Showing posts with label Cathy Henderson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cathy Henderson. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Texas: No death penalty in Cathy Lynn Henderson retrial, DA says

Travis County prosecutors will not seek the death penalty when Cathy Lynn Henderson is retried for the 1994 death of an infant she was baby-sitting.

Henderson, who was once 2 days from execution for the death of 3-month-old Brandon Baugh, will be tried for capital murder and faces a potential sentence of life in prison, District Attorney Rosemary Lehmberg said Monday.

Source: Austin American-Statesman, Sept. 10, 2013

Friday, December 7, 2012

Texas Moratorium Network: The Year in Review

Texas executed 15 people in 2012, two more people than in 2011. 73 percent of the people Texas executed in 2012 were people of color, seven African-American and four Hispanics. There were four white people executed by Texas in 2012. 

Five people were executed from Dallas County, two from Bexar County, two from Montgomery County, one from Harris County, one from Gregg County, one from Polk County, one from Cherokee County, one from Jefferson County and one from Tarrant County. 

Since December 7, 1982, the state of Texas has executed 492 people. There have been 253 executions in Texas since Rick Perry took office in December 2000. 

2011 saw the lowest number of executions in 15 years dating back to 1996. The highest number of executions was 40 in 2000. 

So far, 8 people have been sentenced to death in 2012 in Texas - the same number as in 2011. New death sentences have declined from their high in the late 90s. In 1999, there were 48 people sentenced to death. Harris County, where Houston is located, did not send anyone to death row in 2012. 

After three convictions and death sentences, all of which were at least partially overturned on appeal, the Harris County District Attorney's Office announced in August 2012 that it would drop efforts to execute Anthony Pierce, who had been on death row since 1978. 

87.5 percent of the eight new death sentences handed out in 2012 in Texas have been given to people of color. Of the eight people sentenced to death so far in Texas in 2012, six are African-American, one is Hispanic and one white. One of the eight persons is a woman. 

The number of new death sentences has declined over the last several years in large part because people who serve on juries are increasingly choosing life without parole as an alternative to the death penalty, because members of juries have read about so many mistakes in the system when innocent people have been convicted only to be exonerated years later. 

Cathy Henderson, who has been on death row in Texas for 17 years, was granted a new trial in 2012. The trial court said in its ruling in May that she "has proven by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable juror would have convicted her of capital murder in light of her new evidence". Travis County DA Rosemary Lehmberg has said she will retry Henderson. 

In September, Texas executed Cleve "Sarge" Foster who had received three previous stays of execution from the U.S. Supreme Court. Read a report from Gloria Rubac, who was with Foster's family in Huntsville on the day of the execution. 

John Balentine received a stay from the U.S. Supreme Court in August 2012, less than an hour before he was due to be put to death in Texas. Balentine argued he deserved a reprieve because an ineffective trial lawyer failed to present mitigating evidence, such as emotional problems and a difficult upbringing, that could have led to a life sentence. 

Two people on death row died in custody in 2012: Santos Minjarez from San Antonio died Jan. 14, 2012 in Galveston, six days after he was transferred from death row. The cause of death was septic shock and multiple organ failure. Selwyn Davis of Austin was found dead in his death row cell on July 20, 2012 of suicide. 

More than three decades after he was sent to death row, Delma Banks Jr. in 2012 agreed to accept a life sentence for the 1980 slaying of acquaintance Richard Whitehead - a murder he has long maintained he did not commit. Banks, who is black, was convicted by an all-white jury of the slaying of 16-year-old Whitehead (white) near Nash, Texas, in 1980. 

After 12 years of organizing and lobbying by ordinary grassroots Democrats across the state as well as by exonerated former death row inmates, the Texas Democratic Party has adopted a platform that calls for repealing the death penalty in Texas. "Democrats Against the Death Penalty", which was formed by members of Texas Moratorium Network in 2004, held a meeting at the TDP State Convention in June 2012. Watch a powerful video of Clarence Brandley, an innocent man who spent ten years on Texas death row for a crime he did not commit, speaking at the meeting of "Democrats Against the Death Penalty" on June 8, 2012 at the Texas Democratic Party State Convention in Houston. 

In July, the Austin Human Rights Commission passed a resolution calling for Texas to repeal the death penalty and for a statewide moratorium on executions. 

In July, Texas changed to a one drug method to carry out executions instead of its previous three-drug method, because of short supply in drugs that was caused by pressure on drug companies from people in the drugs producing countries who are opposed to executions. 

In October, Todd Willingham's family officially requested a pardon for him from the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles and Governor Rick Perry. No action has yet been taken on the request. 

According to KTBC in Austin, hundreds of people rallied at the Texas Capitol at the 13th Annual March to Abolish the Death Penalty on November 3, 2012. Three death row survivors from Witness to Innocence attended the march, including Ron Keine (watch video).

Source: Texas Moratorium Network, December 7, 2012

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

New trial ordered for Cathy Lynn Henderson on Texas death row for 1994 infant death

Cathy Lynn Henderson pictured
with Sister Helen Prejean
A Travis County woman who was just days away from being executed for killing a baby in 1994 was granted a new trial on Wednesday by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.

The state's highest criminal court deferred to opinion of the trial judge that scientific evidence that came to light after Cathy Lynn Henderson, now 55, was convicted of killing Brandon Baugh while babysitting at the boy's home in Pflugerville.

In an evidentiary hearing after the conviction, Dr. Roberto Bayardo said recent developments in the study of biomechanics suggested that the baby could have died from head injuries suffered in an accidental fall rather than from a deliberate blow.

"The trial court concluded that applicant has proven by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable juror would have convicted her of capital murder in light of her new evidence," the appeals court said in an unsigned opinion.

District Attorney Rosemary Lehmberg said she supports the appeals court's decision, but did not say whether the death penalty would be on the table in a new trial.

"I believe justice requires that a new jury hear the case, which was the position I took with the appellate court," she said. "We will try the case again. I will review all the evidence at the trial and at the subsequent hearings to determine whether the State will again seek the death penalty."

In 2007, Henderson was only two days away from her scheduled execution when the Court of Criminal Appeals granted her a reprieve and ordered the lower court to hear arguments in her appeal.

Henderson, who is 1 of 10 women on death row in Texas, has always maintained the death was an accident. She said she panicked, packed Brandon's body in a wine cooler box and buried him in a shallow grave 60 miles away. Henderson then left Texas before being apprehended in Missouri under an assumed name.

Brandon's father told KXAN in May that they still believe their son was murdered on Jan. 21, 1994.

"This is so not fair. It should have been over with a long time ago," said Brandon's father, Eryn Baugh. "It's something that you just cannot imagine the amount of pain, anger and frustration for having to live through this experience day in and day out without a resolution."

Source: KXAN News, December 5, 2012

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Judge: Overturn Cathy Lynn Henderson conviction, death sentence

Cathy Henderson and Sr. H. Prejean
Cathy Lynn Henderson, once two days from execution for the 1994 death of an infant she was baby sitting, should have her murder conviction and death sentence overturned, a Travis County judge has recommended.

District Judge Jon Wisser said scientific discoveries into the nature of head injuries — and a change of heart from the prosecution’s star witness, former medical examiner Roberto Bayardo - means no reasonable juror would convict Henderson if presented the new evidence at trial.

“Testimony of the state’s chief experts was, at bottom, scientifically flawed,” Wisser wrote in findings dated May 12 and delivered to the appeals court Tuesday.

After reviewing new evidence via testimony and briefs, Wisser recommended that the Court of Criminal Appeals dismiss Henderson’s conviction and return her case to Travis County, where she may face “any indictment or charges” that prosecutors choose to pursue in the death of 3-month-old Brandon Baugh.


Source: statesman.com, May 23, 2012

Monday, August 16, 2010

And Justice For All - Sister Helen Prejean On Why The Death Penalty Is Wrong

Sr. Helen Prejean
In 1608, on the shores of Britain’s newly formed Virginia Colony, Captain George Kendall was found guilty of spying for Spain and sentenced to death by firing squad. His execution — the first recorded in the colonial New World — began a policy of death-penalty sentencing that continues to this day in the United States, where 3,300 men and women sit on death row. Since 1977 more than 1,200 people have been executed, with the overwhelming majority of those executions taking place in Southern states. One of those killed was Elmo Patrick Sonnier, convicted by a Louisiana jury of murdering David LeBlanc and Loretta Ann Bourque on the night of their high-school homecoming. While on death row Sonnier began corresponding with a Catholic nun in New Orleans named Sister Helen Prejean. Their correspondence, Prejean says, turned her life upside down. Today she is one of the world’s foremost death-penalty abolitionists.

Prejean was born into a life of Louisiana privilege and entered the convent intent on seclusion. It wasn’t until a fellow nun asked, “What are you doing to stop the suffering in the world?” that Prejean decided to leave the cloister and help the urban poor. After moving into a housing project in New Orleans, Prejean became Sonnier’s spiritual advisor. She visited with him in person, right up to the last hours of his life. Sonnier was electrocuted before her eyes, and his story led her to write the Pulitzer Prize–nominated book Dead Man Walking (Vintage), which became an Oscar-winning film starring Sean Penn and Susan Sarandon.

Prejean has since served as spiritual advisor to five more death-row inmates and travels the world to speak in opposition to the death penalty. Her second book is titled The Death of Innocents: An Eyewitness Account of Wrongful Executions (Vintage), and she is at work on her spiritual autobiography, River of Fire. She also assists families of murder victims in New Orleans through Survive, a victims’ advocacy group that she founded. Prejean, who is seventy-one, has received numerous honorary doctorates and been nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize. She says she is encouraged by recent trends toward abolishing capital punishment: in the last three decades six U.S. states have suspended or abolished use of the death penalty, and 139 death-row prisoners have been exonerated since 1973.

I met Prejean at Marquette University in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, where she spoke — with her distinct Louisiana style — to overflow crowds. A cold rain fell outside afterward as she and I sat down to talk. Long accustomed to fighting for justice, Prejean carries herself with a presence that is both firm and tender. When she walks into a room, the atmosphere changes immediately.

Like the best teachers, Prejean knows the path to the heart is through story, and she peppers her talks with moving accounts of those she has encountered in our nation’s prisons. Earlier she’d told the story of Dobie Gillis Williams, who was executed in 1999 by lethal injection. Prejean was with him in his last hours. He had an iq of 65. His last words were: “I just want to say I got no hard feelings for anybody. God bless everybody, God bless.” Prejean believes he was innocent.


Cook: According to Amnesty International, 93 percent of the world’s executions take place in five countries: China, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, and the U.S. Why is our government — supposedly a beacon of democracy to the world — on such a list?

Prejean: The death penalty is a natural outgrowth of our long history of using violence to achieve our ends. We’re a very young country, and violence has worked for us in the past. It began with the settling of this continent and the genocide against Native Americans, then continued when we brought slaves over. Now we tend to blame the poor and see them as a criminal element and use coercion and violence to control them.

Cook: But capital punishment has been practiced for centuries. Is it part of human nature?

Prejean: It’s part of a cultural understanding that says the only way to subdue evil is with violence, but it’s not part of human nature. Look at all the countries in the world that don’t have the death penalty. The very first act of the new Constitutional Court in South Africa, after it got rid of apartheid, was to banish the death penalty. To some extent violence is part of our nature, but compassion is too. Seeking justice for everybody is also part of human nature.

The death penalty is the most important civil-rights issue of our time. It’s a deeply symbolic issue, because it says that the way we’re going to solve problems is by violence. It says that some among us are such a danger to who we are and what we stand for that they must be eliminated. To arrive at this mind-set, human beings have to flip a switch inside themselves. Deep down we know we are brothers and sisters and are all connected. For the death penalty to exist, we have to throw some switch that says, “The Other is not human like us,” and so we can do whatever we want to them. And of course the execution must be removed from the public eye. The chamber is behind prison walls, and we don’t hear about what goes on inside it.

Cook: If we went to death row, who would we find there?

Prejean: Less than 1 percent of the roughly fifteen thousand people who commit homicide each year are selected for death. Ninety percent of the prisoners who do end up on death row were abused as children. Nearly 100 percent are poor. We haven’t tried hard enough to solve the problem of poverty in this country. We have mentally ill people on death row. The Supreme Court has said that it’s unconstitutional to execute an insane person. So what do the states do? They give legally insane prisoners medication to make them appear sane enough to stand trial. We have some people on death row who don’t know how to read and write. But you also meet people on death row who read books and write profound reflections. Some of them will try to teach their fellow death-row prisoners how to read and write.

I used to think that people on death row would support and love each other, since they’re all in the same boat, but you also see people get into fights over tobacco or coffee and sometimes even throw their feces at someone walking by. There is fierceness and cruelty side by side with kindness.

Cook: You are currently the spiritual advisor to two people on death row.

Prejean: Yes. Manuel Ortiz has been on death row for seventeen years. He’s from El Salvador and was convicted of killing his wife for insurance money, solely on the word of a man named Carlos Saavedra. Saavedra said Manuel had hired him to kill his wife, but there is no evidence that Manuel even knew him. I can’t say too much about his case because his lawyers are in the process of appealing the decision.

Normally I serve only one prisoner at a time, but Cathy Henderson wrote me a letter and asked me to be with her. She is on death row in Texas and is accused of murdering a baby she was sitting. She has always said it was an accident. Her lawyers gave virtually no defense. Prosecutors called her a “baby murderer” and said she deliberately killed the infant. Cathy said she was playing the airplane game so many parents play — swinging him around — and her bare foot landed on something sharp. The baby dropped from her hands, and his head hit the floor. The medical examiner at her trial told the jury it could not have been an accident, but her new pro-bono lawyers have gotten four biomechanical experts to look at the physics of what happened, and all four came to the conclusion that it could have been an accident. The medical examiner has reviewed their findings and signed an affidavit saying that, if he’d had this information then, he would have changed his testimony. The Court of Criminal Appeals in Texas, which almost always rubber-stamps death-penalty convictions, has said there must be a new hearing. So there is the possibility she will escape the death penalty and perhaps be set free.

Cook: You’ve said that death row dehumanizes people. How?

Texas Death Row Cell
Prejean: Every day on death row you receive indications that you are disposable: the way the guards treat you, the way you’re talked to, the way the courts treat you. No one gives any indication that you are a human being with dignity. That is why I’m there: to say to death-row prisoners that they are human.

On death row they lock you up and count you four times a day and treat you like chattel. In the maximum-security units there is very little human contact, so the people there are virtually in solitary confinement. It is torture. I believe that we tilled the soil for the torture in Guantánamo Bay and Abu Ghraib with how we treat death-row prisoners in the U.S. We have become insensitive to their pain and humanity. Prisons are like fiefdoms, and a warden is like a king who has absolute power.

Cook: In the U.S. we have almost 5 percent of the world’s population and almost 25 percent of the global prison population.

Prejean: Yes, we incarcerate more people than any other country in the world. Prison is an industry from which certain people benefit: Politicians benefit because they get elected by claiming they are tough on crime. Businesses make money off prisons. That keeps the system going. Two-thirds of the people in prison are there for nonviolent crimes, like bad checks or drug possession. Why do we use such excessive punishment? What does it mean for us to take a woman who writes bad checks and separate her from her family for five or eight or ten years? What is the effect of that? Is that what she deserves?

As a society we have to examine our belief that severe punishment is the way to restore order. The main objective of prisons is to keep society safe, not to cause prisoners pain simply because they caused others pain. People who have committed violent crimes need to be imprisoned to keep the public safe, but we must also strive for rehabilitation. We know that prisoners who get an education tend not to reoffend, but we’ve cut most educational programs from prisons — really, any program that might restore humanity to the prisoners. Restorative justice would improve our society instead of simply throwing people away.

Cook: What would “restorative justice” look like?

Prejean: I once visited a women’s prison in Dublin, Ireland, and had I not known it was a prison, I would have never recognized it as such. The prison provided counseling to help the women understand what had led them to commit a crime. It provided a place for their children to come visit them. And it gave them an education and work supervision and lessons on developing relationships. In the U.S. we would call that “coddling criminals.” There they saw it as taking seriously the prisoners’ needs.

We picture all people in prison as terrible criminals. We picture murderers as people who love to kill, but most who commit murder do so in the heat of the moment and without thought of consequences. The only way to change our impressions is to go into prison and meet the people there.

Cook: Are there rehabilitation programs in the U.S. similar to the one you saw in Ireland?

Prejean: John Sage runs Bridges to Life in Texas. His sister Marilyn was brutally murdered, and he took the pain of her loss and directed it toward helping people in prison. He works with prisoners who are going to be released and teaches them job skills. He also helps them take responsibility for their crimes. They have to meet a victim’s family — not the family of their victim but one that suffered a similar loss. The family helps the prisoner understand the pain he has caused.

Cook: If someone is guilty of terrifying violence, what should his or her punishment look like?

Prejean: I can tell you what it should not look like. Any kind of punishment that degrades a defenseless human being and takes away his or her dignity is immoral. That is the basis for the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Geneva Conventions. No one should be subjected to cruel punishment or torture.

Cook: African Americans represent approximately 15 percent of our population and 50 percent of our prison population. Theologian James Cone has claimed that African Americans are being lynched once again by our prison system. Is he right?

Prejean: It is legal lynching, absolutely. When you look at Louisiana State Penitentiary, over 70 percent of the inmates are African Americans. You see them going out to the fields with hoes over their shoulders, followed by guards on horseback with guns. Basically a young man sentenced to life there will spend his days working on a farm for four cents an hour. The most you can get, after twenty years, is twenty-one cents an hour.

Cook: In your years of public speaking, what arguments have you most often encountered in favor of the death penalty?

Prejean: The most common argument is that death is a just punishment for those who have taken the lives of innocents. The murderer did not respect the life of the victim and therefore deserves what he or she gets. Anything less would devalue the victim’s life.

Cook: Former New York mayor Ed Koch once said, “It is by exacting the highest penalty for the taking of human life that we affirm the highest value of human life.”

Prejean: I’ve heard district attorneys say something like “Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, we are going to ask you for the death penalty, because that is the only way to show how much we respect the innocent life that’s been taken.” Most people who make those kinds of rhetorical statements have never been there in the final hours and watched what it means to take people who are alive and strap them down to a gurney or in a chair and kill them. They are removed from the results of their actions.

I also hear religious arguments. Supreme Court justice Antonin Scalia has said that Christians should support the death penalty because we expect to be punished for our sins. He believes that part of Christianity is to suffer pain and pay atonement. Scalia has also called execution by lethal injection “a quiet death” and “enviable” compared to how the victim died. A Supreme Court justice shouldn’t use those words to talk about torture and killing. Human beings have imaginations, and the condemned die a thousand times in their minds before they are executed.

Some people approve of the death penalty because they think it is cheaper than life imprisonment. Actually the death penalty is more expensive. That’s why more and more states with budget crises are doing away with it. A capital-murder case, as one prosecutor says, is the Cadillac of the criminal-justice system. It takes multiple trials, requires airtight evidence, and uses more expert witnesses than any other type of case. Then you have to build a special section of the prison and hire personnel to staff it. Often death-row prisoners are not allowed to work to defray the cost of their board and keep. In California it costs millions of dollars a year to house more than seven hundred people on death row.

In response to these arguments, I share stories about people I know. When New Jersey did away with the death penalty, sixty-two murder victims’ families testified that the death-penalty process had only prolonged their agony. They had been told it would provide “closure,” but in reality it meant they had to witness the death of another person, often after waiting ten or fifteen years to do so, and this death would do nothing to bring back their loved ones. During the waiting process, their story is in and out of the spotlight. It makes their wound public, and the healing doesn’t come. Many murder victims’ families have been prominent in the abolition movement.

I also point out that the death penalty is not reserved for the most terrible murders. It’s more common in cases where the victim is white, for example: approximately 80 percent of death-penalty cases involve the murder of a white person, yet 50 percent of all homicide victims are people of color.

Whether the death penalty is sought comes down to the decision of the prosecutor. Thankfully juries have to be told now that they can sentence someone to life without parole even when the prosecutor is seeking the death penalty. In the past juries were not given that information. They thought the death penalty or freedom were the only options. Even in Texas death-penalty sentences have diminished because of this. Juries — which are made up of ordinary citizens entrusted with godlike power — have a terrible responsibility.

Cook: What an enormous — and perhaps unethical — burden for ordinary citizens to carry.

Prejean: Yes, we put twelve people behind closed doors for hours or days and let them decide whether a person lives or dies. They don’t have the tools to do that. They don’t know what evidence may have been hidden from them in the trial. Even if they know for sure that this person is guilty of the crime, do they get to look at mitigating circumstances? Parents of the victim ask the jurors to “please kill this bastard who killed my boy”; parents of the accused beg the jurors not to kill their son. What’s a human being to do with that?

Source: David Cook, The Sun Magazine, August 2010. David Cook teaches peace studies at the University of Chattanooga.

Sunday, September 27, 2009

With little oversight in Texas, autopsies often careless

The man almost took the dirty secret of his death to his grave. The Tarrant County medical examiners office said injuries from a pickup wreck killed him. But after a funeral director hundreds of miles away found a bullet in the mans head, authorities realized a killer was on the loose.

Worse has happened in the autopsy suites of Texas medical examiners.

A child molester faked his own death and almost got away with it after the Travis County medical examiner mistook the burned body of an 81-year-old woman for the 23-year-old man.

A woman was on her way to Death Row in Alabama after a medical examiner now working in Texas said she had suffocated her newborn. The sad truth, other experts said, was that the baby was stillborn.

An Austin baby sitter has spent years on death row for a baby's murder. The medical examiner whose testimony helped put her there now says the baby's death may have been an accident.

The medical examiner is the doctor-detective who is supposed to extract truth from the hodgepodge of details about a death. By examining body tissues, organs and fluids, gathering data from a crime scene and examining lab results, the medical examiner provides insight into how and why someone has died. Those judgments are of consequence for violent or suspicious deaths, as well as for unexplained deaths and those that might result from negligence or improper care.

County officials say the state's system works well by unraveling questions surrounding death at a reasonable cost to taxpayers. In the courtroom, much of the work, they say, stands up to scrutiny.

But over the years, Texas medical examiners have misidentified bodies, botched examinations and had to do a double take on cases of individuals later exonerated by law enforcement. That has opened the door for innocent men and women to go to prison and killers to go free. The slapdash work of some medical examiners could also allow public health threats, wrongful deaths and preventable medical errors to go undetected, experts warn.

"The work of the medical examiner's office is just so slipshod," said Tommy Turner, the former special prosecutor who put a Lubbock medical examiner behind bars for falsifying autopsies.

Critics say the medical examiner's office is "the last bastion of junk science." The problems, they say, are similar to those that plagued the states crime labs for years: lack of performance standards, poor documentation, a shortage of qualified personnel and lax oversight.

"The state does not keep track of MEs in any shape, form or fashion," Bexar County Chief Medical Examiner Randall Frost said. The state doesn't even know how many certified forensic pathologists work in government offices, he added.

And a medical examiner doesnt have to be trained in forensics or pass a specialty exam to do an autopsy. All that's required is a state medical license. That's akin to having your family doctor do brain surgery, says a growing chorus of medical examiners.

"It's a travesty for Texas," Frost said. "Most people are horrified that there are no qualifications for this field under the law. They are shocked when I tell them that."

Thoroughness questioned

How often do autopsy blunders occur? No one knows because there are no state data to track when a medical examiner recants a previous determination or when colleagues resoundingly disagree with him or her, leading to different outcomes on death certificates or death row.

The Texas Medical Board keeps records on physicians found to have fallen short of the standards of care or to have committed other violations. But for years, it didn't consider the performance of an autopsy as the practice of medicine because an autopsy has no potential to harm the patient. The board reversed its position in 2000 when it disciplined an unlicensed physician working at the Harris County medical examiner's office. The office was the target of whistle-blower lawsuits and complaints from the district attorney.

Still, the board said it receives few complaints about medical examiners.

County officials, among others, say that if there are problems with medical examiners opinions, the adversarial system of the courts will help ensure that they are exposed. By and large, there have been no such revelations, the officials say.

"We've not had district attorneys coming and saying, 'We're losing because we're not getting quality autopsy work,'" said Donald Lee, executive director of the Texas Conference of Urban Counties. "If there was a widespread problem with the autopsy process, you would think that DAs would be coming to their fellow county officials and raising the alarm."

In Tarrant County, officials say there may be problems elsewhere in Texas, but they are confident in Chief Medical Examiner Nizam Peerwani's office.

"I've heard horror stories from other counties about their medical examiner," County Commissioner Gary Fickes said. "But I have not been made aware of any major problems, just a few little items, but I don't think they are of any magnitude."

Turner sees flaws in such arguments. Who would complain, he asks. "First of all, the person that you're performing the work on is dead," he said. "They're not going to complain."

And grieving families may not know whether a licensed physician examined their loved one or whether appropriate tests were conducted, he noted.

Concerns are being pushed into the limelight, though. Convictions have been overturned or called into question because of incomplete or sloppy autopsy records, failure to conduct vital tests and preserve key evidence, or the use of flawed methods.

A half-dozen forensic pathologists have criticized Webb County Chief Medical Examiner Corinne Stern's autopsy of a newborn when she worked in Alabama. She said the infant was suffocated, but other experts said that her finding was based on junk science and that the boy was stillborn. As a result, a capital murder charge against the mother was dismissed.

Some medical examiners themselves question the thoroughness of some autopsies. Their concerns were echoed in a report by the National Academy of Sciences to Congress this year. It said the quality of forensic science work including crime labs and medical examiners' offices is undermined by inadequate training, inconsistent practices and a lack of oversight.

"These shortcomings pose a threat to the quality and credibility of forensic science practice and its service to the justice system," the report warns.

Major blunders

Elizabeth Gard's husband died within 48 hours of being admitted to an El Paso hospital. She waited 2 1/2 months for the autopsy report, wondering whether his death resulted from injuries in a traffic accident 6 weeks earlier or poor medical care after the wreck.

When she finally saw the report, she was shocked to see her husband identified as Hispanic.

"He was white, blue eyes, really white. He was pink, a big white guy," she said. "There's no mistake he was a white man."

She called the medical examiner, and the error was corrected. But other problems surfaced that made her question the cause of death, and she was disturbed that no toxicology test was performed.

Medical examiners have goofed up eye color and gender. They've made mistakes on the locations of scars and tattoos, described gallbladders and appendixes that had long since been removed even confused one body for another.

Some medical examiners say such minor oversights don't indicate that the case has been bungled. Typos occur, and the eyes turn cloudy after death, Peerwani said.

An appendix may have been removed, but a fingertip-size portion could remain, he said.

But such errors call into question the integrity of death investigations, said Burnet County Justice of the Peace Peggy Simon, who caught numerous blunders by the Travis County medical examiner's office when it was headed by Dr. Roberto Bayardo.

Burnet County doesn't have a medical examiner, so like other counties with populations under 1 million, it relies on justices of the peace to sign death certificates. Simon goes to death scenes to perform the inquest, an inquiry to determine the cause of death.

Once, she saw a car crash victim's dentures lying next to his body. But when she read the autopsy report, it said the man's teeth were natural and in good condition.

Four years ago, she saw a charred body pulled from a car that was set on fire. Police identified the body as that of a man sentenced to prison for molesting a child. Apparently, he had killed himself. Final identification depended on findings by the medical examiner, which conducted autopsies not only for Travis but also for more than 40 other counties.

The autopsy, by Dr. Vladimir Parungao, reported that the body had a penis, as well as urine in the bladder. But Simon, who had observed the size of the body at the scene, challenged the autopsy and ordered DNA testing. Turned out the body was that of an elderly woman who had died more than a year earlier.

"A penis? Urine in the bladder? That would be pretty unlikely, I would think," Simon said.

The convicted man, Clayton Wayne Daniels, had dug up the body of the 81-year-old to fake his death.

"I wonder ... what mistakes your office has made?" Simon wrote the medical examiner.

Parungao told the Star-Telegram that when he received the body, police had identified it as Daniels. The body was so charred, he said, he had trouble identifying organs.

"I should have been very careful," he said. "I let my guard down."

He also said that Bayardo required pathologists to quickly issue autopsy reports, even before tests were completed; if new information came up, the policy was to amend the reports.

Bayardo, who has since retired, said that even competent medical examiners, like Parungao, can make mistakes. "He got bad information and took it 100 %," Bayardo said of his deputy in a recent interview.

Such inaccuracies can be corrected, he said; medical examiners can change their opinions, as he has done. Others say the willingness of some medical examiners to alter their conclusions shows their shaky foundation. In May 2007, Bayardo changed the original testimony that helped put Austin baby sitter Cathy Lynn Henderson on death row. In 1995, he testified that the baby died from intentional blows. But after experts hired by Henderson's attorneys challenged the opinion, Bayardo said he could not tell whether that had been the case or whether Henderson had accidentally dropped the child, as she claimed.

A criminal appeals court granted Henderson a reprieve 2 days before her scheduled execution. Her case was sent back to the trial court, where it is pending.

A team of other experts, including Galveston County Chief Medical Examiner Stephen Pustilnik, has reviewed the case for the state and said Bayardo was right the 1st time. Pustilnik said the baby's skull had been shattered and the death was clearly a homicide.

It took much probing to discover flaws in autopsies by former Lubbock Chief Medical Examiner Ralph Erdmann. After families raised concerns about errors in his work, Turner got court permission to disinter bodies so another pathologist could review the deaths. As the bodies were dug up, truths were unveiled.

A bullet was found inside the head of man whose autopsy report had noted an exit wound on the top of his head. A baby was found with intact intestines, though Erdmann had said the baby's bowels had been ruptured when he was struck.

Missing evidence

Lax laws and poor oversight allow such lapses, critics say.

One significant weakness: Texas law doesn't require medical examiners to take notes, produce body diagrams or photograph evidence.

Such documentation is essential, said Dr. Ray Fernandez, chief medical examiner for Nueces County. Without it, a medical examiner can't back up an autopsy in court or show the validity of conclusions if challenged.

"A good report is based on how well that person documents their observations, so that another pathologist looking at the photographs, the diagrams, the report looking at all of it can at least assess the accuracy of what was done," said Dr. LeRoy Riddick, a retired forensic pathologist who is a professor at the University of South Alabama. "The interpretations are something else."

In one of the state's most high-profile cases the 1991 murders of 4 teenage girls at an Austin yogurt shop pathologist Tommy Brown, who did the autopsies for Travis County, told jurors that he did not take crime scene photographs but relied on those taken by police.

He also said that "a lot of times" information he dictated didn't get into his autopsy reports or he didn't dictate information that should have been included. 2 men convicted in the slayings, based largely on their confessions, were released this summer after new DNA tests showed that another man could have been involved.

Bayardo told the Star-Telegram that he never took notes because he feared they would be subpoenaed.

"That's always a problem," he said.

Instead, he would create an autopsy report by dictating information on tape.

In another case that drew in the Tarrant medical examiners office, capital murder charges against a young couple were dismissed 2 years after their babys death when some evidence apparently disappeared.

That case offered up a merry-go-round of opinions.

Bayardo declared the cause of death undetermined. Peerwani, who was asked for a separate opinion, released a report saying that the baby died of head trauma and that the case was a homicide.

Bayardo questioned how Peerwani who didn't examine the brain because it was apparently misplaced came to that conclusion.

"How can you say she died of head injuries when you have no brain?" Bayardo said in a recent interview.

Peerwani has said he had slides with brain specimens and sent them to a specialist for review. The charges were dropped when the slides could not be found.

In a recent interview, Peerwani supported his preliminary finding of homicide: "A kid that little doesn't have so many rib fractures." The Texas Medical Board did take action after whistle-blowers complained about former Harris County Medical Examiner Joye Carter. Initially, it sought to revoke or suspend her license after finding that she used an unlicensed pathologist to conduct hundreds of autopsies. Eventually, though, she was fined $1,000.

Questions about her work continued to be raised.

Numerous pathologists, including Dr. Lloyd White of the Tarrant County medical examiner's office, have questioned Carters findings in the slaying of Conroe college student Melissa Trotter.

The time of the womans death was a critical piece of evidence. Carter said the young woman had been dead for 25 days or more when her body was found north of Houston. That helped persuade a jury to convict an ex-con. He could not have committed the crime if the woman had been dead a shorter time, because he was in jail for traffic violations.

But forensic pathologists testifying for the defense pointed to evidence that they said showed the body could not have been in the forest for more than 2 weeks. The young woman's weight before she died was just 4 pounds more than when Carter performed the autopsy. Had Trotter been dead for 25 days, her body would have been in more advanced stages of decomposition and weighed much less, the pathologists said.

Dr. Glenn Larkin, a former medical examiner in Pennsylvania, also called Carters autopsy "sloppy," "irresponsible" and "misleading," noting that key medical records were missing and that some tissue samples had disappeared.

After the criticism, Carter signed an affidavit agreeing that Trotter could not have been dead for more than 2 weeks. She blamed problems on not having key evidence during the autopsy. A video of the crime scene and medical records were not available to her, she wrote.

Carter did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

The convicted man's execution was postponed, but prosecutors are standing by Carter's original autopsy report. The defense team, clamoring for the appeals court to intervene, points out that the state is rejecting opinions from some of the very pathologists prosecutors have relied on in other criminal cases.

"If all [these] medical examiners are all wrong on Melissa Trotter, how can they be right on all other cases?" said private criminal investigator Tina Church.

"There's no room for error when somebodys life depends on their findings."

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Autopsies required


In Texas, inquests by medical examiners are required when:

- A person dies within 24 hours of admission to a hospital or institution.

- A person dies in prison or jail.

- A person is killed or dies an unnatural death.

- A person dies in the absence of one or more good witnesses.

- A body part or body of a person is found and the cause or circumstances of death are unknown.

- The circumstances of the death are suspicious.

- A person commits suicide or is suspected of having done so.

- A person dies without having been attended by a physician and the cause of death is unknown.

- A child younger than 6 dies and the death is reported under state law dealing with child welfare services.

- The attending physician is not certain about the cause of death.

[source: Texas law]

Source: Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Sept. 28, 2009

Saturday, November 29, 2008

Cathy Lynn Henderson Inches Closer to Possible New Trial

Cathy Lynn Henderson (pictured with Sr. Helen Prejean) has been back in the news as her case goes back before a Travis County Judge. As the Save Cathy Henderson site and Austin Legal reported last week, Judge Jon Wisser is holding a series of hearings to decide if Henderson should get a new trial. Six hearings take place throughout November. The prosecutors get their turn in January. At the heart of it: "Henderson's lawyers say new tests show Brandon may have fallen from Henderson's arms and was not intentionally smashed against a wall or floor."

She says it was an accident but the jury believed otherwise, making babysitter Cathy Lynn Henderson the only Travis County woman currently on Texas Death Row.

Just days before her scheduled Wednesday, June 13, 2007 execution, Henderson has been given a reprieve because new evidence might support her claims that 3-month old Brandon Baugh did die in an accidental fall in 1994.

At the Save Cathy Henderson web site you can read a PDF of the Affidavit of Roberto J. Bayardo, M.D.. Dr. Bayardo originally testified at Henderson's trial disputing her account of how the baby suffered his head injuries. He now says that in light of new evidence -- based on physics and biomechanics -- he "cannot determine with a reasonable degree of medical certainty whether Brandon Baugh's injuries resulted from an intentional act or an accidental fall." As reported in The Kansas City Star, Henderson says she was "swinging Brandon around in an attempt to soothe him when she lost her balance, and he flew from her arms."

Source: about.com, November 29, 2008