There are 159 inmates on North Carolina's death row.
The only one from Durham is Isaac Jackson Stroud.
The only reason he's there is because he's black, Chapel Hill lawyers William Massengale and Marilyn Ozer contend. But the power of the state's Racial Justice Act is strong enough to overturn Stroud's death sentence and make it a term of life in prison without the possibility for parole, the lawyers said in a motion filed last month in Durham County Superior Court.
Stroud in 1995 was convicted for killing his girlfriend in a jealous rage. Her name was Jocelyn Mitchell, a teacher at the old Durham High School. Stroud in 1993 beat her all night, eventually killing her, according to evidence.
Massengale and Ozer cite two high-profile Durham murder cases involving white men as illustrative of the racial inequity.
Lawyers for Stroud contrast his sentence with a jury in 2003 convicting Michael Peterson for the 2001 murder of his wife. It was believed Peterson -- who'd been a columnist for The Herald-Sun and a Durham mayoral candidate -- killed to collect money from a life insurance policy.
A jury in 2005 convicted Robert Petrick for killing his wife, a cellist with the Durham Symphony Orchestra. In 2003, he reported her missing, claiming she hadn't returned from a downtown orchestra rehearsal. Fishermen found her remains in Falls Lake, and jurors heard about a computer belonging to Petrick being used to research the depth, currents and underwater topography of the lake. Jurors also learned Petrick's computer was used to visit a Web site containing instructions titled "22 Ways To Kill A Man With Your Bare Hands by Big Bad Barbarian."
"If you're white in Durham, it just appears to be a totally different ball game," Ozer said Tuesday.
Peterson and Petrick killed their wives to get money, so the murders were premeditated and calculated, Ozer said. Stroud's was a crime of passion, not as cold, she suggested.
Yet Peterson and Petrick didn't get sent to death row. Stroud did.
Durham County Senior Resident Superior Court Judge Orlando Hudson at some point will make the call on whether Stroud gets taken off death row in favor of life in prison without parole.
The Racial Justice Act -- Gov. Beverly Perdue signed it into law in August 2009 -- allows defendants facing the death penalty to challenge their convictions on the basis of race.
The lawyers who filed the motion on Stroud's behalf said jury selection during his trial was tainted by racial bias. Four potential black jurors, one after another, were excused from consideration during Stroud's trial despite their fitness to serve, according to the motion. Of the 12 jurors selected, only four were black, Ozer said.
Hudson earlier this year said the death penalty is rare in Durham because murder cases here get thorough looks before they're deemed capital cases. That said, the Racial Justice Act is a good law, the judge said.
Durham County District Attorney Tracey Cline previously said over the past 20 years there have been 8 capital murder cases in Durham: 6 of those cases involved a black person killing another black person; one case involved a white person killing a black person; and another case involved a white person killing a white person -- examples that go against the notion that black people are more likely to get the death penalty for killing white people, she said.
A study examining death sentences in North Carolina over a 28-year period ending in 2007 showed, among similar homicides, the odds of a death sentence for those suspected of killing white people are about three times higher than the odds of a death sentence for those suspected of killing black people.
The study was conducted by a sociology professor at the University of Colorado at Boulder and a research scientist in the School of Criminology and Criminal Justice at Northeastern University in Boston.
Source: The Herald-Sun, September 13, 2010
No comments:
Post a Comment