Showing posts with label Election08. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Election08. Show all posts

Friday, November 21, 2008

Green’s gain a seat, National loses one


Kennedy Graham is an MP now that the final election result is in. The Greens have always done well on specials - in fact in 1999 they got seven extra MPs on top of their election night count.

Cam Calder misses out and the Bill and Ben Party has the highest number of votes of all 2008 non-parliamentary parties – although NZ First was knocked out of Parliament. Fewer people voted the Family Party than Destiny Church has members. Brian Tamaki is preparing tomorrow's sermon this afternoon on exercising the right to vote.

But as Farrar notes, had 22 more National voters voted Labour, National could have lost another seat and Damien O’Connor would have kept his place in Parliament. Had Helen Clark not been Prime Minister that would certainly have happened.

Aaron Gilmore can breathe a sigh of relief.

Monday, November 10, 2008

Happy Birthday Mum


It was my mums birthday on Saturday. Happy birthday Mum. I hope you like your present. I got you a new government. Sorry you had to wait until 11:30pm to get it, but I think you could have guessed what it was..

Incidentally, the last time the government changed - 27 November 1999, was the day we got married. We voted too - in our wedding gear.

Sunday, November 9, 2008

The wasted vote came third in 2008


Thanks to NZ First not getting a seat or over 5% but getting more than 88,000 votes, the wasted vote was bigger than the Green vote. The wasted vote was third this year - and that's the first time it has been ranked so high. More than 6.5% of the vote (137,472) was wasted, and had there not been a 5% threshold that would have gone down to 1.28% (26,983).

The wasted voted is vote for a party that does not get 5% or an electorate seat.

So you can see how important it is for a minor party to win an electorate seat and what influence a 5% threshold has. Since 2000 just two minor parties have got both at least one seat and more than 5% of the vote in the same election. That's all.

Interestingly NZ First got more votes in 2008 than in 2002, where it got 4.26% of the vote and four seats – it got 4.21% this year. Also Destiny got more in 2005 than Kiwi got this year. Destiny is now the Family Party. The Family Party got well under half what Destiny got in 2005.

If I get some more time to do some more numbers I'll add to this.

Friday, November 7, 2008

I voted today


I voted in the Ohariu electorate today as is my duty. I took my six-year-old with me. He told me to vote National because his mum was going to. Last night his mum said she was going to vote Act, but she may well have voted National - she voted this afternoon before she went to work. Now voting is one decision we don't make together.

My son told me not to vote for Peter Dunne because I wasn't stressed. I wondered why he said that and when I got home I realised why he said that - Peter Dunne had a mailout that as headed "Families in times of stress" and he read it.

I used both my votes. I split them. I had to - I voted the Maori Party. This makes it the fourth party I have voted for since 1996. We both got stickers afterwards, but not before my son, just after I had made a tick, said in a loud voice, "Why did you vote the Maori Party". I think the whole polling booth must have heard.

But I'm glad I took him, he'll enrol on the electoral roll and vote shortly after he turns 18. I wish more young people would do that - and it would be nice to see more parents take their kids when they vote so they can see democracy at work.

Monday, November 3, 2008

Labour needs the Maori Party: The Maori Party doesn’t need Labour


So, the Greens have said it won’t work with Winston Peters in Cabinet. NZ First is not looking like it will be in Parliament, let alone in Cabinet after November 8. That is why you’ll see Helen Clark moving to encourage NZ First supporters to vote Labour to avoid wasting their vote or voting National. But Clark’s real hope of regaining power is to cosy up to the Maori Party. She just doesn’t know how to.

Lockwood Smith’s references to Pacific Islanders needing to be taught how to use toilets and showers has all been forgotten now that Michael Jones and Inga Tuigamala, from the Labour heartland, have endorsed the National Party. Michael Jones said he wants to get address the deficit model, particularly with education and, that’s exactly what the Maori Party wants to do as well. Education is a key to work and future prospects and its clear that a change of direction is needed to empower Maori and Pacific Islanders to manage businesses, not just to be employed in factories. Labour wants people to get NCEA level 1 credits, calling that an education, National wants people to get an education that will lead to jobs, not a TOP course.

It is something for the Maori Party to consider when they decide to go with National after the election. The party will be making the wrong decision for its people if it was to support Labour after the election.

Sunday, November 2, 2008

Two more Maori electorate polls due tonight


Maori Television has decided to release the last two political polls for the Maori electorates of Hauraki Waikato and Ikaroa Rawhiti tonight, rather than on Wednesday. I'll have those after 8pm tonight.

Thursday, October 23, 2008

The Christian vote


Andy Moore has a new website, Christian vote summarising who he thinks Christians should vote for. He assesses five parties: Kiwi, Family, ACT, United Future and National, who he maintains the majority of Christians will vote for. All had a majority of MPs/candidates that opposed the anti smacking legislation just prior to the third reading of the bill.

If he's correct, a majority of Christians are going to vote National. Those who don't are going to have their party votes either wasted or supplementing votes for successful candidates from Ohariu and Epsom.

Moore says Christians will not vote for any of the other parties - he says they are not worth voting for. I would like to challenge him on this. I recon more Christians will vote Labour than the Family/Kiwi/ United Future/ Act parties combined. Well done on the site, but it is obvious who Moore supports. He said he has endeavoured to provide a balanced and accurate view. He gets a generous two stars for balance from me, but a few more for accuracy.

Moore should take another look at the value your vote website and see which party is the most consistently family friendly party in terms of the percentage/number balance of collective family friendly votes cast on the issues canvassed.

Because he's missed that party out.

It's fairly well known that I'm a Christian, and although I`m an undecided voter, as of today I don't intend to vote for any of the parties Moore maintains the majority of Christians should vote for. In fact there's only one I`d even consider voting for. Looks like I'm in a minority.

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

What the election is about


Garth George has done a pretty good column today
This election is not about trust, because the public does not trust politicians, except, perhaps, those of the Maori Party.

It is not about the economy...tax cuts... Working for Families or KiwiSaver.. It isn't about whether John Key is fit to be Prime Minister, because as long as he is not Helen Clark he can't lose.

It isn't about energy or the environment[or]privisation. This election is all about freedom - the freedom of the individual to live his or her life with as little interference as possible from the state, its politicians and minions.
I suggest you read it in full. It's one of his better ones.

The Maori Party may not go into coalition at all


According to Colin Espiner Pita Sharples has effectively come out and said that there is no way the Maori Party will be in coalition with National, because his people prefer Labour. But if it went into coalition with Labour it would be political suicide if Labour gets fewer seats than National. Labours support is the Maori Party's biggest problem. The biggest problem for the two main parties is entrenchment of the Maori seats is a bottom line for the Maori Party and both main parties don't buy it.

Many Maori won't exercise their right to vote, but they`ll go to the Marae to tell Tariana Turia to pick Labour even if it gets fewer seats than National, if the Maori Party agree, Labour could be the Government. That would outrage so many people.

One thing is clear: The Maori Party want to further the Maori people. But the Maori people need to get out of this "pick National or Labour" mentality because a coalition agreement is not needed to to further Maori aspirations and development. That is what Tariana Turia is trying to tell the Maori people who are fixated on coalitions. However the Maori Party needs to support the governing party to further Maori aspirations and this includes Ministerial posts. Even though Labour is more likely offer the Maori Party a Cabinet post, that does not follow that the Maori people will be better off than under National with a few ministerial posts outside Cabinet. However it is likely that if National offers Ministerial posts to the Maori Party, it will be expected to sign a confidence and supply agreement.

So what does this mean? It means a vote for National is a vote for a change of Government - with or without Maori Party support. It means a vote for the Maori Party is a vote for the future of the Maori people, but it is not clear what sort of a future it will be. If the Maori Party go into coalition with either party, it is less likely to have a long term parliamentary future because Government involves the rest of us. Unless some minds are changed, I don't think the Maori Party will go into coalition with National even if it considers that Maori will get a better deal than offered by Labour.

It won't go into formal coalition at all as neither National or Labour say it agrees to entrenchment if the Maori seats. It would be much better seeking ministerial posts outside Cabinet, which is what I have always promoted. It is up to the voters to pick a parliament that enables this to happen.

Update Danyl @ the DimPost reports that Tariana Turia announced that the removal of Tin from the periodic table of elements would be a bottom line for any coalition deal with a major party. The Greens won't be happy with that!

One in five Maori in latest polls are undecided voters - will they even vote?


A Maori Television Poll poll out tonight gives Maori Party co-leader Tariana Turia a huge lead over Labour's Errol Mason in Te Tai Haururu. Turia polled 79 percent, with Mason 19 percent. Yet the Labour Party lead the party vote 47 to 33 percent which is different to the previous two Maori electorate polls which are evenly split between the Maori Party and Labour.

But 17 percent are undecided voters, and 31 percent of voters aged between 18-24 are undecided as well. That's a high proportion. I wonder if many of them will bother to vote the week after next. Also 2 percent through Tim Barnett should be Prime Minister!

This follows a poll yesterday in Waiariki where two thirds of Waiariki voters currently support Te Ururoa Flavell from the Maori Party as their local Maori MP (66 per cent) – more than double Labour's Mita Ririnui on 29 per cent. The party vote was pretty much neck and neck with 40 percent supporting Labour and 38 percent supporting the Maori Party. Yet 20 percent are undecided.

In Tamaki Makaurau, Pita Sharples is on 80 percent, with undecides coming in second with 14 percent. Labour's Louisa Wall is on 11 percent - probably the only Labour candidate who is polling less than the undecideds!

The next political poll will focus on the Maori electorate of Te Tai Tokerau (Tuesday October 28). The last poll had Labours Kelvin Davis on 17 percent wiith Hone Hariwira in 29 percent with the Maori Party leading the party vote. The following day I`ll have the Te Tai Tonga result, then the Hauraki Waikato (Tuesday November 4); and Ikaroa Rawhiti (Wednesday November 5).

Monday, October 20, 2008

Labour loser as bold plans fail to add up


Good article by Dene McKenzine in the ODT today, summing up the past few weeks.
A bold plan to bring forward infrastructure spending and create jobs at a time when unemployment was expected to rise was also revealed by Miss Clark.

The fact that National Party deputy leader Bill English issued statement after statement asking how Miss Clark would pay for the estimated $1.3 billion of unfunded promises escaped the wider group of voters.

It appeared as though Labour was heading on a road to possible victory rather than one of certain defeat as National continued to hover around 51% in the opinion polls compared to Labour lurking around 33%.

What a difference a week makes.

This column predicted some bold promises would be made on Sunday, thinking particularly of Labour as it continued its spending momentum. But that momentum stalled when Miss Clark at a Wellington rally ruled out making any more spending promises during the campaign. She went back to the issue of trust and leadership and how Mr Key, who made his estimated $50 million fortune on Wall Street, did not have the experience to lead New Zealand during times of global economic upheaval.

Across town, at Parliament, Mr Key used his merchant banking experience and finally found the edge he had been searching for on the economy.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Sore loser


Helen Clark is a sore loser over the TV debate. She is still smarting for losing a debate then stating Key had a telly tantrum. She said at one point " You might be used to shouting people down at home, but you're not shouting me down" - a comment interpreted by some as insinuating Key shouted at his family.

Of course, Clark has never had kids to shout down so obviously didn't have that well-rounded experience of being shouted down. But it is interesting to analyse - in a professional and fairly detached way, of course - the progression of her own analysis on the debate has progressed.
Helen Clark, immediately after the debate:
It was a good old-fashioned debate on the issues. I hope that means we’ve banished any idea that this is a bitter kind of election debate. I think people want to hear us being up front, straight on.

Helen Clark, yesterday afternoon:
Expectations were low, firstly because people hadn’t seen him in a debate before and secondly because he had a disastrous start to the campaign. So the fact he didn’t collapse with a stress attack on the set probably gave him marks.

Helen Clark: last night Last night Miss Clark said she did not think the campaign was bitter and today said she was just offering a professional analysis of how it went...... in a fairly detached way
.
Professional? Analysis? Detached?

Sore loser more like it.

Diddums.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Party lists


The party lists for the General Election are now up on the website.Act has a pretty big list. Even the Resident's Action Movement (RAM) have 26 on its list - more than NZ First.

And looking at the Workers Party list, it's a wonder it's not called the Family Party. We have former VUWSA president Nick Kelly, his partner, the 2009 VUWSA president, as well as the current VUWSA President, Joel Cosgrove, his partner and her sister - all taking up more than a third of the entire party list.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Helen Clark's dream v John Key's vision


Helen Clark is been dreaming too much. "I have a dream when I came to govt" she said,at least twice, on the TV3/YouTube debate tonight, "to give every student the same privileges I had". Nine years on, it might happen in 2012.

That's not a vision - that's a dream. It won't happen. We will not have the same privileges. John Key won the debate tonight because he has a vision and can back it up with recent and current facts as to why that vision is relevant and important.

Doesn't mean I`m going to vote for him, though.

Saturday, October 11, 2008

Helen Clark's vision for New Zealand


According to the Oxford dictionary, the definition of vision is "statesmanlike foresight". Here's John Key's vision for New Zealand
My vision is for a more prosperous New Zealand, a New Zealand that delivers opportunities for everyone. A country that is safer. A country that feels more confident about itself and punches above its weight.
Now compare it to Helen Clark's vision for New Zealand.
My vision for New Zealand is for our country to be a place that offers every person who chooses to live here - and they do have a choice - all the opportunity and security in the world and to be fair and inclusive. That's it is a nutshell. So we have to offer opportunity through education, we have to offer the opportunity to work, and we have to deal with all the underpinnings of that - the health system, housing, security in old age, support for children. But we have to ensure that people of very diverse cultures and faiths and beliefs all feel that they have got a stake in New Zealand because they are fairly treated.
I wonder what others think, with reference to the Electoral Finance Act, which is hardly fair and inclusive, with reference to her comments regarding the inappropriateness of Christians in Parliament when United Future got its 2002 swag of MPs, hardly meeting her vision of being inclusive, hardly fair treatment of people of faith and hardly fair and inclusive with retards to Electoral Finance laws.

This is not foresight, therefore its not a vision.

It's a dream.

Time to wake up. We need a Prime Minister that knows what a vision is. John Key does, so it is a start. We don't need a Prime Minster that thinks dreams are visions, and a lie is the truth if you say it a lot and believe it to be so.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Will Helen Clark laugh at National's tax cuts?


Helen Clark wants people to be wary and laugh at Nationals tax cuts.
Even if it was just at $18 a week more than Labour's package, she said people should still be wary.

But it's Labour we're laughing at. National's tax cuts are $18 a week for those on the average wage. Helen Clark was close to the mark. But is she laughing now?

National has announced its tax cut programme and changes to KiwiSaver are going to fund them. National wants to cut the tax credit to employers, and reduce employees' and employers' minimum contribution to 2 per cent of gross income.In his speech notes Key said the bulk of the cut would come on April 1 2009, meaning a worker on the average wage of $48,000 would be better off by an additional $18 a week above Labour's cuts from that date.

But as you can see here, low paid workers won't get much. That may give Clark something to laugh at(stolen from No Right Turn - bigger chart here for the squinters.) And because I really don't have time to analyse who provides the best deal, so go to No Right Turn. In summary if you`re poor, Labour provides the best deal if you're rich National does - and that's why National's package is bigger. Not only do the rich get more, they get it earlier.

I don't like the package at all.



Heres the calculations from Kiwiblog

Monday, October 6, 2008

PREFU: The rainy day has arrived - but we've forgotten to buy the raincoat and now we can't afford one without going into debt


It's official. Cullen has screwed the economy after eight prosperous years with minimal growth. Cullen was so out of his comfort zone that it is frightening. Now we are in the bad times we will have nothing to show for it except more debt and more government deficits. Gross government debt to rise from 17.4 per cent of GDP to 24.3 per cent by 2013 against the Government's target of 20 per cent of GDP on average. Our dollar is expected to decline in value by 22.7 percent by 2013, inflation is expected to be 4.5 percent next year.

How did this happen? From Stuff .
We had government policies that were open-ended that it was impossible to predict the uptake and when more took part in KiwiSaver and 20 hours free that blew the budget for those items. KiwiSaver alone is $280 million above forecast and benefits were $500 million more than forecast. We have only $500 million in the bank for spending.

In addition, households and businesses had come under increasing cost pressures, meanwhile, including higher electricity, interest rate, fuel and food prices, which had dampened private consumption and business profitability.

Labour can't manger the economy we have surpluses,how on earth can he manage it when we have deficits?

However there's some good news. )Its not the end of the world. And to date this is the only blog to provide some good news on this fiscal update, because we like to be positive here.

Because we are going to run deficits for at least 10 years and there are other spending priorities, there will be no money for completion of Treaty Settlements and so it will be at least 2025 before historic claims are settled and so the Maori seats are safe for some time yet.

For those interested, the PREFU reports are all here showing that the economy is indeed PREFU'd.

UPDATE and I've just noticed on Lindsay Mitchell's site that the projected cost for the ETS is $1 billion - under Heritage, Culture and Recreations expenses. I wonder who the minister for Culture and Heritage is.

PM regrets shutting Greens out of Government


Oh dear. Helen Clark has regretted that the Greens weren't in Government. They would have been if they had have polled higher.

Actually, so would National if it had have polled a bit higher.

Perhaps the PM should encourage people to vote Green, then, instead of aligning herself to NZ First, because, thanks to Helen Clark, a vote for the Green Party is a vote for the opposition. The problem for her is that the only way to increase the Green vote is for it to come off a declining Labour vote tainted by a suport for Winston Peters. She should have been regretting she passed the Foreshore and Seabed Act. Had she not passed it we may well not have had a Maori Party to spoil her coalition fun.

Family Party releases list


The Family Party has released its party list. Problem is that one of those on the list is "electorate only", not that it makes any difference, he won't be in parliament.

But it begs the question. Why is he on the list?

Sunday, October 5, 2008

Latest One New Poll


TV1 had a poll. National increases to a 19% lead. Greens hit 7%. Centre left voters are deserting Labour and going to the Greens.
National on 52% Labour 33% Green 7% Maori Party 2.5, NZ First 2% and Act on 1.5% It's reported on Newstalk ZB but Radio NZ avoids it.

Wonder why? Aren't RNZ onto it anymore?

Meanwhile Helen Clark is telling the international media that she doesn't trust polls.