idaho and other states have challenged the procedure on grounds the insertion of the catheters can cause delays, excruciating pain or other complications.

Brent Reinke, Idaho's prison chief, said the agency and its execution team made adjustments to comply with the federal court order. He said execution team members will wear headgear and other garb designed to protect their identities. The team also held two rehearsals in recent days to adjust to policy changes sought by the news groups.

"We have taken what we believe are the necessary steps to protect the identity of our team, especially our medical team," Reinke told reporters early Tuesday. "But from the time we begin this process, the blinds will be open so the media will see everything that happens."

In the hours before the execution, Reinke described Leavitt as calm and resolved after meeting with lawyers and a few visitors. Leavitt, convicted in 1985 for stabbing and mutilating 31-year-old Danette Elg, did not ask to see a spiritual advisor.

Late Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected Leavitt's last-minute request to stay the execution, clearing the way for Idaho to put to death its second inmate in 17 years. In November, Paul Ezra Rhoades was died by lethal injection for his role in the slaying of three people in eastern Idaho.

About 29 people gathered outside the prison south of Boise to protest the execution and the state's capital punishment law.

Leavitt was arrested after authorities discovered Elg's body in her bedroom several days after she'd been killed. Prosecutors said Leavitt stabbed her repeatedly with exceptional force, and then cut out her sexual organs.

At his sentencing, former 7th District Judge H. Reynold George noted that Leavitt came from a law-abiding family, was married and steadily employed before his arrest, but said those mitigating factors were only "feathers on the scale when balanced against the grossly inhumane act of murder that went beyond all decency."

Source: AP, June 12, 2012

Saturday, June 9, 2012

Idaho: Court rules for news groups in execution case

Idaho Execution Chamber
BOISE, Idaho (AP) — A federal appeals court ruled Friday that witnesses should have full viewing access to Idaho's upcoming execution, siding with The Associated Press and 16 other news organizations.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued the decision a day after hearing arguments in a lawsuit from the news groups seeking to change Idaho's protocol, saying it's unconstitutionally restrictive.

The case aims to strike down a portion of Idaho's regulations that prevent witnesses — including reporters acting as representatives of the public — from watching executions until after catheters have been inserted into the veins of death row inmates.

The lawsuit comes as lethal injections have drawn greater scrutiny, from whether the drugs are effective to whether the execution personnel are properly trained.

It's unclear how the ruling will affect the scheduled execution next week of Idaho death row inmate Richard Leavitt, who will be put to death by lethal injection. Leavitt was convicted of the 1984 murder of a Blackfoot woman.

"We, of course, respect the court's decision. We will take the necessary measures to assure that the execution continues as scheduled," said Idaho Department of Correction spokesman Jeff Ray.

A federal judge Tuesday denied a request from the news groups seeking to prevent Leavitt's execution without the changes. The news organizations appealed that ruling to the 9th Circuit.

The appellate judges, during arguments Thursday, noted that the 9th Circuit had already ruled in a 2002 California case that every aspect of an execution should be open to witnesses, from the moment the condemned enters the death chamber to the final heartbeat.

The decade-old decision established what was expected of the nine Western states within the court's jurisdiction. A decade later, four of the states have kept part of each execution away from public view, according to death penalty experts.

"Nearly a decade ago, we held in the clearest possible terms that 'the public enjoys a First Amendment right to view executions from the moment the condemned is escorted into the execution chamber," the judges said in their ruling Friday. "The State of Idaho has had ample opportunity for the past decade to adopt an execution procedure that reflects this settled law."

Idaho, Arizona, Washington and Montana have conducted 14 lethal injections since the 9th Circuit ruling in 2002, and half of each procedure has been behind closed doors.

Chuck Brown, an attorney for the news organizations, predicted that the 9th Circuit ruling over Idaho's execution process will prompt those remaining states to change their policies to allow for a full viewing of the execution process.

"That's exactly what will happen," said Brown, who added that the ruling clears up any uncertainty about the intent of the 9th Circuit's 2002 decision. "It clears up any doubt."

While U.S. District Judge Edward J. Lodge took issue with the timing of the May 24 request from the news groups, saying it was too close to Leavitt's execution, the 9th Circuit disagreed, saying the state was at fault. The appellate judges noted that media representatives had asked prison officials to alter the execution procedure before November 2011 execution of Paul Rhoades.

The news organizations filed their case after talks were unsuccessful with prison officials, who took the position that the 2002 ruling was based on facts unique to California, Brown said, citing letters from Idaho correction director Brent Reinke.

"We fault the State, not the media plaintiffs, for our need to consider this question several days before an execution: the State has missed opportunity after opportunity to bring its execution procedures into compliance with the clear law of this Circuit," the ruling also said.

During arguments on Thursday, Judge Marsha Berzon questioned why Idaho should be an exception when other states have decided that entire executions can be seen by the public.

"California has been doing it. Ohio has been doing it. Arizona just announced they are going to do it," Berzon said. "You haven't put anything in the record that Idaho is different in this regard. That you haven't done."

Source: AP, June 9, 2012

Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Federal judge rejects news groups' execution case

Idaho Death Chamber
A federal judge on Tuesday denied a petition from The Associated Press and 16 other news groups that want a court to strike down Idaho's policy restricting full access to executions.

The news organizations filed a lawsuit last month over the portion of Idaho's policy that prevents witnesses from viewing lethal injections from start to finish.

The legal challenge came less than three weeks before the June 12 execution of Richard Leavitt, though the media had raised concerns over the policy with the Idaho Department of Correction after the execution of Paul Ezra Rhoades in November.

In his 20-page ruling, U.S. District Judge Edward J. Lodge denied a request for a preliminary injunction that might have required changes before Leavitt's execution. Lodge took issue with the timing of the injunction request filed May 24, saying there was no excuse for the news organizations waiting so soon before Leavitt is scheduled to die for the 1984 murder of Blackfoot resident Danette Elg.

"The claim was brought very late, and if granted, it would undoubtedly change the execution protocol and could disrupt the scheduled execution," Lodge said. "The public has an interest in viewing the whole execution process, but it also has an interest in seeing the judgment enforced without disruption."

The news organizations will appeal to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, said their attorney, Chuck Brown.

An Idaho Department of Corrections spokesman said the agency has no comment on the case.

Prison officials defended their policy in court documents filed late last week. They say keeping the curtain closed on the first few steps is essential to protecting the anonymity of execution team members. Under the current protocol, a small group of witnesses, including members of news organizations who act as representatives of the public, do not see, for instance, the insertion of the intravenous catheters that deliver the fatal drug mixture.

Lodge found that the news organizations' arguments are strong, but he said they had a higher hurdle given the timing issue. Lodge said he was "very concerned" that to the extent the news organizations could establish that the execution policy needs to be changed, there was simply not enough time for the Correction Department to make changes without a delay in Leavitt's execution.

"Plaintiffs ignore how heavily courts have emphasized the need for challenges related to executions to be brought in a timely manner, so as not to delay the scheduled execution," Lodge said. "Here, there is a high likelihood that opening the entire execution to the public will delay the execution."

Until the matter can be fully litigated, Lodge said Idaho's protocol should remain unchanged.

The San Francisco-based 9th Circuit ruled in 2002 that every aspect of an execution should be open to witnesses, from the moment the condemned enters the death chamber to his or her final heartbeat.

The ruling established what was expected of the 9 Western states within the court's jurisdiction. A decade later, 4 of the states have kept part of each execution away from public view, according to death penalty experts and an Associated Press review.

Idaho, Arizona, Washington and Montana have conducted 14 lethal injections since the ruling, and half of each procedure has been behind closed doors.

Source: Associated Press, June 5, 2012


Judge Denies Leavitt's Claim That 1-Drug Lethal Injection is Cruel and Unusual

Richard Albert Leavitt has been denied a preliminary injunction regarding Idaho's new method of lethal injection, in effect sustaining Leavitt's scheduled execution for Tuesday, June 12.

In a 55-page order handed down today, U.S. District Judge Edward Lodge denied Leavitt's challenge of the new execution method, a single, lethal dose of the surgical sedative pentobarbital. The single-drug method is different from the November 2011 execution, when Paul Ezra Rhoades was injected with a 3-drug mixture.

Leavitt joined three other death-row prisoners—Thomas Creech, James Hairston and Gene Stuart—in challenging the new protocol. Lodge agreed to consider Leavitt's case quickly due to his scheduled execution. Lodge said the other 3 inmates' "briefing schedule has been un-altered to allow them additional time to address a pending Motion of Dismiss" from the State of Idaho.

The inmates claimed that the 1-drug lethal injection protocol posed "a substantial risk of serious pain, violating their rights against cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment."

But Lodge granted the State of Idaho's motion to dismiss Leavitt's claim and denied Leavitt's injunction seeking a stay of execution.

Leavitt was convicted of 1st-degree murder for the stabbing death of Deanette Elg in Blackfoot. He was 1st sentenced to death in 1985 and following a remand from the Idaho Supreme Court, was resentenced to death in 1990. Leavitt sought relief from his conviction and death sentence in state and federal court for the next 22 years, but to no avail.

Source: Boise Weekly, June 5, 2012


News media witnesses at executions an Idaho tradition

As Idaho’s news media spar with the state in federal court over limits on access to executions, the case has turned a spotlight on Idaho’s long and consistent history of media witnesses attending its state executions to serve as the eyes and ears of the public.

Media witnesses have been present for all but 1 Idaho execution since 1901 and published detailed accounts of them.

“The body swung not to the right and left, the rope made not a single twist, but facing the sun in the eastern sky, like one standing erect, all that was mortal of Ed Rice was there before his fellows, while the tide of life fast ebbed away,” the Idaho Daily Statesman reported in 1901, recounting the 1st state execution held at Idaho’s state prison.

Prior to 1901, executions were conducted at the county level in Idaho, and most were public, with hundreds attending.

Idaho’s news media, including the Associated Press, The Spokesman-Review, the Idaho Press Club and more than a dozen other news outlets and organizations, are suing in federal court over Idaho’s current execution procedures, which bar witnesses from the first portion of the lethal injection procedure, when the condemned prisoner is strapped down to a gurney and IVs are inserted.

The media have been in discussions with the state over the issue since before Paul Ezra Rhoades was executed in November, but the state has refused to change its procedure. Now, another Idaho execution is scheduled: Richard Leavitt is scheduled to die by lethal injection on June 12.

The lawsuit cites a 2002 9th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals decision that held it was a violation of the 1st Amendment to the U.S. Constitution to exclude media witnesses, and by extension the public, from the full procedure, from the moment the condemned person enters the execution chamber to the time of death. That case was brought by the news media in California. However, only 2 states in the 9th Circuit - California and Nevada - have been complying with the 2002 decision.

U.S. District Judge Edward Lodge is now considering arguments from the media and from the state, which has defended its procedures; he is expected to rule shortly. The state has argued that allowing witnesses to view the 1st portion of the procedure would violate the condemned prisoner’s privacy, could impact other death row inmates, would cause suffering for the prisoner’s family and friends, and could identify members of the execution team. However, the team is masked and wears surgical garb.

“Few of us know with any certainty when or how we will die,” the state’s attorneys wrote in legal filings. “If we did, would we want our full gamut of emotion, or our contemplation of eternity or cessation of existence, or our regret or defiance, on display? Or would we prefer some final, private moments during the arrangements for the execution before the curtain is opened?”

The media, in legal papers filed Monday, argued that 1st Amendment concerns outweigh those issues, and that inmates’ privacy rights are limited.

“Witness attendance at an execution assures public involvement in the process, and transparency fuels informed public debate, which is the main purpose behind granting a right of access to governmental proceedings,” wrote the news media’s attorney, Charles Brown of Lewiston.

No such questions were raised in the early days of Idaho executions, when news reporters had full access to the entire execution process.

In 1901, the Idaho Daily Statesman reporter, Fred Flood, wrote that he and other newsmen were ushered into Rice’s cell, to hear the death warrant read to the condemned man, after the warden “stated that only those present in a religious, official or reportical capacity could enter the cell, on account of its size.”

They then followed the prisoner to the gallows where he would be hanged, and reported in detail on the entire procedure, up to when guards placed the body in a coffin and “carried it to one of the small houses on the (prison) grounds.”

Similar detailed, first-hand accounts were published in the newspapers of the day of executions carried out at the Idaho State Penitentiary in 1904, 1906, 1909, 1924 and 1926.

In 1909, the Idaho Daily Statesman published a photograph of a hand-written, elaborately lettered invitation/ticket the newspaper had received the day before from Warden John W. Snook, stating, “Admit Reporter Boise Statesman, To the execution of Fred Seward, May 7th, at 8 o’clock a.m.” The warden signed his name at the bottom with a flourish.

The only state execution at which members of the Idaho news media weren’t present was a hurry-up double hanging in the middle of the night in 1951, when a frightened prison warden who feared inmate riots refused all requests from outside witnesses, had the gallows erected starting at 5 p.m. for the midnight execution, and had all traces of them removed by morning. The hanging of the two men, ages 20 and 21, was highly controversial due to their age; they had murdered a local grocer.

At Idaho’s last hanging in 1957, several newspaper reporters were present but declined, at the final moment, to enter the observation room at the new indoor gallows. There, a dozen witnesses saw the condemned man, Raymond Allen Snowden, strapped to a full-length backboard, fall awkwardly through the trap door and take 15 minutes to die.

Prison guard Mark Maxwell, who attended the execution, told an Idaho Oral History Center interviewer in 1981, “There was two or three newspaper guys here. … They didn’t want in - they all waited out here.”

Idaho has conducted 2 executions since 1957, both by lethal injection. At each of those, media witnesses were admitted to the execution chamber and documented what they saw.

Associated Press reporter Bob Fick was among the witnesses at the execution of Keith Eugene Wells in 1994. In a 2011 National Public Radio interview, he remembered the lethal injection procedure as “sterile and antiseptic,” in contrast to Wells’ crime, in which Wells beat his two victims to death with a baseball bat at a Boise bar.

In November of 2011, Idaho executed triple murderer Paul Ezra Rhoades. 4 media witnesses attended and shared their observations with other reporters and the public in a pooled arrangement. Idaho Press-Tribune reporter Nate Green said the procedure was “very quiet and somber.” He also reported that once Rhoades was dead, a friend of one of Rhoades’ victims muttered, “The devil has gone home.”

Source: The Spokesman-Review, June 4, 2012

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

U.S.: Five Western states shielding part of executions

BOISE, Idaho – A San Francisco-based federal appeals court ruled in 2002 that every aspect of an execution should be open to witnesses, from the moment the condemned enters into the death chamber to his final heartbeat.

The ruling established what was expected of the nine Western states within the court's jurisdiction. A decade later, five of the states have kept part of each execution away from public view, according to an Associated Press review and death penalty experts.

Idaho, Arizona, Washington, Montana and Nevada have conducted 15 lethal injections since the ruling, and half of each procedure has been behind closed doors.

That means that a small group of witnesses, including members of news organizations who act as representatives of the public, do not see, for instance, the insertion of the IVs that deliver the fatal drug mixture.

The practice comes at a time when the method itself has drawn greater scrutiny, from whether the drugs are effective to whether the execution personnel are properly trained.

The states that limit access say they do so to protect the anonymity of the execution team, which may include emergency medical technicians, military medics or others trained to insert IVs. Open government and journalism groups argue that witnessing all aspects of an execution is the only way to determine if it is being properly carried out.

The AP and 16 other organizations on Tuesday sued the state of Idaho to force officials to open the entirety of their executions, arguing that the news media and by extension the public has a First Amendment right to view all steps of lethal injections.

"This lawsuit is really all about obtaining access to the entire execution process for viewing purposes," said Chuck Brown, the attorney representing the news organizations. "It's very important in a society such as ours to have full transparency in regards to the exercise of government authority."

Idaho Department of Correction spokesman Jeff Ray said late Tuesday the department had not yet had a chance to review the lawsuit, and that the state's attorneys would respond to the claims in court.

Several high-profile cases since 2006 have raised questions about the way states conduct lethal injections.

In two instances in Ohio, one of the few states that allow witnesses to see the entire process, corrections staff couldn't find a vein. In one of those cases, officials halted the execution and the inmate remains on death row. With news organizations present, the experiences of the inmate, Romell Broom, were widely reported.

In another case, in Florida in 2006, which does not allow viewing of the IV insertions, executioners pushed the needles through Angel Nieves Diaz's target veins and into the soft tissue beneath. He had to be given a second dose and took 34 minutes to die — more than twice the normal time.

Historically, the public was able to watch executions from start to finish, said Trina Seitz, a death penalty expert at Appalachian State University.

Over time, executions became more private as technology advanced. Electrocutions, for example, can't be done in a rainy prison yard for safety reasons, so they were moved inside, said Stuart Banner, a legal historian at UCLA's School of Law.

Still, journalists have always been reserved a spot among the witnesses, Seitz said, so they could report the death back to the public.

In the 1990s, several news organizations attempted to get on the witness list for the lethal injection of William Bonin in California. Bonin was dubbed the "Freeway Killer" for the serial murders of 14 young men and boys.

Those who did witness the execution were unsure about what they saw.

Bonin was already strapped to a gurney with IV tubes attached when the death chamber's curtains were drawn open. He barely moved, and his eyes were closed. A few silent minutes passed, and then he was pronounced dead.

The California First Amendment Coalition sued, saying the limited access violated the public's first amendment rights to view executions. California officials argued the restriction was necessary to preserve the execution team's anonymity.

In 2002, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected that argument, saying there were other ways to protect their identity. Execution team members could wear surgical masks, hats and gloves, the court noted.

"Independent public scrutiny — made possible by the public and media witnesses to an execution — plays a significant role in the proper functioning of capital punishment," the judges ruled.

The ruling applies to a region that stretches from Montana to Hawaii and Alaska. Alaska, Hawaii, Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands do not have the death penalty, and Oregon currently has a moratorium on executions. Only California has followed the ruling.

Outside the region, there are 27 states that use lethal injection. Ohio changed its rules in 2004 after the American Civil Liberties Union threatened to sue. For 25 years, Georgia has allowed a reporter to act as a "monitor" during the process, while other witnesses enter the viewing chamber later.

In Idaho, when made aware of the 2002 court ruling, state officials said the decision did not apply to their procedures. "The circumstances of the case are unique to California," said Idaho deputy attorney general for prisons, Mark Kubinski. But Kubinski, other state attorneys, the governor's office and corrections officials have refused to say exactly why.

Kubinski said the protocol balances the public's right to witness executions with the state's obligation to carry it out "in a safe and professional manner, while maintaining respect and dignity for all parties."

During Idaho's most recent execution, Paul Ezra Rhoades, who was convicted of killing three people in 1987, could not be seen as he was brought into the death chamber. When the curtains were drawn, IVs were already connected.

When asked by a reporter about what happened before the curtains were opened, the corrections director, Brent Reinke, said the procedure was somber and professional and described how the IVs and other equipment was inserted.

Rhoades' attorneys had sued in federal court, arguing that Idaho's death penalty protocol created the opportunity for several excruciating errors. Of most concern was incorrect IV placement, which could leave him paralyzed but conscious.

The legal scholars contacted by the AP who reviewed the California court case said it would be difficult to find a ruling that applies more closely to Idaho's policies.

Jen Moreno, a staff attorney with the Death Penalty Clinic at the University of California's Berkeley Law, said the ruling sets precedent for all states within the 9th Circuit and that the non-complying states would likely be forced to change their policies if they were challenged in federal court.

Moreno said the process of setting the IVs is the most crucial part of lethal injection because, if it is done incorrectly, the rest of the execution can go awry.

"The fact that the states are hiding one of the most important parts of the execution, setting the IV, really means that what the public does see is not going to be very telling of whether it was a humane execution," she said.

Source: AP, May 23, 2012


AP, news groups sue Idaho over execution access

The execution scene from
"Dead Man Walking" (1995) with
Sean Penn and Susan Sarandon
BOISE, Idaho (AP) — The Associated Press and 16 other organizations sued the state of Idaho on Tuesday to force officials to let witnesses watch executions from start to finish, arguing that the media has a First Amendment right to view all steps of a lethal injection execution.

The group asked a U.S. District Court judge to require the state to increase witness access to its executions, starting with the upcoming execution of Richard A. Leavitt, a convicted killer scheduled to be put to death on June 12.

The AP was joined in the lawsuit by the Idaho Press Club, Idahoans for Openness in Government, the Idaho Statesman, The Times-News, Lewiston Tribune, Moscow-Pullman Daily News and The Spokesman-Review.

Also joining was Pioneer Newspapers, which owns several newspapers including the Idaho Press-Tribune, the Idaho State Journal, the Rexburg Standard Journal and others.

Idaho, like most states with lethal injection, bars witnesses from watching as a condemned inmate is brought into the execution chamber, strapped to the table and has IVs inserted into his or her arms. The news organizations say reporters must be able to view executions from start to finish so they can accurately report the events — and any complications that may emerge — to the public.

Some death row inmates have challenged the constitutionality of lethal injection executions in court, contending that the insertion of the IVs can be easily botched, causing severe pain for the condemned.

"This lawsuit is really all about obtaining access to the entire execution process for viewing purposes. It's very important in a society such as ours to have full transparency in regards to the exercise of government authority," said Chuck Brown, the attorney representing the news organizations.

The states that grant access to part of the death penalty process say they do so to protect the anonymity of the execution team. Idaho Department of Correction spokesman Jeff Ray said the department had not yet had a chance to review the lawsuit, and that the state's attorneys would respond to the claims in court.

The lawsuit relies heavily on a 2002 San Francisco-based federal appeals court ruling that found that witnesses should be allowed to view executions from the moment the condemned enters the death chamber until their final heartbeat.

Since the ruling, only one state under the court's nine-state jurisdiction is following it: California, where the case arose. Idaho, Arizona, Washington, Montana and Nevada have all barred witnesses from the first half of lethal injection executions.

Most states nationwide do the same. Of the 27 states that have lethal injection outside of the circuit's jurisdiction, only Ohio and Georgia allow witnesses to see the entire process.

The lawsuit comes at a time when questions have been raised about whether the lethal cocktail of drugs used in the procedure is effective and whether the execution staff is properly trained.

The Idaho organizations decided to sue after state officials limited access to the execution of Paul Ezra Rhoades. Put to death in November, Rhoades was the first person to be executed in the state in 17 years, and only the second in the last half-century. Media interest in the event was intense, and the department selected four journalists to view the proceedings.

But none of the witnesses were allowed to watch as Rhoades entered the death chamber, was strapped to the execution table and had IVs inserted in his arms.

That portion was of particular interest because in the weeks preceding his death, Rhoades had argued in federal court that those initial steps were the most likely to go awry. His lawyers said an improperly inserted IV could cause him extreme pain.

At the time, Idaho Department of Correction officials maintained that the first steps of the execution had to be kept private to protect the anonymity of the execution team.

The 2002 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals case was brought by the California First Amendment Coalition against California Department of Correction officials. The court found that preventing reporters — and through them, the public — from viewing all aspects of executions is an unconstitutional violation of the First Amendment.

The news media must be allowed to witness executions in their entirety so that the public can have an informed debate about whether execution by lethal injection meets the evolving standards of decency present in a maturing society, the court found.

"To determine whether lethal injection executions are fairly and humanely administered, or whether they ever can be, citizens must have reliable information about the 'initial procedures' which are invasive, possibly painful and may give rise to serious complications," Judge Raymond Fisher wrote for the unanimous three-judge panel that heard the case.

Source: AP, May 23, 2012

Friday, May 18, 2012

Idaho Opts For 1 Drug Only In Execution Policy

BOISE, Idaho -- Idaho's corrections chief says the agency is switching to a one-drug lethal injection for future executions of death row inmates.

Idaho Department of Corrections Director Brent Reinke said Friday execution teams will administer a single, lethal dose of the surgical sedative pentobarbital.

That's a change from the execution carried out by the agency last fall, when the condemned inmate was injected with three-drug mixture, which included pentobarbital.

Reinke says the change was driven by difficulties in obtaining the other two chemicals used to kill Paul Ezra Rhoades in November.

The decision makes Idaho the latest death penalty state to switch to using only pentobarbital in its lethal injection.

Reinke says the one-drug protocol will be used in the June 12 execution of convicted murderer Richard Leavitt.

Source: The Associated Press, May 18, 2012

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Idaho set to execute second Death Row inmate within a year

BOISE, Idaho (AP) — A 7th District Judge has signed a death warrant for condemned inmate Richard Albert Leavitt, ordering that he be executed by lethal injection.

Barring any last-minute court intervention, Leavitt will be put to death on June 12.

Leavitt was convicted in the July 18, 1984, brutal death of Danette Elg in Blackfoot.

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to consider Leavitt's appeal Monday, and Judge Jon Shindurling signed the death warrant Thursday.

If Leavitt's execution moves forward as planned, he will become the second person executed by the state in the last seven months. Paul Ezra Rhoades, who was convicted of killing three people in eastern Idaho in 1987, was put to death on Nov. 18, 2011.

Before Rhoades' death, executions were rare in Idaho, with only one other inmate put to death in the last half-century. But several death row inmates appear to be reaching the end of the appeals process, and last year Idaho Department of Correction officials predicted there could be as many as four people executed before the end of 2013.


Source: AP, KlewTV, May 17, 2012

Related video: Life on Idaho's Death Row - Excerpt:
"Death row inmates are kept in their cells 23 hours a day, and only let out for an hour of exercise. The only other time they leave is to be escorted to the shower, or if they have appointments with attorneys or doctors. Before a death row inmate is let out, they're handcuffed through the door's utility port.
A typical cell is about 12 feet long by seven feet wide and includes a shelf, coaxial cable for television, electrical outlets for fans and hot pots, and a narrow window.
Outside maximum security, the current execution chamber is literally a mobile home. But Idaho Department of Correction officials say it's likely a new facility will be built before the next inmate is put to death.
Lethal injection is the form of execution in Idaho.
The option of the firing squad was overturned recently. Idaho has only put one inmate to death since the death penalty was reinstated in the 1970's."

Wednesday, April 11, 2012

4 death row inmates sue over Idaho's newest lethal injection procedures

Idaho Execution Chamber
4 inmates on Idaho's death row are suing the state, contending Idaho's new execution procedures give too much power to prison officials, create a risk of severe pain and would allow unqualified workers to carry out medical procedures. The lawsuit, filed in Boise's U.S. District Court late last week, asks a judge to stop all executions until the problems are fixed.

The lawsuit against the Idaho Department of Correction's Director Brent Reinke, Operations Division Chief Kevin Kempf and other department officials comes as the men prepare for the possibility of an execution sometime in late spring or early summer. Richard Leavitt, convicted of the brutal 1984 stabbing death of Danette Jean Elg in Blackfoot, is waiting to see if the U.S. Supreme Court will consider his case. If the high court refuses, Leavitt could be the next inmate to enter the lethal injection chamber at the Idaho Maximum Security Institution.

Leavitt is joined in the lawsuit by fellow condemned inmates Thomas Creech, James Hairston and Gene Stuart. All four men are represented by the Federal Public Defender's office.

In the 37-page lawsuit, the inmates take issue with Idaho's newest version of the execution policy, adopted by the department earlier this year.

The new policy allows the state to use either a 3-drug mixture for lethal injections, or to opt to use just one drug. It also changed the name of the team that administers the lethal injection from "injection team" to "medical team" and limited the legal ramifications for health professionals involved with executions.

It also can be changed at any time, under the sole discretion of one of two IDOC officials, without any notice to death row inmates or their attorneys. If unforeseen developments occur during an execution, Director Brent Reinke or Idaho Maximum Security Institution Warden Randy Blades can determine how to respond without any constraints on their discretion.

That gives too much power to the IDOC officials, the inmates contend, and violates the inmates' right to due process.

"Executing any plaintiff without notice of the procedures to be used denies each plaintiff the right to a reasonable opportunity to review and to be heard, in violation of the right to due process," attorney Oliver Loewy wrote on behalf of inmates in the lawsuit.

The lawsuit also takes issue with the way Idaho officials might obtain the drugs used in lethal injection execution, with the inmates contending that the drugs would likely be illegally obtained or adulterated in some way.

The new protocol doesn't require that members of the medical team have current professional experience inserting or maintaining IVs on a regular basis, the inmates claim, nor does it require that they have any experience or training in preparing chemicals for injection.

That creates the possibility of error, and extreme pain for the condemned, the inmates claim.

The state has not yet filed a response to the lawsuit.

Source: Associated Press, April 11, 2012

Monday, February 6, 2012

Idaho: Changes for state execution policy and procedures

Idaho Execution Chamber
BOISE, Idaho - Right after Paul Rhoades became the first person executed in Idaho in more than 50 years, department of correction administrators reviewed the execution and felt some changes needed to be made prior to any future executions.

IDOC director Brent Reinke said his department has sense made changes in the standard operation procedure.

"This needs to be flawless and we need to do the right job for our state. It's a significant undertaking and it's something that we wanted to make sure as we debrief and find areas where we can improve the process," Reinke said.

Under the improved operating procedure, the warden will no longer be solely in charge of every aspect of the execution.

"There's just too many areas around the facility for that individual to take care of in this kind of setting so we have an administrative team that can be spread out a little more," Reinke said.

The administrative team will handle most of the logistics surrounding the execution while the warden continues to focus on the day-to-day operations.

Members of the media are usually selected as witnesses of the execution but in the past, the selection occurred on the day of the event. Under the new policy, members of the media will be selected seven day in advance.

"That will give us some time to work with those media witnesses prior to them representing the public in that event," Reinke said.

The new policy also allows additional witnesses related to the case to view the execution.

When Paul Rhoades was put to death, executioners used a three-drug protocol to do the job but for future cases, executioners will have the option to use a single lethal dose of drugs.

"We want to have in our standard operating procedure the flexibility to either use the three as we did and that would be our intentions, but if there were some reason that we would want to use the one drug protocol that is a part of the three, then we would have the flexibility to be able to do that," Reinke said.

During past executions, the team responsible for administering the lethal injection was labeled the injection team but Reinke said their title has changed to medical team.

There are other ideas Reinke would like to put in place regarding execution procedures and policies but KBOI was told those specific recommendations would require approval from state law makers.

Source: KBOI2.com, Feb. 5, 2012

Related video here

Saturday, November 19, 2011

Demonstrators voice their position on Rhoades’ execution

Protestors gather at the entrance to Idaho's
Maximum Security Institution in protest

against the execution of Paul Ezra Rhoades,
Friday, Nov. 18, 2011, in Boise, Idaho.
Bright lights cast shadows in the darkness Friday morning as the first protesters arrived. As the sun rose over the South Idaho Correctional Institution, roughly 100 demonstrators gathered to voice their opposition to capital punishment in one prison lot, while a dozen turned out in support of Paul Ezra Rhoades’ execution in another.

Most of those opposed huddled in a circle, lighting candles while Mia Crosthwaite of Idahoans Against the Death Penalty led a prayer. A smaller cluster simply sat facing the prison in silence. For those in favor of the execution, motivations ranged from showing support for the victims and their families — at least one pro-death-penalty demonstrator had known a Rhoades victim personally — to expressing the importance of free speech and assembly.

But regardless of their motivations, they all had one thing in common: Convictions strong enough to brave the early morning cold and darkness.

“I think it’s immoral and it’s wrong to have state-sanctioned killings, and I think that for a nation that claims to be a nation of Christians, we’re a nation of hypocrites,” Michael Lucero of Caldwell said. “Actions speak louder than words, and we need to have our voices heard. The laws will never change until the people’s hearts change.”

On the other side of the field, Craig Bennett stood with a sign depicting victim and schoolteacher Susan Michelbacher, accompanied by the words “My teacher, my friend.” Bennett, an 8th and 9th grade student of Michelbacher’s, described her as one of his favorite teachers.

Michelbacher disappeared a few years after he sat in her classroom, Bennett said. When he first heard the news, he thought there must be some mistake. When her body was found a few days later, however, he said he wasn’t surprised. With a small child at home, he said, she wouldn’t have left town on her own.

Bennett was visibly emotional Friday as he talked about the lessons and memories he carries nearly three decades later.

“For me, it’s not about the politics, although there is that component, of course. For me, it’s about remembering that there were victims involved in this,” Bennett said. “I’m honestly conflicted about the death penalty, for or against. But that’s not what brings me out here.”

Colin McNamara of Boise braved the frigid Friday morning in a red t-shirt to lend his voice to the crowd. He wasn’t making any particular statement, he said, he’s just “built for the cold.” He added a scarf to the ensemble as the morning progressed, though it may not have helped much.

“As a citizen or Idaho, it disturbs me that this man is being put to death in my name,” McNamara said. “I am part of the apparatus that kills him. So I came here to pray over that fact.”

Some demonstrators had endured the cold for hours when Rhoades was executed at 9:15 a.m. Protesters formed a line and faced the prison complex as the appointed time arrived, standing in silence for several minutes with their heads bowed in silent prayer. As the sun came out from behind the clouds, they returned to their vehicles quickly and quietly.

“We’re going to do away with the death penalty,” demonstrator Henry Krewer said as the crowd dispersed. “It’s going to happen. And because it’s going to happen, it’s like the guy killed on the last day of the war. Why are we killing people when we know where the tide is going?”

In a recent Idaho Press-Tribune online poll, 89 % of respondents voiced their support for Rhoades’ execution, though comparatively few faced the chilly November morning to counter those protesting the event. For Chris Bentley of Boise — who favors capital punishment — the right to assemble and speak freely is the most important thing, regardless of one’s position.

“I wanted to come out and support any voice to be heard,” Bentley said. “I’m definitely more on the side of being for the death penalty, but I understand where they’re coming from as well.”

Source: Idaho Press-Tribune, November 19, 2011

Friday, November 18, 2011

Idaho executes Paul Ezra Rhoades

Paul Rhoades
BOISE, Idaho (AP) — Idaho has executed a convicted murderer for his role in the 1987 slayings of two women — the state's first capital punishment in 17 years.

Paul Ezra Rhoades was declared dead at 9:15 a.m. Friday. He died by lethal injection at the Idaho Maximum Security Institution in Boise.

Rhoades was convicted in the kidnapping and murders of 34-year-old Susan Michelbacher and 21-year-old Stacy Dawn Baldwin.

The execution of the 54-year-old Idaho Falls native was the first in Idaho since 1994.

Rhoades acknowledged killing the women but has appealed his case and Idaho's execution protocol. His appeals were denied at the state and federal level, including an appeal Thursday with the U.S. Supreme Court.

Rhoades was the first person executed in Idaho since 1994 and the only person to be involuntarily put to death in the state since 1957.

Rhoades becomes the 43rd condemned inmate to be put to death this year in the USA and the 1277th overall since the nation resumed executions on January 17, 1977. One more execution is scheduled in the USA this year, in Oregon, on Dec. 6. If carreid out as expected, there would be 44 executions in the country this year, continuing a downward trend; there were 46 executions in the USA last year and 52 in 2009.

Source: AP, November 18, 2011

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Idaho urged to prevent first execution in 17 years

Paul Rhoades is set to be put to death by lethal injection

The US state of Idaho should prevent its 1st execution in 17 years, Amnesty International has urged ahead of tomorrow's planned execution of a death row prisoner.

Paul Rhoades, 54, is due to be put to death by lethal injection on Friday, in what would be Idaho's 1st execution since 1994, and only its 2nd in more than half a century.

"The execution of Paul Rhoades looms at a time when many in the USA are questioning the death penalty and when a clear majority of countries have turned against judicial killing," said Rob Freer, Amnesty International's USA researcher.

Paul Rhoades has been on death row for nearly a quarter of a century. He was arrested on 25 March 1987 and charged with three separate murders committed over the previous month. He was sentenced to death a year later.

The Idaho Commission of Pardons and Parole has refused to hold a clemency hearing for Paul Rhoades.

He had sought the hearing and a commutation of his death sentence to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

His petition stated: "Over the past 24 years, I learned that repentance is the only positive way to express my guilt and remorse. For me, repentance means finding ways to make amends for my actions, even if those efforts seem inconsequential in comparison to the crimes I committed--I try to make amends by helping others move from anger toward reconciliation."

A number of Rhoades' fellow inmates submitted letters in support of clemency saying he had changed their lives by persuading them to turn away from violence or by helping them in other ways.

"The death penalty rejects any notion of reconciliation or rehabilitation, labelling the condemned prisoner as an object to be toyed with and discarded. This is a punishment that offers no constructive solutions to violent crime,” said Rob Freer.

Lawyers for Paul Rhoades are challenging Idaho’s lethal injection procedures, including the selection and training of the execution team. On Monday, a federal judge refused to issue a stay of execution. The issue is now before the US Court of Appeals.

Paul Rhoades’ childhood was marked by physical, psychological and emotional abuse. In 2006, a psychologist described his as "a damaged human being with little opportunity to be a healthy adult”.

The judges who imposed the death sentences on Rhoades did not have the full picture about his background and severe addiction to the drug methamphetamine.

Rhoades' victims were school teacher Susan Michelbacher and convenience store clerks Stacy Baldwin and Nolan Haddon.

He received 2 death sentences for the murders of Stacy Baldwin and Susan Michelbacher, and life imprisonment for the murder of Nolan Haddon.

There are 14 people under sentence of death in Idaho. The last execution, of Keith Wells in 1994, was the first in the state since 1957. Keith Wells had given up appeals against his death sentence.

There have been 42 executions in the USA this year and 1,276 since judicial killing resumed there in 1977.

Source: Amnesty International, November 17, 2011


The Final Hours of Paul Ezra Rhoades

Prior to scheduled execution death row inmate meets with spiritual advisers and family

Sometime Wednesday, a medical team will take a needle and prick the arm of an individual inside the F Block of the Idaho Maximum Security Institute. No, it's not the premature execution of Paul Ezra Rhoades, who is scheduled to die by lethal injection on Friday morning. Instead an Idaho Department of Correction staff member will be pretending to be Rhoades as the men and women who will carry out Friday's execution go through one of the final rehearsals before Friday.

"We are going through the entire process, word-by-word, minute-by-minute,"? IDOC Director Brent Reinke told Citydesk. "We run all the way through it and debrief, and then we run through it again and debrief."

In one of his final interviews before Friday's planned execution Reinke told Citydesk that Rhoades has had regular visits from 4 individuals.

"His spiritual adviser has been seeing him on a regular basis," said Reinke. "His attorney has been regularly meeting with him, and his mother and sister have visited him every day since last Thursday."

On Thursday, Rhoades' personal belongings will be taken and inventoried and apart from his clothes, Rhoades will be allowed only one religious item.

"He's been spending a lot of time with the Bible and an additional book, which is scripture-based," said Reinke. "He's concerned about when his last visits will be from his spiritual adviser and his mother and sister. I expect that his attorney will be spending a good part of Thursday night with him."

Rhoades' last meal will not be out of the ordinary.

"I think he was concerned about setting some kind of precedence with his last meal, so he's opted to have what the rest of the prisoner population will be eating," said Reinke. "We'll probably put some ice cream on the tray for him. That's a bit unusual, but we know that he likes strawberry ice cream. During the night, we'll offer him a final snack, some crackers and cheese, to help settle his stomach."

Rhoades will also be offered a sedative a couple of times through Thursday night and early Friday.

Source: Boise Weekly, November 15, 2011

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Judge denies stay of execution for Rhoades

A federal judge has refused to postpone the execution of an Idaho inmate slated to be put to death this Friday.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Ronald Bush said in a 43-page ruling Monday he would not grant a stay of execution to Paul Ezra Rhoades.

Rhoades, who was convicted of killing three people and sentenced to death for two of the murders, is scheduled to die by lethal injection Nov. 18.

He is suing the state in federal court, contending that Idaho’s execution method can be easily botched and so amounts to cruel and unusual punishment, and he asked Bush to put his execution on hold while the lawsuit works through the courts.

State attorneys countered that Idaho’s lethal injection process closely mirrors lethal injection protocol in other states that has already been upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court. The process relies on 3 drugs administered through IV: First, an anesthetic meant to make the condemned inmate deeply unconscious, followed by a paralytic that will make the inmate unable to draw breath, and finally a drug that will stop the inmate’s heart.

The judge said he agreed that the execution, if done incorrectly, could leave Rhoades in agony as he dies. But he also said the Idaho Department of Correction has done enough to safeguard against that error.

“The Court agrees with the parties that if Rhoades is not rendered sufficiently unconscious from the 1st drug used in the 3-drug lethal injection protocol, then he will certainly suffer excruciating suffocation and pain from the remaining 2 drugs. The Court also finds, as agreed by the parties, that if properly anesthetized, there will be no risk of pain for Rhoades.”

Bush went on to say that Idaho isn’t required to implement a 1-drug execution — which essentially overdoses an inmate with an anesthetic — as Rhoades had wanted. The judge said that’s because Rhoades didn’t make a “more certain showing” that the existing 3-drug protocol raises a substantial risk of serious harm.

“The State of Idaho has an interest in seeing that its laws are enforced, and further delay will not meet that interest,” Bush wrote.

The ruling appears to clear the way for Rhoades’ execution, scheduled for Friday at 8 a.m. If the execution happens, it will be Idaho’s 1st in 17 years and the only one in the last half-century to happen without the consent of the condemned inmate.

Rhoades was given 2 death sentences for the sexual assault and murder of Idaho Falls teacher Susan Michelbacher, 34, whose bullet-riddled body was found in March 1987. He also was given 2 death sentences for the 1st-degree murder and kidnapping of Stacy Dawn Baldwin, 21, a Blackfoot convenience store clerk who was shot to death in February 1987.

Rhoades was also sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole after pleading guilty to the March 1987 shooting death of Nolan Haddon, 20, a Blackfoot man who worked at an Idaho Falls convenience store.

The state’s last execution, in 1994, was of Keith Eugene Wells, who gave up his remaining appeals and asked to be put to death. The prior execution was in 1957.

During a court hearing in Rhoades’ case on Thursday, Rhoades’ attorneys took issue with testimony from a prison official in charge of selecting the execution team members. Bureau of Prisons Chief Deputy Jeff Zmuda said he didn’t verify the team members’ credentials or training, and said the documents he did review about the team members were destroyed. The judge indicated that he didn’t take that contention lightly, but carefully weighed the evidence and prior court rulings.

“There is no way to make this judicial proceeding, and the starkness of the decision before the Court, appear as if it is either mundanely routine or somehow freighted with great wisdom because the decision is made by someone who wears a judicial robe,” Bush said. “Similarly, the heartwood of logic and adherence to the Rule of Law that the Court seeks to bring to the question cannot hide the ultimate end of a decision adverse to Rhoades.”

The message of the Supreme Court in previous rulings is unmistakable, Bush said — speculation cannot substitute for evidence that some part of the protocol is very likely to cause needless suffering. The evidence that some of the execution team members might have exaggerated his or her credentials is neither sure nor very likely, he said, particularly since they have all taken part in group practices where others would have seen, in action, if the team member was qualified for the job.

Bush also reiterated his belief that Idaho Department of Correction officials have been “playing catch-up” in preparing for the execution. The state could have finalized its execution protocol months or even years ago — instead of weeks — but department officials have since made up for much of the lost time, the judge noted.

Rhoades has an interest in seeing his lawsuit through to its end, Bush said, but the state has an interest in seeing its judgment carried out as well — a process that has taken 24 years so far. The families and communities of the victims in the case also have a compelling interest, he wrote.

“There is much that has been said and written about the uncertainties and expense of death-penalty cases, and the impact that the length of time such cases place upon the families and communities of the victims,” Bush wrote. “… Continued delay compounds those uncertainties, expenses, and impacts, and therefore is not in the public interest.”

Source: Associated Press, November 14, 2011