Showing posts with label ACLU. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ACLU. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

ACLU asks Ohio Gov. John Kasich to halt executions

Ohio Death Chamber
Ohio Death Chamber
The American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio is asking Gov. John Kasich to halt executions.

The ACLU sent a letter to Kasich today asking him to use his executive authority in light of the questions raised after Thursday's execution of Dennis McGuire. The state used a new drug cocktail in McGuire's execution by lethal injection that witnesses say left him clenching his fists and gasping for air for more than 20 minutes before he died.

Ohio has 5 more executions scheduled for 2014, all that could involve the same drug combination.

"This is not about Dennis McGuire, his terrible crimes or the crimes of others who await execution on death row," Christine Link, executive director of the ACLU of Ohio said in the letter. "It is about our duty as a society that sits in judgment of those who are convicted of crimes to treat them humanely and ensure their punishment does not violate the Constitution."

Link noted the Ohio Supreme Court Taskforce on the Administration of the Death Penalty is expected to finish its recommendations within a few months and asked, "Is not now the time to step back and pause?"

Source: Akron Beacon Journal Online, January 20, 2014

Thursday, October 24, 2013

ACLU sues to lift secrecy over Missouri execution team

After a Post-Dispatch investigation seven years ago revealed the identity of Missouri’s lead executioner, exposing a history including public discipline from the state medical board and false statements in court, the Legislature took action.

It enacted a law to ban any person from “knowingly disclosing the identity of a current or former member of an execution team.’’

The Department of Corrections announced on Tuesday it was adding a compounding pharmacy to the execution team and invoked the 2007 law protecting the pharmacy’s workers from disclosure.

On Wednesday, the American Civil Liberties Union of Missouri sued in U.S. District Court in St. Louis to try to overturn the law so “we can post documents that identify execution team members on our website without fear of violating any statutes,” said its legal director, Tony Rothert. Under the law, an executioner whose identity was revealed could file a lawsuit and recover actual and punitive damages from the person who revealed the name.

Missouri has long struggled to find executioners and execution drugs with spotless histories. Most medical professionals and drug companies avoid being associated with taking lives.

ACLU sued the state this month for records of the state’s inventory of propofol, an anesthetic the state had planned to use in lethal injections to execute murderers Allen Nicklasson on Oct. 23 and Joseph Paul Franklin on Nov. 20.

The records showed the supplier of some of the propofol, Morris & Dickson, of Shreveport, La., had pleaded with the state nearly a year ago to return vials the company had shipped to Missouri in violation of its agreement with the manufacturer, Fresenius Kabi, of Germany, not to provide the drug for capital punishment.

The state finally returned the drug after the ACLU put the records on its web site. But it still had propofol manufactured by Hospira in stock from another supplier, Mercer Medical of suburban Seattle.

Then Hospira said it wanted its propofol back, too, because it had not authorized the sale to Mercer Medical. On Oct. 11, Gov. Jay Nixon postponed the Nicklasson execution and ordered the department to develop a new protocol. On Tuesday, the state announced it would use pentobarbital, commonly used to euthanize pets.

Source: St Louis Post-Dispatch, October 24, 2013

Sunday, October 6, 2013

ACLU sues Missouri for records on execution drug

The American Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit Friday against the Missouri Department of Corrections, alleging that the agency failed to comply with open records requests related to its planned use of the anesthetic propofol in 2 upcoming executions.

The lawsuit, which was filed in Cole County Circuit Court, seeks unspecified damages and asks the court to require the corrections department to turn over the requested public records.

Missouri plans to execute convicted killers Allen Nicklasson on Oct. 23 and Joseph Franklin on Nov. 20. The executions would be the 1st using propofol, which is by far the most commonly used anesthetic.

Nearly 90 % of the propofol used in the U.S. is made in Europe. The Associated Press reported last week that the anti-death penalty European Union is considering export limits on propofol if it is used for lethal injections. Makers of the drug say that could slow movement to the U.S. and create a propofol shortage that could endanger the well-being of patients.

ACLU Missouri Foundation officials submitted a Sunshine Law request in August for a variety of records about Missouri's supply of propofol. The request sought to determine how the state was able to obtain the drug when all the leading makers, who oppose its use in executions, refuse to sell it to prisons or corrections departments, according to the lawsuit. The request also sought records to determine the expiration date of Missouri's supply.

"There is serious doubt that the Missouri Department of Corrections lawfully or ethically possesses the drug it plans to use to end a life later this month," Jeffrey A. Mittman, the executive director of the ACLU of Missouri Foundation, said in a statement.

On Thursday, state Sen. Kurt Schaefer, R-Columbia, sent a letter to Democratic Gov. Jay Nixon saying that in light of concerns about propofol and the inability to obtain execution drugs, the governor should consider budgeting money for a gas chamber. Nixon's office declined to speak to the AP.

The Missouri Society of Anesthesiologists has also urged the state to reconsider using propofol. In a letter to corrections director George Lombardi this week, the society said Missouri "is on the verge of triggering a national drug shortage that will have a severe impact on the general welfare of the citizens of our state and our country."

The letter was part of a petition urging the corrections department to adopt a rule prohibiting it from purchasing or using any drug for lethal injection that could jeopardize use of that drug among health care providers and facilities.

Propofol made headlines in 2009 when pop star Michael Jackson died of an overdose. Missouri is the only state that has adopted propofol for use in executions.

Source: Daily Journal Online, October 5, 2013

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Montana: Lawyers for Canadian on death row argue Montana's execution method is unconstitutional

The American Civil Liberties Union argued in court Wednesday that the method the state plans to use in the execution of a Canadian on death row is unconstitutional.

The ACLU is asking District Court Judge Jeffrey Sherlock to rule that the lethal injection protocol amounts to cruel and unusual punishment under the U.S. and Montana constitutions. The ACLU originally filed the lawsuit in 2008 on behalf of Ronald Allen Smith, originally from Red Deer, Alberta.

An attorney for the group argued that the state does not require sufficient medical training to ensure that executioners properly administer a drug that ensures no pain is felt by the executed.

The Montana Department of Corrections argues its revised execution protocol passes constitutional muster. Executions in Montana have been stayed by the court until the argument is sorted out.

Smith originally sought the death penalty and spurned a plea deal after pleading guilty in 1983 to the shooting deaths of 2 Blackfeet Indian cousins. He later changed his mind about the death penalty and is now seeking executive clemency from the governor.

Ron Waterman, working for the ACLU on the case, said the state's method leaves too much discretion to a prison warden who lacks the training to know for sure whether the executioner is doing the job right.

He said that fails to meet strict demands that higher courts have placed on execution protocols.

"We have the blind leading the blind," Waterman said.

Both sides are asking the court to make a decision based on the legal motions already filed instead of holding a trial later this year. Sherlock did not indicate Wednesday how he will rule.

The judge did quiz the state on whether is it appropriate to have a warden with "zero" training in charge of determining whether the person being executed is sufficiently unconscious to guarantee no pain is felt by subsequent death-inducing drugs. But Sherlock also asked the ACLU if there could be an execution protocol it would find appropriate.

"Can't you find some problem with any protocol that anybody comes up with?" Sherlock asked Waterman during an hour-long hearing.

The ACLU and other death-penalty opponents regularly have asked the Montana Legislature to strike the state's death penalty in favor of life in prison without parole. The arguments have had limited success, advancing in portions of the Legislature, but they have not cleared the entire body.

Meanwhile, the Montana Board of Pardons and Parole has recommended that Gov. Brian Schweitzer reject a clemency request from Smith.

The Democrat met with Smith's family last month and said he is undecided on the request, which seeks life in prison instead of the death penalty. Schweitzer noted he is not required to issue any decision on the request.

The ACLU said its arguments in the case will stand regardless of whether Smith receives clemency because of their potential use in other cases.

2 inmates, Smith and William Jay Gollehon, await execution in Montana's death chamber — a trailer on the prison grounds in Deer Lodge. Montana has carried out 3 executions since reinstating the death penalty in the 1970s, with the most recent in 2006.

Smith and his supporters argue it is unfair for Smith to be put to death while an accomplice who took a plea deal was released back to Canada long ago.

In recommending against clemency, the Parole Board noted the strong feelings of the victims' families and many others from the Blackfeet Indian Reservation who argue it is long past time for Smith to be executed for his crime.

Source: Associated Press, August 2, 2012

Related articles:
May 30, 2012
In a letter to Governor Brian Schweitzer on 21 May, the Board of Pardons and Parole advised that, following a clemency hearing on 2 May, the Board had voted against recommending clemency for Ronald Smith. The letter ...
May 22, 2012
"In the home and towns that Ronald Smith grew up in, there is a deeply entrenched culture of alcoholism and abuse," the document states, suggesting these circumstances had a powerful influence on Smith at the time of the .
Jan 22, 2012
"In the home and towns that Ronald Smith grew up in, there is a deeply entrenched culture of alcoholism and abuse," the document states, suggesting these circumstances had a powerful influence on Smith at the time of the ...

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

US Supreme Court Considers Texas Death Row Inmate's DNA Test Request

The Tarrant County case of Henry "Hank" Skinner could determine what access inmates have to DNA testing.

A Texas death row inmate, convicted of murder in Tarrant County, will get the chance to plead his case before the U.S. Supreme Court for a DNA test, that he claims will clear his name.

Henry "Hank" Skinner killed his ex-girlfriend and 2 other people in 1993. He did not receive a genetic test at his trial, but he wants one now. The high court agreed to hear the case to decide whether inmates may use a federal civil rights law to do DNA testing.

"I really believe that technology should be used in a way to help people people who claim they are innocent," death penalty opponent, Rick Halperin, said.

The SMU professor says the case could open the door for many more inmates to press for the expensive testing.

"It raises questions about America's responsibility to people who are incarcerated and have claims that this will vindicate those claims."

The test can be life or death. Former death row inmate, Kerry Cook, spent 20 years on death row and came within 11 days of being executed before a DNA test exonerated him. A test also showed, Michael Blair was not guilty of killing a Plano girl, after he spent nine years on death row.

But, death row killer Ricky McGinn was executed after receiving two DNA tests that confirmed he killed his stepdaughter. Some fear inmates, like McGinn, may abuse the test. But, experts say Texas law doesn't allow for much leeway.

"I think many inmates recognize that in most cases DNA will not make a difference," said Mike Ware, Chief of the Conviction Integrity Unit at the Dallas County District Attorney's office.

Ware has seen a record number of DNA exonerations in Dallas County. He sees no downside to expanded testing.

"Our philosophy in most cases is to agree to the test. What is the worst that can happen? We will either confirm guilt, exonerate someone or maybe identify more perpetrators through DNA."

Source: KDAF-TV, May 24, 2010


Supreme Court To Hear Case Of Texas Death Row Prisoner Seeking DNA Testing; DNA Evidence Must Be Fully Considered To Avoid Executing Innocent People, Says ACLU


The U.S. Supreme Court today agreed to decide whether a Texas death row prisoner should be allowed to have evidence in his case undergo DNA testing which could establish his innocence. Henry W. "Hank" Skinner, convicted of 3 1993 murders, believes that he is entitled to DNA testing under a federal civil rights law.

Among the pieces of evidence that Skinner would like tested are blood taken from the murder weapons, skin taken from under the fingernails of one of the victims as well as a rape test from her that includes semen, and hair and blood found at the scene of the crime. A number of investigations into the crimes and the alleged involvement of Skinner, who has maintained his innocence, have sharply called into question his guilt.

DNA evidence has led to nearly 140 exonerations of death row prisoners during the past 3 decades.

The following can be attributed to John Holdridge, Director of the ACLU Capital Punishment Project:

"It is unconscionable, and at odds with our shared American values of fairness, due process and justice, that the state of Texas would seek to execute a man when the evidence in his case has not been exhaustively tested. The sheer number of death row exonerations resulting from DNA testing shows that our death penalty system is fraught with error and systemic injustices. We should do anything and everything in our power, including conducting DNA testing of evidence, to ensure that we don't ever execute innocent people."

Source: ACLU Press Release -- The ACLU conserves America's original civic values working in courts, legislatures and communities to defend and preserve the individual rights and liberties guaranteed to every person in the United States by the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.