Showing posts with label Caribbean. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Caribbean. Show all posts

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Bahamas: Minnis Releases Draft Bill On Death Sentences

Opposition leader Dr Hubert Minnis has released a draft Bill which seeks to amend the constitution to cut the London-based Privy Council out of the appeal process in cases where a death sentence has been imposed.

After declaring in his New Years message on Tuesday that immediate steps must be taken to restore the integrity and effectiveness of the country's laws, including capital punishment, Dr Minnis unveiled a Bill for the Constitutional (Amendment) (Capital Offences) Act, 2014.

In the case of murder convictions, the Bill asserts, if the trial judge feels the nature and circumstances "are of such depravity, inhumanity, gravity or severity as to merit the imposition of a sentence of death", and the Court of Appeal agrees, the sentence cannot be appealed "to any other court anywhere else in the world".

The Bill adds that any delay in executing a death sentence caused by the convict's appeal will no longer be grounds for challenging the validity of that sentence.

This aims to overturn the 5 year limit imposed by the Privy Council.

It adds: "The holding of any person who is in a correctional facility or otherwise lawfully detained, prior to, during or after trial, and pending execution of a sentence of death imposed on that person, in conditions which immediately before the coming into operation of this Act were prescribed in the Correctional Facilities Act or the Prisons Act, as then in force; or were otherwise practiced in the Bahamas, shall not be a ground of appeal or of vitiation of such sentence of death."

During his New Years speech, Dr Minnis admitted the bulk of modern research asserts there is no evidence that the death penalty is a deterrent to the would-be murderer.

"That may be so, but what is also clear in our Bahamas is that today there is a hardened criminal element who have nothing but contempt for law, order, or human suffering, and for whom there is no respect for human life even the lives of innocent by-standers, and children," he said.

"At the very least, there should be the certainty of sure punishment, and punishment which is appropriate to the crimes committed. Our policy is not based upon any concept of deterrence; it is based on the right of national self-defence.

"The wave of gang and drug-related murders is a matter which threatens not only the wellbeing of every citizen and every community, it also threatens the fundamental integrity of the state. It threatens the way of life of every law abiding Bahamian. It threatens national security. Violent gun crimes and rampant murders must be tackled on that basis," the FNM leader said.

Dr Minnis said his Bill was designed to address several procedural weaknesses which have caused the Privy Council to overturn capital sentences for convicted murderers in the past; and to strengthen and to enhance the integrity and effectiveness of the trial process in serious gun-related and murder cases.

He said the stipulation that a death sentence appeal can only be made to the Bahamas Court of Appeal, and nowhere else, is a reflection of the FNM's considered view that "in so serious a question as the sentence for a convicted murderer, a determination that a crime is 'the worst of the worst' (or any similar legal formulation) should only be made by judges who reside in the Bahamas, and who consequentially have to live every day in the society which they help to shape by their rulings.

"All other appeals such as an appeal against conviction, or an appeal on constitutional grounds will still be able to be made to the Privy Council," Dr Minnis said.

"Under the Bill, the Governor General, acting on the advice of the Minister of National Security, will prescribe time limits for the lodging and conclusion of all appeals against conviction, or constitutional appeals.

"If the same are not concluded within such time limits, the Advisory Committee on the Prerogative of Mercy will be able to advise that the law should be brought into execution," he said.

The Bill would also remove the Constitutional right to trial by jury either at the request of the prosecution or at the request of the accused where there is a charge of having committed murder, manslaughter, or crimes involving the use of firearms to inflict harm or death, and particularly in instances where there is a likelihood of jury or witness tampering or intimidation.

"In such instances the case will be heard by a panel of 2 Supreme Court Judges along with a qualified non-judicial Attorney called an Assessor," Dr Minnis said.

He added: "As this Bill necessarily seeks to affect fundamental rights and freedoms which are presently enshrined and protected in the constitution, it will require the holding of a National Constitutional Referendum.

"My fellow Bahamians, it will be up to each and every one of you to decide whether these proposals become law by way of an amendment of our constitution."

Source: Tribune 242, January 9, 2014

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Jamaica: Cop killer escapes the gallows

Appeal Court sets aside death sentence of man found guilty of killing ACP Gilbert Kameka

The man who was sentenced to hang for the murder of Assistant Commissioner of Police Gilbert Kameka has won his appeal against his death sentence.

Massinissa Adams, 31, who was convicted in November 2009 along with two other men for the November 2007 murder, had appealed only against the death sentence.

Attorney-at-law Carolyn Reid Cameron argued that Adams should not face the death penalty.

She cited authorities to show that the Jamaican position was that life imprisonment should be imposed unless having considered all the available material and issues there is no prospect of social readaptation, and the circumstances of the case qualify it as the "rarest of the rare", the "worst of the worst" or "extreme and exceptional."

Reid Cameron argued that there was no evidence that Adams was prone to violence and the judge did not address her mind to the prospect of reform.

The Court of Appeal said that the judge's focus was essentially centred on the fact that the murder was premeditated.

"However, premeditation, in itself, would not have been a critical factor in determining whether the death penalty was justifiable in this case," the Appeal Court held. Kameka was killed by one of two shots and the Appeal Court pointed out that it was not a sadistic killing nor was the deceased tortured.

The court found that although the murder entailed a planned, cold-blooded killing, it could not be regarded as falling within the most extreme or exceptional cases.

Adams' death sentence was set aside and he was sentenced to life imprisonment and ordered to serve 35 years before he can be eligible for parole.

Source: Jamaica Gleaner, December 1, 2013

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

Bahamas: Child molester, killer sentenced to death

KOFHE Goodman has today been sentenced to hang for the murder of Marco Archer.

Goodman sat in the prisoner's dock in the Supreme Court hearing crouched forward with his hands on his chin. He made no verbal reaction when the death penalty sentence was handed down.

Justice Bernard Turner said: "This case is a clear and compelling case for the ultimate sentence of death, to satisfy the requirements of due punishment for the murder of this child and to protect this society from any further predatory conduct by this convict at any time in the future.

"Kofhe Edwardo Ferguson Goodman, I hereby sentence you to suffer death in the manner authorised by law."

Marco's mother Tryphemia Meadows told The Tribune afterwards that the sentence wouldn't bring back her son, but at least Goodman 'won't be able to hurt anymore little boys.'

Goodman, 39, stood trial between April 17 and August 2 in connection with the murder of Marco Archer. He was found guilty despite pleading not guilty to the murder charge he faced.

Between September 23 and September 28, 2011, Goodman killed 11-year-old Marco Archer, of Brougham Street.

A death sentence, life imprisonment, and a 15-year prison term were the punishments Justice Bernard Turner was asked by counsel to consider in the sentencing.

Justice Turner said today the case for death was a compelling one - it warranted 'the ultimate sentence of death' - having taken into account the circumstances of the case and Goodman's criminal history - which had revealed his former victims of buggery and attempted murder were around the same age as Marco Archer.

Justice Turner signed the ruling sentencing Goodman to the death penalty and court was adjourned.

Goodman’s attorney, Geoffrey Farquharson, indicated the intent to appeal conviction and sentence.

He asked the court to direct the Superintendent of Prisons to maintain his client's remand status pending the appeal application, rather than hold Goodman as a 'condemned man.'

Justice Turner said he would consider the application.

Source: Tribune 242, October 30, 2013

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

The ultimate price of poverty

Hundreds, possibly thousands, of people are put to death across the world every year. The majority of these are poor. IBA Global Insight assesses the socio-economic arguments for death penalty abolition.

'There are no millionaires on death row' goes the mantra, oft-repeated among death penalty abolitionists. It sounds glib, yet across the world, from the sharia courts of Iran to the jury trials of the United States, evidence suggests the poorest are indeed paying the highest price.

Death, like life, it seems, is essentially unfair. Even hardened pragmatists, who may not flinch at depriving a brutal murderer of his life, often concede that the law surrounding capital punishment is both flawed and ineffective.

In many countries the problem is not simple prejudice - though this too plays a part - but stems from the economics of the judicial system, in which the poor are reliant on the limited coffers of state aid for representation, while the rich retain the top talent for themselves. Elsewhere, where due process is weak, those without the means to pay bribes or blood money find themselves equally powerless. It is often in these less democratic countries that the harshest drug trafficking penalties are applied, in which stigmatised young mules are sacrificed and the kingpins go free.

The US and due process

Clive Stafford Smith, founder of human rights NGO Reprieve, is clear on the matter where the US is concerned. 'The death penalty is not for the worst criminal,' he says, quoting fellow attorney Stephen Bright. "It's for the person with the worst lawyer.'

Stafford Smith, who has saved more than 300 people from death row and last year won the IBA Human Rights Award, claims 'it's not that hard to persuade 12 jurors not to kill somebody'.

'But you've got to do your work,' he stresses. 'You've got to be prepared and you've got to know what you're about. And, unfortunately, when you look at lawyers, the most effective, high-powered lawyers represent huge corporations. The person whose life is at stake is killed.'

Stafford Smith is far from alone in this opinion. When prompted, US criminal defence attorneys working on death row will eagerly recount tales of flawed and feckless capital trials - horror stories of innocence ignored and justice violated. Their view is skewed, of course, by the nature of their position, and often fails to reflect the many cases where the rule of law is carefully and conscientiously applied. But, considering what is at stake, many are concerned that any such cases exist at all.

One case involves Linda Carty, currently on death row in Texas for the 2001 murder of Joana Rodriguez. After what was described by Reprieve as 'a catastrophically flawed trial', in which an 'utterly implausible' defence was mounted by a lawyer with 20 death row convictions to his name - the most of any attorney in the US - the British grandmother was sentenced to death in February 2002, and is now reliant on the Pardons Board and Governor of Texas for clemency.

Indeed, the issue of capital punishment has long been under scrutiny in Texas, which was responsible for 41 of 98 nationwide executions in 2009-10. In 2002, murder defendant Calvin Jerold Burdine, whose attorney slept through parts of the trial, gained a last-minute reprieve from the Supreme Court after surviving 6 execution dates and losing 3 federal appeals. More recently, strong evidence has emerged that Cameron Todd Willingham, executed in 2004 for an arson attack that killed his three children, may have been innocent after a series of experts attested that forensic data presented at trial had no scientific basis.

Death penalty supporter Josh Marquis, District Attorney for Astoria, Oregon, who is on the Board of Directors of the National District Attorney Association and is the US delegate to the International Association of Prosecutors, admits that 'there have been instances of innocent people on death row, no question about it', but says such instances are 'rare'. He also points out there is no conclusive evidence anyone innocent has been executed, stressing the rigorous 15-25-year appeals process designed to catch mistakes.

'Though the conventional wisdom says the defence is threadbare, the lawyers don't know what they are doing and the prosecution is well funded, that's just not true,' he says. 'It probably was 20 years ago, but not anymore. I've just finished a case where the state has spent almost US$3m on the defence, which is not tremendously unusual. I am regularly outspent 10 or 20 to 1.'

Marquis admits, however, that his expertise is limited to Oregon, 'which probably spends more money than any other state', and that 'some states still pay a lot less than others'. Richard Dieter, Executive Director of the Death Penalty Information Center (DPIC), a non-profit, anti-death penalty website, agrees. Though the quality of representation has improved significantly in the past 10 years, he says, stringent standards proposed by the American Bar Association (ABA) are yet to be adopted by the majority of the 35 retentionist states and even competent lawyers are often prevented from doing a good job by lack of funds.

'The ABA has outlined the goals to shoot for, but very few states are willing to do that. To do it you would have to pay lawyers a lot more to get the requisite experience, and you'd need a team of 4 or 5 specialists for each case. These things are not always done when a public defender has 10 other cases going on at the same time.'

States with relatively well-funded public defender programmes, such as Oregon and California, experience their own set of problems. Because of the high standards set for counsel, demand far outweighs supply; a recent estimate suggests that more than 100 of the 700 death row inmates in California are currently without counsel for their direct appeal.

'If there is a problem with capital litigation, it is not during the trial itself, it is during the appeals process,' says death penalty supporter Michael Ramos, District Attorney for San Bernardino County and President of the California District Attorneys' Association. 'The delay in appeals is very frustrating for everyone involved. We need to have additional resources to increase numbers of appellate attorneys, not only for defendants but for the state attorney general office, so they can handle the volume of appeals.'

Despite these problems, Marquis and Ramos are adamant that capital punishment is fair, pointing out that only one in 800 murderers receive the penalty, so it is reserved for the very worst offenders. For Ramos, the justification is simple - 'an eye for an eye', he feels, 'is justice for taking someone's life' due to the irreparable trauma inflicted on victims' families. For Marquis, it is a 'cost-benefit analysis', the prospect of due process error counterbalanced by the potential lives of innocent victims saved. Capital punishment, he believes, acts both as a general and specific deterrent, the latter meaning that the particular person convicted will never have the opportunity to kill again - as happened in the cases of Kenneth McDuff, Robert Massie and Richard Marquette.

'If you have a system of capital punishment, there are going to be errors,' he says. 'But it's a cost-benefit analysis, and it's something we do in our societies all the time. Pharmaceutical companies are allowed to produce drugs that kill a small percentage of people. We don't ban prescription medicines, we try to do better.'

Since 1973, the year after the death penalty was briefly ruled unconstitutional in the US, 138 people have been released from death row after evidence emerged of their 'innocence', according to the DPIC - though Marquis claims only 5 of these were exonerated by DNA. Overall, between 1976 - when the death penalty was revived - and 1995, around 2 in 3 death row inmates had their sentences overturned on appeal, according to a study by Columbia University. Proponents of the punishment cite this as evidence of the system working effectively and catching mistakes before it is too late. Others point out the trauma inflicted on both defendants and victims during the decades-long wait for their appeals to be heard.

Indeed, having a conviction - rather than sentence - overturned is extremely difficult, Dieter says. Proving the original evidence was a little shaky tends not to be enough for most appellate courts; you need something nonsubjective. 'If there is just a little doubt, they have no problem with going ahead - especially in Texas.'

Execution in China
Responding to Dieter's comment, Rob Kepple, the Executive Director of the Texas Justice District and Country Attorneys Association, said: 'After all the legal appeals are done, shouldn't it be a challenge to get a conviction thrown out just because 15 years later an original witness now says he lied at the trial, and that another guy did it - who is usually dead?

'In our country, the state proves cases beyond a reasonable doubt, so by definition all lawyers agree that prosecutors will proceed if there is "just a little bit of doubt." Remember, there are no perfect trials, only fair ones. There is no such thing as beyond all doubt.'

Kepple, Ramos and Marquis are far from alone in their opinions. In an October 2010 Gallup poll of 1,025 adults, 64 % of respondents said they supported the penalty compared to 29 % who said they opposed it. However, support dropped to 49 % when life without the possibility of parole was given as an option, and death penalty opponents are confident support among legislators is waning. Indeed, the number of executions across the country dropped from 98 in 1999 to 46 in 2010, and Illinois voted in January to become the 16th abolitionist state.

Amnesty International USA Chair Rick Halperin doesn't mince his words where the death penalty is concerned: 'Capital punishment is class warfare against the poor. It doesn't approach anything associated with justice. It is about money, race and power.' Halperin is avowedly on the left of the political spectrum, but such opinions are not the preserve of the liberal elite: in 2000, Illinois Governor George Ryan (Rep) commuted all death sentences to life imprisonment due to concern about the way the law was being applied, and in 1994, Republican Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun, who began his tenure on the court in 1970 as a staunch death penalty defender, lamented the Court's failure to prevent 'the biases and prejudices that infect society generally' from influencing decisions on who should be put to death.

One well-documented legal bias is that against African-Americans. Since 1976, 15 white people have been put to death for killing black people, compared to 246 black people killed for murdering whites, according to the DPIC. It is statistics like this that have convinced many non-ideologues, like Michael Radelet, sociology lecturer and death penalty expert at the University of Colorado, to become vehement abolitionists. 'The question is not how you support the death penalty in theory, but how it is actually applied,' says Radelet. 'If the world were a fair place, maybe it would be different. But that would be the death penalty in DisneyLand. If applied equally, it would be the only thing in the US that is.'

A world view

In almost every one of the 58 countries still retaining the death penalty, 'poverty has the same parameters', says Emmanouil Athanasiou, Asia Programme Officer at the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH). 'Rich people pay good lawyers and get good representation. Poor people end up with lawyers not even specialised in the death penalty.'

In Malaysia, nearly 90 % of the 300 people on death row are below the poverty line, according to lawyer and human rights activist Charles Hector. In China, the number of annual executions is a state secret, but is reported by Amnesty International to be in the thousands. Here, subjugated groups such as unskilled workers, the minority Muslim Uighurs and the Falun Gong spiritual sect all have little means of defence if arrested on a capital charge in China - charges that cover 55 separate offences, cut down from 68 in August 2010. Sufficient money to create a workable system will never be provided, Athanasiou believes, both because the threat of death acts as a useful tool of repression and because the more defence lawyers who develop expertise, 'the bigger the risk of state secrets being leaked'.

In sub-Saharan Africa, Marie-Dominique Parent, of the Penal Reform Institute (PRI), says that few countries provide workable legal aid schemes offering 'quality defence' for the poor. The most populous country, Nigeria, has around 600 people on death row, all of whom are believed to be without adequate counsel. According to a 2008 Amnesty International report, hundreds of these inmates - most of whom were convicted of robbery and armed robbery - were not given a fair trial, with many of their confessions made under torture.

'The police are over-stretched and underresourced,' says Amnesty International's Nigeria researcher Aster van Kregten. 'Because of this, they rely heavily on confessions to "solve" crimes, rather than on expensive investigations.'

According to former Detective Superintendent Bob Denmark, of Lancashire Constabulary, who has worked with officers in Eastern Europe, Asia and Africa, forced confessions and police treatment of the poor is a bigger global issue than judicial discrimination. 'The police are simply not given any other tools to work with, such as interview skills or the means to collect evidence,' he says. 'I think police prejudice can be so overwhelming that often whether the judiciary is prejudiced can be something of a nuance compared to that.'

Crime and oppression

But what of cases where the crime is clearcut and no corruption of due process has occurred? After all, it may be the poorer members of society who face the severest penalties, but perhaps this is because it is these people who commit the most crimes. For many, however, this argument in itself points to a more profound social concern among oppressive states. The trend is a common one: government policies help create polarities of wealth, socio-economic tensions erupt and harsh punitive measures are unleashed against those least able to retaliate, to demonstrate that 'order' has been restored.

'The Chinese regime creates the social and economic conditions that make crime inevitable,' says sinologist and author Marie Holzman. She uses the case of Wang Bingyu as an example - a young man who killed his factory boss after he refused to pay him, despite knowing Bingyu needed the money to fund a life-saving operation for his father. 'The Party had to execute him fast because they knew a lot of workers would follow his example, because they treat them so badly.'

It is not hard to find similar tales from across the world. Herbert Smith lawyer Anita Phillips represents death row prisoners from Trinidad, Tobago and Jamaica before the Privy Council, the highest court of appeal for Commonwealth countries, most of which still retain capital punishment. She confirms that most of her clients are poor, illiterate young men in gangs. Though there have been no executions in Trinidad and Tobago since 1999, soaring homicide rates have recently prompted the government to consider lifting the unofficial moratorium. 'These men are prejudiced against because they haven't been educated, or are suffering from psychological problems,' says Phillips. 'They are often refused writing materials and other means of contacting their lawyers.'

'It is not uncommon for clients to meet lawyers on the 1st day of the trial,' adds Saul Lehrfreund, Co-founder of the Death Penalty Project, which provides legal aid to death row prisoners in Caribbean countries. 'There just aren't enough funds to call medical experts or psychiatrists. Because of this, often the medically impaired are sentenced to death.'

Fortunately, many are saved in the Caribbean by a 1993 Privy Council ruling that restricted death row tenure to five years; after this point, all sentences must be commuted to life imprisonment. Prisoners in many other countries, including the US, are not so lucky. Here, the immense cost of a death penalty case due to the lengthy appellate process - US$3 million, compared to around US$1 million for life imprisonment - is a valuable argument employed by abolitionists when trying to persuade policy-makers to consider their options. For them, the choice is clear: spend millions punishing people haphazardly and ineffectually or use the same money to tackle the underlying causes of social unrest.

Public execution in Yemen
'Say the government is spending US$300 million a year on the death penalty, that money could go towards more police on the streets, better lighting in crime areas, open libraries,' says Dieter. 'You have to ask if this is the best use of crime fighting dollars.'

The US administration may not be actively seeking to punish its poorest, but its high crime rate and harsh penal system align it uncomfortably with countries whose nominal value systems differ markedly from its own. In Vietnam, for example, where 22 crimes are punishable by death, the regime's rejection of long-term solutions for superficial fixes is not unfamiliar. Here, where polarities of wealth have sky-rocketed since the country opened its doors to the market economy in 1986, the death penalty is viewed more as a tool of social control than of justice.

Recently, Vo Van Ai, President of the Vietnam Committee on Human Rights (VCHR), appealed for a presidential pardon for 20-year-old student Phan Minh Man, condemned to death in July 2010 for the murder of his alcoholic father, who savagely beat his family after failing to find work. 'The death sentence on this student should be a reminder to us all, and to you, Mr President, that Vietnam still suffers from chronic economic and social problems that plunge millions of citizens into insecurity and despair, and gives rise to innumerable tragedies,' Ai writes. 'It is vital that the government respond to these problems by prevention rather than repression, by protecting worker rights and providing adequate social safeguards for the unemployed.'

Drugs and corruption

Topping the list of social ills in Vietnam is the problem of drugs. According to VCHR Vice-President Penelope Faulkner, the police and Communist Party 'unofficially connive' with dealers, giving immunity to those at the top of the food chain. The people caught instead are the young, poor and easily manipulated.

Vietnam is not alone. Since 1948, the number of countries with death penalties for drugs offences has rocketed from one to 32, while the number of annual executions has risen to the hundreds - or possibly even the thousands once the secret data of China, Vietnam, North Korea, Malaysia and Singapore is taken into account. 'In the places where we have data, we know it is almost always poor and vulnerable people, and often foreigners, who receive the death penalty for drugs offences,' says Human Rights Analyst Patrick Gallahue, from the International Harm Reduction Association. 'Pablo Escobar was never swallowing drugs and crossing borders, so the idea it will act as some sort of deterrent to the highest levels of drug trafficking is some kind of fallacy.'

In Iran, occasional announcements from the authorities suggest that some cities have up to 500 death row convicts for drugsrelated offences alone. In 2009, there were 172 recorded executions for perpetrators of drug crimes, all of whom were tried in Revolutionary Courts. The European Union must be more aware, says Gallahue, that when it offers support for anti-narcotics programmes overseas, it 'takes into consideration the possibility of these programmes leading to the death penalty being enforced'.

Similar problems continue to plague Thailand, where nearly half of the current 708 death row population were convicted on drugs-related charges. Here, corruption is endemic, with the level of sentence determined on the basis of a police report sent to the prosecutor. 'So the officers will ask the prisoner whether they want the death penalty or not,' says Danthong Breen, Chairman of the Union for Civil Liberty, a leading human rights organisation based in Bangkok. 'And that depends on how much you pay them.'

In Nigeria, bribes are the best hope of survival for the 750-plus people on death row, and those unable to join the cash-for-clemency scheme are left to flounder. Speaking in July 2008, Owens Wiwa, the brother of an executed Ogoni activist, said: 'From their 1st contact with the police, through the trial process to seeking pardon, those with the fewest resources are at a serious disadvantage in Nigeria's criminal justice system.

'Some death row prisoners were arrested when they went to a police station because they knew a suspect or had witnessed a crime. Many said the police rounded them up and thendemanded money for their release.'

Bribery among the judiciary in China is now 'worse than ever', according to Holzman. The practice gained new life in 2007, she says, when laws were brought in that required the Supreme People's Court to revise every death penalty case. 'People who pay enough to the judge can buy their life back,' says Holzman. 'But if you are poor and can't pay, you'll get it, no questions asked.'

In Muslim countries, buying one's life back is a familiar practice, but it is from the families of crime victims rather than the state. Diyat, or blood money, is paid to the victim's family, who then have the power to pardon or commute the perpetrator's sentence. Indeed, Article 220 of the Islamic Penal Code states that a father who kills his own child is only required to pay diyat and is subject to a discretionary punishment. 'If someone who is accused is rich, they can sometimes even change the accusation,' says Athanasiou. 'This is the case in every Muslim country.'

Reform or rejection?

So what hope is there of global reform - of making the death penalty a fair and equitable punishment, applied only according to the most stringent standards of due process - when so many forces collude to mire it in prejudice and corruption? For most campaigners, reform is not the issue; for them, capital punishment is an infringement of basic rights, irrespective of the crime. Yet even those who simply oppose the penalty as currently practised do not place reform high on the agenda. No government has enough resources to make the requisite changes, they argue, even should they have the will to do so.

'To convince me reform was an option, you would have to convince me that everyone had a fair trial and that the system was infallible,' says Lehrfreund. 'You would have to convince me that criminal justice was science.'

Public execution in Iran
'I could probably be persuaded that the death penalty was a necessary evil if it could be proved that it would produce a safer society because its deterrent effect was so strong,' adds Freshfields partner Paul Lomas, who represents Caribbean death row prisoners before the Privy Council. 'The problem is, I've never seen any credible case that it acts as a deterrent. I've only seen aspirational cases, which, when unpicked, were actually based on somebody's revenge theories of justice.'

Whether worldwide abolition is on the horizon is difficult to judge. Most staunch advocates give forecasts ranging from ten to 50 years, in the hope capital punishment will soon be as much an anachronism for modern society as slavery or apartheid. Global trends seem to support this view. In 1977, only 16 countries had abolished the death penalty for all crimes; in December 2009, the figure stands at 95, and more than 2/3 of countries have abolished the penalty in law or practice, according to Amnesty International. Countries are perhaps feeling the pressure of developing international human rights standards: in 1976, Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights declared the death penalty should only be imposed 'for the most serious crimes', now generally accepted to exclude drugs and economic offences, and in 2007, the UN General Assembly passed a resolution calling upon members to establish moratoriums of executions, with a view to abolition.

Yet considering how deeply embroidered the practice is in the legal and social infrastructures of so many retentionist states, many activists could be accused of a somewhat blinkered optimism. In Iran, according to the World Coalition Against the Death Penalty, at least 346 people were executed in 2008 - more than 4 times the number killed in 2005. And in China, most activists believe abolition is impossible while the Communist Party remains in power.

It is clear, however, that abolitionists have a passion, focus and coherence lacking from their opponents - and they will not stop fighting until their objective is achieved. 'You rarely see people actively campaigning in the street to keep the death penalty, do you?' says Athanasiou. 'Anyone who has strong enough feelings to make a stand invariably argues against it.'

For information on how to get involved in pro bono work go to: www.internationalprobono.com.

Source: International Bar Association, October 22, 2013

Friday, October 18, 2013

Group fights for end of death penalty in Caribbean

The newly-constituted campaign group Greater Caribbean for Life continues its call for Caribbean countries that retain the death penalty to abolish it.

T&T's Leela Ramdeen who is well known for her work with the Catholic Commission for Social Justice holds the chair.

The organisation claims that tackling crime can be achieved without the enforcement of the death penalty, even though statistics show that murders in the Caribbean have increased in the past decade.

T&T and Barbados are said to be the only english-speaking Caribbean countries that retain the mandatory death penalty for murder.

To mark the observance of World Day Against the Death Penalty on October 10, the delegation of the European Union brought together its members at the National Academy for the Performing Arts on Frederick Street, Port-of-Spain, for the viewing of a film on the topic.

Earlier this year, it hosted a conference titled Delivering on the Death Penalty.

Greater Caribbean for Life representatives from 12 Caribbean countries earlier this month gathered in Port-of-Spain to debate the issue in the context of public security.

The meeting concluded with the adoption of a formal constitution of the Greater Caribbean for Life, an organisation that comprises individuals and organisations from the across the region.

The goal of the campaign group is to achieve the permanent abolition of capital punishment in every Caribbean state and the creation of a culture of respect for the right to life and the inherent dignity of all human beings.

Source: Trinidad Guardian, October 17, 2013

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Trinidad & Tobago: AG proposes categories for murder

Government is considering introducing categories of murder as it seeks to strengthen laws which deal with such crimes, Attorney General Anand Ramlogan said on Thursday last as he met with a delegation from Amnesty International (AI).

Also discussed at last Thursday's meeting were mutual concerns of protection and preservation of human rights, police brutality and the need for improved efficiency in the criminal justice system.

According to a statement from the Office of the Attorney General, the issue of the death penalty was discussed and while Ramlogan pointed out that the death penalty was part of the laws of Trinidad and Tobago he advised that significant attempts were being made by the Government to improve the current law by introducing categories of murder. He said the death penalty would be reserved for the most heinous of murders without any extenuating circumstances. According to Ramlogan, legislation on the categorisation of murder had been rejected when taken to Parliament due to a lack of support from the Opposition.

According to the statement, the AG agreed that there was a greater need for public awareness or a public education campaign on the very emotional and sensitive issue of the death penalty, which he said the majority of the population appeared to support.

He urged the delegation to consider the rights of the victims as part of their deliberations and discussions to ensure that it is properly factored into the agenda for the abolition of the death penalty.

The Attorney General told the visiting AI delegation while many positive studies have been made for the protection and preservation of human rights, he said there was room for improvement. The AI team was led by Chiara Sangiorgio and the meeting was held at the Office of the Prime Minister, St Clair.

Also present at the meeting were newly appointed chairperson of the Greater Caribbean for Life, Leela Ramdeen and attorney Nicole Sylvester, Assistant Secretary of the Greater Caribbean for Life and president of the Human Rights Association in St Vincent.

The meeting was part of Amnesty's promotion of International Awareness for World Day against the death penalty, which will be commemorated this Thursday with special focus on the Caribbean region.

Source: Newsday, October 7, 2013

Friday, May 11, 2012

The global fight to end capital punishment

The death penalty is a shameful legacy of colonialism – now British lawyers are fighting to abolish it around the world by representing condemned prisoners in court.

"If we needed to hang someone tomorrow," Martin Martinez, Trinidad and Tobago's commissioner of prisons, says, grinning wolfishly, "we would grease up the gallows and buy some new rope." Death by hanging is the penalty for anyone convicted of murder in Trinidad and Tobago, although no one has been executed here since 1999.

From his air-conditioned office, minutes from the cemetery in the capital, Port of Spain, Martinez reels off the four witnesses needed: a doctor, a priest, a court official and himself, the prisons commissioner. "It is traumatising to take a man's life," he explains. "It's an emotional issue, as there is such a high murder rate here. The death penalty sends a message, but it may or may not solve the problem."

Prime minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar, backed by former Fifa vice-president Jack Warner, who is now her minister for works and transport, is campaigning for enforcement of the death penalty to fight the "the tsunami of crime" that has hit Trinidad and Tobago. In Jamaica, which has one of the world's highest murder rates, there is also a growing clamour for the rope to be used.

The debate is close to boiling point in the English-speaking Caribbean, partly because it plays on one of the few remaining links to Britain colonialism. The fate of those on death row is currently decided more than 4,000 miles away, in Westminster, at the judicial committee of the privy council (JCPC). "We talk about independence, meaning a flag and an anthem," Martinez says, "but we need to sever the umbilical cord with the mother country."

The JCPC remains the highest court of appeal for 27 countries, including former Caribbean colonies, and the persuasiveness of a British campaign to abolish capital punishment – argued through successive cases – has prevented many islands from carrying out punishments that remain on their statute books.


Source: The Guardian, May 6, 2012

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Britain says it will continue to work with the Caribbean to abolish death penalty

The British government says it will continue to work with a number of countries including those in the Caribbean to abolish the death penalty. 

In its newly released “Human Rights and Democracy Report” the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) said that the United Kingdom’s long-standing policy to oppose the death penalty in all circumstances remains as a matter of principle. 

“We consider that its use undermines human dignity, that there is no conclusive evidence that it has any value as a deterrent, and that any miscarriage of justice is irreversible and irreparable. Global abolition of the death penalty continues to be a priority for the UK Government. 

“The international trend towards abolition of the death penalty was maintained in 2011 and we are keen to see this trend continue,” the FCO said in its newly released report, noting that in October last year, the government published an updated Strategy for Abolition of the Death Penalty, setting out its “three goals to support our overarching objective of global abolition of the death penalty”. 

It said among the goals are to increase the number of abolitionist countries, or countries with a moratorium on the use of the death penalty and ensure that the European Union (EU) minimum standards on the death penalty, such as fair trial rights and non-execution of juveniles, are met in countries which retain the death penalty. 

“Following careful review, our priority countries - China, the US, Belarus, Commonwealth Caribbean and Iran - remain the same, London said, adding that it has raised the death penalty bilaterally with a number of our priority countries at both official and ministerial level, including Japan, the Commonwealth Caribbean, Belarus and Singapore. 

London said that it would continue to work with the European Union Commission to improve the effectiveness of the various strategies against the death penalty in 2012. 

“We believe that the UK has most directly impacted on progress towards global abolition of the death penalty through our project work,” adding that through the United Nations “we continued to raise the death penalty in the Universal Periodic Review process, and encouraged countries including Trinidad and Tobago, Singapore and Antigua to formally establish moratoriums on the use of the death penalty with a view to abolition. 

“In 2012, we will continue to implement our strategy and its 3 goals. We will work hard to ensure that the biennial UN General Assembly Resolution on the Moratorium on the Use of the Death Penalty again achieves record support, as it did in 2010. This will truly reinforce the international trend towards global abolition,” it added. 

Source: Jamaica Observer, May 2, 2012

Sunday, April 29, 2012

Trinidad and Tobago: Hangings could resume

HERALDING what she described as “a new dawn in this country’s legal history”, Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar yesterday announced her Government’s intention to table a bill to make the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) this country’s final criminal court, replacing the Privy Council’s criminal jurisdiction and in the process possibly clearing the way for the resumption of the death penalty.

The move to the CCJ as the final criminal court, which would require a special majority in the Parliament, yesterday looked set for a clear path toward implementation after Opposition Leader Dr Keith Rowley and senior members of the Independent benches of the Senate indicated their support in principle. The Government needs Opposition and Independent bench support in order to pass special majority legislation.

In a special statement in the House of Representatives yesterday afternoon, the Prime Minister expressed “immeasurable pride” at the move towards the CCJ but was careful to point out that the country would still maintain the civil jurisdiction of the Privy Council in a move to preserve investor confidence in the system of commercial litigation.

“In this year as we celebrate our 50th anniversary of independence this year, the time has surely come for us to review our relationship with the Privy Council,” Persad-Bissessar said.

“I am pleased to announce that the Government will be bringing legislation to this Honourable House to secure the abolition of appeals to the Privy Council in all criminal matters so that this jurisdiction would then be ceded to the Caribbean Court of Justice,” she told MPs gathered at the International Waterfront Centre, Wrightson Road, Port-of-Spain.


Source: Trinidad and Tobago Newsday, April 26, 2012

Related article:
Apr 27, 2012
Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar said the government will submit legislation to parliament to abolish appeals to the London-based Privy Council, the final court of appeal for former and current British territories in the ...

Friday, April 27, 2012

Trinidad wants to withdraw from Britain's Privy Council

Trinidad and Tobago plans to stop sending appeals in criminal cases to Britain's Privy Council, a move that could make it easier for death sentences to be carried out in the Caribbean country.

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar said the government will submit legislation to parliament to abolish appeals to the London-based Privy Council, the final court of appeal for former and current British territories in the Caribbean.

The jurisdiction of the Privy Council in criminal appeals is "a matter of grave concern," Persad-Bissessar told parliament late on Wednesday, adding it "affects the dispensation of criminal justice at a time of high crime in our country."

"The situation has been complicated by the issue of the death penalty on which the Privy Council, reflecting contemporary English mores and jurisprudence, has been rigorous in upholding Caribbean appeals in death sentence cases," she said.

A former British colony, Trinidad and Tobago has faced criticism from human rights groups over its use of executions for some violent crimes. Capital punishment, however, enjoys wide support among Trinidadians who view it as a crime deterrent.

The energy rich, twin-island country is battling a high murder rate. Police say it is linked to drug trafficking in Trinidad and Tobago, a trans-shipment point for South American cocaine headed to Europe and the United States.

Last year, Persad-Bissessar imposed a four-month state of emergency to crack down on drug-related crime and gang activity.

Under the proposed legislation, appeals in criminal cases would be handled by the Caribbean Court of Justice - based in Port of Spain and now the final court of appeal for several Caribbean countries.

The last execution held in Trinidad and Tobago was in 1999 and involved a man found guilty of murdering a taxi driver. Earlier that year, nine members of a criminal gang were hanged for murder.

Source: Reuters, April 26, 2012

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Death penalty 2011: Alarming levels of executions in the few countries that kill


Public execution in Iran
 Countries that carried out executions in 2011 did so at an alarming rate but those employing capital punishment have decreased by more than 1/3 compared to a decade ago, Amnesty International found in its annual review of death sentences and executions. 

Only 10 % of countries in the world, 20 out of 198, carried out executions last year. 

People were executed or sentenced to death for a range of offences including adultery and sodomy in Iran, blasphemy in Pakistan, sorcery in Saudi Arabia, the trafficking of human bones in the Republic of Congo, and drug offences in more than 10 countries. 

Methods of execution in 2011 included beheading, hanging, lethal injection and shooting. 

Some 18,750 people remained under sentence of death at the end of 2011 and at least 676 people were executed worldwide. 

But these figures do not include the thousands of executions that Amnesty International believes were carried out in China, where the numbers are suppressed. 

Nor do they account for the probable extent of Iran’s use of the death penalty – Amnesty International has had credible reports of substantial numbers of executions not officially acknowledged. 

"The vast majority of countries have moved away from using the death penalty," said Salil Shetty Secretary General of Amnesty International. 

"Our message to the leaders of the isolated minority of countries that continue to execute is clear: you are out of step with the rest of the world on this issue and it is time you took steps to end this most cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment." 

In the Middle East there has been a steep rise in recorded executions – up almost 50 % on the previous year. 

This was due to 4 countries – Iraq (at least 68 executions), Iran (at least 360), Saudi Arabia (at least 82) and Yemen (at least 41) – which accounted for 99 % of all recorded executions in the Middle East and North Africa. The rise in Iran and Saudi Arabia alone accounted for the net increase in recorded executions across the world of 149, compared to 2010. 

Thousands of people were executed in China in 2011, more than the rest of the world put together. Figures on the death penalty are a state secret. Amnesty International has stopped publishing figures it collects from public sources in China as these are likely to grossly underestimate the true number. 

The organization renewed its challenge to the Chinese authorities to publish data on those executed and sentenced to death, in order to confirm their claims that various changes in law and practice have led to a significant reduction in the use of the death penalty in the country over the last 4 years. 

In Iran, Amnesty International received credible reports of a large number of unconfirmed or even secret executions which would almost double the levels officially acknowledged. 

At least 3 people were executed in Iran for crimes that were committed when they were under 18 years of age, in violation of international law. A further 4 unconfirmed executions of juvenile offenders were reported there, and 1 in Saudi Arabia. 

The United States was again the only country in the Americas and the only member of the G8 group of leading economies to execute prisoners – 43 in 2011. Europe and former Soviet Union countries were capital punishment-free, apart from Belarus where 2 people were executed. The Pacific was death penalty-free except for five death sentences in Papua New Guinea. 

In Belarus and Vietnam, prisoners were not informed of their forthcoming execution, nor were their families or lawyers. Public judicial executions were known to have been carried out in North Korea, Saudi Arabia and Somalia, as well as in Iran. 

In the majority of countries where people were sentenced to death or executed, the trials did not meet international fair trial standards. In some, this involved the extraction of 'confessions' through torture or other duress including in China, Iran, Iraq, North Korea, and Saudi Arabia. 

Foreign nationals were disproportionately affected by the use of the death penalty, particularly in Saudi Arabia, Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand. 

But even in those countries that continue to execute on a high level some progress was made in 2011. 

In China, the government eliminated the death penalty for 13 mainly 'white collar' crimes, and measures were also put forward to the National People’s Congress to reduce the number of cases of torture in detention, strengthen the role of defence lawyers and ensure suspects in capital cases are represented by a lawyer. 

In the USA, the number of executions and new death sentences dropped dramatically from a decade ago. Illinois became the 16th state to abolish the death penalty. A moratorium was announced in the state of Oregon. And victims of violent crimes spoke out against the death penalty 

"Even among the small group of countries that executed in 2011, we can see gradual progress. These are small steps but such incremental measures have been shown ultimately to lead to the end of the death penalty," said Salil Shetty. 

"It is not going to happen overnight but we are determined that we will see the day when the death penalty is consigned to history." 

Amnesty International opposes the death penalty in all cases without exception regardless of the nature of the crime, the characteristics of the offender or the method used by the state to carry out the execution. The death penalty violates the right to life and is the ultimate cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment. 

Regional summaries 

The Americas 

The US was once again the only executioner in the Americas. A total of 43 executions were recorded in 13 of the 34 states that retain the death penalty, a drop by a third since 2001, and 78 new death sentences were recorded in 2011, a decrease by half since 2001. 

The Caribbean 

An execution-free area, with the number of countries imposing new death sentences appearing to be in decline. Only three countries are known to have handed down a total of six death sentences: Guyana, Saint Lucia and Trinidad and Tobago. 

Asia-Pacific 

Positive signs questioning the legitimacy of capital punishment were evident throughout the region in 2011. Not counting the thousands of executions that were believed to have taken place in China, at least 51 executions were reported to have been carried out in 7 countries in the Asia-Pacific region. At least 833 new death sentences were known to have been imposed in 18 countries in the region. The Pacific sub-region was death penalty-free with the exception of 5 death sentences handed down in Papua New Guinea. No executions were recorded in Singapore and, for the 1st time in 19 years, Japan. The authorities in both countries have previously shown strong support for capital punishment. 

Sub-Saharan Africa 

Significant progress in 2011 - Benin adopted legislation to ratify the key UN treaty aimed at abolishing the death penalty. Sierra Leone declared, and Nigeria confirmed, official moratoriums on executions. And the Constitutional Review Commission in Ghana recommended the abolition of the death penalty. There were at least 22 executions in three countries in sub-Saharan Africa: Somalia, Sudan and South Sudan. Only 14 of the 49 countries in the region are classified as retaining the death penalty. 

Middle East and North Africa 

At least 558 executions could be confirmed in eight countries. At least 750 death sentences imposed in 2011 could be confirmed in 15 countries. The continuing violence in countries such as Libya, Syria and Yemen made it particularly difficult to gather adequate information on the use of the death penalty in the region in 2011. No information was available about judicial executions in Libya, and no death sentences are known to have been imposed. Extrajudicial executions, torture and arbitrary detention were often resorted to instead. 

4 countries – Iraq, Iran, Saudi Arabia and Yemen – accounted for 99 per cent of all recorded executions in the Middle East and North Africa. The authorities of Algeria, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Morocco/Western Sahara and Qatar imposed death sentences but continued to refrain from carrying out executions. 

Europe and Central Asia 

Belarus was the only country in Europe and the former Soviet Union, and apart from the USA the only one in the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), to have carried out executions in 2011, executing 2 men. 

Source: Amnesty International, March 27, 2012

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Trinidad and Tobago: Government working to implement death penalty

January 22, 2012: Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar says Government will work to implement the death penalty in Trinidad as part of a serious crime reduction tool.

Persad-Bissessar was delivering an address yesterday at the Ministry of National Security Planning Workshop organised by the Center for Hemispheric Defense Studies (CHDS) yesterday at the Hyatt Regency (Trinidad) hotel, Port of Spain.

With 30 murders in the first 21 days of the year, she said Government is aware of the upsurge in the homicide rate although it has been reduced significantly from 2009 to 2011.

“Despite the fact the statistics for 2011 reveal a decrease in homicide and serious crime, Government is appalled at the brutal nature of the crime. The cautious optimism with which we viewed last year’s statistics…should not be misinterpreted as complacency,” she said.

She said because of this the People’s Partnership government is prepared to use all the resources including the death penalty to vigorously pursue and contain criminal activity.

“To this end my government is committed to implementation of the death penalty which remains part of the laws of Trinidad and Tobago… We shall continue in our effort to facilitate the re-implementation of the death penalty so it might both punish the guilty and deter the would-be offenders,” she stated.

She said regrettably the Constitution Capital Offences Bill 2011 which required a special majority in Parliament did not receive the support of some members.

She said her Government that had introduced 11 other pieces of legislation to aid in combating, including the Abolishing of the Preliminary Enquiry Act, the DNA Bill among others.

Persad-Bissessar said since her Government took office back in May 2010, it had been attempting to address “the tsunami of crime that has hit Trinidad and Tobago”.

“We have pledged to the people of this country that we are going to rid the country the scourge of criminal elements which have been allowed for too long to thrive and prosper on the decent, innocent and hard-working people,” she said.

She added that the Government was compelled to admit that criminal violence occurred too regularly.

Earlier in her address, Persad-Bissessar crime and violence threatened the welfare of citizens and economic growth.

Minister of National Security John Sandy said the workshop was aimed at developing a policy where the Caribbean Basin becomes a safer and more secure place to work, live and do business.

Attending the workshop were United States Ambassador Beatrice Welters, Commissioner of Police Dwayne Gibbs and various Government MPs.

Source: Trinidad Express, January 22, 2012

Friday, November 25, 2011

Linda Carty: "I'm in hell on death row but I didn't kill anyone!"

Linda Carty
The 1st British woman to face the death penalty in 50 years has spoken from a Texan jail cell to insist she is innocent and her life is a living “hell”.

Grandmother Linda Carty, 53, has been on death row for 10 years after being found guilty in a circumstantial case of kidnapping and murdering a mother to steal her newborn baby.

Human rights groups and a raft of celebrity supporters have blasted her defence lawyer, claiming his handling of the case was shambolic.

There was no forensic evidence linking her with the abduction and the men who carried out the crime, who claimed they were acting on her orders, only confessed to doing so after making a deal to serve lesser sentences themselves if they blamed Carty.

The poor track record of her defence lawyer Jerry Guerinot – 20 people he has represented have ended up on death row – has led him to be dubbed “undertaker for the state of Texas”.

Yet all Carty’s appeals have failed, meaning that at any moment a judge could sign her death warrant leaving her 90 days before a lethal injection.

Her plight will feature in a TV documentary this month by filmmaker Steve Humphries. He travelled to Mountain View prison in Gatesville, Texas, to hear Carty’s story. From behind the jail’s razor wire, she said: “I know nothing about this murder, nothing about an abduction, I don’t even know the victim. This is the pettiest place I’ve been in. The people hate you for being different. It’s hell, hell.”

Carty was convicted for the kidnap and murder of Mexican-born Joana Rodriguez in Houston in 2001. The 25-year-old was found bound, gagged and suffocated in the boot of a car while her 4-day old son was found uninjured in another. Both vehicles were either used by or belonged to Carty.

The kidnappers said she was desperate to steal the baby to raise as her own. Police also found a pushchair, baby clothes, a baby bed and a baby bath in one car. They said scissors found in her bag would have been used to cut the baby from Rodriguez’s womb had she not already given birth.

Carty denies it all and insists she lent the cars to 2 men, Oscar and Chris, who used them without her knowledge in a botched robbery on the Rodriguez home on May 16.

At her trial, she said Guerinot did not even speak to her. Nor did he contact the British government, which he was supposed to under international law, because she was entitled to consular support having been born on the Caribbean island of St Kitts when it was under British rule in 1958.

She said: “How would you feel if your trial attorney never spoke to you, never addressed you by your correct name and lied and said he had to bribe me with chocolate to get a conversation going with me when I’m allergic to chocolate?” Paul Lynch, British consul general in Houston, Texas, admitted: “It is a terrible failure of the system and all I can say is that the authorities have changed the system so that it won’t happen again. But that’s too late for Linda Carty.”

Carty’s last hope lies with Michael Goldberg, of global law firm Baker Botts, who has taken up her case for free. He said: “If you throw out the criminals’ testimony, what does the state have? The state has nothing.” Also in her corner are celebrities including Bianca Jagger.

Guerinot did little to even uncover circumstances that could be used in mitigation. Had he used the funds he was given to fly to St Kitts he would have discovered that Carty was raised in a well-off religious family and worked as a teacher, but was forced to leave when she gave birth to a daughter as an unmarried mother in 1982.

In America she attended college while caring for her daughter, Jovelle. When she fell pregnant again after being raped, her life started to unravel. She put the baby up for adoption, but then fell into a series of troubled relationships. One was with a drugs kingpin, which led to her working undercover for the Drug Enforcement Agency.

In her last relationship, she suffered 2 miscarriages, which supporters say may explain the baby paraphernalia in her car. Jovelle, now a mother of 2 boys, said: “My fears are that they’ll win and my mom won’t come home.”

Carty no longer fears death but says: “If I have to die, I pray that my family, especially my mother and daughter, will not look and not feel ashamed. It isn’t because I am guilty, it’s because the state of Texas has failed and failed me badly.”

The last woman in Britain to be executed was murderess Ruth Ellis in 1955. The British Woman On Death Row, Channel 4, November 28, at 8pm

Source: Daily Mail, November 25, 2011

Related articles:
Jun 27, 2010
This is where, in all probability, Linda Carty, the only British woman on death row in America, is living out her last weeks and months. Carty has been on death row in Texas for the past nine years, accused of murdering a ...
Feb 22, 2010
British grandmother Linda Carty (pictured) was wrongfully sentenced to death by a Texan court and is now dangerously close to execution. Please watch this video about her disastrous case - and find out how you can help ...
Sep 23, 2010
As Teresa Lewis is set to become the first woman to be executed in the US for five years, Briton Linda Carty continues to await the same fate for killing a young mother in Texas. Peter Marshall meets Carty, ...
Sep 21, 2009
"Because we were not informed, Linda Carty was not given all the assistance she should have been given by her government. And therefore she did not get the representation that she should have had at her first trial," ...
1
2
3