 |
| Manuel Valle |
The treatment of a man who has been held for over three decades on death row in the US and is now facing execution in a matter of days would be considered ‘inhuman’, ‘degrading’ or even ‘torture’ in a swathe of other jurisdictions around the world, legal action charity Reprieve can reveal.
Manuel Valle, a Cuban national with strong Spanish links, has been awaiting execution on Florida’s death row for 33 years, and with a stay set to be lifted this evening, could face lethal injection in a matter of days.
Being held on death row for such a long time has been described by the UK Privy Council as “an inhuman punishment because it add[s] to the penalty of death the additional torture of a long period of alternating hope and despair.”
Most countries that administer the death penalty agree that it is entirely unacceptable to subject anyone to such additional punishment before finally carrying out an execution. Examples include Kenya, Malawi and Uganda – where three years on death row, a delay one tenth as long as that faced by Mr Valle, can result in commutation of the death sentence.
The European Court of Human Rights has also held that where a ‘condemned prisoner has to endure for many years the conditions on death row and the anguish and mounting tension of living in the ever-present shadow of death’ that is a violation of prohibitions against ‘inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment’.
Mr Valle has now spent well over half of his life on death row, having been sentenced at the age of 27. Much of the time he has served has been due to a series of botched trials resulting from mistakes made by the trial judge or misconduct by the prosecution.
Reprieve investigator Katherine Bekesi said: “Traditionally, the State has always blamed the prisoner, desperately trying to avoid death through his right to appeal, for any delays in execution. However in this case it was the State that gave Mr Valle two unfair trials and spent over a decade trying to correct their mistakes. For Mr Valle, every botched trial was another trauma as he was sentenced to death again and again, spending years in between wondering what was to become of him.”
Source: Reprieve, September 8, 2011
Related articles:
Jul 18, 2011
Earlier this month, Scott signed the authorization for the state to go ahead with the execution of 61-year-old Manuel Valle on Aug. 2 for fatally shooting Coral Gables police officer Luis Pena in 1978. Valle would be the 70th...
Jul 16, 2011
One of them is Manuel Valle, 61, who has spent nearly half his life wearing the bright orange shirts that clearly distinguished the condemned men from all others at Florida State Prison in Starke. Scott spoke at length this week ...
Jul 28, 2011
Florida had planned to execute Manuel Valle, a Cuban with close ties to Spain, using pentobarbital on August 2, but the State Supreme Court issued a stay until September due to concerns over whether use of the drug could...
Aug 18, 2011
Meanwhile, a decision is expected imminently from the Florida Supreme Court on the state's plan to use the same drug to execute Manuel Valle – a Cuban with close ties to Spain – despite serious concerns that doing so...
Aug 08, 2011
The case will now proceed to the Florida Supreme Court, with lawyers for Cuban national Manuel Valle, who faces execution using pentobarbital in early September, expected to file later this week. Reprieve investigator ...
No comments:
Post a Comment