Showing posts with label Michigan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Michigan. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 9, 2013

The Execution Standard

As the oldest constitutional democracy in the world, the United States is often criticized for continuing to carry out state-sanctioned executions. Over the past couple of generations, every European country, with the exception of Belarus, has outlawed the death penalty. The principle is enshrined in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.

But we have not always been the throwbacks. In fact, in the 17th and 18th centuries, the English colonies had far fewer capital laws than England and other European states.

My students have been reading the Massachusetts Body of Liberties, written in 1641 as a guide for the colony's General Court. It included 12 capital laws. Religious crimes such as witchcraft and blasphemy came first, then murder (three different types), then sex crimes (rape was not among them), followed by kidnapping, bearing false witness in a capital case, and treason. That seemed like a lot, until we discovered that the list of capital crimes back in the old country was more than 10 times as long.

The Puritans were certainly not free thinkers. They harassed and tortured religious and political dissenters, and they were perfectly willing to execute criminals in capital cases. But they radically reduced the number of offenses punishable by death under English law.


Source: philly.com, October 9, 2013

Wednesday, May 29, 2013

Exceptions to Harsh Rules

On Tuesday [May 28, 2013], the Supreme Court handed down two important criminal procedure decisions, both allowing defendants to seek habeas corpus review of their convictions in federal court.

The 5-to-4 majority, with Justice Anthony Kennedy joining the court’s four moderate liberals, reached the right result in each case. But, in a larger sense, the two decisions show how much the scope of habeas review has been curtailed by the Supreme Court in the last three decades, so that it now must work around earlier precedents to avoid doing injustice.

In a case from Texas, Trevino v. Thaler, the court ruled that a death-row inmate in Texas can make the claim of ineffective counsel for the first time in a federal habeas petition because the rules of Texas procedure made it virtually impossible for him to raise that issue during an appeal in state court.

In a case from Michigan, McQuiggin v. Perkins, the court ruled correctly that an inmate who can make a credible showing of actual innocence is not barred from filing a habeas petition to have his case reviewed by a federal court — even if the petition is filed after the one-year limit for such claims under the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996, the federal statute that sets forth rules about habeas use.

The federal statute says a state prisoner ordinarily has a year to file a federal habeas petition after the conviction becomes final or after he should have discovered the new evidence that he claims supports his innocence.


Source: The New York Times, Editorial Board, May 28, 2013


Divided Court, in 2 Rulings, Makes It Easier to Challenge Criminal Convictions

WASHINGTON — In a pair of 5-to-4 decisions that divided along ideological lines, the Supreme Court on Tuesday made it easier for inmates to challenge their convictions.

In McQuiggin v. Perkins, No. 12-126, the majority said that a one-year filing deadline for prisoners seeking federal review of their state court convictions under a 1996 law may be relaxed if they present compelling evidence of their innocence. The new “miscarriage of justice exception” to the deadline, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote for the majority, “applies to a severely confined category” — cases in which no reasonable juror aware of the new evidence would have voted to convict the defendant.

The decision did not seem likely to help the prisoner whose case was under review, but the exception it announced drew a barbed dissent from Justice Antonin Scalia, who called the majority opinion “a series of transparent non sequiturs” and “a flagrant breach of the separation of powers.”

In the second decision issued Tuesday, in Trevino v. Thaler, No. 11-10189, the same five-justice majority extended a ruling last year that had allowed prisoners to challenge their state convictions in federal courts based on the argument that their trial lawyers had been ineffective, even though the prisoners had not raised the issue in earlier proceedings.


Source: The New York Times, May 29, 2013


Justice Scalia: Ensuring Innocent People Get Out Of Prison Is A ‘Faustian Bargain’

A man who may be locked up for a murder he did not commit should not be allowed to challenge his conviction, according to Justice Antonin Scalia and his three most conservative colleagues. And three members of the Supreme Court seem to believe that most people jailed due to unconstitutional convictions should have no recourse to the federal courts. At least, that’s what emerges from a four justice dissenting opinion written by Scalia in a case dealing with the rights of state prisoners who may be “actually innocent” of the crime they were convicted of committing.

McQuiggin v. Perkins is a fairly unusual case. After being sentenced to life in prison for murder, Floyd Perkins spent years gathering three affidavits from witnesses corroborating his claim that another man committed the crime. Yet he sat on this new evidence for nearly six years before presenting it to a federal court. Justice Scalia’s dissent claims that a one year statute of limitations prevents Perkins from presenting six year-old evidence that he may be innocent. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s majority opinion holds that “actual innocence” may overcome this one year time limit, although she also requires prisoners in Perkins’ shoes to overcome a very high bar before their claims of innocence may succeed in federal court.


Source: Think Progress, May 28, 2013


An Innocent Extension

The Supreme Court moves to protect the innocent, and Justice Scalia fumes.

In 1996, Congress cracked down on defendants who repeatedly try to go to court to overturn their convictions. The Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA), signed by President Bill Clinton, created a thicket of new requirements for people in prison who file last-ditch appeals—called habeas corpus petitions. The idea was that once you’ve lost your first and only direct appeal, you should only get a single try at habeas corpus (the “great writ,” dating from the 14th century, that allows a prisoner to sue his warden for release). And you were supposed to get moving quickly: The law generally imposed a new deadline of one year from the date on which you lost your direct appeal.

Congress made an exception, however: If you say you have new evidence, then you have one year from the day you could have discovered it through “the exercise of due diligence.” But what if you miss the deadline without any good excuse—and yet the new evidence could show that you are innocent? On Tuesday, the Supreme Court widened what it called the “gateway” to reviewing claims of actual innocence that are made long after the one-year deadline expires. It’s a 5-4 decision, split between liberals-plus-Kennedy and conservatives. The opinions, by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Justice Antonin Scalia, read like a pitched battle in a long-simmering war. At the end, Ginsburg succeeds in opening what she calls a “gateway” to court for innocence claims that blow by the one-year deadline.

Click here to read the full article

Source: Slate, May 28, 2013

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

Appeals Court Affirms Michigan Death Sentence

DETROIT (AP) - An appeals court on Tuesday upheld the conviction and rare federal death sentence of a western Michigan man who was accused of killing a woman in a national forest in 1997 before she could testify against him in a rape case.

Michigan outlawed the death penalty in 1846. But the victim was killed on federal property, which put the case in federal court and allowed the government to seek the ultimate punishment for Marvin Gabrion.

Gabrion’s conviction and sentence were affirmed, 12-4, by the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

A key part of Gabrion’s appeal was that his attorneys were barred from making certain argument to jurors during the sentencing phase in 2002. They couldn’t try to sway the jury against death by saying he would only face a life sentence if the trial had been in state court.

But the appeals court said Michigan’s lack of a certain punishment is not a mitigating factor to argue in a death penalty case.

Gabrion, 59, is in federal prison in Terre Haute, Indiana.

Source: AP, May 28, 2013

Thursday, June 7, 2012

USA: After 26 years in prison, Ionia man is cleared in fire that killed his family

An Ionia man who spent 26 years behind bars for murdering his wife and daughters in a house fire walked out of prison a free man Wednesday after prosecutors agreed he was convicted with faulty evidence and outdated science.

His first stop: a cemetery near Ionia to visit the graves of his wife and daughters. It was the first time he'd been there.

"It was a very emotional scene," said David Moran, a law professor and co-founder of the Innocence Clinic at the University of Michigan Law School, which fought for the release of 54-year-old David Lee Gavitt. Moran said 15-20 of Gavitt's family members also arrived to welcome him home.

Gavitt's conviction is among several nationwide that innocence projects have challenged with modern fire science.

Last week, James Kluppelberg was freed after Cook County prosecutors dropped their case against him. He had spent nearly 22 years in prison for setting a fire in Chicago that killed a mother and her five children.


Source: Detroit Free Press, June 7, 2012

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Why has Michigan opposed the death penalty for more than 150 years?

GRAND RAPIDS, MI “Michigan needs the death penalty.”

This is among the most typical of comments whenever the crime of murder leads to what, for many, is the unsatisfying conclusion of Michigan’s ultimate punishment: life in prison without the possibility of parole.

But for 165 years, capital punishment has not been an option for state juries. This is despite some unsuccessful efforts to make it so that have been stopped by voters or stalled out in legislatures, whether they be dominated by Republicans or Democrats.

“Support for capital punishment is a mile wide, but only an inch deep,” said former state Sen. William VanRegenmorter, R-Hudsonville, after a try to get the death penalty enacted in Michigan sputtered out in the 1980s.

As far back as Michigan’s first settling as a territory in 1805, the use of the death penalty was sparse. By most tallies, less than a half dozen people, many of whom were American Indians, were sentenced to capital punishment.


Source: mlive.com, Barton Deiters, April 17, 2012

Related articles:
Sep 20, 2009
The state of Michigan executed its last criminal, Stephen Simmons, in Detroit on Sept. 24, 1830, before becoming the 1st government to abolish the death penalty. The 50-year-old known drinker was convicted of beating his ...
Jul 12, 2010
Michigan has history with death penalty. In 1847, Michigan became the 1st English-speaking government to ban the death penalty. But that didn't stop the federal government from seeking the death penalty in Michigan.

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Sixth Circuit reverses first death penalty imposed in Michigan since 1937

Today the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the first death penalty to be imposed in Michigan since 1937. United States v. Gabrion, Case Nos. 02-1386, 1461, 1570, arises out of a federal murder prosecution in the United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan. 

Although Michigan abolished the death penalty in 1846, defendants convicted in the federal system are still eligible for the death penalty. Mr. Gabrion murdered a 19-year old woman and her infant daughter and dumped the bodies in Manistee National Forest giving the federal government jurisdiction to prosecute the defendant. 

Although the Sixth Circuit panel unanimously affirmed Mr. Gabrion’s conviction, Judges Merritt and Moore determined that Mr. Gabrion’s sentence must be reversed because defense was entitled to inform the jury that Mr. Gabrion would not have been eligible for the death penalty if this case had been prosecuted by Michigan state authorities. 

It is likely that the government will file for en banc review or a writ of certiorari, to appeal this case to the United States Supreme Court. Either request has a fair chance of being granted.

In 1996, the State of Michigan accused Mr. Gabrion of raping Rachel Timmerman. While awaiting trial on the rape charge, Mr. Gabrion murdered Ms. Timmerman and her young daughter. Although the child’s body was never found, Ms. Timmerman’s body was recovered on July 5, 1997 in Oxford Lake. The lake is located within Manistee National Forest. Because Ms. Timmerman was found in Manistee National Forest, both the State of Michigan and the United States Government had jurisdiction over the case. Ultimately, the federal government assumed jurisdiction over the case and prosecuted Mr. Gabrion for the murder of Rachel Timmerman.


Source: JDSUPRA, August 8, 2011

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Life in prison for man in fatal Michigan bank robbery

A federal jury in Detroit has declined to order the death penalty for a man convicted of killing an armored-truck courier during a heist in 2001.

Timothy O'Reilly will serve life in prison without parole.

Michigan's Constitution forbids the death penalty in state court, but it's an option for murders prosecuted by the U.S. Justice Department in federal court.

The jury said Wednesday it failed to reach an unanimous verdict on life or death, so the judge will automatically impose a life sentence.

The same jury three weeks ago found O'Reilly guilty in the fatal shooting of Norman "Anthony" Stephens, who was restocking ATMs in the middle of the night at Dearborn Federal Credit Union in Dearborn.

Stephens was shot in the back and legs before O'Reilly and others got away with $204,000.

Source: WNDU.com, August 26, 2010

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Five Myths About the Death Penalty

David Garland, a professor of law and sociology at New York University, recently addressed some common myths regarding the death penalty in America. In an op-ed in the Washington Post, Garland provided information challenging the common wisdom about capital punishment:

- The United States is a death penalty nation. Garland contends that, in fact, the death penalty is rarely imposed today. It has been abolished in 15 states and in the District of Columbia. Of the 35 states that have the death penalty, one-third rarely impose death sentences, and another one-third impose death sentences but hardly ever carry them out. Eighty percent of executions are carried out in the South, largely in Texas and in Virginia.

- The United States is out of step with Europe and the rest of the Western world. Since 1981, when France stopped executing people by the guillotine, Europe has been an abolitionist continent. However, for most of the past 200 years, American states have been actively working towards death penalty reform. Michigan abolished the death penalty for all ordinary crimes in 1846, a century before most European nations did so.

- This country has the death penalty because the public supports it. Even though polls show that a majority of respondents say they support the death penalty, it is less clear whether people are well-informed about the issue, have given the matter much thought, or have considered alternatives to capital punishment.

- The death penalty works. “[I]t stretches credulity to think that the death penalty, as administered in the United States today, can be an effective means for deterring murder -- the only crime for which it is available. Last year, there were more than 14,000 homicides in the nation but only 106 death sentences. The chances of any particular killer being caught, convicted and sentenced to death are vanishingly small.”

- The death penalty doesn’t work. Among the possible "benefits" of the death penalty, the author states, "Politicians give voters what they want by enacting capital punishment statutes even when they will never be enforced. Prosecutors use the threat of a death penalty as leverage to elicit plea bargains and cooperation. The news media are drawn to death-penalty cases because they elevate a routine case to a suspenseful drama where life and death are at stake."

Professor Garland concludes, "We avidly consume these dramatic stories and enjoy the opportunity to engage, once more, in the old and familiar debate. But it's time to change the terms of that all-too-familiar debate. Getting past the myths and looking at how the death penalty actually operates is one place to start."

Garland has a forthcoming book entitled, “Peculiar Institution: America’s Death Penalty in an Age of Abolition.”

(D. Garland, "Five myths about the death penalty," The Washington Post, July 18, 2010).

Source: Death Penalty Information Center, July 21, 2010

Sunday, July 11, 2010

Michigan has history with death penalty

In 1847, Michigan became the 1st English-speaking government to ban the death penalty.

But that didn't stop the federal government from seeking the death penalty in Michigan.

In November 1937, U.S. District Judge Arthur Tuttle sentenced Anthony Chebatoris, 38, to hang for fatally shooting a bystander during a bank robbery in Midland.

He was hanged at the federal prison in Milan at dawn on July 8, 1938.

In August 1942, Tuttle sentenced Detroit restaurant owner Max Stephan to hang for harboring Lt. Hans Peter Krug, a Nazi pilot who had escaped from a prisoner-of-war camp near Toronto. Krug was captured in Texas.

Stephan was convicted of treason. Krug testified at trial for the prosecution.

In August 1943, 8 hours before he was to be hanged, President Franklin D. Roosevelt commuted Stephan's sentence to life in prison. Stephan died in prison in 1952 at age 59. Krug returned to Germany.

In March 2002, Marvin Charles Gabrion II, 48, was sentenced to death in U.S. District Court in Grand Rapids for killing Rachel Timmerman, a 19-year-old single mother, to prevent her from testifying against him at a rape trial.

She and her 11-month-old daughter vanished in 1997, 2 days before she was to testify in the rape case she had filed against Gabrion. Her bound, gagged and weighted-down body was found 1 month later in a lake in Manistee National Forest -- federal property. Her daughter was never found.

Gabrion denied any involvement in Timmerman's death. He's on death row at a federal prison in Terre Haute, Ind.

Source: Detroit Free Press, July 11, 2010


Detroit man to fight for life at trial

Confiding in inmate leads way to federal death penalty case

While sitting in a state prison on a gun charge in 2004, Timothy O'Reilly violated the cardinal rule of doing time -- confiding to a fellow convict.

O'Reilly told the inmate about his involvement in a fatal 2001 armored car robbery in Dearborn, court documents show. O'Reilly's confidant, Barron Nix-Bey, then contacted authorities. They, in turn, rigged a portable radio that Nix-Bey used to record O'Reilly's complete confession, records show.

Nix-Bey, 41, of Detroit is expected to be the government's star witness and the recording he made, Exhibit 1, when O'Reilly, 37, also of Detroit, goes on trial for his life Monday morning in U.S. District Court in Detroit.

It will be the 1st federal death penalty trial in eastern Michigan since 2003. Although the state banned the death penalty in 1847, such trials are permissible under federal law.

The Death Penalty Information Center in Washington said 61 prisoners are on federal death row. Juries impose the death penalty in about 1/3 of such cases.

O'Reilly is accused of premeditated murder, bank robbery and other counts in the fatal shooting of Norman Stephens, 30, of Detroit. Stephens, a married father of six working as a guard for Total Armored Car Service, was filling ATMs at a Dearborn Federal Credit Union about 4 a.m. Dec. 14, 2001, when hooded gunmen ambushed him.

They fled with $204,000.

O'Reilly also is accused in a June 2003 robbery in which an armed car guard at a Comerica branch in Detroit was wounded. The robbers got away with $170,000.

Prosecutors and defense lawyers wouldn't comment.

But defense lawyers who handle such cases said O'Reilly's trial is likely to be gut-wrenching.

"It's a grave, grave responsibility," said Grand Rapids attorney Paul Mitchell. "What you do impacts whether that man or woman lives or dies."

The trial before U.S. District Judge Victoria Roberts is to be conducted in two phases: The 1st to determine guilt and the 2nd to determine whether to impose the death penalty.

"This case won't be so much about guilt or innocence, but about life or death," said Wayne State University law professor Peter Henning, a former federal prosecutor. "And all you need to avoid the death penalty is the vote of 1 juror."

Investigators had hit a dead end in the case until Nix-Bey, who was serving time for home invasion, told authorities that O'Reilly had bragged about the robberies, court records show.

"Seemed like he had no kind of remorse for the things he did, so I was wondering was it true," Nix-Bey testified.

Authorities said the confession Nix-Bey taped on the radio implicated six other men: Norman Duncan, 40; Kevin Watson, 40, Earl Johnson, 43; Archie Broom, 42; Khayyam Wilson, and Henry Matthews, ages unknown. All the men are from Detroit.

Broom, Wilson and Matthews pleaded guilty and are awaiting sentencing.

Johnson was tried and convicted for his role and was sentenced to life in 2008.

Duncan and Watson also are facing the death penalty for firing on Stephens.

Source: Detroit Free Press, July 11, 2010

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Murder suspect faces death penalty in rare Michigan case

Detroit -- Jury selection begins this morning for a type of trial rarely seen in Michigan -- one in which the defendant could face the death penalty.

Timothy Dennis O'Reilly, 36, is charged with murdering Norman "Anthony" Stephens during a Dec. 14, 2001, holdup of an armored truck at the Dearborn Federal Credit Union.

Michigan was the first state in the union to ban capital punishment, in 1847, but death can still be imposed in Michigan for federal capital crimes such as murder during a bank robbery.

O'Reilly is the first of three defendants in the Dearborn robbery to go to trial in front of a jury and U.S. District Judge Victoria A. Roberts.

Two co-defendants, Norman Herbert Duncan and Kevin C. Watson, also face possible death sentences when they go to trial. Read more.


Michigan death cases

Death penalty cases are rare in Michigan, which banned capital punishment for all crimes except treason in 1847 and later extended the state ban to treason as well. Only certain federal crimes are eligible for the death penalty in Michigan.

* The last person executed in Michigan, Tony Chebatoris of Hamtramck, was hanged at Milan in 1938 for killing a man during a Midland bank robbery.

* A federal grand jury in Grand Rapids sentenced Marvin Gabrion to death in 2002, but his case is still under appeal.

* In Detroit, a federal jury convicted drug dealer John Bass of murder in 2003, but rejected the death penalty for Bass in the separate penalty phase of the trial.

* Before Chebatoris was executed, nobody had been put to death in Michigan since 1830, before statehood.

(Source: Detroit News research)


Source: The Detroit News, June 9, 2010

Sunday, September 20, 2009

Michigan: last execution took place in 1830


The state of Michigan executed its last criminal, Stephen Simmons, in Detroit on Sept. 24, 1830, before becoming the 1st government to abolish the death penalty.

The 50-year-old known drinker was convicted of beating his wife to death. Before he was strung up on gallows near Campus Martius, Simmons told the crowd that had gathered about the evils of alcohol and sang the hymn "Show Pity, Lord, O Lord, Forgive."

Wayne County Sheriff Thomas Knapp refused on humanitarian grounds to execute Simmons. The gruesome task went to hotelier Ben Woodworth, who volunteered.

The spectacle was one of the reasons why 17 years later, Michigan banned capital punishment.

A prisoner at the federal prison in Milan was executed in 1938, but he was convicted in federal court.

Source: Detroit Free Press, Sept. 20, 2009